Zildjian Then and Now: A Comparison of Vintage and Modern Cymbal Sounds | Avedis (Part 1 of 4)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 134

  • @ancientskies8408
    @ancientskies8408 4 роки тому +25

    John's playing makes me so happy. So many dynamics

    • @ancientskies8408
      @ancientskies8408 4 роки тому +1

      Also Great job Zildjian! Thee A series are some of my favorite cymbals! Everything from desert rock to jazz
      Blues to bop. The A's can do em' all! 🤘
      (Thin to Paper thin crashes are my favorite, and medium thin crash rides are just bliss 👌)

  • @robertwallace7213
    @robertwallace7213 3 роки тому +10

    I could listen to Paul and John talk about and play cymbals all day long! Thank you for making these great video's!

  • @felixstaffano6538
    @felixstaffano6538 4 роки тому +35

    MEMPHIS DRUM SHOP!!! You guys are consistently giving us the BEST content. THANK YOU! Other drum shops are closing left and right, but its clear you guys will stand the test of time! Can't wait for part 2!

  • @goatatl
    @goatatl 4 роки тому +79

    So, after 47 years of using their products, I find out the accent in Avedis is on the "Ah" ? I've been saying a-VEE-dis my entire life...

  • @jetseat
    @jetseat Рік тому +2

    I had a 1955 22 inche Zildjian, and my my hi-hat we're 14s. At that time, I'm happy to say that Zildjian was it! Whatever else that was out there never came close to the sound of my Zildjians. If I were to be asked by a young man starting out to play drums what cymbals should he purchase I definitely would steer him to Zildjian. BTW the drums I played on were a set of Ludwig. Just an 82 year old finger and hand taper today.

  • @thomasmoje5926
    @thomasmoje5926 3 роки тому +6

    The new issue 'Avedis' cymbals sound remarkably close to their 'vintage' counterparts. Kudos to Zildjian for capturing that 'vintage A' sound and feel. One thing I have found with Zildjian cast cymbals (and this may just be my imagination); they seem to 'age in' well and get better with age. I have a Zildjian 'A' 14" thin crash that sounded very bright when I bought it in 1995: it's now just beginning to get a nice balanced timbre and one of my go-to crashes.

  • @Cavie1974
    @Cavie1974 4 роки тому +12

    Your shop is on my bucket list and on my wife's No Fly Zone.

  • @MalikEmmanuel
    @MalikEmmanuel 4 роки тому +6

    One of the things that I really like about the older cymbals over the newer cymbals is the complexity, or even those undesired (under or) overtones. Learning how to control those and play them individually are what helped develop my technique, my touch and helped me to share my love of the instrument with other students. That the uniformity of modern cymbals really robs us of those opportunities is bittersweet.

    • @polara01
      @polara01 2 роки тому +1

      I know where you're coming from, but a clunker is a clunker LOL and there were a lot of Clunkers in those vintage piles of cymbals. The new Avidas line are awesome I have played some and brought a couple over the last few years they are great to record with I just wish they made him a little bit heavier because they are really thin which are fine for low volume situations and small music ensembles for instance I think they should have made a 20 available also around 2100 G and an 18 around 1400 G to 1500 G so when you are playing live they cut through a little more but still have the same general characteristics of this line would be really great but they are awesome cymbals nonetheless... and Mr Riley really brings out the best in them!

    • @bryanherward4679
      @bryanherward4679 Рік тому

      @@polara01 try to find some of the Armand series...just got a 22 Avedis...had a 16" Armand crash...thin and soft just like the Avedis line...planning on getting the 19" Avedis i found locally. (side note" just got in a 19" Armand Beautiful baby...it's at 1899 grams...definitely on the ride side of things...so check weights before you buy) Not sure where a 20" Armand falls in A weights...a few videos in the 2050-2150 range)

  • @omarsaleem3076
    @omarsaleem3076 4 роки тому +2

    Im 43 and was giving a 20" A zildjian owned by my step dad when I was about 12 years old, before I though about playing drums....I did eventually start playing and thank god I saved the cymbal....I assume it is a cymbal from the 60's but it may be from the mid 70's...I have yet to find out...I love it and it has served me well in all situations.

  • @andyham6094
    @andyham6094 4 роки тому +9

    I’m a meinl guy and have a huge hoarding collection of meinls but the one non meinl I have is the cymbal on the right side, mine is a 21 inch Avedis ride which is basically a crash ride yet has a great bell still. Super thin and crashy with a great bell but they sound different than anything else on the market. I love my meinl rides but this avedis is one of my favorites. I play in a progressive metal/djenty band and this cymbal works for that as well as other styles

    • @gabe1655
      @gabe1655 4 роки тому +1

      i feel like that's a lot of drummers' cases. they love istanbul, meinl, sabian but they always fall for the vintage a or k sounds.

  • @ilovegongsmygongsongs2094
    @ilovegongsmygongsongs2094 4 роки тому +11

    They all sound great ! now all you need is a vintage Gretsch Set !

    • @chefbrittan84
      @chefbrittan84 Рік тому

      I have a 1953 Gretsch Round Badge. And it came with a set of ‘50s era cymbals too. A customer I was pouring concrete for said he couldn’t even give ‘em away to friends, they didn’t want them. I jumped on it. Still got em.

  • @wilkinsnl
    @wilkinsnl 4 роки тому +3

    From the first moment I played them in a drum shop in Portland, I’ve been crazy about these cymbals. I have all but the 16” Hats and 22” Ride.

  • @joachimekermann8267
    @joachimekermann8267 4 роки тому +50

    The vintage ones sounds so much better :o

    • @MichaelWashingtonAE
      @MichaelWashingtonAE 4 роки тому +2

      Hand shaped, hand hammered (before they started using machine hammer), hand lathed... Hand made. That touch of the master craftsman and their feeling and understanding of resonance and vibration throughout the shaping and hammering process makes a big difference. Also the vintage cymbals were made with water from the sea of Marmara mixing with water from the Black Sea is different from the tap water or even possible Atlantic water that they are getting in Boston. It's like a home cooked meal in the home country then somewhere else thousands of miles away. Even if the ingredients are the same, the soil makeup where the vegetables grow is different, the grass and hay is different, the water source is different. Both meals may taste great but it will be nothing like home.

    • @MalikEmmanuel
      @MalikEmmanuel 4 роки тому

      @@MichaelWashingtonAE they sound a little thinner, but I am not using monitors just my computer speakers. They sound a bit like when people clean their vintage A's to me.
      P.S. you have my father's name...

    • @DenEz_TV
      @DenEz_TV 4 роки тому +3

      Disagree. They are just different.

    • @joshuavalentindrums
      @joshuavalentindrums 4 роки тому +2

      Yeah but because you can never recreate 30 or 40 years of playing. But they have come as close as posible to the vintage sound with a new cymbal.

    • @pablogodi1392
      @pablogodi1392 4 роки тому +1

      Well, that ones sound very good, almost in the video, but there are "vintage zildjians" that, actually, sound, being polite, "not very good"

  • @dmitryshkolnik5233
    @dmitryshkolnik5233 4 роки тому +8

    the hammering pattern on the new ones actually looks pretty much like that on zht line.. that's a little disturbing if you ask me

  • @adrianlyord5300
    @adrianlyord5300 4 роки тому +7

    Defiantly the vintage cymbals hands down!

  • @jimsozrics
    @jimsozrics 4 роки тому +3

    The 'vintage' cymbals win it hands down over the 'new' Avedis cymbals in my opinion. In my 66 years as a drummer I have played with a 13 cymbal quiver on my 7piece set. I have always taken at least a year to audition different cymbals before purchasing. Except for a 22" non-riveted 'swish', nearly all my cymbals were manufactured in the 40's - 60's.

  • @demonicsweaters
    @demonicsweaters 4 роки тому +1

    heard some of these in person, and man do they sound amazing

  • @joevetrano3902
    @joevetrano3902 4 роки тому +1

    The Avedis cymbals are higher pitched which make a comparison harder. The original A's are the gold standard - sound and response, especially the two rides on the right hand side. I think the Avedis series are fine for contemporary drummers to be able to get some of the vintage characteristics by buying the off the shelf, instead of searching for original A's. And they may have more appeal to the "modern drummer's ear". But for guys like me who were playing during the original era, it was great to here the A's and would look for them instead.

    • @rhythmista7707
      @rhythmista7707 Рік тому

      Steve Smith uses the A Avedis line, and he's in his late 60s..

  • @gregpeller1499
    @gregpeller1499 4 роки тому +1

    "Thank- you so much for this super informative video MDS!"

  • @franktatom1837
    @franktatom1837 4 роки тому +4

    I have a 50's Zildjian, drilled for 6 rivets when it was made, there is much more bow to the cymbal than modern cymbals, and I think the metal composition is different than for modern cymbals - I'm no metallurgist, but my older cymbals tarnish much more readily than the newer ones, I think because there was more silver used in them years ago - and the cymbal has a different sound than a modern cymbal, not necessarily better (that's a matter of taste). When silver went from $10.00 an ounce to $60.00 an ounce about 40 years ago, I recall there was some caterwauling about it from the Zildjian folks. But the Avedis cymbals sound great, to me.

    • @dropdtune9199
      @dropdtune9199 4 роки тому

      Same alloy as ever. The difference in tarnishing is the coating...most old cymbals had no coating whatsoever.

  • @Monsterdrumma
    @Monsterdrumma 4 роки тому

    I just actually found a literally like new Avedis 18” crash for only $150.00 that is thin and opens up immediately and has a beautiful shimmer well like the ones in this video. I haven’t gotten to use it on a gig yet and I can’t wait!

  • @spartandrew8672
    @spartandrew8672 4 роки тому +1

    I’d say I like modern hats and rides but the average vintage crash is so nice with the bells and everything

  • @sgtpepper1138
    @sgtpepper1138 4 роки тому

    Chad Smith was playing on some of these on FB during this crazy isolation. He was playing pretty hard on a vintage kit, and I was mad at first because I thought they were vintage cymbals, until I saw the logo, then I wasn't as mad after.

  • @andy80sdrums
    @andy80sdrums 4 роки тому +1

    John's playing is pure

  • @rogerferronato6876
    @rogerferronato6876 Рік тому

    My setup : hh A avedis (new); 18" avedis( old); 19" A avedis(new); 22" avedis (old) .... Beautiful sound !!!

  • @mellowtron214
    @mellowtron214 4 роки тому +1

    *VERY TASTEFUL DRUMMING THERE AT THE END.*
    Nice

  • @papapoodo6685
    @papapoodo6685 4 роки тому

    What a coincidence! I just bought a bunch more As tonight! Great cymbals, great video

  • @boomerguy9935
    @boomerguy9935 8 днів тому

    At 15:00, I prefer the sound of the vintage Avedis over the modern Avedis. It's hard to describe but as a jazz drummer, the new ones are not even in the same ballpark. I still have my Avedis cymbals that I bought new in 1966. However, I do like the K Constantinople line but haven't bought any yet.

  • @alexmagor
    @alexmagor 10 місяців тому

    Now I want some vintage cymbals! The new ones seems darker/muffled by comparison.

  • @nanceeleana
    @nanceeleana 4 роки тому +2

    Sounds like Zildjian is trying to get a little bit of that vintage crowd like what Paiste did with their 602 modern essentials line.

  • @wyndymequine9206
    @wyndymequine9206 4 роки тому

    This is exciting- I have yet to find something close to the 20" med, 18" crash ride and med 14" HH Zildjians that came with my 67 Super Classics- they have matured and I get offers to sell them every time they are out- especially the Hats- nothing out there sounds as good for brush work on a recording session.- this new line might tap into the obvious market out there.

  • @xylosforkids5357
    @xylosforkids5357 4 роки тому +5

    Hey Paul! And Riley! - Paul when are you guys going to make a mini cup 22 or 24 Avedis like the old days! I would consider selling my right arm to buy it- and then happily play it left handed! Riley- Your stick mallets are magic- and Memphis-keep up the high standards- can you open a California branch? Please....

    • @davidwinthrop7077
      @davidwinthrop7077 4 роки тому

      Xylo's for Kids
      Yes bring back the mini cup. I bought an Avedis 16” mini cup crash in the late 1970s, sadly I sold it many years ago but I can still remember how sweet it sounded!

    • @MalikEmmanuel
      @MalikEmmanuel 4 роки тому

      I find that many of those small cup cymbals are K's and even some of the A's that Avedis was making before he really developed his signature style and sounds.

  • @RyanAlexanderBloom
    @RyanAlexanderBloom Рік тому +2

    I wonder what the oldest surviving Zildjian on earth is… like the company is 400 and cymbals are metal chunks. We got any 400 year old examples?!?

    • @Lupine.
      @Lupine. 7 місяців тому

      If not... Hopefully some Archaeological dig will excavate something we'll get to hear one day.

  • @autodidacticprofessor869
    @autodidacticprofessor869 4 роки тому +2

    For over 30 years of my life, having been aware of Zildjian, I've been pronouncing it, "a-VEE-dis" this whole time. I'm stunned. lol

    • @arrowintheknee9956
      @arrowintheknee9956 Рік тому

      Well, you pronounced it right. The guy here on the left is pronouncing it wrong. It's a latin word.
      Edit: Maybe it's an armenian or turkish word.

  • @seppoinnanen5577
    @seppoinnanen5577 4 роки тому +3

    I've been running away from these kind A Zildjian sounds since the early 80's. And listening them now again with good headphones, I can't say that I like what I hear. Too high pitched wash under a fragile stick sound and strange bell-like overtones still seem to be there. But I know that many like this kind of cymbal sound... John Riley's playing is delicate and fluid, enjoyable to listen to

    • @mason2203
      @mason2203 4 роки тому

      Seppo Innanen what cymbals do you play?

  • @KardSore
    @KardSore 4 роки тому

    FANTASTIC! Thank you soo much for that...

  • @ruffdrag
    @ruffdrag 4 роки тому

    Some great historical info here form Paul Francis. John Riley keeps saying if Avedis logo wasn't on cymbal I could be convinced this is a 40 or 50 year old cymbal. Well, 2019 - 50 = 1969. I think John meant to say more like 60 to 70 year old cymbal (1949 -59). Time does fly by. Though IMHO there's nothing like the original old 1950's A's.

  • @adamwilson1691
    @adamwilson1691 4 роки тому +1

    Can’t wait to see the K cons one

  • @thenel2162
    @thenel2162 4 роки тому +1

    they really sound fantastic! Love my 50s tho

  • @gregpeller1499
    @gregpeller1499 4 роки тому

    Memphis Drum Shop: "Does Zildjian offer a box set or pack of the Avedis line?? I was also wondering if they ever plan to make smaller cymbals just like the days of the big band era such as 10"-15" plates? Thank -you."

  • @AlexanderSeleznov
    @AlexanderSeleznov 4 роки тому +1

    As my grandma loved to said: "there used to be times ..."

  • @BPJazz
    @BPJazz 7 місяців тому

    The old hi hat is infinitely better!

  • @Andrew3154
    @Andrew3154 4 роки тому +1

    I still have a 22" ride I bought in 1966.

  • @nickhaldin8674
    @nickhaldin8674 4 роки тому

    Those vintage hi-hats are gorgeous

  • @bobbyboygaming2157
    @bobbyboygaming2157 4 роки тому

    Paul Francis started liftin'. flexin' those biceps

  • @rhythmista7707
    @rhythmista7707 Рік тому +1

    Vintage, hands down..But the new ones are very nice as well.

  • @westerlu77
    @westerlu77 4 роки тому +4

    The old ones beats the new one. There’s something with the overtones I think that the new not have unfortunately.

    • @spartandrew8672
      @spartandrew8672 4 роки тому +1

      Someone’s gonna judge your grammar fix it before it’s too late

  • @iRideuWatch
    @iRideuWatch 3 роки тому

    I think the modern Avedis sounds better. They are lower in pitch with a little less overtones so a smoother sound. They are buttery smooth and pleasing.

  • @NelsonMontana1234
    @NelsonMontana1234 4 роки тому +6

    They all sound different. Not necessarily better or worse.

  • @kongoff
    @kongoff 2 роки тому +1

    100% the vintage. Not even close in my opinion. Much nicer overtones and richness to the cymbals - divine 👌

  • @JulianFernandez
    @JulianFernandez 4 роки тому

    nicely done!

  • @smeesturkeyleg
    @smeesturkeyleg Рік тому

    Both sets sound tremendous. Still prefer the vintage ones, especially the 50's hats. I have a 15" featherweight pair from that era and they are the closest ive heard to the Agop 30th Anniversary hats.

  • @alexmagor
    @alexmagor 10 місяців тому

    What bass drum/kit is that?

  • @scotttaylor7211
    @scotttaylor7211 4 роки тому

    I have a 20”, 18” & 16” Zildjian A from when I first started playing in the early 60’s. What were these early cymbals made of as compared to the b20 bronze of today?

    • @dropdtune9199
      @dropdtune9199 4 роки тому

      they too are B20 alloy. Coating differs, likely taper too.

  • @ZOB4
    @ZOB4 4 роки тому +3

    The "modern" ones have too much wash - I prefer the dryer sound of the actual vintage ones

  • @rogerwelsh2335
    @rogerwelsh2335 4 роки тому +1

    The sweet ride sounds better.id love for zyldjian to get the medium A ride to sound like it used to. The old A medium and ping rides sounded much better than the ones being made in the last 25 years.

  • @davidlatimer3091
    @davidlatimer3091 4 роки тому

    Both sound great and have their own identity.

  • @CommanderNewton
    @CommanderNewton 3 роки тому

    I own vintage Zildjian cymbals entirely for the fact they are about two to three hundred dollars cheaper than new Zildjians and they sound the same if not better

  • @antkn33
    @antkn33 4 роки тому

    The cymbals sizes? 14, 18, 20, 22?

  • @robsco1249
    @robsco1249 4 роки тому +1

    It was better than...think about '60/70 Avedis hats or '70/80 Ping ride...

  • @antkn33
    @antkn33 4 роки тому

    Interesting!

  • @julianboyd8719
    @julianboyd8719 4 роки тому

    Hot take but if you want that Vintage sound then just buy hand hammered cymbals. There are so many great brands these days - cymbal & gong, murat diril, istanbul etc. I love Zildjian and almost exclusively use them but I really don't "get" this particular line.

  • @douglasdrummer
    @douglasdrummer 4 роки тому +1

    They looks amazing but the old ones have more personality. Maybe the dirty over the decades.

  • @wiisportss
    @wiisportss 4 роки тому +1

    great video and I love John, but they’re like totally different cymbals. doesn’t capture the essence of the classics at all imo

  • @jonnyMcSee
    @jonnyMcSee 4 роки тому +1

    After playing them for a few years now: they are GREAT crash cymbals. Not so good for main rides. Not dry enough, not enough articulation, not enough even distribution of overtones

  • @kenrubio1200
    @kenrubio1200 4 роки тому

    Cymbalholics are trying to figure out if it’s a transtamp, hollow block or large stamp, or small stamp from the 50s.

  • @joshuanelson627
    @joshuanelson627 2 роки тому

    anyone know the the sizes are?

    • @memphisdrumshop
      @memphisdrumshop  2 роки тому

      From John's left to right: 14", 18", 20", 22"

    • @joshuanelson627
      @joshuanelson627 2 роки тому

      @@memphisdrumshop thanks and great video series 🤙

  • @bradydastrup1025
    @bradydastrup1025 4 роки тому

    All I want is three of each size. Is that too much to ask? Lol

  • @virtualcircle
    @virtualcircle 4 роки тому

    Make a 24 a Avedis ride already

    • @OpethTheater3
      @OpethTheater3 4 роки тому

      vintage ones exist, they sound better than modern ones anyway

  • @rogerwelsh2335
    @rogerwelsh2335 4 роки тому

    They sound good, but not at all like the old. The old ones were much brighter. Not saying that makes the old cymbals better. They are just different

  • @rowintettero1255
    @rowintettero1255 Рік тому +1

    I know John Riley is getting paid for this video, and the cymbals are very good, but he is realy just sucking up to Zildjian. Paul displays his knowledge and then John confirms it in an awful commercial way.
    When he he plays I believe him all the way, when he speaks about this product I tend to doubt him

    • @Lupine.
      @Lupine. 7 місяців тому

      They've treated him really well as an endorser. He might be overselling the brand, but it gets him access to all the models and sizes he wants to try. I tend to like his MDS videos the least of all their demos, so his opinions don't sell me more towarda Zildjian. I'm a Paiste Stan, but every company makes great cymbals.

  • @johnnybgoode2333
    @johnnybgoode2333 3 роки тому

    Those vintage ones sound amazing, but most vintage A's for sale sound like crap. If you do manage to find great sounding cymbals like these, you'll really be paying for it. Better off buying the new ones.

  • @jambajoby32
    @jambajoby32 4 роки тому +1

    It’s not aye-vee-dis?? 🤦🏾

  • @arrowintheknee9956
    @arrowintheknee9956 Рік тому

    Avidas???

  • @cszetela1
    @cszetela1 4 роки тому

    The modern Avedis cymbals sound better to me - more definition.

  • @jimilove7773
    @jimilove7773 Рік тому

    Vintage!

  • @bandfromtheband9445
    @bandfromtheband9445 4 роки тому

    Wait! He was called "Al-vi-DUSS?" When I was 17 years old, and buying my first drum kit and cymbal collection, the salesman always mentioned "UhVEEDIIS Zildjian. When it comes to dealing with dumb american accents and what is currently going on in parts of Turkey...... No surprise.
    Happy Holidays, Happy Festivus, ALL OF the HOLIDAY SPIRIT! Then let's call it another year!

  • @jsstroup81
    @jsstroup81 4 роки тому +1

    Every famous drummer: “Saved up money from my paper route.” Uh huh. Right.

  • @goneaway8759
    @goneaway8759 4 роки тому

    I bought a full set and sold them soon after, just didn’t Iike them.

  • @TimTkachyk
    @TimTkachyk 4 роки тому +2

    I’ve been saying “a-veee-dis” for 20 years.. Oops lol

    • @Timotheetv
      @Timotheetv 4 роки тому

      You're right

    • @richardguinan3298
      @richardguinan3298 4 роки тому

      Who knew right?

    • @richardguinan3298
      @richardguinan3298 4 роки тому

      Then again maybe he is saying it wrong

    • @richardguinan3298
      @richardguinan3298 4 роки тому

      Certainly great sounding cymbals worth giving a try

    • @duprattcarol
      @duprattcarol 4 роки тому

      Many foreign names are americanized through constant mispronunciation and become unrecognizable .

  • @bobbyboygaming2157
    @bobbyboygaming2157 4 роки тому

    Too much gloss on the new ones. They really gotta stop putting that shiny lacquer on the cymbals, they gotta reinvent the [fake] patina

  • @gulinotm
    @gulinotm 4 роки тому +1

    Not really feeling any of them

  • @googlepigs7027
    @googlepigs7027 3 роки тому +1

    Too bad zildjian doesn't just make
    these great cymbals only, like they
    used to, and charge a fair price,
    instead of all the crap they
    make now, and charge $$$ like
    they're great. They've definitely
    become elitist play things for the
    very well to do. GREED !!!

  • @franoputica7448
    @franoputica7448 3 роки тому

    vintage killed modern.

  • @longfade
    @longfade 3 роки тому

    First of all, what do they mean by ‘vintage’? I hear them both say ‘50 years old’ and ‘40 years old’...does that mean they’re going for that classic 80s ride sound that everyone’s looking for? Or are they dodging by being totally non-specific?
    Secondly, they keep fixating on cup size, shape, bow, lathing, and ‘hammering’; the easiest elements to copy when counterfeiting an original. You can take piece of vinyl and duplicate those superficial qualities perfectly. That fake patina gimmick creeped me out big time.
    And of course they sound like what they are: horrible facsimiles made with cheap materials and very expensive CNC machines.
    Great vintage A’s are going for so cheap these days that there is no incentive to buy these things anyway.