Purdy has a 4-2 playoff record because he had elite offensive playmakers and a good defensive team around him. Average arm, injury history, and small size. Decision making ability regressed this season. Offer him 3-year, 153 million dollar maximum contract. If he refuses offer, pick up Darnold or Wilson for 3-year, 120 million contract and draft a QB in the draft to develop.
This is categorically false on so many levels. For one, he has only lost once in the playoffs. Also, the 9ers don't win in the Divisional or NFC championship without Purdy’s plays in both games. Purdy has been part of the top QBs this year and last year, throwing over 30 yards. He played through many injuries and still performed at a very high level, as is seen by the stats he had put up in his career so far. He is also the same size as Pat Mahomes, so I don't see how size is an argument, especially with how much he has produced so far. His decision-making is influenced by what he is given, and right now, the 49ers rank towards the bottom of separation after the snap, along with O-line, special teams, and defense. So get the hell out of here with these bullshit excuses about why you hate Brock.
No team wants Brock for over 50 mil. You keep naming all these other QB's that have no rings, BROCK HAS NO RINGS. He also had one of the best teams around him. We don't need to over pay.
I'd take Rodgers before I'd take Cousins. I'm not saying I want Rodgers, just that I'd have him before I'd have Cousins. I'd rather keep Brock if he was willing to take 45-50 million
Larry you need to consider the talent around these QBs. It’s not black and white as their playoff record. Jimmy G and Purdy have been propped up by having elite talent around them. There’s way more nuance in the argument that (wins and losses)
You say there needs to be more nuance; then you go to one of the most basic arguments against Purdy. For one Brock has been the most efficient QB in the 9er offense since Kyle took over by every metric. This season alone, Brock and Jennings have been the only offense we've had, and Purdy is still in the top 10 of QBR despite all the shit that had gone down. There are very few games this season or in his career that you can honestly say we lost because of Purdy. On the other hand, the reverse can and should be noted, as in the Divisional and NFC Championships of last year, to name a few. The idea that one season where people don't want to play or get injuried is all on Brock is just straight bullshit. Brock has to deal with a struggling and depleted receiving core, an injury-prone running back room, a trash O-line, special teams, and defense. Very few athletes could do it and still play at the level Purdy has been.
What makes you think Rogers, Cousins, Fields or any QB will play for $20 mil? Look at the going rate for starting QB. Unless you fully guarantee then you can’t get a lot anyway. At this point, I would love for niners to just cut him or trade him so he can play for a team with OL and WR that can separate. Probably beat the brakes off niners for years with those QBs.
This AAV discussion is pointless. Even if Brock gets paid he will only be making around 20 million his first year and bumping up. It's all about how his contract is structured. If the Niners structure his deal like Jalen hurts, we will be able to modify the amount he will get paid in the future
Take Mac Jones, cheap as a back up plan, if broc wants to hold out, let him, go with Jones not much if any drop off,until Broc sees the light. Can't have what what we've had every year with hold outs
Yes, he made a mistake, but come Krueg, we were not making playoffs too hurt. I have seen a lot of Qbs make mistakes, even Mahomes has made stupid throws. It is pressure on him from not playing well and trying to force the ball.
Pay purdy y’all trippen we would have 4 wins with darnold . Purdy could’ve easily led us to playoffs this year if those division games didn’t go to shit at the last second. Russel Wilson bro 😂WTH are you smoking
I say if it doesn’t work out with purdy go and sign Justin fields to a 2 year deal plenty of arm strength and intangibles can run and put some players around him and see what he can do. And we save money on the back end not signing purdy
We dont need to trade for an old quarterback! Cousins is good but we need youth. Brock needs a good oline. Look what has happened to Mahomes this year. He has been sacked the most in his career. Now, he is hurt, and Chiefs are not going deep in playoffs. They have just been getting bye.
Get Cousin and draft some rookie QB for future, trade Purdy for 3-4 rounds. Pay Cousin $25 million a year. I’m a Brock fan he’s not worth $50 or $60 a year, he can’t play in the wet or snow then he’s just average QB not elite
Trade Brock to who Krueger? You keep saying this without naming your prospects. When was the last time you heard a NFL team interested on Brock? Maybe as a temp or qb2 but no one will pay 30+ million to have Brock. If he says no to the niners he has no future in the NFL
“Herbert has never won a playoff game”.. Larry STOP. Herbert is better than Purdy and every GM in the league is taking him over Brock. Your arguments are elementary
I haven’t watched any niners UA-cam media this year cause yall have lost your minds. Yall need to make less videos cause the quality and substance is gone. You’re constantly repeating yourselves which forces you all to have idiotic takes.
@Larry you keep saying about Brock's record in the playoffs being 4-2 but that's the teams record not his alone. Burrow & Jackson haven't had the best team in the NFL around them the previous 2 years. You put Burrow in the Niners team we would've won a SB already & some 🤷
Brock saved Lynch and Shanahan. Not many coach’s/GM’s get to blow three first rounders on a bust and keep their jobs. Pay up!
Purdy has a 4-2 playoff record because he had elite offensive playmakers and a good defensive team around him. Average arm, injury history, and small size. Decision making ability regressed this season. Offer him 3-year, 153 million dollar maximum contract. If he refuses offer, pick up Darnold or Wilson for 3-year, 120 million contract and draft a QB in the draft to develop.
This is categorically false on so many levels. For one, he has only lost once in the playoffs. Also, the 9ers don't win in the Divisional or NFC championship without Purdy’s plays in both games. Purdy has been part of the top QBs this year and last year, throwing over 30 yards. He played through many injuries and still performed at a very high level, as is seen by the stats he had put up in his career so far. He is also the same size as Pat Mahomes, so I don't see how size is an argument, especially with how much he has produced so far. His decision-making is influenced by what he is given, and right now, the 49ers rank towards the bottom of separation after the snap, along with O-line, special teams, and defense. So get the hell out of here with these bullshit excuses about why you hate Brock.
Krueg, the hardest working man in the business. Hats off
No team wants Brock for over 50 mil. You keep naming all these other QB's that have no rings, BROCK HAS NO RINGS. He also had one of the best teams around him. We don't need to over pay.
I'd take Rodgers before I'd take Cousins. I'm not saying I want Rodgers, just that I'd have him before I'd have Cousins. I'd rather keep Brock if he was willing to take 45-50 million
Neither of them, one is going to Elmer's, and the other, is on his way to Purina.
@FrankWebber-n4b you missed my point. I don't want either of them either
Larry you need to consider the talent around these QBs. It’s not black and white as their playoff record. Jimmy G and Purdy have been propped up by having elite talent around them. There’s way more nuance in the argument that (wins and losses)
You say there needs to be more nuance; then you go to one of the most basic arguments against Purdy. For one Brock has been the most efficient QB in the 9er offense since Kyle took over by every metric. This season alone, Brock and Jennings have been the only offense we've had, and Purdy is still in the top 10 of QBR despite all the shit that had gone down. There are very few games this season or in his career that you can honestly say we lost because of Purdy. On the other hand, the reverse can and should be noted, as in the Divisional and NFC Championships of last year, to name a few.
The idea that one season where people don't want to play or get injuried is all on Brock is just straight bullshit. Brock has to deal with a struggling and depleted receiving core, an injury-prone running back room, a trash O-line, special teams, and defense. Very few athletes could do it and still play at the level Purdy has been.
This going market value for Qbs and Brock is better than half of the top ten paid Qbs!
Tanner Mordecai is the next Mr. relevant
Could bring Russell in as back up or Cousins is as back up
What makes you think Rogers, Cousins, Fields or any QB will play for $20 mil? Look at the going rate for starting QB. Unless you fully guarantee then you can’t get a lot anyway. At this point, I would love for niners to just cut him or trade him so he can play for a team with OL and WR that can separate. Probably beat the brakes off niners for years with those QBs.
Raj!
This AAV discussion is pointless. Even if Brock gets paid he will only be making around 20 million his first year and bumping up. It's all about how his contract is structured. If the Niners structure his deal like Jalen hurts, we will be able to modify the amount he will get paid in the future
Purdy is better than Jimmy G and Sam Darnold was there last year. Darnold is good because of being with us last year and a good system right now.
Sign Brock with a high guarantee and than resturcture it later.
😂 all these quarterbacks these analysts are praising best quarterbacks cause of strong arm but hasn’t done what brock has accomplished in two years
How old is cousins now?
Brock, you’re 4-2 in the playoffs. What have you done lately?
Take Mac Jones, cheap as a back up plan, if broc wants to hold out, let him, go with Jones not much if any drop off,until Broc sees the light. Can't have what what we've had every year with hold outs
Umm …Jimmy g also won a lot in the playoffs with this team but no team is gonna pay 💰 cause of that
Yes, he made a mistake, but come Krueg, we were not making playoffs too hurt. I have seen a lot of Qbs make mistakes, even Mahomes has made stupid throws. It is pressure on him from not playing well and trying to force the ball.
Deebo dropped a TD pass period it is not all on Brock!
I pay him 50-55 mil a year!
Kyle may get his dream!
Pay purdy y’all trippen we would have 4 wins with darnold . Purdy could’ve easily led us to playoffs this year if those division games didn’t go to shit at the last second. Russel Wilson bro 😂WTH are you smoking
The reason we lost SB is because of head coach!
I say if it doesn’t work out with purdy go and sign Justin fields to a 2 year deal plenty of arm strength and intangibles can run and put some players around him and see what he can do. And we save money on the back end not signing purdy
We dont need to trade for an old quarterback! Cousins is good but we need youth. Brock needs a good oline. Look what has happened to Mahomes this year. He has been sacked the most in his career. Now, he is hurt, and Chiefs are not going deep in playoffs. They have just been getting bye.
Larry needs to take the purdy blinders off. Hard to listen to
Beeping noise in the background was annoying
Get Cousin and draft some rookie QB for future, trade Purdy for 3-4 rounds. Pay Cousin $25 million a year. I’m a Brock fan he’s not worth $50 or $60 a year, he can’t play in the wet or snow then he’s just average QB not elite
If a QB can't move out of the pocket in 2025 they're toast, Brock is kidding himself. He's an injury prone one hit wonder.
Trade Brock to who Krueger? You keep saying this without naming your prospects. When was the last time you heard a NFL team interested on Brock? Maybe as a temp or qb2 but no one will pay 30+ million to have Brock. If he says no to the niners he has no future in the NFL
“Herbert has never won a playoff game”.. Larry STOP. Herbert is better than Purdy and every GM in the league is taking him over Brock. Your arguments are elementary
I haven’t watched any niners UA-cam media this year cause yall have lost your minds. Yall need to make less videos cause the quality and substance is gone. You’re constantly repeating yourselves which forces you all to have idiotic takes.
@Larry you keep saying about Brock's record in the playoffs being 4-2 but that's the teams record not his alone. Burrow & Jackson haven't had the best team in the NFL around them the previous 2 years. You put Burrow in the Niners team we would've won a SB already & some 🤷