GTA 5 - NaturalVision 2.2 vs. Redux vs. Vanilla Visual Graphics Mod Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 жов 2024
- BoostBoxx | Quality - Expertise - Individuality | Best Gaming PCs -- bit.ly/2ot7rpe
The popular graphics mod NaturalVision for GTA V has received an update to version 2.2 - time to compare it to GTA 5 Redux and vanilla on PC. We installed each mod according to the detailed instructions, this time we did not use a custom ReShade preset on any of the mods. As recommended by the mod author of NaturalVision, we adjusted the games ingame brightness to 75%, while vanilla and redux were set at the default value of 50%. We also installed L.A. roads in all NaturalVision scenes, Redux does not use additional mods. We used the exact same ingame time and weather preset on each scene (we used ScriptHook V with NaturalTrainer for it and activated persistent weather and stopped clock for it). All download links can be found below. Be free to leave your feedback in the comments.
---------------------
Die beliebte Grafik-Mod NaturalVision für GTA 5 hat ein Update auf Version 2.2 bekommen, Zeit sie mit der ebenfalls sehr populären Grafik-Mod Redux und dem ungemoddeten GTA 5 zu vergleichen. Wir haben beide Mods exakt nach Anleitung installiert und haben dieses Mal keine eigenen ReShade-Presets angewendet. Wie vom Mod-Autor empfohlen haben wir bei NaturalVision die Helligkeit im Spiel auf 75% geregelt, bei Redux und Vanilla ist er der Standardwert von 50%. In allen Szenen haben wir gleiche Uhrzeit und Wetterbedingungen sichergestellt, mit der Hilfe von ScriptHook V und NaturalTrainer. Alle Links zu den entsprechenden Downloads gibt es unten.
Mods:
GTA 5 Redux gta5redux.com/
NaturalVision 2.2 de.gta5-mods.c...
L.A Roads 2.0 Mod de.gta5-mods.c...
L.A Roads 2.0 Patch www.gta5-mods....
ScriptHook V + ASI Loader + NaturalTrainer www.dev-c.com/g...
Candyland on Facebook: / candylandgs
Candyland on Twitter: / candylandgs
Captured with BlackMagicDesign Decklink 4K Extreme 12G
Music: Digital Juice - Coming Up
System used in this video:
GameStar-PC Ultra
------------------------------------
Hier kaufen: bit.ly/1O7piZC
Intel Core i7 6700K 4.00 GHz
16 GB DDR4 RAM
Nvidia GeForce GTX 1080
MSI Z170A PC Mate Mainboard
Windows 10 Pro 64bit
Our second system:
GameStar-PC Titan
-------------------------------
Hier kaufen: bit.ly/1ZiQdlE
Intel Core i7-5820K 6x 3.3 GHz
16GB DDR4 Crucial Dual Channel 2133MHz (2x 8GB)
ZOTAC GeForce GTX 980 Ti Amp! Extreme Edition 6GB
500GB SATA III Samsung 840 EVO SSD
2TB SATA III Western Digital Red WD20EFRX
Windows 10 64bit
Vanilla: Original GTA 5
Redux: Far Cry
NaturalV: GTA 4
Redux:pubg
Redux is more like just cause id say
Türksün Demi Len
naturalV fuckin idiot....
@@familstyle6021 What kind of question is this man, obviously he is.
Vanilla looked best other than the clouds. NV ruins contrast a lot and Redux overdoes everything.
And on Redux clouds look completely flat, like painted on a sphere around the map
Marvincent Acuña o
And if you look on FPS count, you can see that vanilla has twice more FPS, than both mods. Don’t see any reason to use them.
I think NV looks the best
I personally like the Redux because of its overhaul aspect. Just my opinion
natural is the one you would actually use to play the game
redux is the one you use to do clickbait gta vi videos
...natural Vanilla, yes!
I use Redux
Eduardo Ferreira ur 300th like
comes from me
😂😂
8k RTX GTA V Real Life
Redux = Trevor Infinite rage mode
Man, this should be on top. 😂
Yep
No actually
Its Micheal's special ability
It looks so similar
@@cyrusEdits864 No Bro,IT Looks Blue When Activated
@@agtechandgaming1301 oh im sorry
Its franklins one
At night Franklins ability looks like you have a mod
3:16 looks like a nuclear bomb explosion😂😂😂😂
FallOut4 nuclear
Yeah lol, I noticed that, looks like the sun is finally about to blow up after swelling most of the planets. In this photo sun is almost about to kill earth
it looks so much better ingame xd
Say hello TO MY LITTLE FRIEND!!!!
3:15 Are we like, crashing into the sun or something.
Leaon Mendoza pretty hot
NaturalVision is a bit too faded, while Redux has too much color.
There are lots of Presets on Redux to change the look
natural is less color and that makes it close to rl
Helder Cunha no it doesn’t blind ass nigga have you been outside and seen the sun take up the whole sky and see blood red trees with cars that are mo fukin mirrors blind ass
@@1NewsNewZealand ah yes, here we see the MW2 lobby squeaker's son.
The colors seem almost too saturated in the redux. I guess I would have to play it to really get a feel for it.
Integral Titan and then again. I think the vanilla feels unnaturel because of that. The colors feel clustered and to bright and fantasy like to feel real
I think Redux to me more closely resembles what my eyes see in those situations
Integral Titan i think redux just has too much orange
You can choose different profiles of ENB, some of them are, other ones look dark, others look boring, if you like vanilla gta5 colors, install the "original" profile.
dislike,redux is the best,but is too much dark
Hey, you know what, I could enjoy all three of these.
- Vanilla outperforms in some shots, like 0:59, which is impressive! And of course, it's still very playable today and will be for MANY years, the graphics are good.
- NaturalV is modest and whitewashed, it comes down to preference really. I would simply enjoy playing the game with its different visuals, the angle at 0:24 particularly looks nice.
- Redux is extreme. I would love to do a playthrough using this. And clearly, so much work went into the look. There's a big stigma around playing games with high saturation but I have no problem with it, if the game looks fresh then it looks fresh. I also really enjoy the contrast changes too, like at 1:50
But yeah, I understand people's complaints, and it's never cool to like the saturation mods so it's no surprise the comments section is full of laughing and complaining about it hahah. I get it in my own comment sections. I am open to many different types of mods because I can replay games easily, so it's no problem using one mod graphics mod one time, another the next. And it's not like I don't see any flaws or my preference doesn't get in the way, like, NaturalV's contrast isn't very good in my opinion, as I said the whitewashed look comes down to preference - I would easily still use it though. I think most people will just jump on the bandwagon and post popular like-whoring comments, so I thought it'd be interesting to post my own actual opinion.
very complet comment
@@nudlz5343 thanks, just wanted to give my opinion. forgot i'd wrote this lol
@@InternetRob you are racer
but i wanna become racist
This only made me realise how good the original graphics still hold up.
also Ac unity
Looks like Redux will give you eye strain.
3:16 oh look, a nuclear explosion
@@Samchong2005 lol 🤣🤣i still prefer it tho
Helder Cunha life doesnt glow bright neon all the time
NaturalV looks worse than vanilla lol
InfiniteTias ha ha ha yes
poipoipoi ha ha ha
InfiniteTias natural vision is worst than the ps3 version
QuzhYuno yes right
like gta 4 XD
"Dull Colors for GTA V" would be a better name for NaturalVision
Taquito e d g y
Egg
Btw this video used a custom ENB/Reshade preset , thats why it looks bad
it doesn't use the original one and its like people bitch that this mod looks bad , even tho in reality this video uses fanmade preset
Wrench, yeah I've seen livestream of it and even Redux looking better than videos of them, but still, your game's graphics are better!
Linator4 my game graphics?
3:30 THE REDUX SUN LMAOOO
Lol its betelgeuse
@@sadboi9060 😂😂😂👌👌
@@sadboi9060 no its VY Canis Majoris
@@Artonix2000 it's just a joke, no need to take it seriously
also UY Scuti
it’s 5 feet away lol
how to remake a game
first: water.
So that means GTA V copied Minecraft beacause it has water too
Russian Assassin Pro No! It was a reference to the overuse of water pits
zudeyix r/woooosh
Lol gta Sa mods hahaha
I noticed in most games the biggest graphical and mechanical problem is water
redux still have good point, I like the color wich made by redux, but I think redux have too much shadow and over exposure.
overall I like it very much, it's give me better real experience
WOW i feel like both the mods dont have NEARLY enough shodows tbh
NaturalV = Depressed like gta 4.
Vanilla = Good.
Redux = so bright and saturated.
Lol if gta 4 was an emoji it was 🙁
I like the stile of Natura it add more seriousness to the game
Wrong
I don’t even have Gta on PC, why am I watching this.
Me too
Vanilla: more realistic
Redux: more cinematic
NV: Ah shit, here we go again
I have a GTA on my PS 4 its graphic is like the Redux
@@creestly8903 HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Future What you said is an absolute oxymoron, pal
Lol bruh
Natural vision is way better then 3 years ago, look up natural vision evolved
Vanilla: normal girl
Natural vision: sensitive girl
Redux: Plastic surgery girl
Redux : Kim Kardashian lol
Redux is Over saturated, Natural IV is dull AF and Vanilla is perfect.
Well given color dulls and fades in the sun, it's kinda natural. That's why newly paved asphalt streets fade from a black to a more grey and lighter of time. It all depends on the time exposed. Streets fade rather fast due to being constantly exposed almost 24/7.
The SRA Natural IV is what it says on the tin, it's natural. Supposed to be more realistic in colours.
You gotta check out natural vision remastered. Its the perfect balance between redux and vanilla.
The SRA. there are so many gamers who likes over saturation
Chethas leo Hey guys whats up! Today i bring you GTA 6 IN 2018?!?! Dont forget to like, comment and subscribe for a chance to win the SHARK CARD GIVEAWAY!!!!1111111111
vanilla is better for me i like the bluish environment
Its more like red/yellowish
Redux is blue
2:52 I know that this is a game. But that boat not moving with the wave ticks me off.
True
Big boats don't really move too much in water...
It’s a ship... it won’t move too much on port waters.
You are just trying to find a topic of drama, GTA5 does have boats rocking and moving due to waves.
Vanilla: Good
Natural vision: Ruins the contrast. Too bright
Redux: Ruins the contrast. Too dark
and also makes almost everything into blue that can't even be *blue*
@@treett4268 yea
he didnt follow installation instruction, on the download page it says you should reduce your brightness by half. this guy didnt do that. i installed it, it looks worlds apart from his version. i wish i could show you my version
@@mugisama779 which version are u using Redux ????
People forget how long they took to make the game. They had many years to work on Vanilla so its bound to be better than most mods.
Even after reading all the comments about how over saturated Redux is I still think it looks the best.
THANK YOUUU
same thinking c:
Redux seems fake it makes it look like a movie and NaturalV and Vanilla have more realism
Vanilla still the best...
then ur eyes have down syndrome
very humerouse youtube name Obviously...
you need a good glasses
zLoRd CrUeL 47 TM I will buy some soon
console peasants
Gotta be honest. I prefer the vanilla over all of these
how to download vanila mod plz help
@@mdsajjadahmed9009 that means default graphics.
@@mdsajjadahmed9009 LMAO
@@mdsajjadahmed9009 XD
NaturalVision 2.2 ---> Looks Realistic
Redux ---> Looks Beautiful
Vanilla ---> it's just looks normal
True
Nigga u blind?
Siapit Apit everyone has their own opinion u dumbass
Siapit Apit stfu you Indian
Natural is my type, but they all have their different specialities. Hard to choose on of them :(
redux is like the afterglow of an acid trip, everything is more vibrant, colors are more poppin, i like it
Vanilla looks the best on my option
Recaked Esquire it's not
***** opinion , sorry English is not my first language
Honestly, Vanilla is still the most realistic looking by far. Redux's reshade is cool for some screenshots and for people who like cartoony looking eye popping graphics, but that's about it.
Redux is the perfect case of complete oversaturation, overcontrasting, and oversharpening. Reminds me of when a kid first gets into photography, and they overprocess the living shit out of their pictures to try and make them look more impressive. It ends up looking like a cartoon. That's what Redux does. Those colors on natural surfaces are so overbearingly saturated it makes the sidewalks and bricks and trees look like a McDonalds playplace.
GTAV vanilla is still stunning and incredibly realistic on ultra settings.
Fuck you no Chocolade is way better then Vanilla you dumbfucks
Aric Roy thanks man , I feel better about me self
For me it's mixed.
Some scenes look better on some setup while others looks better on another.
Luftbubblan I know right xD
Honestly, the saturation from the colors from redux are way more vivid, and I feel like that's very important for a game like GTA V. In my opinion, despite being oversaturated it's a healthy step up from the grayish horizons from GTA V, I feel like that way, the game can become even more vivid.
3:17
It makes it look like the sun is when it’s between a red giant and now
1:25 the drunk😂
NaturalVision for #GTAV got an update. Time to compare it to Redux! Which one do you like most? Edit: I use Ultra V2 Preset with Redux.
If you like our videos, please support us! Like the video or subscribe us or visit us here:
Candyland on Facebook: facebook.com/candylandGS
Candyland on Twitter: twitter.com/CandylandGS
Candyland U should also do QuantV.
www.gta5-mods.com/misc/quantv
Candyland welcome back😀
whats reshade preset on redux are u using?
Ah sorry, I use Ultra V2 ;)
Candyland ty
Redux oversaturates the image, and increases the contrast too much
NaturalIV makes it look boring and flat just like GTA IV
Vanilla is the best one.
Jossif, redux is oversaturated but realistic
Sorry Rhedox
Rhedox if you messed around with the settings you would be able to change that I'd imagine.
Rhedox
.
It's NaturalV, not NaturalIV dumbass.
natural vision is just like San Andreas
Vinay Shakyawar Agree. Dull, feels like there is something missing.
Pootis Spencer i guess you havr not tried it out yourself. i installed a mix of naturalvision+visualv and the la roads, and it looks much better than vanilla. I don't know why it looks so aeful in the video tho
1:48 Skyrim ENB
NaturalV looks like recording on a budget phone camera.
since when "natural" means awful color?
when NaturalVision was released
DankMusic ''most countries including LA'' that's a nice ''country''!...
oops. but still, you get what i mean, a lot of countries aren't "dull", you can't assume something looks natural because it's dull when in other places it wouldn't be dull.
Los Angeles is my country.
OutFreak28 try natural vision remastered
Vanila looks more realistic
Redux is like something that we see in movie
and Vanila looks like something we see in reallife
Ur wrong Vanilla isn't the one in real life its redux because the brightness graphic and in vanilla cities is foggy in the farthest and not same as real life
I must say, as far as realism vanilla is best. Redux is strange looking. During a bright clear day, the sky is almost a dark blue and looks unnatural as all hell. Even the night time looks odd. To each their own though.
Vanilla: perfection
Redux: ...
NaturalV: GTA IV
No natural vision now is insane, it was shit 3 years ago
Vanilla: Really nice
Redux: A little bit too much saturation... But sometimes extremely sexy like in 2:48
NaturalV: oof 2:24
NaturalV: RTX Off
There's literally nothing natural about NaturalV. It looks dull as fuck.
SkeleCrafter Its supposed to look like Gta IV, hence the IV in the name
Muhammad Muneeb My mistake, but the purpose was still to give it the gta iv look
Natural is dull
Redux looks really over-saturated IMO.
SkeleCrafter Real life is duller than in GTA though.
When i set it on my pc: -58fps
Ur profile picture matches the whole comment..
@@culixul its negative number :(
Redux looks digusting. Sometimes Natural IV looks better but i honestly just like the original best
Just lowering Brightness that's pretty much it!
fucking console pleb
Yup that's why I just bought myself a GTX1060, moron.
Lmao Bob, "I will be playing minecraft and other games on this chanel with my friends! I will also be making tutorials!". Honestly the best troll I've seen on UA-cam.
1:26 how is that disgusting? it's amazing!
Why is vanilla looking actually nicer than the other ones in a lot of pictures?
fan made preset in this video, it looks so shitty.
2:03 hmmm trees seem to look best in vanilla.
Lol I'm just gonna replay the whole game with redux on
for online : original (vanilla)
for gameplay : natural vision
for pics\movie : redux
You can't use any mod online anyways.
lol but i said the original gta v graphics for online
well that's the only way you are getting online is with vanilla graphics
Vanilla better then NaturalV
Sky looks good in redux
Nature looks good in vanilla
Buildings looks good in NV
Imagine if they combine together
3:17 wtf it’s so beautiful omg
If the sun was that close to us irl we’d fry like bacon for about two seconds before turning to dust after a quick boiling of our blood and popping of blood vessels and shit of course
@@Krosstic but lool🤣🤣
@@Krosstic I mean the bloom is the only reason it looks big, wtf
idk but redux is so colorful and bright that actually my eyes are burning
1:48 who else thought of far cry 5 at this moment?
Just cause 4
Skyrim with mods
This only shows how GREAT original engine was! Great job rockstar 👍
0:20 the pollutions gone
Vanilla is better
No vanilla redux
@Guitarguy shut up
No, ntr is the best
Vanilla is the best looking till this moment in time, those mods make it way darker or saturated and even took off some of the main effects.
Redux mod looks amazing but vanilla gives more fps.. natural IV doesn't look better nor gives much framerate
this is how i see it.
1.Redux
2.Vanilla
3.Natural vision
Redux nailed it! It looks really vibrant and cinematic!
Vanilla: nice
Redux: ew
Natural: realistic but very bad at times
naturalvision looks fugly to me.
TangoDinosaur I agree
Shit finally I can play GTA V on my Intel Integrated Graphics with Natural Vision! Thanks :D
i don't get the point of using those mods. the game is already beautiful even on high/very high settings.
@@blackcitadel37 And you think iGPUs can handle that? I don't think even the Vega 11 can
Redux looks like a movie. That's awesome. Exactly what I need to enjoy the game.
Alt title: How to make GTA V vanilla graphics seem good.
The natural one looks like when u got the gta v settings on low
GTA SA looks better than this NaturalV
Gta 1
Natural is the best in my opinion
Redux has better graphics but the colours are bad
vanila looks best ! what a great mod "vanila" , clap clap
1:25
Redux - best for night time
Redux: Too saturated
NaturalV: Needs more contrast
Vanilla: Perfection
NaturalV looks like gta v beta.
or GTA 4 which it is ment to represent
If GTA V took place in Costa Rica, Redux would be amazing.
Im from Costa Rica and its nice to see your comment
nice name
Redux makes it a bit too realistic lmao
No, it makes shit look like you are on acid.
I like the natural lighting one. it's closer to usual day's lighting irl
I think if you’re looking which looks more realistic:
1 - Redux
2 - Vanilla
3 - Natural
For easier gameplay:
1 - Natural
2 - Vanilla
3 - Redux
For better overall experience (gameplay + visual)
1 - Vanilla
2 and 3 - depends on which you give more value
NaturalVision sucks here, idk why. Looks like it lacks ambient occulsion? and possibly a bit grayscaled?
Redux looks way too saturated and over the top in some parts
Vanilla looks fine.
Honestly, if it was about more in the middle between vanilla and redux with some color adjustments from natural it would look pretty good.
Natural: gamma all the way down
Redux: gamma all the way up
Redux выглядит сексуально, но все же отдам голос за Ваниль.
Соглашусь, в Vanill'e более естественные цвета.
Vanilla очень реалистично. Как установить её? негде не могу найти инструкцию
Сука Блят
Ванильная игра/прога/ОС - это без модификации. Т.е. оригинал.
sega sega рукалицо
Vanilla- good for sunny weather
Redux- good for cloudy weather
Natural Vision V-good for low end pc's
a lot of comments say natural looks worse, but it actually seems very close to irl colour-wise
Here's the thing modders rarely understand. It's the cohesion of all the graphical elements. If you think that overdone bloom, DOF and screwed contrast are improvements to the picture, you need your fucking head checked by a doctor.
P.S. Vanilla is still the king. You can't replace artistry just by just adding shit up.
USMAN HUSSAIN Go play your realistic military simulator called Call of Duty.
USMAN HUSSAIN 7 years later and you're none the wiser.
USMAN HUSSAIN CAPSLOCK LOOKS THE BEST, YOU SHOULD BUY 200$ KEYBOARD FOR SHITPOSTING ON EBAY
USMAN HUSSAIN
Redux aucks in framerates...Its just a oversaturated piece of shit
The Undertaker HIYOOOOOOO!
Is there a way to get Redux but to lower the saturation?
There are different presets when you install it you would aplt it with reshade and there are darker lighter presets
@@benjaminsalt8271 Thanks, that does help, but I'm less concerned with high/low contrast and more with the color saturation. Are there different presets or sliders to be used for making something higher and lower chroma? Too high of saturation is always ugly to me. Makes it look unnatural and too cartoony. Needs balance with the lighting and contrast values, they all play off of each other to create an image.
When u see how good looking vanilla is until you use ultra settings and your computer can't handle it ):
My processor bottlenecking most of my open world games I have
I hope you bought a new one
@@Beste.TwitchClips I hope you meant a new graphics card, processor bottlenecking means the gpu is dragging the processor behind...
@@inzane3475 bro this was 11 months ago😂
@@Beste.TwitchClips i don't see how that changes anything... 1 year ago or not, bottlenecking is bottlenecking
@@inzane3475 broo chill
when the CPU IS the bottleneck then you change your CPU and same with the graphics card
Vanilla has the perfect amount of contrast without overdoing it like Redux or underdoing it like NaturalVision.
Redux: Very vibrant, makes for great, atmospheric environments. NV: Realistic filtering, makes for immersive, realistic gameplay.
Graphics:
GTA V / GTA: San Andreas / GTA IV.
butthurted console peasant?
PC is wayy more affordable. You can build a pc with at least 2-3x the graphical power of a console for almost half the price... and then upgrading the GPU every few years (the equivalent of buying a new console generation every few years) for less than half the price. Not to mention the wayy expanded mod choices, and numerous other benefits. The "consoles were built for games" argument is half true. They're built so that they can be as cheap as possible while still being able to play games but not being able to do anything else... but those savings go straight to their own wallets, not to you,. Do your research and you'll realize the only benefit to consoles are the console exclusives... This is coming from someone with a PS4 and a PC, because i'm weak and love me some Uncharted and Bloodborne ;)
Redux is too much. But it still looks good.
OriginellerName 12345 I said the same thing until I installed it, ever since then I don't regret it
Trunks Fucked Yo Bitch
I too installed it but I liked the original version better as redux just is oversaturated
I was thinking it looks OTT but I might give it a try, I've been needing a reason to go through storymode again, so i might do a redux story playthrough and see what its like as a whole. Im worried how much of an FPS hit ill take though, im getting 70-80fps maxed on my GTX 1070, heres to hoping it doesn't take it below 60 in the ultra grass areas :/
use redux and go down your screen saturation. the perfect mod.
Redux wins
i want colors and fun...
not gray slug
then play fortnite
Loop 🦵🏻
The redux in certain shots looked like real life, but on other shots you can tell it's an ENB.
the reason natrual IV looks so bad is because he has his brightness set to high and in the discription it says to turn brightness to half way than it looks amazing.
Vanilla looks best lol.
woah definitely installing that mod called vanilla
yes this was (supposed to be a) a joke.
am running REDUX and on top of it Natural Vision remastered BEST!
Wait... That's illegal.
NV 2.2 looks the most realistic to me, but I like the reduxs' movements and shadows better.
In other words, they're needs to be an in-between
i7 6700k and gtx 1080 and you have 30 fps with the mods on?