They removed Karl, Wolfgang and Florian from the visuals... and I only just now notice they had already removed Karl and Wolfgang from the visuals in their 1991 tour. Kind of fits the mentality of the music being about the music and not about the musicians, but still. Making The Telephone Call instrumental because it was sung by Karl is going kind of far.
Maybe they made The Telephone Call instrumental as respect because the lyrics were mainly written by Karl Bartos. Karl Bartos does something simillar in his concerts as respect. He only plays the Kraftwerk songs where he was participated as a song writer. That's why Karl never played Autobahn or Radioactivity. What Wolfgang did is unacceptable. There's a video of Wolfgang's concert where he played Pocket Calculator (The Mix) on playback and he didn't even touch the keyboard. Wolfgang thinks that he can play every KW song, but he wasn't participated as a song writer in any KW song.
@@KanalvogtSG I've seen the video of Wolfgang playing Pocket Calculator. I don't know exactly how the legalities and such works in regards to live performances, but a lot of artists play songs of other artists live (actually, Kraftwerk is one of the few artists I know who don't ever do that). Karl has also played Daft Punk's song Alive live, for example. I guess one could argue Wolfgang playing a version of a Kraftwerk song he didn't contribute to is not really different to that. But in both cases it seems like they pretty much just put on the studio version which is kind of cheap. Also, I realized after I made my original comment that things are a bit more subtle than I thought. I noticed Wolfgang uses a lot of video clips of Kraftwerk during his live performances and I'm not really sure what to think of that. I can kind of see Kraftwerk removing Karl, Wolfgang and Florian from their visuals and Karl's lyrics from The Telephone Call being more of a respect thing now, though of course I don't know if that's their intention. I still think it'd be okay to keep the lyrics though. If they removed everything from their songs that ex-members were responsible for, some of their songs would probably be missing their melodies as well.
Actually, they didn't remove Karl and Wolfgang from Music Non Stop in their 1991 Tour. They removed them in 2008 / 2009. You can still see them in Minimum-Maximum.
In my opinion, what they did with the tracks in the 3D versions is great (Mostly), however, If Kraftwerk kept the original pacing of the albums, then 3d The catalog would've just been 5 hours of heaven (I mean come on, Autobahn was condensed into literally two tracks). Still some of the greatest music ever created in my opinion.
The most strange thing i notice about it is that there's 3 edits of these animations they made on apple music, one for the robots, one for musique non stop and other for tour de france. Why on apple music only? i have no idea, lol.
@På Luffen Well, yes (+Boing Boom Tschak too in this list))... Cause, Im just 15 years old a all my live, before getting full access to UA-cam, I watched only a collection-performance of 2005. There, the songs were merged and cut, heh...
@@petrutmarcu9450 Sorry, but I can only upload it on August because the 18th anniversary of the Tour De France album will be on August. The Kraftwerk albums I uploaded are not ordinary albums. They are special albums from the 3D-Catalogue and the music videos from the 3D-Catalogue are very rare and hard to find. I'm very sorry that I can't upload it yet.
It's OK. It's not that important to upload albums on their anniversaries, but the most important thing is to remind ourselves about the albums on their anniversaries.
Oh my, this is truly dreadful! It's like the muzak versions of hits one may hear in the 'bargains' stores! The original recording is still best, even though it should have been more 'techno', and harder. I didn't really like it at the time - after waiting outside the shop for it to open to get mine. I fast-forwarded it all until 'techno pop', and then fast forwarded it to the end. It took a while to come to terms with them producing a turd.
They removed Karl, Wolfgang and Florian from the visuals... and I only just now notice they had already removed Karl and Wolfgang from the visuals in their 1991 tour. Kind of fits the mentality of the music being about the music and not about the musicians, but still. Making The Telephone Call instrumental because it was sung by Karl is going kind of far.
Maybe they made The Telephone Call instrumental as respect because the lyrics were mainly written by Karl Bartos. Karl Bartos does something simillar in his concerts as respect. He only plays the Kraftwerk songs where he was participated as a song writer. That's why Karl never played Autobahn or Radioactivity. What Wolfgang did is unacceptable. There's a video of Wolfgang's concert where he played Pocket Calculator (The Mix) on playback and he didn't even touch the keyboard. Wolfgang thinks that he can play every KW song, but he wasn't participated as a song writer in any KW song.
@@KanalvogtSG I've seen the video of Wolfgang playing Pocket Calculator. I don't know exactly how the legalities and such works in regards to live performances, but a lot of artists play songs of other artists live (actually, Kraftwerk is one of the few artists I know who don't ever do that). Karl has also played Daft Punk's song Alive live, for example. I guess one could argue Wolfgang playing a version of a Kraftwerk song he didn't contribute to is not really different to that. But in both cases it seems like they pretty much just put on the studio version which is kind of cheap.
Also, I realized after I made my original comment that things are a bit more subtle than I thought. I noticed Wolfgang uses a lot of video clips of Kraftwerk during his live performances and I'm not really sure what to think of that. I can kind of see Kraftwerk removing Karl, Wolfgang and Florian from their visuals and Karl's lyrics from The Telephone Call being more of a respect thing now, though of course I don't know if that's their intention. I still think it'd be okay to keep the lyrics though. If they removed everything from their songs that ex-members were responsible for, some of their songs would probably be missing their melodies as well.
Actually, they didn't remove Karl and Wolfgang from Music Non Stop in their 1991 Tour. They removed them in 2008 / 2009. You can still see them in Minimum-Maximum.
Instrumental telephone call doesn’t do it for me, why doesn’t Ralf sing in it?
Karl made the telephone call what it is, a monster classic song.
amazing album
Monster!
Thank you very much (the post)
KRAFTWERK is THE BRAIN...
;)
HD, HQ, 3D... Super!
Absolute masterpiece
In my opinion, what they did with the tracks in the 3D versions is great (Mostly), however, If Kraftwerk kept the original pacing of the albums, then 3d The catalog would've just been 5 hours of heaven (I mean come on, Autobahn was condensed into literally two tracks). Still some of the greatest music ever created in my opinion.
"Es wird immer weiter gehen"
Edit: Happy Birthday, Electric Cafe
Musik als Träger von Ideen!
Party Y'all
I don't know wherr you did find this version but SO THX!! Frédéric. #ElectricCafe walks my life since i was 18/19 .. I'm 53 now. THX FOR THIS GIFT.
Electric café. Merci.
@@DuckDAWorld It's from the 3D-Catalogue.
Marvelous!
ELEKTRONICZNA KAWIARNIA KRAFTWERK. CHCIAŁBYM DO NIEJ WSTĄPIĆ !
Arcydzieło!💚
Po Trawie lepiej wchodzi!🔥🇵🇱😤😳🇳🇱🗽🤠👊
Струнные, басс, перкуссия - в этом альбоме самое прекрасно всё
Very minimal sounds and beats, love it!!!!!!! ( Ps very first KW I've ever bought).
Techno Pop is the best song on this, if only it was 7mins. It's sad so many songs are cut short in their live shows but I understand why 😶
The telephone call’s sounds sound very dry compared to the 2015 Amsterdam Paradiso version.
this is fantastic
I hated this album when it came out in the same way I felt about Jean Michel Jarre’s ‘Zoolook’ album. Now I love them both.
Мега😊 супер 😊
Класс ❤❤❤
Los ingenieros de la electrónica...
THE OLDEST VANGUARD BAND
NON STOP!
German magic
Ale Cudowna !
Boing Boom Tschak now has a different drum beat and different drum itself. Techno Pop is shorter, Musique Non Stop is longer.
Creators of electronic muzik.
The most strange thing i notice about it is that there's 3 edits of these animations they made on apple music, one for the robots, one for musique non stop and other for tour de france. Why on apple music only? i have no idea, lol.
Thx!
🤩
Now i understood that Music non stop and Techno pop aren't one song...
@På Luffen Well, yes (+Boing Boom Tschak too in this list))... Cause, Im just 15 years old a all my live, before getting full access to UA-cam, I watched only a collection-performance of 2005. There, the songs were merged and cut, heh...
@På Luffen Heh, i know)))
Variations, babies...😂
Супер!!!!
This album is hot😊😊😊😊
Electric Cafe - 13:03
JBL, thank god I have good speakers. The whole house shakes yes!!!!!!😊😊😊😊
👍 naj bolje iz moje mladosti
❤
Can you please upload the full film album of Radio Activity?
Cheers!
I already did: ua-cam.com/video/jY9fk7BBDn8/v-deo.html
Sorry I just saw it.
I wanted to say Tour de France full film album. Please!!!!
Dont know why I said Radioactivity
:))
@@petrutmarcu9450 Sorry, but I can only upload it on August because the 18th anniversary of the Tour De France album will be on August. The Kraftwerk albums I uploaded are not ordinary albums. They are special albums from the 3D-Catalogue and the music videos from the 3D-Catalogue are very rare and hard to find. I'm very sorry that I can't upload it yet.
Mass Effect 2, Omega, club "Afterlife"
❤💯💥
Electric Cafe sound so known but i cant remember...maybe some old cartoons
Very nice :D
kraft werk
Porraaaaaaa amooooooo adoroooooooooo 💖💖💖💖💖💖💗💗💗💖💖💗💖💖💖💗💗💗💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💗💗💗💗💖💖💖💖💖💗💗💗💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💗💗💗💖💖💖💖💖
Fodasticooooooo👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Kraftwerk é PHODA mesmo... heheheh
hey, the timestamp for eletric café is wrong, it starts at 13:04 :p
This ... We have work to do here.
Y'en a d'autres des comme ça ?? #coin #ildemande
Show
9:55🎉🎉🎉
And i don't upload anything.
It's OK. It's not that important to upload albums on their anniversaries, but the most important thing is to remind ourselves about the albums on their anniversaries.
Oh my, this is truly dreadful! It's like the muzak versions of hits one may hear in the 'bargains' stores! The original recording is still best, even though it should have been more 'techno', and harder. I didn't really like it at the time - after waiting outside the shop for it to open to get mine. I fast-forwarded it all until 'techno pop', and then fast forwarded it to the end. It took a while to come to terms with them producing a turd.