Nine Inch Nails - Panorama NYC Concert - 07/30/2017 [Webcast Mirror]
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 сер 2017
- I Can't Seem To Wake Up 2017 Festival Tour -- Live from Panorama NYC.
Debuted on webcast at smarturl.it/NINPanorama
Pulled directly from the ts files in the webcast.
Line-Up:
Alessandro Cortini: Keyboards, guitar, bass, backing vocals
Robin Finck: Guitar, Keyboards, backing vocals
Trent Reznor: Vocals, guitar, keyboards
Atticus Ross: Keyboards, samples, programming, backing vocals
Ilan Rubin: Drums, keyboards, backing vocals
Set List:
00:02:35 - 01. Branches/Bones
00:04:37 - 02. Wish
00:08:20 - 03. Less Than
00:11:55 - 04. March Of The Pigs
00:16:19 - 05. Something I Can Never Have
00:22:32 - 06. The Frail
00:24:35 - 07. The Wretched
00:30:08 - 08. Closer
00:34:57 - 09. Copy Of A
00:40:20 - 10. Gave Up
00:45:15 - Trent Speaks
00:46:50 - 11. I Can't Give Everything Away (Farewell Mix) (David Bowie cover)
00:50:50 - 12. The Lovers
00:54:50 - 13. Reptile
01:01:32 - Band Introductions
01:02:02 - 14. The Great Destroyer
01:04:58 - 15. Burning Bright (Field On Fire)
01:10:48 - 16. The Hand That Feeds
01:14:20 - 17. Head Like A Hole
01:20:53 - 18. Hurt
James Hetfield has mastered the phrase of “oh yeah!” And Trent has mastered “Alright!” & “hey!”🤣
I personally can't stand his fuckin "hey" during live shows. Rubs me so wrong. Pisses me off Trent does that.
Grandi nin ❤❤❤
Lol! 😂 so true!
Or! Mmyeah or Yeaaaaaahh
LAYNE STALEY mastered "OH YEAAAH"
"I am still right here"
"Yeah, you are!"
Magnus Lindkvist that was me!!!...loveeeee nine inch nails show was amazing
More power to you, Kevin!
You can see him smiling after that hahaha
That was great! Put a smile on my face to hear it (and Trent's too haha).
Is that in the video ? I heard the whole video and haven't noticed it. If it's in the video can someone tell me when it happens ?
Nine Inch Nails was my first concert (2006) and the best concert experience that I've had at Panorama. Guys, when I tell you at 4:39 the crowd went fucking wild, it's an understatement. I pushed my happy ass all the way up to like 10 people from Trent. As soon as that first note hit for Wish, as far as the eye can see was one large mosh pit. I've never seen anything like it lmao. I was in the middle of it. This is THE band. My favorite band. My favorite vocalist. My favorite songs. My favorite performance. Love this band. The songs hit even harder since my mom passed September 2023. Something I Can Never Have R.I.P.
When wish went on, all hell broke loose and it was the most insane concert experience in my life.
the drummer Ilan Rubin is a fucking animal!
puyrm I fucking love how in March of the Pigs he destroys, jumps off, plays the keyboard, then goes back on to go even harder.
I was thinking exactly the same thing!!
He's really turned into a great drummer
He hits fucking hard and makes his presence known on stage. I like him better than Vrenna or Freese.
I didn't say he was better, I said I liked him better. Stage presence has as much to do with it as technical ability.
1:23:57 - Someone in the crowd yells out "yeah you are..." - Literally changed the way I'll view this song forever. This used to be a song about how addiction will dismantle your life and now suddenly it's a song about surviving it. Cheers to whoever yelled that out.
Awesome comment. Thank you for it.
Then you look at the Johnny Cash version and it just becomes a song about someone who has seen it all and you are the only one left.
Best comment ever!!
That dude was standing right in front of me! Awesome moment, and I hope Trent never changes this version of Hurt.
I've always seen it as being about survival, I mean the last couple lines nails it
28 years and NIN are still better than most out there!
Mean ideal Fucking Right ! No More Bands That Sound Like This Out There !
It’s about time they skip a bunch of these shite bands and get there spot in the R&R hall of fame!
griffisjm what behind One Direction!!!
Absolutely👍
They bring it every night! First time I saw NIN was in 2005, at Hultsfred festival in Sweden. After that I've seen them three times in arenas and on one more festival. I think I've seen them five times, I think the last time was in 2014. And, man, they fricking rocked every time! There's just some raw energy in the band and in Trent that I haven't seen a lot. Foo Fighters are energetic too, but Nine Inch Nails are actually better live, in my humble opinon (and I've had a lot of fun watching the Foo Fighters; also trauma, because I was at the stadium when Dave Grohl broke his leg, but he continued playing). No band has a better sounding show than NIN! Only Failure are up there, but every other band just doesn't sound as clean. At a NIN show, you can hear the vocals! You can hear the drums, the bass, the guitars, synths, everything is excellently balanced!
Something I can never have. Fuck.
I could give everything to hear it live. I think about all that random people who were there thinking what the fuck this song is about.
Life is pretty hard sometimes.
This is such a great rendition of it too. He's choked up. Fuckin got me hearing that and I don't break very easily.
ONE OF THE LAST TRUE ROCKSTARS
I was first introduced to NIN when I was 14. I'm now 28. I can honestly Trent and his work has had a great impact on my life, in a positive way. He radiates courage and gives us introverted weirdos a medium to relate to and melt in.
Robert Kcisaw I was introduced to nin at 14 as well and I'm 40 so enjoy many more years:)
same here! You must be my twin brother. :)
I was 18 in 94 when first introduced. I'm now 41. He is the only person I know of, that has words to all the feelings I have. When the dark times creeps in. All the hate all the pain. his words let me know, That I am still… right here.
I've only had a pleasure to listen to NIN for 7 years, there's just sometimes a time in life when I actually feel a need to listen and melt into all of it, re-discover all over again. It's some sort of therapy almost, I feel the music takes my failures and makes me stronger, makes me think in retrospect and promise myself to change, at the same time encourages me to never lose honesty. I have to see this live at least once in my lifetime, but it's kinda hard to get a hold of them here in northern Europe, I really hope they will tour here this season, I'll miss an exam if I have to, I don't care anymore, I missed Tension tour because of a goddamn exam....
Ditto! Although I am 44!
Robin: Don't ever change
This is the most fucking epic March of the Pigs performance in terms of soundscapes. Holy shit.
agreed! that was pretty rad.
And Closer
I noticed the same. Is it because of Atticus, I wonder...
Probably, he adds so much to the live band
It is 100% because of Atticus. He's doing the soundscapes.
Trent is so far ahead when it comes to modern music it’s fukn scary
Trent is so naturally cool that he makes the tambourine badass.
Trent is the only person that could pull off looking cool while playing the tambourine. He’s a master at the tambourine 🤣
holy fuck reptile is insane
52 year old and still looking good
James Fung Testosterone is a helluva drug.
54 😊
@John Sabp Testosterone is 100% a drug lol.
Drug: a medicine or other substance which has a physiological effect when ingested or otherwise introduced into the body.
It meets both criteria...
Cos Trent lifts.
Hey, thanks!
Oh, you meant Trent.
Been a NIN fan since early '90s. And All That Could Have Been is the live show which defined how I thought live shows should be. This blows it out of the water. A 52 year old guy, no drink, no drugs, no stage antics, no keyboard destruction, just pure music. It's someone at the top of their game.
I don't know how he can still be so authentic like this... vulnerable in front of a huge crowd, choking up during the most deep and cutting songs. Everything NIN does is perfect.
He did say Hurt came straight from his soul.
No other artist can ( for me personally) represent "teenage angst" better than Trent yet still sound mature and relatable to me as an adult. A lot of the bands that were great at capturing & representing "90s teen angst" sounded relatable when i was 13 but sound whiny and ridiculous now. Trent grows and matures along with his music. Been a fan since age 10 when I first saw the video for Closer back to back with the video for Head like a hole then a few days later I caught the Woodstock 94 performance. Trent's older songs have all new meaning to me as an adult and in a way the sight of him is comforting. In a sense i feel like I grew up with Trent, like he's that cool uncle that you've always looked up to. We've lost so many great frontmen from the 90s that I'm thankful Trent is still here kicking ass and looking and sounding amazing! NIN forever!
So glad Trent is still here. He must've had to go through the wrist to get to his best life. Yet he was a professional. it came to the music
I was having the worst month & at point last month when suddenly I. out they were. ab extended your this year & my son said he will go with me & that changed my throw outlook on everything. Anywhere in the US-If I can afford to get us there we will be up there right up in the front row for our positively life changing experience.
I spent all day being sent from this sure to that sir taking about staying in Ohio late last month then ending in CA with two music festivals too in September. Yet I couldn't find anywhere to not tickets
I just to want something I can never have. Please do this tour Nine Inch Nails-Me & my son desperately need this. We need you.
I had to leave my wife in the summer of 2017 and this live show UA-cam video was there for me almost daily. Hey pigs!🖤
I was at this concert. The man at 24:19 said "Never stop making music!"
Trent Reznor: Vocals, guitar, keyboards, Megaphone
You also forgot Tape Recorder on "The Lovers."
nice to see Alessandro on 7th guitar, 5th bass and 3rd keyboards
man's gotta eat
Robin finck is so badass... the only survivor of the old lineup. Glad he’s still around.
Its crazy he was out of the scene for so long and then came back and its like he never left. Dude is legendary. Smashing all of our other options for "rock" right now for sure.
The reworking of the Blackstar track with Bowies voice coming in and out with the audio made me cry.
I loved Bowie as though I m knew him. When he passed away I cried off and on that entire month it effed me up. I remember feeling sad for Trent because I knew how much David meant to him.
It's wild coz 3 inspirations of mine David Bowie, Gary Numan, and Trent Reznor and they each seam to really admire and respect each other.
I will always feel that empty spot for which I never got to see Bowie live.
Craziest thing, my first boss, from my first job I started part time at age 13,, if she had known I liked David Bowie I could have gone with her to the Oct 24th, 1995 show in Tacoma WA!!! 🤦♀️🤯😖😣😢🥺😭
She would have taken me with her to the Bowie Nine inch Nails show!!!! I was month shy of turning 15, she didn't really know NiN then and she was thoroughly confused by Trent and David basically doing so many of their songs together. .
If I only had a time machine.
To hear Robin Finck as backup vocals is sheer brilliance.
One of the most awesome guitarists in existence!
Reptile never sounded so brutal, fkn overwhelming
This song is BADASS
Damn, that tribute to Bowie brought tears to my eyes...
It’s like his angel is singing and watching over Trent. I wonder what he would think.
I admit, Felt the Same way, when I heard Bowie's vocals, and "I can't give" is the last song on the last Bowie album, BlackStar. Interesting choice, Trent!
Christ, so many feels. It hurts!
Takin me back to freshman year in HS for sure (1994).. shitty as it was, I'd do it all over again just for the music.
14:20 I've never seen him do this before, that's fucking awesome.
Awesome tribute to Bowie. NIN still sounds more advanced than today's music.
This version of Hurt is my absolute favorite because when trent says, I am still right here, the guy in the crowd yells, YEAH YOU ARE. Such a moment 🖤
Your welcome lol I was real drunk that night
@@kevinabraham9260 If that was indeed you, you sir rock! 🤘
@Winter Lynn …. Twas indeed me, I get real emotional whenever I hear that song and for some reason that night it just came out of me in the form of “YEAH YOU ARE”
@@kevinabraham9260 It's a very emotional song for me as well, I loved it for different reasons when I was 12 now it has a whole new meaning for me at 38. But that "Yeah you are" is really a great moment, I'd like to think that is the reason you see Trent smiling in the next shot
@Winter Lynn I’d like to think any words I said that night specifically those had the ability to impact Trent even if only for that split moment in time….as his lyrics his composing his music as a whole has talked me off a ledge I don’t know how many times in the last 24 years…..he’s so gifted… unrelated I saw your photo attached to your name, really diggin the tattoos 🤘
I love when Robin sings. He's so good. It adds an energy that we can't get on the album version.
SHit mirror is mind blowing!
"Less Than" is badass!
Ikr :D
Ilan Rubin's snare drum sounds like a fucking shotgun going off. Love it! You especially notice it during The Hand That Feeds
He's a machine...ie an awesome drummer...so tight
Hurt has got to be one of the best song's ever written.
this performance just solidifies the fact that Reptile is NIN's best song
The tape like material attached to the drum set clearly reminds me of head like a hole video. Fucking rad!
Very Downward Spiral Tour throwback
33 years and NIN are still better than most out there!
am i the only one that's in awe of how epic/chaotic "Branches/Bones" sounds live? perfect concert opener - just wish it was longer! haha
That and Burning Bright (Field on Fire) are the best tracks off of NtAE
All the band members are all-stars; masterful aggressive but warm. I can tell they all REALLY LIKE playin music. Straight up. This version of "Reptile" blew my mind. (compare the Woodstock 94 version) Trent seems to be enjoying himself, cam work is killer. 10s across thee board!
This man's voice never ages or changes.. Sounds just as passionate and powerful as when I saw them for PHM in the 90's. That drummer though.. From beast mode to slow piano back to beast mode for March Of The Pigs..
i wish this were true, but the man has lost a good octave of his upper range, granted he has improved his lower range a great deal, so the quality isnt lost, but i would be very impressed if he managed to sing the pre-Downward Spiral material at the recorded pitch. Dont get me wrong, Trent is possibly my most favourite musician, but his range has definitely shrunk. The only vocalist i know of that truely has maintained near enough their full vocal range with aging is Robert Smith from The Cure. His performance at Glasto this year was pitch perfect, which is just impressive for a high male voice at 60.
Really? Because it’s changed a shit load. Dudes voice got deeper & he can’t even scream like he used to instead opting for other members to scream for him
@@HoodGoblin Only for songs like Head Like A Hole, where it isn't practical for him to scream for a long period of time- and even so, he still does the vocals for March Of The Pigs. He pitched down Last, but he seems to be able to perform it fine.
Yeah it's true. He can't sing as high as he used to. But that's ageing for you. I've always imagined he would take care of his voice, and sing with good technique. It appears that way, but it would be great to see a vocal coach reaction.
He was never a great singer, but singing is only part of the story. he makes up for it with passion, song writing, lyrics etc. so the sum of the parts are great.
Reptile is always so fucking heavy live.
That aside, Beside You In Time is still their best live video released.
It sounds so evil.
holy fuck. burning bright.
burning bright is one of the most beautiful things i have ever heard.
30:51 I love that little "HEY!"
Holy shit!! branches/bones sounds fucking amazing, its perfect for the opening
its so emotive to see trent singing , crying in the shows ... he is a star
Never ceases to amaze me the way Ilan Rubin can keep the rhythm during Copy Of A! Definitely one of my favorite NIN songs to hear live!
Through all the lineup changes NIN had over the years, i personally am really happy to see that Robin Finck is still in the live band after so many years. Having seen NIN live already 9 times in Europe, i always thought, he was one of the best parts of the NIN live lineup beside Trent.
Although Trent kinda always has a fantastic live lineup at every position (f.e. Atticus Ross now, or Alessandro Cortini earlier), this guy always gives everything on every show.
Sorry, hate to be "that guy" but (from the Description):
Line-Up:
Alessandro Cortini: Keyboards, guitar, bass, backing vocals
Robin Finck: Guitar, Keyboards, backing vocals
Trent Reznor: Vocals, guitar, keyboards
Atticus Ross: Keyboards, samples, programming, backing vocals
Ilan Rubin: Drums, keyboards, backing vocals
Alessandro I think has been continually in the band again since the tension tour...
Feels weird saying it but throughout all the concerts I've seen, it's now at 50+ he does the best live rendition of Something I Can Never Have that I've ever heard from him.
I get a little moist watching Robin Finck playing guitar. He's one of the greats
NIN live is nothing without Finck
Trey Schroeder Robin is king... Trent being God
NIN live doesn't sound like NIN without Robin. There's just a vibe to the way he plays those parts. Every time he goes on tour as part of the band I get the feels.
agreed
Have to say that the best live guitar performance out of NIN was from Aaron North during the With Teeth tour. Finck is the mainstay, but Aaron's guitar sound was just unreal during that tour.
The deconstructed version of, "I Can't Give Everything Away"... so many tears...
Another thing to add NiN live is 'quieter' than other bands that are guitar/bass/drums and don't use drum machines/synths. When I saw them (twice now, late 90's and back in 2014 in Irvine CA) other bands opened, or co headline like SoundGarden, and some other band I can't remember THEY WERE LOUD AS HELL couldnt even enjoy it. Then NiN came on and it was perfectly loud enough but not hurting. Always loved that, their live mix is spot on all the time.
He is our true genius musically of our gen.
NIN is still relevant after almost 30 years of service...epic as always:: Reznor, Fink, Ross are a solid trifecta of visceral talent!!
Saw NIN at Lollapalooza 91
First time EVER hearing their music and I was blown away
Something I can never have - Back in the mid 90's I had glow in the dark stars all over my ceiling in my bedroom, I used to turn off all the lights and just stare up at the stars while listening to this. It was intoxicating.
still full of energy at age 50+ amazing
God damn Trent's voice is killing it in this one. Everyone is so damn good in this. HOLY SHEET.
Like magic I came here to see if Trent had anything to say about his friend's passing, and he did much more.
I was there about 10 rows back. I also scored tickets to their surprise show they had at Webster Hall the very next day.
🖤❤️🖤❤️🖤
He's Still got It
Revolutionary concert video; like, unprecedented. First song alone sounds/feels like Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas
9:36
That SMILE ♥♥♥
I've seen Trent at least nine times and Bowie four times. Seeing them together was a once in a lifetime experience.
Reptile is so good live. Heard it live many years ago, easily one of my favorites live. Sounds even better here.
Atticus is seriously amazing, and to have him with the live band. Overall this is the most raw I've seen this band. Its beautiful Trent.
Still keep coming back to this one. Fantastic show
The ending part of March Of The Pigs is fantastic. Ilan Rubin is so fuc**ng energetic
Oh Trent.....celebrity crush #1, gets better with age.
Great concert! I'm 63 and have been listening to Nine Inch Nails for 20 years! I also listen to Frank Sinatra, The Beatles, Miles Davis, Led Zeppilin, et al...great music is great music, regardless of the genre or year!
Damn they sound as good as the recording, if it wasn't for the crowd I wouldn't really know that this was live!
Just to be clear we were wayyyyyy louder and rowdier a crowd than the video captures lol
Holy shit, Rubin is a goddamn maniac on the drums. DAMN
Trent still sings flawlessly after all these years...
The last time I saw NIN, they had Soundgarden with them in Dallas.
That was a Great concert.
The night after this show, they played a surprise show at Webster Hall. I got the only ticket a available on the street..that was an INCREDIBLE show!
That baseline towards the end of closer is absolutely killer
I cannot begin to describe how grateful I am that this album came out when I was a teenager. It helped me get through some times.
Trent, don't force me to clap my hands, it's not a family show.
My favorite band of all time..his music is timeless
I've never been a hater, but also never a huge fan - this is just great and a real top notch rare example of killer arrangements and dynamics - totally in the now - seeing this after Twin Peaks part 8 is making me a huge fan. Something timeless going on here.
I don't know why, but this is probably my favourite lineup since the Fragility tour. It's essential all the best live players since that tour. Hopefully they can bring it back to Toronto before Trent decided to pack it in for good.
PS. the tape reels all over the stage is giving those good old school feels!
Unbelievable how awesome NIN are still to this day. Trent is still current and just keeps cranking this shit out. I don't normally like new stuff from bands, but this shit is amazing. I'm a fan from way back from 1989. NIN can easily sell out big venues
Whoa, Reptile sounds fucking awesome, as always. Still got it Trent!
That David Bowie tribute though! Made my day.
Man, The Great Destroyer live... it really made my whole day.
That Farewell Mix-David Bowie cover made me start crying pretty quickly & I'm such a new Nine Inch Nails fan- Just discovered how great they are & always were in August 2021-Since then I keep discovering new concerts online & this was Excellent & So Beautiful & I wish they come back to NY & do a show so I can go see what I've been missing 25--30 years but Loving so much now-I love the Live shows- the Real emotion & I relate to just about everything I've heard so far-Trent is in my head
Man, I love this performance. You can really feel the synergy between the band members.
Seen thousands of concerts in my time, and Trent and co. (no matter who he has with him) has been some of the best nights of music in my life. Jaw dropping more times than not.
Fully agreed. Saw them during Tension in 2013. Utterly amazing. Face melted right off my skull.
Superb ! This band will still have a meaning in 100 years from now on.
Alessandro cortini taking bass duties for atticus ross... only nin can have that luxury
jesus... i get chills just watching this on youtube, can't imagine how great must it feel to see this shit live... hope they come to europe one day
The stage set up with the PHM head like a hole type tape hanging off of stuff is awesome
NIN just keeps getting better and better
Still one of the best live bands 30 years after I first saw them.
Trent Reznor is the last bastion of music legends... I hope this man inspired legends for our children, I wish I was one, but I don't even possess a shard of his musical talent.
Hands down best live version of Closer I've ever seen or heard! That song usually stinks live but WOW! That was amazing!
This goes really back ro the roots ...
I love the band, the setlist, the atmosphere ... absolute 🖤