The Truth About Smelling Salts
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 бер 2023
- Stop using smelling salts. Please
NFL and Football Videos:
• NFL and Football Injuries
NBA and Basketball Videos:
• NBA and Basketball Inj...
UFC and Boxing Videos:
• UFC and Boxing
MY MUSIC:
Epidemic Sound - Sign up with this link for a FREE 30 day trial!
www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
Follow Me on Twitter!
/ briansutterermd
I'm a doctor and a sports fan and this channel is dedicated to exploring the unique medical side of the world of sports, including NBA, MLB, NFL, UFC, and many more! Breaking down the biggest what ifs, historical injuries and stories, and making learning about medicine fun and relevant for all sports fans!
Anatomy images: www.biodigital.com
DISCLAIMER: Content not intended to be taken as medical advice. Opinions are my own and do not represent those of my employer. I have not personally treated or evaluated the individual(s) discussed in this video. Content used with educational and transformative intent within Fair Use Guidelines
Content owned and produced by Brian Sutterer LLC 2023 - Спорт
I replaced my smelling salts with coke and my entire team performed so well.
That definitely explains why they call you Rad Dad
just like in the good ol' days 2 bumps before game, then 2 bumps every quarter. worked wonders for the Raiders!
I never liked coke....just the smell of it
Cause coke has high sugar
🤭 silly..
Reminds me of Tuco Salamanca: "TIGHT! TIGHT TIGHT!"
I love this comment.
Lmfao underrated comment
Dude it was exact!! Good catch! Lol
Classic!!!!!
😂
Ok, so save money and just sniff my cleaning ammonia got it 👍
It’s mixed
A dash of bleach really makes it pop.
My attorney: Obviously don’t bc you’ll die
Vinegar
Balsamic?
@@briancreyes_official Malt
holy speed, from tweet to video in less than an hour 👏
I got some STUFF ON MY MIND lol
Dr. B.H. watched another doctor's video, this is what happened to his sinuses
A hockey player smelled smelling salts, this is what happened to his liver
@@BrianSuttererMD Been sitting on this one for a while waiting for the right moment huh?
He presented to the ER with these symptoms…
I used smelling salts back in 2014-2016 when I power lifted. I definitely agree that it’s more of a perceived effect then actually helping your performance. I only used it during competitions and I didn’t always lift more than I normally would. Sometimes I did and sometimes I didn’t. But I feel like with enough motivation I would have done the exact same thing I did using the salts. My advice to athletes is just compete hard and stop looking for “an edge”.
While I agree with the sentiment, of course if you perceive an effect and it helps you focus due to normal avenues, there's going to be an effect. The physiological side may not be there, but the psychological is obvious.
@@gavinhemmerlein1241 that is true. It’s does make u feel more confident but understanding that whatever the result at the end of the competition could have been the same with or without the salts is important. That way u don’t have as many athletes abusing it and causing more problems because they truly think it’s giving them a performance boost. At the end of the day to each his own and thankfully to the best of my knowledge nobody has died 🤞🏾from the use of salts in competition but I don’t think we need to be openly promoting it to impressionable young athletes out there.
Athletes are incredibly prone to magical thinking, though. They have lucky socks and underwear, they have pre-game rituals, all sorts of things. It's a natural human coping mechanism. You don't have control over everything, and you want control as an athlete, so your brain tells you that spitting in your left shoe before kickoff will improve performance. So you do it.
No harm in most of it.
But then it gets extended into edge-seeking activities that are part and parcel of sports. Everyone wants to do better, and they look for everything they can get that will do so, usually within the bounds of the rules, but they'll often disregard warnings of safety on the grounds of even perceived benefits. If they'll wear the same pair of socks for 6 months straight they'll certainly swallow a pill of sniff a funky gas.
"stop looking for 'an edge'".
These are words that would never come from a competitor...
Gaining an edge is the most important thing in competing.
or just do cocaine like an adult 🤷♂️
Fainted in the doctor's office once when I was a kid and he used smelling salts on me. Was the most jarring immediate experience in my life. From unconsciousness to "WTF IS HAPPENING?!"
😂😂😂
Huh so apparently you're not, in a sense, dead when unconscious, just kind of asleep.
@@romiarkan450 That's literally the definition of unconscious 😂
@@romiarkan450have you never fainted before? Or been asleep? Both those things are being unconscious. No heartbeat and breathing is not being unconscious thats cardiac arrest or you are just straight up dead.
I always thought the benefit of smelling salts was a mental / nervous system thing. Like the shock to the system sort of overloads the senses spiking adrenaline and leaving you in a more focused state. Similar to slapping yourself.
always just gave me a headache lol
It’s excellent for waking up when drowsy.
Recently tried for first time and that’s it exactly. Also for some it causes a breathing reflex for a few mins which also adds but that went away for after the first time. So it’s just the slap in the face for me.
That's a big leap from "shock to system" to theoretically bumping up adrenaline. Doesn't work that way.
@@slymcfly123 then how do you explain the increased heart rate and blood pressure?
I’d love to see a video about the health effects of Dereck Wolff’s adderrall/mushroom mix he took before nfl games. Great work as always!
Or Doc Ellis's no-hitter on LSD
he was micro-dosing mushrooms but from what I’ve heard, psilocybin heightens the senses and of course adderall releases dopamine which makes you hyper focus. super interesting combo really
@@poindextertunesthe problem is that amphetamines can raise blood pressure and heart rate due to vasoconstriction, so he might actually have been trying worse blood flow with more stress on the heart.
@@poindextertunesthat's basically meth.
My relatives had a funeral home. They had Smelling Salts available all the time - in case people fainted during a viewing.
Based on personal experience freshman year of high school playing football was waken up twice after getting knocked out. This was 2000 so I guess no one knew what a concussion was at the time but the smelling salts definitely gave me a jolt, and I was back on the field for afternoon practice. Smartly, I was never allowed to play football after that year.
I used smelling salts when I was OTR trucking. They saved my ass many times. Gave me just enough to stay awake and make it somewhere I could sleep.
That seems like a legit use for your safety and the others
That’s real
I'm a trucker and this is why I'm here. I was curious of the correlation between the 2.
Don’t lie to us doc. I’ve seen that blues sweater hanging on the skeleton. You’ve got unresolved issues with Reaves and decided to put him on blast 😂
Most the players are really just using it to wake themselves up if they're feeling sluggish, the shock it gives to the body kinda snaps that sluggish feeling out of you sort of like a cold splash of water to the face to wake up. Most players are aware that the perceived enhancements are negligeable but aren't really using it for that reason.
I’ve done smelling salts before. Felt like a hot metal pole got stuck up my nose for 10 minutes
It’s like the feeling you get when water goes up your nose but 10 times stronger
@@Chadius_Thundercockgood way to describe it
in other words its terrible 😂
@@Chadius_Thundercock EXACTLY! It's like waterboarding yourself for a quick second. Your nervous system it's screaming that you're drowning, even though your rational brain understands you really aren't drowning.
I purchased the salts for driving trucks. Sometimes you feel super tired and can't stop exactly right where you are at and need that extra 25 30 minutes to get to the next truck stop. I figured I'll only use them when I absolutely have to if I feel like I'm going to daze off and be upside-down in a ditch if I keep driving. So many small use of them aren't bad for your health. I mean, better than crashing, I suppose..
Better than being a methhead like most of the truckers I knew lol so I can respect you big time for that bro 💯
This doesn’t sound like a bad idea( Have my cdl as well)
Bruh… someone had a bottle of smelling salt laying around a friend’s house during a party. The label was slightly ripped and faded, all I saw was “scent and smelling”. I never knew about smelling salts, so I curiously opened it, and took a big sniff… I thought I was going to die 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
As a medical student and competitive powerlifter, I see both sides here. Use cases may vary, but I’d like to add two points.
1. Since the salts give such a jolt, I suspect they may briefly activate the sympathetic nervous system, which could prove useful for short, intense bouts (lifting, sprinting etc).
2. Anecdotal evidence is still evidence (albeit weaker). Yes, we lack RTCs to tell us some good data, but if so many athletes are flocking to the substance, that’s evidence we can’t ignore.
I used to use these a lot in college when we had late-night powerlifting practices before some bigger lifts because I didn’t want to take caffeine so close to my bedtime. I thought it was a good substitute.
Food for thought. Results may vary.
Great info as usual!
Well explained, thank you!
So there's a risk if they have a possible brain/neck injury, but what about for sports where you can rule that out? Specifically, smelling salts have been pretty popular in the powerlifting scene.
My friend was a dealer, and would randomly open mason jars of weed and jars of oils and tell me to have a smell. One time I was distracted, I heard him say smell this…. Thinking it was oil, he had me take a HUGE wiff of Smelling salts. A lesson was learned that day!
Did you like it tho?
Always love the intellectual videos doc
What about the use in weight lifting like powerlifting, Olympic lifting etc? It's so widely used in PL so seeing this video was a bit of a surprise
I always thought the purpose of smelling salts was to clear the nose up from congestion. Whenever I've been at hockey arenas, the melting ice made my nose runny.
Thanks for sharing the info! Definitely had no clue what the chemicals were and what it actually did.
Get a runny nose in the cold has nothing to do with melting ice. Cold air is dryer than warm air. Cold, dry air irritates the inside of your nostrils so your body produces mucus to protect it.
I remember when I was a little kid, I asked my grandfather about smelling salts after seeing them in cartoons, and he basically said, "It's a scam, you're just waking up because you're smelling something nasty." I always just assumed thats' what it was, and an irritant reaction seems like it would basically be the same thing. I agree at the idea of it being used to mask a concussion is a threat, but I'm just surprised, I guess that people still use them these days at all.
Rather than to get a boost of oxygen to the brain, my hypothesis would be that it helps to trigger the sympathetic nervous system to get more involve in the game. It's taken in many sport, but in hockey, an high energy game, it's not easy to play 82 games in 6-7 mouth with commitment. Everything to get an edge.
Great video and topic! I'm just trowing cards on the board here.
Well I agree that an 82 game regular season schedule is to many games for nba / nhl , I would also say getting paid millions sure makes it easier and to make 7 - 8 figures playing a children’s game should be motivation enough , not having to work in the salt mines .. pun intended
You are correct it’s to elicit a nervous and adrenal response
Yeah this douche is over looking that so spread his opinions on salts. Never listen to a doctor just because they’re a doctor
*BIG 700K SUBS* *BIG ups DOC* 🎉🙌🏻
Dr Brian, would long term use of this stuff actually make you reliant on it to perform? That is the fear I have which is why I will never use it.
Do one on Victor Wembanyama. The injury risks of being too tall.
plain physics
He does a video every time an athlete gets hurt so if you're right then we will get a video about him sooner or later
Too tall and too skinny
@@Cart_kid he did a video about Zion before he got hurt. Just about the danger of being that athletic and that heavy.
I keep some in my car incase I get tired while driving and it always helps.
Fresh bottle of nose tork hit that man like a ton of bricks lol I miss those days.
I assumed it was to make players awake when fatigue wears on you. is there any evidence that the salts can cause more alertness? or is it safer to just rest and deal with the reality of fatigue?
Just did a project on this so very interested to hear your take on it!!
From my experience the only benefit you will get is during the 3-7 seconds post inhalation. The only practical application for this being used as a performance enhancing substance would be for powerlifting. I never found it beneficial for doing sets of resistance training higher than 3 reps. Although, the first 3 reps after using smelling salts you gain quite an edge. It only works primarily if you are in a state of low arousal to begin with. Definitely wouldn't work if you're already feeling anxious.
No doubt, these are probably not good for you.
Dr Brian, I strongly agree with you. If I was to use it, it would be after after walking for over 10 miles, tall kneel for 30 minutes after the walk, cold shower plus tall kneeling, and then follow up with a smelling salts.
I used smelling salts that belonged to my mom when I was younger. I wasn't prepared, and my body reacted just like this player. I never really understood, until now, how an ammonia based product could revive a person.
I'm only familiar with the use in weightlifting sports. I always thought it was something did as part of routine to reset themselves into a certain state of mind and focus. In a sport where you need every literal fiber of your being to be functioning at a high level, it's no surprise to me such a jarring bodily response aids lifters in feeling like they are the same starting situation each lift. Whether it helps or not, idk, but I would be interested to pull salts-using athletes' access to them cold turkey and I personally would suspect their performance would dip for the following several times after. And yeah, covering up potential injuries does sound dangerous; any examples?
Ammonia? Well I can tell you as a chemist that sometimes work with it… that it smells a lot like concentrated Urine and feels like needles in your nose.
It’s really not fun to inhale.
The hockey players initial reaction is due to it stinging in the nose. And his reaction of wanting to puke is from the strong smell of ”urine”.
The ammonia is a base and will react with the moist/water in our body. And since our cells has a lot of water in them, inhaling too much will cause corrosive injuries like burns.
I never used them to enhance performance when I played hockey at a high level. We used them to wake up, get focused on the game more and shake off the last of the hangover lol.
I wonder which is worse for your nasal passage, sniffing smelling salts or taking a cross check in the nose from Ryan Reaves after he sniffs smelling salts.
Smelling salts wake you up that’s about it and the effect wears off after maybe 10 seconds. I used them in football but only when I needed to wake up and not for a performance thing. It doesn’t improve performance
Thanks for the video 🙏 can u do a video on Reggie Lewis
We had to take a chemistry class when I was in high school so one day our teacher had us mix smelling salts. So it said on the sheet to smell the ingredients before the one had a little smell and the other had no smell so it said to mix the two ingredients and sniff it so I took a huge whiff it hurt quite a bit it made my heart race for a while
I thought it was to clear your head if it's cloudy, to bring you back to your senses
It’s not a problem when used in short burst sports like weightlifting or track and field.
I enjoy the videos. You're very informative. But i wouldn't be inviting you to any parties🤣
3:59 “…could make it worse from that sudden jerking motion” 🤔 usually when I make a sudden jerking motion, I feel great 😂😂😂
When I get into a funk and don't feel like doing my workout, I take a smell and BAM!!! Working out.
My mate Dave took 24 in one night and the next day he was really buzzing and had loads of energy and everyone on the Eggham to Langley Village bus says that he drove it better than ever before.
Booyakasha
I think a lot of the people that are using them are using them before they lift helping opening up the nasal passages allows you to breathe better and being able to breathe is key for working out. Let alone doing rep sets... It can also be used to jolt yourself awake if feeling a little drowsy... But I'm a firm believer and using too much of anything can be bad for you everything in moderation!
that little smirk he gets on his face when he gets the more potent bottle of salts is hilarious to me lol. i know this is a somewhat serious topic but it is a fun clip.
The amount of times the Joe Rogan smelling salts clip has come across my feed... well, I'm glad that I now have this knowledge lol
I need that when driving during rush hour traffic.
Hello M.Sutterer
Could you make a video on Kani basami, the cisor throw?
i have a question for you if you may: what happens if a person uses smelling salt multiple times and if in the times of medieval to 17 or 18 centuries, can they get chest disease really bad and get worse if they are in old age? thanks
I have sleep apnea and so hard to wake up in the morning and get the kids on the school bus, would it be really bad to use this in the morning?
Can you do a video on Byron Jones? I think it’s very interesting how he said playing at the nfl level came at a regrettable cause
Can you do a video on Bianca Andreescu’s injury
I just wanna see if it wakes me up in the morning 😅
I keep smelling salts in my car so if I am tired but want to keep going.. I take a sniff a little and wake up without caffeine.
do more hockey injury videos please
As a person that experiences quick drops in blood pressure, I appreciate these
Blast some music that generally gets you pumped and take a hit of salts and watch how into the music you get, taking a hit on the way to the gym blasting music, then 2-3 during the end of the workouts to get me back in the zone…. All aboard the gain train 💪🏼💯
Finally someone talks about how stupid smelling salts is, thank you and great video
yeah, i thought of that when i heard of them for the first time
Lol I saw your post on twitter.
We used to use it in the wee-hours of the graveyard shift at my first factory job. The old-timers put me on to it. I found it quite exhilarating. Worked like a charm. 😅
Great video, with a thoughtful and reasonable analysis. Thanks Brian!
Yeah let's go induce blunt force trauma by running into each other at high speed over some stupid ball, but god forbid someone *takes a chemical*
Could you use this right when you wake up so you can get outta bed fast?.
I always thought they were only using smelling salts for like alertness/a pre game jolt and not any type of performance benefits
I’ve seen it take unconscious people back to consciousness and had them back in the fight in less than 20 seconds.
It serves a purpose.
This reminded me that I need to reup on my smelling salts
i was playing hockey a few yrs back and there had to be 15-20 opened smelling salts packages on the bench and wall and I KNOW the guys I was playing with were not using them...only thing I figured was some high school teams or travel squads were using them....either a lot of kids were fighting off concussions or they read something where this might help performance
Ty 4 ur opinion
burn that jersey doc! 😂
I would LOVE to see you break down a movie or TV show injury…something even unrealistic or deadly. I know you specialize in sports, but I’m watching Barry on HBO right now, and can’t help but think of your medical analysis of S2E5 when Barry is getting his ass kicked. Just a thought 👍 Thanks, love your channel!
I’m curious on your thoughts of when somebody slaps you in the face to get a similar effect of being “more alert”
It’s working for him dudes in a heater right now 😂
Great video! Did you really have to kill my boy Booker though? 😭
Used smelling salts before football games to purely get in the game. Never felt any physical effects, just pure rage thats why I used them. I don’t think players are really looking for physical effect, rather they’re looking for a stimulation to get pissed or focused
Is the ammonia absorbed into the bloodstream? If it is, then does it create more strain on the kidneys?
Can you give your thoughts on bianca andreescu injury?
There's always a perfect doctor against everything!! Have you ever played hockey doc?? I doubt it!
I remember when my buddy pulled out smelling salts in the school cafeteria and it made a bunch of them cry 😂 definitely not something that would help their performance
May help people drive if they feel sleepy. Especially Long Haulers.
Also, correct me if I'm wrong but aren't you supposed to whaff it and not directly smell it?
As a student nurse, I did that to keep awake during my internship. I have no plans going back again since the BO of some of my coworkers is way stronger than that.😆
Haha the bo part sounds horrid. Eww
You want to be a nurse but bo is that much of a bother? You may be pursuing the wrong career.
@@EChino92 Oh dear call me racist but wait till you smell some of my Indian and Pakistani coworkers. Our bosses warmed them to cut back on their traditional food due to patient complaints already.😆
@lipstickzombie4981Now that was FUNNY 🤣🤣 LOL 😁 I hear U 💯 -- ((Your co-workers B.O.))
What about using them to wake up in the morning?
78 we broke lock on Corp. gas pump, I was running around looking for empty containers & found a big empty one. Cracked lid & took a big whiff... it was ammonia... last gas I ever stole.
I just like a little jolt from the salts from the irritation and it wakes me up a bit
can you do a video on shane mcmahons injury from wrestle mania
The only time I've ever used smelling salts seriously was at a lifting competition. I drove 6 hours on 3 hours of sleep and I was definitely tired half way through the comp. I needed a pick me up.
That stuff is absolutely brutal
Can you do Bianca Andrescu injury please
What a sally. Wait til you see all the dangers when they actually go on the ice.
You tell ‘em, Bryan
In strongman and powerlifting where even just a hard slap on the back is supposed to be a necessity, even just perceived benefit is worth it, and if you are able to sit there and inhale the salts long enough to damage your nasal passage ways then either you have done way way too many smelling salts or the salts you have aren’t strong enough. However it’s not as though it’s wide spread in sports and in many situations like after a hard foul you get up and play regardless, so guys on the bench don’t really do it when they are trying to get some rest either. If the shot you received wobbled you and you get called to the sidelines, it’s to be evaluated not to take a quick rest and get back in there anyway.
Can you please make do video of the USWNT star Mallory Swanson knee injury?
What about those cans of enhanced air that have a higher percentage of oxygen than regular air?