Outlander | Brianna Learns The Truth About Her Father
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2021
- Claire tells Brianna the truth about her real father.
Season 2 Episode 13: Dragonfly in Amber: In the late 1960s Claire and her daughter Brianna, attend her friend Reverend Wakefield's funeral, meeting his adopted son Roger. Roger and Brianna look through the reverend's papers and discover Claire's time-travel secret, which she then explains to them, including Brianna's paternity, earning her daughter's disbelieving scorn. However, a meeting with Scottish Nationalist Jillian, whom Claire knew as Geillis in the eighteenth century, confirms Claire's story. Mother and daughter are reconciled, and then Roger gives Claire astonishing news.
Watch now: ua-cam.com/users/showSCyxfa7B...
Subscribe to SPTV for more from your favorite shows: bit.ly/OfficialSPTV
FOLLOW OUTLANDER
Facebook: / outlandertvseries.starz
Instagram: / outlander_starz
Twitter: / outlander_starz
FOLLOW SONY PICTURES TELEVISION
SPTV Facebook: / sonypicturestv
SPTV Twitter: / sptv
SPTV Instagram: / sptv
SPTV: www.sonypictures.com/tv/outla...
ABOUT OUTLANDER: A married combat nurse from 1945 is mysteriously swept back to 1743 and thrown into the middle of the Scottish rebellion against the British army. Forced by circumstance to marry an outlawed Highlander, she finds herself falling in love and torn between her loyalties to two men in different centuries.
#Outlander #Starz #ClaireAndJamie
Outlander | Brianna Learns The Truth About Her Father
/ sptv
I never could have stomached Frank after seeing how deranged his identical twin was in the past, I remember in the hospital how Clair recoiled when he approached her bedside and reached out to touch her.
The first time watching it I really thought Claire would feel the same. Idk how she was able to live with Frank after everything she went through with Randall…
Frank was Black Jack’s multiple great nephew and not a twin. BlackJack Randall was evil. Frank was a good man who put up with a lot after Claire came back from the past, even raising Brianna as his own.
I felt sorry for frank a bit,he loved Claire and when she went missing it must I broke his heart,and he excepted her when she got back and took on the baby,he can't help who his ancestors are.
@Joseph Gillespie Yeah, but the second his brother died, he started beating on him. I get he didn't want his brother to die, but beating him tells me he has no good in him at all
Well thankfully he was descendant of his younger brother, so Jamie was able to kill him without endangering Frank
Roger is me when I go to my friend's house and they start arguing with their parents.
The worse is that he is in his own house
@@MegaAndjac ahahahaa true
This is so true 🤦♂️
I must say Frank is quite a tragic character
loses his wife, discovers he's sterile, finds her pregnant, raises somebody else's child for 20 years only to then die and his wife and daugther go back in time to the other man, dude!
Jack would be dissapointed
Frank was no angel.
Yeah it is somewhat sad but a good amount of it is his own fault. He incessantly begged Clair over and over to be with him even knowing she didn't love him anymore. He literally had tantrums over it. Sure he's an incredibly nice guy but he just set himself up for a lot of pain. And then him later trying to guilt trip Clair was extremely pathetic.
Text book simp.
Plus having a certain ancestor…
Tragic, yes; pathetic, quite the contrary. Only the very immature could come to such a conclusion.
Poor Roger is just sitting there like 😳
Actually he had already figured it out and was keeping stum
Outlander is THE BEST show I have ever watched. More happens in one episode than happens in a whole season in any other show that I have ever watched!!
I also enjoy how they accurately portay Natives like me, our customs and languages are treated with respect in this show and that's VERY much appreciated
Lets be honest something decent out of Hollywood is so rare these days the competition is not exactly tough
Mostly because it’s a book. They should just make movies out of books
@@deanfirnatine7814 There is so much good television out there. I suggest you expand your horizons.
The France episodes were meh
Tobias Menzies is a wonderful actor. After seeing Outlander it was amazing to see Menzies as Prince Phillip in the Crown .
Yes, he stole every scene he was in. Incredible range
Even though this took place in the 60's in those days a woman who'd cheated on her husband was considered pretty disreputable. In the late 40's when Bree was born It was far worse! In the book a doctor realized Bree had the wrong blood type to be Frank's child and was on the verge of refusing to have her and her mother as a patient until Frank saw it coming and casually said that Claire was a pregnant widow when he married her.
These days we care little. What someone does with their own self is their business. It's between the couple, not us. Some are still chopping at Claire for her "Time travelers divorce" (simply don't go back to that time and they aren't your husband anymore if you never come back.) but most of us love this story despite her seeming offense.
Technically there was not adultery, and so no cheating. Frank was death is 1740, and Jamie was death in 1948.
The old priest at the monastery told her to think of God's time construct, not ours. She married Jamie in the 1700's. She married Frank in the 1900's after Jamie had died. Therefore, Jamie was her first husband. She was a widow when she married Frank, though she didn't know that yet. 😅
Still, by what people saw, and cared about, in the 40's and 50's she'd have been thought poorly of if anyone knew.
"Born in the Highlands of Scotland, he is an immortal and cannot die." Wait, wrong movie.
Loved the concept of the other one but they hired crappy writers that made me cringe. This one, though he's going to die, is better all around. I guess there's something about Highland warriors.
Hhhhhheeeeeeeeerrrrre we are born to be kings 🎸 we're the princes of the universe
In the end there can be only 1.
@@Blue-rl5dp Pfft Highlander was brilliant
😂😂😂
Funny Frank had a vicious streak, he took care of the guy who tried mug him pretty brutally, looks like he had a little of his ancestor in him.
Lol Rob is like ".... maybe I don't wanna be here...."
Roger !!
Beautiful scene !
Let her real accent slip with the word "anything" at the end 😆
I knew from the moment she came into the show that she wasn’t actually American. Her voice annoyed me so much and when I searched her up I was not surprised at all
@@gochieie4223 She's a terrible actress.
@@shurik121 she is. This is not at all what I imagined Brianna to be.
@@fatimah230 I'm rewatching the show now, and the moment she and Roger appear on the show is the moment it takes a nosedive in quality. I haven't seen it since it aired and I forgot just how amazing the show was in the first 2 seasons, when it was just Jamie/Claire's story mixed with the history of the Jacobite rebellion.
@@shurik121 the first two seasons were definitely much more compelling. There was more intrigue and idk just more magic that surrounded the Castle Leoch. It was an entirely different world. I wish they had spent more time in it. I didn’t know anything about Highlanders or Scotland except their very long battle to win freedom from English rule. It was so interesting and exciting and so well written…then came Brianna and Roger and their dumb love story 🙄 l could write forever about how much I dislike them so I’m not going to, but can we just replace them with Marsali and Fergus and call it a day lol
excellent color coordination. books, clothes, furniture. decent effort.
Be happy to have someone who could have conceived you as your father! (Frank was sterile) . Love this scene by the way. I understand her hurt completely but she is a brat!
She's also been lied to her whole life, so I totally get it. She's a much more mature character now.
@@xxwhispersxx2856 She had every right to be mad, but at the same time, she was disrespectful as all get out to her mother. I really didn't like Brianna until the fifth season. Thankfully she's matured, like you said.
Jamie was a hot head too. Blame him
I always thought her character was an EXTREME brat & have disliked her from the beginning. Time will tell if she’ll mature in the series or not but unfortunately, her character is totally insufferable! She’s someone who consistently has to learn things the hard way & takes everyone down with her in the process.
I’d love to see how rational you’d take the news your father wasn’t your father, your biological father is presumably dead in the 1700s. That your mother accidentally time traveled and has kept this a secret your whole life.
James Alexander Malcolm Mckenzie Fraser
I love Brianna's voice in this series.
Ugh.
@@lesliemccormick6527 😂😂😂
She’s cool but her voice sucks
She's not a good actress. Ugh.
She’s awful
Outlander is amazing. What an incredible show.
I understand her shock but she didn't have to treat Claire that way. It was a very complicated situation but I am sure Brea assumed that Claire cheated on Frank.
I agree. The hostility is bizarre. She is angry without even hearing the full explanation. Makes her look super immature.
Or maybe is just all the bad acting by Sophie. 😬
It would be very natural to be angry and irrational when you discover something like that. Not the best acting, though
excellente scène 👍 très émouvant ♥️
Sophie Skelton gives me major Evan Rachel Woods vibes
Brianna’s character in the show is like “hey wanna watch me do the dumbest things possible and react in the dumbest ways possible?… wanna see me do it again?”
Sure. Nobody makes mistakes and repeats them. Never.
@@npeace312 sure we do but not when so much is at stake. Lmao come on now.
Her reaction here is pretty reasonable though
@@Lee.na.23 Sure, for a teenager or child… not an adult.
Jesus, I had forgotten how Roger looked with short hair.
I forgot Roger was a time traveler. This show has too much time between seasons…
😂
Great cast great crew
Drama series
Tv series
Haven't been in her situation, but I really don't get the anger. You learn your past is more complicated than you thought and "you lied to me" is all you have to say about that? I don't know, man. "Wait, what? What the hell happened?" seems more realistic to me.
I found out the same thing when I was 8 and didn't have that reaction 😂
It's a classic fictional trope.
Poor writing
I think she's angry partly because she feels loyal to the person she recognizes as her father, Frank. She doesn't want to believe that the man who raised her and who she looked up to isn't actually related to her at all. Plus now she knows that her mother technically "cheated" on the man she recognizes as her father, meaning her family was never whole to begin with. All of the secrets coming out after Frank's death also means that she can't even ask Frank his side of the story. Also she was closer to her dad so of course she's going to feel injustice on behalf of her father over the man her mother technically had an affair with to conceive her. I think all of this built up and that's why she's so angry.
I think it is perfectly natural for her to be upset. Frank raised her more than Claire did. Claire was a doctor and always at school and later working. Frank was an academic. Bree spent a lot of time at his place of work. She felt her mom betrayed her dad. Her dad had recently died and she was still reeling from that.
She was shocked about it
Caitriona is way too young to be her mother.
I just watched this episode again tonight
Can’t stand Bree in these episodes so angry towards Claire…Roger trying to help…brilliantly acted by Caitriona ❤️
Perfectly understandable, she feels her mother treated her father like trash
Yessss i was so annoyed like give your mother chance to finish her explanation. Ik it infuriating having a mother but she was mostly in another world the whole time, bree should also think that if her real father was alive all this time why did claire stay w them the whole time. If she was such a b*txh of a mother she couldve run away after gave birth, no need to make up ridiculous story. Sorry bree, jamie daughter or not, i dislike you alr bcs of this
Brianna not a likeable character or actress
What episode?
Mais rommencer et fantastique pour la série ☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
Mais certains faits réels sont introduit dans cette superbe série ☆☆☆☆☆.MERCIIIII
I love Outlander but cant watch as haven't got channel to see it .Will get dvds so can catch up .
Roger face: 😬😓
Maybe go to Cardiff, Wales and a community of Coal Hill and look for a police box.
u can kinda hear bri's british accent towards the end
What episode is this
Different in subtle ways from the book.
She is nothing like book-Brianna. Sad.
I know.
Can you tell me how "book Brianna" reacted please ???
Shocked silence until Claire sat them down to explain and then she threw the newspaper clippings into the fire then threw a poker through a window?? She didn’t find out from the newspapers, Claire was shocked into letting it slip and then tried to explain.
@@ameliewiseman744 Thank you !! ; Personally i like both versions !!
She is horrible. They didn't even TRY to get the right person for the role. Maybe she slept with somebody?
Poor Roger
omg why am i getting this on my feed 😳
What is the name of this episode? I’m binging it on Netflix and feel they miss placed this episode.
Outlander was batting a thousand UNTIL they cast her as Brianna.
Such a shame.
Um, actually Sophie Skelton is a fantastic actor.
@@diannebdee LOL...stop playing
@@whutzat Who's playing? I like Sophie. A way better actress than most on television thinking they're actresses. Like most on the CW.
@@diannebdee The CW??...i'm comparing her to the OTHER Outlander actors. She in no way stacks up and she in no way matches the Brianna in the books, and not just physically.
@@whutzat From what I get the Brianna in the books is tantamount to Brienne of Tarth in GOT. Gabaldon 's writing is terrible and reflects on eugenics more than biology. Oh, and I'm sure Jamie the Brute in the books is sexy to you?
How can people watch, How come I never watched it. How did I not heard of this show until now.
I don't know. Been living in a cave? It's been a show for 7 years and a best selling book for close to twenty years.
@@Blue-rl5dp I came to the books because of the series. Same with Game of Thrones.
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
@@martingreenberg870 I saw the book around for years before I read it. I knew nothing of the show until my son downloaded season one for me. To convince me that I wanted to watch, he showed me a clip... The "take your shirt off, I want to look at you." scene from the wedding night.
I decided right there that if Jamie would take his shirt off with regularity I was willing to watch. 😘 😁
This actress choice is the only incongruent note in the series. She is nothing like the description of Brianna in the books. Her voice grates on my nerves.
She's awful
Bel scène entre la mère et la fille ou Bree apprend la vérité sur son vrai père difficile à croire pour elle top top 😍💓
Difficult to believe? Would you believe the cock & bull story that your mother wet back in time two centuries and returned two years later? More likely Claire ran away and had an affair. They broke up and Claire returned to Frank as she had nowhere to go.
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
Bruh how did youtube know I was watching Outlander again. I never even typed it in or anything. I only spoke about it to my sister.
Magic. Maybe the fairies were watching. Or Big Brother. The UA-cam algorithm is amazing.
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
I mean, is this a good series? I keep seeing clips of it and it intrigued me but I don’t know if I want to dive into a series that’s so established and then to be disappointed. It gives me Poldark vibes.
It’s absolutely fantastic. Currently rewatching it for the 3rd time!
It’s amazing!
It’s way better than Poldark, at least for the first 3 seasons.
It’s very good!! I love the books more.
Poldark disappoints because just when you start thinking he appreciates demelza and her loyalty; he f's their relationship up.
The constant theme of outlander is the intense deep relationship between both characters.
Kedy bude 6 seria..???
Počula som takú informáciu, že niekedy začiatkom roka 2022, ale vzhľadom na súčasnú situáciu sa to pravdepodobne posunie
Outlander les romants de Diana calbaldon sur des faits ..historique
Still waiting for Netflix to have season 5
Netflix has season 5
@@goldplayer2003 I checked and they still don't have it here
@@markl5156 it's probably your location, but it's odd, I watched season 5 months ago on Netflix here in Portugal.
It's not on Netflix US and not supposed to be until 2022
Whhhyyyyy!!!!!😭😇
Brianna the brat. I’m glad her arc changed.
Is this the show that came out in 2014?
Ugh Brianna was so bratty and witchy to Claire
This happens in the grave yard in the book
I understand why Brianna is upset but she acts like a brat. Didn’t she remember that time when Frank wanted to tell her something and then didn’t.
She acts like a flat boring spoiled brat for the whole series. Roger's cool. He could do way better
Love frank always
That huge Adams Apple would be heaven for me to get my hands around it and then squeeze it
It’s fiction, these are characters in a book, it’s just a story people.
Ah Brianna the “engineer” 😂
What an ungrateful child Brianna is who is she to judge Claire
Her daughter.
Yessss
@@alessaross3559 not my point you are supposed to respect your mother
Didn't like the character or actress at all
@@joslynhill3529 Respect is earned, not inherited. Brianna is young and judgmental. Welcome to being a teenager (of course she is a little older).
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
the younger girl is really bad at acting like?? where’s the emotion
I don't like ppl s$@3 on Clare or Frank. Can anyone blame her for moving on and forming a family without a reliable or known way back? No. When she came back it has been so long for her that she practically became a different person because of it. And as far as Frank goes.... well (at least in the show) he's not the beacon of righteousness but he is very human. He lost his wife to another man, and raised that man's child as his own. He couldn't divorce her without ruining the lives of her and the child (and that is the best case scenario). No he did not do the right things, he cheated, and hid things from Clare and Brianna, but... imagine if doing the right thing meant loosing the most important things in your life? Would you do it? No. He wanted a divorce when he knew no matter what, he lost...
Series / Movie name??
Outlander
Brianna's TV character is cringe and terrible. Way better in book.
I can’t stand Brianna 😭
Funny that they gave Brianna brown eyes. Two blue-eyed people can NOT have a child with brown eyes. It is genetically and biologically impossible.
Sameeeee
Amen
How did Brianna go from having brown hair to red hair?
It has always been red, but the light made it look brown
On number 6
This seems like incredibly bad acting until you ask whether any actor could make such a ridiculous situation seem real.
That's what I said! Why does she get angry at her mum like that? Seems so forced and unnatural. Confused, curious, overwhelmed and overly emotional, yes, but "you lied to me!!!"? Come on.
@@joanneaugust6611 I read the book because it was literally the only book I had at the time in a remote location. It has to be some of the worst written drivel ever. a step above Twilight.
@@Facetiously.Esoteric I love fantasy so suspension of disbelief comes naturally to me but Diana Gabaldon is dreadful! I wanted to try the TV series in case it was more interesting but the acting here seems really hammy.
I think Brianna should go back two school and retake Maths. Because Claire couldn't of been 3 months pregnant in April, if she gave birth in November. Other wise she would of been pregnant for 10 months. So Brianna Got it wrong Claire was actually about 2 months pregnant.
I think I've just lost a thousand brain cells trying to read that.
You're joking, right?
Nope! Also I'm pretty sure, before Claire went through the stones. Jamie literally said that he tracked her cycle, and he knew Claire was 2 months pregnant. So yeah Brianna got it wrong.
A woman is actually pregnant for about 10 months. 4 weeks per month but the extra days equal up about another month. (29,30,31) approx 3x9=27 extra days past "9 months"
School Lied To Me What!!!
Alot of hate for the actress who played breanna.. Hope you get juyst as much abuse from other ppl when you do your job..
It's not her fault. It is whomever cast her.
Amen! Just nasty people.
@@lesliemccormick6527 All the characters from the book are hard to cast. If you come to the series via the books you probably have strong convictions as to how the characters look and act. A tough job casting the characters . A tough job playing the characters.
This is a tough crowd on this forum.
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
0
oh my gawwwwwd, what horrible acting. I don't know who is worse Brianna or King Louis....
I love this show but I HAAAATE Brianna’s actress. She can’t act to save her life and her line delivery is bland and emotionless it drives me crazy when every other actor is fantastic.
Yesss, I really dislike her character. She isn’t a bad actress, but I don’t think this role was meant for her.
She's awful
Actually excuse me my bad in like the 60s
There on there typical 2 hitius.
Is she wearing a wig here, or is her hair dyed, because I have to say, if so, this is the only episode in which it looked real.
Can't stand the character but it's a good svene.
Why
@@gutan6248 scene.
She's a spoiled brat.
That accent tho lol
I'm refreshed by the innovative insights in this content. A book with related content inspired new perspectives in me. "Temporal Echoes: Amelia's Odyssey Through Ancestral Shadows" by Vivian Rosewood
Frank is Briana’s father. Jamie is only Brianna’s biological father until she time travels.
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
This show is confusing....is it like the Futurama episode where Fry is his own grandfather!! When he time-traveled back & banged his own grandma!?!?
I love everything about Outlander except for the actress who plays Brianna. She's so weak that it's distracting. Ugh.
She really effects ot in a very negative way
Funny that they gave Brianna brown eyes. Two blue-eyed people can NOT have a child with brown eyes. It is genetically and biologically impossible.
Casting directors aren't geneticists....
Could’ve gave the lass some blue contacts 🤣
I was thinking The exact same thing
If either of her grandparents had brown eyes she could, recessive genes. Some traits skip generations. My niece has red/ copper hair like her maternal grandmother but both my brother and his wife have black hair.
Er, what? Blue eyed parents can absolutely produce a brown eyed child. Or green eyed. Or hazel. If they are carriers for such traits. That IS how genetics works.
Brianna is the literal worst.
Not to be rude, but I genuinely hated her acting and her accent. Everything about her was wrong and even Briana as a character was so annoying and disappointing!!. Especially that scene when she first met Jamie!! God, I was so underwhelmed and I felt so bad for Jamie. And don't get me started with the lack of chemistry between Her and Roger. I am planning on reading the actual book I hope that Briana and Roger would have a great storyline and characters.
I have read the books first and couldn’t watch the series, because you can’t compare them.I truly hated the series.
After deciding to see them as different things, it works better to me, but you will love the relationship of Brianna and Roger in the books. (Sorry for my English, I am German.)
Roger is way to good for her
Cant stand, clair.
She's not a likeable character imo
Claire should have back handed her then. Them maybe she wouldn’t be so obnoxious piss poor avtress
I know my mom would and so would have I If she was my child
piss poor actress yet in your comment you imply you were sold by the obnoxious brat she was portraying? okay then.
@@andrewpersaud4144 She really isn't a good actress at all....but I like the show. Lol
Almost every show and movie seem to feel the need to make every teenager a brat and disrespectful.
She's awful. Worse thing in this series.
Anyone else loves this show but hates that it’s so cruel to the main characters??? Just like game of thrones
Clair is one of he most selfish people I have ever seen in cinema. Frank gave everything for her. Literally everything.
How is she selfish?
How is she selfish? She lost The love of her life & had to live a lie for 20 years.
So Frank wasn't selfish when he decided to make Claire believe she was sterile even though he knew he was. Or let's not forget that their second honeymoon was only in Scotland so he could trace his family's lineage.
She's not a likeable character
More than Scarlet O’Hara?
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
Brianna was unlikable as a character in the TV series unlike in the books. The actress was badly miscast as she lacked the ability to have the audience sympathize with her, just came across as too strident, self entitled and judgmental.
"You told me you wanted the truth no matter what. This is it." Ah how amusing, how common, and how _wrong._ A man thinks a woman means exactly what she said.
who hurt you lmao
hes right though....shes not
If you're going to say something, you better mean it. Otherwise, don't say it at all.
But it actually does well, she asked for it and now she's throwing a "tantrum".. at least he's got some sense
She DOES, but circumstances change sometimes.
She should be happy Jamie was her real father. Jamie was handsome. Frank was so unattractive to me.
Does it really matter how your parents look?
@@johanaronsson7774 - To me it does. I took after my mother who was very pretty. My sisters took after my father who was not.
1. I grew up getting compliments and unfortunately my sisters did not and they are still jealous to this day.
2. I finally told them, if you don't like the way you look, take your complaints to God! I had nothing to do with your looks!
@@valvacious2793 youre a weirdo. literally nobody thinks to themselves about how good looking their parents are.
@@wintersummer1633 - let me override your unawareness. 1.Your comment just showed how petty you are.
conceited much. Looks don’t matter. What matters is who is there for you at the end of the day. And Some people don’t even have parents and wish they did.
Playstation plus Video pass
Thanks, finally I will be able to recover your products safely. I can't wait for it to come out of the beta, immense catalog in Italy ❤️
Nope it’s not cause he doesn’t have a any interest in meeting you it’s because he’s back in like 19 1800s and you guys are in millennial time
Theyre in the 60's or something 😅
Such a bad accent.. it makes me cringe.
The bitter representative successfully mark because pastry emphatically stir by a dusty reindeer. repulsive, exotic hamburger
bruh her hair is red and neither of her parents are??? like i’m sorry but doesn’t everyone doubt that their parents aren’t their parents?
Ummm what Jamies hair is bright red 😅
Do we need another stream of comments about genetics? One or more of her grandparents could have red hair and that character trait can be manifested in a skipped generation. Unlikely but possible.
I’ve never doubted my parents were my parents. After all, who would have wanted me as their son?
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
I just CANNOT watch the series. None of the actors are like the book.
I think that they all are except Brianna. She's HORRIBLE.
I agree. But they never are.
Another way to say that is none of the characters look like the way you imagined them. @lindatimmons3675 is right.
The charting director has a difficult task. The actor must look somewhat like the character in the book. On the other hand the actor must breathe life into the character and be believable. A difficult task. Wouldn’t you agree?
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)
No one cares about briahanna
Everyone seems to ignore that the protagonist is a scumbag that cheated on her husband (while she was supposedly still trying to get back lmao).
If your teleported to the past i think it cannot be considered cheating. Its like saying widows are cheating their spouses if in the future they get resurrected which makes no sense.
Claire didn't cheat because it was circumstances beyond her control that made it necessary to marry Jamie Fraser. She didn't want to, but it was the only way to save her from being handed over to the English (which in that situation was a fate worse than death). I can't blame her for choosing to escape that fate in the only possible way. After their wedding, as the months went on unable to return through the stones, I can't blame her for falling in love.
In your mind it was cheating. There are far too many angles to the subject to make it cut and dried. The priest at the Abby told her Frank didn't exist when she married Jamie and never had. As well, clearly 1743 preceded whatever date she married Frank. Therefore, her marriage to Jamie was the first one. Frank was her second husband.
@@Blue-rl5dp Er, that doesn't quite work because it was the same Claire who first married Frank and later married Jamie. She was entirely conscious that she was getting married each time, and her first husband was Frank. Still, as I said above,, under the circumstances I don't consider her to have cheated. (Had it been Frank who accidentally time-traveled and was forced by circumstances to marry a woman in the distant past, I'm sure he would have done it, and quite possibly would have fallen in love as Claire did with Jamie.)
@@rowanaforrest9792 😄 Yes, in HER timeline she married Frank first. In everyone else's timeline she married Jamie first. She was a widow when she married Frank and didn't even know it because Jamie was dead nearly 200 yrs. We can prove it. His ghost came to see her. 😵💫Time travel makes everything so complicated.
This show is ridiculous.
Ridiculous? No. Fiction? Yes.
Time travel has been an element in science fiction. Perhaps you believe the entire genre of science fiction is ridiculous. Fair point.
I was a psychiatric nurse for 30 years. One takeaway from my experience is reality is overrated. The entire key to this series is time travel is possible. Get over that hurdle and everything else follows. Can’t make that leap of faith? Then the books and series is ridiculous.
A question. If the show, and by inference the series of books, is ridiculous I what are you doing in this stream of comments? Isn’t that ridiculous?
Mask On Nurse Marty (Ret)