বাংলা তথা ভারতের নবজাগরণের প্রতিকৃত মহাত্মা রামমোহন রায়ের ২৫০ বছরের জন্মজয়ন্তীতে জানাই সশ্রদ্ধ প্রনাম, আর এই প্রতিবেদনের জন্যে আপনাকে জানাই অজস্র ধন্যবাদ
খুবই যৌক্তিক ও তথ্যসমৃদ্ধ আলোচনা। যাঁরা কাজ করেন, সমালোচনা তাঁদের নিয়েই হয়/হবে এটাই স্বাভাবিক। সমালোচকরা যেহেতু কোনো কাজ করেন না, তাই তাঁদের নিয়ে কোনো আলোচনাও হয় না।
খুব সুন্দর তথ্যসমৃদ্ধ আলোচনা৷আমরা ছোটবেলায় স্কুলে পাঠ্যবইতে যা পড়েছি তাতে রাজা রামমোহন রায় গোঁড়া হিন্দু পরিবারে জন্মগ্রহণ করলেও পৌত্তলিকতার বিরোধী ছিলেন৷তাঁর বাবার সাথে এই নিয়ে তুমুল বাক বিতন্ডা হয়েছিল৷মূর্তিপুজো তিনি মানতেন না৷স্বাভাবিকভাবেই হিন্দুশাস্ত্রের কুঃসংস্কারগুলোর প্রতি তাঁর চরম বিদ্বেষ ছিল৷এটা মনে রাখতে হবে তখনকার দিনে হিন্দু পন্ডিতরা অত্যন্ত ক্ষমতাশালী ছিলেন৷তাঁদের বিরুদ্ধে রুখে দাঁড়িয়ে সতীদাহর মত কুপ্রথা চিরতরে বন্ধ করা বিরাট কৃতিত্বের ব্যাপার৷তিনি কোনোভাবেই ব্রিটিশদের দালাল ছিলেন না৷ইংরেজরা তাঁকে যথেষ্ট শ্রদ্ধা ও সম্মান করতো৷এটা তো ঠিক ভারতে শিক্ষা বিস্তারে ইংরেজদের ভূমিকা ছিল৷সেই অন্ধকার সময়ে শিক্ষার আলো একান্ত আবশ্যক ছিল৷রাজা রামমোহন রায় প্রকৃত রেনেসাঁ বা নব জাগরনের পথিকৃৎ৷রবীন্দ্রনাথ তাঁর সঠিক মূল্যায়ন করেছিলেন৷
অসাধারণ বিশ্লেষণ যত দেখছি তত মুগ্ধ হয়ে যাচ্ছি অনেক অজানা তথ্য আমরা আজকে জানতে পারছি আপনার চ্যানেলের মাধ্যমে ধন্যবাদ দাদা আপনি আরও এই ধরনের ঐতিহাসিক নিদর্শন আমাদের সামনে নিয়ে আসো।
As far as I remember Swami Vivekananda said that rise of modern India started when Raja Ram Mohan Roy sailed for England to bring light in this dark nation.
@@rakhimukerji7937 Since long Raja was seeking to take the case of Satidaha to British monarch but the huge passage money was an obstacle. Therefore when Badshah requested him to present his case of "pension hike"before the king of England, he gladly agreed to the Badshah's request. The Mughal emperor promised to bear his expenses of to and fro journeys. Raja sailed off to England pleaded for both the cases, i.e. emperor's pension hike and satidaha, and won the both. However the emperor forgot his benefactor and did not send the return passage money. Desperately waiting for the money in Bristol he fell sick and breathed his last.
@@arijitkundu5577 please do not try to explain these idiots, they are the viewers of Jaipur Dualogs..they followed half knowledge Chadha historians. They ignored the words of Vivekananda, Rabindranath Vidyasagar about Raja Ram Mahan Roy.
@@tanmoymondal5721 India has glorious past as well as certain chapters not to be.proud of..The neofascist ideas will not do any good to either hinduism or to India
দ্য গল্পসল্পর প্রতিটি এপিসোড অত্যন্ত তাৎপর্যময় এবং জ্ঞান ভান্ডারকে সমৃদ্ধ করার মতো একটি চ্যানেল। উপস্থাপকের উপস্থাপন অত্যন্ত পরিস্কার, সাবলীল ও সুস্পষ্ট বর্ণনা বিমোহিত করে। বাংলাদেশ থেকে চ্যানেল ও উপস্থাপককে জানাই স্যালুট ও নিরন্তর শুভকামনা।
The new debate in India is that Sati was not there at all in Bengal, but only in Rajasthan, as told by Minaxi Jain, Rajiv Malhotra, and Avijit Chavra. Ram Mohan started his campaign to help the missionaries as he was a Christian. Please analyze this issue.
One of the greatest personality of Undivided Bengal.. he is also a great contributor of human resources of ordinary bengalis.. you have very nicely highlighted and explained.. the controversial topic.. thank you.. golposolpo.. best wishes and good luck.. satya-meba-jayate.. 🇮🇳🌺🙏
Thanks for discussing these controversial issues. Please also note that Rammohun Roy fought for freedom of press and in that respect he did not spare the British ruling class. He also criticised the drainage of Indian resources, especially monetary funds, by the British. In this context he expected the British to settle down in India and use their wealth in improving the infrastructure of this country and not take back the wealth to England thus impoverishing his country.
Apner discussion a Ami vison mukdho. Knowledge thaklei poribesona sundor hoina bt apner ta atoi vlo lage charipaser sob kichhu vule gie tonmoy hoye apner katha suni. Dhonnobad.
খুব ভালো লাগলো আপনার তথ্যনিষ্ঠ বিশ্লেষণ। আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ। তবে এই কুপ্রথাটি সমাজে এল কিভাবে? কোন সময় থেকে? বাংলার বাইরে ছিল কিনা? আকবর সহ মোগল রাজাদের এই প্রথাবিরোধী ইচ্ছার প্রকৃত কারণ কি? ইত্যাদি আপনার কাছে জানার আগ্রহ রইলো। নমস্কার নেবেন।
In those days, Ram mohan fought against religious superstitions. It was really courageous and heroic deeds. Nowadays, no body has courage to protest against increasing religious narrow ness.
SATYAJIT Rays contribution was.universal.BC Ray was.not part of the art.world but as a cheif minister of West Bengal he arranged to finance of Pather Panchali.Also he was the last cheif minister who had a vision for.future of WBENGAL and l improvement happened inspite of constant opposition of CPM
We Bengali muslims failed to get any enlightenment from this towering figure of Bengal. He ceased to be an upholder of any so called religion, he was a perfect and foremost renaissance man in whole of India. Not only hindus but muslims can also share his legacy of humanism.
Welcome your Episode Projected Excellently.We should not expect more what done by Raja Ram Mohan Roy as he was the Reformer not the Ruler.Some are always looking the clues how to underestimate the Reformer for their hidden prestigious causes that always maintaining till date. Muslim Rulers could not due to interfering others Believing Section that should not.Might be satiring what so ever but Raja Ram Mohan Roy did well what others researching the dark-side.
Now people like Minaxi Jain and Rajiv Malhotra are saying that there was no sati in Bengal but only in Rajasthan and Rammohan Roy was a British agent promoting Christianity. Please make a video to oppose these argument.
Whatever he did he did for the betterment of the Indian society through modern relevant education and brought about the reforms in the country. For advancement of any society reforms in many folds are necessary. For that goal one has to fight against the establishment which could be done with the help of cutting edge powrful establishment of the British Raj. He sacrificed his life for this noble cause which is difficult for many to realize sitting comfortably in a least prejudiced society where we are living now.
রমেশ চন্দ্র মজুমদার এর সম্বন্ধে আপনার assessment অত্যন্ত ভ্রান্তি মূলক। জানিনা আপনার bias kon ঐতাহিসিকতার প্রতি। RCM আপনার মত লোকের শিক্ষা ও আলোচনার অনেক উর্ধ্বে
আমার সম্পর্কে যা বলেছেন, মেনে নিলাম। তবে দেশ পত্রিকার গত সংখ্যার প্রাবন্ধিক শোভনলালবাবুর লেখাটি পড়তে অনুরোধ করছি। RCMকে বুঝতে সুবিধা হবে। আমি তো ভিডিওতে একজন সংকলকমাত্র। আমার কথার গুরুত্ব আর কি আছে, কিন্তু যাদের মূল্যায়ন সংকলিত করেছি, তাঁরা কেউ এলেবেলে নন। RCM বিখ্যাত ঐতিহাসিক, কিন্তু সমালোচকদের মতে, রামমোহন রায়কে নিয়ে তিনি biased ছিলেন।
He is a great patriot and fought against the superstition of Hindu rituals. 200 years ago it was necessary for Western culture to eradicate the Hindu superstition. He is the opener of renaissance in India.
Crucial point is as follows, even after 200 years of Raja Rammohan even today Bengali parents take pride to tell the stories of that great soul to their kids. And nobody cares who Rameshchandra Majumdar was or no one bothers what those demented historians told or lectured on.
R C Majumdar was India's greatest historian. He may have erred but one cannot deny his greatness. I am apalled to find that your channel wants to downgrade the contributions of this great historian, unless, of course, you are a communist sympathiser. Suttee was actually prevalent amongst the upper caste hindus of bengal and in Rajasthan. Very little is heard of forced suttee in Rajasthan. Suutte was never a pan Indian matter. The Macaulay education system has made us foot licking dogs of the west. Whereas, there are great researches going on in Germany on ancient Indian text, we just tease ourselves when we talk about our ancient culture. Very sad. Your research doesn't come with an open mind, dear GALPOSOLPO. I protest for denigrating one of the greatest historians of India.
@@santa4091 When you endorse something or someone as the greatest, then the statement should be time tested. Now, you may rethink because it seems that the "greatest" of yours badly failed in the test of time. Never say someone the greatest, because the dusts from under the carpet come out slowly. I hope I make it clear.
R c mojumdar and bankim chondro is forgotten because of their bias ness towards false history writing... Bangali don't understand how to write true history... because German introduce true history writing but Bangla is under British philosophical hegemony
@@santa4091 rc mojumdar was so radical and biased that neheru preferred other historian from Punjab to write official history of Indian freedom struggle...but no body in North India opposed the decision...as everyone of North India knows that 1857 mutiny was freedom struggle...
Ami akono video ti dekini pause kore comment ta korchi sir apni je image ta upload korechen amr tha bissas holo na mone hoi tar ulto ta bolte chaiche ।
Even if we consider Ram Mohan's intention to be noble but one cannot deny the fact that the English education that the British thrusted upon us through the notorious official Thomas Babington Macaulay broke the backbone of indigenous education. The Indians got modern education only to serve the colonial masters at the end of the day, although some positive aspects were definitely there!!!
Dear Mr. Majumdar, Yes, it is true that our olden education system was destroyed partially by British Education system. But do you think that if they would not come and rule it would had been worst for Original Hindus by the oppression of Islam Rulers. On top of that the cast system, which would have been much more to destroy , as lacs and lacs so called lower cast were converted to Islam and a part of Christianity. At least with modern education this was partially reduced.
@@shyamalsengupta2663 That's why I mentioned in the previous comment that some benefits of modern education were definitely there but as a whole the British intended to create a clerical class to serve them. The Indians were barred from holding the higher echelons of office. The British established railways, infrastructure, civil services etc to serve their selfish interests only. The Mughal Empire was dying a slow death after Aurangzeb's demise. The Marathas and the Sikhs subdued them and wrested back most of the territories by 18th century. Last but not the least I would suggest you to read "Castes of Mind" by Nicholas Dirks. It is a fantastic book regarding the reality of caste system in India.
@@rakhimukerji7937 Sure we needed modern ideas and philosophy, but who wants to remain a slave of the colonial masters forever after becoming enlightened with Western education? The higher posts in Civil services and military were reserved for the British only bcoz they didn't have faith in the integrity of the Indians. The British wanted a class of Western educated elite brown sahibs who will kowtow to their each and every command!!!
@@soumyadiptamajumder8795 So you mean to say a foreign writer has a thorough knowledge of caste system of India?British ra amader agriculture ar industry puro destroy kore diye geche,amader 100 bochor pichiye diye gache.nikrishtotomo jati.
The patriotism & great service of Rammohan is meaningless , all he did, said for India's benefit, we may oppose his style of action. He is really Raja.
Indian culture and civilization is like Diamond. Western polishing helped. One fellow English engineer once told me: "Our philosophy was enriched by Indian philosophy". Historically Sati-daho practice evolved by some narrow minded blind cruelty. But then why Joan of Arc was burnt alive ?
Bidese bichar namak jonistir antato astitwa chilo.joan of arc ero bichar hoyechilo. Akhono tar dalil dastabej bartaman. Amader ar bideser jnan er modhye farak bides tar jnan ke manuser kolyane proyog koreche.tar prasar kara hoyeche.kintu bharater jnan darsan ke kukshigata kore brahman bade samasta jatike dabiye rakhar astray hisabe babohar kara hoyeche.
আমার ভালোলাগার দেশ ভারত। তবে এ কথা বলতেই হয় আজকের এই কালচারাল ভারত তৈরির পিছনে ব্রিটিশ দের ভুমিকা অনেক। ভারতে ধর্মিয় প্রথার নাম দিয়ে যে কতো কুসংস্কার পালন করা হয়েছে তার হসেব নেই। এখনো কিছু কিছু যায়গায় কুসংস্কার আছে। তবে এখন ভারতের সংস্কৃতির যে অগ্রগতি তাতে খুব শিগ্রিই সব কুসংস্কার ভেসে যাবে।
একদম ঠিক বলেছেন। কোন ব্যাক্তির সমালোচনা করতে গেলে তাঁর সময়ের থেকে তুলে এনে বর্তমান সময় নিয়ে আলোচনা করলে চলবে না। রাজা রামমোহন রায় বাংলার নবজাগরণের পথিকৃৎ। এই কথাটা অস্বীকার করা মানে মিথ্যাচার। খুব সুন্দর বিশ্লেষণ করেছেন। ধন্যবাদ স্যার।
It is a very good deliberation. As far as you Sati was fully banned If any widow wants to be a sati she had to burn one of her finger without moaning or crying. The Sati custom was also referred on the Nobel Gone with the wind. Rhett Butler told of it to Scarlet O'Hara If Rammohan was not successful in his mission we would have got Meghnad Saha Satyendra nath Bose and other good scientist who helped us build modern India. By the way. Bhabani Charan Bandopadhyay was very much in favor of Sati. Professor Kalyan Kundu Paschim Pally Santiniketan Birbhum West Bengal
Rammohan was born in 1772 (1774 ?). Anti Act was passed in 1829. At that point of time the concept of "nation state " was not born in this part of the globe. Naturally in 1757 Bengal did not bother much about what was happening in Palasy on June that year. It not , therefore unnatural that not only the Raja but men like Dwarkanath or even Vidyasagsr did not say much against British rule. It was Dirojio (death 1830) who was cocious about the the "foreign" rule. He wrote , My fallen country ......" Though he was not born of Indian parents.
Yes The ISIS, Alquida,Boko Haram Taliban, Harkat Ul Ansari are doing the great jobs in slaughtering the innocent peoples in the name of darkness religion.
Kolkata= I am interested to donate something to your fund.Pl. display your a/c. no.+ branch + IFSC no.Thanks Yes, Netaji. is /was the product of British culture who fought for freedom.It has to be agreed , India became INDIA after Patelji's forceful acquisition of native States. This has been emphasised by actor Saif Ali Khan son of Ex. Indian Captain Pataudi Nawab.Joy Hind.
ভারতে যদি ব্রিটিশরা না আসতো তাহলে নবজাগরণ বা রেনেসাঁ হতো না আমরা এখনও সেই মধ্যযুগে পড়ে থাকতাম । সেইসময় ব্রিটিশ শাসনের অবশ্যই দরকার ছিল আমাদের স্বার্থেই ।
@@kinnormukherjee2231 এটা অপ্রিয় সত্যি কথা। বিজ্ঞানের আলো ভারত তখন দেখতে পেত না। তাই বলে ব্রিটিশ সরকারের অত্যাচারের কাহিনী অস্বীকার করা যায় না, আমি ওদের ঘৃণা করি।
@@sayanbanerjee7719 Many others.have tortured Indian prople.British are not the only.people.to do.it.Also.British were not the only people with advanced technology
@@rakhimukerji7937 yes There were French in Chandannagar, Dutch in Chinsurah, Portuguise in Goa, but they didn't have much power to abolish our superstitions, British were able to do it British were not the only nation with advanced technology, but at that time there was industrial revolution during 1740-80, in France, there was Political Crisis during French Revolution and later Napoleon, so industrial revolution took place in France in 1830-1860 So, at that time British was the most technologically developed nation
There is no British rule in Japan there is no British rule in Russia ,there is no British rule in China ,they don’t speak English,did you think that primitive ,did you think, what kind of a third rated argument you portray. This world is not run by the logic or truthfulness, this world is run by negative and power. Leave the silos of this leftist and you will understand. Truthful people like you present that time also, that’s why we are colonised.
In my humble efforts I tried my best to find out as to how & when Sati Daha started. In my research, I could not find, prior to medieval time, any historical evidences/materials to support that this inhuman social evils was part of Sanatana Dharma. No where in Vedas (Shruti) or Puranas (Smriti) or History (Ramayana/Mahabharata) mention Sati Daha protha. I gather, recently, a book on "Sati Daha" was published in India - I forgot the name of the author - a well known lady professor in UP.
Eta asampurna tathya Raja Ram Mohan Roy William Bentick ke bujhie ordinance jari korie chhilen companir amale. Tar pore kichhu brahman sampraday Privy Council e ta kharij karar jonno mamla kore mami dami Saheb barrister lagie. Ram Mohan Roy nije soal kore sei mamla 4 _ 3 sankha goristha judge er raie kharij koran. Uni soal kore na lorle sei ordinance kharij hote parto. Kajei Ram Mohan Roy kritto khato korar chesta Mane amader bemani ebang kritaghnata kora hobe. Tar karma kander mulyan korar khamata ek matra Vidyasagar Mosai i korte paren. Mone rakhte hobe tokhon banglai moghal sasan ar cholto na ebang bisrinkhala abastai chhilo. Job Charnok sambhabata 1680 khirstabde Patnai e ballya bibahita brahman konna ke sasan theke sati daho rukhe take bibah koren ebang tar nam Engela. Bora bori protirodh chhilo kintu ainer madhme Ram Mohan Roy na thakle samay khichhui hoto na.
Gentleman, you are also becoming a person giving judgement unfortunately. I interpreted this Chanel as a platform to showcase different opinions & views as prevailed time to time. Let the true flavour of history be flown like that only. After summarising all views & opinions none is expected to put forth final gist. Human behaviour can’t be captured in binary mode, I felt. Let people perceive the way they are capable, as per their level of intellect. This Chanel is yours, so you can do whatever you feel right. I am just sharing my thought. 🙏
Please note that it was Raja Ram Mohan Roy who was the prime mover to outlaw this barbaric custom perpretrated by the ignorant Hindus. Raja Ram Mohan Roy did not return to Hindustan and died in Bristol,England.
বাংলা তথা ভারতের নবজাগরণের প্রতিকৃত মহাত্মা রামমোহন রায়ের ২৫০ বছরের জন্মজয়ন্তীতে জানাই সশ্রদ্ধ প্রনাম, আর এই প্রতিবেদনের জন্যে আপনাকে জানাই অজস্র ধন্যবাদ
খুবই যৌক্তিক ও তথ্যসমৃদ্ধ আলোচনা। যাঁরা কাজ করেন, সমালোচনা তাঁদের নিয়েই হয়/হবে এটাই স্বাভাবিক। সমালোচকরা যেহেতু কোনো কাজ করেন না, তাই তাঁদের নিয়ে কোনো আলোচনাও হয় না।
একদম খাঁটি কথা।
খুব সুন্দর তথ্যসমৃদ্ধ আলোচনা৷আমরা ছোটবেলায় স্কুলে পাঠ্যবইতে যা পড়েছি তাতে রাজা রামমোহন রায় গোঁড়া হিন্দু পরিবারে জন্মগ্রহণ করলেও পৌত্তলিকতার বিরোধী ছিলেন৷তাঁর বাবার সাথে এই নিয়ে তুমুল বাক বিতন্ডা হয়েছিল৷মূর্তিপুজো তিনি মানতেন না৷স্বাভাবিকভাবেই হিন্দুশাস্ত্রের কুঃসংস্কারগুলোর প্রতি তাঁর চরম বিদ্বেষ ছিল৷এটা মনে রাখতে হবে তখনকার দিনে হিন্দু পন্ডিতরা অত্যন্ত ক্ষমতাশালী ছিলেন৷তাঁদের বিরুদ্ধে রুখে দাঁড়িয়ে সতীদাহর মত কুপ্রথা চিরতরে বন্ধ করা বিরাট কৃতিত্বের ব্যাপার৷তিনি কোনোভাবেই ব্রিটিশদের দালাল ছিলেন না৷ইংরেজরা তাঁকে যথেষ্ট শ্রদ্ধা ও সম্মান করতো৷এটা তো ঠিক ভারতে শিক্ষা বিস্তারে ইংরেজদের ভূমিকা ছিল৷সেই অন্ধকার সময়ে শিক্ষার আলো একান্ত আবশ্যক ছিল৷রাজা রামমোহন রায় প্রকৃত রেনেসাঁ বা নব জাগরনের পথিকৃৎ৷রবীন্দ্রনাথ তাঁর সঠিক মূল্যায়ন করেছিলেন৷
আপনার সাথে আমি সহমত। খুব সুন্দর লিখেছেন। আপনাকে অজস্র ধন্যবাদ।
আপনার সাথে আমি সহমত। খুব সুন্দর লিখেছেন। আপনাকে অজস্র ধন্যবাদ।
অসাধারণ বিশ্লেষণ যত দেখছি তত মুগ্ধ হয়ে যাচ্ছি অনেক অজানা তথ্য আমরা আজকে জানতে পারছি আপনার চ্যানেলের মাধ্যমে ধন্যবাদ দাদা আপনি আরও এই ধরনের ঐতিহাসিক নিদর্শন আমাদের সামনে নিয়ে আসো।
আপনার অসাধারণ তথ্যসমৃদ্ধ ব্যাক্ষ্যা সত্যিই মনমুগ্ধকর এবং অতবড় দেশহিতৈষী মানুষটির প্রতি যথার্থ মূল্যায়ন করেছে ,ধন্যবাদ আপনাকে।
Apnar bisleshan jathajatha
আপনার মতো পষ্টবাদী ইউটিউব চ্যানেল কর্তৃপক্ষ ধন্যবাদ জানাই।
অসাধারণ আলোচনা। অনেক নতুন তথ্য জানা গেল। আমি আপনার নান্দনিক উপস্থাপনা ও তথ্য বহুল আলোচনা শুনার অপেক্ষা করি। নমস্কার।
As far as I remember Swami Vivekananda said that rise of modern India started when Raja Ram Mohan Roy sailed for England to bring light in this dark nation.
HE WENT TO TALK ABOUT THE PENSIONS OF THE Mughal Badshah.Raja title was given by Badshah
@@rakhimukerji7937 Since long Raja was seeking to take the case of Satidaha to British monarch but the huge passage money was an obstacle. Therefore when Badshah requested him to present his case of "pension hike"before the king of England, he gladly agreed to the Badshah's request. The Mughal emperor promised to bear his expenses of to and fro journeys. Raja sailed off to England pleaded for both the cases, i.e. emperor's pension hike and satidaha, and won the both. However the emperor forgot his benefactor and did not send the return passage money. Desperately waiting for the money in Bristol he fell sick and breathed his last.
@@arijitkundu5577 .
@@arijitkundu5577 please do not try to explain these idiots, they are the viewers of Jaipur Dualogs..they followed half knowledge Chadha historians. They ignored the words of Vivekananda, Rabindranath Vidyasagar about Raja Ram Mahan Roy.
@@tanmoymondal5721 India has glorious past as well as certain chapters not to be.proud of..The neofascist ideas will not do any good to either hinduism or to India
👍👍. খুব ভালো লাগলো । আপনাকে ধন্যবাদ, শুভেচ্ছা ও কৃজ্ঞতা জানাই এই সুন্দর প্রতিবেদনের জন্য।
অজস্র ধন্যবাদ।
দ্য গল্পসল্পর প্রতিটি এপিসোড অত্যন্ত তাৎপর্যময় এবং জ্ঞান ভান্ডারকে সমৃদ্ধ করার মতো একটি চ্যানেল। উপস্থাপকের উপস্থাপন অত্যন্ত পরিস্কার, সাবলীল ও সুস্পষ্ট বর্ণনা বিমোহিত করে।
বাংলাদেশ থেকে চ্যানেল ও উপস্থাপককে জানাই স্যালুট ও নিরন্তর শুভকামনা।
The new debate in India is that Sati was not there at all in Bengal, but only in Rajasthan, as told by Minaxi Jain, Rajiv Malhotra, and Avijit Chavra. Ram Mohan started his campaign to help the missionaries as he was a Christian. Please analyze this issue.
One of the greatest personality of Undivided Bengal.. he is also a great contributor of human resources of ordinary bengalis.. you have very nicely highlighted and explained.. the controversial topic.. thank you.. golposolpo.. best wishes and good luck.. satya-meba-jayate.. 🇮🇳🌺🙏
Absolutely right. Raja Rammohan Roy pioneered the awakening of bengal n we reverentially acknowledge our debt to this illustrious son of bengal.
Thanks for discussing these controversial issues. Please also note that Rammohun Roy fought for freedom of press and in that respect he did not spare the British ruling class.
He also criticised the drainage of Indian resources, especially monetary funds, by the British. In this context he expected the British to settle down in India and use their wealth in improving the infrastructure of this country and not take back the wealth to England thus impoverishing his country.
He is a pionerr of our society and his thoughts are still relevant in order to socia
Add reply
খুব ভাল,এই ইতিহাসের আগা গোড়া সবিস্তার ,আপনার কাছথেকে জেনে খুশি হলাম।ধন্যবাদ।
এতটা জামতাম না ! এমন সুন্দর ঐতিহাসিক তথ্য তুলে ধরার জন্য ধন্যবাদ।
অসাধারণ যুক্তি দিয়ে আলোচনা।
এই চ্যানেলের তথ্য সমৃদ্ধ সব ভিডিওগুলি ই আমার খুব ভালো লাগে
Well explained about Raja Ram Mohan. Thanks a lot.
বাঙালি জাতির অগ্রদূত রামমোহন রায়। কোন সন্দেহ নাই, যে কোন বিবেচনায়!
Love him (Ram Mohan Roy)very much
form my heart ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
আপনার বিশ্লেষণি আলোচনা খুবই ভাল লাগে। আপনার দীর্ঘায়ূ কামনা করি।
ধন্যবাদ
Akdom thik,valo laglo 🙏🏻 Pala Dutta
Apner discussion a Ami vison mukdho. Knowledge thaklei poribesona sundor hoina bt apner ta atoi vlo lage charipaser sob kichhu vule gie tonmoy hoye apner katha suni. Dhonnobad.
আপনার আলোচনা অত্যন্ত মূল্যবান ।
An intelligent presentation about Raja Ram Mohan roy.pranam.
The administration of British was better than present India. I support Raja Ram Mohan Roy.
খুব ভালো লাগলো আপনার তথ্যনিষ্ঠ বিশ্লেষণ।
আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ।
তবে এই কুপ্রথাটি সমাজে এল কিভাবে? কোন সময় থেকে? বাংলার বাইরে ছিল কিনা? আকবর সহ মোগল রাজাদের এই প্রথাবিরোধী ইচ্ছার প্রকৃত কারণ কি? ইত্যাদি আপনার কাছে জানার আগ্রহ রইলো।
নমস্কার নেবেন।
Narrator's voice , expression ,attitude follow the topic ! I'm really eager to these historic short notes full of culture ! Thanks !
Thanks a lot.
In those days, Ram mohan fought
against religious superstitions.
It was really courageous and heroic deeds.
Nowadays, no body has courage to protest against increasing religious narrow ness.
Thanks a lot for your comment
যবন্ দের হাত থেকে বাঁচাতে বিধবাদের অন্য পথ ছিল না। এখন সবাই সত্যিটা বললে সেকুলার গিরি হারানোর ভয় পায়
Congratulations.
Superlative narration after detailed research.
To me he was first person on Bengalee resonance and the last one was Dr B.C Roy.
No. Last one was Satyajit Ray .
SATYAJIT Rays contribution was.universal.BC Ray was.not part of the art.world but as a cheif minister of West Bengal he arranged to
finance of Pather Panchali.Also he was the last cheif minister who had a vision for.future of WBENGAL and l improvement happened inspite of constant opposition of CPM
ভিডিওটি খুব সুন্দর লাগলো
আমার সবচেয়ে প্রিয় you tube চ্যানেল।
We Bengali muslims failed to get any enlightenment from this towering figure of Bengal. He ceased to be an upholder of any so called religion, he was a perfect and foremost renaissance man in whole of India. Not only hindus but muslims can also share his legacy of humanism.
Thanks for your valuable comment.
@@thegalposalpo you are most welcome, I voraciously observe your lectures.
@@taufiquealamtusan I can say Thank you..this is what everyone should feel..as a muslim you are feeling same as us..i m really seeing light
আপনার পরিবেশনা অসাধারণ
অসাধারণ বিশ্লেষণ
Welcome your Episode Projected Excellently.We should not expect more what done by Raja Ram Mohan Roy as he was the Reformer not the Ruler.Some are always looking the clues how to underestimate the Reformer for their hidden prestigious causes that always maintaining till date.
Muslim Rulers could not due to interfering others Believing Section that should not.Might be satiring what so ever but Raja Ram Mohan Roy did well what others researching the dark-side.
Now people like Minaxi Jain and Rajiv Malhotra are saying that there was no sati in Bengal but only in Rajasthan and Rammohan Roy was a British agent promoting Christianity. Please make a video to oppose these argument.
সত্য তুলে ধরার জন্য ধন্যবাদ।
বাল এর সত্যি বলছে।
সেই সময় শিক্ষার সুযোগ( tole যে শিক্ষা চালু ছিল) কি সবাই পেত ? রাজা রামমোহন এর অবদান অনস্বীকার্য ।
"Know the historians before read history ". This famous line is very much relevance here.
রাজা রামমোহন রায়ের ২৫০তম জন্মজয়ন্তীতে তাঁকে প্রনাম আর আপনাকে অসংখ্য ধন্যবাদ। আপনি প্রকৃত গবেষক এবং অতি উচ্চমানের বক্তা।
আমি গবেষক নই। ভালো লাগে বলে একটু নাড়াচাড়া করি। মন্তব্যের জন্য ধন্যবাদ।
@@thegalposalpo আমার ক্ষুদ্র বুদ্ধিতে আপনাকে গবেষক বলেই মনে হয়েছে। আপনার নিরপেক্ষতা ও অনুসন্ধানের ক্ষমতা প্রশংসনীয়।
🔥🎉
Nice.... Very good
Whatever he did he did for the betterment of the Indian society through modern relevant education and brought about the reforms in the country. For advancement of any society reforms in many folds are necessary. For that goal one has to fight against the establishment which could be done with the help of cutting edge powrful establishment of the British Raj. He sacrificed his life for this noble cause which is difficult for many to realize sitting comfortably in a least prejudiced society where we are living now.
আপনার প্রতিটি ভিডিও আমার ভাল লাগে।অনেক কিছু জানতে পারি।
রমেশ চন্দ্র মজুমদার এর সম্বন্ধে আপনার assessment অত্যন্ত ভ্রান্তি মূলক। জানিনা আপনার bias kon ঐতাহিসিকতার প্রতি।
RCM আপনার মত লোকের শিক্ষা ও আলোচনার অনেক উর্ধ্বে
আমার সম্পর্কে যা বলেছেন, মেনে নিলাম। তবে দেশ পত্রিকার গত সংখ্যার প্রাবন্ধিক শোভনলালবাবুর লেখাটি পড়তে অনুরোধ করছি। RCMকে বুঝতে সুবিধা হবে। আমি তো ভিডিওতে একজন সংকলকমাত্র। আমার কথার গুরুত্ব আর কি আছে, কিন্তু যাদের মূল্যায়ন সংকলিত করেছি, তাঁরা কেউ এলেবেলে নন। RCM বিখ্যাত ঐতিহাসিক, কিন্তু সমালোচকদের মতে, রামমোহন রায়কে নিয়ে তিনি biased ছিলেন।
He is a great patriot and fought against the superstition of Hindu rituals.
200 years ago it was necessary for Western culture to eradicate the Hindu superstition.
He is the opener of renaissance in India.
Very important matter thanks
Robindro nath o mahatma Gandhi debate kintu hoyesilo tilak ke Niya noy , borong ram mohon Roy ke niye...
অসাধারণ , খুব ভালো লাগলো।
অসাধারণ।
Crucial point is as follows, even after 200 years of Raja Rammohan even today Bengali parents take pride to tell the stories of that great soul to their kids. And nobody cares who Rameshchandra Majumdar was or no one bothers what those demented historians told or lectured on.
Well said. Thanks by heart.
R C Majumdar was India's greatest historian. He may have erred but one cannot deny his greatness. I am apalled to find that your channel wants to downgrade the contributions of this great historian, unless, of course, you are a communist sympathiser.
Suttee was actually prevalent amongst the upper caste hindus of bengal and in Rajasthan. Very little is heard of forced suttee in Rajasthan. Suutte was never a pan Indian matter. The Macaulay education system has made us foot licking dogs of the west. Whereas, there are great researches going on in Germany on ancient Indian text, we just tease ourselves when we talk about our ancient culture. Very sad. Your research doesn't come with an open mind, dear GALPOSOLPO. I protest for denigrating one of the greatest historians of India.
@@santa4091 When you endorse something or someone as the greatest, then the statement should be time tested. Now, you may rethink because it seems that the "greatest" of yours badly failed in the test of time. Never say someone the greatest, because the dusts from under the carpet come out slowly. I hope I make it clear.
R c mojumdar and bankim chondro is forgotten because of their bias ness towards false history writing... Bangali don't understand how to write true history... because German introduce true history writing but Bangla is under British philosophical hegemony
@@santa4091 rc mojumdar was so radical and biased that neheru preferred other historian from Punjab to write official history of Indian freedom struggle...but no body in North India opposed the decision...as everyone of North India knows that 1857 mutiny was freedom struggle...
Ami akono video ti dekini pause kore comment ta korchi sir apni je image ta upload korechen amr tha bissas holo na mone hoi tar ulto ta bolte chaiche ।
তথ্য সমৃদ্ধ আলোচনা।কিন্তু এক ই সাথে তথ্য সূত্র গুলো দিলে উপকৃত হব।
তথ্যসূত্র ভিডিওর শেষে অথবা ডিডিওর ডেসক্রিপশন বক্সে দেওয়া আছে।
@@thegalposalpo অনেক ধন্যবাদ।আমি ওটা পরে দেখলাম...
Love from Bangladesh... love u sir
অসাধারণ সুন্দর অবতারণা।
EXCELLENT
Even if we consider Ram Mohan's intention to be noble but one cannot deny the fact that the English education that the British thrusted upon us through the notorious official Thomas Babington Macaulay broke the backbone of indigenous education. The Indians got modern education only to serve the colonial masters at the end of the day, although some positive aspects were definitely there!!!
Dear Mr. Majumdar,
Yes, it is true that our olden education system was destroyed partially by British Education system. But do you think that if they would not come and rule it would had been worst for Original Hindus by the oppression of Islam Rulers. On top of that the cast system, which would have been much more to destroy , as lacs and lacs so called lower cast were converted to Islam and a part of Christianity. At least with modern education this was partially reduced.
@@shyamalsengupta2663 That's why I mentioned in the previous comment that some benefits of modern education were definitely there but as a whole the British intended to create a clerical class to serve them. The Indians were barred from holding the higher echelons of office. The British established railways, infrastructure, civil services etc to serve their selfish interests only.
The Mughal Empire was dying a slow death after Aurangzeb's demise. The Marathas and the Sikhs subdued them and wrested back most of the territories by 18th century.
Last but not the least I would suggest you to read "Castes of Mind" by Nicholas Dirks. It is a fantastic book regarding the reality of caste system in India.
@@soumyadiptamajumder8795 The British wanted clerks but english education brought science.and modern technology.We badly needed it.
@@rakhimukerji7937 Sure we needed modern ideas and philosophy, but who wants to remain a slave of the colonial masters forever after becoming enlightened with Western education? The higher posts in Civil services and military were reserved for the British only bcoz they didn't have faith in the integrity of the Indians. The British wanted a class of Western educated elite brown sahibs who will kowtow to their each and every command!!!
@@soumyadiptamajumder8795 So you mean to say a foreign writer has a thorough knowledge of caste system of India?British ra amader agriculture ar industry puro destroy kore diye geche,amader 100 bochor pichiye diye gache.nikrishtotomo jati.
Ram Mohan Roy is the bestman also Greatman for the uncivilised and narrow minded Indian.Ram Mohan Roy is my greatest HERO.
Excellent dada so well explained!
The patriotism & great service of Rammohan is meaningless , all he did, said for India's benefit, we may oppose his style of action. He is really Raja.
?
হুঁ হুঁ, এজন্য তাঁকে অকাল মৃত্যুর সম্মুখীন হতে হয়েছিল। এ প্রথা অন্যায় অমানবিক, সকলের জানা।ধন্যবাদ, নমস্কার।
ধন্যবাদ
Indian culture and civilization is like Diamond. Western polishing helped. One fellow English engineer once told me: "Our philosophy was enriched by Indian philosophy". Historically Sati-daho practice evolved by some narrow minded blind cruelty. But then why Joan of Arc was burnt alive ?
Bidese bichar namak jonistir antato astitwa chilo.joan of arc ero bichar hoyechilo. Akhono tar dalil dastabej bartaman.
Amader ar bideser jnan er modhye farak bides tar jnan ke manuser kolyane proyog koreche.tar prasar kara hoyeche.kintu bharater jnan darsan ke kukshigata kore brahman bade samasta jatike dabiye rakhar astray hisabe babohar kara hoyeche.
আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ💐💐💐💐💐
তখন কার পরিপ্রেক্ষিতে রামমোহন ঠিক ছিলেন
আমার ভালোলাগার দেশ ভারত। তবে এ কথা বলতেই হয় আজকের এই কালচারাল ভারত তৈরির পিছনে ব্রিটিশ দের ভুমিকা অনেক। ভারতে ধর্মিয় প্রথার নাম দিয়ে যে কতো কুসংস্কার পালন করা হয়েছে তার হসেব নেই। এখনো কিছু কিছু যায়গায় কুসংস্কার আছে। তবে এখন ভারতের সংস্কৃতির যে অগ্রগতি তাতে খুব শিগ্রিই সব কুসংস্কার ভেসে যাবে।
এ ব্যপারে মুসলিম শাসকদের অনেক অবদান ছিল।
Sir
Thank you for such a valuable topic .
Thank you.
Welcome
একদম ঠিক বলেছেন। কোন ব্যাক্তির সমালোচনা করতে গেলে তাঁর সময়ের থেকে তুলে এনে বর্তমান সময় নিয়ে আলোচনা করলে চলবে না। রাজা রামমোহন রায় বাংলার নবজাগরণের পথিকৃৎ। এই কথাটা অস্বীকার করা মানে মিথ্যাচার। খুব সুন্দর বিশ্লেষণ করেছেন। ধন্যবাদ স্যার।
খুব ভালো লাগলো। এইরকম সত্যি ইতিহাস জানতে চাই।
ধন্যবাদ ভাই।
ধন্যবাদ
It is a very good deliberation. As far as you Sati was fully banned
If any widow wants to be a sati she had to burn one of her finger without moaning or crying. The Sati custom was also referred on the Nobel Gone with the wind. Rhett Butler told of it to Scarlet O'Hara
If Rammohan was not successful in his mission we would have got Meghnad Saha Satyendra nath Bose and other good scientist who helped us build modern India.
By the way. Bhabani Charan Bandopadhyay was very much in favor of Sati. Professor Kalyan Kundu Paschim Pally Santiniketan Birbhum West Bengal
Thanks for your valuable comment.
Rammohan was born in 1772 (1774 ?). Anti Act was passed in 1829. At that point of time the concept of "nation state " was not born in this part of the globe. Naturally in 1757 Bengal did not bother much about what was happening in Palasy on June that year. It not , therefore unnatural that not only the Raja but men like Dwarkanath or even Vidyasagsr did not say much against British rule. It was Dirojio (death 1830) who was cocious about the the "foreign" rule.
He wrote , My fallen country ......" Though he was not born of Indian parents.
Anybody born in India is Indian. Derozio was 100% Indian
darun laglo
Any deregatory remark against of raja rammohon roy iz strongly regrettable & shameful act
অপূর্ব
Thanks
নতুন একজন রামমোহন রায় কে চায়
সতীদাহ গিয়েছিল,আজ নবদাহ দৃশ্যমান!
সামপ্রদায়িকতার নবদাহ কে বা কারা রুখবে?
Yes The ISIS, Alquida,Boko Haram Taliban, Harkat Ul Ansari are doing the great jobs in slaughtering the innocent peoples in the name of darkness religion.
কী পরিমান সতীদাহ হয়েছিল ?
সাল ভিত্তিক পরিসংখ্যান পাওয়া যাবে ?
ভালো তথ্য
young Bengal Association kothai bad gelo arr William Carrie?
Thanks 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
সত্য কথা বলেছেন
Many many thanks dada
Welcome.
Kolkata= I am interested to donate something to your fund.Pl. display your a/c. no.+ branch + IFSC no.Thanks Yes, Netaji. is /was the product of British culture who fought for freedom.It has to be agreed , India became INDIA after Patelji's forceful acquisition of native States. This has been emphasised by actor Saif Ali Khan son of Ex. Indian Captain Pataudi Nawab.Joy Hind.
Thanks
Raja was a visionary
Sathik tathya jene khoob bhalo laglo.
ভারতে যদি ব্রিটিশরা না আসতো তাহলে নবজাগরণ বা রেনেসাঁ হতো না আমরা এখনও সেই মধ্যযুগে পড়ে থাকতাম । সেইসময় ব্রিটিশ শাসনের অবশ্যই দরকার ছিল আমাদের স্বার্থেই ।
ওই ভাবনা তেই থাকুন
@@kinnormukherjee2231 এটা অপ্রিয় সত্যি কথা। বিজ্ঞানের আলো ভারত তখন দেখতে পেত না। তাই বলে ব্রিটিশ সরকারের অত্যাচারের কাহিনী অস্বীকার করা যায় না, আমি ওদের ঘৃণা করি।
@@sayanbanerjee7719 Many others.have tortured Indian prople.British are not the only.people.to do.it.Also.British were not the only people with advanced technology
@@rakhimukerji7937 yes
There were French in Chandannagar, Dutch in Chinsurah, Portuguise in Goa, but they didn't have much power to abolish our superstitions, British were able to do it
British were not the only nation with advanced technology, but at that time there was industrial revolution during 1740-80, in France, there was Political Crisis during French Revolution and later Napoleon, so industrial revolution took place in France in 1830-1860
So, at that time British was the most technologically developed nation
There is no British rule in Japan there is no British rule in Russia ,there is no British rule in China ,they don’t speak English,did you think that primitive ,did you think, what kind of a third rated argument you portray. This world is not run by the logic or truthfulness, this world is run by negative and power. Leave the silos of this leftist and you will understand. Truthful people like you present that time also, that’s why we are colonised.
In my humble efforts I tried my best to find out as to how & when Sati Daha started. In my research, I could not find, prior to medieval time, any historical evidences/materials to support that this inhuman social evils was part of Sanatana Dharma. No where in Vedas (Shruti) or Puranas (Smriti) or History (Ramayana/Mahabharata) mention Sati Daha protha. I gather, recently, a book on "Sati Daha" was published in India - I forgot the name of the author - a well known lady professor in UP.
A*/*
He was a great man.
Eta asampurna tathya Raja Ram Mohan Roy William Bentick ke bujhie ordinance jari korie chhilen companir amale. Tar pore kichhu brahman sampraday Privy Council e ta kharij karar jonno mamla kore mami dami Saheb barrister lagie. Ram Mohan Roy nije soal kore sei mamla 4 _ 3 sankha goristha judge er raie kharij koran. Uni soal kore na lorle sei ordinance kharij hote parto. Kajei Ram Mohan Roy kritto khato korar chesta Mane amader bemani ebang kritaghnata kora hobe. Tar karma kander mulyan korar khamata ek matra Vidyasagar Mosai i korte paren. Mone rakhte hobe tokhon banglai moghal sasan ar cholto na ebang bisrinkhala abastai chhilo. Job Charnok sambhabata 1680 khirstabde Patnai e ballya bibahita brahman konna ke sasan theke sati daho rukhe take bibah koren ebang tar nam Engela. Bora bori protirodh chhilo kintu ainer madhme Ram Mohan Roy na thakle samay khichhui hoto na.
১৮১৯ সালে স্বতিদাহ প্রথা উচ্ছেদের বিরুদ্ধে বই লিখলেন ? (ভিডীও তে ৪ মিনিট ৮ সেকেন্ড)
তো?
অসাধারণ
Raja rammohon roy iz regarded as the father of the modern india,a fronliner of navajagaran,
Women shouĺd come out& make strong agitation against such condemmable thought by some very cheap_ minded people
Gentleman, you are also becoming a person giving judgement unfortunately. I interpreted this Chanel as a platform to showcase different opinions & views as prevailed time to time. Let the true flavour of history be flown like that only. After summarising all views & opinions none is expected to put forth final gist. Human behaviour can’t be captured in binary mode, I felt. Let people perceive the way they are capable, as per their level of intellect.
This Chanel is yours, so you can do whatever you feel right. I am just sharing my thought. 🙏
Ami cai ai protha abr chalu Huk. Joy ma Kali 🌷🌷
Please note that it was Raja Ram Mohan Roy who was the prime mover to outlaw this barbaric custom perpretrated by the ignorant Hindus. Raja Ram Mohan Roy did not return to Hindustan and died in Bristol,England.
Thanks for your comment
সংস্কৃতিক জাতীয় বাদে জনক ছিলেন
মেয়েদের উপর বিধান চাপান। যুগে যুগে।
Raja Ramohon Roy was our solution maker
রাজা রামমোহন রায়।