Best Pliers (TONGUE & GROOVE)? Knipex vs Fujiya, Irwin, Klein Tools, Channellock, Doyle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 жов 2021
- AMAZING difference among the brands! BRANDS TESTED: Knipex, Gedore, Stanley, Channellock, Irwin, Doyle, Klein Tools, Husky, GearWrench, S&R, Fujiya, Stanley Fatmax, and Hautmec. Pliers tested for maximum grip on threaded and non-threaded metal, including mild, medium, and very hard steel. The best performers are simply AMAZING compared to the poor performers. So, brand selection does indeed make a huge difference. I purchased all of the products tested to ensure unbiased testing. So, thank you for supporting the channel.
➡ Thank you very much for supporting the channel: / projectfarm
➡ An easy way to find past videos along with products tested: bit.ly/2FCrBpk A big thanks to Jim for putting this together.
➡ Merch: www.Project-Farm.com
➡ Click here if you'd like to subscribe: / @projectfarm
➡ As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
➡ Products Tested In This Video (in no particular order):
Knipex: amzn.to/3DOrGPS
Gedore: amzn.to/3aMkpmW
Channellock: amzn.to/3vj1aeg
Klein Tools: amzn.to/3aK0hlr
Hautmec: amzn.to/2XidkHG
S&R: amzn.to/3lMXRJ9
LAOA: amzn.to/3p8O0zr
Gearwrench: amzn.to/3lNh65r
Stanley: amzn.to/3vhdQ5e
Irwin: amzn.to/3n0JQXF
Fujiya: amzn.to/3mTZ5Sg
Stanley Fatmax (set of 2 pliers): amzn.to/3AM8EaD
Doyle: Sold at Harbor Freight
Husky: Sold at Home Depot
Videography Equipment:
Sony DSC-RX10 III Cyber-shot Digital Still Camera: amzn.to/2YdXvPw
Canon 70D Camera: amzn.to/31b5Gy0
Azden Microphone: amzn.to/34d3DLE
Go Pro Bundle: amzn.to/3Ca0ZVN
This video is only for entertainment purposes. If you rely on the information portrayed in this video, you assume the responsibility for the results. Project Farm LLC - Навчання та стиль
The dedication this man has is incredible. You should do folding knives next!
Great suggestion! Which brands do you suggest testing? I'll check back later to see the suggestions from everyone.
Bench made 940 Osborne
2nd bechmade, Spiderco, Gerber
@@ProjectFarm would be good to learn about the 500 different grades of steel most folding knife brands advertise and comparing edge retention sharpenning and durability
@@ProjectFarm i would suggest gerber, coldsteel and spyderco.
I've been a fan of Knipex for nearly 15 years. There's a reason everyone copied their design. 8-10 years ago, they were the only pliers that looked like that. (Edit: in the USA, anyway) Great review, as always!
Yea i was wondering if the patent had run out or how come every other manufacturer has just straight up copied knipex. Or maybe it was never even patented.
Yeah i believe the patent ran out thats why everyone copied, they can copy all they want but almost no one can match the steel and casting quality of knipex
I've got a few Channelocks that are older and they just have pretty straight jaws. I'm usually quite happy with their performance. Not everything is a pipe.
I've had a set of old channel locks for many, many Moon! They have let me down a few times but not recently. I guess if I start having more issues I know what to buy.
Same here. I bought the 5 piece set with the 6 8 10 18 & 24 inch. Glad to see the quality hasn't suffered with the price reduction.
Own a car repair shop, Knipex are, by far, the best pliers out there. If you want a plier that slips and rounds off bolts, use something else. Great video!
European brands in general, Wiha, Knipex, Gedore, Unior, Bahco, Hazet, Stahlwille.
Thanks!
Same, went through 3 different brands, trying to save a buck, ended up only the knipex could get the bolt off
And boxo have proven to be quite good, at least in my experience
I might have to check them out, the Milwaukee pliers were absolute trash so I upgraded to the heavy duty Crescent (Black and orange with far more aggressive teeth) and they’ve been very good so far.
It's nice that Knipex has performed so well, I work for Knipex.
I was already clear that they perform best because they are manufactured with much love and should last a long time.We have very high quality standards.
Thanks for the feedback.
thanks for making a great product! I've got all 100 through 300 size cobras, and use em for everything.
Lol is it, K ni pex or n I pex?
@@clion520 i don´t know , why english native speakers allways dropp the "K" if an "N" follows, but in german you pronounce the "K" in the beginning. Most native native german speakers pronounce the word like "Cnippex" - the emphasis goes not on the "i" but on the "p", while the company itself emphases the "i".
So officially its more sound like "Cneepex".
@@Teuronium just how my boss who introduced me to the brand pronounced it. Thanks for the info.
I have owned the Knipex Cobra presented here for about 40 years and have still not been able to break it. All the other Knipex pliers I own - there are many of them - have also never let me down.
My oldest Knipex was given to me by my grandfather and it has served well for a good 100 years.
Thanks for sharing.
100 years? Those Germans man... they’ve always been a cut above in engineering.
The Knipex brand name was registered first time in 1942, 80 years ago.
The Knipex brand was actually only registered in 1942.
This was necessary because Knipex wanted to enter the international market.
In fact, the company was founded in 1882.
I often wonder what would become of Germans if they were allowed to continue the quality they proved in industry but war destroyed much of their ability to do things they way they used to for local needs. Mono-culturism promoted by the parasitic entity pushing a false spam-de-mic, propaganda, sodom-mites and printing legal tender is actually the real disease of mankind. Here in Japan war happened before Men could use their minds for the industrial revolution so they rely on precision machines and organized systems to make sure Men are not made responsible for their own thinking or abilities. When social credit systems come into play the System will gain again from Mankind and not the other way around.
It's seriously hard to quantify how valuable your tests are. Unbiased factual real-world applications. Thank you
You are welcome!
Manufacturers must hate Project Farm Sundays, lol, especially when the named brands get trounced by the much cheaper generic tools... Thus proving, your only actually paying for the name, not quality!
@@Denathorn well 700k people are not manufacturers but users , lol
@@sdqsdq6274 are you for real… He’s not testing 700k different brands of the same product, not unreasonable to think 10 people from various companies view these out of 700k is it? Unless of course, your logic is a bit backward, lol
just bought all my work tools based on his videos. one tool at a time
Suggestion: Allen or Hex Wrenches, there are some really cheap ones and some really pricey ones, I'd be interested to see the differences. Great video!
Yes... I hate it when a cheap allen wrench strips out a screw. Would love to know what brand holds up better.
I second this, I'd be happy to invest in a good set if I knew what was a good set.
yes please @Project Farm
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
That would be a great video! Been using a brand named titan extra long for awhile.. but I'd love to see the new wera ones.
Just wanted to say THANK YOU for spending the time to look at the feedback in the comments. I suggested something like 15-20 different things to review and you've done over half of them through the last 6 months. Definitely have helped me spend my money efficiently. Keep doing what you're doing
You had me questioning my faith in Knipex pliers early in the video, but they triumphed in the end!
Have been using Knipex pliers since 2003, and haven't bought anything else since.
Great review!
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Right on. I feel the same way using them till I die.
i know i have said this before PF. but, some of your testing rigs are straight up genius! as an old army engineer it warms my cold dead heart to see someone who thinks "outside the box!" SALUTE!
Thank you very much!!
Another good thing about these are consistently good microscope shots, a lab grade freezer, and reliable (I think!) digital scales and other measuring devices! 👍🏼😎✌🏼
I like that he does tests that you clearly see how the product functions. And not just some statics that don't translate to real use.
.."cold dead heart"?..so..you're a ghost?...
when you have seen some of the things i have seen that people do to each other and seen them live and in color. it has a tendency to make you jaded in the heart dept.
As a hopeless nostalgic and a proud Pennsylvanian, I LOVE Channellock Tools. But. I am seriously impressed with the Knipex and Gedore pliers, and saddened that the Channellocks didn't perform better. At least they held up well and aren't expensive. I still love them, and I'll keep owning and using them, but I'm fixing to add some Knipex and Gedore to the roster...
Great video as always!
Thanks!
I use Channellock as my everyday carry. I did have Knipex, but lost them. I might get them again now
You have Pride and have Brand Loyalty , there is nothing wrong with that ! American Made is a prized issue . 63/23
Whatevet it is the chanellocs better then kline but knipex is the 2x king in diagonal catters eg. " dikes"
Man I am so glad that I found this channel, very informative and helps me from guessing which products brand is suppose to be better than the other one by actually demonstrating, experimenting and observing. Thank you so much for your content.
Off the subject here, can we all truly appreciate the fact that Todd goes through great lengths to respond to as many people as he can. Thank you!
I appreciate that!
He's clearly dedicated to what he's doing. And his videos are very informative.
You know there are people you can hire to do that, right? Most responses are canned replies. Not saying he does that, but it's entirely possible to pay a service to comment canned replies to everyone.
He doesn’t lie at all, he actually means it, very consistent and he’s always making the next video while reading every comment. I can’t imagine half stuff I’ve bought because I’ve watched his videos to be sure get the best to the best product without getting scammed hard like other people do.
We could, if he ever responded to me and I'm always with in 10 minutes of video launch
as someone who needs to buy a lot of tools for work, these videos come in way handy. thank you!
Thank you!
As some one doesn't buy any tools these videos are really entertaining and I really appreciate the effort. So I also thank you.
HVAC?
Aye aye. I won't lie though he aways kind of reinforces my just always buy milwaukee and you'll be alright mindset
Knipex is a brand I have a lot of respect for. Glad to see that they did well in these tests.
Just a silly side note but I and the people I've worked with pronounce them "nip-ex" and leave the "K" silent.
Thanks for sharing.
Got a pair of Knipex more than a year ago. Outstanding ! work better than any other channel locks I have ever used !
I’m very impressed with Doyle. Wasn’t expecting that.
Me too! The Doyle brand has proven to be far superior than the Pittsburgh lineup at HF.
@@ProjectFarm Doyle brand is their premium Taiwanese brand. The Pittsburgh hand tools are their inexpensive Chinese line. Pittsburgh Pro is higher quality than the regular Pittsburgh stuff but is hit or miss depending on whether it was made in Taiwan or China.
All Doyle stuff I have bought has proven to be a good value.
@@jonmeyer6063 I’m gonna give them another look.
Their wire crimping pliers feel and work great.
With the holidays coming up, your channel is going to be a great guide for choosing some of the best gifts.
Tools are the gift that keeps on giving!
Thank you! I plan to have a "top 10" tools video before Black Friday
@@korvo9936 Some one said you can not have enough tools, however if you are like me and can never find them when you want them end up buying again.
Half the stuff on my Giftster account is from PF reviews!
@@tonysheerness2427
You certainly can't have enough 10mm or 9/16 sockets or wrenches.
I don't comment often on videos but I want to say I really appreciate your content. I recently found your channel and now always try to guess the winner. I enjoy that you have probably the highest fact per minute rate of all tool reviews. Once I finish watching the videos you have already made I am sure to have a viewer suggestion or two. Thank you.
Thanks so much!
Awesome video! I'm always pleased to see that the tools I carry on my hip all day at work were good choices. You really help make sure us trades workers aren't wasting our money. Greatly appreciated!
Thanks!
You should test the handles for chemical resistance against chemicals which are common in a shop like acetone, motor oil, gasoline, diesel, ATF and so on
My Knipex handles have survived 6 years of e85, gas, diesel, kero, etc no problem. All I can add lol
I like this idea, but only see acetone being a problem. As far as the metal handles, only alcohol could lead to rust of all the things you mentioned. The rubber bits are only for branding, everyone who knows anything knows that crap is useless if you are not working on electronics. Rubber = blisters
Great suggestion! Thank you.
I have (2) sets of Knipex channel locks, that came with 3 each. They’ve been in daily use (especially the 10” & 12”) in our shop since 2017 and no issues with the grips from various chemicals/petroleums.
Also test the grips against solvent weld glue and their heat resistance for us plumbers/pipe fitters!
Anybody else root for a brand they know they have when they watch these videos? Even if I seem to own a lot of the cheaper tools he brings up.... Lol!
Thank you!
Sure, it's like with the sports. Being from Europe, I always root for European brands :-)
Yup, always rooting for Knipex, since I live close to their HQ :-) It's like a sports event
Rooted for knipex. Brand snobs can be annoying but I've bught a few of their pliers over the years. Never had one fail me.
Lol, yes and "my" pliers won - Knipex for the win! I've always used Knipex as I know they'll do the job and they last for a very long time, although I've worn a few out over the years. lol
This is pretty cool. I found a set of knipex on track years ago and I kept them. 5 years and they still look and feel NEW. I use them every time I need pliers.
That was a superior set of tests. Very practical uses for this tool. For some reason I had missed watching this one. Glad I caught it finally, and also glad that I bought that Doyle without knowing it compared well to the competition out there.
Thanks!
I love my Knipex tools. I busted my hand open on a greasy stove and swore to myself that I would never used cheap Pliers ever again. I went out that day and replaced all of them with Knipex and never looked back. Great videos as always!
This definitely reflects my own experience with knipex vs irwin vs channellock pliers. I started with a pair of channellocks because all the old guys used them, saw the knipex at menards one day and decided to try them out, and they worked fantastic, replaced all my channellocks with them. Then I saw the irwins and decided to give them a go, and within two months of daily use the teeth were all rounded out and didn't grab shit anymore. The knipex are still going strong ~6 years later
Thanks for sharing.
Knipex is the best performance professional grade brand (Made in Germany). Irwin is made in China, should I say more?
Irwin, like Craftsman, is a good "ONLY BUY USED" brand. Their old US-made tools tend to be perfectly good.
Knipex best pliers going
nobody mentioned that you can grip something with a pair of Knipex, let go of bottom handle, and it will not slip as long as you keep pressure on top handle.. Pretty handy....10 yr. old pair still going strong.
Good test. I use my Irwin's pretty heavily and truth be told they worked fine for me for many years. Great performance for great price.
My dad and I have used both the Knipex and Channellock, I’ve noticed the Channellocks rely more heavily upon squeezing force instead of biting in when you rotate the pliers
Great feedback on both brands! Thank you
@@ProjectFarm No, thank you for continuing to put out phenomenal tests of products
also by design the channel lock brand will smash your fingers when they slip as where knipex does not
10 years in industry tells me this is an accurate set of tests. The Knipex pliers are the best hand tool you can buy, in my opinion/experience. The results of the Irwin are equally telling....they start strong but do not last. Save your money and get something better. The Doyle brand does seem like a nice budget alternative.
I agree. Everytime I need to break out the Cobras, I get a warm fuzzy feeling. I recently picked up their new slip joints and I think I have found a new favorite.
They Doyle definitely surprised me
Japan very good.Germane very good 👍🏻 but I like Japan
I was literally in Home Depot yesterday looking at these thinking... "I wonder if there's a Project Farm video testing these... I'll check before I buy"
Thanks for sharing.
Irwin is a really decent tool brand for middle of cost, middle of quality tool range. It's kind of difficult to argue more expensive tools to them in some tool market segments in terms of cost/quality ratio. Especially with the way the tool industry is this day and age, with 99% of all tools being made in S.E.A. and China, even when legalease can allow some countries to say that "Made in" is made in their country, when it's not.
That's too funny, I was doing the exact same thing.
@@JosephArata
Irwin seems to be the equivalent to our UK brand that is Draper. Not the most expensive but shockingly good for the money.
I've got a 1/2" Draper ratchet that's about 17 years old and after releasing anything from trim bolts to head bolts and driveshaft nuts (which you really shouldn't do with a ratchet) it's still going strong.
I have a large and medium of there Irwin's for years and still holding up (not using for car mechanic or industrial use)
such thorough tests and he does this in his own shop with no expensive machines..great job
In my opinion this may be the most useful channel on You Tube. NOBODY test tools like you do nor do they have the variety o competitors that you do. Very very excellent review.
Aty from Ohio
Thanks so much!
Knipex Cobra costs about 26 USD here in Germany (21€)
And they stay forever 👍😁
I'm using them over 20 years and had never problems with them 🙃
I was glad to see Knipex do so well, I've been using those for years. I knew they were above average on price but was always happy with the performance.
Thanks for the feedback.
@@ProjectFarm Thank you for what you do, You are my "go to" before buying many products.
Buy once cry once! 😎
@@davidspriggs1945 buy chinese, buy twice
I can't believe I watch these videos that are quite long, but amazingly informative for things I've never even thought of. I'm a tool guy, worked with my hands most of my life. I love this stuff.
BTW, my girlfriend doesn't understand, but she knows which purse matches which shoes...
Another great video helping me decide which replacement tool I should buy for work. thank you very much, I greatly appreciate your videos.
Thanks and you are welcome!
Both Gedore as well as Knipex are highly regarded here in Germany, too. I’m not surprised they worked as well as they did.
On behalf of the whole world thank you Germany for making great tools
Thanks for the feedback.
I have a knipex at work. Love that plier, it takes a beating working on trains.
Gedore Knipex and Wera, you'd have a hard time finding anything else in my toolbox.
I’ve got a knipex cobra that i love for plumbing.
Very informative! I can't say I was surprised, though. There's a reason why every pliers type tool in my bag is a Knipex from wire cutters to diagonals to linemans to Cobras, all the way down to my newest favorites, the 7-1/4-in pliers wrench. As a tool geek (and a fan of Knipex...) I admit I was sitting forward in my chair and cheering as though I was watching the Olympics :D
Hehee, same here. How lame cheering on my pliers brand. Also second on the pliers wrench, amazing tool!
Thanks!
I fell in love with the pliers wrench from knipex the first time I saw them several years ago. They are awesome as long as you don't need to tighten with too much force.
Bought a smooth jaw Knipex after watching a different UA-camr recommended the brand. The only complaint was that you need both hands to set the jaw opening. Bought a 2-pack of Irwin (serrated jaw) at Lowe's for HALF the price of the Knipex. I like the ratcheting adjustment of the Irwin more, lets me set the size one-handed.
oh man, those pliers wrenchs are amazing! I never knew thats what they are called, I always call them parallel grippers lol. I don't use them too often, but for one very specific task, they are hands down the absolute best (and sometimes only) tool for it. the only downside is they are a little hard to adjust. For normal stuff the quick adjust of the irwin is my favorite as well.
Man….. I’m not into tool quality because I’m a budget first Neanderthal and most of my tools are really crap, but I recently found your channel and stared upgrading my tool, and I love and respect you work, is really a social work, you really make people’s save money……. Thank you thank you. God bless you and keep the good work.
While I did expect Knipex to come out on top, the Doyle pliers were quite surprising. Not bad if you cannot afford Knipex or Gedore, which also performed well.
Cannot afford Knipex? Tool for long years is never too expensive. I was using my first COBRA at industry "everyday technical job" for 7 years and it is still in about 90% quality ;)
@@andrzejfabianski4948 bro not everyone can afford the good stuff. Especially when starting off.
@@andrzejfabianski4948
it is probably 98 percent.
If you're putting a tool box together, the price difference can make or break a budget. I'd go with the Doyle.
@@andrzejfabianski4948 It’s not always a matter of ‘can’t afford knipex’. Not everybody is a tradesman who will use them everyday. Why would a civilian who’s only going to use them a few times a year pay 3 times the cost when you can get similar, often better, performance for so much less? After all, the knipex didn’t win in all categories of testing.
Great stuff. Earlier this year I was talked into converting from my daily go-to pliers of many years in Channel Lock brand, to Knipex Cobra's, and it's unreal how much better they are. Absolutely worth the money. So much lighter, stronger, and easier to get in tough places. Can't imagine ever going back now, haha
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
You might want to check out the Irwin as well. The ratcheting mechanism is SUPER nice when you need to adjust the size and hold the wrench with the same hand. That's my only complaint of my Knipex, I need 2 hands to adjust the jaws. I got 2 of the Irwin (small/large) at Lowe's for half the price of my 1 Knipex (which I still love).
@@AHustleIsLikeASideOfFries Is it just my imagination, or is Irwin a name that come up often in PF reviews as a good performing value priced tools? I don't own any, but seems the name keeps coming up in these reviews. I've never heard of Knipex before, but have so many tools I doubt I will be investing in them at my advanced age!
@Beaf Supreme I don't know. They still seem pretty solid for a low price brand. But definitely not the quality tool they used to be..
As soon as I saw the title I knew Knipex would win! The pliers wrench from them are awesome also!
it was an easy one...
They did an amazing job! Thank you
Don't forget the wire stripper! ;-)
@@MrNickelbrille I needed some wire strippers asap so I picked up some Milwaukee ones locally and they're pretty nice not gonna lie.
@@HeWearsGlasses I just had one. Never needed another one. But that was 100Mark ~50$! but that was 30 years ago. I kept it like new ;-)
It's quite shocking how well the Knipex did. In this case I think you can justify their cost. Thanks for another great video!
You are welcome!
If you used Knipex its not shocking - there is always that one job where they pay for themselves and do the unthinkable.
Excellent reviews, as always. I was quite impressed with the Doyle. I've had run into issues before where the jaw width is too much. Every now and again you need one that is narrow.
Thanks! Thanks for sharing.
I have used a set of Knipex slip joint pliers for 33 years. There is some slight wear from things I shouldn't have tried with them. They hold up extremely well. No corrosion issues with them either, and they've seen a lot of rain and grey water. If they still make them as well as they did back then, I'd highly recommend them.
Thanks for the feedback.
Wood chisels. You could test how the cheap hardware store ones stack up to brands like Narex or Veritas.
Thank you for the video idea!
Not a bad idea, but that sounds like the sort of thing where the outcomes of torture testing could be pretty hazardous.
Or japan ones. They make great wood tools
@@ProjectFarm If possible try to get the german "two cherry" brand chisels in the test. Havent met a joiner that doesnt use them yet.
I'd add CK and Axminster to the chisel testing list
I didn't know much about Knipex until I saw an aircraft mechanic using a Knipex Wrench Pliars, and I was so impressed I had to get one for myself. One of my favorite and most used tools in the box
Thanks for the feedback.
such good videos. the lengths he goes to to ensure he remains impartial and tests empirically is commendable!
Thanks!
Als Österreicher freue ich mich natürlich über die guten Ergebnisse von Gedore auch wenn ich Knipex bevorzuge.
Sehr gutes Video weiter so.
Die Zangen kommen aus Österreich, richtig? Wobei mit der Verstellmechanismus dabei überhaupt nicht gefällt ^^
Something about Knipex is better :)
🤔
Ja, I guess, lmao 😂
Als Deutscher bin ich stolz auf den deutschen Ruf, das wir gute Sachen herstellen
I work in saltwater, the "Quick Adjust Slide Button" kind never last more than a week for us. They rust up too easily, with the old style you can bang them free and use them again, the speed adjust kind are just trashed. Outstanding video, as per usual.
That's rapid corrosion! Thank you!
Yeah, i prefer the old school ones that just old with a bolt.
Like you said, just bang it and its good to go
Just drop it in muriatic acid, rinse, and go
knipex offers chrome plated version
@@nseriousget8165
I was just about to mention that, the style is called 87 03 XXX (offered in 125, 180, 250 and 300mm).
The're not as cheap as some others but should be worth a try for this specific application. Even the button is chrome plated so corrosion shouldn't be an issue.
you are incredible, i love all your videos, i swear i spend the last few days binge watching your comparisons haha these videos are so well made!
Thanks so much!
Another great and informative video. Your channel is such a resource. Thanks very much!
You're very welcome!
I’m a heavy equipment mechanic and I ONLY buy knipex. I broke a pair of channellocks the first time I used them. They are definitely worth the money. Not only to the grip extremely hard, the build quality and durability is by far the best.
I prefer Knipex, but Bahco are often good also.
I also always want to have a cheap option of every tool available, for those time when they will be abused. Don't want to accidentally weld something to a pair of Knipex.
Edit: Generally prefer Kamasa-Tools over Bahco, but not sure if they are available globally. At work we use many small Lindström pliers, their flush cutting side cutters are amazing, but has a tendency to shatter if abused.
@@MrJamesBanana oh I totally do the same thing 😂 those channellocks quickly became a pair of welding pliers
Thanks for the feedback.
I'm a diesel mechanic and I love my Knipex pliers.
@ Joe Momma Buddy You could break a Large Crowbar !
I've seen many tool reviews. Yours are the best. SUGGESTION: Oscillating multitools. There is a lot of heat here, but very little light. I've watched at least a half dozen reviews on these, but they range from "RAH, RAH! Brand Z Fanboy!" To non-systematic efforts, which, though they try, just are not what you do. Nobody appears to test them systematically as to longevity, usability, cutting ability, ease of handling, value for price, etc.
You would. So. A request.
I second this suggestion!
DeWalt FTW. No brand loyalty
He did do one on the blades. Not the tools themselves. Might be interesting but subjective
Im a Hikoki fan myself, but my multitool of choice is a Fein.
Went for the Hikoki, but the dealer advised my the Fein.
Held them side by side, and the feeling of the Fein won me over in an instant.
Much less vibration from the Fein.
So comfort wise the Fein easily wins over Hikoki, and with the danger of vibration damage to muscle/tissue/fingers and hands I do think that a test would be hard to do, and maybe should be focused on comfort/vibration and maybe not outright performance.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
I have a pair of Irwin pliers.....they are super. Took rounded off brake bleeder valves and saved the job.
Thanks for the feedback.
Absolutely fantastic! Really useful information found nowhere else!
Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.
Brand advertising: we do something better!
Project farm: we’re gonna test that.
Brand advertising: damn, you got us :(
I look forward to the day that tool manufacturers start using Todd's tests as a token, like how car manufacturers use the Teknikens värld's moose test. not 100% "scientific" but covers the things you'd care about. incredible.
When things were at their very worst:
2 Suns, Cross in the sky, 2 comets will collide = don`t be afraid - repent, accept Lord`s Hand of Mercy.
Scientists will say it was a global illusion.
Beware - Jesus will never walk in flesh again.
After WW3 - rise of the “ man of peace“ from the East = Antichrist - the most powerful, popular, charismatic and influential leader of all time. Many miracles will be attributed to him. He will imitate Jesus in every conceivable way.
Don`t trust „pope“ Francis = the False Prophet
- will seem to rise from the dead
- will unite all Christian Churches and all Religions as one.
One World Religion = the seat of the Antichrist.
Benedict XVI is the last true pope - will be accused of a crime of which he is totally innocent.
"Many events, including ecological upheavals, wars, the schism in My Church on Earth, the dictatorships in each of your nations - bound as one, at its very core - will all take place at the same time."
"Arab uprising will spark global unrest - Italy will trigger fall out"
The Book of Truth
Love the knipex ones, worth the cost.
Yes, amazing quality!! I thought they'd perform well but they exceeded my expectations in a quantifiable way!
Excellent work! On the test using the Impact driver, you can actually see when the metal is "shaved" off the bolt when it turns. Very interesting!
Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks to this super informative video, I made my choice. I was leaning on the fence with a few here and the rest were new to me. Thank you!
You are welcome!
Every Sunday I look forward to a new video! It has become our family tradition to sit down and watch another epic comparison showdown! Just want to thank you from the bottom of our hearts for being so dedicated to what you do and making these awesome videos!
I appreciate that! Thanks so much!
Finally one of the products I purchased isn’t at the bottom of all the tests!
I can attest that my Knipex tools holdup very well to abuse.
Thank you for making these videos.
You are welcome!
I really enjoyed that. You really put the effort into it. Thanks!
Thanks and you are welcome!
@@ProjectFarm will you do a shop tour ? Would love to see what's inside your workshop area . Thanks!
I often grip the pliers too hard and destroy the adjustment mechanism. I would have loved to see a comparison on how strong the different mechanisms are!
Thanks for the feedback. Thanks for the suggestion.
From having (ab)used a bunch of those pliers, in my opinion 2 tests are missing: the force required to strip the adjusting mechanism (or whatever fails first) and the force required to separate the rubber grips from the pliers.
Still a very comprehensive and useful video as always!
Your IQ must be super high to use the word abused and used like that. I am impressed.
@@hamood1234fool higher than yours, muhammed
I refuse to work with those tongue and groove pliers like the channel lock one. With very little force they already skip and become very painfull. The type used by Klein tools is a bit better, but skips quite easily (mostly annoying when trying to use in hard to reach places. Can't remember getting injured by the Gedore and Knipex. Latest one to the collection is a Wiha automatic for ease of use, but not yet put it to hard labor.
Excellent testing as always! Thanks for all the time you put into making these money saving videos!
Thank you!
I agree. Money saving for most maybe but for a addict...I’ve got a two piece Irwin, ChannelLock set and a dangerously expensive Gedora. I’ve been tempted by the new SpeedGrip ChannelLocks too. They are so slick looking. I hear the SnapOn truck coming.
Wow I just started a new job that required me to purchase some tools. Got the Doyle and wasn't sure if it was good and UA-camd it to find this video. I am glad to know my tools will be reliable. Thanks!
Thank you so much again, I am from Germany and have been watching your videos. You waste no time on any BS. Everything is perfect.
Thn!
We love these videos. I know they take a lot of time and money, but we really appreciate what you do. You really help us make smart decisions on our purchases.
Thanks so much!
I'd love to see a "Best Chef's Knife" or "Best Cooking Pans" type video.
Wouldn't be the usual auto/ construction theme; but they are tools nonetheless.
Thanks for the suggestion.
absolutely! "Best non-stick available on the market"
Ooo how about a second channel Todd you would put Americas Test Kitchen to shame!!!!
@@jahnkaplank8626 , "the manufacturer says burned food won't stick to this pan----- we're gonna test that!". (Brings out a flamethrower and a can of gasoline).
@@goodun2974 that's the kind of test i'm looking forward to!
Thanks for another great video. Looks like I'll be shopping for more Knipex products.
You are welcome!
Really thorough test. Thanks for your hard work.
Thank you!
When you do your graphs, would you be willing to put a horizontal line indicating the average so we can easily see what falls below or rises above the overall average? Thanks!
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm On the subject of graphs. A summary table would be great. Tool across the top, category down the side. Each score is listed, then a weighted score is shown at the bottom. For each category, you could color code each score in Red, yellow, green to show if it is the upper, middle, or bottom of it's range . So cleary the ones with more green would stand out. Weighting would help amplify or diminish the effect of a category.
Another suggestion I can give is for flashlights, all with a specific battery size. Using the best rechargeable batteries for instance. I have a few Maglites, but there are so many brands (Streamlight, Olight, Nite core to name a few) to test which might make it difficult.
Yes, this. I am currently making a box of a flashlights that don't work...some just need some cleaning, some are just made like junk, some are antiques.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I generally don't buy the super fancy, expensive LED flashlights but I have a number of different flashlights, usually around $10 to $12, a few at $20, And the Achilles heel of almost all of them seems to be electrical connections that that are press fit or loosely crimped, which oxidize a little and fail intermittently. The Springs in the battery holders or battery compartment are usually crimped very loosely to little metal plittle metal plates and even if they appear to be gold plated the contact at those points is invariably a little bit loose. I solder the springs to the metal plates (It is much easier to do this before you experience any battery leakage no matter how minor) and eliminate the intermittent connections. Ditto for the cylindrical 3 battery holders, solder the springs to the contact plates for fewer problems.
@@somethingsomeonesaid6455 , the Achilles heel of most flashlights that use AA or AAA cells is battery leakage, and intermittent mechanical connections *by design* (even before leakage ocurs). First of all, one famous " copper top" brand is absolute crap nowadays. Secondly, batteries wired in series tend to leak when one battery is slightly different than the others (slightly used, slightly older, different batch, differing brands); It appears that the one battery with different characteristics or slightly lower voltage or different chemical makeup or at an increased stage of age-related degradation ends up functioning kind of like a resistor and overheats from the current of the other batteries passing through it. This phenomena is probably worse than anit is probably worse in any flashlight that has multiple modes such as high low and flashing because such flashlights are never truly off and invariably are passing a small amount of current through an integrated circuit's integrated circuit at all times which is how they remember what mode they were in when last switched on. This phenomena is probably worse than anit is probably worse in any flashlight that has multiple modes such as high low and flashing because such flashlights are never truly off and invariably are passing a small amount of current through an integrated circuit's integrated circuit at all times, which is how they remember what mode they were in when last switched on (and typically switch to the next mode in line, which is annoying). A flashlight with a true mechanical on/off switch and is off switch and just one single mode of operation, or where it has a separate switch to select mode's, might not draw a current all the time and perhaps the batteries will be less prone to leaking. Any review or evaluation of a flashlight should include how easy it is to get inside of it to clean corrosion from battery leakage. The little slide-in plastic cylinders that hold 3 batteries are definitely more convenient in this regard. Note that the springs in those battery holders, and indeed the springs in almost all flashlights, are often loosely crimped in place and have a mechanical contact at that point which will oxidize and become intermittent, especially if there is any battery leakage. Soldering the springs to the thrust plates will usually eliminate this problem, and even if the flashlight undergoes battery leakage later on you will find it much easier to clean the springs and contacts and get the device functional again. (White vinegar will foam away the visible corrosion but a pencil eraser or fiberglass bristle "scratch brush" may be necessary to polish the contacts).
Anyway, do not mix battery brands or batches, and don't leave them inside a flashlight that is used only occasionally. If you have a good quality small soldering iron and good soldering skills, solder those springs! Clean the metal first,and the solder should flow more easily without you overheating and melting adjacent plastic.
PS, apologies for echo-like repeating sentences; that's not me, it's the voice-to-text software on this phone, which does this all the time, sometimes changing the comment right as it posts, after passing my own proof-reading. If I reopen the comment to edit it, sometimes it won't re-post and it just vanishes in the ether.
Always use Channellock on the jobsite but Knipex are excellent well crafted tools. Their small copper pipe cutters are far superior over my reed or ridgid cutters by far!
I'm much more likely to use channel locks on site. I'm not hitting a pair of knipex with a hammer. Also something nostalgic. I have some knipex pliers, and they have their place.
@@jonathanpopham5483 knipex are great for plumbers ive used them every day for years
Some great testing as alway! With winter coming up would love to see some testing done on space heaters, thanks again!
Great suggestion! Thank you.
This is the one video PF has done that pretty much everyone knew the results to beforehand.
Nothing like Knipex for Pliers.
Did you not see the Doyle do pretty much just as well?
yea i saw knipex and knew it was over for the other brands
Thanks for the feedback.
I actually never heard of majority of these brands, put an order in for Gedore in because of this!
@@rapTorfx4
The Doyle did well, but not on the very hard steel.
It's a lot cheaper in the US, but to be fair one has to mention that 43$ for the Knipex is a really inflated price, over here the standard dipped handle version costs 17.52€ (incl. 19% sales tax).
Can you do a (most accurate) tire pressure Guage shootout. I can't thank you enough for all the time and effort you put into your amazing videos. Consumer reports is afraid of you!
Thanks for the suggestion.
Anytime I need a tool I come see your reviews, thanks so much for your tests!!!
You are welcome!
Outstanding side-by-side comparison testing! This is the info is was looking for.
Thanks!
Very informative! Whether by a simple set-up, or complex, your tests seem to cut straight to the heart of the information that a person using the tested object as a work-day tool really needs, providing non-biased and extremally useful data as to which tool will serve the best. Something that the manufacturer's boasting almost never does.
Thanks again for all your efforts.
You are welcome!
We now have insight as to why Todd does what he does.... Apparently, quite a few years ago, he bought a pair of slip joint pliers that he regrets buying and, now, he is driven to find the true quality of all products that exist in the world.
lol
I bought a cheap copy of the Channellock which didn't have undercut arc grooves. After pinching my fingers a few times as the jaws jumped out of the grooves I threw it away.
Awesome comparison! I love your videos man !
Thanks so much!
I know you usually do tools and diy repair type items, but I would really love to see a valve oil for brass instrument comparison. I can’t find any non subjective or anecdotal data anywhere, and I really appreciate how well thought out your experiments and data collection are. Even if this is outside your scope of expertise, I will continue to watch and enjoy your videos. Thank you for making this wonderful channel!
You are welcome! Thanks for the suggestion.
Please do a complete wrench comparison.
With snapon, stahlwille motor, craftsman, hazet, gedore, wera,...
That would be really interesting.
I also love all the oil comparison videos...
Thx for your work
Thanks so much! Thanks for the suggestion.
Yes
I'd be interested in how the new channellock x series would hold up.
@@ProjectFarm i am wondering too for some missing big brands as above said Hazet, Wera, Facom, makita, etc.
@@simeonsimeonov4776 add nepros or ktc brand from Japan
I was skeptical about knipex because of the price but now I’m confident they are worth it.
Thanks for sharing.
As always an excellent video, covering all the relevant aspects of these tools in an unbiased manner. Would like to see a test of compact bolt cutters next.
Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.
Thanks you for the vids.
I watch your videos before purchasing tools 👍
Thank you. It's appreciated.
Keep doing the good work.
Thanks and you are welcome, will do!
I’ve got an old pair of Proto that I really should toss in the trash. If you squeeze those things very hard they will slip, which in the wrong situation could result in an injury. I really enjoy your channel sir👍🏻
Yes, I have some pliers that did the same thing. I finally threw them in the trash
I've had the same experience with Irwin. They were ok for a little while, then they'd let go on you at the worst time. Knipex pliers are my go-to set now. Almost indestructible.
Considering Proto is an expensive industrial brand that's terrible.
The proto probably has a lifetime warranty dude, try to turn on it in or check on their website anyway
My protos are holding strong. I'm the second generation to use them. Only downside is the plastic is wearing through. Knipex is better, but until these finally break or wear out, they are gonna sit in my tool bag.
Knipex makes really great tools for bolts and hardware etc. I build communication towers and Knipex is my favourite for that sort of thing, but for lineman pliers, and copper loppers, and other cutting tools I lean more towards Klein as my favourite...18 years in and my feelings on some tools have changed over the years, but that's where I stand at the moment.
I second this. I've been a Klein guy, but after really liking my knipex pliers I decided to try their diagonal cutters. Total junk. They broke within 2 months while I was cutting something that my kleins have no problem with. I went back to those kleins and have been abusing them daily for 5+ years and they still work great.
bahco make lot better tools than knipex newer can. i use only elektric tools knipex all other metal work tools and woodwork tools have lot better bahco.
Yep, totally agree. Inside wireman for twenty years, and all my tools are Klein except for the Knipex pliers. They are very well made and grip hard on everything.
Truly impressed with the Doyle's. Gonna pick some up this week
Thanks very much for another fantastic comparison test, my wife asked me what I would like for my birthday, I am so glad I suggested Knipex, pliers wrench hoping to get them in June lol😊
You are welcome!
Pipe wrench showdown, Straight vs Swedish, Ridgid vs Knipex, Stillson vs Gedore, Milwaukee vs Bahco
Since you measured the width, it would also have been interesting to see the grip strength presented in terms of grip strength per inch of tool width. Or did you look at that in editing and decide that there wasn't a lot to be learned from that statistic?
I wanted a graph of width vs grip too
Simple physics is why the Irwin brand was able to do the best job gripping with threaded rod, it failed with the very hard metals because they are cost-priced with materials. The others are slim because they are trying to conform to a relatively loose industry standard. Looks like the most common sizes are ~1/4-3/8" standard, ~7-10mm metric with Irwin being the only one close to 1/2" or almost 12.5mm.
Thanks for the constructive feedback.
I own Knipex and love them glad they held up to your test they work for anything I’ve thrown at them
Thanks for sharing.
Thank you so much. I've just ordered the Knipex wrench 👍
Brilliant! You've covered most type of pliers but Needle-Nose. We already know Knipex is probably going to win but give it a thought as a project for your next videos. Thanks!
Yeah, that would be interesting. I would like to see torsion tests for cases where you have to reach nose first and rotate handle like a screwdriver. Low quality needle-nose pliers slip because the grip opens sideways.
Thank you very much! Thanks for the suggestion.
What stood out to me, and made me wonder about some of the tests, is that the angle was not always held constant. I don't know if changing the angle between the item being grasped and the pliers would make it grip better or worse, but I did see it varying alarmingly.
Thanks for the feedback.
Thanks you for your efforts. Your tests are hands-on and I can second your result with the Knipex Cobra. My father worked in engineering and gave me my first tool kit when I was 14. I still have the "Kombizange", I think this is the European equivalent of the American lineman's pliers. Those are tools one buys for life. Recently I got me a Knipex "pliers wrench" after pondering quite a while about buying a new wrench set. It was the best investment ever, I must admit. Perhaps it might be of interest to you too, since it is a very intelligent solution which saves a lot of time and tool kit weight, simply by combination of a wrench with a plumber's pliers.
You are welcome! Thanks for sharing.
Super glad a stumbled into this channel! Saves me some money and something better to go off than name brand!
Thanks! Glad to hear!