May Allah guide the brother. He's definitely one of the more reasonable Shias that I've spoken to. Any rude comments directed at him will be deleted and may lead to ban from channel comments. Just because we disagree with someone doesn't mean that we have to be rude and condescending.
@@muslimresponse103 not all shia are kuffar, u cant say akhi to a kafir so depends. But not sure about brother if it has the same weighting as akhi, Allah knows best.
@@westlisbon6307I get your sentiments. But if you want to follow the Mahdi, they will call you a Shia of Imam Mahdi? Will you reject that call? Because there will be Muslims who fight him and they will absolutely call him a khariji. Think deeper brother. There is many nuances.
@@westlisbon6307it is not politics, it is about the kind of Hadith you choose to follow (Sunni being more strict, and shia Hadith being more lenient) Succession is very much a non-issue and was only given weight in later political discussion. Besides a small handful of isolated reports, the vast majority of the companions of the Prophet peace be upon him, supported the method of succession that was utilised in the early generations. Where the problems and conflict truly begin is how this issue in succession was used to justify major theological differences, often with little or no evidence from the Quran and Sunnah. The mainline Sunni schools of thought take evidence for practices and worship very seriously, and where we see individuals supporting practices that are born from exaggeration and lack any evidence, we dismiss the practice as being an innovation.
"The easiest thing to do is prove the historical evidence for the existence of a historical personality. That's the easiest thing to do. [To go to] prophecy is a problem." 14:16
The Prophet foretold that the Kholafa (successors after him) shall be 12 Imams, and that are all from Qoraysh. (Muslim 3:220, H. 1821). This hadith can only apply to the 12 Imams of Ahlul-Bayt (as).
@@TheProofLady I’ve read it but I just wanted to see what somebody who is more knowledgeable has to say about it… whiteout bashing them or something.. just some facts from hadith and quran
@@yassinesmahi9298 they were always consider as disbeliever and they accepted it unlike qadyanis , they never used Muslim with their names or claim the Islamic units as their faith , Like prayer , mosque , eid , ramadan etc they took many things from Islam but Muslims never felt to deal with them like we deal with Qadiani as they trying to steal our identity with their fake and false identity
One thing is for sure. The Baha’i faith is Kufr. This religion is a joke, it doesn’t really stand for anything. It calls for the “unity of all religions”, which is illlgical because most religions contradict each other in fundamental aspects. The members of that faith claim that god revealed all religions (polytheistic religions including). “And whoever desires other than Islām as religion - never will it be accepted from him, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers.” (Quran 3:85)
@@supertaxi5324 This is a misunderstanding of their claims. It is like how Muslims believe Christianity and Judaism were revealed religions. They believe that various major religions were INITIALLY revealed but then became misunderstood. They do make various claims and have various stances, even the Universal House of Justice which clarifies what is haram etc
The person you are streaming with is condescending. Not good character feature. I think he should work on that to be taken seriously, and for you to be taken seriously aswell because that kind of attitude alongside you on camera also diminishes your reputation.
Following is the list of the personalities considers as "Imam ghayb" i.e, hidden imam by different Shia sects: 1)Abdullah ibn Saba's followers used to considers "Hazrat Ali" as hidden imam 2)Kaysania considers 'Muhammad al Hanfiya" as hidden imam 3)Nawusiya considers " Jafar bin Muhammad " as hidden imam 4)Waqfiya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam 5) Bishriya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam 6)Fathiyya considers"Abdullah ibn Jafar" as hidden imam 7)Muhammadiya considers"Muhammad bin Ali al Hadi" as hidden imam 8) Qaramita considers"Muhammad bin Ismail"as hidden imam 9)Daruzi considers"Hakim bi Amrillah" as hidden imam 10) Bohra considers " Tayyeb bin Ali Amir" as hidden imam 11)Muhammad Shahi Nizari considers " Amir Muhammad al Baqir" as hidden imam 12) Ithna Athari considers "Muhammad bin Hasan Askari" ( a fictional character) as hidden imam And the list is endless.....
But this list isn't proof of anything. There is also a large list of people who believe in last prophets other than Muhammad in Abdullah (saaw) even though it's very clear he is the last prophet of God. That doesn't make the belief in a last prophet of God wrong
@@fark69 This is a irrefutable proof regarding the fallacy of faith of the Rafidah, but will be observable to only those who has sincere heart(Qalb e Saleem) to accept the truth. This proves that this bizarre concept of" hidden Imam " was very much prevalent since the early day's of Islam and founders of Twelver sect like Kulaini, Mufeed,and the so called four deputies just plagiarise this concept ,but there is one significant difference, unlike the hidden imams of other sects who were historical characters, the hidden imam of Twelvers is a purely fictional one.
Salam Farid. I found an old tweet of yours about the issue of fasting Arafah. Please can you do a video about it as the issue needs to be more well known.
@@syedabualhussain Yeah I know. That's why we call him Shia Imam.Apart from the non-existence of Muhammad Ibn Hasan Al-Askari, the father's name of the Mahdi is supposed to be Abdallah,not Hasan. So it's another contradiction
There is no MAHDI in ISLAM. Mahdi is just another name for SAOSHYANT from the AVESTA, embedded in the HADITH collection authored by PERSIAN Zoroastrian Converts.
Mahdi exists in the Islamic literature. But he doesn't exist in the world now . Shias believe mahdi is alive now . So the title is referring that mahdi doesn't exist now .
The way of the Rawafid is very strange indeed,they says Abu Bakr,Umar ,Usman ,Muawiya committed atrocities on Ahlul Bait,lo and behold, very very surprisingly the Rawafid took revenge of all this alleged atrocities not on Sahaba but on prophet Muhammad (S.A.W),if not then why would have they included other person's name beside prophet in Sahadah and Adhan,Why then they would have believed Imamat to be greater than Prophethood? why then they would have included another persons in the attributes which are specific to prophet only like "Masum","Divinely appointed "? why then they would have barked at his pure wives, only and no other women?Then why would have they considers the Quran to be corrupted? Then why would have they believed the importance of Prophet (S.A.W) being in that he was just someone's father-in-law and someone's grandfather and nothing more? Then why would have they believed that his mission was a failure! why would they have believed that the purpose of the prophethood is just to be harbinger of someone's Imamat and nothing more than that? All this implies that the real target of Rawafid is prophet (S.A.W) and not the Sahaba.
When the Shia (real Shia who don’t curse companions and wives of the prophet) say that the Imamat is more than prophethood, they are saying that the imams of Ahlul Bayt are higher in rank than the majority of the prophets on the day of judgement (not sayyid al anbiya). The Hadith from Ibn Hajar says that Muhummad Saw, Ali, Jafar, Hamza, Hussein, Hassan, and Mahdi are the chiefs of the people of paradise. Only one person in this Hadith is a prophet yet they will be the chiefs of paradise… many Shia don’t understand this because they are being led by fools who wouldve deserted Hussein and Ali if given the chance. They have no idea what they are saying. Many fools have the audacity to speak on the matter of this religion today, and their stupid opinions get displayed and semantics conjoined people who completely disagree, together. Just like I wouldn’t consider you I.S.I.S just because they claim to be Sunni. Don’t conjoin me with these “Shia” idiots because I claim I’m a Shia.
@@Nobody-q2j the thing is that the majority of Sunnis speak against ghulo. The exact opposite is true for Twelvers. You rarely hear any ridiculous scholars and personalities of Sunni Islam mouthing off these ridiculous things like Shias do despite the Shias being only 10% and Sunnis being majority. You'd think since there are more Sunnis you'd find more ridiculous claims like this coming from Sunnis but it is opposite.
@@yourfriends Are you insane? Both “Shia” and “Sunni” have come with horrific things. Both do it. No true Muslim would have a problem with being called “Shiatul Ali” or “Sunni”, or even “Minhaj a Salaf”. The words aren’t the problem. The problem is the idiotic people who attach themselves to these words and act as though they are the standard bearers of “Shia” “Sunni” “Salaf” and so on. Wallahi if the Ahlul Bayt and the Sahaba met the people who speak on their behalf today they would curse them all. You are living in the time of the useless idiots. These people have made halal haram, and haram halal. They have no knowledge and speak when they shouldn’t and stay silent when they should speak. Allah, InshaAllah will resurrect them upside down walking on their faces because they inverted the truth. May Allah invert them. If you think that there will not be people in Jannah who say “I am a Shia of Ahlul Bayt” you are a small thinker. Just because you claim to be a helper of the family of the prophet doesn’t denote that you are a Khariji. If that’s the case than Hassan, Hussein, the son of Khalid Ibn Walid, and all of those who died with Hussein and Fought with Ali were Khawarij. This isn’t sound methodology. The Shia/Sunni who spew out stupid statements have nothing to do with Islam. Wallahi I don’t curse the wives of the prophets or the Sahaba or ask for suqoor or any of the stupid things these people do. I am a Shia because I believe they are the most worthy to be called “Imam”, “Khalif”, and they are the most trustworthy of this umma. I believe that the prophet said “If you hold onto two things, you’ll never go astray, the Quran, and my Ahlul Bayt”. None of the family of the prophet believed the bid’ah of these idiots who call themselves Shia. They made a bunch of things up (not all, some are valid). Yet it is recorded that “Sunni” ulamah wouldn’t even take Hadith from Ahlul Bayt and called them “Weak transmitters”. This is a complex topic and I’ve already written enough, but this umma is committing a crime against Islam, whether they call themselves “Shia” or “Sunni”.
Following is the list of hidden Ismaili imams and their period of occultation - 1)Muhammad ibn Isma'il al-Maktum ( term 775 A.D to 813 A.D) 2)Abū Aḥmad ʿAbd Allāh al-Wāfī ibn Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl (term 813 A.D to 828 A.D) 3)Abu al-Husayn Ahmad al-Taqi ibn Abd Allah ibn Muhammad ibn Isma'il (term 828 A.D to 840 A.D) 4)Husayn ibn Ahmad (Abd Allah al-Radi) (term 840 A.D to 881 A.D) 5)Ali al-Hadi ibn Nizar, (term 1097 A.D to 1136 A.D) 6)Muhammad al-Muhtadi bin Hadi (term 1136 A.D to 1158 A.D) 7)Al-Qāhir ibn al-Muhtadī (term 1158 A.D to 1162 A.D) 8)Qasim Shah bin Shams al-Din Muhammad. (term 1310 A.D to 1368 A) 9)Islam shah (term 1368 A.D to 1424 A.D) 10)Muhammad ibn Islam Shah (term 1424 A.D to 1464 A.D)
12th imam is a fictional character, Jafar bin Ali Naqi (Son of 10th imam and brother of 11th imam) categorically denied that Hasan Askari has begotten a child, thus laid bare the greatest religious hoax in the history of mankind and for this he is known as Jafar kazzab in the tradition of the Rafidah but for ahle sunnat he is Jafar as siddique, and upon virtue of exposing this myth ,he is one of the greatest benefactor of Ahle sunnah and his obligations on the neck of Ahle Sunnah will remain till yaum e qiyamah.
He had claimed Imamate against Imam Mahdi (a.j.) and the biographers refer to him as Kazzab (liar). He was like the brothers of Prophet Yusuf (as). To get what he want
@@geekezahrasoltani815 Hasan Askari died childless. Following is the list of the personalities considers as "Imam ghayb" i.e, hidden imam by different Shia sects: 1)Abdullah ibn Saba's followers used to considers "Hazrat Ali" as hidden imam 2)Kaysania considers 'Muhammad al Hanfiya" as hidden imam 3)Nawusiya considers " Jafar bin Muhammad " as hidden imam 4)Waqfiya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam 5) Bishriya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam 6)Fathiyya considers"Abdullah ibn Jafar" as hidden imam 7)Muhammadiya considers"Muhammad bin Ali al Hadi" as hidden imam 8) Qaramita considers"Muhammad bin Ismail"as hidden imam 9)Daruzi considers"Hakim bi Amrillah" as hidden imam 10) Bohra considers " Tayyeb bin Ali Amir" as hidden imam 11)Muhammad Shahi Nizari considers " Amir Muhammad al Baqir" as hidden imam 12) Ithna Athari considers "Muhammad bin Hasan Askari" ( a fictional character) as hidden imam And the list is endless.....
Shias are Kuffār, and don’t call Kuffār “brothers”. because of al-wala’ wal-bara’. Read Quran 60:4, Quran 58:22, Quran 49:10, Sahih al-Bukhari 2442. only Muslims are brothers/sisters of each other.
@@AbuTaymiyyahAshShaami you can't say that brother. I am with you and I consider the vast majority of Shia to be kuffar but you cannot know for certain. Not all Shia worship their 12 Imams, some of them just view them as political leaders. Not all Shia curse the companions of the prophet ﷺ.
They(shia) say the prophet's ﷺ name casually without sending salawat (even the guy on this call). We have Quran through him ﷺ. They do believe in it, don't they. { إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ وَمَلَٰٓئِكَتَهُۥ يُصَلُّونَ عَلَى ٱلنَّبِيِّۚ يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُواْ صَلُّواْ عَلَيۡهِ وَسَلِّمُواْ تَسۡلِيمًا } Look at the narrators of this hadith: It was narrated from al-Husayn ibn ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “The miser is the one in whose presence I am mentioned and he does not send blessings upon me.” Narrated and classed as hasan by at-Tirmidhi (3546); classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh Sunan at-Tirmidhi.
The TALMUD is also authored by PERSIAN Zoroastrian converts claiming to be JEW. MAHDI or MOSHIACH is just another name for SAOSHYANT from the AVESTA. There is no Mahdi in ISLAM,
As a Sunni i have to agree with the shia brother about the Muta’ verse! If it was forbidden, Quran would have mentioned it just like the alcohol verse was gradually forbidden
Al-Rabi’ ibn Sabrah al-Juhani narrated that his father told him that he was with the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1406)
Shamsi at speakers corner is the Mahdi. He meets almost all the criteria and is doing with the Mahdi is supposed to. The thing about the Mahdi is he's only a teacher. He is not someone who is supposed to compete with Rasulallah in any way so you can not expect him tall, handsome, etc. Instead look for short, average looks etc.
May Allah guide the brother. He's definitely one of the more reasonable Shias that I've spoken to. Any rude comments directed at him will be deleted and may lead to ban from channel comments. Just because we disagree with someone doesn't mean that we have to be rude and condescending.
.
may Allah ﷻ guide him 🤲🏻 ameen. but you shouldn’t call him brother until he accepts the true path of islam.
@@muslimresponse103 Who are u referring to wessam or rizvi ?
@@zadinho2904 any shia.
@@muslimresponse103 not all shia are kuffar, u cant say akhi to a kafir so depends. But not sure about brother if it has the same weighting as akhi, Allah knows best.
May Allah guide him, I used to be Shia like him
Ameen
I'm just a plain old muslim. Leave me out of your politics.!
@@westlisbon6307I get your sentiments. But if you want to follow the Mahdi, they will call you a Shia of Imam Mahdi? Will you reject that call? Because there will be Muslims who fight him and they will absolutely call him a khariji. Think deeper brother. There is many nuances.
@@westlisbon6307it is not politics, it is about the kind of Hadith you choose to follow (Sunni being more strict, and shia Hadith being more lenient)
Succession is very much a non-issue and was only given weight in later political discussion. Besides a small handful of isolated reports, the vast majority of the companions of the Prophet peace be upon him, supported the method of succession that was utilised in the early generations.
Where the problems and conflict truly begin is how this issue in succession was used to justify major theological differences, often with little or no evidence from the Quran and Sunnah. The mainline Sunni schools of thought take evidence for practices and worship very seriously, and where we see individuals supporting practices that are born from exaggeration and lack any evidence, we dismiss the practice as being an innovation.
@@Nobody-q2j
Shiaism is a myth about 12demigods
Just my humble advice to Brother Wesam is to stop laughing and giggling when giving Dawa😊
agree.
"The easiest thing to do is prove the historical evidence for the existence of a historical personality. That's the easiest thing to do. [To go to] prophecy is a problem."
14:16
Short answer: No!
Long answer: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
May Allah bless you akhi for your gentle, objective and non-mocking approach
جزاك الله خيرا اخي العزيز
The hadith that he quoted talks about 12 khulafa, not 12 imams,
and how many of the 12 shia imams were khulafa?
Exactly. Only Ali was a Khalifah.
@@Spined1234Syedna Hassan RA too but his reign was too short. So technically only 2 but rafidah cult is based on deceit and lies 🤥
@@Spined1234 Hasan RA too
The Prophet foretold that the Kholafa (successors after him) shall be 12 Imams, and that are all from Qoraysh. (Muslim 3:220, H. 1821). This hadith can only apply to the 12 Imams of Ahlul-Bayt (as).
@@geekezahrasoltani815 The hadith does it say 12 Imams. Please read the hadith again. None of them mention anything about 12 Imams.
There is a series on the concept of immamat in shia sects . But in urdu
Channel name is dr hafiz mohmmad zubair
Salame alaykum brother,
can you make a Video of the Bahai faith and their quranic claims?
I honestly don’t even know what you’d say. I’ve read their Seal of the Prophet response. It’s incoherent.
@@TheProofLady I’ve read it but I just wanted to see what somebody who is more knowledgeable has to say about it… whiteout bashing them or something.. just some facts from hadith and quran
@@yassinesmahi9298 they were always consider as disbeliever and they accepted it unlike qadyanis , they never used Muslim with their names or claim the Islamic units as their faith , Like prayer , mosque , eid , ramadan etc they took many things from Islam but Muslims never felt to deal with them like we deal with Qadiani as they trying to steal our identity with their fake and false identity
One thing is for sure. The Baha’i faith is Kufr. This religion is a joke, it doesn’t really stand for anything. It calls for the “unity of all religions”, which is illlgical because most religions contradict each other in fundamental aspects. The members of that faith claim that god revealed all religions (polytheistic religions including).
“And whoever desires other than Islām as religion - never will it be accepted from him, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers.” (Quran 3:85)
@@supertaxi5324
This is a misunderstanding of their claims. It is like how Muslims believe Christianity and Judaism were revealed religions. They believe that various major religions were INITIALLY revealed but then became misunderstood. They do make various claims and have various stances, even the Universal House of Justice which clarifies what is haram etc
The person you are streaming with is condescending. Not good character feature. I think he should work on that to be taken seriously, and for you to be taken seriously aswell because that kind of attitude alongside you on camera also diminishes your reputation.
Following is the list of the personalities considers as "Imam ghayb" i.e, hidden imam by different Shia sects:
1)Abdullah ibn Saba's followers used to considers "Hazrat Ali" as hidden imam
2)Kaysania considers 'Muhammad al Hanfiya" as hidden imam
3)Nawusiya considers " Jafar bin Muhammad " as hidden imam
4)Waqfiya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam
5) Bishriya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam
6)Fathiyya considers"Abdullah ibn Jafar" as hidden imam
7)Muhammadiya considers"Muhammad bin Ali al Hadi" as hidden imam
8) Qaramita considers"Muhammad bin Ismail"as hidden imam
9)Daruzi considers"Hakim bi Amrillah" as hidden imam
10) Bohra considers " Tayyeb bin Ali Amir" as hidden imam
11)Muhammad Shahi Nizari considers " Amir Muhammad al Baqir" as hidden imam
12) Ithna Athari considers "Muhammad bin Hasan Askari" ( a fictional character) as hidden imam
And the list is endless.....
jazakAllahhukharan.
But this list isn't proof of anything. There is also a large list of people who believe in last prophets other than Muhammad in Abdullah (saaw) even though it's very clear he is the last prophet of God. That doesn't make the belief in a last prophet of God wrong
@@fark69
This is a irrefutable proof regarding the fallacy of faith of the Rafidah, but will be observable to only those who has sincere heart(Qalb e Saleem) to accept the truth.
This proves that this bizarre concept of" hidden Imam " was very much prevalent since the early day's of Islam and founders of Twelver sect like Kulaini, Mufeed,and the so called four deputies just plagiarise this concept ,but there is one significant difference, unlike the hidden imams of other sects who were historical characters, the hidden imam of Twelvers is a purely fictional one.
Salam Farid. I found an old tweet of yours about the issue of fasting Arafah. Please can you do a video about it as the issue needs to be more well known.
There is also no historical proof that Jesus is alive or that he is coming back to save the world.
Correct Wesam, he needs to be less impulsive.
Why is wesam acting like that? Does he really think mocking people will make them change their mind? Get this guy off your steam
May Allah (God) guide him❤
Allahu akbar
Whoever dies not knowing the Imam of his time has died the death of Ignorance (Kofr). (Muslim 3:239, H 1851)
obviously imam Mahdi exists in islam. the title should be different!
The title refers to the Shia Imam who is the son of Hasan al 'Askari which is different from the Sunni Mahdi who will appear at the end of time.
Calling imaginary person “mehdi” wouldn't make him mehdi.
@@syedabualhussain Yeah I know. That's why we call him Shia Imam.Apart from the non-existence of Muhammad Ibn Hasan Al-Askari, the father's name of the Mahdi is supposed to be Abdallah,not Hasan. So it's another contradiction
There is no MAHDI in ISLAM.
Mahdi is just another name for SAOSHYANT from the AVESTA, embedded in the HADITH collection authored by PERSIAN Zoroastrian Converts.
Mahdi exists in the Islamic literature. But he doesn't exist in the world now . Shias believe mahdi is alive now . So the title is referring that mahdi doesn't exist now .
The way of the Rawafid is very strange indeed,they says Abu Bakr,Umar ,Usman ,Muawiya committed atrocities on Ahlul Bait,lo and behold, very very surprisingly the Rawafid took revenge of all this alleged atrocities not on Sahaba but on prophet Muhammad (S.A.W),if not then why would have they included other person's name beside prophet in Sahadah and Adhan,Why then they would have believed Imamat to be greater than Prophethood? why then they would have included another persons in the attributes which are specific to prophet only like "Masum","Divinely appointed "? why then they would have barked at his pure wives, only and no other women?Then why would have they considers the Quran to be corrupted? Then why would have they believed the importance of Prophet (S.A.W) being in that he was just someone's father-in-law and someone's grandfather and nothing more? Then why would have they believed that his mission was a failure! why would they have believed that the purpose of the prophethood is just to be harbinger of someone's Imamat and nothing more than that?
All this implies that the real target of Rawafid is prophet (S.A.W) and not the Sahaba.
When the Shia (real Shia who don’t curse companions and wives of the prophet) say that the Imamat is more than prophethood, they are saying that the imams of Ahlul Bayt are higher in rank than the majority of the prophets on the day of judgement (not sayyid al anbiya). The Hadith from Ibn Hajar says that Muhummad Saw, Ali, Jafar, Hamza, Hussein, Hassan, and Mahdi are the chiefs of the people of paradise. Only one person in this Hadith is a prophet yet they will be the chiefs of paradise… many Shia don’t understand this because they are being led by fools who wouldve deserted Hussein and Ali if given the chance. They have no idea what they are saying. Many fools have the audacity to speak on the matter of this religion today, and their stupid opinions get displayed and semantics conjoined people who completely disagree, together. Just like I wouldn’t consider you I.S.I.S just because they claim to be Sunni. Don’t conjoin me with these “Shia” idiots because I claim I’m a Shia.
@@Nobody-q2j the thing is that the majority of Sunnis speak against ghulo. The exact opposite is true for Twelvers.
You rarely hear any ridiculous scholars and personalities of Sunni Islam mouthing off these ridiculous things like Shias do despite the Shias being only 10% and Sunnis being majority. You'd think since there are more Sunnis you'd find more ridiculous claims like this coming from Sunnis but it is opposite.
@@yourfriends Are you insane? Both “Shia” and “Sunni” have come with horrific things. Both do it. No true Muslim would have a problem with being called “Shiatul Ali” or “Sunni”, or even “Minhaj a Salaf”. The words aren’t the problem. The problem is the idiotic people who attach themselves to these words and act as though they are the standard bearers of “Shia” “Sunni” “Salaf” and so on. Wallahi if the Ahlul Bayt and the Sahaba met the people who speak on their behalf today they would curse them all. You are living in the time of the useless idiots. These people have made halal haram, and haram halal. They have no knowledge and speak when they shouldn’t and stay silent when they should speak. Allah, InshaAllah will resurrect them upside down walking on their faces because they inverted the truth. May Allah invert them. If you think that there will not be people in Jannah who say “I am a Shia of Ahlul Bayt” you are a small thinker. Just because you claim to be a helper of the family of the prophet doesn’t denote that you are a Khariji. If that’s the case than Hassan, Hussein, the son of Khalid Ibn Walid, and all of those who died with Hussein and Fought with Ali were Khawarij. This isn’t sound methodology. The Shia/Sunni who spew out stupid statements have nothing to do with Islam. Wallahi I don’t curse the wives of the prophets or the Sahaba or ask for suqoor or any of the stupid things these people do. I am a Shia because I believe they are the most worthy to be called “Imam”, “Khalif”, and they are the most trustworthy of this umma. I believe that the prophet said “If you hold onto two things, you’ll never go astray, the Quran, and my Ahlul Bayt”. None of the family of the prophet believed the bid’ah of these idiots who call themselves Shia. They made a bunch of things up (not all, some are valid). Yet it is recorded that “Sunni” ulamah wouldn’t even take Hadith from Ahlul Bayt and called them “Weak transmitters”. This is a complex topic and I’ve already written enough, but this umma is committing a crime against Islam, whether they call themselves “Shia” or “Sunni”.
Following is the list of hidden Ismaili imams and their period of occultation -
1)Muhammad ibn Isma'il al-Maktum ( term 775 A.D to 813 A.D)
2)Abū Aḥmad ʿAbd Allāh al-Wāfī ibn Muḥammad ibn Ismāʿīl (term 813 A.D to 828 A.D)
3)Abu al-Husayn Ahmad al-Taqi ibn Abd Allah ibn Muhammad ibn Isma'il (term 828 A.D to 840 A.D)
4)Husayn ibn Ahmad (Abd Allah al-Radi) (term 840 A.D to 881 A.D)
5)Ali al-Hadi ibn Nizar, (term 1097 A.D to 1136 A.D)
6)Muhammad al-Muhtadi bin Hadi (term 1136 A.D to 1158 A.D)
7)Al-Qāhir ibn al-Muhtadī (term 1158 A.D to 1162 A.D)
8)Qasim Shah bin Shams al-Din Muhammad. (term 1310 A.D to 1368 A)
9)Islam shah (term 1368 A.D to 1424 A.D)
10)Muhammad ibn Islam Shah (term 1424 A.D to 1464 A.D)
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Akhi can you react on the video "The Quran's fake challenge-A Surah like it?" By Adam Elmasri
salam
12th imam is a fictional character, Jafar bin Ali Naqi (Son of 10th imam and brother of 11th imam) categorically denied that Hasan Askari has begotten a child, thus laid bare the greatest religious hoax in the history of mankind and for this he is known as Jafar kazzab in the tradition of the Rafidah but for ahle sunnat he is Jafar as siddique, and upon virtue of exposing this myth ,he is one of the greatest benefactor of Ahle sunnah and his obligations on the neck of Ahle Sunnah will remain till yaum e qiyamah.
Mahdi is SAOSHYANT in the Avesta. There is No MAHDI or MOSHIACH, as written in the books of PERSIANS converts in the HADITH or TALMUDIC collection.
Not only him. Wholebanu hashim of that time denied that hasan askari had a child. Read tarikh tabari
He had claimed Imamate against Imam Mahdi (a.j.) and the biographers refer to him as Kazzab (liar). He was like the brothers of Prophet Yusuf (as). To get what he want
@@geekezahrasoltani815
Hasan Askari died childless.
Following is the list of the personalities considers as "Imam ghayb" i.e, hidden imam by different Shia sects:
1)Abdullah ibn Saba's followers used to considers "Hazrat Ali" as hidden imam
2)Kaysania considers 'Muhammad al Hanfiya" as hidden imam
3)Nawusiya considers " Jafar bin Muhammad " as hidden imam
4)Waqfiya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam
5) Bishriya considers" Musa Kazim" as hidden imam
6)Fathiyya considers"Abdullah ibn Jafar" as hidden imam
7)Muhammadiya considers"Muhammad bin Ali al Hadi" as hidden imam
8) Qaramita considers"Muhammad bin Ismail"as hidden imam
9)Daruzi considers"Hakim bi Amrillah" as hidden imam
10) Bohra considers " Tayyeb bin Ali Amir" as hidden imam
11)Muhammad Shahi Nizari considers " Amir Muhammad al Baqir" as hidden imam
12) Ithna Athari considers "Muhammad bin Hasan Askari" ( a fictional character) as hidden imam
And the list is endless.....
@@geekezahrasoltani815 your mahdi doesnt exist kid. Askari died without a progeny. Hisown family denied that he dad a son which was hidden
Can someone explain please? Where's the mention of Imam mahdi?
He’s mentioned in several Hadiths.
@@eros727 he doesn't talk about him in the video even though it's in the title
@@shirosatsuma4946 I’ll be honest I haven’t watched the whole video. I was just replying to your comment.
Mohammed ibn hassan alaskari is the Shias “imam mehdi”. They claim hassan al Askari’s son is Mohammed almehdi
Shias are Kuffār, and don’t call Kuffār “brothers”. because of al-wala’ wal-bara’. Read Quran 60:4, Quran 58:22, Quran 49:10, Sahih al-Bukhari 2442. only Muslims are brothers/sisters of each other.
Not all of them are kuffar
@@MuhammadSinap The Shias of today aren't like the Shias of back then.
@@okflyaway99 What do you mean
@@MuhammadSinap all of them today are Kuffār.
@@AbuTaymiyyahAshShaami you can't say that brother.
I am with you and I consider the vast majority of Shia to be kuffar but you cannot know for certain.
Not all Shia worship their 12 Imams, some of them just view them as political leaders.
Not all Shia curse the companions of the prophet ﷺ.
Aamiiinn
A person not leading people isn't an imam(leader)
Where is super omar?
Lawsuit forced him to close his account
They(shia) say the prophet's ﷺ name casually without sending salawat (even the guy on this call). We have Quran through him ﷺ. They do believe in it, don't they.
{ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ وَمَلَٰٓئِكَتَهُۥ يُصَلُّونَ عَلَى ٱلنَّبِيِّۚ يَٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُواْ صَلُّواْ عَلَيۡهِ وَسَلِّمُواْ تَسۡلِيمًا }
Look at the narrators of this hadith:
It was narrated from al-Husayn ibn ‘Ali ibn Abi Taalib (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) said: “The miser is the one in whose presence I am mentioned and he does not send blessings upon me.” Narrated and classed as hasan by at-Tirmidhi (3546); classed as saheeh by al-Albaani in Saheeh Sunan at-Tirmidhi.
Not true. We also should say salawat and majority of Shia Muslims are doing this.
Wesam seems immature. And little bit over confident.
The shia mahdi is unironically just the dajjal, his story is Extreme similar to the jewish king that will rule the world in the talmud lol.
The TALMUD is also authored by PERSIAN Zoroastrian converts claiming to be JEW.
MAHDI or MOSHIACH is just another name for SAOSHYANT from the AVESTA.
There is no Mahdi in ISLAM,
As a Sunni i have to agree with the shia brother about the Muta’ verse! If it was forbidden, Quran would have mentioned it just like the alcohol verse was gradually forbidden
Al-Rabi’ ibn Sabrah al-Juhani narrated that his father told him that he was with the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) who said, “O people, I used to allow you to engage in mut’ah marriages, but now Allah has forbidden that until the Day of Resurrection, so whoever has any wives in a mut’ah marriage, he should let her go and do not take anything of the (money) you have given them.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1406)
Bro! There's a literal hadith on it !
yu ignorant one
Prophet a.s forbade Mutah forever. And words of Prophet a.s are Revelation.
Allah forbade it through the Prophet
The Sunni theology is correct BUT the only thing the Shias got right is praying with their arms down(unfolded)..
Mate maliki and ibadi also pray with hands down
There are sunnis who pray with arms down too
of course he exists..
the mahdi is the man Maryam marries to guide Jesus.
And his father is in Gaza..
I have his date of birth and location.
Go back to your AVESTA, Zoroastrian.
There is NO Mahdi(Saoshyant) in ISLAM.
Audhubillah
Shamsi at speakers corner is the Mahdi. He meets almost all the criteria and is doing with the Mahdi is supposed to. The thing about the Mahdi is he's only a teacher. He is not someone who is supposed to compete with Rasulallah in any way so you can not expect him tall, handsome, etc. Instead look for short, average looks etc.
Are u serious or joking?
Shut the hell up with your blasphemy
lol
@@raden1998obviously he is a joke. are you seriously not sure!
Wow... I actually dont know what to say