Cosmologist Bernard Carr Explores the Mysteries of the Universe with Sadhguru
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2024
- Renowned cosmologist Prof. Bernard Carr and Sadhguru engage in a fascinating discussion about some of the deepest mysteries of our cosmos. In a discussion facilitated by Dr. Bala Subramaniam, Professor of Anesthesiology, Harvard Medical School, Prof. Carr and Sadhguru explore a range of topics, including science, spirituality, time and space, multiverses, and consciousness in an event hosted by the Sadhguru Center for a Conscious Planet at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center.
#Science #spirituality #Sadhguru
0:00 Conversation begins
2:21 The link between science & spirituality
11:15 Sadhguru on infinity and how the universe was created
25:34 Prof. Carr on mathematics as a way of understanding the universe
32:17 Prof. Carr on exploring different cycles of time
37:33 Prof. Carr on Consciousness in physics
42:06 Time through the lens of the Theory of Relativity
49:50 Sadhguru on five layers of the body & extraordinary knowledge
57:53 Prof. Carr on different levels of consciousness
1:06:25 Sadhguru on developing a vision of the beyond
1:11:48 Levitation, mysticism, and spiritual & psychic experiences
1:30:00 Prof. Carr on the definition of physics
1:36:45 Sadhguru decodes “science” & “spirituality”
1:43:00 Prof. Carr & Sadhguru on the nature of consciousness
1:52:15 Sadhguru on the big bang, parallel universes & 84 creations
Transform Your Life in 7 Steps With Sadhguru Register now: sadhguru.co/ie-yt
#7StepsToMentalHealth #7StepsWithSadhguru #InnerEngineering
"The Sadhguru Podcast - Of Mystics and Mistakes (Listen Now on)"
open.spotify.com/show/69ZUhdV...
Get 14-day free access to Sadhguru Exclusive, the largest video catalog on Mysticism & Spirituality.
Only On Sadhguru App
*T&C Applied
Visit: isha.co/Sgx-SM
Official UA-cam Channel of Sadhguru
Considered among India’s 50 most influential people, Sadhguru is a yogi, mystic, bestselling author, and poet. Absolute clarity of perception places him in a unique space, not only in matters spiritual but in business, environmental and international affairs, and opens a new door on all that he touches.
Inner Engineering
Inner Engineering is a comprehensive course for personal growth that brings about a shift in the way you perceive and experience your life, your work, and the world that you live in.
innerengineering.sadhguru.org/
Isha Life products for everyday health and well-being. Buy online at bit.ly/3L0gTar
Save Soil Movement
Launched by Sadhguru, Save Soil is the world's largest people's movement, reaching 3.91 billion people to address impending soil extinction by supporting governments to create policies for soil revitalization.
savesoil.org/
Sadhguru app
Accelerate your spiritual journey with transformative guided meditations, daily wisdom, and Yogic tools.
onelink.to/sadhguru__app - Навчання та стиль
Very rarely we come across scientists like Dr. Bernard who is full of Humility, Integrity, Knowledge, Wisdom and Willingness to listen & understand from Sadhguru. What a wonderful conversation. Sadhguru is Sadhguru, A Master who is Unique, Unmatched, and Unparalled.
@@thisarchanabahugunaright now, you're speaking out of arrogance. I'd suggest you to re-watch the entire video and study the body language of the gentleman. If he would've been uncomfortable or found any views offensive like you're describing, he would've expressed thru his body (which he didn't)
😂😢😢I
Nice story😂
@@thisarchanabahugunayou are right sadhguru has to be arrogant you know how much it costs to be arrogant as sadhguru is ? He truly knows he really knows thats why he appears to be arrogant
@@mementomori5374 Ok cool dear. Enjoy what you have!
Sadhguru is not confused. Because he does not separate aspects of life, he is able to see the connections between subjects and how they relate. Dr. Carr, is in my view, a true scientist and has my deep respect. He is open minded and also willing to consider all viewpoints. It was fascination to see these two humble giants engage. Thank you.
. .
I agree!!
True well said
finally a science guy who is not full of himself, love the energy of that guy!
I agree ❤
This was the best one among other science interactions.
Instead we a have a guru who is full of himself.
Sadguru came in with Black dress ... For absorbing all the energy from Bernard .... Black body radiation 😢
@@favorite2523 Oh yeah, he said about the colour of his clothing before.
That Rose given by Sadhguru in the end indicates that the scientific approach of this gentleman is honest and sincere without any arrogance or prejudice. His eagerness is like that of a toddler.
😊😊
Was fortunate to attend this talk in person in Boston. Sadhguru’s sheer presence is magical and Dr. Carr’s wisdom and knowledge along with his humility is endearing. India has had a huge tradition of Samvaad or debate and this one truly meets the standards of how two fields, science and mysticism should be conversing.
❤
Well said, politicians have a lot to learn from this conversation in context with how a meaningful debate/discussions can unfold solutions for many challenges the world is facing today.
The problem with western politics and debate is we dont go this deep to find common ground within ideological spaces and thats do to subjective reality bias and playin for a team politics and capitalist ideals on the same occord non dualism philosopy can help our society thats very stuck in dualism beliefs that are not benificial for all of humanity and creates more division then unity non dualistic Philosophy brings the oneness of the cosmos and the human together on the same level not seperate from
@@CaddilacJoe1
My lord..... Such sophistication in a reply?!?!!
You are more enlightened than ALL the NOBELS METTED OUT FOT PARTICLE PHYSICS TILL DATE!! AMEN
same...I was in the room myself... a magical experience
I've been watching guru for the past 10 yrs almost & every interview is Fresh & new, he is a real guide for ppl, & to learn the true mysteries of yoga, I'm thankful to be born in this era just to see & learn from Sadhguru
Same with me, I had been with my Guruji so many years. The more I dig dipper I go, makes me realise that I am ignorent but some light at the end of the tanal which helps to be blissful
I hope you’re practicing his yoga as well. That is when you will truly realise what he is about.
I am very happy, I born in Bharat 🇮🇳 because Bharat have various Gurus like Sadhguru ❤
Such a humble person Dr. Bernard is!
Listening to sadhguru is always enlightening 😊🙏🏻
Not agree with you. He already revealed that he is not a humble physicist that he is striving to explore the link between conciousness and the modern science.
@@MrMaximillian1984 I can see he's a humble person and that's what @iamtherj said. Being at the cutting edge of something putting your effort into extending it doesn't make you less humble
@@MrMaximillian1984 he is humble in the way he converses with sadhguru, not humble in portraying his achievements. Humbleness in presence is not the same as humbleness in knowledge
I can't express enough how this man is the truth. He describes everything so simple and easy to stand and comprehend he deserves a Nobel Peace prize Cuz he don't hide anything 🎯💯
He is all "The Nobel Prizes "combined. Blessings!
@paulthottakaran161🤣🤣🤣 you a sado tryna deflect. Why are you here? Did someone force you to come? Oow you jealous it's not you getting the shine!! 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
Nobel prize is given not for talking nice, but for breakthrough in science.
@@mindaza0 How easily yiu neglected the breakthroughs his yogic practises have made in the domain of yoga and meditation. Yoga and meditation is not separate from science. Your hate for this guru shows sheer Ignorance.
You can tell Bernard is one of those scientists who keeps an open mind and willing to be open to the possibilities of there being a dimension that might never we perceptible through us via the intellect but via the being within us that is beyond body and mind.
Build a rocket and make it fly then.
@@RoshanKumar-xh3gfi made a rocket come my home sir
Thata also science.
No my friend be not seperate from your self, be sincere no fear be fore real seek to know the knower known being known.❤❤❤
Again the miracle is understanding the pathway of understanding is understanding.❤❤❤
Dr. Carr is admirable. He was very patient and genuinely seemed to make an effort to understand. We need people like him who are open-minded.
that old man is a geek... could barely handle the conversation.. he mad it more like a debate..
@@toxicd310 who??
The middle East uni minded will never understand
With this video, Sadhguru took my consciousness to next level. Specially the opening story unfolds a new era of knowledge within me.. kala and Mahakala introduced in a new light . Jai Mahakaal, Jai Shambhu !!!❤❤❤
Sadhgurus explanation of how the universe has evolved is a true masterpiece.
Excellent words: You can either crushed by Time, Trapped by Time or liberated by Time by Riding the Time (Cycle) by going tangent. Escaping this time cycle is Moksha / Mukthi.
Excellent... bullshit! So, your mind is easily carried away by a rattling rhetoric instead of standing the ground by logic and facts.
Escaping the time cycle is possible in our life time! simply by Renouncing ego
Thank you Dr Carr, for being brave and open minded enough to take on a mind as wild and powerful as Sadhguru!
48:23 he's trying to hang in there!
When going on summer vacation with our kids, way before cell phones! We took our watches off, we lived life according to our bodies and the sensations it gave us, timing our meal times bed times, etc.
If your vacation includes timed events, you can disregard and put your watches back in! Such as Disney now with timed passes the no watch thing is counterintuitive.
Dr. Carr's is truly admirable. It's hard to stay 'true to curiosity' in academia, particularly if the truth lies in aspects which is deemed childish or nonscientific by your fellow colleagues. That said I think if one were consciously seeking or 'curious beyond inhibits' there would be no such thing as the need to take on. Because opinions or points of view don't matter in the quest of truth. You know what I mean? Dr. Carr is truly curious and doesn't care much if the truth lies in place others disregard but there is still an extremely slight inhibition, and I think it stems from his love for science. And that's lovely..He hopes his love (science) can make even the invisible, partially graspable through the academic means. And I don't think he is wrong for it. But Sadhguru says it might be necessary to reform the definitions and methodologies in academia in their pursuit cause Infinite cannot be grasped it can only be experienced at the very least appreciated.
Brainless followers.....desperately searching for someone under whom u can take comfort.
This sadhguru proclaims himself as wild , energetic...but open ur eyes and look at his belly....that i sthe only thing that is wild.... he rides bike....every fat american cruises on a harley ...does it mean they are fit??
😂
I love the chemistry these two share. Hope they get together again soon.
Yes, nice to watch this conversation between Cosmologist Bernard Carr Explores the Mysteries of the Universe with Sadhguru. I Love the the chemistry of these two. 🙏👍
It was an absolute joy to watch this conversation. Sad that, it ended in 2 hours when the conversation beginning to go through deeper waters..
Dr. Bernard is admirable as a cosmologist childlike wonder and zest.
Definitely a breath of fresh air
Is the point of paradox for nothingness becomes something and where mind is focused in time as consciousness. And that is the very things that define quantum gravity or Quantum relativity
Infiniti 100 percent is zero. My friend you are getting it my God
Wine and spirit of part of physics my friend you are missing the point but you're close
Mind is prior to matter but Consciousness is not
Missing these discussions since COVID ..glad Sadhguru back in real form🎉
Same here 😅
Same here 😅
Same here 😅
This has been one interview where the dialogue is open and even handed. Being an engineer and on my spiritual journey since a few years, this conversation has been the most intellectual stimulating yet spiritually soothing at the same time. Great conversation!! ❤🙂
I’m only 49 minutes in, but this is such a beautiful conversation. There is lots of respect between the two whilst exchanging super high level wisdom, and that’s lovely to see. Also the hilarious moments like at 49:36 bringing in a playful dig, and many others, just added perfect humour
This should be a colossal meeting. Sadhguru all the way ❤️
00:00 Introduction
00:42 Intro Chant
01:27 Sadhguru Explains The Chant
02:20 Conversation Starts
11:15 Sadhguru's Perspective Of Universe
11:24 Infinity Vs Zero
18:09 From Emptiness To Physicality Of Cycles
21:33 Yogi's Goal Towards Cycles Of Life
22:17 Science & Ramanujam
25:49 Cosmologist's Mathematical Approach To Universe
38:04 Physics, Time & Conciousness
50:00 Sadhguru's Approach To Time And Space
01:01:04 Mind & Body
01:11:48 Different Types Of Experiences
01:22:20 An Experiment By Sadhguru
01:27:25 Sadhguru On Time & Space
01:33:33 Cosmologist On Science & Beyond
01:34:38 Conciousness & Life
01:52:13 Significance Of The Number 84
02:05:44 End Of Conversation
Thank you Sumitji
@@RanjitGodbole pranam🙏🙏
@@sumitkumardas9690Thank you 🙏 for timings
@@hariharang8872 pranam🙏
Thank you brother
There is another plain of awareness to see from, That plain is where the moment lies. Where God meditates loving vibration.❤❤❤
My two favorite subjects Science and Spirituality ♾️ thank you ❤️
Even their point of humor which amuses the audience relates towards clarity of their discussion. This is awesome coming out of these two beautiful minds.
AI & da B ruet tuff fulusion.
It comes out of nothing
❤me
So kind of Sadhguru to sit down with this man and impart deep wisdom
Super, This is Sadhguru at his best in putting so many important concepts & understanding in one discussion
Mathematics is the language of physics 😊 Two kind and intelligent beings are sitting together, explaining different dimensions from their perspectives❤
In the interval before mass enlightenment , one fine attribute of the physical sciences is the distribution of knowledge.
@@jondor654what do you mean? Interval betweem masses?
Girls if exposed to knowledge hooman attained make it bloomed for sure .
Dr Bernard Carr is true Human !! Excellent Sir.
Topic dekh ke hi majja aaya. Fir dekha 2 ghante ka conversation. Double dhamaka!!!😅
Thanks for sharing 🙏
When Sadhguru is with scientists and highly successful medical professionals he is at his best and listeners thoroughly enjoy the discussion, it seemed the discussion ended so soon proving that time is relative.
This conversation is a blessing 🙏
Bernard seems like a curious child the way he speaks about math and physics, very endearing
Yup! I noticed it too.
All Scientists Must be like Curious Child
Dr. Carr's is truly endearing. It's hard to stay 'true to curiosity' in academia, particularly if the truth lies in aspects which is deemed childish or nonscientific by your fellow colleagues. But I don't he's fully childlike or uninhibited. I think it stems from his love for science. And that's lovely..He hopes his love (science) can make even the invisible, partially graspable through the academic means. And I don't think he is wrong for it. But Sadhguru says it might be necessary to reform the definitions and methodologies in academia in their pursuit cause Infinite cannot be grasped it can only be experienced at the very least appreciated.. which makes perfect sense. The cause(finite) can only admire the maker(infinite), but it can never fully understand the maker in its finite state. It can only experience the maker when it becomes infinite.
That is the point. Every human should be amazed and curious all the time, because we are nothing and know nothing 🙏
Endearing :) Enchanting Engrossing :) Enrapturing :) aahaa! I was combing the comment section specifically for remarks about Dr. Bernard's pleasing personality!
Sadhguru anyway needs no words
Amusing that ancient teachings explain things the same if not better than modern science
If you play a Japanese video game, you will notice all the stories seem to be on far fetched planets, when in fact they are always talking about Earth and how we as humans and human likes have risen and fallen many times over Eons always leaving behind indecipherable ruins
@@gratefulkmwhich game?
@@gratefulkmwhich game??
@@rahulpoojari9266 Final Fantasy, Zelda, Xenobalde, Chrono rigger, Secret of Mana , I'm pretty certain I could list every jap game ever made
There was an ancient civilization that was far more advanced than now and it left behind mad stuff we know nothing about,
Pretty generic in all thier stories
@@pv9214 anything made by the Japs, Ancient Civilization far more advanced then now and left behind amazing stuff we cant work out
It was such a joy watching these two. There was mutual respect to each other. The scientist has an open mind and a result learned a lot from Sathguru. I am sure It went the other way too although it is hard to tell if there is anything that Sathguru does not know. Overall, an interesting conversation.
Experiencing the rich interplay between science and spirituality in this video reminds us how beautifully challenging and profoundly simple it is to keep an open mind.
Wow it must be a total joy to be Professor Bernard’s student. When the light is so enthusiastically curious, the vision shall be a joy as well.
A very beautiful comment
Sadhguru is Explaining Everything in Very Detailed, Clarified manner, Hats Off n Heartfelt gratitude for Him ❤ #Science Meets #Spiritulity
Consciousness is never incidental or accidental.❤❤❤
Consciousness is life and life is time and time is cycle which is movement
Out of all Sadhguru's conversations from Harvard to David's this was a very Unique one & His Perception is indeed attribute less. It would take a lot for the physicists to comprehend & frame in order to understand what he's trying to debate about beyond the logical limitations of the physicality of existence!
One of the most beautiful conversation between Sadhguru and dr. Bernard, mind-blowing
Wow! I'm so glad I found Sadghuru and did Shambhavi 3 years ago. It has changed my life in so many ways 🙏
how
@@argxoxo7326you can learn shambhavi in inner engineering prgram
To lighten the tone of magificence, Sadhguru is such a "Bless You!" He converts complexity to simplicity geniusly well! In the big picture, some would say "Everything reverts to Simplicity". What an incredible Guru, teacher and Inspiration!!
This was magical.. especially when Sadhguru says you have name this science something else Where the science is about non physical. Lucky to be in this world while he is around. He is much more than what we see…he is ruthless when is a Guru 🙏🏼😊
Bernard Carr is very good. Some mysteries can be understood, but some mysteries have to be experienced. 🙏
SADHGURU...It's happening BIG TIME. and I'm totally sane. But. It's incredible and there's a long road. Incredible. Thank you. TCMO
Bernard's attitude is the ideal archetype of a scientist who can accelerate the convergence of science and mysticism to arrive at truth
Can't believe such an insightful conversation isn't reaching more humans out there, hope that happens!
Brilliant! The world is more than what we can see, such a humbling disposition! Even if you live for a 100 years, you know very little
even a child knows that the world is more than it can see, question is do you have the competency to see it all? How long you live cannot determine how much you see
Wow... Just wow.
Many complex concepts are explained in such an easy way with banter that makes it so interesting.
I wish our teachers were like these two wonderful people 🙏🙏
Thank you for this conversation. The child-like curiosity of Dr Bernhard Carr was so endearing and I always learn something new about eastern philosophy from watching Sadhguru.
It's not philosophy, it's inner experience
Hats off to these thought tinkers.❤❤❤
From this conversation we can learn that the less the physical science one has consumed the more Spiritual they are. Simply, Spirituality proceeds from where the physical science ends.
Watch videos by Michael Singer to understand that science provides the evidence of the spiritual.
Quantum physics is evidence of how material matter comes from a field of energy.
We are holograms.
Atoms are 99% energy, 1% matter. ❤️
I don't completely agree sir, science and spirituality or I should say the yogic culture quite go hand-in-hand, it's just that we should not limit ourselves and should not be in absolute disagreements about the things which have not been discovered by the science yet.
@@kartikeyarathee We're saying the same thing here
Spot on.
Extremely intriguing discussion , amazing people both !!
First person who is with sadguru and i literally love to hear his words also.
Sadhguru 🙏🙇🏻♀️no words to greet your wisdom and compassion that you are pouring on us... You're truly driving the bus of humanity forward
What a fascinating conversation.
The frame setup is so beautiful, Sadhguru looking wow as always ❤️😘
Sensational Video! Very few humans in this world can hear different frequencies. You have acquired a different level of consciousness. 99.9 % of humans in this world walk around blind for they can only see what lies before them, not what lies ahead. This is why I love Hinduism. Namaskaram Sadhguru! You are a blessing to this world.
Such a GREAT personality both of them...I loved the way DR Carr asking and speaking...he make me understand even I m so far to science world in my daily life....♥♥♥
you dont believe in god?
What an insightful conversation! I don't know why, but whenever Sadhguru says something, I am totally convinced without any doubts. There is so much clarity and wisdom n his explanation.
But he may be wrong so explore for yourself
Hope to meet you soon again Sadhguru with your grace ❤
You are my hope ❤ You are my power 🙏
Thank you Sadhguru and Bernard Carr
"how deeply you are identified with your physicality, that's how much power time has over you"
wow !!! it was 2 hours of beauty ...thanks dear Sadhguru ... fascinating conversation.... LOVE
I love this! I am so grateful for this day!
Same ❤
HUMBLENESS IS BORN OUT OF SUCH PERSONALITIES
Cosmologist joined such a conversation with a yogi who is not a scientist is a brave thing and both have played their part well.
We need mathematics, not coming from intellect but from the Self 🙏
What does that even mean?
@@phoenix007ism when one is inspired like Ramanujam and we get equations non-stop without any hardwork. hehehe. because we are indians (kind of lazy and shortcut/jugaad loving people) hehe
@@phoenix007ism Mathematics from the Self would be exact "forever"
👍👍😇😇🙏
Its going to be infinity before the zero@@EmmaYoga
27:00 he perfectly grasps about miracles what Sadhguru was trying to explain to Professor Pinker for two hours.
Spirituality and science are complementary, spirituality is knowing the CREATOR and science is knowing his CREATION.
Very well said !🙂
Such a joyful conversation, was laughing all the time and learn many interesting points. Thank you!!!
Great conversation as usual by 2 great personalities
Wow! What a great conversation. Really fascinating and illumination.
Sadhguruji is really a mysterious human being. He has knowledge of physical and biological sciences and space. 🙏
One of the most enlightening conversation I heard in long time
physical body - physical time, mind - mental time, emotion - emotional time, energy level - energy time, every dimension has a time of its own..
Well said
Information as knowledge just confuses you! Inner experience settles you and gives you an unmatched clarity!
This is so apparent in this conversation! Pranam sadhguru 🙏❤
I love wisdom of sadhguru. Love from Nepal❤️
I wish Bernard took/understood the gist - "don't try to expand physics, keep physics for things of physical nature, Science is a an overarching umbrella, keep expanding science to see (perceive, understand) things beyond physical and maybe mathematics can help in doing that".
Thank you. Sadhguru explains the obvious so well. Love gratitude peace to All. One Light. 💛
Long video but priceless. So thankful for the two beings.
I’m crying ecstatic tears in appreciation for this wisdom.. I’m glad he has not left us yet.
I don’t care about any celebrities, don’t go to concerts and I’m nobody’s fan other than my family and a couple close friends …… if there was anyone I could have a chance to meet in this world ….. let’s face it, it’s got to be Sadhguru
I can’t imagine the radiance this man must reverberate whilst in his presence
Namaskaram Sadguru
Great sadguru ji❤
What is more than apparent is infinite but what is more infinite is not so readily apparent.❤❤❤
It’s FUN to watch and listen to Dr. Carr and Sadhguru!!!!!🎉
What a great chat, I really loved it, I am closer to wisdom now.
I love how yogic philosophy beautifully lines up with Kabbalistic thought. It says to me that these insights are universal regardless of culture and language.
I highly suspect kabbala rose from yogic tradition, just like zen
Any references for kabbalistic thought that we can refer to on internet or books ? I have never seen anything on the same lines so would be curious.
@@padyala the yogis will break it down better than most people who claim kabbalah to be there ting, even Madonna jumped on it for attention seeking tactical efforts
@@nyakwarObat Agreed
What a delightful talk! Thank you so much for making it publicly!
Sadhguru is intervening too much without giving enough time for the good Prof to explain his points. Yet, an exciting conversation. Thanks to both gentlemen.❤
Thank You for this wonderful discussion. Its too good for somebody who is interested in knowing. Hope people listened to it and expand their understanding.
I think this conversation ended so soon. Bernad had more questions. There should be a follow up session to discuss remaining topics i.e. difference between mental ,psychic and spiritual experience, how to measure them atleast using body chemistry and how to go about building mathematical model around it .
Don't worry they will discuss those at dinner time not for all.
Loved this conversation. Thank you and love you sadhguru!
That rose at the end... A seeker got blessed...❤
Love you SADHGURU 🙏🏽❤️
Awesome content thanks
Thank you, the spiritual science of the era ❤
I have never imagined my existence so clearly. Beautiful way to put it in words.