'Taking notes' and 'chewing a pen': Jury 'enthralled' with testimony in Trump's hush money trial
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 кві 2024
- MSNBC's Katie Phang, jury consultant Alan Turkheimer and former Assistant Attorney General for New York Tristan Snell share more about how the jury is reacting to David Pecker's testimony in former President Trump's hush money trial.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#Trump #DonaldTrump #hushmoneytrial
Help me understand. A guy who is not allowed to run a business in New York is asking you to hire him to run the country.
IT'S NOT A HUSH MONEY TRIAL! STOP CALLING IT THAT!
It is NOT against the LAW
its not,you are correct.
trying to send someone to jail for a 100 years because a lawyer tries to shut down a rumour,it happens all the time with billionaires. Whether it was for an election or not doesnt matter,its not a CRIME!!!!! He wasnt trying to hide a CRIME!!!
@@charlesf4428That's not what the trial is about! Please keep up.
@@charlesf4428WRONG! Election interference is illegal. Keep up.
This is the worst nightmare ever just lock his A$$ up
Well, see, they would maybe in N. Korea
The fact that it only takes one juror out of 12 to cause a mistrial, seems like injustice in my opinion.
All but ONE juror is college educated, spells doom for the man depending on stupid to get off.
I was just thinking that a jury of his peers would have inherited 1-4 million from their senile fathers. Gee, that shouldn't have been that hard.
@@kathleenkenyon1583I thought the jury would be made up of those convicted of fraud and are out on parole
If he continues to intimidate witnesses, maybe he should have to pay for their 24/7 protection.
Good idea!
In my opinion Trump should be paying for many people's security detail. Ruby Freeman & Shay Moss to start with.
I have believed that for months. Dt is a constant drain on resources of our country. He should have been made to pay. He also should have been locked up. The jury should be sequestered for their unpaid work because dt and his maggots are unhinged and dangerous.
That’s very fair!
Stop calling it a "Hush Money Trial!
It's sexier and the talking heads may not be smart enough to know what it is really about.
@@davidmccarthy6061 The "talking heads" are law professors and former AGs and other legal experts.,
@@davidmccarthy6061talking heads do but it may lose the audience which spotlights the hypocrisy in the "MSM"narrative... They all an angle, some more dubious than others...this I see as far less problematic than the disinformation the right wing new sphere is feeding its audience
Turning this into a , did Trump win the 2016 election fair and square by trying to shut down a selacious accusation a non crime , basically a rumour. How dare his lawyer do what he was hired to do, DAMAGE CONTROL.
You sure your name isn't Karen?
All court and no golf make Trump a dull boy.
All court and no golf make Trump a dull boy.
All court and no golf make Trump a dull boy.
😂
That's exactly what I was thinking 😂
I love that!
The dude cheats at golf, as well. 🙄
Trump, as punishment write this one hundred times "All court...."
Don't commit crimes in NY if you don't want to be tried by a NY jury!
I'm a NYer and we've known what a cheap, lying, cheating, attention hog, bullying, whining, lying, mobbed up POS he's always been. Glad I wasn't summoned.
Did I say lying twice? My mistake. He's a LIAR.
I thought Trump was the only one in court in New York City.
Funny President Biden is too busy running the whole country Not NY.
Quit blaming Biden , he didn't pay or was with McDougle or Stormy !spanking a butt!
what crimes??? Bragg still hasnt said what it is Trump committed.
enough with the "just one juror" talk!!
think positive
Just one juror, I can here a bell ringing, one juror and forget everything, oh oh Mamma Mia
He is charged with fraud. The dirty laundry is irrelevant. He has already be found guilty of fraud in previous trials.
Stop talking about a hung jury. Jesus.
IKR?!
For real he is innocent and anything less than all jurors aquitting him is nonsense
While I agree with your comment otherwise, please do not use the name of Jesus in any connection to diaper don. diaper don doesn't deserve any association with Christ, not even in this manner, which I presume you mean negatively. Thank you for considering my comment.
@@YellowbellyshoeI wonder what evidence you’ve seen or heard that makes you say that?
Is your assertion just a knee jerk defense to someone saying he might be less than perfect?
It is completely reasonable to assume that a presidential candidate would not want his indiscretions to go public -so he’d be willing to buy the story and keep it quiet until after the election. (Especially right after that “gab ‘em by the…” video came out. He was in trouble with that one and couldn’t afford another one)
It’s reasonable to assume he wouldn’t want the bank records to prove he paid directly, so he paid in a roundabout manner, having the national enquirer and his fixer pay.
The really big, dumb mistake was trying to write it off his taxes. If he hadn’t done that, probably nobody would’ve noticed.
Are you saying Trump isn’t capable of making a mistake? Nobody’s perfect. Especially when they’re under that much stress and the stakes are that high.
You can say that you think what he did shouldn’t be a crime, but I don’t see how you can say he didn’t do it.
@@Yellowbellyshoe lol...the last time Trump was innocent was 5 minutes after birth.
A rich brat throws a temper when he lost the match and years later, the continuing America's nightmare
I am a Canadian and I am getting just a little worried about our next door neighbor.
Don't worry about us, people are trying to come here in record numbers.
If the US goes full flat earth in November we need to find new trade and military alliances.
I live in New Hampshire do you have a spare room?
GETTING a little worried? Where ya been? You should've started worrying in 2016. Things in the US have been in a spiral since then and there's no sign of things getting better anytime soon.
@@jamesswain2465 Poorly educated people, not Canadians.
Hold the press!! Are you really saying a juror chewed the end of their pen?? Incredible im on the edge of my seat.
Man, I was a better journalist at age 5...
🤣🤣🤣
more magats indicted in Arizona.... so AWESOME!
Hilarious!
Oh my 😮 probably been his fingernails 😂😂😂😂😂😂
The jury is paying attention is a good thing.
@msnbc - you are doing us a journalistic disservice by not calling this "the 2016 Pre-Election Interference Case" - as the Supreme Court case is callously hearing the "Insurrection Case" ... words matter.
The STINK!! is toast
Stinky is what Putin calls Trump in private, when the translators have been sent to the gulag.
I wish, but I dare not to hope for any real consequences for Trump.
The American people are toast with this ongoing BS morning noon and night for years on end with no end in sight
Old McDonald had a trial, here a trial, there a trial, everywhere a trial.
Old McDonald had Fronto-Temporal Dementia
With a not guilty here and a not guilty there everywhere a not guilty
@@jamesswain2465 oops 4 guilties so far. All civil but could be time to add a criminal guilty. 😮
@James Swain
Trump IS getting CONVICTED, not acquitted.
@@jamesswain2465 as a rapo here, he's a rapo there a rapo rapo all the way to prison, rapo
Heard there might be a problem with juror #2 - who gets his news from Truth Social and X. (Have to confess - it gets me nervous as well)
That’s why they have 6 alternate jurors for the case so if necessary that juror could be removed and replaced.
Just a thought. What if there is a Trump juror in the jury and after listening to "evidence" turns on Trump? 😂
Vote 💙
Maybe it should take more than one juror to derail a conviction.
This only 1 witness of many, he should becconvicted on several of these charges, remember he only has to be convicted on one charge,each conviction has a max of four years in jail
This whole unanimous decision thing between 12 people seems awfully convoluted to me. Where else in our society do we prescribe that everyone must agree?
Throughout our criminal justice system. Our justice system is not based on Democracy. It is based on upon being beyond a reasonable doubt, times twelve.
@@AlbertHess-xy7ky I understand that but what does it mean to have 1/12 of reasonable doubt? Any single person can throw off what it means to have a fair trial. Like seriously you can just buy off one person if that's all it means. What sense does this actually make? Not talking about the past in the present time, What sense does this actually make?. How does this even make sense to have a 12 to 1 chance in a trial?. I pray that if I get set before a judge then I get 12 other people where I only need to convince one of my wrongdoing. This is not a judicial system. This is a farce
@@jared7612 Wow!
In our current system it takes 12 to "prove" that you are guilty or 12 to "prove" that you are innocent, With less than 12 your guilt is undetermined. You are subject to being retried until you your guilt is proved, or disproved.
What system should be in place to determine guilt or innocence? Democracy? Supermajority? Unanimity?
@@AlbertHess-xy7ky what is "Wow" about the statement. You literally put the word prove in quotes. That diminishes your point entirely. Supermajority is fine.
🇺🇲trump's Dictator Demands 2SCOTUS: Give me DICTATOR IMMUNITY NOW.
Four years to hold your nemesis to account. He's no criminal mastermind, he's left a long trail of incriminating evidence. Don't bother thinking up excuses, nobody's interested.
📣 Katie, you look great without the heavy makeup!
I think she looks better with the cake
Trump thinks he looks better with mass makeup. Gag
@@thomasbullen5239 he probly does
They forgot to report the color ink of the pen the juror used.😏
Orange
@@TeddScheckler 😂
All juries should be anonymous. Puts the power in the hands of the jury, NOT consultants using psychological and verbal cues to manipulate the outcome.
All juries should be anonymous? The the Judge? To the lawyers? to the accused? Should they know about the jurors previous convictions? You are a fool!!!
Can I do a goFundMe “won't you please donate to trump so he can pay his family to show up and act like they care”??
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'd like to be a fly on the wall listening 😮
Jury Consultant sounds to me like a position that only wealthy defendants can afford, like say for example, a defendant who can afford to have a team of attorneys rather than a court appointed public defender. "Equal Justice Under Law" Yeah, right.
Except Trump isn't wealthy... not for long.
She is breathlessly treating this Trump disgrace like a game like a tournament. Sickening really.
And you’re watching like a dope fiend 24/7. Trump is her drug and yours too. He is the only ratings for DJTMSNBC
Vote him out the national discourse.... This November punch the ballot against trump circus
Katie looks great with no make up, I wish all the ladies of msnbc would follow this trend of no make up. Thanks Katie Phang, refreshing.
She is wearing makeup. It's just done in a way to look as if she isn't wearing any.
The use of "jury consultants" sounds as corruptive to the process as lobbyists are to government.
How is the Flatulent Don doin'?
😅😅😅 amazing that folks want him to represent them.
Depends USA is cheering.
Full loads a happening..
He looks tired and in need of a diaper change.............AGAIN
@@regu6582Maybe they can offer a special Orange Cheetos model.
Preloaded with bs. 😂😂😂😂😂
Full of it, bigly.
SOMETHING STINKS ! Oh wait that's just DUMP ! A waitress probally threw her pen and note pad at him BECAUSE she couldn't stand the stench
Donald needs to testify!
The jury needs all of the information about him! How else are they expected to make an objective decision?
a juror who is paying attention is not good for trumpo
Love the artwork
The news that makes crap up.😢
Lock him up already.......somebody pleeeeeezzzeee lock him up.
"BULL" not available.
Yeah "Bull" got cancelled before he had to take on the mess that is Trump. Does make me wonder if he would take this case.
FFS, a juror is chewing on a pen? Seriously? This is news?
Jury psychology, sounds like a former television program, what happen to evidence evaluation?
Drumph is absolutely toast.
Jury consultants, how pathetic the justice system has become.
What a complete mess
At least the dumpster fire is not in The White House.
mmm ink pen buffet
I would imagine that a good number of jury consultants have had some fair amount of experience in a prosecutor's office.
Will the jury consultants also not get paid by Trump?
I am ignorant on this! Why does it have to be a unanimous vote to convict vs the majority? Anyone? Thanks!!
Ignorant Illegal immigrant? The majority often get it wrong, look at murder conviction exonerations. Better 100 guiltily go free than one innocent locked up, or killed.
It's the way our founders wanted it. Have faith, Kathleen. 3 juries unanimously found Dumpy guilty so far. The evidence against him is so compelling, the fourth will as well.
Because if not then the prosecution has not met their "burden of proof". But, the defendant can still be prosecuted in state court for similar crimes, or civil court for liability...
Most jurors believe their opinions are more relevant than facts or the law.
You can only prove a premise is true beyond a reasonable doubt if it's valid in the first place.
Reading the indictments you run across several ≠s requiring cognitive leaps.
Which one's?
Only if you are ignorant of the law.
@@Knight3rrant there are lawyers and legal consultants that share my view.
Only people who say they guide their lives with reference to observation, evidence, probability and reason should be allowed on a jury. Anybody who adheres to a notion of 'belief without evidence' should be excluded because they shouldn't be involved with anything important in the only world that matters - the real one.
Agreed. Unfortunately, the defense in this trial wants wingnuts who believe in conspiracy theories...on the jury.
WHY is this woman, Katie , talking so fast? Really ,is having jury consultants news?
You can always go back to Fox. You're missing that Jerry Springer rerun marathon.
Outside the courthouse there are none
of his flock of sheep to welcome him or
to cheer him on. Now, increasingly saddened
by his solitude, alone and abandoned, he
must realize that his only supporter is the
old man he sees in his mirror.
Katie Phang is beautiful without makeup !!! 😍😘
America is strong why we are using this nonsense
Would the jury forgive Trump for breaking wind indiscriminately or would they swallow the argument that he is avoiding constipation?
14 X 30 = 420 days in jail
🇺🇸Republicans agcinst Trumg👎
Wow, Jansing is actually doing her homework and bringing her A game to this trial coverage. I'm usually a harsh critic of her, Mitchell and Tur, but she's a lot better here. Hopefully that spreads to the two others.
This just in Trump blinked 3x signaling to his followers to rise up😂
I wouldnt be surprised if thrump threw some hush money on one of the jurors hes good at this
American courts need to lock-up this pompous career criminal, thinks he's the Queen of England.
Why is this guy differentiating between the lawyers on the jury and the "lay people" on the jury. It's not like people on the jury who don't practice law for a living can't reach a verdict in this case.
They are engaged and listening Donnie.
Why he need jury i think the jurors supposed to be in the middle and be honest to the case?
cc is out of sinc with the visual. FIX IT!!
Jury consultants aren't looking for the perfect juror -- they're helping the lawyers decide which jurors to exclude with their peremptory challenges. And they help the lawyers try to figure out what questions they want the judge to ask. Jury consultants can only work with whatever questions the judge and lawyers ask. Tuerheimer is right on. The idea that jury consultants can read minds is ridiculous. They just help the lawyers do the best job they can do with what they have. But the idea that prosecutors don't need jury consultants is ridiculous. Any lawyer can benefit from someone who is not a lawyer who understands juror behavior.
This isn't good😒. Get it to flip out on them. This will end their celebrity infatuation.
As if anyone thinks that the voter registration data wasn't accessed by the defense...
Dozy Don will be convicted but he will never be jailed. 😢
Jury Consultant = $$$$$
(aka, paying too much money because you don't trust your own intuition even though you've been in lawyering for decades)
What a rort.
Katie looks so beautiful without makeup!! imho
Statistically, hung juries only occur about 6% of the time in state juries. This pundit is making too much of this as a potential possibility.
I suspect that we all know who is the turd in the punchbowl.
Are some lawyers for trump missing?
Oh, please forget that Republican way to forge troubled delay in the process, simply to dismiss the case.
Sounds like the jury is bored out of their skulls...
In terms of the Supreme Court mullings...You may remember the handle "White House Council." This isn't about what a president can do on his own, it's about what his Council tells him he can or can't do. So, the question is, what resource is the council using to form their opinion? And how would that change depending on the court decision?
Remember, Trump listens to no one, including his council...
It’s funny that Trump thinks it’s not childish to complain about the temperature of the court.
It's not right that this trial is not being shared publicly. We have to put up with these pundits steering us in the wrong direction. Ugh.
Stop talking about 'trying to convince just one juror.' You know that's not how it works. The jury works together, to share how they viewed the evidence, to ask for clarification, to talk. Their goal is to come together, not to have a hung jury. The influence the jurors have on each other is far greater than the Trump lawyers trying to pinpoint one juror and heavily influence that juror. Not to mention they have no business doing that.
Remember he started his career with a tiny loan from his father of a million dollars leaving out the other three hundred and ninety million he inherited.
I'd be leary of using a jury consulting firm that cost me half a million bucks! Id trust my own judgment.
This is like a mob boss trial, i dont even wanna think of a juror being bought by Donnie bone spurs!
i am so SICK OF TRUMP getting away with every crime there is a law for and the law seemingly being written to allow it.
OMG Katie is so pretty w/o makeup 😳🤒
Maybe a jury is not the greatest idea to find justice. Maybe it's better not to have layman make such important decisions. Would you want a jury of layman decide about your treatment when you're seriously ill? Or laymen repair your car? Or take care of your finances?
Laymen cannot afford to live in Manhattan...
🩵
Msnbc: sources say trump was doing cartwheels and biting at the judges ankles in the courtroom, drawings confirm.
trump is scared of prison.... he is a sexoffender... he very well should be terrified... did you see what happened to the Olympics doctor PDO?... not pretty.... but Donny deserves it all.
This may be the closest we ever get to world peace
BS, jury consultants are looking for jurors who are biased for them, and try to manipulate the rest.
Your legal system based on personal opinions and "precedents", not on actual laws, is beyond ridiculous. America has the highest rate of wrongfully convicted people, as high as all the other countries combined. This kind of legal system cannot be repaired, it needs to be replaced with actual laws and a robust state to protect the rights before protecting liberties. There can't be justice in a Court where there's nothing above the "judge" personal opinion and above the personal opinions of a small mob of 12 "peers". In civilized countries, justice is a right, not a freedom. But you don't know what rights are because you value only liberties, you hold the problem backwards.
ORANGE KLOWNS MATTER!
Why do you News People think the PUBLIC IS STUPID! WE KNOW HOW A JURY WORKS EINSTEIN
Well 73 million adults in this country voted for the chump second time around. I'd say that's a huge amount of stupidity. Also there will be children watching as well (perhaps).
@@davids4313 Is like the media is helping him get away with it
We should understand that in this case, Trump is being charged with 34 NY State political interference penalties. That of course means that the jury will be asked to make their decision on all 34 charges. If they agree that Trump is guilty on AT LEAST ONE of the 34 charges, that gives Judge Merchan the duty of coming up with a penalty.