@@Biggsman_IVrains fall wanted the best for someone like arthur who helped his son and the tribe if they ever were to find a cure for TB they wouldve made sure to come in time to help him when he was at his lowest
@@onepieceking1770 oh yeah, 100%. I just really wish eagle flies could’ve made it. That part almost made me break down when they brought him back to rains fall. They never deserved to get used the way they did. They were great people. I’m glad a lot of the gang got out. And I’m glad they actually cared for Arthur.
We played as him and got to know him like we do any person. Personality, temper, actions, dialogue, and even the most emotional moments, we were there through everything
You can mourn for anything that has given enough to you and others If a rock can give you Kindness, confidence, meaning, fun, peace. It’s okay to feel sad when that rock is gone and is no longer able to give it to you. Nevermind if it’s a person; fake or real. Your not sad for a silly reason friend. Your sad arthur can’t exist in a sequal.. lest it’s a prequel anyway in johns case.
I think it’s more about intentions and he might have been an outlaw but he only robbed from those who robbed others and the rich he helped the poor he might have been against mans law but he wasn’t against gods law in my opinion🤷♂️
@@cheshirehat8355hes in the first red dead redemption game as a stranger, you can watch some videos about him if you want just look up "strange man rdr"
@@cheshirehat8355 A mision giving stranger in original RDR. He was supposed to be a mysterious and supernatural figure, a lot of peopel consider him the devil, the death or something of a sort.
@@cheshirehat8355he gave Herbert Moon two options, two generations, or to be happy. Herbert chose two generations as he had a daughter and upcoming granddaughter. Meaning he would no longer be happy. So the strange man causes a deadly disease (cholera) to hit Herbert’s home town. Causing him to lose business as a shopkeeper
@@nirab9553 all those random NPCs I killed, to me that never actually happens in the game and is only to make Arthur seem like a cold hearted killer slowly learning redemption to the right side, if that makes sense😭
@@rook2stoned it does make sense and I guess that’s exactly what rockstar was going for with the slight changes in the aspect from rdr1 where John is made to be a hero with his redemption instead of Arthur being a cold killer and robber to dying to help John escape n the side mission stuff which is why he had the real redemption
@@ДмитрийИванников-х5бyes but i think the story is about a person becoming bad to good you can't get the point from low honor arthur high honor is the man that we should be
I love that John wants them all to know how Arthur saved him. Even if it’s painful for him to relive it every time, it’s also like a badge of honour. I knew this beautiful person that made the ultimate sacrifice for myself and my loved ones, and I must honour his memory.
Always felt the same. Like he owes so much to Arthur that any opportunity to let someone know what he did for love, for brotherhood, for what was right…. He tells them. And you can tell he feels almost bad… this man became a good man. Saved John and Abigail and jack. And died alone after having his whole world crumble down around him. Seeing his best friend and father figure Dutch lose it, and then in his final moments that man left him and didn’t say a word to him… that always hurt me. I remember shouting at Dutch my first playthrough… say something Dutch!! Say something now for christs sake!! Only to have John do it for me later on… when John said say something Dutch… and he fell silent again… I knew that Arthur dying… that broke Dutch. That’s why we got what we saw in the first game.
For good, it was one of my favorite stories probably is. Honestly the story was fucking fantastic and having a sad ending although heartbreaking, in my opinion it just made it more impactful and way more better. Not as in I dislike Arthur’s character but more so that his approaching demise was important for not only his character, his arc, but also his redemption as he knows he’s living not the best, he knows he’s not all that great. Though Arthur realizes that maybe Dutch’s philosophy probably wasn’t all that great for the gang, he knows that he’s done bad and if you play the missions with “Agnes Downes” (I believe it was) and her son later in the story. Arthur tries to make up for his wrongs and tries to help Agnes out of the bad situation she is in. Arthur knows he doesn’t have all that much time left, but he doesn’t find somewhere to flee and live out the rest of his days relaxing and enjoying things, but instead he tries to help many others like John, Abigail, and Jack Marston get out and be safe. And that is Arthur’s redemption..
I always get the sense whenever John starts talking about Arthur he feels guilty based on everything. The type of guilt you feel once the person is gone and you realized how loyal they were. This game gets me
@@TRVSHSKXLLthe game uses protagonists first names twice, usually to represent a symbol, remember towards the end of chapter 6 when Arthur is looking for bounty named Arthur (there’s a message there) just like with Mary
It's funny how when Rockstar announced that Rdr2 will have a new protagonist everybody took to the internet with pitchforks & torches, only to now say that Arthur is literally the best character ever written.
The playthrough of RDR2 is an emotional rollercoaster. You get angry, even violent, you laugh, you feel loyalty and betrayal, love and regret. And believe me, you will cry. And then Rockstar hits you with this epilogue and gives you at least a little bit of closure. Genius.
"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." Arthur didn't know most of these people, but still helped them. He knew his life was coming to an end, and he felt it necessary to help those around him, not for gain, in the end, but to come to terms with himself with what little time he had. Still one of my favorite video game characters. His story is a hell of a ride.
honestly the best way to play rdr2 is to make arthur an ass at first but as u progress make him more honorable, it makes the story way more impactful imo
If you read his journal you can see he had always had the fight of good and bad in him(he literally Write that) I was low honor in chapter 2+3 especially when he talk abt how he hate beating the guy with TB and how his son looked at him as evil even though he acted like he doesn't care but in his journal he said what was really going on so I think the game is just you choosing who would beat the other
I was sad when Arthur Morgan and John Marston died because I earned respect from both of them throughout the game, and it's almost like you knew them because that game is very long.
Yeah, Arthur passing did not hurt me that much untill I had to play like John. Every conversation with almost everyone was painful. No wonder John did not want to talk about it. What a way to start RDR1. ❤
I love how they dropped RDR1 and got praised for making the greatest redemption story in gaming, and then they dropped RDR2 and broke their own record. Nothing has encapsulated the nuances, joys, and pains of redemption quite the same
Even raina fall remembers Arthur I will say this right now And everyone else would agree with me that Red Dead redemption 2 was a freaking masterpiece The storyline was incredible The graphics were incredible The characters were incredible there was so much free roam sure you had to go back and do the mission to get farther in the campaign but you could just go around town and insult NPCs or just be nice to NPCs or you could go hunting or go find gold all across the map to customize your guns or go fishing there's so many stuff to do in that game
I swear Arthur and Mary Beth were a perfect couple when playing through man She was probably the nicest in the gang especially to Arthur and never really hated anyone aside from Dutch or Micah maybe
Bro I swear sometimes I wish I could break the fourth wall and be like ITS ME ARTHUR IN JOHNS BODY I KNOW WHAT YOU BEEN THROUGH, TREAT ME LIKE ARTHUR NOT LIKE A STRANGER
Funny how Arthur only talked about how bad he was but by dying a hero he redeemed himself. Red first is the bloodshed he caused, then dead is his heros death, and in dying that death he got redemption
Realistically the only logical scenario was for Arthur to die one way or another, otherwise there would be no good reason canonically as to why he’s not in RDR1
Poor john. He went through a lot of horrible moments in his life, now lost a brother (also he wrote in arthur's journal that he keeps having only ghosts in mind, something like that, so clearly suffers, as when going back to the old camps 😥)... He's a broken character and a martyr, what a great character
John let them know Arthur saved him, a way of remember how much of a great man Arthur was in his last days. And how remarkable Rains Falls memory is, he remembered John after all that time
they literally out did themselves like im not even joking, john was already a top tier protagonist snd then they made Arthur who is even better somehow, not to take anything sway from john at all, he's still top tier but Arthur was alittle more fleshed out in some ways snd just genuinely one of the best protagonists ever created, rdr2 is still genuinely a gaming landmark title
Why rdr3 needs to be playing as Jack, he’s the result of being raised by all the Vanderlin Gang, Arthur, John, even Dutch. You give this multiple endings and it would be the ultimate send off to this series
Bro Seriously why hasn't @RockStarGames Added in John Marstons Og Hair? And his Outfits? And some of his RDR2 NPC Quotes and Antagonizing Quotes? And John Marstons Chapter 2 Scar with the Strings that Abigail put on his Face? They Fucked John Model up Dramatically and I hope someone Starts a Petition and maybe we All can Get @RockStarGames to Add in Content and fix stuff in RDR2 Storymode Only, FUCK RDR2 Online its Fucking Trash ....us The Fans Saw Every Cut Content that shoulda been on RDR2 Console and we Should Bug @RockStarGames about John Marstons Hair again....There was 2 Petitions I Signed about John Marstons Hair.... if someone makes a New Petition I'll sign it to but Keep Money out of it be because nobody wants to Donate... ❤ We just Want Red Dead Redemption 2 Storymode Only Cut Content in the Game ASAP in 1 or 2 updates ffs..... Why is us the Fans Letting @RockStarGames Bend John Marston? This was supposed to Be GAME OF THE FUCKING YEAR RiGHT???
Love leaving the last Hamish mission to John. It gives Hamish a couple of longer years to live out his life having met a good friend in Arthur. And then you hear, as John about all of Arthur's adventures with Hamish. It's a bittersweet moment, until you lose Hamish for good. (But at least John gets Buell)
I dislike everyone shitting on John for Arthur...John in the epilogue is still great...Hes just a different man from RDR1...He hasn't become the hardened gunslinger yet he's a man trying to hide his past so of course he is nervous often
@@April-zr4bi too much money too much time to give it any room for error. The story belongs in a children's book the same clunky controls and gunplay also mission design is ripped from gta3 wait no gta3 had tolerable missions
@@MegAGAM3RMaN so you wanted a game with less funding and less effort put into it? go to a different studio if you wanted that. while yes, some missions are less than great, the characters are still amazing and the setting is beautiful.
@@April-zr4bi no I wanted my game with infinite finding and 8 years to have close to 0 flaws not flaws every time u turn around or rotate kinda cause it's a rockstar game
Rdr2 beginning: i want john back
Rdr2 ending: i want arthur back 😭😭😭
Real af game was a master piece both of em
@@tony2down996Yessir
Literally how it was
Yes ! Yes! And again YES! I fucking love this game so much play this nearly everyday !
Truer words were never spoken...WE as gamers were SOOOOO WROOOONG😢😢😢❤❤❤ #RIPAURTHUR
Playing a game that breaks your heart, then having an epilogue where you have to break the news to a bunch of other people is borderline not cool
Lmfao Fr this game needed to come with a free therapy coupon
@@BIGPOPPA2098that's what sister Calderon is for.
@@burninsherman1037 she's the best
No, not cool, it's incredibly wonderful
@@burninsherman1037 bruh that shit makes me cry more lol
He saved my life & he gave his.
That doesn’t surprise me one bit.
Love that exchange, you can feel the reverence for their old friend
Can u support my channel
Arthur put his life on the line for his son and the whole tribe multiple times. And wanted nothing in return. Such a solid dude.
I love how rains fall knew everything about Arthur, even though he’d barely known him. He knew everything about his character.
@@Biggsman_IVrains fall wanted the best for someone like arthur who helped his son and the tribe if they ever were to find a cure for TB they wouldve made sure to come in time to help him when he was at his lowest
@@onepieceking1770 oh yeah, 100%. I just really wish eagle flies could’ve made it. That part almost made me break down when they brought him back to rains fall. They never deserved to get used the way they did. They were great people. I’m glad a lot of the gang got out. And I’m glad they actually cared for Arthur.
I know Arthur is a fictional character but i mourn him somehow.
I do too I really do every time I think about him I get sad and depressive like thinking about a friend long gone
His soul was real
We played as him and got to know him like we do any person. Personality, temper, actions, dialogue, and even the most emotional moments, we were there through everything
You can mourn for anything that has given enough to you and others
If a rock can give you Kindness, confidence, meaning, fun, peace. It’s okay to feel sad when that rock is gone and is no longer able to give it to you. Nevermind if it’s a person; fake or real.
Your not sad for a silly reason friend. Your sad arthur can’t exist in a sequal.. lest it’s a prequel anyway in johns case.
Its hard not to when you spent over a hundred hours playing as him.
Meanwhile Arthur in heaven :
YOU SIR ARE A FISH 🏖🎩👉🏻🐟
@@Mellik47 No, he is in heaven
@@Mellik47it depends if you have high or low honor
@@gustavoszigethiaraya2381 no he’s not how are you going to be in heaven when you don’t even believe in god ? 😂
I think it’s more about intentions and he might have been an outlaw but he only robbed from those who robbed others and the rich he helped the poor he might have been against mans law but he wasn’t against gods law in my opinion🤷♂️
damn let them dream@@Mellik47
"You've forgotten far more important people than me."
- The Strange Man
Doesn't trelawney get called a strange man in rdr2
Who is this strange man I keep hearing of?
@@cheshirehat8355hes in the first red dead redemption game as a stranger, you can watch some videos about him if you want just look up "strange man rdr"
@@cheshirehat8355 A mision giving stranger in original RDR. He was supposed to be a mysterious and supernatural figure, a lot of peopel consider him the devil, the death or something of a sort.
@@cheshirehat8355he gave Herbert Moon two options, two generations, or to be happy. Herbert chose two generations as he had a daughter and upcoming granddaughter. Meaning he would no longer be happy. So the strange man causes a deadly disease (cholera) to hit Herbert’s home town. Causing him to lose business as a shopkeeper
*Meanwhile im doin the good ol "HEY there mister" to get the good endings*
Yeah but it doesnt matter though Arthur still dies
@@remeks2472but it does matter because it changes how John talks about him
Hours spent in Saint Denis none of us will ever get back but it was dam sure worth it
@@nirab9553 all those random NPCs I killed, to me that never actually happens in the game and is only to make Arthur seem like a cold hearted killer slowly learning redemption to the right side, if that makes sense😭
@@rook2stoned it does make sense and I guess that’s exactly what rockstar was going for with the slight changes in the aspect from rdr1 where John is made to be a hero with his redemption instead of Arthur being a cold killer and robber to dying to help John escape n the side mission stuff which is why he had the real redemption
Random pedestrian: “…”
John: “ARTHUR SAVED MY LIFE”
John in RDR1: Who the heck is Arthur? (Didn't exist back in 2010)
“ do you have the tim-“
“HE SAVED MY LIFE”
YOU EAT BABIES
“MORE THAN ONCE” 🗣️🗣️🗣️‼️‼️‼️
Random Pedestrian: He said hey to me and two other people once. Then he told me my face looked just like my horses ass. I miss him.
Arthur Morgan is the best video game character ever
Arthur is neither a hero nor a villain, he is a controversial personality but it all depends on the player
@@ДмитрийИванников-х5бyes but i think the story is about a person becoming bad to good you can't get the point from low honor arthur high honor is the man that we should be
Imo Arthur was a good man that had to do bad things sometimes to survive
@@Ariegon yes man but low honor is the worst man killing kids and humans for no reason is bad actually but yet still it's fun but it affects the story
@@skhistoryofstory803when the hell do you kill kids? lol
I love that John wants them all to know how Arthur saved him. Even if it’s painful for him to relive it every time, it’s also like a badge of honour. I knew this beautiful person that made the ultimate sacrifice for myself and my loved ones, and I must honour his memory.
this is so sweet
Always felt the same. Like he owes so much to Arthur that any opportunity to let someone know what he did for love, for brotherhood, for what was right…. He tells them. And you can tell he feels almost bad… this man became a good man. Saved John and Abigail and jack. And died alone after having his whole world crumble down around him. Seeing his best friend and father figure Dutch lose it, and then in his final moments that man left him and didn’t say a word to him… that always hurt me. I remember shouting at Dutch my first playthrough… say something Dutch!! Say something now for christs sake!! Only to have John do it for me later on… when John said say something Dutch… and he fell silent again… I knew that Arthur dying… that broke Dutch. That’s why we got what we saw in the first game.
Until he kills them all later
@@ChiralityPracticality who? only jhon and uncle died
I think it's also a lot of survivors guilt
I swear Arthur is the only fictional character I ever mourned like a real person. 💀
Don't lie, you hassled Seth MacFarlane when he killed off Brian, didn't you. Lol
@@Poppa_Capinyoaz Ngl you made me look it up lol. I didn’t knew he died. 😂
@@Poppa_Capinyoaz who?
Solid Snake/Big Boss dying made grown men cry…then there’s Lee from TWD…
@@collegebro85 i got them feels in Guns of Patriots too but Arthur’s death man that shit hits hard
i pretty much punched the data disc after arthur died
You mean you ripped and teared it...
I'll let myself out🚶♂️
@@attackhelicopter588he means the data disc, not the play disc
@@rdr_darthh He was making a DOOM joke, Rip and Tear is a musical piece from the 2016 remake
What an idiot.
*aggressive shotgun reload*
Damn this just shows how impactful Arthur was on the ingame characters and us in real life for good or for worse
For good, it was one of my favorite stories probably is. Honestly the story was fucking fantastic and having a sad ending although heartbreaking, in my opinion it just made it more impactful and way more better. Not as in I dislike Arthur’s character but more so that his approaching demise was important for not only his character, his arc, but also his redemption as he knows he’s living not the best, he knows he’s not all that great. Though Arthur realizes that maybe Dutch’s philosophy probably wasn’t all that great for the gang, he knows that he’s done bad and if you play the missions with “Agnes Downes” (I believe it was) and her son later in the story. Arthur tries to make up for his wrongs and tries to help Agnes out of the bad situation she is in. Arthur knows he doesn’t have all that much time left, but he doesn’t find somewhere to flee and live out the rest of his days relaxing and enjoying things, but instead he tries to help many others like John, Abigail, and Jack Marston get out and be safe. And that is Arthur’s redemption..
@@imbored4798when I was talking for worse is was referencing low honor arthur but yeah most of the time it impacted them for good
I always get the sense whenever John starts talking about Arthur he feels guilty based on everything. The type of guilt you feel once the person is gone and you realized how loyal they were. This game gets me
It helps make sense how in the future he never talk about Arthur
Idk why I always thought Mary Beth had a crush on Arthur.
She's so cute, ngl. I wouldn't blame arthur, but the age difference is probably another reason why they weren't together.
probably because you mistook her for Mary Linton, Arthur’s actual girlfriend/wife. i got them both mixed up too
I agree with you accualy i had a dialog with her she be uppset after Arthur went and talked to Mary linton
@@TRVSHSKXLLyou mean ex and Mary was annoying and only came around when she need stuff
@@TRVSHSKXLLthe game uses protagonists first names twice, usually to represent a symbol, remember towards the end of chapter 6 when Arthur is looking for bounty named Arthur (there’s a message there) just like with Mary
It's funny how when Rockstar announced that Rdr2 will have a new protagonist everybody took to the internet with pitchforks & torches, only to now say that Arthur is literally the best character ever written.
The playthrough of RDR2 is an emotional rollercoaster. You get angry, even violent, you laugh, you feel loyalty and betrayal, love and regret. And believe me, you will cry.
And then Rockstar hits you with this epilogue and gives you at least a little bit of closure. Genius.
That's redemption, in a nutshell, but the cost of sin is always death.
You die rather you sin or not, nuns are not immortal
The cost of living is death.
@@lobodesade6780 what's dead shall never die
@@bcal8118 you misunderstand
@@bcal8118sin puts you in an early grave is the point being made
Best story mode ever, bar fucking nun.
What about the nun?
Haha I see what you did there 😇
what about fucking the nun D:
Lucky bar bastard
"That doesn't surprise me one bit."
High honor Arthur was the most reputable man in the whole RDR
Somehow this games makes you go from wanting to play ad John, to *having* to play as John...
Lol yea i know some people were upset how John was just an NPC in this game then realize how much better it was this way
Tv girl with Rdr2 is a lethal combination
Absolutely breaks my heart everytime
Do you know wich tv girl song it is?
"not allowed" by tv girl@@warm_upmycold_pants3388
not allowed
Tv girl?
Charlotte was so wholesome
Nothing is wholesome anymore, sorry. You've all beaten the word to a bloody pulp...
@@MeadeJ67womp womp
@MeadeJ67 what exactly does it mean to you, then?
@@MeadeJ67?
@@MeadeJ67waa waa waa that’s all I’m hearing from you
The "sigh" Charlotte gave sounded so sad😢😮
Out of all the games I played. This one had tears flowing out of my eyes. A masterfully made game.
"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." Arthur didn't know most of these people, but still helped them. He knew his life was coming to an end, and he felt it necessary to help those around him, not for gain, in the end, but to come to terms with himself with what little time he had. Still one of my favorite video game characters. His story is a hell of a ride.
I would do anything to play this game for the first time again without any spoilers
I left that last Hamish mission to play as John. They also talk very well about Arthur
If you do Hamish missions except the last one Hamish will member him
Yeah, I did that. I'm very glad I did, it was a wholesome conversation 😌
@@MrFlakko30 I know his face makes it 100 times more sad
Mary Beth and John are some of only a few people that really cared about Arthur
Charles and Sadie as well
That gang could've survived so much better without the good-for-nothings that were, Uncle, Dutch, Micah and Bill.
@@mhk906Tilly and Lenny
@@Poppa_Capinyoaz and Javier
@@Poppa_Capinyoaz”I have a plan!”
My girlfriend's name is Mary - Beth
She always reminds me of Arthur when I say her name
Do you pronounce it murreh beth?
Arthur Morgan: The man who saved many, The man who many couldn't save 😢
honestly the best way to play rdr2 is to make arthur an ass at first but as u progress make him more honorable, it makes the story way more impactful imo
If you read his journal you can see he had always had the fight of good and bad in him(he literally Write that) I was low honor in chapter 2+3 especially when he talk abt how he hate beating the guy with TB and how his son looked at him as evil even though he acted like he doesn't care but in his journal he said what was really going on so I think the game is just you choosing who would beat the other
Hearing rains fall say that just made me tear up man, didnt expect that
I wish someone would make a book or a tv series adaptation of rdr2 cause this story is seriously a masterpiece
“You may not like it but it’s your turn now” hits hard
“That doesn’t surprise me one bit.”
I loved this character man ♥️wholesome
Who was this character again?
@@pkpillai685 Rains Fall
“Arthur saved my life, more than once.” And “Arthur, I don’t talk about him much, but I think about him.”
Hit hard.
I need a third game that goes further back in time so I can have more of Arthur Morgan…😭
You may get your wish, Rdr3 supposedly is going to be a prequel.
But there's no redemption
I was sad when Arthur Morgan and John Marston died because I earned respect from both of them throughout the game, and it's almost like you knew them because that game is very long.
Arthur Morgan is the best character of all time, he has a good heart, goodbye Arthur
Yeah, Arthur passing did not hurt me that much untill I had to play like John. Every conversation with almost everyone was painful. No wonder John did not want to talk about it. What a way to start RDR1. ❤
Your a good man Arthur Morgan.
More like a bad man with a good heart
@@Sith_lord_maula good man who did bad things
@@Zghost276 true
@@Sith_lord_maul Badass man with good heart but unfortunately got involved in bad things
I love how they dropped RDR1 and got praised for making the greatest redemption story in gaming, and then they dropped RDR2 and broke their own record. Nothing has encapsulated the nuances, joys, and pains of redemption quite the same
Even raina fall remembers Arthur I will say this right now And everyone else would agree with me that Red Dead redemption 2 was a freaking masterpiece The storyline was incredible The graphics were incredible The characters were incredible there was so much free roam sure you had to go back and do the mission to get farther in the campaign but you could just go around town and insult NPCs or just be nice to NPCs or you could go hunting or go find gold all across the map to customize your guns or go fishing there's so many stuff to do in that game
I swear Arthur and Mary Beth were a perfect couple when playing through man
She was probably the nicest in the gang especially to Arthur and never really hated anyone aside from Dutch or Micah maybe
Arthur was a very bad good man. ❤
Bro I swear sometimes I wish I could break the fourth wall and be like ITS ME ARTHUR IN JOHNS BODY I KNOW WHAT YOU BEEN THROUGH, TREAT ME LIKE ARTHUR NOT LIKE A STRANGER
Worst part is i missed all of these clips 😢
How? You only need to go to some places
@@Ghost-gr4qjwhere
@@EdwardWhite-ly5pn train station of anessburg, train station of emerald ranch, the store of rhodes...
Funny how Arthur only talked about how bad he was but by dying a hero he redeemed himself.
Red first is the bloodshed he caused, then dead is his heros death, and in dying that death he got redemption
Realistically the only logical scenario was for Arthur to die one way or another, otherwise there would be no good reason canonically as to why he’s not in RDR1
Bro arthur was a real one.
God this game is so perfect. The story, characters, world building, dynamics, setting, everything.
Arthur is such a great character 😢
Where is Hamish ?
Hamish dies in the last mission with him as Arthur. He gets hit by a giant boar they’re hunting and dies
@@Nunya111You can do the mission as John Too Then Hamish Remembers Arthur
@@Nunya111 you can save the last mission for john, you will get a special cutscene and buell for john
@@dominikschachner7208 damn Arthur lowkey took years off the man’s life 😅
@@Nunya111 yeah theres times i purposely do the last mission as john so hamish can live longer, i could care less about Buell though.
Poor john. He went through a lot of horrible moments in his life, now lost a brother (also he wrote in arthur's journal that he keeps having only ghosts in mind, something like that, so clearly suffers, as when going back to the old camps 😥)... He's a broken character and a martyr, what a great character
John's not dead. I think you have to be dead to be a martyr.😊
@@scottcertain9888 okay, i didn't know. For me, an alive person could have been a martyr by suffering during his life, but i think you're right 👍
@@scottcertain9888John is dead
Arthur Morgan is by far my most favorite personality in a video game. Red Dead Redemption 2 is truly a masterpiece.
Guys just remember Arthur is always by your side even though he's not here but he's always by your side
And John 😢
Fuck rockstar for killing arthur, he was a better protagonist the best dare I say
he was the best because he passed too
@@timoteomantovani6489 nah he deserved to live
It was a canon event
@@mohammedalharbi5970he had to die for John's story to make sense
John let them know Arthur saved him, a way of remember how much of a great man Arthur was in his last days. And how remarkable Rains Falls memory is, he remembered John after all that time
Please we Want our Beloved Arthur Morgan back in the Game 😢❤
It wouldn't make sense for him to be alive. He had to die for John's story to make sense
Even though Arthur isnt real, I idolize him
worse part is that any unfinished stranger missions you didn’t finish have no idea arthur’s been dead
How you get those double bandoilers?
finished the game more than a year ago but this still hits deep man arthur is such a greatly developed character
I’ve played this game in its entirety about 4 times now, on my 5th play through and it still always gets me
John: I don't talk about him much
Him casually telling everyone about how he saved his life
To end up wirh Arthur's Honor in the end would be the best ending for me
Arthur is a legend in the rdr2 world everybody knows him
they literally out did themselves like im not even joking, john was already a top tier protagonist snd then they made Arthur who is even better somehow, not to take anything sway from john at all, he's still top tier but Arthur was alittle more fleshed out in some ways snd just genuinely one of the best protagonists ever created, rdr2 is still genuinely a gaming landmark title
john talking about arthur is something else its so painful
Rain Falls kinda souns like bigfoot from rdr1
How do i get the MaryBeth cutscene? Got all the others...?
Такой же вопрос
just go behind the post office in valentine
Arthur was a great men despite being manipulated by Dutch all these years
This was a very powerful mission, I loved how everyone remembered Arthur fondly, but differently.
so many people in rdr2 called him a monster for killing thomas and stuff but then...
Ah, my favourite character, Horthur Mortgage
Why rdr3 needs to be playing as Jack, he’s the result of being raised by all the Vanderlin Gang, Arthur, John, even Dutch. You give this multiple endings and it would be the ultimate send off to this series
Arthur and Charolette was my favorite strangers missions 🥲
Johns catch phrase in rdr2 epilogue: "ARTHUR SAVED MY LIFE MORE THAN ONCE"
Arthur Morgan; you were a good man!!
Bro Seriously why hasn't @RockStarGames Added in John Marstons Og Hair? And his Outfits? And some of his RDR2 NPC Quotes and Antagonizing Quotes? And John Marstons Chapter 2 Scar with the Strings that Abigail put on his Face? They Fucked John Model up Dramatically and I hope someone Starts a Petition and maybe we All can Get @RockStarGames to Add in Content and fix stuff in RDR2 Storymode Only, FUCK RDR2 Online its Fucking Trash ....us The Fans Saw Every Cut Content that shoulda been on RDR2 Console and we Should Bug @RockStarGames about John Marstons Hair again....There was 2 Petitions I Signed about John Marstons Hair.... if someone makes a New Petition I'll sign it to but Keep Money out of it be because nobody wants to Donate... ❤ We just Want Red Dead Redemption 2 Storymode Only Cut Content in the Game ASAP in 1 or 2 updates ffs..... Why is us the Fans Letting @RockStarGames Bend John Marston? This was supposed to Be GAME OF THE FUCKING YEAR RiGHT???
The best game i've never played
It’s crazy how you had full control over Arthur, but he ended up changing you!
I love the way your John looks!
Thas he's default look💀
RDR3 it will be like who is this? i want Arthur back.
R.I.P. Arthur Morgan! A true American hero!
Get this out of my algorithm I'm on my second playthrough and I'm on chapter 6 i don't want Arthur to die but it has to happen and it makes me sad
Arthur truly was a great person
Love leaving the last Hamish mission to John. It gives Hamish a couple of longer years to live out his life having met a good friend in Arthur. And then you hear, as John about all of Arthur's adventures with Hamish. It's a bittersweet moment, until you lose Hamish for good.
(But at least John gets Buell)
rest in peace my love and prayers are with you
Arthur Morgan was that dude, one bad ass who was loyal to his friends. This game won't ever get old to me.
Whos the last lady
me
She's a girl Who Arthur teaches tò Hunt and live alone After Her husband dies
@@giannilaroccia2901 i never encountered that before
@@giannilaroccia2901 where's that encounter
@@TheCleansedUgvorit's in the very top right of the map, you'll find a grave where she's found crying
I dislike everyone shitting on John for Arthur...John in the epilogue is still great...Hes just a different man from RDR1...He hasn't become the hardened gunslinger yet he's a man trying to hide his past so of course he is nervous often
Omg I still can't believe what a masterpiece rockstar almost made so close
wdym?
@@April-zr4bi too much money too much time to give it any room for error. The story belongs in a children's book the same clunky controls and gunplay also mission design is ripped from gta3 wait no gta3 had tolerable missions
@@MegAGAM3RMaN so you wanted a game with less funding and less effort put into it? go to a different studio if you wanted that.
while yes, some missions are less than great, the characters are still amazing and the setting is beautiful.
@@April-zr4bi no I wanted my game with infinite finding and 8 years to have close to 0 flaws not flaws every time u turn around or rotate kinda cause it's a rockstar game
@@MegAGAM3RMaN tf?
If tears didn’t come out of your eyes when Arthur died ……. You didn’t live this game how you were supposed to….
I wish dutch could of had a scene where hes gose to arthurs grave and says to arthurs grave
Dutch rest in peace my dear boy my son
Nah he turned into a monster remember in the final mission as Arthur they tried to kill arthut
You're forgetting Tilly Jackson she's in Saint Denis I'm pretty sure she married a lawyer
Bro..wtf u mean to tell me my homie art is gone!?... Bruh I just started playing😢😂 I gotta find lenny
Rockstar: We tortured ourselves making this game now we’re torturing your asses playing it.