BDH Shifter vs Pro-Sim Quaife H Pattern - The Bazooka Shifter Take On The Tank!!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2021
- I'm not sponsored by Fanatec, but if you want to support the channel, you can use this Affiliate Link: www.fanatec.com?FAP+Banner&General+Links&a_aid=375377
If you want to give me a small tip you can do that here: streamlabs.com/rvrcloset/tip
This is just a hobby, and all money I earn here will go back into the channel, and probably give you guys some new shifter reviews and comparisons. ;D
Please join my 3D Discord if you want to hook up on track or chitchat: / discord
Gear and Equipment I use:
(with Amazon & Ebay Affiliate links if you want to support the channel.
And it doesn't matter which of the links you press, or what you end up buying, as long as you follow my links it will give me a small commission on your purchase. :)
*Fractal Design Define R6: amzn.to/34yXsAm
*Aourus Pro Z390: amzn.to/30J4pO2
*i7 8086K: amzn.to/3lqaLtG
*NZXT Kraken: amzn.to/2Syv7Vf
*Corsair 32GB: amzn.to/33GYWcg
*MSI RTX 2080 Ti Gaming X Trio 11GB: amzn.to/3iDOuGL
*Samsung 970 EVO: amzn.to/3lilDto
*Seagate Firecuda: amzn.to/3jFbO8s
*Windows 10 x64: amzn.to/30G7caz
*Logitech C922: amzn.to/2FejYWw
*Aoc Agon AG352UCG6: amzn.to/3d8tQ0s
*NLR V3: amzn.to/3daxiHY
*Jetseat kw-908: ebay.us/h78jpx
*GT Omega RS6 Seat
*Fanatec DD1: fanatec.com/eu-en/racing-whee...
*Podium Kill switch: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec Universial Hub: fanatec.com/eu-en/steering-wh...
*Fanatec Podium Hub: fanatec.com/eu-en/steering-wh...
*Fanatec ClubSport Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec NASCAR Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec BMW M3 GT2 Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/steering-wh...
*Fanatec Formula Black: fanatec.com/eu-en/steering-wh...
*Fanatec GT Forza Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec Classic Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec Classic Formula Rim: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Fanatec CS Magnetic paddle shifters: fanatec.com/eu-en/shifters-ot...
*Fanatec CS SQ Shifter V1.5: fanatec.com/eu-en/shifters-ot...
*Fanatec CS HB V.1.5 x2: fanatec.com/eu-en/shifters-ot...
*Heusinkveld Ultimate Pedals
*Fanatec Damper Kit: fanatec.com/eu-en/accessories...
*Motamec Double D: ebay.us/62Wr4n
*Dimsim F320H: ebay.us/svXjOa
*Pro-Sim H Pattern Quaife Shifter
*Pro-Sim Pro SQ Shifter
*Pro-Sim Lite V2 Shifter
*Frex H Pattern Shifter +
*BDH Shifter
*Sim-Lab GT1 Evo
*Sim-Lab Pedal Slider Baseplate
*Heusinkveld Handbrake
*Heusinkveld SQ Shifter
*TH8A Shifter: amzn.to/34GZuyu
*DSD Button Box Panels
*Sim racing studio Wind simulator
*TP-Link UH700 x 2: amzn.to/2GO04lw
*Oculus Rift S: amzn.to/2Gs0v5p
*Rift S Headphones: amzn.to/2IBQ4Ni
*Oculus Quest 2: amzn.to/3lqdaVe
*Quest Link cable: amzn.to/36HNwqJ
Special thanks to Houmiss for channel art: houmiss@yahoo.com
Captain Flat Spot for music on streams: / @captainflatspot
Also check out:simrace247.com/
#ProSim #RaceSimHardware #Quaife #BDSShifter #SimGear #Comparison SimShifterComparison #HShifters - Ігри
Both shifters sound to be in the same level in the video. I have the sound level on both shifters at the same setting in edit, but my camera is cutting out on the Pro-Sim.
Irl the Pro-Sim is a lot louder.
then the most realistic is bdh shifter?
@@annntonio8370 Hard to say, I have never used a real dogbox H shifter like the ones Quaife is making for real cars.
But the BDH feels more like my own irl car.
After some time with the BDH shifter, I think it is brilliant. The team at BDH are brilliant also. Very supportive. If you are a reader /watcher and haven't tried this shifter, really try to have a go of it. Its a special piece of equipment.
I agree, and Dave and Billy are great guys!
Also really looking forward seeing how BDH will evolve over the years! :D
Thank you so much for this excellent in depth review. I was considering buying one of these shifters and your video was so helpful!
You are welcome, and thank you so much for your comment!
Been waiting for this review. Great video man.
Congrats to BDH too for producing a great piece of kit.
Thanks a lot buddy! 😃🍻
That image at 0:22 feels like the sim racing equivalent to Sabaton for music! :-) 🏎 🎸🏴☠️
☝😁👍
Been waiting for this one! Nice!
Thanks for watching and comment mate!🍻
Nice comparisons. The fact that the pro Sim is so loud is a concern for me as well as I do most of my driving a night. I also like the BDH reverse, looks, size and described gate feel better. Thanks for the review.
Thanks for watching and comment buddy!
Yeah I'm not sure if it's possible to shift the Pro-Sim quiet, maybe if you turn it down to like 1 - 2 kilos and do slow shifts, but what is the fun in that.. XD
Really loving the BDH, and constantly trying to figure out left hand side H shifter cars to drive. :)
You have just sold the BDH to me. I will be buying one. Great comparison RVR!
Thanks mate, nice to hear! And hoping you will like it as well!
Really looking forward seeing a comparison between this and the Simvertex! :D
Fantastic and genuinely a very helpful comparison video, MR-VR Closet. And I think if I ever won some money in Tattslotto somehow (given I don't play it ; ). I think that the BDH Shifter has finally now replaced the AIOLOGS Shifter as my own sim-racing shifter of choice... even if just for the choice of multiple gears like in my real car, verses just the sequential changes of the Aiologs???. Thanks for the great overview, and VERY MUCH LIKED!!! [:]-)
Thank you so much for the watch, nice comment and support SingleRacer!😍🍻
And I'm crossing my fingers someone else's Tattslotto win falls in your lap!..🏃💵😃😁
MAn they both look fantastic I'm not sure I could choose between them but I know I'd be very happy to have either, Great review my friend 😍😍👍
Thank you so much buddy!💕
It was a really hard pick to make!😅
Awesome shifters friend💪🙂 Everyone is beautiful in their own way
Thank you so much my friend!! They sure are! :D
Super comparison. The BDH wins for me because you mounted it to the correct side 😁
Hahaha, it sure makes me want to race more right hand side cars as well!😁👌
Very good video my friend👍satisfying to watch keep it up
Thank you so much my friend!🍻
Both shifters look like they belong in a race car. Choosing which one is better is a very hard choice for me. Awesome vid mate :D
A really hard comparison, they both outperform the shifter in my irl car!..💪😂
Thanks a lot buddy!😍
In my opinion not really a hard decision. Race cars have dogbox gearboxes and as far as i know only the pro-sim shifter can simulate this style of race car gearboxes with its shift lock box mentioned at the end of this review.
From watching your videos of all these high end shifters i have learned one thing for sure.. your wife's sleep is VERY important.
Hehehe it is, I don't wan't to get closed out from the closet..😅
Nice video! 2021 great year for folks getting into sim with all these options now. So in the BDH does shift knob threading, is it the traditional M8-M12aftermarket shift knobs?
Thanks buddy! Oh yes, sim racing is flourishing!! :D
I think it's M10 if I'm not mistaken, will look that up.
The threading is M10 x 1.5mm.
Any plans to review the Bash Pro active h shifter? You are probably one of the only people who could do a comparison with the Pro Sim and BDH :)
Sadly not. But that shifter do look like an awesome shifter!
that bazooka shifter looks really awesome!! great video. btw do you know how many usb ports you are using now. Must be a crazy amount if you have everything plugged in 😅👍
It's really awesome!😍👌
Hahaha, a few!. .😁 Haven't counted, but over 20..😅
Hey what's the song at the end? I really like it a lot. I'm saving up for one of those bdh shifters- it looks very solid!
It's called Fairytale, my kid sister. It used to be on Spotify, but not sure if it's still on there.
An awesome shifter!💪😃
Never thought I would say the BDH is a bargain compared to prosim lol
Same here. :D
One thing I am a bit concerned about is I tend to be a bit rough on my H-pattern especially on the 1st and 2nd gear...can you do a resistance test pulling sideways from the 1st/second gate transitioning to the reverse section?
You mean you are afraid of accidentally putting it in reverse?
I won't be able to see the scale, but will see if I can do some testing for you.
You could also mount it the other way, with reverse to the right beside 5th and 6th.
@@RVRCloset oh! Ya I remember you saying that. I didn't think about that lol ya, I am not in 5th as much. That does it! I will begin the process of obtaining one I think!
@@DouglasThompson Just tried a bit, and it's at least taking double the force getting it out to get into reverse.
@@RVRCloset that sounds great!
Ordered the BDH. Do you know where I can find your knob? I love the reverse to the left like on my BMW :)
Nice! Hope you will be happy with it, I love mine!
I got it with the shifter, so ask Dave or Billy if they can make that one for you. :)
I prefer the sim pro.. but the BDH looks nicer.. They are both beautiful shifters in my opinion 😍👌🔥🔥
Awesome shifters, was a hard comparison!😍😅
Have you gotten your hands on the Bash Pro Active H-pattern yet? I'm holding out buying my endgame shifter until you've had a chance to compare to these two.
Thank you so much for the trust mate!
Sadly I have not, and do to a really busy work and family schedule, I'm not sure when, or if I will be able to try it..
You could sheck Douglas sim racing channel, he have tried both the BDH and Bash Pro Active. ua-cam.com/video/el-P9Pjfj-w/v-deo.htmlsi=pbl3x1v1gPQaDhzD
Thanks for the comparison! Would you say the BDH is worth it over a frex + synchro mod? I like a lot the idea of locked gears without the clutch, but does the BDH experience trump that?
I really like the Frex, my to go to shifter for prototypes and classic formula cars.
But I no longer use the sim synchro, if you put any pressure on the shifter before you engage the clutch, the clutch get's locked out..
So there are a risk you might damage something on your clutch.
@@RVRCloset I see, thanks for the insight! I guess that leaves only the pro sim with its add-on… can’t wait for your review of it!
@@ChrisMorganYT Yeah sadly.. And that will be an expensive addon especially now after brexit..😅
Let me guess you have a bmw? Also how does the lockout on the prosim work? I guess it is detecting the clutch input, does it let you change gears if you mis shift?
Saab.🙃
It should be working with a software, and yes, be able to lock the gears when clutch is not used. But I'm actually not sure if they ever release it.
Hi , any long-term review update for BDH ? Planing to get one , but i found BDH using mirco switch not hall sensor
Still haven't had anny issues with mine.
glad to hear that , they asking for 950 pounds now for BDH shifter , just place the order @ murrymotorsport , Thanks @@RVRCloset
I'm trying to decide between the Frex and the BDH, would you say that they could both be used for training driving a manual in real life or does only the BDH feel like a real gear shifter? I know they're very different price brackets but I can afford either one, I'm mainly concerned about realism (but if the Frex also feels realistic enough for training then I'll go with that option).
EDIT: Sorry I just realized you already replied to another comment asking basically the same thing
No worries. :)
For a normal road car feel I would go for the BDH. Frex falls more in the classic formula and prototype car category.
But as I said on the other comment, BDH is a small team, and I actually think they don't take any new orders at the moment do to high demands..
@@RVRCloset I think I'll have to go with the Frex then, I love classic formula cars in sim racing. Also don't wanna have to wait for the BDH. Cheers, thanks for the reply!
@@ZakFR You are welcome.👍
Where did you get the centre caps for your steering wheels on line. I'm looking to pick some up . 😊. Like your videos. Bdh looks very interesting are they going on sale soon.
Thanks mate!! :)
I bought the emblems here: onesimpro.com/emblemas/
The BDH is up for sale, and they have started shipping overseas, they only have a fb page so far: facebook.com/BDHRACINGSIMHARDWARE/
Thanks rvr problem though they won't ship to North America
@@geoffholden4655 Oh that's to bad, I have a friend in the states that have emblems on his rims, I can check where he bought his.
He said he got his emblems here, but they are not listed on the page, so you need to ask them: www.innatosr.com/
Ok yeah I did not see any emblems either. I will fire off an email to them. Thx
Hey my friend your Upload is amazing 🔥
Smashed the like button for you 👍
Thank you so much my friend!😍🍻
NNNNNNNNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! Great comparison homeboy.
Hehehehe, I know right, I did think the BDH was going to be good, but I was surprised how good!
Pro-Sim is awesome, but just not worth double the price of the BDH.
Hey, what's the song? Couldn't find it in the description or comments :D
My kid sister, it's called Fairytale. It used to be on Sportify, but not sure if it's still on there.
@@RVRCloset sadly I can't find it anywhere :/ but i also don't have spotify premium.
Surprising that this can still happen - not finding a certain song^^
Thanks anyway
@@JojoSptzle Ah okay, too bad..
😎😎 awesome news buddy!
Thanks buddy!
And a suitable name! XD
@@RVRCloset 🤣🤣 literally so applicable. It wasn't intentional I promise! 😎
@@bazookabill9232 😂👌
Another awesome video :) Are you really sure that bdh can compete with prosim? even OUTSIDE OF THE PRICE, only in function and feeling.
Thanks mate!
Yes I do think it can, they are different, and some aspects I find better on the BDH, like the engagement feel.
@@RVRCloset Thanks man, I ordered BDH also. keep uploading awesome videos. I love you reviews!. really really great and helpful!
@@gyujinyang2680 Thank you so much, and hope you get happy with it! Please let me know once you got it.🍻
@@RVRCloset Okay :)
I bought the BDH and i'm extremely satisfied. The shifter is amazing and really gives me that extra level of immersion! Are u still using the BDH?
Oh yes, my all time favorite shifter.😃👌
Blir nog en BDH shifter för mig sen, den verkar lite smidigare.
Jag den är lite lättare att placera på riggen, och tar inte upp lika mycket yta. Priset gör den väldigt fördelaktig också. :)
Where do you get one of these?
They only have a fb page so far. Search for BDH Race Sim Hardware.
very cool
Thanks mate!
welcome my friend, I was just looking for this model of gearbox and I came across your video :) I am making a Lebois Racing gearbox, do you know?@@RVRCloset
How would you rate this the Frex HShift? The BDH is almost double the price of the Frex for me so I just want to know if there are any major differences in feel to warrant the extra cost.
They feel very different. The BDH have a distinct tactile feel inbetween the gates. The Frex have a more constant resistance between the gates. I love them both, one thing to have in mind is that BDH is a really small two man operation, and I think the waiting time is pretty long at the moment, like +6 months if not more.
Where do I buy the BDH shifter if I don't have Facebook?
They have said they will have a webpage at some point, but I don't know when.
@@RVRCloset ok, nice. I'll just have to wait then.
Seems like the lock system for the Pro-Sim is a nice feature. I wish the BDH had the same.
@@DennisKarlsson Yeah that would have been cool!
Sadly the lock out system on the Pro-sim makes an already expensive shifter, crazy expensive..😅
So.. which one do you have mounted on your rig right now?
The BDH, I sold my Pro-Sim.
@@RVRCloset thnx!
You are welcome, and happy new year!🍻
@@RVRCloset 😄Happy New Year Buddy.
@@BDHRaceSimHardware You too mate! :D
How loud is the BDH compared to the Frex? You're the only one I know who has had both in their possession.
BDH is a lot louder.
@@RVRCloset Is it still loud on lower tension settings?
The tension make a big difference, but still a clunky shifter.
I would say the frex is one of the shifters that are easiest to shift quiet with, one of few I'm able to use when my wife is sleeping.
@@RVRCloset Thank you!
You are welcome.
Boa✌️
Thanks mate! :)
Try the V2/V3 Simvertex its like 700 Euro
Do they have a H pattern as well?
Or do you mean the SQ?
@@RVRCloset Yes they do. However their QC and customer services are terrible. Mine was stuck because of the defective milling. I would avoid this company in the future. Own the Simvertex V2, got it repaired/modified by myself. Still waiting for my BDH to come. Thank you so much for the comparison. What's the reason that you sold the Pro-Sim btw?
@@INKWALK Thank you so much for the input!👍
I was almost never able to use it since my wife started working night, it was too loud to use when she is sleeping.. The BDH have taken it's spot on the rig though so no harm done.😁👌
Looking forward hearing your thoughts on the BDH!
@@RVRCloset Thanks for the prompt reply. A British company called Base Performance Simulators had just became the exclusive supplier of the BDH. I think BDH itself no longer build/ship the shifter. Not sure how things will change. That was why I came up checking your review again to see if I would like to buy a pro-sim instead ( endless waiting as well ).
@@INKWALK Oh, more info I did not know, thanks again for the information!
Yeah sadly, how long is the waiting list for the BDH at the moment?
hard decision 🤔...
the scale tells me to stay with both 😌
It was hard! 😅 the scale wheying everything I gone through, and if I would buy one of them now, and could only pick one, I would pick the BDH.😃👌
🔨🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🔨 This gets a serious rat squashing approval rating from me!
Hahaha, thanks buddy!! I'm armed to the teeth ready to do some serious squashing!! XD
this guy doesn't have enough shifters
😅
Jag kan fortfarande inte välja. BDH hade varit solklart om det inte var för alla ändringar man kan göra på Quaife, som throw, sen hur neutral känns osv. Men framför allt throw, BDH ser ut att ha väldigt lite throw, vill inte att det känns för kort. :(
Jo BDH har lite kortare throw i originalutförande, går ju dock öka på om du förlänger spaken, dock har du lite lägre maxmotstånd på BDH mot Quaifen. Själv är jag van vid en ganska mjuk och lätt växelspak i min Saab, så brukar sätta mina växelspakar i riggen till 3-4 kilos motstånd.
@@RVRCloset Tack för svar. Min nuvarande har bara 1.2kg eller något, så allt över 2kg är bättre, haha. Men du upplever inte att BDH har FÖR kort throw? För den är lättare att mounta så det lutar mot den ändå.
BDH är min favorit, och sålde faktiskt Quaifen till slut.
@@RVRCloset Oj okej, vad fick du för den, om det är okej att jag frågar? Jag kör BDH också då.
Var ett bra tag sedan, och sålde den till en från USA, men har för mig omräkningen till sek landade på runt 13 tusen.