Fiesta ST vs Abarth 500, which one should I keep?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2019
  • In this video, I need to decide which car am I going to keep, the Fiesta ST or the Fiat Abarth? I need your help to decide.
    Our Amazon Store: amzn.to/2Xfh2AN
    Tool Maniac: carsforpaul.krtra.com/t/pri3z...
    Our Merch Store: bit.ly/2Hy0465
  • Авто та транспорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 196

  • @haidersohail1649
    @haidersohail1649 4 роки тому +28

    Keep the Abarth. Such a capable and underrated vehicle. Quick, quirky and rapid. Also we know your long going love for the Abarth. So the ST should go. It’s an awesome car but I would keep the Abarth anyday. And now it has the amazing interior updates. It makes the Fiesta look really old inside now ahahah

  • @stevenjones19-m8i
    @stevenjones19-m8i 4 роки тому +5

    Hi Paul,I've put my vote in,I would keep the Abarth 500,the Fiesta to me is too chavvy in my opinion and everyone has them as a hot hatch,I do like the 500 myself and think they are a great car.Merry Xmas and New Year,all the best for 2020.

  • @Jordan-fs2ne
    @Jordan-fs2ne 4 роки тому +3

    Please keep the 500. Very interesting and inspiring me to take a look at them myself. Much more diverse content than the usual ST, Golf R ect. (Not that they aren't interesting, just 'the norm'). Good luck with your decision👍

  • @Ezekiel-of5so
    @Ezekiel-of5so 4 роки тому

    Really enjoyed tonight’s flog great show as always more please

  • @richardmounfield7822
    @richardmounfield7822 4 роки тому +8

    Sell them both before you get flashed by a camera lol. No seriously I would advertise them both and see which one sells first , sounds like they both have pros and cons from your view. I have always been like the moment they are all fixed up I get bored and want a new challenge I have voted and picked the right one according to the vote . Best wishes for Christmas and the new challenge project in the new year regards Rich

  • @LZDEN
    @LZDEN 4 роки тому

    merry xmas to you Paul and all of your family..and a very happy 2020 to you all...all the best my friend.

  • @johnmason3410
    @johnmason3410 4 роки тому +1

    I'm a fiesta st man so I love them and Ive loved watching the front end rebuild, the power from the st is enough for me to keep it over the arbarth

  • @katwells3755
    @katwells3755 4 роки тому

    Hey buddy just subscribed stay with the Abarth. Laddo on salvage rebuilds asked us to show some love here. So big hugs and look forward to watching your vids.😎

  • @ra52
    @ra52 4 роки тому +2

    In the car trade everything is for sale advertise both at a good profit. However you are more set on the abarth so you should do what makes you happy. Personally when I was at it full time I drove the cars I had in the process of fixing and selling so really do not need to keep as such a car as always have something to drive. Keep selling and getting profit and moving forwards. I did vote but base on what you like really it was clear in the video and you got to have things that make you smile and happy.

  • @GaryAlanCohen
    @GaryAlanCohen 4 роки тому

    Awesome channel, ta Paul!

  • @davec1704
    @davec1704 4 роки тому +2

    Keep the Abarth. Merry Christmas Paul & Family.

  • @chrisyoung5573
    @chrisyoung5573 4 роки тому +6

    Got to keep the one that makes you smile the most Paul. I worked for Fiat for 40 years and would never want to own a Fiat, i do own a Fiesta st and love it. It's different strokes for different folks

    • @rickhammond7867
      @rickhammond7867 4 роки тому +2

      Well I worked for Ford for 13 years an never would own a Fiesta an I own a Fiat an love it

    • @chrisyoung5573
      @chrisyoung5573 4 роки тому

      @@rickhammond7867 Congratulations fella, there is no right or wrong here, it's all about choice as i mentioned in my first post. There is nothing wrong with you liking Fiats, it's your choice but that does not follow that everybody should like Fiats. You have a good Christmas and try not to get too upset that not everyone wants to own a Fiat

  • @TITANICSI
    @TITANICSI 4 роки тому +4

    Much as I love Fords, I’d say keep the 500

  • @mariasnell6868
    @mariasnell6868 4 роки тому

    Before watching full video your face said it all whilst in the fiesta there was a but before you finished asking the question? Personally I’d keep the Abarth definitely more fun and makes you smile just on the approach. Merry Christmas to you and your family xx.

  • @chrisclegg3711
    @chrisclegg3711 4 роки тому

    I think you’re in a great position to sell both and work towards a car you would like to keep ,a car you’ve always wanted

  • @MrPabsUk
    @MrPabsUk 4 роки тому

    My brother has a 2012 Abarth 500C, he`s a driving instructor. It had done 240,000 miles & only suffered 1 breakdown (thermostat capillary pipe clip breaking, letting all the water out) which I fixed at the roadside. Its had a starter motor & 2 alternators, & a couple of sensors go, but none of them stopped the car, they all gave him warning & gave him days to find replacements. The heads never been off, its never leaked any oil, & there's still zero play in the turbo shaft (swapped the cat to a sports cat at about 190,000 miles, the old cat was like new inside, as was the turbo, with no oil contamination), The only reason he's stopped using it is because the insurance wrote it off after a light rear ender (they valued it low due to the mileage). He had it back from them & Its now sitting on his drive waiting for me to repair it. He`s now using his 1.2 500C `by Diesel` backup car to teach in. I even got one recently, a 2012 Twinair Gucci, & I get what your saying about the driving position, they do feel like your riding "on" them rather than being "in" them & that does detract from the driving experience slightly, especially compared to my old Fiat Uno`s & Seicento`s, which feel like go carts, but the 500 IS still fun & has a lot of character! It's hard to drive any Fiat without smiling!
    I`d keep the Fiat, but I`m obviously biased!

  • @JonnyFRS
    @JonnyFRS 4 роки тому

    A stage 2 st180 does not need the exhaust straight through, i would agree with you on the springs

  • @paulbull7924
    @paulbull7924 4 роки тому

    I would sell the Fiesta there are so many that are on UA-cam being done so I would keep abarth and do some upgrades that no one else is doing keep up the good work mate and merry Xmas to you and your family paul

  • @Katiebop89
    @Katiebop89 4 роки тому +2

    Fiesta all day. Best hot hatch of the 10's. My metal edition eats the fiat alive.

  • @billkhan6333
    @billkhan6333 4 роки тому

    Hi paul hope your keeping well, personally i think you sell the fiesta and keep the abarth i just love the overall look and quality of it.

  • @garrytierney6887
    @garrytierney6887 4 роки тому +4

    You should keep the 500 Abarth

  • @alanm9976
    @alanm9976 4 роки тому

    HI Paul, completely bias vote from me having a fiesta ST myself, i'd like to see where you can take it. Something to look at if not already done is the symposer delete, that could help reduce the booming when stepping on the gas.

  • @jake500s7
    @jake500s7 4 роки тому

    My 120 bhp two cylinder 500 is fun and when on 0.8 bar of boost even more fun especially for the power to weight ratio with the two cylinder engine

  • @capB1535
    @capB1535 4 роки тому +1

    Keep the Abarth and keep on smiling behind the wheel 👍

  • @riggs3.036
    @riggs3.036 3 роки тому

    I have no idea what you decided to do...... I have always been a VW guy, last car was a MK5 GTI, lowered, induction kit, remap milltek etc..... I have traded that in recently for what I never thought I would do... a Focus ST MK3! Its decat, cobra exhaust, induction kit and remapped so on about 280BHP ( my GTI was at 240)
    My partner owns an Abarth 135, standard wexecpt for a bluespark tuning box so its around 170 - 180 BHP... lovely to drive although basic, with m enow owning an ST rather than a German car and having driven the Abarth I would suggest getting rid of the ST and having a good play with the Abarth :)

  • @Philtomlinson85
    @Philtomlinson85 4 роки тому

    I would keep the st as I love them car hoping to get my self one soon 😁

  • @andy_v4443
    @andy_v4443 4 роки тому

    see if @bodgit and leggit wants the st, he likes a bit of BOOM, SORTED.merry Christmas paul to you and your family, and all the best for the new year

  • @scorcha100
    @scorcha100 4 роки тому +1

    Me I’m a Ford man being i work for them and you would expect me to be biased but.... the fiesta is as common as muck whereas the Abarth is a bit of a special edition car so personally i would say keep the Abarth and sell the fiesta. That Fiesta will make a boy racer very happy. No disrespect but and older guy in a boy racer car isn’t a good image. Keep up the good work and have a nice Christmas 👍🏾

  • @propertydev6042
    @propertydev6042 4 роки тому

    My opinion as I asked you in an earlier post if it was a keeper.. keep the fiat as that is where your heart is. That is important in making a great project car! ;-)

  • @leewescombe3812
    @leewescombe3812 4 роки тому +14

    Sell the fiesta too common

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      Did you vote?

    • @leewescombe3812
      @leewescombe3812 4 роки тому

      @Chris theres a lot of st content on UA-cam, this is one of the first abarths I've seen on here and in my opinion I'd like to see more content on it.

  • @wornoutgrafter9581
    @wornoutgrafter9581 4 роки тому

    Advertise them both first one to draw the cash will decide , difficult month coming up January usually quiet with credit card bills dropping through door after christmas spend .

  • @ASH.......................1976
    @ASH.......................1976 4 роки тому

    And maybe uprate the suspension on the fiat ,it's up to you,your the boss !😀

  • @markjohnson5964
    @markjohnson5964 4 роки тому

    Tough choice I have a fiesta st and love it. But I can see that the fiat is a great car as well I am a 51 year old so I am a old school boy racer then as I love how harsh the ride is and the noise the car makes. I would keep the fiesta as you have more boot space. But what you choose you can’t go wrong.

  • @benevans3733
    @benevans3733 4 роки тому

    Keep the st and merry Christmas to you

  • @bigmacsnoobselectronicsrep8032
    @bigmacsnoobselectronicsrep8032 4 роки тому

    Fantastic video Paul as always but I thought you said in a previous video that abarth was for your son mate I would keep it as much as I love ford I mean I’ve had nothing but fords for the last 20 years in my opinion keep the abarth mate but it’s got to be your decision and i think you went and got your r8 didn’t you hahahahaha keep up the great work mate

  • @markhopton1704
    @markhopton1704 4 роки тому +1

    Keep the Abarth. Merry Christmas.

  • @ASH.......................1976
    @ASH.......................1976 4 роки тому

    Put those wheels you said about on the fiat and definitely keep it !!😀 that fiesta is definitely a boy racer car ,but like nova SR, when I was younger ,I see them all over the place !

    • @Skiddins
      @Skiddins 4 роки тому

      Those were the days, people lusting after the SRi, which no-one could afford to insure, and drooling at the thought of an Astra GTE lol

  • @telboy1968
    @telboy1968 4 роки тому

    Keep the fiat, my neighbour used to own your st fiesta, merry Christmas and happy new year paul, all tge best

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      That will be Ricky then 👍

    • @telboy1968
      @telboy1968 4 роки тому

      Yes thats him, he bought another st the same as your one, didn’t even realise he had another car till i see his old car on your channel lol

  • @HatefulHola
    @HatefulHola 3 роки тому +1

    why not test the st against the 180 competizione, with performance pack? Bit more of a match up in every way, and still sound loads better. I've had both, Abarth wins out.

  • @citroenman
    @citroenman 4 роки тому +1

    Paul - to be honest keep the Fiat. Its a better looking car in a good spec. Don't see in my eyes that it needs to be modified but each to their own.

  • @LewisTDC
    @LewisTDC 4 роки тому

    The fiesta will work perfectly fine with any 2.75" and above exhaust with any variation of boxes/resonators, you could just buy a backbox and swap it out

  • @HH-zi5li
    @HH-zi5li 4 роки тому

    Keet the fiesta , way more videos and installs you can do

  • @alexspence6895
    @alexspence6895 4 роки тому

    hi paul . which car did you decide to keep and can you do a breakdown cost on the abarth . alex from manchester

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      kept the abarth and will do a breakdown in the near future

  • @danssalvagerebuilds6638
    @danssalvagerebuilds6638 4 роки тому

    If I had to make the decision it would come down to whichever one would bring in the most money that's how I would do it more wonga = more project's or a step closer to the R8. Both very capable and good looking car's I guess for you it's a hard decision. But if I had to pick one I'd keep the abarth.

  • @richardnorth5994
    @richardnorth5994 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth maybe a wrap and hybrid turbo. As many say Fords are so common and you've got love for the Fiat.

  • @TheMaccatakker69
    @TheMaccatakker69 4 роки тому

    Sounds like you've made your mid up Paul on the Abarth! I say get rid of them both and keep the channel fresh and churning new cars.

  • @michaelsmith-eb2yy
    @michaelsmith-eb2yy 4 роки тому

    you have already made your mind up.

  • @stugil1986
    @stugil1986 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth. The fiesta has run its course. You fixed it as you set out to do and its had its day. The Abarth will give us more content but to be honest I would rather see you get into fixing another one from scratch

  • @GG-im1cb
    @GG-im1cb 4 роки тому +1

    The Fiat is a fun little car, but the build quality is not comparable to the Ford, that said I’d change the exhaust, or have a resonator fitted into the existing exhaust, it won’t make any difference to the power

  • @claywalker9064
    @claywalker9064 4 роки тому

    Paul you are getting old mate - I personally would go for the Fiat - The noise from the Fiesta will drive you mad - it is doing so already. I wish you and your family a very happy and merry Christmas and a peaceful and prosperous New Year. Kind regards Clay.

  • @jeremybevan5946
    @jeremybevan5946 4 роки тому

    Paul I think that you should sell the fiesta but you do a lot of driving to your work and for safety the ford would come out on top.

  • @andrewkehoe9116
    @andrewkehoe9116 4 роки тому

    HELLO IAM 57 AND I OWN A FIESTA ST 150. NOW IAM LOOKING FOR AN ABARTH

  • @drinternatg6391
    @drinternatg6391 4 роки тому

    I would keep the Fiesta and change the exhaust back to standard, I feel it would be a safer car in the event of an accident. Just saying!

  • @colinstevenson9419
    @colinstevenson9419 4 роки тому +1

    Your smiliing more with the Abarth, so keep smiling. Merry Christmas

  • @Lizzard-t
    @Lizzard-t 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth. The Italians know how to build a pocket rocket , it looks the part both inside and out .Ive never been fond of fords because it seems you see those everywhere and everyone has one .
    I've had a fiat 500 , and I miss it was just so much fun !

  • @Mantuxs87
    @Mantuxs87 4 роки тому

    I can bet that you keep abath!👍😉

  • @Love500
    @Love500 4 роки тому

    You know what I voted. Abarth all day long. I’m looking for a new one now but it has to be a facelift.

  • @THEQUINNEY
    @THEQUINNEY 4 роки тому

    Merry Christmas Paul you don’t need me to tell you wot to keep Fiat as everyone loves the Fiat just get more pop’s and bangs out of it 😂🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻🎅🏻👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @vulpsturm
    @vulpsturm 2 роки тому

    You should keep both and.. ummm... keep both.. and... oh you'll figure it out!

  • @cormackable
    @cormackable 4 роки тому

    What was the website you used to work out the part numbers for repairing the wing on t e fiesta ?

  • @jonricketts2408
    @jonricketts2408 4 роки тому

    Keep the car that makes you feel good when you drive it Paul I’d keep the Arbath much nicer car and would suit you more than the Fiesta

  • @nigelstrarup
    @nigelstrarup 4 роки тому +1

    Well I wold get red off both off them and start to do the new one nigel

  • @gioforeal
    @gioforeal Рік тому

    Abarth 4 life!👏🏾💯😎

  • @CarlsModsClass
    @CarlsModsClass 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abath such alot more to come out of that little car

  • @healthylifecircle2801
    @healthylifecircle2801 4 роки тому

    Abarth is good but ST for me..lot.fun to drive.

  • @Somebody_1337
    @Somebody_1337 4 роки тому

    If I were you I would sell fiesta, finish garage project and then sell abarth, ooor advertise both cars and sell whichever get sold first as you said categorised cars sell longer, so this might help you a bit.

  • @puggster
    @puggster 2 роки тому

    Abarth all the way, not because its better, but you dont see as many on the roads, ST's are usually Boy racers first choice so have a huge stigma, as a chavs car, plus there all over the place 😅 lol, I got the Abarth after much self debate on the fiesta St line eco boost, but there not all that unique, plus the abarth has some charm and you feel it every time you drive it, problems just melt away. 🙃

  • @abrael333
    @abrael333 4 роки тому

    how much do you want for the fiesta?

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      email me at paul@carsforpaul.co.uk

  • @bmwman1981
    @bmwman1981 4 роки тому +1

    Keep the fiat the fiesta is old hat and nearly everyone on the road is owned by a 19 year old .The fiats got rarity going for it and it’s probably faster then the st which isn’t anything special

  • @smart3k
    @smart3k 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth, not enough of them on UA-cam. Seen enough ST's sick to death of em!

    • @smart3k
      @smart3k 4 роки тому

      Get the Abarth up to 180/190bhp and they feel savage

  • @hoffmanlol
    @hoffmanlol 4 роки тому

    Normally i would say keep the fiesta and get rid of the fiat
    However in this case i personally dont like how heavily damaged the fiesta was and that plays on my mind if i were to keep it. The fiat looks lovely and wasnt smashed to bits. Just my opinion

  • @Nas4real
    @Nas4real 4 роки тому

    Do you have traders insurance or multi car policy?

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      multi car, works better for me.

  • @connorladelldzz6754
    @connorladelldzz6754 4 роки тому

    I think you've answered your own question. Power isn't everything. The 500 you can build the way you want it with the parts you want. It's a blank canvas. The St is already done. Keep the 500 and make it yours they way you want.

  • @alexdalgleish1061
    @alexdalgleish1061 4 роки тому

    Neither am afraid. Try What Car? Leasing site for price on Kia Picanto 1.0T GT Line S in metallic grey on a PCP. £165 month?! Mega spec, heated seats, wheel, climate, cruise, Nav?! DAB, Smartphone wireless charging. 99k mile warranty. Have 3 years then get another one. 👌 Secondhand 1.2's in this spec getting cheaper used.

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      Am trying to get away from PCP's having been paying for PCP's for the past 12 years

  • @robp8218
    @robp8218 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth, it's got more character than the Ford. Granted, it's not as fast, but with a few mods, I'm sure that could be addressed. The suspension and the exhaust would do my nut in on the Ford too.

  • @nickrendell4300
    @nickrendell4300 4 роки тому

    Both great cars but if you want the power then keep the ST, but if you like the fun factor then keep the ABARTH.

  • @neilsessions9744
    @neilsessions9744 4 роки тому

    If you sell the fiesta ,you need the get the welding put right before someone drives it

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому

      The welding has already been put right by a bodyshop

    • @neilsessions9744
      @neilsessions9744 4 роки тому

      fab paul ,keep the st then ,the fiats are a bit tinny I found

  • @danieldoherty919
    @danieldoherty919 4 роки тому

    Dagenham Dustbin must go keep the Abarth ☃️🛠☃️

  • @paultaylor9652
    @paultaylor9652 4 роки тому

    If it were me I would have the Fiesta and change the exhaust. But for the people on here the Fiat, less common.

  • @chrisrickett1
    @chrisrickett1 4 роки тому

    I like the look of the abarth but I'm always a Ford guy keep the fiesta st

  • @sydmichel
    @sydmichel 4 роки тому

    keep the fiat but I hate the front grill. can you do something with it?

  • @leeopenshaw9302
    @leeopenshaw9302 4 роки тому +2

    Abarth 100%

  • @ozboz33
    @ozboz33 4 роки тому

    I think different age groups will choose one over the other. The Ford is more of a young uns motor,unless you sorted the suspension and exhaust to your liking. The abarth is different and quirky . I do not see as many abarth's and I think you like the fiat more,as you fitted the new android system and digital clocks. Keep the fiesta if do the changes,if not stick with the abarth

  • @NorthOntarian
    @NorthOntarian 4 роки тому

    Keep the abarth for the fun factor.....full disclosure I'm biased just got a used canadian abarth (160hp) a few months ago.

  • @wizardzx2
    @wizardzx2 4 роки тому

    Advertise both. Whichever gives more profit!

  • @r46ful
    @r46ful 4 роки тому

    abarth is more special to me then fiesta. I flip st an mod abarth alongside project 2020..

  • @mattybates78
    @mattybates78 4 роки тому

    Keep the ST put standard springs on and sort the back box out you don't need it removed for stage 2, I'm a bit biased but try filling the 500 with IKEA furniture or an engine and gearbox and still having a laugh on the way home 😉😂

    • @CarsForPaul
      @CarsForPaul  4 роки тому +1

      Lol, nice one

    • @mattybates78
      @mattybates78 4 роки тому

      @@CarsForPaul i've got a set of standard springs you can have for free if you pay the postage,only did 1000 miles before i lowered my old st...so they're like brand new.

  • @everydaysalvage
    @everydaysalvage 4 роки тому +1

    Abarth 🥰

  • @Housie40
    @Housie40 4 роки тому

    Keep the abarth! The personality alone is worth the keep

  • @davidjob7332
    @davidjob7332 4 роки тому +2

    Abarth for me Paul, much more stylish and very different, don't see them around every corner 👍👍👍

  • @Aidan-LM02
    @Aidan-LM02 4 роки тому +1

    Get rid of the abath not spacious uncomfortable keep the Ford you have the reliability put the stock exhaust back on and put a little higher and softish on it and the fiesta is more spacious and comfortable and put the stage 1 tune on and put the newer steering wheel on and out of the 2 the fiesta is way better you get the reliability compared to the Italian reliability and plus the abaths exhaust sounds like a fart box

  • @ASH.......................1976
    @ASH.......................1976 4 роки тому

    I couldn't see the voting thing !!,anyway you know what I think !

  • @antschiari8000
    @antschiari8000 4 роки тому

    I’ve had both and the Fiesta is just so much better... I really wanted the Fiat to be better...

  • @jamessbarrett5260
    @jamessbarrett5260 4 роки тому +6

    Abarth all the way

  • @SeriousAboutSalvage
    @SeriousAboutSalvage 4 роки тому +6

    Fiat abarth all day long

  • @MrSausageT
    @MrSausageT 4 роки тому

    Sell the one that’s worth the most, so you can put it towards the next one😀

  • @steverichmond3903
    @steverichmond3903 4 роки тому

    How do you vote Paul?

  • @makavelimotorsport6165
    @makavelimotorsport6165 4 роки тому

    Keep the Fiat,I think the new car is German Paul and a summer cruiser?

  • @steverichmond3903
    @steverichmond3903 4 роки тому +1

    Keep The Abarth Paul, It has way more class, no disrespect but the Fiesta just screams boy racer mate.

  • @domellis5830
    @domellis5830 4 роки тому

    Keep the Abarth!