Tigers, Panthers & Stugs - How Many Survive 2023?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 вер 2024
- How many WW2 German heavy armoured vehicles survive today? Which is the most common, and how many single examples of famous tanks remain? Which is the rarest? Find out here...
Dr. Mark Felton FRHistS, FRSA, is a well-known British historian, the author of 22 non-fiction books, including bestsellers 'Zero Night' and 'Castle of the Eagles', both currently being developed into movies in Hollywood. In addition to writing, Mark also appears regularly in television documentaries around the world, including on The History Channel, Netflix, National Geographic, Quest, American Heroes Channel and RMC Decouverte. His books have formed the background to several TV and radio documentaries. More information about Mark can be found at: en.wikipedia.o...
Visit my audio book channel 'War Stories with Mark Felton': • One Thousand Miles to ...
Help support my channel:
www.paypal.me/...
/ markfeltonproductions
Disclaimer: All opinions and comments expressed in the 'Comments' section do not reflect the opinions of Mark Felton Productions. All opinions and comments should contribute to the dialogue. Mark Felton Productions does not condone written attacks, insults, racism, sexism, extremism, violence or otherwise questionable comments or material in the 'Comments' section, and reserves the right to delete any comment violating this rule or to block any poster from the channel.
Credits: The National Archives; Library of Congress; Bangnerfahrer; VFF Wehrtecknische Studiensammlung Koblenz; Samuel Penn; Maciej Born; Alf van Breem; Alan Wilson; Werner Hillmann; Schierbecker; Fat-yankey; Superewer; Picasa
The tank museum at Bovington is a much recommend, I remember standing next to the king tiger and being completely in awe at how large it actually was 😬
Was really cool to see it in Parola tank museum in Finland 😄 never imagine it to be so damn big
The jagdtiger is even bigger. Like a small house
I agree, i saw the same king tiger this year and it was so absurdly huge, i definitely recommend others to go see it.
I live in Dorset but since I don't drive haven't had the chance to get to Bovington in far too long. I remember an event there once seeing tanks outside being put through their paces with smoke grenades going off. Was pretty awesome. Amazing speed on that Stug 3 in the video.
Yes, that would be expected. But what isn't expected- I stood in front of a Sherman a few years ago, and man, THAT seemed huge to me. You get the impression from history the Sherman wasn't all that impressive. It really is when you stand next to it.
When i grew up in the 90s a farmer near my home still had a panzerkampfwagen, that had been used as vegetable transport on the property for decades. he had many broken down ones in a shed aswell, i always loved to see those things, the feeling of some of these vehicles running again like that stug... lovely. brings me back to when i saw him driving out of the shed. making noises but never shutting down. Todays society is like if its making noise, its going to die on you. these german things are something special.
Here in Australia, a number of US Stuart light tanks were converted to farm and mining machinery by small operators. One converted Stuart operated through to the 2000s at a mine.
A panzerkampfwagen what? Panzerkampfwagen means Tank in German. Could you mean a Panzer 1?
@ a half track transport
@@tony199120A half track is designated 'sonderkraftfahrzeug" rather than "panzerkampfwagen". Your neighbor may have had a sd.kfz 10. The Germans made several thousand of those.
Yes that’s probably what he meant. Those old half tracks would make great farm workhorses. An actual tank, not so much.
Absolutely love all your work and dedication to keeping our history alive, we thank you Dr.Felton
I know Dr. F is telling the truth. I was playing Panzer General 2 last week, and before one of the final battles in the "Defending the Reich" campaign, I was awarded a prototype unit: The Panther 2. Amazing!!
@@Lerxstification Ideal for tactic purpose learning Panzer General II: "Allied General" is recommendable. Yet you got to be good, in the beginning you get the hell out'a trouble. The Soviet campaign is really a nut. It actually ends in the bitter fight for Berlin.
Mark wonderful video! Just 1 minor correction. The Panther II hull is at Ft. Moore (formerly Ft. Benning) GA, and is part of the US Army's National Armor and Calvary Collection (it is technically not a museum - it is an instructional collection, now occasionally presented to the public in periodic open houses). This collection is no longer considered the Patton collection, since they moved what was the Ft. Knox Patton museum presentation of the collection from Kentucky to Georgia as a result of the Base Closure and Realignment Commission (BRAC) decisions. I have attended 3 open houses at Ft. Moore (Ft. Benning), Rob Cogan is the collection curator (great, dedicated guy), and Sofilein, Hillary Doyle and Nicholas Moran have all done videos related to the armor collection there, with 1 or 2 of those videos discussing this Panther 2. This week Nick released his 2nd of 2 videos on the US Army's T-28/T-95 "doom turtle", filmed there at the collection at Ft. Moore.
Yes, I was going to post that the Panther II is no longer at the Patton museum. I was lucky to see it in 2000 while I was in the USA on a trip for the F1 race at Indianapolis. I also went to the Air Force Museum next to the Wright Patterson Air Force Museum.
@@simonkevnorris I took my son to the National Museum of the United State Air Force almost every Saturday for 2 years -- probably about 90 visits of between 2 and 6 hours - from when he was old enough to walk until we moved from the area. My family and I have also visited the Tank Museum at Bovington as well as the NACC and the former AAF tank museum in Danville Virginia (just closed).
The Armor collection was part of The Armor School and was housed not only at Patton Museum but all over Post ( Fort Knox, KY). When Armor School became ' The Center of Maneuver Excellence ' and moved to FT.Benning, GA...they took 90 percent of the Armor and the entire library housed at Patton...it was after all part of the school. GEN.Pattons personal items are still in display as are several pieces of Armor. I used to work at Patton...helped with putting the ONTOS back into running order. Sad day when we learned the Armor & Cab were leaving Knox.
Armor Memorial Park is still at Patton, they couldn't move all that.
It will *always* be Ft. Benning, no matter what the communists in DC call it.
Blue Yank winner’s history or no history at all😢
Mark, a *huge thank you* for all your work! I am very hopeful that the work being done at the Australian Armour & Artillery Museum in Cairns may result in the number of running Tigers doubling to 2!!! Fingers crossed, 2024 for the news! If you watch their Workshop Wednesday posts, it's amazing how many of these German WW2 vehicles and guns they actually have AND their efforts at restoring them are captivating viewing (I think).
Us Aussies have a long history of stealing German Armoured Vehicles going all the way back to WW1
yes indeed, see "Mephisto" the sole surviving A7V (Sturmpanzerwagen), which was "liberated" by Australian troops and is now on display at the Queensland Museum in Brisbane Australia.
www.museum.qld.gov.au/learn-and-discover/podcast/mephisto-the-sole-surviving-ww1-tank
Those guys are awesome
It's a daunting task. I used to watch a tank restoration show on the Military channel. Finding the blue prints and manual's was a real challenge for some of these rare tanks. Then any part that couldn't be dug up from some tank grave yard needed to be fabricated from scratch. If you don't have the original specs....you can imagine how long and difficult that can be. My hats off to the workers trying to get a second Tiger up and running. They are up for a real challenge.
If AAAM gets a Tiger running it will be #3, the Swiss one is much closer to completion. The place is indeed awesome and Tank Fest is worth coming Down Under for if you ever get the chance. @@Davivd2
There is a private military muzeum in Kłanino, Poland. They have running Stug III ausf G, and are still working on their panther. Panther was set on exhibition in early 2023. It is mostly complete, but they are still working on returning it to driving condition.
The museum actually have their own UA-cam Channel called @TankHunter. It is mostly focused on salvaging artefacts
Somewhere in a forest, swamp, lake or river a few more may exist, as previous MFP videos have indicated, thanks much Dr. Felton.
They absolutely do and if you look in the right places there are piles of bits still around. Have a look at the Australian armoured museums rebuild of a Tiger. Well worth an hour of your time 😊
There are accurate records of King Tigers being dumped in German lakes here and there, although getting them out might prove impossible.
I guess in Russia you find many more examples of tanks. Of many types. Either as a model on static or as a sunken fate of "Vergeltungsoperationen" against Partisans in the swamps.
Read "Der zweite Weltkrieg" by Militaerverlag of GDR.
Wonderful to see this great topic on a Sunday night Mark! Hope you’re well lately!
I had no idea how large the Sturer Emil actually was! Great video! Keep up the good work!
No idea either! Very cool. What was the tank behind the Sturer Emil in the photo? Looks like a tank destroyer of German build.
It's a Waffenträger, one of several prototypes with the goal to mount a large gun on a cheap chassis.
It translates to "Stubborn Emil"
@@derauditor5748 The translation does not matter, because it is not a really name but some made up bs. Like Brummbär. And of course he is a Panther guy. Lol. "Historian".
@@Pepe_Silvia My wife's uncle drove a Sherman Firefly in Italy in WW2, well actually he drove a Sherman fitted with a 17pdr gun fitted. He had never heard of them called a"Firefly" until I bought him a model kit of one around 2005, he passed away in 2007. So if he drove one and he didn't know they were called Firefly's was this something that was concocted post war?
Mark Felton videos are a Godsend for people who love History. Thank you Mark for your work. It is appreciated.
Another Felton gem. Mark is without doubt the foremost authority on WW2.
I was lucky enough to discover the Bovington museum during their Tiger days, where they had gathered all produced types of Tigers in one place for a special exhibit. It was truly amazing to stand next to these massive tanks! I hope to attend their Tank driving days next year. Here in Belgium we are fortunate to still have a King Tiger on display, in the town of La Gleize.
Very interesting, thanks very much for making this. It's great that there are survivors of so many fighting vehicles that were already very rare by WW2 standards. I hope good care is taken of them to preserve them for future generations.
The American Heritage History Museum in Hudson, Massachusetts has the only fully restored and operational Panzer Mark 5 Panther in North America and also has several operational Stug III self-propelled gun and 1 Stug IV.
Hey Kyle, I visit the Panther a few times a year when I'm visiting my folks. The way they have it on display battling a T34 is absolutely brilliant. The amount of armor on display from every decade is mind-boggling. But, the museum isn't just all about armor... they even have a Uboat conning tower and a beautiful Me109 for all to see.
The Panther is from the late Jaques Littlefield collection and was featured on the History Channel years ago. 👍🏽
@@jerryjeromehawkins1712
I know and one of Saddam Hussein's SCUD missiles
@@kyledunn6853Haha... yes. The first time I saw that I was in disbelief.
What the... ??? 😮
@@jerryjeromehawkins1712
Me too!
@@jerryjeromehawkins1712 You need to go to Chicago to see a whole U-boat at the Museum of Science and Industry.
The Panther Tank at the American Heritage Museum in Hudson Massachusetts is a must see.
They have it on display battling a T34... absolutely amazing.
I visit the Panther 3 in 4 times a year as I live just an hour away. 💨
They also have a Stug IV along with plenty of other armor from every decade and war.
That just went on my bucket list!
There's a fellow here who has built one very late war Mk IV from bits he's gathered together. All original and historically accurate except for the engine. He went with a modern engine for reliability and serviceability since he intended the tank to be operational. It's really quite amazing. Even has the radio equipment, though non-operational due to the lack of the wiring for it. He also has a Mk II Luchs, though I think that has a lot more scratchbuilt parts since the originals are rare as hens teeth. He's also in the process of building a second Mk IV from gathered pieces.
May I ask where you live? US?
@@Ko.Wi. You are correct.
Wiring? Do you mean the power cables and connector cables? I can't understand how that would be the biggest problem. There are people who own Panzer radios, and have them in working order. They trade cables all the time.
@@daveybyrden3936 I have no idea why he doesn't have those, it's not my tank. Besides, I'm sure it's way down on the to-do list. Call me crazy, but I know I'd be far more concerned with DRIVING the tank than worrying about whether or not the radio works.
Can’t imagine being an infantry soldier and facing machines like these back then.
The video doesn't show how big these tanks are. I stood next to the Panther and the Tiger II in the Munster museum, they dwarf any modern tank, and it takes a couple of days to get used to their height and sheer mass. These are true monsters of steel.
WW2 German armor did look fearsome indeed!
I really am enjoying all the history from Mark Felton 🇺🇲🇺🇸❤️🥰💞💕
I like the us tanks better
This is some pretty impressive heavyweight content. Thank you, Dr. Felton!
Great video! One correction, all the armor from the Patton museum (including Panther II) was moved to Fort Moore in Georgia 10 years ago. They are in storage and no longer on display to the public :(
they do have open house days for anyone to visit and I think anyone with military id can get in to visit
It's true, Fort Knox, Kentucky used to be "Home of Armor" where I became an Armor commander. It's been my contention that many in the DoD consider that tanks are of little use today what with the advent of high technology in war. I believe at some time Armor will be phased out or phased into another purpose. Sad, but true.
Typical government waste. Closed the museum and moved the artifacts shortly after renovating the place.
Saw them a few years ago sitting on sand hill in some motorpool pretty interesting to see out of nowhere, was the last place I expected to see a German tank, along side some t72s bmps and a couple of other odd vehicles
I should have read further down before posting lol. They should find space to reestablish that museum. I wonder what has happened with the Ordnance Museum collection since it moved from APG?
Mark, the Panther 2 prototype isn't at Ft. Knox, it is currently at Ft. Moore (Ft. Benning) in Columbus GA at the US Army Armor & Cavalry collection. The collection is closed to the public, opening only during open house events, usually 4 a year. I was lucky enough to in September and have a picture of the Panther 2!
And Ft. Knox is in Kentucky of course, not Georgia. Still a great video.
@@bobs1728I’m glad you pointed that out. It would be like saying London is in Wales.
@@pjkentucky LOL yeah that took me back as well since I live in Louisville and my mom lives off Dixie Hwy leading to Ft Knox.
Loving this series. Interesting seeing what’s survived and in running condition
I was a tank gunner and trained at Ft.Knox...this was in Kentucky. Small slip but just wanted to mention it.M60A1 was my tank..great video sir!
Tigers and Panther and Stugs.
Oh my!
Beautiful catalogue of these glorious battlefield veterans..!
I've been to the Tank Museum a couple of times, 2014 and summer 2023 and both visits were great many, many hour afairs. I think the first had more to see as there was a warehouse full of rows of military vehicles you could wander around and that I think has now been turned into a further area showcasing specific models with a lot more information. They have so many vehicles now that the museum could be twice the size and probably still not have room to display everything.
Thanks for the Sunday evening video Mark. Always appreciated.
I really wish you had a full series. These are great vids, but just for the big production and all that. Thanks again for the knowledge fellow Norfolk dumpling.
I'm glad that there are still running examples of my favourite German WW2 tank, the Jagdpanther. I regard this to be the sleekest tank of WW2. Its shape reminds me of a sports car.
A Tiger II (H) is currently being restored in Full Switzerland, which should be able to do everything, shoot and drive, turn, etc., just like back then.
I have almost every one of these tanks in 1:28 Cobi model form. Awesome models made from LEGO-like bricks of great quality.
Must admit this got me thinking about the other German armoured vehicles like Panzer III , Hetzer, Panzer 1 and 2 ( especially the Luchs) :)
This subject is one that I always wondered about. Many thanks.
I remember when my family and I were on holiday in Belgium and we got to see some static tanks that had been put on display in some of the villages, one was a damaged Panther either an Ausf A or Ausf G and probably the one tank I didn’t expect to see, a Tiger II which had a panther barrel put in as its original long 88mm barrel was gone, i still remember that it had a few dents in its upper plate and one dent where the upper and lower plate met, goes to show how strong the armour was
I would love to see any one of these in person. Thank you, Dr. Felton.
I got to ride in a JagdPanzer 38T Hetzer at Overloon in Holland, they have a militracks event.
The only Panther II left in the world is actually in the Fort Benning US Amry Armor and Cavalry Collection. I know because I saw it lined up with their King Tiger in their "Tankodrome" facility during their open house event.
Also the only surviving Porsche-version of the Jagdtiger is there!
@@TheGhostofCarlSchmitt I believe Jagdtiger 331 is a Henscel variant. The one you're referring to is stored next to the King Tiger in the Bovington Tank Museum.
I was going to say Ft. Knox is in Kentucky, Ft. Benning is in GA......but who am I to correct Dr. Felton! Great video regardless!
@@xenoamen ahh yes, you are correct!
Thank you Dr. Felton ! The Jagd Panther is my favorite German WW2 tank.....
There is also a fantastic tank museum in Munster (half way between Hamburg and Hannover) with a wide range of historic and modern tanks.
FUN FACT: The only running Tiger (the 131 from the Tank Museum) was used in the film "Fury", during the famous scene between the Tiger and 4 Shermans.
Even funner fact..tiger 131 did very little in the film..it was mostly a replica upper hull and turret on a postwar british army alvis running gear with tiger running gear added by cgi which did most of the work in the movie..the replica tiger was sold to the australian armour museum..they rebuilt it onto a replica tiger running gear and resold it.
It's amazing how many stories Dr Mark keeps coming up with. Simply amazing. If you appreciate seeing these stories consider donating a few dollars or whatever your currency is so we can keep enjoying these.
Thanks for posting Mark
It would be good to see a video on "Missing In Action" WW1 & 2 vehicles with no known examples. It might focus recovery efforts in swamps etc. where there may still be recoverable examples.
DR Felton has a few videos of exactly that on his channel.
I would hate to think what would have happened had he gotten a lot more big tanks out - could you imagine 4,000 king tigers and or tigers - great video
What a pity most of us won't be able to visit the Russian museum tank exhibits any time soon. I'd love to see the Maus. Vey hard to get an idea of its size from a video.
Kubinka outside Moscow is a wonderful museum. You're right, it truly is a pity. Visiting the Maus on its own makes it worth a trip.
Thank you so much Mark, for this german Tank history👌
It's sad to know so few of these tanks still exist and run.
I mean it's cool that there's still some on them, but what would be the reason to have more in running order?
@@FreGZile better accessibility to historical items and artifacts?
I see no reason why they shouldn't be having more in running order.
At least the likely ww2 films to come would have more genuine vehicles to star in them instead of poor-looking fantasy pieces made from soviet tanks.
@@averagejoeschmoe9186 98% of audience can't tell a real or fake german Tank, so why bother anyway? I think ww2 focus too much on material accuracy which really doesn't matter history-wise, the facts, events and politics are what really need to be remembered. tanks are just... tanks.
@@averagejoeschmoe9186 The problem is you think that people care as much as you do which is not the case, when Saving Private Ryan came out is 1998, how many people could tell that the tiger was not not a real one, or that beach obstacles were facing the wrong direction, or that the German bunkers were completely out of place or misused? all these details are just details and overall nobody cares but ww2 buffs, and even so, they liked this movies and others that have as many or more flaws because they tried to be faithful to history of what people went through to shape the world of today, because that's whats most important in the end, the human, political and social aspect. I respect that people cares for technical details but I wish they would not overdo it with giving too much importance in promoting that kind of history.
@anTenorfr I don't necessarily disagree but in my view it's all about who is the film's target audience?
What's the budget size and what can thus be expected of it?
Will it try to cater to any casual consumer that doesn't know better and is willing to ignore inaccuracies?
Or would it rather try cater to history buffs and "nerds" and the casual consumer just happens to get entertained, maybe even educated on the side as well?
Films that strive to entertain and satisfy more or less everyone should be the ones to get made.
Great timing of that video! Just visited the German Panzermuseum in Munster today with my son and it was magnificent🎉
I live in Maryland and for many years, the Aberdeen proving grounds had all of these vehicles (and more) in its collection. I was lucky enough to get my picture with most of theses. One day, I met tank historian and author Thomas Jentz (who also lived in Maryland), and he was stocked that I had his books in my car and he kindly showed me around the proving grounds and told me about all the tanks.
And they have moved to Virgina??
@@chriscarbaugh3936 yes unfortunately the last time I was up there many of them have moved, but not all of them at that time. They still have a few there.
@@chriscarbaugh3936 Most ended up at Fort Moore or at Fort Gregg-Adams.
I remember their fine display well, was there in '82, but disappointed it was all moved.
That's awesome, but they can't have had examples of all of these in the video. Some have never made it to the states and rare example only ever stayed in Europe or Russia.
I had the pleasure to walk through the armour collection at the Shrivenham Defence Academy during a break when I was there for a symposium back in 2010. It was a sketchy drive picking up the car at Heathrow and jumping right onto the M4 to get to my hotel in Swindon!
2:28 I am guessing Mark may be referring to the Australian Armour and Artillery Museum's dedication to restoring WWii tanks and have their own youtube channel that is well worth a visit
The only surviving StuG III A is there too.
The Tiger 1 is probably the most valuable vehicle today that was at its time simply scrapped after use.
Love all the information and videos on tanks and their rehabilitation! Mark, do your numbers include tanks in private collections as well as museums, or it it tougher for the private collections? I can't imagine the Allied soldiers sitting in their foxholes hearing those behemoths bearing down on them!! Terrifying!
FYI - Mark the Tank Museum at Fort Knox is in the State of Kentucky not Georgia. I did my basic training there for the Army and have visited the tank museum many times. Its extraordinary and I recommend it to everyone.
Have you been back to the museum since they moved the armor collection to Georgia?
Enjoyed it, but the Patton Museum is at Fort Knox in Kentucky, not Georgia
Well, yes and no. A lot of the armor collection that was at Fort Knox has been moved to the facility in Georgia. Don't ask me why although I'm sure there were reasons.
@@wayneantoniazzi2706 The Army's Armor School was moved to Ft Benning as part of BRaC in 2010 and the Armor part of the museum went with it and became the National Armor and Calvary Musuem.
Quick correction. Ft Knox is in kentucky however the Army moved the armor center to benning in 2011, I went to basic at knox in 05 and got to see the museum on a RARE treat from the drill instructors.
you missed two for #1! There is the Waffenträger that was visible next to Sturer Emil in Kubinka and there is a Heuschrecke in the US!
Specifically, the Ardelt Waffentrager 8.8cm PaK 43. Which is the only one of the Waffentrager prototypes to survive.
The 'Australian Armour and Artillery Museum' in Cairns, Australia, is a must visit. Best in the southern hemisphere. They also have a UA-cam Channel.
I myself wonder the same, especially because so many were destroyed in combat, or scrapped after the surrender. So informative and thank you Dr. Felton!! And I agree with Dr. Felton's feelings about favorite vehicles as the PzKw V Panther is my favorite as well!
Aw shucks, i did an edit and lost my ❤ from Dr. Felton!
The German Panzermuseum at Munster once had a Tiger I as a lend vehicle by an American collector. Yet they had to return it on the wish of the collector. Tiger I is quite rare. It is hard to get undiscovered ones. Ask near St. Petersburg in case the fights in Ukraine will cease one day.
Fascinating topic. Really great footage of the runners. Thank you Dr. Felton.
Panzerfarm in Poland is working on making another Tiger 1 up to running order
Tanks for another phenomenal video Dr. Felton!
It’s surprising to hear how few German tanks were ever really built.
And I’m sure I’ve seen at least three of the King Tiger tanks.
1 in Bovington, 1 or 2 in the Ardennen. And I’m nearly certain I saw 1 at this quaint little war museum near Arnhem.
I’ll have to look up some old photos!
Edit:
So, it wasn’t a King Tiger near Arnhem… ahum… yeah well, I’m old…
yet their conquest was so strong withso less armored vehicles
Thank you Mark.
I've had the pleasure of seeing one of those Nashorns at Militracks in Overloon as one of them was restored nearby. This was months after if had suffered major fire damage however, meaning it was not in an operational state and the restoration crew had to start all over again. Nevertheless they managed to piece together and clean up the vehicle enough to make it worth displaying.
It’s running
Mark Felton Productions never disappoints! Thank you Dr Felton for sharing this tour with us.
Looking at all those armored vehicles I can't help but wonder what the effect on the German war effort might have been had they standardized on three or four types and produced them en masse instead of "reinventing the wheel" with others.
Say, upgrading the Panzer IV (the "German Sherman") as needed and the same with the STUG III and IV? Something to think about. It certainly would have simplified the logistical support tremendously to say nothing of training crews.
Than there would be no Hiroshima... instead a german town...
I think this argument is not hitting it.
Germany attacked the soviets with a large variation of captured tanks and trucks from all over Europe, which made logistics difficult, but it was all they got.
But since late 1941, all their domestic produced tanks based on the Panzer III and IV chassis were using the same drive train (same engine, same gearbox, same steering system. The sherman alone came with 5 different engines and two different types of fuel. Even the US operated both at the time M10 diesel, M4 Petrol.
After 7 years of production and ongoing upgrades the Panzer IV and III chassis reached their designed 25ton weight limit. There wasn't potential to grow anymore.
Bigger engines, would need a bigger engine bay... Leads to increased weight... Which leads to new running gear,
a bigger gun.... Leads to a bigger turret... Which leads to more weight again... It's an endless cycle. You will end up with a new vehicle anyway.
Panther was designed as the basis to replace Panzer III and IV in all their roles. Medium Tank, TD, Flakpanzer, sp. artillery and ARV. Medium tank, TD and ARV were already realized.
Tigers, Jagdtigers, Ferdinands dont even make up 4% of all 55.000 tanks and spgs the Nazis built. They were special weopons and don't mess with the logistics and production capacity as much as it was made out to be.
They were organized in their own battalions, and most of them were produced by a single small factory.
Germany spent only 6% of its war budget on tanks, of which Tigers are just tiny part.
The Luftwaffe and the Uboots used much more money for reseach and production.
@@HaVoC117X You brought up some very good points!
You're right about the Germans invading the Soviet Union with an array of military vehicles from all the occupied countries, in fact Operation Barbarossa was described as a "Military museum on wheels." The fact is th Germans NEVER had enough of their own equipment to go around so WHY complicate things further by developing more vehicles that will need production facilities you'll have to design and build as well. Better to stick with what you've got and make more of it, especially if it works.
Let's talk about the Sherman. Yes, there were five different engines for the model and two fuel types, gasoline and diesel. All the Shermans used in Europe had gasoline engines to simplify supply. The diesel engnined ones were used by the US Marine Corps in the Pacific, diesel being easily obtainable from the US Navy. The remaining four gasoline engines in the Shermans were also interchangeable with other American pieces of equipment, again simplifying supply. Other diesel Shermans were kept in the US but for training purposes.
As far as weight the standard Sherman weighed no more than 30 tons, just slightly more than a Panzer IV. The Panzer IV was sucessfully up-gunned with a 75mm cannon and could more than hold it's own against a Sherman, or a T-34 for that matter. Thorough Germn tank crew training which Russian crews were deficient in and sometimes American crews as well could have made up the difference in performance.
So it's my contention that the Panzer IV could have been adequate to German puposes. Others may not agree and that's fine.
It should be remembered that all those different German vehicles also complicated the parts resupply system and the Germans NEVER had enough spare parts to go around. There's stories of German tank maintanance men from different panzer units having fist fights at the railheads just to get their hands on spare parts. It's been documented that American tank repairmen were surprised the Germans didn't seem to go through the effort of trying to recover disabled tanks as we did. No wonder, with no spare parts what's the point?
Anyway, this is a good discussion and who cares why the Germans lost? Thank God they did!
@@wayneantoniazzi2706small correction:
M10 tank destroyers based on M4 used Diesel and served along the Petrol consuming M4 tanks in Europe.
The M4a4 hull for the giant 30 Cylinder Multibank engine was longer and not interchangeable with the others.
Furthermore Panzer IV was not streamlined for mass production.
The Panther was.
They built 8500 Panzer IVs since 1937 till 1945.
But 6300 Panthers from 1943 till wars end.
3800 Panther in 1944 vs 2500 Panzer IV in 1944. Despite the fact that the Nibelungenwerke which built the Panzer IV was the largest Tank factory of the Reich.
There was no way around it, they needed a new tank design for the now ongoing war of attrition.
With the Panther they could built 6300 medium tanks in 1944.
The russians built 12500 T34/85 the same year.
Given the industrial infrastructure of Germany and given the fact that they were trading tanks at a ration of 1:4 in favor for the Germans on the eastern front in 1944, this is not a bad number and hardly sign of great mismanagent.
But the US also built over 13. 000 Shermans the same year.
There was just no way Germany could win at this point. It doesn't matter if they have settled for another tank. They already had cheap mobile spgs like the Hetzer and the Stug III. Germany only had limited access to oil and overstretched their logistics with the tanks they already had. More tanks wasn't a viable solution.
@@HaVoC117X OK, well done, you win!
By the way, what branch of the forces were you in?
Amazing how these few of these relics are left.
The turret of the Panther2 might not be totally original, but the gun mantlet is.Note the thick bottom to reduce the shot trap. Surprisingly two out of 18 SturmTigers exist. Quite a percentage. Thanks for the video.
The turret of the Panther II was never made. This turret, including the gun mantlet, is from a Panther ausf G (late).
@@hjalmar4565 I stand corrected, the mock up shows a much narrower turret with a Saukopf mantlet.Have a good day.
Yeah I saw the Sturmtiger from the 2nd picture today in Munster! I was loudly saying ( in German) " Oh my god the really have a Sturmtiger" it was awesome
Small correction...Fort Knox is in Kentucky...IIRC the Panther II has been moved to Fort Benning (may be wrong on this one)
You beat me to it! lol. My late father and uncle did training at Fort Knox, Kentucky.
All us old Ft. Knox graduates caught that small correction.😅
All us old Ft. Knox graduates caught that small correction.😅
Mark Felton made a mistake? I guess it had to happen someday!
@@davidtaflan941 👍🇺🇲😆
Thanks for all the great videos man. I am a huge fan!
Many years ago there was an operating Tiger II at the Aberdeen Proving Grounds in Maryland (USA), where they apparently evaluated it after WWII. They would trot it out on Armed Forces Day, along with a number of other armored vehicles, and let the public get a good look. I remember it particularly because I counted seven direct hits on the frontal armor from anti-tank guns, none of which disabled it.
Didn't all that stuff get moved to somewhere near Petersburg VA?
Last I heard it was at Ft. Lee near Petersburg. The name is changed to ???? Whatever; still Ft Lee to me.
7 direct hits and it kept going strong just like Johnny Walker !
This is a great idea for a video series! Thank you.
Spanish contribution to this preservation effort is up to 3 Pz.IVs (one in running condition since around 2004) and as far as I know 3 StuG.IIIs.
A fourth StuG was used in the early 70s as a test bed launcher for a experimental field support tactical rocket. The rocket was quite large (38-41 cm 15-16" calibre) and had a range of 20 km, like a prehistoric unguided Himars. Not sure if the StuG was scrapped later, but for the trials had its gun removed and a kind of cage structure movable single launcher added on top. A truck crane assisted to the rocket loading.
The rest of the batch (17 Pz.IVs and 6 Stug.IIIs) were sold to Syria to be expended as IDF targets in the 6-Day War.
I've always loved the stug, it's like a deadly toy car that I wanted for Christmas when I was a kid
G'day Mark, thank you so much for this, I think it may be a unique look at the entire range of German WW2 tanks/tank destroyers. Like the many types of medium bombers used by the Luftwaffe, I would like to ask you a question I've been pondering for a long time.
Firstly, I recognise that both the UK and the US had wide ranges of various weapons groups, but it has always seemed to me that throughout WW2, Nazi forces 'over diversified' in many weapons types.
So, my question is this: do you think that, overall, the German's preference for many different types of armour, aircraft and other weapons systems was a direct contributor to the mid-war downturn of Germany's fortunes and its eventual loss of WW2?
Certainly, in sheer weight of numbers produced, of course, they were 'out produced' by the US and even the UK in some instances. But as a follow up query; do you think they would have had more sweeping victories, say over Russia etc., if they had concentrated, like the US did on the Sherman tank and three major types of heavy bombers etc.?
I'm not usually one for 'what if' questions but, lastly, I've had to wonder what would have transpired if the Kriegsmarine had been given the 400+ U-Boats they requested as soon as war was declared; and this submarine force was successful in stopping the stockpiling of US weapons in Britain.
All the best, as usual, cheers, Bill H.
Small correction. 2 StuG IVs are still fully operational, one in Poznań Tank Museum, Poland and one in Australia.
I’m loving these “how many are left” series!
I was born at Fort Knox, KY,and raised outside Fort Knox. My dad was a tanker, and took me to the Patton Museum on many occasions. Great memories.
Awesome effort !!!!😊
First
Good job 👍
Man, I could use a Mark Felton tour of the kubinka and bovington tank museums 👀👀
Dr Mark, The tanks that were at Fort Knox are now at Fort Moore in Georgia
I am surprised that the soviet union hasn’t pulled all the WW II tanks out of the museums and sent them to Ukraine…😆😊
It is do mostly to the fact the Soviet Union no longer exists…🤦♂️
@@genbigmac2872😂😂😂😂
Tanks a lot Mark!
Dr Felton's favorite tank of WW2 is the Panther!! 👍🏽
Outstanding Video! Had no idea of so many different types of tanks there was in the War. I JUST CANNOT IMAGINE ! What our soldiers and others thought or had to endure. When one of these Massive Armoured Vehicles of Pure Destruction. Was coming towards them. I love listening and seeing th
The tank museum in bovington is a cattery aswell.
Great stuff Mark. Thank you.
Hey, Mark, just a quick note; Fort Knox is in Kentucky. Fort Benning in Georgia, recently renamed, is where they have the armor museum now. I was lucky enough to see many of the tanks including the Tiger 2, Jagdtiger, Elefant, Tiger 1 and many other including artillery pieces when they were all still at Aberdeen Proving Grounds. Now they keep them locked away except for 2-3 times a year. Before anyone could walk right up to them, take pictures, climb on top of them and such.
Those Aussie guys rebuilt a Tiger recently, and hope to have it running once they can source an engine!
Sorry if this was in the video already. I havent watched it yet.
They need to restore more of these awesome machines!!
SUPERB tank review.
No surprise when Doc Felton
sets the bar.
It just doesn't get much better, a bedtime story and film from Dr. Felton!
These armored vehicles have one thing in common they are noisy as hell and must have been heard coming from a mile away.
Tigers, Panthers & Stugs...oh my!
It's amazing to watch the tanks, thanks Mark!
Mindblowing how little of these tanks survived.
The US Army collection of historic armored vehicles was moved from Ft Knox KY to Ft Moore, GA (formale Ft Benning) when the Armor School was relocated there several years ago.
The sturmtiger fired, essentially, a 15" shell?! That’s an armored vehicle rolling around looking for a battleship to fire on!