I feel like everyone is misunderstanding that Claire is not making him feel guilty about this. He's making himself feel guilty, his track record is making himself feel bad for it. The only one she was upset about was Laoghaire because he didn't want to tell her about it and she tried to have her burned as a witch. Claire only wants honesty from him and he struggles with that because of his shame not hers.
its that psychological angle...if you tell someone something really bad to scare them then tell them the thing you were going to say... and it turns out not bad news...
You're so right. Cait's facial expression acting is better than even the most seasoned actresses. Always outstanding. Hard to believe this is her first acting gig.
All though he felt the need to be honest with Claire, he really did nothing wrong ,he was given tenderness from a woman that also needed it ,he had been through so much and without Claire he was a lost and lonely man. Claire was his heart and she was the only woman he loved .
@@heikethielcke8910 im Grunde sagt der Verfasser des Kommentares, dass Jamie nichts falsch gemacht hat als er mit McNabb die Nacht verbracht hat. Beide haben die Nähe gebraucht und Claire war ja weg und sie war seine einzige Liebe.
Awesome chemistry and actors… so compelling ❤ love their story… there understanding of each other and the way they protect their love by being honest with each other is beautiful
This reminds me of the incident with Bree to prove to her she could not have defended herself against Bonnet. Telling this means she can absolutely believe he didn’t have an affair with Malva.
@@HaYlEeXx19 Yes, when he did tell her about it Claire said she was thankful that Jamie had at least one point in that lonely grubby time that was tender and sweet.
Yeah...I think the harm from adultery is very much overstated and overemphasized in the USA. If I believed in god and sin, I would not deem it a sin. If two people need each other and do it tenderly and with compassion, it can be a beautiful thing. I think a lot of the teeth-gnashing about it comes from people who are, really, jealous that the adulterers might be enjoying life more than they are. And this habit about decrying the sins of others: it's a petty and mean thing to find fault with others, and dwell on it. In my experience, the most histrionic people crying out for the punishing of sinners are very often guilty of the very same sin themselves. I can think of 3 or 4 TV clergymen who have displayed such infinite hypocrisy.
@@DOCSAM35 LOL I bet you'd feel differently if YOUR spouse was committing adultery! I can't even begin to fathom how you could feel that adultery is okay. I'm guessing you've never been married.
I wondered why he even told her about this. It happened 20 years ago, 6 years after she went through the stones to be precise. She was intimate with Frank, so she had to know Jaime at some point would start sleeping with other women. The important question was answered when she first returned. Did he fall in love with another woman after she left.... That's a resounding NO! So what made him pull this tid bit of ancient history out of his pocket, is beyond me. I wouldn't think he would feel guilty for it, especially since he couldn't have know Claire would return to him ever.
Frankly, I think he didn’t tell Claire because he practically forgot. I mean he told her about the important one, the mother of his son. Mary Mcnabb is basically nonexistent in the whole story. Also, Claire was bloody gone and was sleeping herself with Frank. The whole confession, guilt and drama is about nothing.
I agree Monica...especially afte Jamie telling her about Geneva ..and the way she found out about Leaghorie ( sp) I think he was "leery" about telling her anymore things...and then it just didn't matter anymore ....I don't ever think he thought it was a betrayal of love for her ... also I don't know about in the books but Claire had a few nights with Frank and do you think her and Dr.Joe Abernathy would have gotten together ? I know he was married but was that after Claire left????Just a thought...
@@radicalreactions1633 Leave poor Frank alone. He loved a woman who didn't love him back and raised a daughter that wasn't his for 20 years. He was a good man who lived a sad life.
Nobody expected it of him, but himself. That's why on her first day back Claire keeps hint asking if he has "other ties" and is totally un-shocked to hear he has a son. Her only hope is that he still loves her. His sister and everyone else keeps trying to toss other women at him after he starts getting over the first grief, but then they think Claire is dead. He believes, hopes, she's still alive so taking up with another woman would be unfaithfulness. It took 18 yrs. before he gave in that Claire was not coming back and he took Leerie, and that was because he wanted the children to be his. He confessed this because he intended that Claire be clear and absolute that he wouldn't lie to her about it, even if he could get away with it.
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT! This was completely unnecessary and over the top, like really Jamie? You didn't do anything wrong, stop making a big deal for drama. 😒
I think what hurt the most was that he didn’t own up to it as soon as they reunited. She kept asking if he was tied to anyone/family. He talked about the son that’s it.
He confessed because he felt guilty over it, and because he could tell Claire still felt he was keeping something from her. He wanted her to know that it wasn’t Melva. Ultimately, I think he told her so they both could have peace of mind.
Claire wasnt being judgy because of that woman, it's because this is happening when he has been accused of sleeping with Malva and for a second there she thinks he's going to confess.
I don't want him to be sorry that happened. He was so destroyed over loosing Claire and he'd lived alone in that grimy cave for eight years. All they did was share some human comfort, and he needed that. So did she. Whether he told Claire to prove to her he'd never lie to her, or just kept it in his private book of memories, he didn't need to be sorry for it in the least. Claire didn't need proof. He'd always casually blurted out the truth to her, from day one.
Claire’s “Aww come here, lil fellow” haircut needs to grow back soon. It’s starting to make me giggle. I hope she doesn’t decide to rock it indefinitely like Cersei on GOT.
What I honestly don't get is how come we never saw a scene where Claire explains she did willing try to sleep with Frank again in the future even if it didn't actually properly happen? Like to me - that deserves a mention.
She wasn’t angry about this. She was upset because Malva had just accused him of being the father of her baby and then he said he has a confession to make and she was afraid he was going to tell her he has indeed slept with Malva
So, all of his cards are on the table, even the least significant one. Now... at what point is he finally gonna learn that Frank Randall was a straight up doppelganger of Black Jack Randall? I figured that was the reason they established that Brianna can accurately capture a likeness. That at some point she was gonna innocently draw a portrait of Frank and Jamie would happen to see it and it would finally all come out. But then that never happened. Is that Chekhov's gun just gonna hang there on the wall forever?
I don't know why he felt he should confess this as if it were something he did wrong. She left, she went back to Frank (as he told her she should do). He didn't just decide to do it right after she left. He had no reason to believe she would come back so it wouldn't have been considered being unfaithful. Not really sure why this scene was necessary. In the book, sure, but it just took up a few mins of screentime for a confession that really shouldn't have been a confession. Now if it were told in a normal conversation it would've been okay but I kinda feel like this was just for dramatic effect because the way he opened with his statement made it seem like it was going to be something detrimental to their relationship.
I understand that in season 3 Jamie tells her about his son and she understood that and it never really seemed to bother her. Yet they bring this situation up like it would a bigger deal to her, and yes they made it seem like it was. Even though he never loved either women. So I'm not sure why bring it up, claire did seem to get over it though and understood him after he explained himself. I honestly think she was just stressed that season and well something just pushed her over and the show wanted more tension. Still love the scene though, just not sure why they made it like that.
No, this is the time they had this conversation. It's not in Voyager. Also, he didn't tell her about William until after they saw LJG in Jamaica. He was scared to tell her straightaway about Geneva and Laoghaire because he thought he would lose her again. Telling her about Mary McNab here just gets everything out in the open.
The reason this confuses me is because Jamie told Claire that he'd been with other women while she was gone for 20 yrs. Not sure why she or anyone else would be surprised.
Claire acepta todo las explicaciones fidelidad Siempre dice hace mucho tiempo que no hago. Esto. Claire no le importo que ae acostara con otras mujeres Más le importaba que no le mintieran
Une scène magnifique où toute la force de leur amour l'un pour l'autre ressort. Malva peut raconter ce qu'elle veut, ça ne les séparera pas. Ils en ont vu d'autres et pire!❤❤❤❤
@@tahora1594 J'aurais aimé parler avec vous plus souvent et en privé, puisque ce profil est connecté sur un lieu public où j'utilise comme moyen de contacter mes fans dans d'autres bases, j'aimerais avoir votre contact Whatsapp, alors nous pouvons parler plus souvent et en privé, acceptez-le et retirez celui-ci à la place afin que nous puissions en savoir plus sur nous-mêmes
Jamie est trop mignon repentant pour expliquer à Claire qu'il lui a été infidèle elle peut comprendre cela elle était dans le futur elle pardonne tout son amour pour cet homme se ressent dans son attitude 😔🥰😍
Poteva fare a meno di fare questa confessione senza senso dopo più di vent'anni! E poi con mary un'insignificante donna che non si è lasciata scappare l'occasione di andare con un bell'uomo!
They butchered one of the best scenes in the books. She is such an overacting melodramatic actor. She's so wrong for Claire. This is one of the most beautiful scenes in the books.
I feel like everyone is misunderstanding that Claire is not making him feel guilty about this. He's making himself feel guilty, his track record is making himself feel bad for it. The only one she was upset about was Laoghaire because he didn't want to tell her about it and she tried to have her burned as a witch. Claire only wants honesty from him and he struggles with that because of his shame not hers.
true, people underestimate how insecure Jamie actually is
He confessed to prove that he hadn’t slept with Malva. Knowing that Claire would believe him after this confession.
its that psychological angle...if you tell someone something really bad to scare them then tell them the thing you were going to say... and it turns out not bad news...
Kind of manipulative really
I don’t think he was wrong for doing that when she was gone. He didn’t think she’d ever be back.
And he might not have expected to ever leave prison again
Sam as always so convincing and Cait's facial reactions superb.
You're so right. Cait's facial expression acting is better than even the most seasoned actresses. Always outstanding. Hard to believe this is her first acting gig.
She sounded unbearably cringe worthy. They should have just left it at her saying she understood and let her facial reactions do the rest.
@@Blue-rl5dp I believe she was in some indie films before Outlander
@@genesisc6281 Yeah? We hear about every tiny part Sam played but they never talk about anything at all that Cat did except the runway modeling.
@@Blue-rl5dp yes, very much so .
Claire thought Jamie was confessing to sleep with Malva but he was talking about another woman and she was OK with it, she understood.
All though he felt the need to be honest with Claire, he really did nothing wrong ,he was given tenderness from a woman that also needed it ,he had been through so much and without Claire he was a lost and lonely man. Claire was his heart and she was the only woman he loved .
Bitte in deutsch übersetzen.
Danke
@@heikethielcke8910 im Grunde sagt der Verfasser des Kommentares, dass Jamie nichts falsch gemacht hat als er mit McNabb die Nacht verbracht hat. Beide haben die Nähe gebraucht und Claire war ja weg und sie war seine einzige Liebe.
The thing he does wrong is not trusting her with the truth. He needs to be honest with her because of the number of times he's promised to do so.
@@horsegirlb7120 It's not that he didn't trust her. It's that he felt guilty and shameful, despite the fact that he did nothing wrong.
Awesome chemistry and actors… so compelling ❤ love their story… there understanding of each other and the way they protect their love by being honest with each other is beautiful
This reminds me of the incident with Bree to prove to her she could not have defended herself against Bonnet. Telling this means she can absolutely believe he didn’t have an affair with Malva.
"it feels like a punch to the gut". It feels like she remembered that time with black Jack
In the book, it was a wonderful and tender sharing, between two people who needed comfort. There was nothing shameful in it.
And Clair was grateful to the women to.
@@HaYlEeXx19 Yes, when he did tell her about it Claire said she was thankful that Jamie had at least one point in that lonely grubby time that was tender and sweet.
Yes but this was a different setting and timing awful.
Yeah...I think the harm from adultery is very much overstated and overemphasized in the USA. If I believed in god and sin, I would not deem it a sin. If two people need each other and do it tenderly and with compassion, it can be a beautiful thing. I think a lot of the teeth-gnashing about it comes from people who are, really, jealous that the adulterers might be enjoying life more than they are. And this habit about decrying the sins of others: it's a petty and mean thing to find fault with others, and dwell on it. In my experience, the most histrionic people crying out for the punishing of sinners are very often guilty of the very same sin themselves. I can think of 3 or 4 TV clergymen who have displayed such infinite hypocrisy.
@@DOCSAM35 LOL I bet you'd feel differently if YOUR spouse was committing adultery! I can't even begin to fathom how you could feel that adultery is okay. I'm guessing you've never been married.
I wondered why he even told her about this. It happened 20 years ago, 6 years after she went through the stones to be precise. She was intimate with Frank, so she had to know Jaime at some point would start sleeping with other women. The important question was answered when she first returned. Did he fall in love with another woman after she left.... That's a resounding NO! So what made him pull this tid bit of ancient history out of his pocket, is beyond me. I wouldn't think he would feel guilty for it, especially since he couldn't have know Claire would return to him ever.
Same. And she wouldn't have thought he slept with Malva anyway.
Frankly, I think he didn’t tell Claire because he practically forgot. I mean he told her about the important one, the mother of his son. Mary Mcnabb is basically nonexistent in the whole story. Also, Claire was bloody gone and was sleeping herself with Frank. The whole confession, guilt and drama is about nothing.
I agree Monica...especially afte Jamie telling her about Geneva ..and the way she found out about Leaghorie ( sp) I think he was "leery" about telling her anymore things...and then it just didn't matter anymore ....I don't ever think he thought it was a betrayal of love for her ... also I don't know about in the books but Claire had a few nights with Frank and do you think her and Dr.Joe Abernathy would have gotten together ? I know he was married but was that after Claire left????Just a thought...
Claire slept with flabby-fish, I mean Frank, TWICE. Big effin' deal.
@@thekrayonkidsbookadventures Dude, her and Joe were FRIENDS, that's all. And Joe had a ring on BEFORE she left to go back, nice try,
@@radicalreactions1633 first of all I'm not a "dude", second of all it is not " her and Joe" and last but not least ...it was hypothetical.
@@radicalreactions1633 Leave poor Frank alone. He loved a woman who didn't love him back and raised a daughter that wasn't his for 20 years. He was a good man who lived a sad life.
Never understood why Jamie felt the need to confess to this. Was he really expected to remain celibate for the rest of his days?
Nobody expected it of him, but himself. That's why on her first day back Claire keeps hint asking if he has "other ties" and is totally un-shocked to hear he has a son. Her only hope is that he still loves her.
His sister and everyone else keeps trying to toss other women at him after he starts getting over the first grief, but then they think Claire is dead. He believes, hopes, she's still alive so taking up with another woman would be unfaithfulness. It took 18 yrs. before he gave in that Claire was not coming back and he took Leerie, and that was because he wanted the children to be his.
He confessed this because he intended that Claire be clear and absolute that he wouldn't lie to her about it, even if he could get away with it.
THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT! This was completely unnecessary and over the top, like really Jamie? You didn't do anything wrong, stop making a big deal for drama. 😒
I think what hurt the most was that he didn’t own up to it as soon as they reunited. She kept asking if he was tied to anyone/family. He talked about the son that’s it.
@@Blue-rl5dp So Beautiful way to describe it. 💛👏🏼
He confessed because he felt guilty over it, and because he could tell Claire still felt he was keeping something from her. He wanted her to know that it wasn’t Melva. Ultimately, I think he told her so they both could have peace of mind.
I understand those that don't understand why he confessed to this but it was him being transparent with his partner ....laying his sins bare
Claire wasnt being judgy because of that woman, it's because this is happening when he has been accused of sleeping with Malva and for a second there she thinks he's going to confess.
I don't want him to be sorry that happened. He was so destroyed over loosing Claire and he'd lived alone in that grimy cave for eight years. All they did was share some human comfort, and he needed that. So did she. Whether he told Claire to prove to her he'd never lie to her, or just kept it in his private book of memories, he didn't need to be sorry for it in the least. Claire didn't need proof. He'd always casually blurted out the truth to her, from day one.
Claire’s “Aww come here, lil fellow” haircut needs to grow back soon. It’s starting to make me giggle. I hope she doesn’t decide to rock it indefinitely like Cersei on GOT.
Of course she ain’t gonna keep it. She was devastated when that little bitch cut off her hair.!!!
Ich liebe diese Serie und die Schauspieler, Caitriona und Sam es ist ein freude ihnen zuzusehen. Ich bin ein großer Fan !!
What I honestly don't get is how come we never saw a scene where Claire explains she did willing try to sleep with Frank again in the future even if it didn't actually properly happen? Like to me - that deserves a mention.
fantastic acting - again and again and again
She more angry at this then when she found out he had a SON!!! HOW DO YOU THINK HIS SON GOT HERE!!!
She wasn’t angry about this. She was upset because Malva had just accused him of being the father of her baby and then he said he has a confession to make and she was afraid he was going to tell her he has indeed slept with Malva
Cannot count the sons mum. She basically held a gun to his head.
So, all of his cards are on the table, even the least significant one. Now... at what point is he finally gonna learn that Frank Randall was a straight up doppelganger of Black Jack Randall?
I figured that was the reason they established that Brianna can accurately capture a likeness. That at some point she was gonna innocently draw a portrait of Frank and Jamie would happen to see it and it would finally all come out. But then that never happened. Is that Chekhov's gun just gonna hang there on the wall forever?
Hell, Claire wasn't celibate when she went back to Frank. And it wasn't only once.
She was literally married to Frank. It's not the same thing.
It was TWICE, big deal. And Jamie ATTACKED her for it when they were at the brothel, so why shouldn't he be treated the same way?
In the book, they never stopped sleeping together at all. Frank and Claire.
@@mgbow-y5n To be fair, neither couple actually exists at the same time.
@@mschenandlerbong8539 Very true.....great point.
I don't know why he felt he should confess this as if it were something he did wrong. She left, she went back to Frank (as he told her she should do). He didn't just decide to do it right after she left. He had no reason to believe she would come back so it wouldn't have been considered being unfaithful. Not really sure why this scene was necessary. In the book, sure, but it just took up a few mins of screentime for a confession that really shouldn't have been a confession. Now if it were told in a normal conversation it would've been okay but I kinda feel like this was just for dramatic effect because the way he opened with his statement made it seem like it was going to be something detrimental to their relationship.
Does anyone know when season 6 will be available on Netflix?
Couple of years apparently…I have pre ordered the dvd
Two years later 2024, but dvd will be available in September.
They are two of the best fictional characters ever created! Love them so!
I heard 2 years as well..it's a shame because I know it would do great on it ..when it first came to Netflix..their audience really probably tripled.
It's out and on starz
She made me supper 🤣
so...".I had to repay in kindness ??????:) ha!" Actually she gave him a hair cut too ..with all of that how could he resist ???
Goodbye Outlander addicts, keep on dreaming and drooling. Leaving for my next trip, haleluya
What even 🤣
Miss Outlander haven't got the channel it's on will have to get dvd 6 sorted .
Yes, agree Sam is such a real man, not afraid of telling his truth
I want his hair baaaack
Can you upload the scene where malva accused Jamie and when Claire tells her to stay away please
I understand that in season 3 Jamie tells her about his son and she understood that and it never really seemed to bother her. Yet they bring this situation up like it would a bigger deal to her, and yes they made it seem like it was. Even though he never loved either women. So I'm not sure why bring it up, claire did seem to get over it though and understood him after he explained himself. I honestly think she was just stressed that season and well something just pushed her over and the show wanted more tension. Still love the scene though, just not sure why they made it like that.
Actually Jamie slept with 3 women when Claire was gone. Mary McNab, Geneva Dunsany, and his other wife Laoghaire MacKenzie McKimmie (yuck).
They had this conversation in Voyager in the books I think. Did they wait till now to have the conversation in the show?
No, this is the time they had this conversation. It's not in Voyager. Also, he didn't tell her about William until after they saw LJG in Jamaica. He was scared to tell her straightaway about Geneva and Laoghaire because he thought he would lose her again. Telling her about Mary McNab here just gets everything out in the open.
Never understood why this was a big deal, she knew he fathered a child and Claire knew that so why was this supposedly something to confess to????
I guess maybe because he hadn't told her about it before, as if he was keeping it from her?
@@melinabelanzaran1558 maybe so that sounds like a good reason …guess it became issue when evil Malva accused him of being the father of her child.
I laughed and laughed when I read this part in the book.
Why did you laugh?
@@lanabudvarson2553 the way Claire reacted to Jamie when she found out was funny to me. Jamie was serious and Claire wasn’t shocked at all.
I laughed too! It played differently in the book.
@@EpoRose1 yes it did
me too! 😆 one of my favorite parts from the book!! the best!!
Im confused was this during the time she went back to the future? The comments are making it seem like she went away for a long time again
The reason this confuses me is because Jamie told Claire that he'd been with other women while she was gone for 20 yrs. Not sure why she or anyone else would be surprised.
unless he's slept with another woman in the time that she's been back
When did this happen??
Claire acepta todo las explicaciones fidelidad
Siempre dice hace mucho tiempo que no hago. Esto.
Claire no le importo que ae acostara con otras mujeres
Más le importaba que no le mintieran
Both always have some kind of awkward chemistry at some point
Jamie's still very handsome .
Une scène magnifique où toute la force de leur amour l'un pour l'autre ressort. Malva peut raconter ce qu'elle veut, ça ne les séparera pas. Ils en ont vu d'autres et pire!❤❤❤❤
Uma cena linda como tantas com que têm nos brindado ao longo desta série ❤️
Je ne suis pas seulement une fan, je suis une Outlander addicte, série, livres et bien sûr du casting ❤❤❤
D'accord, merci beaucoup pour votre amour constant, d'où venez-vous vraiment ?
@@samheughan5128 Je suis francaise. J'habite Marseille
@@tahora1594 J'aurais aimé parler avec vous plus souvent et en privé, puisque ce profil est connecté sur un lieu public où j'utilise comme moyen de contacter mes fans dans d'autres bases, j'aimerais avoir votre contact Whatsapp, alors nous pouvons parler plus souvent et en privé, acceptez-le et retirez celui-ci à la place afin que nous puissions en savoir plus sur nous-mêmes
I really think Jamie needed confort they both were lonely and sad i eas happy for him but his love for Clair would always be their
What season and episode is this?
Season 6, episode 6 I believe. Sure on the season, not on the episode
wow splendide scene 🤩❤❤merci pour ce partage
Public service announcement:
Halloween is in 55 days
Thanksgiving is in 79 days
Christmas is in 110 days
Jamie est trop mignon repentant pour expliquer à Claire qu'il lui a été infidèle elle peut comprendre cela elle était dans le futur elle pardonne tout son amour pour cet homme se ressent dans son attitude 😔🥰😍
Se la chiami infedeltà quella di jemie con quella donna !diciamo che è stata una forzatura da 6 anni di astinenza!
Didnt he already tell her this ?
Soy una superadicta y espero con ansias la sexta temporada en Netflix
He was with three..the woman he had a son with Mary and when he married leighough
Come si fa a chiamare tradimento! jamy che va insieme alla serva mery pensando a claire
A beautiful scene
yes it is :)
Poteva fare a meno di fare questa confessione senza senso dopo più di vent'anni! E poi con mary un'insignificante donna che non si è lasciata scappare l'occasione di andare con un bell'uomo!
I absolutely hated the wigs for Claire in this season. I understand why they used them, but this one is not great.
Por favor traducirlo en español
Best movie ever!!!
Well, since it's not a movie
It's the best TV show ever
She slept with frank why was that okay
Because Jamie told her to go back to him for Brianna's sake and they were married
Go thru the stones
He didn't sleep with her she saw him with claire .
Siempre teniendo otras mujeres y humillando a cler
But he slept with malwa ??
No
She already knew he had a son while she was gone, how was this any different? This scene made no sense whatsoever.
@chelseaoocandy : This wasn't the mother of his child tho, this was another woman, and she wasn't angry she was shocked !!
Too many video clips on youtube lately. They probably trying to keep viewers interested by promotion videos. Gets very tiresome
It's an algorithm..if you watch one others show up..example..if you watch say star trek clips..you will get more clips.
@@gretchenvanwalterop1929 other choice is to stop watching all this nonsence I am getting to the point to.........
@@gretchenvanwalterop1929 wrong answer
@@coradejong1014 well stop watching then. Nobody's forcing you. And true fans enjoy them.
Not really, love a good cry me🥹
I want to ask both of them, why they didn’t married in rial life with all this love between both of them
Mary macnab and the Mother of his son. And in the brothel the owner said that he had brought other women. It doesnt make any sense.
DIOS,por que no traducen al español montones de fans quedamos en 0😖😖😖
I’m sorry if I knew Spanish I would
She didnt
Nunca sirvió para marido fiel.
Keep it pimping never simping 😆
They butchered one of the best scenes in the books. She is such an overacting melodramatic actor. She's so wrong for Claire. This is one of the most beautiful scenes in the books.
🤮🤮🤮🤮
Please stop the crap. Thank you