Pulling the product to fix it is definitely impressive. And as others have pointed out $699 makes it super tempting. And as always, thanks for the review, Ross!
Lots of PLA filaments fail by becoming brittle over time and this concerns me with this style of printer filament holder to hotend path. The older filament doesn't break straight away as it comes off the reel. It takes up to an hour of being straightened before it snaps. We have seen this behaviour on many filament brands. As you print, this isn't an issue as it moves through the tube quick enough but after the print concludes, it breaks into sections within the tube as it sits there. Clearing all of the broken bits in the tube becomes a real hassle as you can't just print hoping the filament will push the broken parts through it as each broken end bit curls and jams occur in the tube. The filament handling (especially mounting the reel on the back of a very heavy printer) seems to be an after thought. Many people are moving the filament holder to the side or top, but that just increases the length of the delivery tube as the runout sensor is still on the back. I have two of these printers arriving soon and am already thinking about how to move the filament holder, the runout sensor and the usb plug to around or near the front.
Thanks for the good reviews.. Your review to the QIDI Tech X-Plus 3, along with several others has sold me on the printer and QIDI's excellent service. Good review my friend. Thanks again.
Great review and like you said when a company listens and then comes back with a better built unit they deserve much respect. As for that filament spool being placed in the rear that's a killer. But you placing it in that Eibos filament dryer was a great alternate solution. Happy printing.
Good on you for having the integrity to pull the old video to avoid accidental misinformation even though you had to spend hours editing it and such im sure. I don't completely agree with your take on ACF based on my own testing but your integrity cannot be denied good sir.
i have 2 X-MAX 3 i print PAHT-CF, TPU95, PET-CF, PET-GA and PLA all qidi filament and these just always work really a great printing company beign overshadowed
Well, that's useful - I've just bought a P1S because my Neptune 4 broke its extruder and I'm _still_ waiting for Elegoo to accept that (they keep insisting it's an electronics problem and sending me pointless component replacements). While I'm generally happy with the operation of the P1S, it's got a few annoyances that would be solved by _not_ having a closed ecosystem; Klipper is the one advantage the Neptune 4 had over the P1S. QIDI Tech have just gone from being "meh, low-quality generic crap" to "genuine contender", so next time I'm in the market for a printer...they're going to be up there on the list. Great video!
Still using the first version of this printer and I haven't really had any of the known issues with it. Flexing due to heat has never caused my z offset to change and first layers always go down smooth. During one of the earlier updates the printer completely bricked itself to the point that the EMMC being replaced wouldn't even fix it. Got the latest version of the motherboard instlled today and it's working perfectly. Also for anyone who has one of these give Orca Slicer a try - it's basically Bambu Slicer which is basically Prusa Slicer but the configuration for the Qidi printers is built right in.
I have an x-plus 2 and I'm really impressed by qidi support. They even provided an stl to print a cooling fan for my high temp hotend. So I dont have to remove it from the regular one when i switch hotends.
Following up with my last comment, I ended up buying the Max 3 and I couldn't be happier honestly. It just works beautifully, is sooo fast, and has just been a dream thus far. Highly recommend. I'm considering getting rid of my Ender-5 S1 and replacing it with a second Qidi X-Max 3. Absolutely love the size/volume too.
Good on them as a company. Honestly. I love seeing companies take feedback seriously and try to make it up to the first backers, reviewers, and just the community as a whole. If more did this -we'd have less crappy clones and much better hardware all around.
Good review and worth considering. One thing that bothers me for every electronic device I have has the power switch on the front. I noticed the power switch with the X plus 3 is on the back. They need to put it on the front or someone needs to do a DIY fix to remotely locate the power switch on the front. thanks for posting
The best review ever seen, above all for the honesty in describing the real problems found in this printer which at first glance really seems like a very valid competitor of Bambu Labs, but which reviewers often do not specify fully. I discovered this printer and for 700 euros it seems really impressive, above all the seriousness of the manufacturing company is important, ready to correct defects and malfunctions. The fact that they replaced the slicer with a customized version of Prusa Slicer (I have been using it for some time and consider it the best ABSOLUTE) demonstrates a truly rare attention towards the end customer, congratulations for the way of reviewing, I hope it will always be like this. Registration successful.
I've bought the qidi xplus 1 xmax 1 xplus 2 and now the xmax 3 and will stand behind their customer service. You have a problem and they fix it, no bs, no fees, no shipping charges etc.
I agree it is a fine printer and were Bamboo's multi colour/material features not available then I would be pulling the trigger on this, however, I am not buying an AMS equipped Bamboo Lab printer because I am hoping that Bamboo Lab will release a toolchanger printer to compete with the XL. I was thinking the other day how awesome twin AMS units would be with an IDEX printer as this could reduce the wastage of multi colour prints.
I have had my Bambu Lab P1P for a little over a year and a half and it's given me zero problems. Absolutely none. I can slice a file, send it, and forget about it. But, given I haven't gotten around to enclosing my P1p, some filaments are more challenging to print with....and these are the filaments I use the most (PC, ABS, PA-12CF) So,after a lot of consideration I bought an X-Plus 3 about a month ago. I am starting to have buyers remorse. I'm having stock Creality 3 flashbacks on a regular basis. I forgot what a pain it was to use a little piece of paper to set the Z height and have to set the bed on a regular basis. If I had to do it again I wouldn't buy it. I'd either deal with the snails pace or my MakerBot Method or start saving for the new X1 with the heated chamber!
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf honestly, I think the Bambu Lab will give you better all around finished prints. I do a lot of printing with PC and I really appreciate the heated chamber on the X-PLUS 3, it makes it a little easier to print PC, ABS/ ASA, and Polypropylene, but I can also get quality prints with those filaments on my P1P. I've had my P1P for 18 months now and my X-Plus 3 for about 6, and while I like the Qidi I really wish I would have gotten a second Bambu Lab instead. It just makes it easy to get good prints
Would you compare this to the K1 or K1 Max? The build late is in the middle of the two, but the specs seem amazing - heated chamber, included dehumidifier, which feels like it’d be super useful for flex PLA or similar, and £150 cheaper than the K1 Max.
Mine came in yesterday, and I've thrown some test prints at it and compared to my Lulzbot Taz5 from 2014, and this has been a very pleasant experience. I didn't get reasonable prints off my Taz5 until I threw out the factory hotend and extruder (almost a year after purchase). It feels much better today, getting a printer that can be as close to plug-and-play as you can get in this hobby. Great update.
I also have a TAZ6, actually 2 of them. I now use 2 different nozzles but I do, periodically use the original BUT I rebuilt it to TAZ 8 architecture. I build a E3D toolhead so I can use 1.75mm filament with a .4mm nozzle. And I built a great toolhead for very quick prototypes, a 1.2mm nozzle using the 2.85mm filament a MoarStruder. It's a really cool toolhead and on parts that require no real definition it's awesome. I also run it at 140% speed so it's not all that slow. I use CURA not the Lulzbot version of CURA. I keep the CURA print speed at 50mm/s but on the LULZBOT LCD I change the speed, after the first layer, to 140%. You do have to adjust E-steps and calculate them so you have to make sure you do that and I have to do it for each of the 3 different toolheads so I right them down. If you screw that up you can cause a filament jam and these toolheads are a bit of a pain to clear the jams, heatgun is ABSOLUTELY needed. My best machine, and I have 10, if the Luluzbot but I do not have, yet, any Bambu, Ankermaker, or QIDI. If I get one of them I will have to watch multiple comparative reviews. This review was excellent. By the way, 7 of my 10 printers I got on eBay "as is, for parts only". I fixed them all. The 2 TAZ 5s I got, wow, the previous owners misaligned the frames, miswired them so the fans didn't work and the z and y rails moved together, the supports for the rails were installed incorrectly, what a mess. One of them took me 10hrs to fix but both now work great. I did replace the PEI on one with a flexible bed, the other I retained the PEI.
I can agree with you! I have mind since around a week now and already played around with the settings a bit. What I found out was that they set their extrusion multiplier to 95% instead of 100%, which made my prints better! And don‘t hesitate too adjust your pressure advance and smoothing time to lower levels. At these high speeds their preset smoothing time has to be shorter and their pa-value can be calibrated using some online research.
Enjoyed the video greatly. Fun question... if you found yourself in a situation where you only had access to 1 Sub-1000$ printer for a month, what would you choose?
What is the part availability like in the UK for Qidi products ? I have a older Qidi Xplus which has most proprietary parts zero parts are available here in Australia - paying air freight shipping from china adds up Seems Qidi have now removed the support information for the older models from their web page ?
A huge thank you for the review, finally a company whom decides to take action in order to improve their product + deliver what claim. Great review, I’m going to look into this one some more as it has pretty much all I’m looking for. Bambu has been doing great and all , but damn, the amount of waste for multi color is significant. Thx again!
I have the same printer, is there a correct way to shut down the printer? Or do you just turn off from the main power button that lies on the back next to the power cord?
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf Yes still strange things...might be because of updated firmware. My printer got clogged now and I bought new extruder...stil same result. Printing in PLA and the only solution was to increase temp 210 to 240 degrees. And that's make me wonder if the firmware use wrong temperature. I tried different brand of filament and stil same result
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf Recommend bambu lab or flash forge...think you get less headache with those. X-max 3 seems to also be a bit of a disaster 😑 Saw one review that was really good but the guy took it back 1 month later...he had hard time to get that work good 😑
Printing speed isnt just how fast the hotend can move around, it is also how fast it can melt plastic. How strong the extruder is and how well it can deal with back pressure. Would be good to see how fast it can do a benchmark print like the benchy
Looks cheap, but all of the specs way above K1, just missing camera. But focusing on industrial/business printing that can’t be exposed to the cloud, bigger print volume, hotter nozzle, hotter bed, and heated chamber. Market is slowly getting saturated and good for everyone.
@@RathOX its closed source, but hey did you see majority of useless upgrades in k1 majority are useless and then if its usefull its a mod that fixes manufacturers errors, i have k1 and max both have terrible engineering solutions in good few places, and if you go by facebook groups there are alot more whining in creality k1 groups than p1/ x1c groups…..
Huge freaking probs to qiditech... Taking it off sale.. fix it . And relaunch . Thats a big example for most companies.. Also carbon to hardened steel is good! U lose a LITTLE speed, but u get a big bump in reliability and can probably even replace bearings on it!
I give them the respect for being the only company outside of stratasys and MakerBot using a fundamental technology that's been known since I think the early 90a but their extruders still suck almost as much h as their name. I supposed they were build in the qidi-pa-town.
Can the printer actually last constantly printing at a 65C chamber temp? On the marketing they say 65C but then they seem to limit the temp in the slicer to 60C and they have a warning on the printer itself saying don't go beyond 50 or 55C
huh, well good on them for pulling it, and released a fixed/updated one, sadly its price point puts it mostly out of my budget, but i'll keep an eye on qidi now, that kind of commitment to making things right is danged rare it feels like, these days
Its price point is actually pretty reasonable, if you compare it against the machines they're marketing it against, like the Bambu, Prusa or Creality K1 series. I get it that its currently out of your budget, but it's sort of akin to someone driving a Ford saying the BMW is out of their budget... you're not their target market.
@@ndcollins yeah, i didnt mean to imply it was overpriced or anything! it appears to be fantastically priced for an FDM printer at the (amazing) resolution it appears to print at, and its very much something that, should my finances improve (or i finally sell off some of the pile of oop minis, boxes, etc on ebay), i will very much be taking a hard look it
Great video- thanks for pointing out the how the spool is loaded. I think this will make it a pass for me. Aside from that, it is great for the 3D printing community when a manufacturer takes criticism and adjusts.
Thx for this nice and informativ video. Im on the way to buy this one or a Creality K1. On a old QidiTech X-Plus 3 review, thre was also a lot of mechanical problems under the Printer. everithing is hold by plastic , and screws are fixed only in a plastic I mean. normal is metal screw in metal tube and this is glued in plastik. On the old version it was metalscrew direct in plastik. and this hold not a long time. Is this now fixed?
My XPlus 3 arrived today so I can answer this for you. Aside from the outer shell plastic, everything in the base of the main box frame is now metal, and has an added thick metal bracing bar that runs left to right in the middle bottom of the frame. Basically it's a full metal frame internally with a plastic outer shell for the enclosure.
as there is no direct sales by bambu in my country, official retailer sells p1p in 800$..I would rather take this , as it's price are same or lower than P1P including tax, import.. etc.
Much like with the Creality K1, I don't get the whole thing with putting the filament on the back. Who doesn't put their 3D printers with the back towards the wall? I guess if you have your printers in a freestanding rack or on a table it might work, but as-is, that one particular aspect is really a deal breaker for me. Especially when you can get something like a Bambu Labs P1S with the AMS for a few hundred Euro more and have built-in multi-material printing, while loading all the filament spools easily accessible on the top.
Well the other option is listening to me and staring at a blank screen. I don't have the setup or space for talking head moments, so until i do. this is what you'll get.
Buy the QIDI Tech X-PLUS 3 Here: shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=2395089&u=3060349&m=130069&urllink=&afftrack= Original Video - ua-cam.com/video/TMzvTFgXGUI/v-deo.html
@@leanja6926 affiliate links are always up before the reviews? It’s the only way to earn on this platform. Or should I let 5000 people watch it before I post the link? I don’t really understand the complaint?
@@leanja6926 I don’t even know how to respond to that. If people click the link and buy, then later find out it’s a negative review. That’s on them. This review has been online for nearly a week for my channel members. They’ve seen the video and the link is fir them. Where do you get off telling me what my Job is? My job isn’t even to tell you if it’s a good printer or not. Have you seen my other videos. Have I ever given a printer a score? I’m here to tell you how they work so you can make a decision for yourself. If you haven’t watched the review. Don’t click the link… is that easy. You are literally complaining at me for being prepared for a video to launch…
@@leanja6926 yeah, I'm just gonna choose to ignore you going forward. An affiliate link is not an endorsement, it;s posted on every video I've made, even when the reviews have not been positive. I'm not going to change it, if you wnat to read it as an endorsement, go ahead. I'm confident enough that you're in the minority, and you are getting hung up over such a petty thing where you have cosen to interpret preperation of a video in a specific way.
@@FauxHammer A skill that I've been trying hard to learn lately is to not take personal offense with people's comments and to try to let negativity just slide off and focus on the positive. In this instance, it probably would've been far better to simply ignore @leanja6926's first comment, as most everyone else would have. Instead people like me who are first timers to your channel are met with this fairly acrimonious exchange before the video has even started. Ignore the haters. The world's full of them and fighting with every one of them is just going to be exhausting, not to mention possibly drive potential subscribers away. Just my 2c.
@@stew675 No that's a fair comment to make, and yeah I should rise above it. but i have a long histor of calling people out when they make daft comments. especially when they seem to have some crazy idea of what my responsibilities are as a reviewer. I have some of course. they are to share my honest opinions with you all in videos. And I'm quite proud of the reputation I've grown in that regard. But when it comes to when and where I share affiliate links. that;s my call. My viewers have a responsibility to not blame me if they click it and buy it before watching my review. Besides. The wait time is literally only a few hours. I do aim to engage with my audience, no matter the comments. Many other viewers would enjoy my blatant openness in calling out daft comments like this for what they are. Apologies if your first impression is a neagtive one. please continue to watch and you'll soon see that this fits with my character.
Hey gutes Video. Es sieht für mich so aus als wäre der druckkopf vom xplus 3 etwas andres als der vom xmax 3. Mein letztes Wissen ist das der xmax 3 einen Bl Touch verbaut hat und der xplus 3 nicht ?
They sell mostly on Amazon do they not ? maybe the fear of them all being returned was a driving force to pulling them Really wonder was qidis game is, they've been around for years yet still a minor players really ? - Is qidi brand a side hustle for a factory that assembles for other entities There early model was basically a clone of flashforge which was basically a clone of Makerbot Replicator - as were many in that era
I have had my X-Plus 3 for six weeks now, after giving away my older X Plus. I'm now wishing I had kept the older model. Issues with my X-Plus 3 are numerous, reliability and print quality being the top issues. Also, after homing the system and I jog the table to the top, the "ZERO" position is actually about 1.5mm from the nozzle tip. Sometimes, when I jog it to the top, the Z axis will shut off when it's within 10mm, which results in the table drifting to the bottom. Other issues, NO fail-safe sensors to stop a inaccurately homed table from crashing into the nozzle or into the frame at the bottom. To top it off, there is virtually no documentation beyond a very basic quick start guide. Finally, the older X Plus made noticeably better parts. If all you are going to make are low resolution parts (over .2mm per layer) then you might be okay with this machine. I have YET to make a .16mm layer part that isn't a huge FAIL! And this is from PLA. I'm not even going to try it with ABS or something else. IMO, the firmware on this machine needs work. When selecting parts to make from their thumb drive, the user interface NEVER displays the part on the first try. I have to make multiple tries (as in over 5 tries) before the user interface will display the part. Update: I HATE this piece of crap! My two year old X Plus was slower but at least it WORKED. I loaded their new firmware (per their suggestion), and it now causes the extruder assy to crash into the finished part, with the last crash resulting in the extruder cover being knocked off. There are only two possibilities, either their firmware is crap or their slicer is crap. This system is beta at best and should have never been released for sale.
It's baffling why qidi clings on to an obsolete manual offset and probing system, when the rest of the competition has moved on to completely automatic nozzle probing - bambu, prusa, and even creality.
I bought one of the first ones. They sent parts from China to texas in 4 days, answered every question along with firmware and tech to troubleshoot shoot it, AND then sent me a new printer free of charge and let me keep the old one. I’ve bought new cars that sat in the shop for months, was given a sub par rental, and still didn’t get what I payed for. Qidi didn’t give me any run around or hassle. They were very honest and went beyond anything I could have asked for. They also gave refunds to people that wanted to move on. If anything maybe this has woke up some of the competition on how to handle warranties and claims. I would buy this printer again it’s so good.
Pulling the printer isn't really that impressive considering it never worked. They would have just had to refund everyone anyway. So save the praise for what they decide to do rather than what they needed to do.
If you're buying a Quidi over a P1P...I don't know what to tell you, I'm also sick of paying to be a Beta Tester for these companies...Well done to Qidi for finding out how to fix their own machine. Elegoo & Bambu Labs are just dominating with every machine they bring out ( Possibly Prusa with a pricing & logistics improvement) once Bambu Labs bring out X1E in the next few months, I don't think any of these copycats will have a hope in hell.
One rather obvious retort would be: "If you're okay with giving up privacy, control over intellectual property and compromising your network security just to be able to participate in a closed ecosystem, then I don't know what to tell you". Edit: Check out the Nathan Builds Robots video about this topic. At the end of the day, not everyone wants to agree to the BambuLabs ToS and it's good to have viable similarly performing alternatives.
@@stew675 im really worried about Bambu Labs stealing my baby yoda stl file. @stew65 by the way the illuminati are watching your house and have your phones bugged...
@@stew675 Have you read prusa ToS or creality ToS, elegoo ToS or(..._you get the idea. Its a boilerplate TOS they ALL use. Prusa will keep your data for 10 years AND they will share it with 3rd parties. Are you ok with that? Use Prusa slicer/ Cura slic3r same deal. Lawyers write them up so they wont get sued and every company has similar wording so lets stop pretending bambu is doing something new or nefarious. NBR is a sensationalist and preys in low information folks. Go read the TOS yourself if you dont believe me. You can even do a quick search through the eula and tos for "third party", "data". NBR and 3dmusk does the same thing. You are just feeding their algo for clicks.
This printer works perfectly for me. Have you saved material or found old filament in the basement or are you too stupid for 3D printing??? Well, you can unpack... at least something.
@@FauxHammer Sorry !! Feel free to delete my thread again. I must have had a bad day and let you become my victim. I like the Qidi's, even if there were problems at the beginning. Especially since Qidi offers an extremely competent and reliable service that many manufacturers can learn from. My mistake!
This is a nice video pointing out the several key improvements that make the current versions of the X-Plus 3 and its smaller and larger siblings very good printers and very reasonable prices. But how can someone be this into 3D printers and then "have no idea" why Qidi changed from carbon fiber to hollow steel rails??? Really? No idea at all? FH says he watched Clough42's review of the revised printers and certainly James (Clough42) made quite clear, as have most other reviewers that the change was made because the CF rods were critical wear items that could not be replaced. Even Qidi's marketing materials make clear the benefits of the hollow steel guide rods. I just don't get it...
I understand things to 100% or not at all. I don't get how carbon rods are irreplaceable yet steel is… I know this is the reason they were replaced, but other than quoting that same line, I don't get why carbon is irreplaceable. But honestly, I don't care enough to find out unless we see this more
It is admirable that Qidi pulled the unit and improved it. Well-done! It's the sort of thing that builds brand loyalty.
... and good reputation. Far too rare approach by so many companies these days, that seem to only see the value of short term revenues in their eyes.
Pulling the product to fix it is definitely impressive. And as others have pointed out $699 makes it super tempting. And as always, thanks for the review, Ross!
There's an active coupon code found with just a quick Google search that will knock another $50 off the price.
Lots of PLA filaments fail by becoming brittle over time and this concerns me with this style of printer filament holder to hotend path. The older filament doesn't break straight away as it comes off the reel. It takes up to an hour of being straightened before it snaps. We have seen this behaviour on many filament brands. As you print, this isn't an issue as it moves through the tube quick enough but after the print concludes, it breaks into sections within the tube as it sits there. Clearing all of the broken bits in the tube becomes a real hassle as you can't just print hoping the filament will push the broken parts through it as each broken end bit curls and jams occur in the tube.
The filament handling (especially mounting the reel on the back of a very heavy printer) seems to be an after thought. Many people are moving the filament holder to the side or top, but that just increases the length of the delivery tube as the runout sensor is still on the back. I have two of these printers arriving soon and am already thinking about how to move the filament holder, the runout sensor and the usb plug to around or near the front.
Thanks for the good reviews.. Your review to the QIDI Tech X-Plus 3, along with several others has sold me on the printer and QIDI's excellent service. Good review my friend. Thanks again.
Great review and like you said when a company listens and then comes back with a better built unit they deserve much respect. As for that filament spool being placed in the rear that's a killer. But you placing it in that Eibos filament dryer was a great alternate solution. Happy printing.
Good on you for having the integrity to pull the old video to avoid accidental misinformation even though you had to spend hours editing it and such im sure. I don't completely agree with your take on ACF based on my own testing but your integrity cannot be denied good sir.
i have 2 X-MAX 3 i print PAHT-CF, TPU95, PET-CF, PET-GA
and PLA all qidi filament and these just always work really a great printing company beign overshadowed
agreed, so many companies are selling shit printers off their popular brand name, and here we have an amazing printer that is completely unknown.
Well, that's useful - I've just bought a P1S because my Neptune 4 broke its extruder and I'm _still_ waiting for Elegoo to accept that (they keep insisting it's an electronics problem and sending me pointless component replacements). While I'm generally happy with the operation of the P1S, it's got a few annoyances that would be solved by _not_ having a closed ecosystem; Klipper is the one advantage the Neptune 4 had over the P1S.
QIDI Tech have just gone from being "meh, low-quality generic crap" to "genuine contender", so next time I'm in the market for a printer...they're going to be up there on the list. Great video!
Still using the first version of this printer and I haven't really had any of the known issues with it. Flexing due to heat has never caused my z offset to change and first layers always go down smooth.
During one of the earlier updates the printer completely bricked itself to the point that the EMMC being replaced wouldn't even fix it. Got the latest version of the motherboard instlled today and it's working perfectly. Also for anyone who has one of these give Orca Slicer a try - it's basically Bambu Slicer which is basically Prusa Slicer but the configuration for the Qidi printers is built right in.
I got mine a few days ago. It's been running non stop since. Printing a Mecha King Kong at 200%. Cause I can. lol.
Their current printer lineup seems awesome. The X-Smart3 being only $300 for the features is crazy! Totally slept on.
Yeah, totalky
You print with ASA or ABS and use Acetone smoothing with a 0.12 layer height and you will get prints every bit as smooth as resin.
I have an x-plus 2 and I'm really impressed by qidi support. They even provided an stl to print a cooling fan for my high temp hotend. So I dont have to remove it from the regular one when i switch hotends.
could i get that stl?
Thank you so much for this review. I think I'm going to buy the latest Qidi printer now, especially because of their support.
Following up with my last comment, I ended up buying the Max 3 and I couldn't be happier honestly. It just works beautifully, is sooo fast, and has just been a dream thus far. Highly recommend. I'm considering getting rid of my Ender-5 S1 and replacing it with a second Qidi X-Max 3. Absolutely love the size/volume too.
Good on them as a company. Honestly. I love seeing companies take feedback seriously and try to make it up to the first backers, reviewers, and just the community as a whole. If more did this -we'd have less crappy clones and much better hardware all around.
Oh I hear you loud and clear!
Good review and worth considering. One thing that bothers me for every electronic device I have has the power switch on the front. I noticed the power switch with the X plus 3 is on the back. They need to put it on the front or someone needs to do a DIY fix to remotely locate the power switch on the front. thanks for posting
The best review ever seen, above all for the honesty in describing the real problems found in this printer which at first glance really seems like a very valid competitor of Bambu Labs, but which reviewers often do not specify fully. I discovered this printer and for 700 euros it seems really impressive, above all the seriousness of the manufacturing company is important, ready to correct defects and malfunctions. The fact that they replaced the slicer with a customized version of Prusa Slicer (I have been using it for some time and consider it the best ABSOLUTE) demonstrates a truly rare attention towards the end customer, congratulations for the way of reviewing, I hope it will always be like this. Registration successful.
I've bought the qidi xplus 1 xmax 1 xplus 2 and now the xmax 3 and will stand behind their customer service. You have a problem and they fix it, no bs, no fees, no shipping charges etc.
I agree it is a fine printer and were Bamboo's multi colour/material features not available then I would be pulling the trigger on this, however, I am not buying an AMS equipped Bamboo Lab printer because I am hoping that Bamboo Lab will release a toolchanger printer to compete with the XL.
I was thinking the other day how awesome twin AMS units would be with an IDEX printer as this could reduce the wastage of multi colour prints.
I have had my Bambu Lab P1P for a little over a year and a half and it's given me zero problems. Absolutely none. I can slice a file, send it, and forget about it.
But, given I haven't gotten around to enclosing my P1p, some filaments are more challenging to print with....and these are the filaments I use the most (PC, ABS, PA-12CF) So,after a lot of consideration I bought an X-Plus 3 about a month ago. I am starting to have buyers remorse. I'm having stock Creality 3 flashbacks on a regular basis. I forgot what a pain it was to use a little piece of paper to set the Z height and have to set the bed on a regular basis. If I had to do it again I wouldn't buy it. I'd either deal with the snails pace or my MakerBot Method or start saving for the new X1 with the heated chamber!
Im considering the P1P or the X-Plus 3. Other than the setting the Z height, what printer gives the best detail in the finished prints?
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf honestly, I think the Bambu Lab will give you better all around finished prints. I do a lot of printing with PC and I really appreciate the heated chamber on the X-PLUS 3, it makes it a little easier to print PC, ABS/ ASA, and Polypropylene, but I can also get quality prints with those filaments on my P1P.
I've had my P1P for 18 months now and my X-Plus 3 for about 6, and while I like the Qidi I really wish I would have gotten a second Bambu Lab instead. It just makes it easy to get good prints
Would you compare this to the K1 or K1 Max? The build late is in the middle of the two, but the specs seem amazing - heated chamber, included dehumidifier, which feels like it’d be super useful for flex PLA or similar, and £150 cheaper than the K1 Max.
i am blown away with how they turned this machine around.
Mine came in yesterday, and I've thrown some test prints at it and compared to my Lulzbot Taz5 from 2014, and this has been a very pleasant experience. I didn't get reasonable prints off my Taz5 until I threw out the factory hotend and extruder (almost a year after purchase). It feels much better today, getting a printer that can be as close to plug-and-play as you can get in this hobby. Great update.
Wow yeah that’s gonna be a massive jump in technologies
I also have a TAZ6, actually 2 of them. I now use 2 different nozzles but I do, periodically use the original BUT I rebuilt it to TAZ 8 architecture. I build a E3D toolhead so I can use 1.75mm filament with a .4mm nozzle. And I built a great toolhead for very quick prototypes, a 1.2mm nozzle using the 2.85mm filament a MoarStruder. It's a really cool toolhead and on parts that require no real definition it's awesome. I also run it at 140% speed so it's not all that slow. I use CURA not the Lulzbot version of CURA. I keep the CURA print speed at 50mm/s but on the LULZBOT LCD I change the speed, after the first layer, to 140%. You do have to adjust E-steps and calculate them so you have to make sure you do that and I have to do it for each of the 3 different toolheads so I right them down. If you screw that up you can cause a filament jam and these toolheads are a bit of a pain to clear the jams, heatgun is ABSOLUTELY needed. My best machine, and I have 10, if the Luluzbot but I do not have, yet, any Bambu, Ankermaker, or QIDI. If I get one of them I will have to watch multiple comparative reviews. This review was excellent. By the way, 7 of my 10 printers I got on eBay "as is, for parts only". I fixed them all. The 2 TAZ 5s I got, wow, the previous owners misaligned the frames, miswired them so the fans didn't work and the z and y rails moved together, the supports for the rails were installed incorrectly, what a mess. One of them took me 10hrs to fix but both now work great. I did replace the PEI on one with a flexible bed, the other I retained the PEI.
I can agree with you! I have mind since around a week now and already played around with the settings a bit. What I found out was that they set their extrusion multiplier to 95% instead of 100%, which made my prints better! And don‘t hesitate too adjust your pressure advance and smoothing time to lower levels. At these high speeds their preset smoothing time has to be shorter and their pa-value can be calibrated using some online research.
I started 3D printing on the qiditech shadow pro 6.0 (resin). Great printer for getting started on. Got a ton of great prints on it.
where can i find the stls for that skull with the face?
SkullDroid.
Enjoyed the video greatly. Fun question... if you found yourself in a situation where you only had access to 1 Sub-1000$ printer for a month, what would you choose?
What is the part availability like in the UK for Qidi products ?
I have a older Qidi Xplus which has most proprietary parts
zero parts are available here in Australia - paying air freight shipping from china adds up
Seems Qidi have now removed the support information for the older models from their web page ?
Prefer this machine or the Bambu P1S?
lol, no. Not even close
A huge thank you for the review, finally a company whom decides to take action in order to improve their product + deliver what claim. Great review, I’m going to look into this one some more as it has pretty much all I’m looking for. Bambu has been doing great and all , but damn, the amount of waste for multi color is significant. Thx again!
Exactly, they are a great bunch too and even in my original negative review I mentioned how helpful they were being
I have the same printer, is there a correct way to shut down the printer? Or do you just turn off from the main power button that lies on the back next to the power cord?
bend in the door are most likekly to give it rigidity so it flexes less
i would hope the frame did that
@@FauxHammer flex of the door, not the printer
where can I get the model at 4:54?
You don't have to manually adjust the z offset? :o
Does anyone know what model that is at the very start? It looks very cool would love to make it🔥
so how would you compare to the P1S (combo)? If the combo is even valuable?
Don't say to much...weird things can happen with that 3d printer 😅 I have the x-max and still surprised how many weird fault I have had 🤨
Im considering the x-max, is this still an issue for you?
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf Yes still strange things...might be because of updated firmware. My printer got clogged now and I bought new extruder...stil same result. Printing in PLA and the only solution was to increase temp 210 to 240 degrees. And that's make me wonder if the firmware use wrong temperature. I tried different brand of filament and stil same result
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf Recommend to buy bambu lab or flash forge if you can afford those
@@MrBiggs-wu2kf Recommend bambu lab or flash forge...think you get less headache with those. X-max 3 seems to also be a bit of a disaster 😑 Saw one review that was really good but the guy took it back 1 month later...he had hard time to get that work good 😑
Printing speed isnt just how fast the hotend can move around, it is also how fast it can melt plastic. How strong the extruder is and how well it can deal with back pressure. Would be good to see how fast it can do a benchmark print like the benchy
how is this compared to the p series from Bambu?
i just bought one, any tips
looks like cheaper version of creality id still go for bambu end of story....
Looks cheap, but all of the specs way above K1, just missing camera. But focusing on industrial/business printing that can’t be exposed to the cloud, bigger print volume, hotter nozzle, hotter bed, and heated chamber. Market is slowly getting saturated and good for everyone.
so bambu which is closed source and propitiatory parts and bad Cs?
@@RathOX its closed source, but hey did you see majority of useless upgrades in k1 majority are useless and then if its usefull its a mod that fixes manufacturers errors, i have k1 and max both have terrible engineering solutions in good few places, and if you go by facebook groups there are alot more whining in creality k1 groups than p1/ x1c groups…..
@@RathOX as well as customer support i cant say anything about bambu but creality wouldnt be best….
Huge freaking probs to qiditech... Taking it off sale.. fix it . And relaunch . Thats a big example for most companies..
Also carbon to hardened steel is good! U lose a LITTLE speed, but u get a big bump in reliability and can probably even replace bearings on it!
I give them the respect for being the only company outside of stratasys and MakerBot using a fundamental technology that's been known since I think the early 90a but their extruders still suck almost as much h as their name. I supposed they were build in the qidi-pa-town.
Can the printer actually last constantly printing at a 65C chamber temp? On the marketing they say 65C but then they seem to limit the temp in the slicer to 60C and they have a warning on the printer itself saying don't go beyond 50 or 55C
Honestly this machine has gotten progressively worse since I got it unfortunately where my P1S is still going strong
@@FauxHammer Any tips for the printer in hindsight?
@@joeb2009in hindsight, I’d have gone back to my original review
@@FauxHammerwould you recommend an SV08 or K1Max as alternatives to this?
@@PerfectPuddingsv-08
Thank you for the review!
Is there a way to tell if i just bought the revised version or an older version?
Older version was never released to anyone beyond influencers. But the new version has a big metal bar on the base between the lead screws
Would you buy this or the P1P
I haven’t used a P1P, but I’m unboxing an X1C as we speak
It… sounds like my X1C
i'm not sure if stating "I don't know what CoreXY or Klipper means" will help your channel grow : ) Stellar review though, well done !
Thanks for the review. can you please share what actual printing speeds did you achieve with different materials while maintaining reasonable quality?
I got a successful print at 350mm/s quality was terrible though
huh, well good on them for pulling it, and released a fixed/updated one, sadly its price point puts it mostly out of my budget, but i'll keep an eye on qidi now, that kind of commitment to making things right is danged rare it feels like, these days
Its price point is actually pretty reasonable, if you compare it against the machines they're marketing it against, like the Bambu, Prusa or Creality K1 series. I get it that its currently out of your budget, but it's sort of akin to someone driving a Ford saying the BMW is out of their budget... you're not their target market.
@@ndcollins yeah, i didnt mean to imply it was overpriced or anything! it appears to be fantastically priced for an FDM printer at the (amazing) resolution it appears to print at, and its very much something that, should my finances improve (or i finally sell off some of the pile of oop minis, boxes, etc on ebay), i will very much be taking a hard look it
Great video- thanks for pointing out the how the spool is loaded. I think this will make it a pass for me. Aside from that, it is great for the 3D printing community when a manufacturer takes criticism and adjusts.
How is it compared to the q1 pro?
Both are shit imo
@@FauxHammeryou don’t recommend both of them? Isn’t it reliable?
Thx for this nice and informativ video. Im on the way to buy this one or a Creality K1. On a old QidiTech X-Plus 3 review, thre was also a lot of mechanical problems under the Printer. everithing is hold by plastic , and screws are fixed only in a plastic I mean. normal is metal screw in metal tube and this is glued in plastik. On the old version it was metalscrew direct in plastik. and this hold not a long time. Is this now fixed?
My XPlus 3 arrived today so I can answer this for you. Aside from the outer shell plastic, everything in the base of the main box frame is now metal, and has an added thick metal bracing bar that runs left to right in the middle bottom of the frame.
Basically it's a full metal frame internally with a plastic outer shell for the enclosure.
thanks for great review! in 699$, its value is HIGH
as there is no direct sales by bambu in my country, official retailer sells p1p in 800$..I would rather take this , as it's price are same or lower than P1P including tax, import.. etc.
Much like with the Creality K1, I don't get the whole thing with putting the filament on the back. Who doesn't put their 3D printers with the back towards the wall? I guess if you have your printers in a freestanding rack or on a table it might work, but as-is, that one particular aspect is really a deal breaker for me. Especially when you can get something like a Bambu Labs P1S with the AMS for a few hundred Euro more and have built-in multi-material printing, while loading all the filament spools easily accessible on the top.
100% agree
why no information of printing speed of all your prints ?
Very happy to read this rocky to rock star story :) Thanks for all your work.
It‘s esun not sunlu!!!! at 3:57!
Oh sorry !?!?!?!?!!!!!!?!!!?!?!!!!!!!!
And I have to watch some clapping-time-waste 5:30 movie-brake, for WHAT? What I have done ?!?
Well the other option is listening to me and staring at a blank screen. I don't have the setup or space for talking head moments, so until i do. this is what you'll get.
Buy the QIDI Tech X-PLUS 3 Here: shareasale.com/r.cfm?b=2395089&u=3060349&m=130069&urllink=&afftrack=
Original Video - ua-cam.com/video/TMzvTFgXGUI/v-deo.html
@@leanja6926 affiliate links are always up before the reviews? It’s the only way to earn on this platform. Or should I let 5000 people watch it before I post the link?
I don’t really understand the complaint?
@@leanja6926 I don’t even know how to respond to that.
If people click the link and buy, then later find out it’s a negative review. That’s on them.
This review has been online for nearly a week for my channel members. They’ve seen the video and the link is fir them.
Where do you get off telling me what my Job is? My job isn’t even to tell you if it’s a good printer or not. Have you seen my other videos. Have I ever given a printer a score?
I’m here to tell you how they work so you can make a decision for yourself.
If you haven’t watched the review. Don’t click the link… is that easy.
You are literally complaining at me for being prepared for a video to launch…
@@leanja6926 yeah, I'm just gonna choose to ignore you going forward. An affiliate link is not an endorsement, it;s posted on every video I've made, even when the reviews have not been positive.
I'm not going to change it, if you wnat to read it as an endorsement, go ahead. I'm confident enough that you're in the minority, and you are getting hung up over such a petty thing where you have cosen to interpret preperation of a video in a specific way.
@@FauxHammer A skill that I've been trying hard to learn lately is to not take personal offense with people's comments and to try to let negativity just slide off and focus on the positive. In this instance, it probably would've been far better to simply ignore @leanja6926's first comment, as most everyone else would have. Instead people like me who are first timers to your channel are met with this fairly acrimonious exchange before the video has even started. Ignore the haters. The world's full of them and fighting with every one of them is just going to be exhausting, not to mention possibly drive potential subscribers away. Just my 2c.
@@stew675 No that's a fair comment to make, and yeah I should rise above it. but i have a long histor of calling people out when they make daft comments. especially when they seem to have some crazy idea of what my responsibilities are as a reviewer. I have some of course. they are to share my honest opinions with you all in videos. And I'm quite proud of the reputation I've grown in that regard. But when it comes to when and where I share affiliate links. that;s my call. My viewers have a responsibility to not blame me if they click it and buy it before watching my review. Besides. The wait time is literally only a few hours.
I do aim to engage with my audience, no matter the comments. Many other viewers would enjoy my blatant openness in calling out daft comments like this for what they are.
Apologies if your first impression is a neagtive one. please continue to watch and you'll soon see that this fits with my character.
Hey gutes Video. Es sieht für mich so aus als wäre der druckkopf vom xplus 3 etwas andres als der vom xmax 3. Mein letztes Wissen ist das der xmax 3 einen Bl Touch verbaut hat und der xplus 3 nicht ?
I’ve no idea what the difference is
They sell mostly on Amazon do they not ? maybe the fear of them all being returned was a driving force to pulling them
Really wonder was qidis game is, they've been around for years yet still a minor players really ? -
Is qidi brand a side hustle for a factory that assembles for other entities
There early model was basically a clone of flashforge which was basically a clone of Makerbot Replicator - as were many in that era
Loading the filament into the holder is no more fiddly than putting new Cors in a strimmer lol
True. But when other printers make it so much easier lol
@@FauxHammervery true lol.
This printer is better than any any bambu
In what way? Curious?
As a noob, can someone tell me who he was talking about when saying at 5:50
I'll never confirm it...
@@FauxHammer come on dont be a puss.
But whats the quality'of parts like / build quality ? Bambu just seems like you get what you pay for
If I would not have the need for a MUCH bigger printer than XMAX3, I would have for sure buying QIDI, for this behaviour.
3:56 that literally says esun and not sunlu lmao
You sold me!
I have had my X-Plus 3 for six weeks now, after giving away my older X Plus. I'm now wishing I had kept the older model. Issues with my X-Plus 3 are numerous, reliability and print quality being the top issues. Also, after homing the system and I jog the table to the top, the "ZERO" position is actually about 1.5mm from the nozzle tip. Sometimes, when I jog it to the top, the Z axis will shut off when it's within 10mm, which results in the table drifting to the bottom. Other issues, NO fail-safe sensors to stop a inaccurately homed table from crashing into the nozzle or into the frame at the bottom. To top it off, there is virtually no documentation beyond a very basic quick start guide. Finally, the older X Plus made noticeably better parts.
If all you are going to make are low resolution parts (over .2mm per layer) then you might be okay with this machine. I have YET to make a .16mm layer part that isn't a huge FAIL! And this is from PLA. I'm not even going to try it with ABS or something else. IMO, the firmware on this machine needs work. When selecting parts to make from their thumb drive, the user interface NEVER displays the part on the first try. I have to make multiple tries (as in over 5 tries) before the user interface will display the part.
Update: I HATE this piece of crap! My two year old X Plus was slower but at least it WORKED. I loaded their new firmware (per their suggestion), and it now causes the extruder assy to crash into the finished part, with the last crash resulting in the extruder cover being knocked off. There are only two possibilities, either their firmware is crap or their slicer is crap.
This system is beta at best and should have never been released for sale.
It's baffling why qidi clings on to an obsolete manual offset and probing system, when the rest of the competition has moved on to completely automatic nozzle probing - bambu, prusa, and even creality.
I do t know the difference. It works and I had no issue with auto levelling
I know why alot of youtubers convert their channels to 3d printer ones...free merch lol 😂
lol yep, it started that way, now I have a trove of printers I can't get rid of.
@@FauxHammer sell them people will buy or donate them
Orange pla+ from sunlu ... Puts down roll from esun 😂
>.> wow i would just place on the side.
Reilly Pass
I read the thumbnail as: "Quiditch deserves respect", and no.
No. It does not.
What, you don't appreciate a good Quaffle?
A bit crap if you actually bought one of those original machines.
They took them off sale whilst on preorder, I don't think any got shipped.
I bought one of the first ones. They sent parts from China to texas in 4 days, answered every question along with firmware and tech to troubleshoot shoot it, AND then sent me a new printer free of charge and let me keep the old one.
I’ve bought new cars that sat in the shop for months, was given a sub par rental, and still didn’t get what I payed for. Qidi didn’t give me any run around or hassle. They were very honest and went beyond anything I could have asked for. They also gave refunds to people that wanted to move on. If anything maybe this has woke up some of the competition on how to handle warranties and claims. I would buy this printer again it’s so good.
Pulling the printer isn't really that impressive considering it never worked. They would have just had to refund everyone anyway. So save the praise for what they decide to do rather than what they needed to do.
Good video .Thank you . Subscriber now ... Qidi on the way to me ...
What’s the face that open up and dirty mask?
SkullDroid
If you're buying a Quidi over a P1P...I don't know what to tell you, I'm also sick of paying to be a Beta Tester for these companies...Well done to Qidi for finding out how to fix their own machine. Elegoo & Bambu Labs are just dominating with every machine they bring out ( Possibly Prusa with a pricing & logistics improvement) once Bambu Labs bring out X1E in the next few months, I don't think any of these copycats will have a hope in hell.
One rather obvious retort would be: "If you're okay with giving up privacy, control over intellectual property and compromising your network security just to be able to participate in a closed ecosystem, then I don't know what to tell you".
Edit: Check out the Nathan Builds Robots video about this topic. At the end of the day, not everyone wants to agree to the BambuLabs ToS and it's good to have viable similarly performing alternatives.
@@stew675 im really worried about Bambu Labs stealing my baby yoda stl file. @stew65 by the way the illuminati are watching your house and have your phones bugged...
@@stew675 Have you read prusa ToS or creality ToS, elegoo ToS or(..._you get the idea. Its a boilerplate TOS they ALL use.
Prusa will keep your data for 10 years AND they will share it with 3rd parties. Are you ok with that? Use Prusa slicer/ Cura slic3r same deal. Lawyers write them up so they wont get sued and every company has similar wording so lets stop pretending bambu is doing something new or nefarious.
NBR is a sensationalist and preys in low information folks. Go read the TOS yourself if you dont believe me. You can even do a quick search through the eula and tos for "third party", "data". NBR and 3dmusk does the same thing. You are just feeding their algo for clicks.
This printer works perfectly for me.
Have you saved material or found old filament in the basement or are you too stupid for 3D printing???
Well, you can unpack... at least something.
Pardon? I also said it was great.. did you even watch this
@@FauxHammer Sorry !! Feel free to delete my thread again. I must have had a bad day and let you become my victim.
I like the Qidi's, even if there were problems at the beginning. Especially since Qidi offers an extremely competent and reliable service that many manufacturers can learn from. My mistake!
Man its so excessively bulky
Too plasticky for me.
It's got a full metal frame, this is just the housing.
This is like a tank, 24 kg vs 14 kg (bambu X1C). You want the weight in the frame, not glas doors and panels like other brands.
This is a nice video pointing out the several key improvements that make the current versions of the X-Plus 3 and its smaller and larger siblings very good printers and very reasonable prices. But how can someone be this into 3D printers and then "have no idea" why Qidi changed from carbon fiber to hollow steel rails??? Really? No idea at all? FH says he watched Clough42's review of the revised printers and certainly James (Clough42) made quite clear, as have most other reviewers that the change was made because the CF rods were critical wear items that could not be replaced. Even Qidi's marketing materials make clear the benefits of the hollow steel guide rods. I just don't get it...
I understand things to 100% or not at all. I don't get how carbon rods are irreplaceable yet steel is…
I know this is the reason they were replaced, but other than quoting that same line, I don't get why carbon is irreplaceable.
But honestly, I don't care enough to find out unless we see this more
Hey, we expect you to know every engineering nuance inside out and every possible pro & con otherwise we just can't get it 🤣@@FauxHammer