Discussion with General GD Bakshi: "Bold Proposals on India's Security Dilemmas"
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 чер 2017
- A very candid and bold conversation with one of India's foremost military experts on Information Warfare & Psychological Operations. General Bakshi examines India's options on Pakistan, China, Islam's civil war between Sunnis and Shiites. He gives forceful facts and ideas for the forthcoming Modi-Trump summit.
To donate to Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do:
इनफिनिटी फ़ौंडेशन की परियोजनाओं को अनुदान देने के लिए व इस प्रकार के एपिसोड और हमारे द्वारा किये जाने वाले शोध को जारी रखने के लिए: infinityfoundation.com/donate-2/
To Subscribe to Rajiv Malhotra Official:
राजीव मल्होत्रा ऑफिसियल की सदस्यता लेने के लिए: / @rajivmalhotraofficial
Join Rajiv's discussion (राजीव की चर्चा से जुडें): groups.google.com/d/forum/inf...
GD Bakshi can stop a person committing suicide.. Inspiration
So true.I thought the same too
What a nice perspective and compliment.
Every Indian army officer is trained so. He is also one such Wonder
As a soon to be IAS officer Sri Rajiv Ji has inspired & taught me a lot through his own lifelong tapsya. JAI HIND.
Abhinav Singh we need a lot of IAS officer like you. May! God bless you.
Abhinav Singh Congrats bro👍🏽
thanks man N P
Abhinav Singh hope you make all bharatiya proud i am young and dream to work for my country in intellect front. everyday i try to seek more inspiration and guidance from people like rajiv ji.
be vigilant and smart.... best of luck... jai hind bharat mata ki jai...
Rajiv ji is right when he says there is rampant mediocrity today in the new generation.On the social media one comes across millions of nationalist youth who do the pak/anti national bashing, name calling, ramble rousing etcetera; but what we need are not an army of trollers, but an army of nationalists, who actually serve national interests by first developing themselves into individuals with skills/expertise/knowledge that can effectively be employed to fight the battle on a given plane(strategic /intellectual & academic/social/cultural/political & electoral).We must be in this for the long haul and that requires serious commitment. That is precisely what i am gearing up to do. Jai hind
The majority of so-called nationalists are prone to a "feel good syndrome". This kind of attitude is not going to get us anywhere. We as a nation still lack collective identity, it is high time we should rejuvenate ideological and cultural glory of Bharata. This will play a crucial role in addressing the regional, social, religious differences and it will also help in addressing the inferiority complex in the minds of young Hindus and Muslims vis-a -vis West and Middle East respectively. Only when we are strong from inside, we can think of doing certain kind of high-risk geopolitical and military manoeuvres which could yield pathbreaking results. Jai Hind.
Develop Mind that is
Dharmic-Hindu Nationalist
Open
Accepts everything Good / Bad / Ugly
Rejects nothing
Puts everything
in their RIGHT position
within the overall SCHEME of things
Works CONTINUOUSLY on the overall SCHEME
as the real world becomes increasingly VUCA (volatile, uncertain, chaotic, ambiguous)
keeping dharma as the top level concept unchanging & stable and willing to change all else !
yes....It's true....
Prithvi Patil so true I'm in this position to ans any pak person jai hind vande mataram
Incognito Juggernaut advantage is not for a particular class. This govt. is bringing a new NCBC for OBC, SCs and STs
Gen Bakshi is a great strategist and a patriot!
it's a shame that such an interesting conversation has got only 150+ likes and 1.4k views
two great Nationalist....100 salaams.
General DG bakshi you are a real think tank.
This was great ! I am amazed at the clarity and the depth of thoughts of both Gen Bakshi and Mr Malhotra.
tumhari hum keh ki le lenge
If bakshi was pm there would be no terroism in india
Gen.G.D.Bakshi belongs to this kinda discussions & rendezvous where the audience can hear him out loud n clear unlike on those stupid debates aired on typical TRP greedy news channels.
Thank You so much for this Shri Rajiv ji.
Aum Shanti.
India need a bold expansive long term policy towards Pakistan so that Pakistan falls in line otherwise India cannot achieve its potential. But before that we need to straighten the award vapsi brigade inside India.
My full respects to Sir GD Bakshi but I loved Rajivjis questions than the answers.
Thank you Rajiv ji & Genl Bakshi for this very informative and eye-opening geo-strategic & geo-political discussion. Excellent questions raised, brilliant elaboration by Genl. Bakshi, over all a lesson for me in this "India-Centric" International Geo-political & geo-strategic discussion. Salute to both of you & look forward to more such interviews. God bless!!
First of all I would like to thank Rajiv Malhotraji for sharing the knowledge which was very difficult to get. your podcast UA-cam video not just answers questions but clear other vision. मे फिर एक बार आपको धन्यवाद करता हूं और ईश्वर से आपके अच्छे स्वास्थ्य और लंबी आयु की कामना वह प्रार्थना करता हूं धन्यवाद
Someone is finally talking about this comprehensively! I have not heard such clarity, scope and laser focus anywhere else. Well done Rajivji and Bakshiji. Hopefully, this gets to the right ears. Our political timidity is intolerable.
Awesome talk! If we would have been Israel we would have taken each of the steps discussed by these two great men.
Who is stopping the government from re-establishing Kashmiri Pandits back in their ancestral homes. This has to be done by force. Does Indian government have such guts and grits? BJP came to power twice since 1990 when Pandits were thrown out of Kashmir. It has done nothing so it is only all talk no action.
dude oic (organization of islamic countries) is behind them. whenever such step is taken leftist and communist elite in media and human rights starts crying for human rights of kashmiries. so first we have to counter them by taking them out of power from parliament then we have to replace these communist elite from major places of influence such as literary festivals human rights organizations and universities etc with our nationalist intellectuals... so this will take some time...
The major issue is security.
Please sir! I think your video needs more "SEO" on youtube!! With lots of thing like proper "Tagging" and "title" setup!!! Then more people will find your video on search on related topics and it will boost your video ranking, more people will subscribe !!
Pls write me privately at RajivMalhotra2007@gmail and help us. We need competent volunteers like you.
very good conversation
Rajiv sir please make Substantial Swamy sir also join this debate he knows China in and out
Namaste Hindu family 👪
Jai Hind
Thanks for your hard work
gen bakshi said UPA waster 10 years by not militarizing. I would like to correct that. UPA tried to systematically destroy the Indian military, deteriorate it. It was well thought out. I repeat, UPA TRIED TO DEGRADE THE INDIAN MILITARY AS A WELL THOUGH OUT MEASURE. Pakistan needs to thank Signora.
We are with you Sir GD Bakshi Ji.......you can just tell us what little we could do to achieve the mighty task...........OmShantiOm.
USA has invested in Saudi and sunni alliance hence USA will continue to support Pakista. We are the other big elephant in the room if not chna ...USA rather see us disintegrate, so we better be fully equiped and self sufficent on oil and weapons in the next war.
At 5am I can't stop me from viewing another episode of conversation between general Baksi and Rajeev Malhotra.
please do a video on Muslim Brotherhood and Bollywood
Siddharth Chakraborty Mullah wahabbi brotherhood.most Muslims of India r fine
Supreme Leader What is up with the Muslims in Bengal,Kashmir and Karnataka then ?
Great talk Rajivji and General Bakshi. Hope Indian govt. is listening.
Great talk 4 Jihadis disliked it so far.
We need one of them as PM
General Bakshi a true brave soldier with killing instinct. He is absolutely right on almost all accounts.
Thank you for the candid, honest view on the Kashmir troubles, General GD Bakshi. The deep-state of Pakistan military and ISI need to be crushed.
It is sad that Modi like his predecessor did only lip service to Baluch nationals. He should take it up a notch higher, but turned out to be another disappointment with one day headlines. Show some guts and bring it up.
Excellent conversation very interesting and informative!!!
Bakshi is a Indian Alsatian, Highly vigorous, Highly patriotic, well read informed, brave and Down to earth. Very very inspiring
Thank you
Please do more discussion with gd
Excellent . For anyone who wants to know the geopolitical issues of India, this is the place. I would have liked to hear more of solution based approach on how India can tackle these foreign forces. Nevertheless, great talk and knowledge for taking.
❤️What gd is saying is happening in 2020
Smart man ❤️
The window of Indian engagement with Pakistan is shrinking by the day, The quicker China gains leverage and deploys assets in Pakistan, the faster India loses whatever little advantage it currently has. Kashmir problem has been allowed to fester for too long. Sindh / Balochistan secession should have been supported years ago etc. Unfortunately, Indian politicians have lacked the interest & will to decisively engage Pakistan militarily or strategically, all actions are reactive.
India is under active attack internally by Breaking India forces; externally encircled by China over land & sea; and shackled into inaction by US/Israel interests.
In spite of this, Modi and his govt. seem more interested in burnishing their international image and to date have not taken any strategic actions on geo-political issues, other than to posture ineffectively using "surgical strikes" in response to extreme provocations.
As has always happened, India's national security is mortgaged to outside influences and serious action never taken to end long-running problems, which are kept simmering until they become too big to fully resolve to a stable equilibrium.
Hero of india. GD Bakshi sir. Salute from the bottom of my heart. Islamic terrorism needs to be curbed.
Both these Gentlemen are to be revered as our great patriarchs.
Alas, today's youths don't even wanna stand up for the anthem
so called "wanting Azadi"...haha great dialogue General!
It was a contrast of thoughts.. RM was a bit pessimistic(or I should say "realistic" ) and Major was optimistic.. Nice one
Comparing India to an elephant, slow to react, but hard to stop when in motion, is emphatically true, encouraging,& not an exaggeration.
Well said Sir GD Bakshi Ji, Tibet should be released from China, Tibetan government established there, in the near future, come what may.
Taking back Indian lands from Pakistan & China should be India’s “Very unshakable resolve” and need.
How to accomplish this, can be safely, left in the able hands of
Sir GD Bakshi Ji and the “Like Minded” thinkers of the Nation............OmShanti, Shanti, Santi hee.
I wonder how Israel will fit in. This topic was not touched in detail. Or did I miss it?
thanks rajiv bhai for this discussion. bakshi saab 1000 salam. hail .......you know who and we shall win...hope we stop giving money to Uk (refer prof of IIM)so that we have enough to build military...... and i wonder have we in all sense achieved freedom or some lacuna in our freedom from british...technically...that the common wealth has to be shared or queen is the final authority on dire consequences.....want to know (refer rajiv dixit who said abt domanian state or smthing)
General Bakshi has given a wonderful and fruitful ideas and forceful facts. We have to see as to how for the Present Indian Government takes this advice and moves forward to reduce the day to day killing of the uniformed services.
Nice video.
excellent discussion.
great video sir.please make more of such videos
Rajiv sir, ek interview Madhu Kishwar mam ke saath bhi kijiye.
naveen rawat
Already done few months ago
Even the Saudis who are not from Nejad are against Wahhabism!
please a three prong discussion with u two an subramaniam Swamy sir u also need a economist of his calibre in this panel
Sir, Please do one video with Sadguru Jaggi Vasudev.
The question of Rajiv Ji about pakistan been able to get multi aligned help from both communist and democratic countries like China, Russia and USA, while Indian diplomacy could not and also about internal disturbance from local Sunnis when an all out war is waged against Pakistan; has been intelligently circumvented by Gen GD Bakshi. The General, In ideal conditions is absolutely right about our military capabilities, but we are still a struggling country from within and do not have deep pockets like China to afford a long term war or even a battle. Analogy of India with a heavy weight elephant, who, when gets up will be relentless and unstoppable is a rhetoric that is not affordable lest it may not only empty our pockets even for food, but may also lead to balkanization of our country. We are so heavily dependent on Saudi Arabia for oil, and have to a heavy price to antagonise them. Our around 85% of defence budget whatever little goes in paying salaries and pensions, how can we swiftly modernise in mere 5-6 Lakh Crore rupees. Further unlike China, we are totally dependent on arms support on USA, Europe, Russia and Israel. Despite being 3rd largest economy, by way of sheer population, we aren't strong enough to be able to stand on our own feet, with little indiginisation of military weaponry. That means heavy investment in private sector RnD and industrialisation of defence equipment manufacturer. As Rajiv Ji has emphasized earlier we are decades behind china in AI, Avionics, military grade semiconductors and metallurgy to be able to fight even conventional battlefield. Focus has to be export of technology, and not just being servants to Google's, Facebooks and twitter...... But given present condition with danger from within like Kisaan, movement, NRC/ CAA opposition, Pro Pak mentality of good chunk, Maoists, leftist..... This is rather a pipedream.
I am not one of that nationalist, who flow into emotion and then give up soon. I fight with facts and with true national interest...Not happy with modi policy to handle the current crisis, I think he need to change his strategy to handle current crisis...
The question put by Rajiv is straight forward and plain: What are the options available to India in tackling the Pakistani menace? Gen. Bakshi says many things in response, which are quite o. k. but not so straight forward. I do not know whether somebody in the government is listening and would take note of these suggestions or not. My take: We - that is, India - should be very clear of a few facts. 1. Pakistan as a nation is based on their religious mandate of cleansing of the world - including India - of the kafirs or non-believers. India is their nearest enemy, old sour in their side and target of their first fury. Till Pakistan is what it is, India can not live in peace and security. 2. The world is what it is. China or the US or Russia, all, have their own interests and strategy to kill two birds with one shot. So, India should take this reality into account and take the Pakistan problem as its own problem and deal with it by taking into account of the world reality. 3. Atomic weapons of Pakistan is a reality and India has to find an answer to that reality in a reasonable manner. With these preliminaries, my suggestion: Pakistan problem should be handled with a comprehensive approach. A. Help Balochistan freedom fighters in every possible way. B. Divert Sind River waters by unilaterally abrogating the treaty in question. It should be done quickly and before China is able to construct storage of diverted Brahmputra waters. C. Help and encourage the Pakistani thinking people, liberals, Sufi stream there. All possible help. D. India should inform and get united the world opinion against the Pakistani terrorism on the war footing. Hold urgent conferences, leaders-meets, cooperating treaties with the willing parties. E. India HAS TO BE READY to answer Pakistan nuclear blackmail. An open policy that if Pakistan provokes India enough it is not Pakistan but India that MAY use its atomic arsenal and not the other way round. Also get its own missile-shield, awaks etc. in place. Develop technology fast and fast enough, at whatever cost. F. At the same time, parallel with this approach, India must advance speed of the development of her economy, again at whatever the cost - defeating in whatever way possible the internal political opposition to such growth. G. Coordinate with the anti-terrorist plans and initiatives of the countries that are the sufferers of this menace, be they US or Israel or Russia. G. Try to create understanding with China; give the reasons that they understand. etc.
Excellent Post. Summary is as follows
===============================
1. upgrade economy
2. develop & deploy relatively better military technology vs pk
3. divert river waters & then abrogate IWT (not the other way round)
4.openly help liberate balouchistan
5. put the missile shield in place > use atomic weapons first !! (not react to
pakistani attack)
@@nuramig8126 can we use Nuclear To kill 200 million people
👍🏼
love it gd bakshi
sometimes iam afraid to watch Rajiv ji program. so blunt, it's better to watch Subramanian Swamy, bit humour and positive
lovely debate.....plz take some hindu janjagruti sangathan people they also doing well for india...jay hind
Sunny Sharma what are they doing?
Chinese
Teacher : students what is opposite of Good ?
students : answer Bad
Teacher : tell me what is opposite of Original ?
students : answer Made in China :D Even kids know China means Duplicate and bad quality
1st of all I'm not pakistani nor a supporter of pakistan. Im of bangladeshi origin uk national. Rajiv, i admire you and your effort to educate indians and make them more patriotic. But i note, Pakistan is a very hot topic amongst you indian. It seems very explosive topic and has left very toxic feelings implanted amongst you indian and im sure amongst some pakistan too. When will you ourgrow your facination of Pakistan?
GD has paid his dues,we better listen to him.
Mujhe bakshi sir se milna hai.. Please
Indians commonly do not take intrest in International affairs and we are paying the price , had the people been more aware we would have pushed the coward congress govt to take some action against pakistan after 26/11 , it was great opportunity we had sympathy of the world, countries fed with pakistan were waiting for India to take action , and we backed out
👏🚩💯✔👍✌👌
Mr. Malhotra I don't have any money to donate to anyone ... What can you do for me in Canada ? I can run your branch in Canada with due diligence ... How much salary in excess of Canadian dollar sixty thousand plus benefits can you pay me?
56:48 One reason why Nehru must have been more assertive towards India's security.
Nar seva hi Narayan seva, Manav seva hi Madhav seva, Kar bhala toh ho bhala, Ek bhalai ke anek Labh
Service to man is service to God, When You Do Good God Does You Good, Many benefits of a good
"The Pakistani military are rational actors" That's a ... relief?
You guys missed Sri Lanka. 😐😐
no capture half of sindh ,baluchistan and full of gilgit,balistan and pok
In 1947 Jammu had ethnic cleansing of 4 lakh Muslims
Why was not that done at that time in Kashmir valley itself?
This thing wouldn't have dragged it till 1990
It would have been buried there itself
Maj Gen GD Bakshi Shares His Leadership Insights
www.linkedin.com/pulse/maj-gen-gd-bakshi-shares-his-leadership-insights-bhattacharjee
24 pakistanis disliked the video
Get rid of article 371 in the Indian Constitution which is actually conceding to Pak narrative.
collect wapon as much as possible
Please dubbed in hindi.i think thousands of people understood clearly .I request sir please
Devendra Maurya also Tamil Kannada Telugu Malayalam Marathi Bengali
@@dcmhsotaeh agree bro
He forgot to tell abt Indo Israeli alliance
Just talks no action
I express my objection for saying stupid Islamic mentality.
1- suicide attack is not a part of islam.
If someone say its a part of islam we accept their views. Then we r stupid coz if someone called a horse is donkey n any person agree n calling a horse a donkey. I m sure 100% all people says that man is stupid. 2- if I advice to our govt. n armed forces how India became a safest palce in the world three things we should do 1 stop n erase wahabi ideology from my country (I.e INDIA) 2 make Pakistan army weak n weak as possible. 3 Also erase all extremist ideologies I mean who want to ran or impose there ideology in india ( directly or indirectly ). n says who's agree or follow their ideology can live in this country . n who don't they r anti national. n says get out from india or they killed them.
Yeah I thought that was a bit too strong in terms of language. I think it would have been better put as the stupid mentality of Islamic radical terrorists (who are pretty much apostates)
There are problems with the fundamentals of islam, it's a maximalist religion which has done all sorts of atrocities all over the world. Just to sound politically correct I will not subscribe to the point of view that Islam is a religion of peace. It's hypocritical to call a religion peace whose identity is strongly linked to the persecution of others . All those peacefull preachers of Islam don't you see what Islam has done to this world . Almost every terrorist is a muslim , it can't be a mere coincident. Sooner or later world as a whole has to fight this menace called Islam or else it will make this world too dangerous to live .
Post script: Some questions to all who have different point of view
1 Why no Islamic country in this world is secular ?
2 Why almost all Islamic countries transport terrorism to their neighbouring countries?
3 Why no muslim respects constitution of this country at par with the so called Holy Quran, which is by the way a piece of bull shit .
4 How can there exist so much difference between interpretation of same text by different people ?
Mohammad Abdullah ur last line is not digestable. yeah wahabism should be discouraged but wahabis cannot be killed bcoz killing a human being for his ideology is worst form of human rights violation. as long as a muslim associate himself as muslim not bharatiya problem is not going to vanish. once the vote bank politics will stop then only our country can reclaim our postion globally. muslims in this country are in total denial mode by reading or hearing wrong history. As long as they are not proud for their hindu ancestors they cannot became bharatiya and this problem will continue. jai hind
Lol what a farcical comedy.. India role in baluchistan will be failure vis a vis kashmir. Kashmir is Muslim state that have an inclination towards Pakistan which proves a fertile ground for pak isi using religion as a catalyst adding kashmir border to pak while baluchistan is far away from india n religion inclination towards india is zero only funding nationalist movement will be only short term game...
Jedi barca bangladeshis were also muslims i guess
@@srmohanty7460 but pakistan army exploited them
👍🏼