Mikayla Nogueira messed up BAD this time... - REACTION
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 січ 2024
- Mikayla Nogueira messed up BAD this time... - REACTION
SUBSCRIBE! bit.ly/2DxtJhM
INSTAGRAM: / charlaychaplin
TWITTER: / charlottedobre
TIKTOK: / charlottedobreofficial
FACEBOOK: / charlottedobreofficial
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/5F95o6W...
RECENT UPLOADS PLAYLIST: bit.ly/31RVL07
2ND CHANNEL: bit.ly/3v1ZJPV
MERCH: shop.charlottedobre.net/
Hey ya'll! Today on my channel we are reacting to the latest tiktok drama involving Mikayla Nogueira and a small business owner Matthew Stevens who owns a self tanner brand Illusion Bronze. Matthew recently took to Tiktok to call out Mikayla for being shady and not following through with her promises and there are definitely lessons to learn for all influencers and brands. Enjoy :)
#mikaylanogueira #matthewstevens #illusionbronze #tiktokdrama #tikok #drama #charlottedobre #reaction #react #reactionchannel
Hi, I'm Charlotte Dobre. I'm an actor, reactor, singer and sometimes (not really) comedian. On this channel I do reactions, commentary and occasionally I make a joke or two. I love poking fun at social media, weddings, entitled people, tiktok and OF COURSE petty people. I upload daily, usually 7 days a week, unless life gets crazy or I get lazy. Come hang out, it's a good time.
CREDITS - for licensing inquiries email licensing.charlottedobre@gmail.com
www.tiktok.com/@mvstevens?lan...
www.tiktok.com/@mikaylanoguei...
Edited by Timothy Dunsmore
Co-Executive Producer: Vanessa Peprah-Addo
vanessatoro...
Footage/Sounds/Effects provided by Storyblocks
End screen song:
Defunk - (Feat. Charlotte Dobre, Sam Klass)
open.spotify.com/track/3S6FXA... - Розваги
The extra shady part is that Mikalaya was faster to post a response than to post the review she promised to do.
THIS!
Exactly! The review that took 4 months and still never came
..and why did she text him that she used it and wore it for 12 hours and loved it when the directions state that it's a rapid tan and to keep it on 1 to 3 hours? I've never paid her much attention and now she's a hard pass.
Yup! He has receipts, she does not.
That part. Also still hasn't posted the review.
Mikayla's reviews are NOT spot on. There is literal video evidence that proves that she will change her review on a product if she's being paid. She is a known liar at this point.
Especially after the mascara/falsies saga.
@@CleverBunnyOfficialAnd there was that one foundation or concealer she tried the first time and said it was shit and then she re-reviewed it after being paid and said it was amazing
they all lie....paid to lie.
I'm thinking she is just going for who is paying her the most.
@@CleverBunnyOfficialthat was so crazy to me because I use that mascara and it works! She didn’t even need to lie but still chose to
Sorry Charlotte, I did not agree with you on this one. I love you and your videos but if Mikayla said she was going to do something she should have followed through on her promise. Or she should have been straight up with him instead of stringing him along for months with promises of following through.
Nah I wouldn't do anything for free if you want me to do something for free I'll get to it when I get to it. He should've just waited patiently.
@@arielle_abarcaThat is fine to not want to do whatever for free. The problem is NOT keeping your word. You should have just said "no." Also that is very stuck up when your fans would be the reason you are where you are. A little humble juice might be needed.
Exactly! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
Right
4 months of waiting isn't an emergency. She didn't bother to even speak to him til the internet took notice.
Why tf use color gradient if you're a makeup artist??
@@BouncyBAWLSso glad to see someone else say this, I thought that too, I immediately thought wtf when she turned it off, she looked so much better with it off!
Nuh uh. After 4 months of communication, asking, being promised - she was absolutely in the wrong and deserved him taking it to social media.
My things is that he clearly knows that she is unreliable (since the communication span for 4 months) why take that amount of loan? Both are on the wrong here, Mikayla shouldn't say yes but the guy has no right trying to put that burden of taking loan on Mikayla.
@@realitytea6457 I think he just still believed in her. Since he had seen that prior video about how smaller businesses can't keep up with her orders it seems like he's been a long time fan. He probably imagined she was busy and still trusted her at that point. He lost trust when she was telling his fans to shut up.
@@kerrysmiles He has a business and they are in the same industry, he for sure knew Mikayla and her antics. I'm not trying to defend Mikayla here but putting a grown man mistake on the hands of Mikayla is bizarre. Plus why not pay her if he want her to review his product, these form of content is their main source of income.
She only issued her "apology" when she got a HUGE backlash about what she did. She's just NOT a nice person!
Pffft....I would hardly call that an apology from her. She never reviewed the product, made excuses that she doesn't usually use tanners, showed us she uses filters to make herself orange(lol...why?), got upset that he is posting about it and that SHE didn't approve him buying 10k worth of product, and basically said it's not on her. Yeah....NOT an apology. She's just again and again proving herself to be a trash person.
The only thing i notice in these type of videos is Charlotte really seems to like Mikayla. If it would have been any other influencer, she would be saying different things. And that’s okay because we all have biases. However, in this instance calling it a “misunderstanding” is complete BS. Mikayla at any point of time in these 2 months could message that she won’t be able to make a video and leave it at that. But she continue to give new timelines for her video without thinking of the other party. I would rather hear an outright NO than a Yes that never comes.
She flat out said in this video that she likes Mikayla and doesn't know Matthew. Then, she proceeded to defend Mikayla and place majority of the blame on Matthew. BIASED AF!
Who doesn’t see that Mikliar is a pathological liar. Everything out of her mouth is a lie.
If Mikayla didn't like the product and didn't want to be rude or mean, she could have just messaged him saying that. That would have been more respectful than leaving him hanging.
true, she didn't need to made a bad review, but said to him, hei, I didn't like it, so your call! I can state my opinion or not... But she saying, i loved it kind of breaks this hypothesis.
Literally 4 months in between her saying she was going to do it is crazy
You are right, but his reviews are solid and better than the spray tan she used. His product is gorgeous and I don't believe her excuses.
@@yassine8935ok I do feel bad for her about the 4 month thing because 4 months is still within my definition of asap😅. This is why I always get dates set on paper, because when I say asap it means between now and the next six months. Even if you think you are not in a rush, you are... people may not know it themselves but they have already set a date in their minds and will be disappointed and mad if you don't deliver. No date, no work. I refuse to do stuff without a clear idea of what your expectations are. If there is no date and written agreement I categorize it as low priority and will do it only when all my actual responsibilities are taken care of.
They are both business owners they should know that A- you don't rely on other people's kindness to promote stuff without a clear contract having your back, B-you don't expect people to do promos for free, you pay to make sure it will hold up in court C- Never take a loan before being shown a preview of the promo. D- don't make promises, even if you are doing it out of the kindness of your heart. If you fail to deliver or do not fulfill someone's expectations they will be out to get you. In business credibility is everything
To me, It sounded like you were siding with Mikayla. Not explicitly, but it had an underlying tone where you tried to make sense of things from her point of view. Mikayla is notorious for drama and has been called out so many time for faking things and lying. If she can not do she NEEDS to communicate it. To me it felt like she led him on. She is completely at falt. And if he gained followers and sold out products he derseved it! That doesnt negate the fact that he had to go through so many things before he called her out! Which prolly still stressing him out.
I saw it as empathetic to both sides of the argument.
But the dude is dumb as well. If she has a known history of lying and being shady, they do not have a contract and he did not pay her for the endorsement... taking out a huge loan on the promise of a known liar... is really not sane business owner behaviour and he should really take a hard look in the mirror. Also, if matches the tanner to peoples skin, how is it sitting in his house? I am sure he will eventually sell those products, tanners don't really have a best by date do they? So technically he lost whatever the interest on the loan was.
+1 this reaction appears biased towards Mikayla
I agree. I love charlottes videos and I don’t watch anything from Mickayle, but the bias from the start was apparent :/ the first comments she right away sided with her before hearing the rest.
She has mentioned before that she is friends with Makayla. She even defended her when she got a lot of hate for saying how hard her life was as an influencer. That’s why there is a bias there.
Am I crazy for thinking this video was biased ? Charlotte definitely likes Mikayla, and according to her was only wrong in one aspect, while she bashes the small business saying that he used social media to get a lot of attention to make his business work. That’s a lot from someone who says that we shouldn’t assume. I don’t know 🤷♀️
You're not crazy for thinking the video is biased. Because it is! She gave so much wiggle room to a known liar but was super critical of Matthew.
Very biased
100% this is the first time I’ve seen charlotte post something I disagree with so strongly. Charlotte is so so biased here. Mikayla was so shady here, and I don’t even know much about her, I have almost zero knowledge of her. Charlotte was so critical of Michael immediately and gave Mikayla so much leeway. Bizarre!
Yeah, with all the communication Mickayla had she could have easily said “I’m not a fan of your product” or “I can’t do this all for free” because she’s a content creator and is payed by brands so I understand that. I think Charlotte felt attached vicariously because she’s also a big content creator and so she was super lenient with Mickayla and was way too harsh with Matthew. Him telling tik tok wasn’t an attack it was just a follow up since his followers for asking. So yeah, she biased.
They're friends. I previously watched a video where she mentioned Mickayla and how she's mentally struggling about the backlash from the eyelash gate. They're def friends.
As a Paralegal, in the legal world, there was a verbal contract. Mathew relied on Makayla's word that she was going to do something, and she didn't follow through.
okay if that was real he wouldve sued her ass instead of whining online that hes in debt for pity points
@@teleportingpotatoe this was faster and less of a headache.
@@teleportingpotatoe he needed to pay his debts ASAP, and this is a faster way, I guess??
No that means absolutely nothing dude. She wasn't getting paid to do shit. And she said at the beginning she'd get to it ASAP. He was a fool to not wait until the video was posted to take the loan out since he said he got the loan in less than 24hrs and had product a few days later
@@teleportingpotatoehe's not in debt he sold out
I love how you try to give Mikayla the benefit of the doubt…but her reputation for being shady and a liar proceeds itself.
Right?!! Charlotte really showed her bias in this one.
@@ll2323definitely 😭😓😓. This blindness was in the wedding video too. She just isn’t opened minded at all when it comes to Mykayla. Even when it’s been proven she’s a lair.
Maybe Charlotte just doesn't want to get on her bad side, in case future deals could be in play or doesn't want to upset Mikayla's fans. This would be against a huge TikTok infulencer. So i would be cautious too.
But this is all speculation. We do not know what's in Charlotte's head.
Im also biased because i dont watch Mikayla's videos. Her voice annoys me. Haha, so i dont have an opinion on her ethics, and i can't go by hearing what others say. Nor do i care to even do the research to find the truth. Like i said, i just personally dont care for her.
@@LunarGoddess86 tbh if that’s the case then that shows lack of integrity on her part. Considering the risk involved working with someone like Mikayla.
@@ll2323 you bring up a very valid point. As she stated, she is careful who she works with and doesn't make promises anyone. My statement was all speculation. We dont know what her reason for her demeanor about the case is.
I love Charlotte. she's always fair about her judgment. However, i do see this one case being biased.
I completely disagree with you on this one. I feel like people give her too much grace for her actions. She lies about sponsorships, lies in her reviews & doesn’t address anything when she messes up, instead she mocks every situation. She needs to grow up & take ownership of her mistakes. There’s thousands of people living paycheck to paycheck who go out & buy her recommendations & she’s not being truthful. Not everyone has the means to buy thousands of dollars on makeup, her reviews are fake & hard working people are the ones wasting their hard earned money because of her.
Yes! Love Charlotte but gonna have to disagree with her on this one. Your word is your word and is a contract in itself 👏🏼
Thats not how the real world works unfortunately. Wake up and get a contract if youre going into business with someone. @@lrdemideleon
Agreed
I am in no way familiar with the fashion world, but this notion that "well, we didn't sign anything, so it's your fault for believing me" blows my mind.
How can someone have the audacity to openly admit to the whole world that their own word is worth literally nothing?
@@noxteryn it's not the fashion world. It's the real world. Have you never heard of contracts? Verbal contracts are not a thing. Sure it makes you seem immoral, but that guy is dumb for believing her in the first place.
She literally told him that she slept in the tan for 12 hours so she definitely got a tan not just his. She's wrong and rude
His biggest misstep here was trusting Mikayla in the first place. She’s proven herself untrustworthy. After the mascara debacle, I officially wrote her off as a credible source. He should not have purchased such a large loan without a written contract between the two of them. That being said.. I understand why he took the leap. She said she loved his product and would review it, and chose not to. “In a rush” isn’t a valid excuse to not apply a 1-hour tanner and follow through. If she wanted to keep her promise, she would have found a way to do so. She lied. Again. Lol
What's the mascara debacle?
@@blizz2795 She did a sponsored mascara Ad for L’Oréal, and in the Ad she claimed that the eyelashes were her own. After applying the mascara to “her” lashes, they magically grew twice the thickness and length. She claimed it was the power of the makeup… Unfortunately what she didn’t disclose, was that wearing false eyelashes, and she was caught lying in an Ad.
As a side note, Shopify is really messed up for offering loans to smaller creators who don't have the customer base. Stuff like that is so exploitative 😬
It’s predatory lending. Thank Republicans for that ability and usury laws being destroyed.
Sorry for going political with this but it’s unfortunately true 😢😢😢
Right, but at the same time, he shouldn't have just put the cart before the horse by taking it before her following through. He made the mistake of accepting the loan on the assumption that she would help his business, without seeing the results of working with her. She was shady, but that loan was his fault not hers
@@ahoward3503 agreed.
But my point is, listen to how he talked about it. He said they had been trying to give him this loan. They approached him.
I'm talking about a larger conversation here. I'm sure he's not the only one Shopify has done this to. They're the real bad guy here. Well... That and capitalism to begin with 🤷♀️
I disagree because he needed it to support the supply and if they weren't available he would've been screwed.
Well he sold out so…? 😅
I love Charlotte, and i usually agree with Charlotte, but honestly, I feel a lot of bias here. I don't follow/ know Makayla or Matthew but I'm pretty sure the other brand probably put in contact that she wasn't allowed to review another self tanner hence the contract and she'll probably get fined for it if she did so even with time to sit and text and do a video she chose not to review the item even though she told him she would.
He seems genuine. Mikayla’s colors keep showing through and it’s not looking good for her. Unfortunately for her, the bigger you get the more eyes are on you and all you need to do at the very least is be HONEST
I'll say this as someone who worked in a tanning salon and in spas that offered spray tans...it looks like a spray tan to me. Because usually when you apply lotion yourself, you usually start heavy at the top and it gets wispy near the wrists.
My thing is this... if she agreed to do a review, contract or not, she should have done one. It's called being a person of your word. And if like Charlotte said, the tanner just didn't work for her, why didn't she message him and let him know? Don't just ghost him. Tell him honestly. "It just didn't do it for me, and I didn't want to make a bad review of it and hurt your business". Really not that hard of a message to send.
Fukkin' Thank You! Really ain't that hard, jeez
agreed plus she left it on 12 hrs when instructions said 3 hrs max for the darker look. u don't completely screwed up the instructions, keep it on 4 times longer than recommended then say oh i didn't like it. if u are going to review a product u use it as directed for the review itself then if u want to leave it on 12 hrs another time when u aren't reviewing it fine. that's like taking antibiotics once a day for a week when instructions say 3 x a day for a week and wondering why your infection isn't gone. geesh not hard to follow directions.
I mean a verbal contract is a thing and legally binding in a lot of places. One thing I was wondering tho is why didn't he mention to her that he was planning on stocking up on a ton of product on her word? It's almost like he figured that either way, not mentioning his plan to her would be a win-win for him anyway because If she stuck to her word, good for business, and if she didn't, well she's a huge public figure whose reputation is already on thin ice for other things, so he'll just call her out, play the victim...then still good for business!
Don’t gas him up, claiming to be the champion of small business owners. “My parents are small business owners…” has the same energy as, “I’m not racist, I have a POC friend!”
@@beingbeckeronimaybe I misheard but wasn’t he saying that that’s what mikayla said to him?
I´m really bored of people making excuses for the crappy behaviour of this person.
Same. And it’s even more painful watching Charlotte trying hard to give her the benefit of the doubt
Same here
@@daydreamer4971 same
Never heard of her so to me I was on Charlotte's side. What is the Mikayla girls deal?
@@claudiafernandes1150Well, there's a lot, but I'll just give you what I IIRC is the worst: She put out sponsor ads/vids without informing people that this was sponsored or an ad. They thought it was just a normal review, so of course they fell for it. She did it for quite a while. Also, in general she allegedly lies a ton about products, especially based on what they pay her. So people who know about all this can't really trust her reviews anymore.
[Edited for grammar.]
it's the way she responded to people + blocking after that irks me the most...
No, I’m sorry, but it wasn’t just him saying she’d do the review, he had texts proving it. And he contacted her more than once about the review, she had multiple opportunities to tell him it wasn’t going to work out. Instead, she kept making promises. That’s sucky behavior. She has been an influencer long enough and is popular enough to absolutely have a formal policy re reviews. She should have sent him a contract, she should have them immediately available, hello, she should have someone who handles that for her.
If this were a lone instance, that would be one thing, but this is one of many such anecdotes. Her integrity is in shreds right now, and I think that, unless she gets her act together, she’s going to start losing collabs and sponsors.
Charolette seemed to try and justify Mikayla more. It should be unbiased. She was the one that reached out to him and made promises that she hasn't kept. He ordered based on that promise. None of this would have been a problem if she didn't promise to do a review. Once she set a date, she put it in stone and should have done it. You can't make a written contract in business and not fulfill it. He didn't cost her money. She cost him money, plain and simple! He acted in good faith, she did not!
Yes! And make no mistake, that WAS a contract!
While I definitely agree that Mikayla was in the wrong here, I just wanted to say that this is Charlotte's channel. She never promised to be unbiased. She's a reaction youtuber, and she reacts based on her own opinions. It's the cornerstone of the genre, I think, so expecting unbiased reactions probably isn't going to work out all that often.
Are we really shocked from Charolette?
@@hand0fm1dasyour definitely right that she’s not a no biased channel. But I feel like with Mykayla ive noticed that she isn’t very opened minded. It’s proven time and time again that Mykayla is just a lair. She isn’t honest with the products she reviews for money. But I’ve definitely noticed how our Char just seems to be blind to that.
@@kathydelarosa1286not at all. It's the only down side for me liking Charlottes videos, she's super bias
Charlotte, I think if this was a MUA influencer you didn't care for, you would've been a lot more honest. Makayla is clearly someone you don't want beef with, and the guy is a smaller influencer so he took a lot more of the ChaWrath in this video. It's disappointing to see you defending her more than the smaller influencer. Sometimes you can't stay neutral just so you don't burn bridges that haven't been built yet.
this is what I feel exactly. this felt extremely biased when it's just a clear-cut case of mikayla having a lack of integrity. he made some mistakes but in comparison theyre pretty minor imo.
Yeah this really actually changed my opinion on charlotte a bit. So many people in the comments saying like it’s not a big deal, and charlottes allowed to have different opinions on things and all that. I realize she’s allowed to have her opinion on things, and that’s completely fine… but it goes both ways lol her opinions can change my opinion of her also.. if that makes sense. 🤷🏻♀️
He has the right to speak about it when he has contacted her so many times and she's not doing it. She shouldn't do promises that she can't keep. It's been months and she kept lying to him. Even as a fan, you gotta admit that's so messed up. It's not good to make excuses for her.
The irony of Charlotte saying he’s trying to capitalize on people hating McKayla meanwhile she’s making this video
I've been watching this situation and, while Mikayla is a garbage liar, this guy made the bad business decision to take out a loan on someone's word, rather than a contract. Get it in writing my guy!
Facts. I won’t lie, I watch mikayla’s content now and then cause I’m a makeup junkie lol but she’s not reliable. And this is no one’s fault but his. He got no contracts, it’s not like he was payin her to use his brand, like she didn’t really have any reason to jump through hoops for this random on the internet.
@@Mashy8722 Agreed. I really used to enjoy her content because her eye looks were gorgeous, but I just can't get over the way she's been lately. It's sad to see.
Truth
While I want to understand his reasons for doing what he did, he shouldn't have ever trusted her word, you NEED stuff in contracts, Not just writing, as she promised to do it over text... but thats still not a contract. I feel bad that he was so naive and got to see first hand why peoppe do NOT trust her. Truly I do feel bad for him and don't want to blame the person who suffers most here toooo much.
Everyone messed up plain and simple.
What if her review was bad? Why would he automatically think he would be flooded with orders after her review. I still think she's a poop bag for giving him the run around
She spent more time messaging him than if she just did what she promised and used his product and reviewed it!😂
Good point!
Who the heck leaves tanner on that long?
No wonder she looked crappy 😂
And if her "review" wasn't good, then what? What if she did try it as she said, and did not like it? Bozo already got the loan. I don't even like the girl but she would get destroyed if she posted a terrible review for a small business. Even I know that. We would have been quick to tell her she should've not even posted it... because it will ruin a small business blah blah blah.
And to add on the fact that at his big age he is doing bad business on all fronts here... but is painting himself as the victim. If you are an adult, and taking a loan out with the hopes of a stranger's favor making you rich... you are a dodo. Then you send your followers days into this flimsy "agreement" to bother her non stop.... I dont blame her.🤷♀🤷♀ If i get harassed to do something I dont have to do... F you, your tanner and everyone who has a problem.
She is not obligated to do anything.Just because he overspent because he thought her review would be positive. If it was negative he'd be crying the same way. He needs business advice, not a product review tbh.😆
@@winniethepooht5776 No one with more than 2 brain-cells to rub together cares she "lied" about her accent... why would they? Anyone who actually cares about that is in too deep and needs to log off and grow up, honestly. It is not that deep.
See this is what I don't understand. Are we allowing and encouraging influencers to not have integrity? If she said she would post it, then seemingly avoided using it while saying she would post a review that never came, why would someone think she has integrity as a spokesperson for up-and-coming brands? All I would see is someone who doesn't value their word and will say whatever they think the person wants to hear to keep them happy and out of their hair. 🤷♀ Might just be how I was raised, but you don't tell someone you will do something for them (free or not) and then never do it, while still claiming you're going to do it.
Edit: Charlotte and I usually agree in most of these, but I have to point something out. She said herself she likes Mikayla's makeup, which generally means she has bias. She makes a point that he could have been cashing in on the "hating on Mikayla" train, but Mikayla could also be using this to fuel her own fires against him. I don't think it was handled well by taking it to social media, but I don't think Mikayla is as innocent as Charlotte is making her out to be in this one.
How did she have time to post a fake apology but not a reveiw? Also, it seems he tried to resolve this via text before going to the internet and she kept pushing him off. This is more than "just" self tanner, this is a small business trying to succeed. Do what you say your gonna do. Period.
The tanner seems legit, have watched some of his insta vids. Congrats on the British Vogue mentions Matthew.
“Mikayla is one of the biggest beauty influencers” Me: Has never heard of her
Me neither 🤷♀️
Same, I only have heard her here 1-2 times
Me neither
Same!
I’ve tried to watch her but her voice is so grating, I can’t stand to listen to her.
In the US her promise or textual proof is considered a verbal contract. He can in fact sue her. Don't make promises or verbal contracts you don't intend to keep.
Yup!
No it’s not. Lol yikes
@@NaomiDollxoxo yes it is. I just dealt with this in court. My opponent had to pay me $6,580 for failure to uphold a verbal contract.
I think it depends on the state you live in @@TheHumanBeanery I'm so glad you won yours!!
@TheHumanBeanery Contracts usually need to have "consideration" or what the other party will get in relationship to the agreement. This was a free review. Therefore, the business owner wouldn't have a case. I DO NOT like Mikayla but she had no obligation to do a review/positive review. The business owner made a terrible financial decision and wants the public to feel sorry for him. What if she didn't like the product and told her followers? Would she still be to blame for him taking out a loan?
He ordered that amount of product to be sure he could handle the orders. He knew her history of saying small businesses can't handle the order volume after she posts a video reviewing said product. SO he was preparing his business to fulfill the orders.
okay but hes blaming her for being in debt for 10k and thats all on him.
Him making the decision before getting a review publicly (and for her to disclose slower ship out times because of the size of her platform) or even that she actually liked it is a dumb business move. And to then blame her for his decision is shitty all together.
A verbal contract is also a contract! People, businesses , and influencers tend to forget that. If he were to take those conversations to court it very well could be seen as a contract. A defamation case could also come of all this. Now the loan part, he made a business decision.
so if its so serious he wouldve sued her instead of whining online
In this day and age, you really don't have to when clout is gonna get you more. Like I said, "IF HE WERE TO TAKE..." ***^^^ I would assume since his video went viral, his business once again went viral and he has gotten those orders, DUH.. You tried tho
My mom is a lawyer and at a young age she would do things out of her way to do things for people despite her busy schedule. And when i asked her why, she would say “it’s my word of honor.” As long as you promised someone you’d do it, you should keep your promise. A verbal contract is as good as a written contract and that’s the same when you go to court. idk, just disappointed at mikayla.
She still wouldn't owe him 10k though. That's his own silly ass that took it upon himself to do that. And he's posting videos saying she owes him 10k which he could get in trouble for.
Its not silly at all to have made sure he had the product. It's part of the risk of business and at best it just shows how ignorant of small business she is especially having criticised other indi businesses to not be ready. She set him up for failure even if it wasn't intentional.
@@andreah1104he said she owed him the 10k?
@@andreah1104 he did not say she owed him money, he said that he was in debt because hes sitting on product that may not sell. Fortunately, I do think he is selling.
@@ZNARCIhe did have that on the thumbnail but im not sure he said it again. It felt like clik bait but it goes against him for sure.
Bottom lines, 1. Don't say you will do something unless you will do it.period. 2. Never count your chickens before they hatch.
To be fair, he was told the chickens were coming so he got what he needed to prepare for them. It's not his fault that he was lied to. This is basically like if the weatherman told you a storm was coming and you bought a lot of food to prepare for it, and the storm never comes.
Someone should be able to rely on a written contract in business.
I breed exotic chickens, and so many die in the shell before hatch day. Just sayin' 😅
Mikayla lied about the mascara, it is strongly suspected that she lied about her accent, she lied to Matthew putting him down 10k, and let’s not forget the whole “try being an influencer for one day” thing.
It all just makes her look like a questionable person.
Don't forget being a predator protector with scum James Charles. She is absolutely trash and no one should be giving her grace at this point as she repeatedly has proven herself to be a trash person.
I don't think she didn't like it, I think because she wasn't paid for the review it wasn't a priority for her...
I love Charlotte, one of my favorite people for sure. However I feel like this video was made to defend Mikayla. HE DID send her the products for FREE, more than once. Mikayla NEVER says yes or anything to just be nice. She is popular because she is supposed to be blunt and honest.
Mikayla is sketchy about reviews as is. She hates on things but when they pay her to review the same item she suddenly LOVES it. And let's not forget lash gate
Yeah, I bet if he paid her with some of that 10k loan she would have been all over the tanner raving about it
Truth. Mikayla is a Narcissist.
Use the product properly.
I've noticed that too. I'm a fan of Nikkie so I used to see mikayla's videos from time to time. And every time she does a negative review, the next one is positive even if the change is minority and/or off the point🤷♀️
I'm not on makeup tiktok anymore so... I haven't seen her in a while. But ppl hate her for many many reasons 🤔
@@joey4222 I'm guessing she got a pay day from the other company.
The thing about her bashing him for going onto social media about it... First, he tried to handle it privately with her. Multiple times. He was very transparent in his communication. But she specifically chose not to tell him any of the things she now claims as excuses in her video. If her claims are true, she had so much opportunity to be honest and tell him before this happened. Finding ways to resolve it. The only reason for her not to say anything, is because she probably thought of the excuses after the fact. And as he said, he only felt the need to say something after his own followers got poor treatment from her. Something like that can easily be the last straw for anyone.
I think someone who can’t keep their word is not to be trusted, the worst part is she didn’t just say she’d do it on one occasion but multiple occasions and then never did. It reveals a lot about someone’s character.
Mikayla was wrong for majority of the situation. Matthew was wrong for purchasing so much without knowing for sure she did the video. Why would she tell him she would do it if she knew she doesn’t tan that often?? And now 4 months have gone by and all she gave was a “sorry, but your business decisions aren’t on me?”… thats horrible. I mean yes that part isn’t on her but she did LIE and clearly has no integrity
Mikayla's makeup is hideous, change my mind
Nah, she never should have entertained his request to begin with. Him guilt tripping her for reviewing his competitor and the implied threat of dragging her for it was red flags. He's just another corrupt little clout goblin like her, lets be real.
sure. and she's a liar -- zero integrity. @@ANPC-pi9vu
And he showed up as a fan of hers citing where she said she’s hesitant to review small business because they often don’t have the capacity to fill an influx of orders after she reviews. You can’t speak your opinions of small makeup businesses on the internet, but then claim you didn’t influence a business decision.
@@ANPC-pi9vu your comment is a red flag to me
I don’t wear makeup of any kind, nor do I use tanner, but the things I hear about Mikayla in videos is horrendous. People need to stop giving her a platform.
I am a black woman so I don't watch her but I'm like you, I've heard nothing but HORRIBLE things about her on multiple channels..
@@alexandriav3956 a lot of the makeup she does might not work with their skin tone so they watch people with their skin tone
@@SwnsasyI watch everyone's videos no matter what color they are. 🤷🏼♀️
@@beelowe3474do you need medal !!?
@@alexandriav3956 Why would I watch a white woman for makeup tips when I'm black? How on earth is that lost on you? 🤣
Whoosh! She is off putting in soooooo many ways. How in the world is SHE a beauty influencer?! 🤯
Lowkey disappointed that you only left links for Mikayla but not Steven.
But the fun part is she couldn't post a review video (twice!) but could SURE post a response video ASAP.
EXACTLY! When *she* had something to lose, that’s when she spoke up. But couldn’t have cared less when it was Matthew
When she clearly had a tan 😂😂😂 Must've just happened during one of those random one or two times a year that she tans...lol
@@nativegirl8186 weird coincidence right?! 😂
Mikalaya only addresses something when she gets called out on it, then cries victim. She is just a terrible person in my opinion. Have a lovely day everyone.
I've watched her a handful of times and she completely grosses me out
He's doing the same thing, she literally owed this guy nothing and never told him to take out a huge loan.
@ANPC-pi9vu yeah. But there was evidence to suggest that when she did the review that he might not be able yo keep up with demand. So he was trying to be prepared. And she did technically owe him either a review or a message telling him why she didn't post one. She told him that she would do the review but never did. That's the real ick here. If you say you're gonna do something, then do it! Plain and simple.
@@loosilu Yeah, she gives me the ick.
@ANPC-pi9vu Her makeup is hideous, I'm a fan of beauty products, I wouldn't give this b the time of day
I feel bad for this guy. It's irresponsible to tell anyone that you will do something and then not to. Shame on her.
What about the fact that using a colour grading filter overtop of a photo/video of a tanning product is super disingenuous to the company and their product? 😒 That alone would be something to be upset about... not a great excuse
I came to the comments to find this comment!
He did what any business would do to prepare, especially after her note on how indies just can't meet demand. Mikayla has shown time, and again she's not a trustworthy person, and that is the overall point to this entire situation. Those text messages count as a contract. Even if it's written in an email, it counts, even in court. Mikayla is in the wrong here, not Matthew. Yes, he ordered to be PREPARED for it because she misled him. Not to mention that she also lied, she said she used it and would review it when it was clear she didn't and wouldn't. Highly disagree with you here, saying both are in the wrong when Matthew did what anyone would do to prepare.
THIS
Yup! May be the first time I’ve disagreed with Charlotte! 😂
YES!
This is not a contract. Not because texts can't be, but because a contract can't be made out of someone saying they will do you a favour, there needs to be mutual consideration.
@@Rose_Castle In the US this most definitely can constitute a contract.
Something similar happened to me with my clothing brand. A influencer reached out to me and I was willing to work with her. We decided to have lunch to talk about the brand. The day we were supposed to meet, she stop taking my phone calls, and ignored my text messages. Smh. What irritated me more was the fact that SHE reached out to me. Like, if you weren't serious, you could've just stayed out of my inbox 😒
Don’t be shy.. expose her!
Can I ask what your clothing brand is? just out of curiosity. I need some new clothes. Tho I am chubby so do you xl sizes?
@becky8369 Hi had to do a partial shut down due to personal reasons, but the clothing brand is called Sweet Riot. I'm on Instagram, Tiktok and Facebook. I'm doing a relaunch this year.
@@becky8369I'm an XL in most clothes, too. I bought a cute, little workout skirt a few months ago. When it arrived, I noticed that the size in the garment is marked as "extra lovely." ☺️
That's such clever marketing! It's a great way to make customers feel good about themselves, and thereby convert them into loyal shoppers. After all, who buys a twirly skirt for working out, and _doesn't_ want to be considered extra lovely? 😁
Ugh. My point got away from me. I started this response to tell you that you're not chubby. . . .you're extra lovely! 💕
As an aside, the owner of that business just got a patent on the skirt I bought, because the high volume, cheap knock-off places kept stealing the design. Some people put their creativity, heart, and hard work into starting a business. Others advance by stealing ideas. It's frustrating that the idea thieves usually get away with it, since small business owners often don't have the extensive resources that are necessary to fight back.
@becky8369 Hi! I'm sorry I'm just now seeing this. It's a streetwear clothing brand called Sweet Riot. I'm on Instagram, FB, and Tiktok. I'm not taking orders at this time but I plan to be up and running by the end of the year.
I don't justify her actions/ inaction at all, but taking out a $10k loan is nuts if you don't have anything in writing, no guarantee she likes your product etc. Huge risk.
Especially before she even posted a review. Like I’m not saying what she did was ok, but its unreasonable to take out a loan when no video has been posted, you don't know how the video will review your product, and you don't know what kind of demand a video will bring
Dude, Charlotte, just don't make another video like this if you decide to be so biased towards an influencer like Mikayla. It'll turn out to be bad business to you. You'll start to lose your own fanbase.
I just don’t understand and how she ended up being one of the biggest beauty influencers in the world. 🤷♀️
It baffles me as well 🤷♀️
Luck. And her soul was quite cheap
People wanna see makeup make magic. Let’s be real, her before and after is dramatic.🤷🏾♀️
She does look great for a trans woman tho.
@@stephenellwood161she’s trans???
I don’t blame Mikayla for him taking out a huge loan, that was all him. But, she continued to lead him on that she would review it and THAT was not ok.
See that’s the only thing I think she did wrong. Matthew is more in the wrong in this situation
@@ashleywiley3523yeah, maybe in this situation but Mikayla is just generally not a good person. She lies to her viewers non stop and has been caught several times with proof. Honestly, the tan situation is just adding fuel to the fire that she started herself whether she’s right or wrong this time
@@ashleywiley3523 ok Keep defending wish Washy until it lands you into a rocky position
She's not known to be reliable... so it's all on him
@ashleywiley3523
He wanted her to do a free review. If he wanted it done by a certain time, he should've made a contract and paid her. He thinks all she is doing is thinking about his product as much as he is. He is still blaming her for the 10k loan because she said she reviewed brands that couldn't keep up with the supply. That is STILL a business decision on HIS part. He makes a video complaining that she hasn't gotten to his FREE review, sells out of product by doing so, and is STILL complaining.
13:50 GIRL, WE HAVE CAUGHT U LYING SO MANY TIMES! U know damn well u have had a spray tan before!!! 😂😂😂
Hmmm idk with this one girl. I get why, looking at this from an influencer’s POV, you’d be more lenient on her. I think your post was very fair because you have insight on both sides, and I’m so so sure it’s exhausting getting asked constantly to promo every small business or every single person you’ve ever interacted with online, I totally get that (honestly I’ve been taken advantage of just because I buy things for friends, and I’m a normal person) so I can’t imagine how bad it is with a platform…. Truly that must suck, you definitely have to protect your name and yourself for sure! But this is my POV as someone who used to watch her videos as they came up, never really liked her but the algorithm pushed her hard.
BUT Mikayla is a scam artist, he wasn’t pushy and he seems like a decent guy who saw this as like basically a lottery ticket, and he has a good product! No wonder he was worried! 10k to Mikayla now is nothing, but when she was working at Ulta it was probably life changing money, so it’s about perspective, he’s probably not going to become homeless from it but yeah it was that deep to him!
She told him she would, then she should, or should’ve told him she couldn’t, it’s simple. I don’t believe for a fact a single influencer on this platform hasn’t hustled and gone out of their way to sell themselves or their business in some way shape or form, and I’m sure he didn’t love asking her to review it, it he did it cause he believes in his product.
We have all seen she’s been vile and vindictive to people that disagree with her, she’s straight up lied and faked reviews and has repeatedly been exposed with proof that she is a chronic liar… look at the girl that she blocked and cussed out and then claimed it was her anxiety… she really doesn’t seem to care about anyone she feels is beneath her. I don’t trust anyone that fakes their entire personality down to their accent for views and money. She’s the most self centered creator for the most minimal work I’ve ever seen truly. He even waited 3 weeks before even checked in or started “bothering” her.
I also think something is missing though because WHO would ever agree to do a review of a product without trying it? She basically only does good reviews, or does bad ones then deletes them and redoes them when the company pays her, so logic follows it would’ve been a good review, why tf would she agree to that blind?
If she’s saying “I’ll do it in X amount of time” it’s not unrealistic for him to make the “well I need more stock” leap in his head. Even her apology sounds like “I know I said I would but he should’ve known better” it sounds like she’s blaming the dude for trying to make a proactive decision for his business and she’s shaming him for… what trusting her word? That’s what this amounts to.
I don’t even watch her and I’ve seen enough of her videos to know that people taking things to social is the ONLY way she’ll actually respond, she’s blocked multiple people now who tried to reach out to her personally and she’s only responded when she was publicly called out well after the fact.
I feel like it’s not beyond her pettiness to purposely go get that orange ass spray tan acting like it’s his, to kind of shade him for bothering her. Truly it seems like that’s the person she is.
I’ve seen his product, HopeScope posted a video and it was randomly in there and it looked soooo much more natural than what Mikayla had on in the pic he showed. I know it was his assumption but if it looks, quacks and walks like a duck… I’m just saying
I will say this, Matthew owned up to his mistakes while Mikayla seemed to double down on hers. That's where I am on the situation. Both sides messed up in the beginning, but only one owned it. That's what I look at when fights happen.
I think this is a fair point, especially in terms of basic integrity.
This. Thought the same.
I stopped the video to hunt this guy down and see real reviews and his product seems gorgeous and solid. Makayla has a history of being disingenuous and I don't believe that she's ever tried his product.
Remember that right now he is getting pity buys. People jumping on the bad wagon. Go back down the road. Then it will be more honest.
What mistake did he make other than spending 10k he didn't have on his product?
So from what I am seeing and hearing, Mikayla did agree to do a review. Matthew waited and waited and even saw her review of the other company.
Now when he reaches out to her she says she is going to do a review the next day. Also she said she used it and loved it. However, later on she admits she hasn’t had a chance to review the product. So to me she lied about even using it. And yes she didn’t tell Matthew to purchase more products, but she also made a video saying small business can’t handle the amount of business that comes there way, so he was just preparing for an onslaught of orders.
Also it seems he went to social media only after he tried to deal with Mikayla on his own.
I fully agree that she was completely in the wring and that he was trying to be proactive and prepare for the onslaught of orders but he really shouldn't have taken the loan before especially since there was no legally binding contract thankfully he was able to get it all sold. That being said that was a dick move by Mikayla she did him really dirty
Mikayla has always rubbed me the wrong way, even before the drama ensued. I blocked her and still can’t even escape her. But regardless I’m so glad I did considering how she’s shown her true colors and gotten herself involved in so much trouble. Not to mention she still doesn’t know how to disclose her ads and such. 🤷🏻♀️ Can’t trust what is genuine and what’s being made for money anymore. I love Charlotte but I wish she opened her eyes a little more to the type of woman Mikayla really is. It’s frustrating seeing her validate and subtly defend her actions.
For everyone saying they disagree, I give you major props for having some good points and just not being nasty about your side of things. This is how you have healthy discourse lol
Nah, because he confronted her privately, she decided to tell him bs privately, so I think it was actually the wisest thing to pull it in front of the publics eye cause that is the only way to ensure that she will actually check her own behavior. It's no longer one nobody, it's all the nobodies on the internet that turned her into what she is: successful
Right?!! Like he definitely tried to handle it privately for several months.
@@ll2323like 4 months or something he gave her so many opportunities to handle this privately. And she did lie, she said she loved his product and used it all weird, and girl why would you have that color gradient filter on??? It literally makes you look orange, why would you want to look like that? She looks so much better with it off! And why hype him up privately and then be rude to people asking about it in her comments? If you genuinely used it and didn’t like it you, why not just say that?
@@outcastnine2224then get someone else but never put all your eggs in one basket. He made so many mistakes here and it’s wrong to point the finger at anyone that would be doing a favor in the first place regardless of who that is.
I used to run an official social media site for a former celebrity. Her manager told me to get fan questions and she would answer them in a video "this week". This week ended up being 9 months. I had fans continuously asking me where the video was. I messaged the manager and he kept saying "tomorrow " finally I was like "I could have conceived and birth a baby in the time Ive been waiting, it's pissing the fans off and Im getting hate messages".
Well I was actually Facebook friends with the celebrity's husband. I never went to him for anything because it wasn't my place but we were at almost a year now with "tomorrow" being the answer I got every day. I messaged the husband and was like "Im sorry to bother you, but on September 6th manager said..."
I got a video call from the celebrity herself apologizing. She said that the manager never even told her about this, and she didn't know why he was stringing her fans along, and that day she had sent me the video answering the fans questions. The manager was so pissed at me for going to her. And I felt really bad and I actually got another message from her apologizing again and saying I did nothing wrong. She was very nice about it.
He actually ended up getting fired from her team a couple of months later.
So yeah I get the anxiety, of waiting for a video, and I didn't even buy any product. I can't imagine if I lost money over this like he did.
He actually didn't lose money. Charlotte said he sold out of that product.
Will NEVER understand why anyone would behave that way. It's not beneficial to anyone involved.... Entitlement and audacity are not a good look. Best wishes to you and yours my friend!💖
That was his mistake. Taking out such a big loan before the review was just stupid. She could’ve done the review but something completely out of her control could’ve prevented it. You never know what life throws at you. Not to mention that pre orders are a thing if he was stressed about the stock “problem”
That seems so common in Hollywood, doesn’t it? There are SO MANY actors who have missed out on roles they wanted, originally and to come back to, because their “people” told the producers they weren’t interested but never actually talked to them about it. Those people need to be fired
So true, reps are gate keepers, even orgs like make a wish get turned down and I’m always like did the celeb even know.
They had a verbal contract . Road of mouth . She can be sued
"I will do it tomorrow" - she didn't do it tomorrow, didn't reach out => she lied. So he is accurate.
“I’ve never gotten a spray tan in my life” girl you have talked about your spray tan before in past videos😅
Yeah and the reviews of his bronzer looks nothing like that. Not even close. His bronzer looks super natural.
She’s so shady
I've never watched her videos but I immediately felt that she was lying about the spray tan. I'm glad you confirmed that because I was wondering if any who's watched her videos could confirm or deny.
@@sn6328 when it comes to what people say I can remember it. It’s dumb to lie about it when there’s video proof😆
Ohhhhhhh dang!!!!! Another lie apparently! Geeeeeees.
He literally waited months trusting over her integrity....what was he suppose to do? Let his products rot. I am glad he told the truth with receipts and sold out.
👍🏻right!
He could have just entered into a contract instead of e-begging an influencer for clout, taking out a loan he couldn't pay, and damseling. I think creating a victim narrative against a controversial influencer was the game all along and it worked.
"Maybe she didn't like it or was feeling pressured...?" Umm then she should've said that without giving him false hope!
As a small business owner. I want to help support him.
Honestly, she has always given me vibes that something is off with her.
Bashing is a strong word, everything is out here on social media and he just told his side. No slander no defamation just truth
Eh, idk. I saw a lot of things that might be his truth, but not factual. And it felt a little “bashy” to me, but that’s not saying it wasn’t warranted. I feel that they both messed up. Clearly she made way too many promises she didn’t keep. But his lack of any accountability is a bit entitled, in my opinion. He can’t arrogantly say he doesn’t need her for success out of the same mouth that created this fiasco and blames her that he’s not selling product as quickly as he expected to, with her help. It’s just contradictory and he’s got to be consistent with the point he’s arguing. Either way, they’re both making bank and I’m not, so good for them. 😂
To very publicly say she cost him 10,000$ when it was his own mistake, is accusatory. To stalk her tanning situation and make assumptions is just straight up creepy. And to throw her mental health back at her to pressure her into working for his brand for free is just.. bad.
@@lakritz8732 na, she said she "used" it in a post and it looked like shit turn's out she didn't and said she did and it looked like a shitty spray tan
@@BeingAMomAndBeyond He took responsibility for what he did. Watch till the end. For taking the loan buying the product, he stated that he did it as a business move not because she asked him to because she had earlier stated that business most times do not prepare for the outcome of her reviewing their product and sometimes get greedy
Shes got time to make an apology video but didnt have the time to make the review video she had promised. Thats where the issue lies with me.
Charlotte giving defense lawyer 😂
SN: why would you put a filter on a product review…
I stopped this video to look up and follow this guy. Elizabeth Hartman reviewed it and omg this bronzer looks so natural and pretty! I'm legit sold on this guys product. Mikayla did him dirty and lost an opportunity to look way better than whatever spray tan she was using. Seriously his product seems quite superior. I don't think she tried it because it looks so natural and pretty and I think that she would have liked or loved it.
Michaela is one of those individuals, that even if you try to like her, she makes it impossible with the way she is
I don’t know her, this vid is my introduction to her. I don’t have any interesting in getting to know her more after watching this. C’est la Vie.
She has the aura of "don't you know who I am" and those types of people are insufferable
@@amyroseplusoneBINGO! super spot on...I wasn't sure how to put it into words the vibe I get from her but that's spot on
I agree! Which is why I don't understand how she's soooo successful and popular.
Her voice alone is enough to put me off let alone all the shady shit 😂
I think Mikalaya took a brand deal with the other company intentionally for the bag and has a contract where she can not review his product. It's the only situation that makes sense for her lying
But that still doesn't make sense because if this was true, then she could and should have told him that she was under contract and couldn't review his brand at that time.
Well actually it does make sense if you consider that she probably lied from the jump when she told him that it was a coincidence that she reviewed the big company rip off product 4 days after he messaged her about reviewing his!!
@@jillvasquez1010I don't think she would admit as there is already lots of hate for how she gives fake reviews if she is paid (as per comments on this video). Why would she say that when anyone can post the screenshot online and cnf the accusations?
All this really comes down to, is staying true to your word.... that's it.
He sent her a video asking her to review his product and FOUR days later she posted the competition.
But those endorsement contracts take longer than four days to arrange and finalize. So she was always planning to review the competition before he ever tried to contact her
Unfortunately, I feel like if this were a reddit story and not about Mikayla we wouldn't be hearing the level of dismissal of her behavior. I feel like "wishy-washy" is not enough to describe what now looks like a pattern of behavior. The small business owner made his own mistakes and miscommunications, but that doesn't make Mikayla's behaviors less inappropriate and unprofessional.
I agree.
Exactly she lied to so many people throughout this about so many things. Sure he should have got a contract but he has it in writing and in court verbal agreements can be evidence so I don’t think his to blame other than trusting a know shady individual.
She doesn't owe him anything! You can do a favour and you can choose not to, imagine if her review was "it's awful"? That could disrupt his business entirely. He made a business decision without even knowing if she will like it or not. That's a lot of nonsense business decision.
@@jemmaj2919that doesnt change the fact that she just straight up fkn lied.
Thank you. This is brilliant and so true. Most people aren’t going to use critical thinking like this, though.
When she said "I'll do it tomorrow", that's kind of a promise. It's so tough to start a business these days, esp cosmetics, and of course the companies rely on advertisement, even the big companies need to promote their products. If she didn't want to do it, she should have said no and shouldn't have made false promises. This influencer culture is awful. Imagine having to depend on the mood of some spoilt person who can ruin your business with one stupid clip.
Absolutely agree. I would 100% prefer to remain a niche business, with a smaller revenue than having to depend on any influencer in the hope of blowing up and becoming rich, it's not worth it.
ik its a verbal contract, but also the suggestion from Charlotte that you need a written and notarized contract for every single interaction like this is sad. it's a shame a lack of integrity is the norm
The thing is, verbal contracts are a thing. He could technically use those texts in court over a verbal contractual agreement. Either way, she wad quick to post a rebuttal but couldn't post the review after 4 months? Mikayala has always been shady and he's not the first to have issues with her. Just because her makeup brand is good, doesnt mean the person behind it is. I mean...
Idk Charlotte. You occasionally talk about this influencer but it seems like it's only when you can find some way to be pro-Mikayla. I don't remember seeing anything about "lash gate" where basically everyone agreed she was in the wrong and maybe even committing fraud. Maybe as an influencer yourself, the many dramas surrounding Mikayla should just be something that isn't video worthy.
No, Mikayla only cares about the money. Even if she loved it she won’t talk about it unless she’s getting paid.
THIS. I'm presuming the other company probably paid her and likely sent her free product. His expectation of a review (iirc) was based off of a promise and no money or contract was exchanged nor free product sent, right? That's why she wasn't in a hurry (or likely never going to) do it.
My problem is still largely with Mikayla. She set a timeline and, while not a hard contract, it could be construed as a “verbal” contract. If she didn’t like the product or did not have time, she should have said so. Set hard timelines and boundaries. Mathew isn’t in the clear for that huge purchase, but that was also a response to a promise of increased traffic.
I couldn't have said it better myself. This is precisely how I see it.
And based on her previous statements of previous indie brands being overwhelmed by orders and not having the inventory and capacity to fulfill the orders. “Mikayla cost me $10k” is the actual truth by not just how she handled his specific situation, but posting her reasoning for reviewing less small businesses/indie brands online for the universe to see.
Um no. Contract law 101 is that both parties receive something. There’s no contract in agreeing to give some pushy dude a favour for free. Can we stop acting like we know the law when we don’t?
@@Anna-sh6pt that is not at all what contracts are. google will even tell you that a contract is defined as "a written or spoken agreement, especially one concerning employment, sales, or tenancy, that is intended to be enforceable by law." this falls under verbal agreement with sales. But go off sis.
@@Anna-sh6ptyeah that’s not how that works. If there is communication between two parties, and one party acts on the other’s last communication that is seen as agreement and they’ve accepted the other party’s offer/terms.
Charlotte is just the messenger. These 2 adults are responsible for both of their actions. Keep up the good work charlotte ❤❤❤
But he was working on Mikayla’s intention of making a review, because she’s a huge influencer. If I knew that I was going to have an influx of orders, I would’ve done the same thing and ordered stock to prepare. She should’ve said no from the jump if she doesn’t do Tanner often.
I’m a huge fan of you Charlotte but I feel like you have a soft spot for Mikalaya. This is the second videos I have seen of you defending her even when she was in the wrong. You’re looking for a way to make her right. She was clearly in the wrong and I don’t think it was a coincidence. She is a shady influencer.
I feel the same way
My view is that Charlotte has a lot of business experience so she has insight into how reviews, ads for sponsors, and contracts work. It was wrong of her to not do the review when she said she would. It was wrong of him to order product on a loan.
I actually feel like Charlotte is playing devil's advocate. She pointed out the flaws in each side of the argument. Seems fair to me, but we're also all allowed our own opinion.
I think Charlotte is a fan of Mikalaya anyway and is able to see it from her point of view as a influencer (kind of) so is playing devil's advocate. We as viewers can't imagine what goes on behind the scenes. I think Mikalaya is in the wrong more here too, but I think it may seem like Charlotte has a soft spot because she actually might have (which is totally up to her!) but also because she has a different angle on the situation to us viewers.
I think she was fair.
She’s not defending mikayla. She’s just saying that it’s not 100% on just her. That guy made a decision all on his own to take a loan. They didn’t have a contract, she didn’t owe him anything. He should’ve known better given the track record of their previous convo.
My mom is a small business owner. To me it’s more about this is someone’s livelihood. Sales for us means rent, food, and mortgage, so I perceived this, as it’s not just about self tanner this is putting food on the table for him. And let me tell you she had no problem posting that video so quickly as she did.
Exactly!
My dad also is a small business owner, he got fucked over a lot because of shit like this. I empathize but all I can see is irresponsible business decisions. You ALWAYS have a clear contract, never trust someone's good faith when it comes to money. My dad lost 27k because of mistakes like this one... I know what is like listening to your parents cry because they lost years of savings in one go, I know what it is like to see your dad move to another country so y'all can stay afloat... It is a hard lesson but what the tan guy did was beyond irresponsible, and Mikayla was shady af for not being more transparent
23:34 if she didn’t like it she could’ve texted him about not liking it. If she had valid concerns about the quality of the product it could’ve helped him more than not posting.
Never heard of her until today, but I do rendering and video editing for a living. There's an edit point (cut) in her video when she says she'll turn her filter off. The tone and colour of everything behind her in the video looks the same as it did before the cut, but she doesn't. Looks to me like she changed her makeup between cuts. I've never heard of a camera with a built-in colour filter that only filters the person and nothing behind or around them.
I think Mikayla is in the wrong here. First of all, if in the first contact with Matthew, she’d have told him that she doesn’t make free reviews or that she’s not interested, it’d have been ok. But no, she agreed to post the review. And second, she was the one that set the date about posting the review. It was all her fault. If she would have ignored him or tell him “no sorry” this wouldn’t have happened
saying mathew 'lied' or 'fabricated a lie' is really shady coming from mikayla when mathew didn't lie about anything and just speculated which was very evident by his video where he even showed their convo where she said she used it.And why was mikayla blocking and saying no to all the fans who were asking for the tan video?If she did have a problem with reviewing it she should have said it 'in private' like she is saying now that they could have solved it offline but also as we know talking to mikayla doesnt lead to any result as y'all can see
I'm done letting ppl make excuses for her
The first time I ever heard of this so-called beauty “influencer” was when Markie did his reaction video to it.
Neither side is perfect but I lean towards his side. She should have told him that she only tans a few times a year and either did it when she said she would or told him that it could be months before she got to it and she would tell him once she had it filmed.
She made promises and didn’t follow through or communicate with him. He has every right to be upset with her.
Yes inagree but posting it to bash her name was not right to sell out his fuck up.
Upon all her controversies , he still decided to work with her ?!? What did he expect? Besides he shouldn’t have taken the loan in advance like that.
@@deathroseae4317 He didn't fucked up she did.
@@foivechan Even though she said she was going to review his tanner on the 7th December, of course he would go for a loan to prepare for orders.
@@kerriemccoy1647no, it’s his own fault. He put all his eggs in one basket. He’s a business owner, he should know better.
Matthew spent $10,000 on product BECAUSE of Mikayla's ability to increase sales for small businesses. Is anyone realising that Mikayla herself said that Indy Brands have sold out due to her review videos and customers had to wait for their orders? Matthew in good faith bought extra product to make sure that didn't happen to him and that his customers got their product. Mikayla is the one totally in the wrong. She strung Matthew along promising a review video and not delivering said video. Sorry but Mikayla made a promise to Matthew and failed to keep it. He was making a promise to his expected customers by having enough product that was not wrong of him. Text messages are a contract. Mikayla agreed to deliver sonething and she broke that promise. Sadly it is a harsh lesson for Matthew to learn, that not everyone is to be trusted.
text messages are not a contract that equates this this idiot guy taking out a 10k loan lmaooo
@teleportingpotatoe try that 'text messages are not a contract' excuse in court. It is a written agreement between 2 parties. As for his taking the $10,000? You did see the proof in the video that Mikayla boasted how small brands got so many orders that they sold out of product, right? She promised to do a video and he got extra product due to that promise. If she had no intention of doing the video? Tell him. Don't string him along with promises of 'I'll do it ASAP, I'll do it tomorrow'.
@@karaleetrappTruthfully, no...that wouldn't hold up in court. It's not a contract between 2 parties...it's just a conversation.
@kellykountouris7193 it is not 'just a conversation' when 1 of the parties agrees to provide a service in that 'just a conversation'. Try watching Judge Judy and what she says about text message contracts.
Because of this exact type of thing, I no longer do ANYTHING (like take that loan he was offered & buy product) until the other person fully does whatever they said they would do.
That's exactly correct.
She shouldn't have made promises she couldn't/wouldn't keep. Also the fact that she kept lying to him makes it real hard for me to be on her side. Honestly, I never got good vibes from her and am not really surprised by this. Hopefully that guy sells the product.