well said by Bublik, people before they comment whatever they like need to put themselves in the player’s shoes, where emotional and physical state were already taxed as the match went on for 3 hours or so, and to put in context that the outburst happened in deciding points, especially considering what is at stake here: millions of money, etc which will put tremendous stress on the player
No consideration for the fans. They were cheated. A point penalty would have been sufficient. Especially since it was a case of I said/you said. The director didn't know who was right. Personally I've been tired of officials who think they're bigger than the game.
Maybe they were watching him for a while and decided the next time this kind of behavior will be punished? It’s not like it’s the first time he is intimidating someone like this. I feel bad for him but also he has himself to blame, no one else. Kids are watching him and taking example.
I think it would get a bit ridiculous if the crowd has to wait for the umpire to listen - possibly with the help of interpreters - what was SAID. This should be done carefully after the game to determine whether fines are justified. The default was unfortunate, a harsh judgement call, but maybe it'll help Andrey control his temper a little bit better in the future.
@@TalkingTennisTT it is counter productive to tell this to people directly. You just make quality of your content lower. I was subscriber, but I am going to unsubscribe now.
We are humans, we have emotions, if someone wants people to play without emotions, then think how audience will feel about these boring games. For me the solution if to replace referees with robots who don’t care about being called moron, but very accurate with identifying whether the ball is in or out
It is not a question of emotions or human beings - the umpire made a mistake - can you imagine such a mistake on a crucial point?Rublev didnt do anything wrong - ABSOLUTELY ANYTHING WRONG , HE WAS EVEN TOO POLITE TOWARDS THE UMPIRE .They are not playing for fun or for leisure , this is 100% PURE BUSINESS WITH MONEY AT STAKE , WITH PLAYERS SALARY AT STAKE! Can you imagine a business trade involving mR tesla, Mr Microsoft , HSBC BANK (or another bank)m and one of the accountants , or one of the sollicitors involved makes a mistake during the trade?? Only idiots and born losers can accept such mistakes during a business activity!
@@mamijot69 YES- There have been situations and times when I took things in my own hands and was ready to use the violence ; I certainly have abused some authorities over the time because I was in the right - AND I AM CERTAINLY READY TO BEHAVE IN THE SAME WAY IN CASE THE SAME SITUATIONS HAPPEN -- NO TH ING W R O N G W I T H T H A T . I always ask ' can I ' ; I am always ready to help other people - but I am not a born loser. Only BORN LOSERS IDIOTS CAN ACCEPT MISTAKES OR WRONG DECISION / CALLS WHEN THEY ARE IN THE RIGHT
that was an amazing match and to cut it short for someone being upset for a potential missed call is lame. and they said they’d review the cameras and then follow it up with not wanting to? even rublev was admit about reviewing the cameras and just taking a word of one person? not even the linesman was the one that was upset about it
I think upset is an understatement. Rublev got in the guys face. Totally disrespectful. Yes its a shame that the match ended this way, but Rublev has no one to blame but himself. He could have called for a review of the call as soon as it happened if he was so damn sure it was a bad call.
Yelling a ref a moron should never get you disqualified. It’s not classy or appropriate, but to be DQ hell no. Sports is about emotions- sometimes if it goes over then a point penalty is fine. In basketball players go at refs and get a Technical Foul. If it happens again then 2nd tech and DQ. Calling a ref a moron and yelling at that point of the game and to be DQ is embarasssing to any real competitive sport
@@TalkingTennisTT ATP is so fascist -- I'd start looking for another sport to report about. Seriously. [You 'agree'd with the arm-chair psychologizing comment further down the thread of comments on this vid. Stay with tennis -- you fit in with the dumb-as-sheeeeeet country-club condescending crowd.]
@@TalkingTennisTT why did you 'agree' with the arm-chair psychologizing comment below on this thread of comments to your vid? you're a dumb-sheeeet, probs. Not interested in subbing.
One of the best matches I have seen in a long time. 42 winners before the end in a 3 setter for Bublik. 13 unforced errors. Rublev similar. Amazing. Terrible ending. I remember bublik saying: I’m ok to continue. (Even at the risk of losing). The fans lost today. Respect is important sure. Point penalty even game penalty. Same result but less drastic. IMHO. Good luck Andre. Best of luck tomorrow Sasha.
The bigger problem here is umpires and line judges act like they are above the rules and they’re too subjective to be professional adjudicators. If you’re going to act on your ego and take players for a ride at least let them know early so they can prepare what to expect. Otherwise you’re being chickenshit. It’s too deliberate to believe it’s a simple mistake now. I empathized with Coco and her set-to with the chair umpire who was patronizing her throughout that entire dialogue and didn’t allow her the right to consult with the supervisor. I’ll empathize with Rublev here. Most people are concerned about Rublev’s outburst but the bigger problem is the umpires actions have been driven by their ego and nobody wants to talk about it. I would hate to see this be a trend. It’s time to keep the umpires honest.
Especially the ones who oversee the Dubai tournament. They suck. I knew there was something fishy going on since the umpire was patronizing Coco and then Monfils and Medvedev had to go through unanticipated barriers to win their matches.
I dont like to see Rublev behaving like this, when he seems like such a good person, always, off-court. I think a point penalty would be fine. Not a DQ. Also agree about the Umpires, many feel the need to self-insert themselves. Rules need to be enforced, but many give problems due to perceived disrespect, real or otherwise, their job is to be impartial.
Man, you see it much differently than I do. Rublev gets in the guys face, insults him, totally disrespectful actions and you think the larger part is the officials doing their best to make calls, which actually appeared to be the correct call. BTW- looking at the replays, the ball appears IN! Rublev has no one to blame but himself. He went too far.
@@kawai99100 Correct, but neither you nor i nor the lines person is a professional athlete and that is why we need to have electronic line calling and video reviews. Not draconian umpires and arbitrary rulings. good day to you too.
Consequently any roraring, yelling should be forbidden on the court during games. Also excitement yelling. As well as shouting or making noise while the ball is in game.
No, one point, warning, is not enough. It doesnt matter what Rublev said . What matters is he behaved in a threatening, extremely aggressive way. The linesman was timid and clearly he was scared. Nobody knows if Rublev winds himself up to a point when he strikes, hits, fires a shot at someone . He is a very good player who has a problems containing his nerves and following the code of conduct. Emotions, -yes. Bullying, threatening, screaming in someone's face -no.
Rublev didn’t do great thing as man, however in such intense match lines umpire don’t do their job in time is really problematic. It’s just nerve-wracking always when human does judge on such high speed sports.
Rublev should have stopped and challenged the call if he was so sure the ball was out. ELC would've shown the ball was in and he wouldn't have have shouted at the linesman. Rublev is the architect of his own downfall.
His behavior warranted disciplinary action as outlined by the rules...code of conduct violation that progresses from warning, to loss of point, to loss of game, then default. The word of one linesman should not set the table for an immediate DQ and loss of earnings and points. It's outrageous and if Rublev was from a country other than Russia, he would have been warned and nothing more. Serena Williams actually threatened an official with violence, and she was sanctioned as is appropriate by the rules with code violations. Once again, the rules are enforced whimsically and inconsistently depending on the location and player, and that hurts the sport.
This whole thing reminds me that pro tennis desperately needs to stop letting Europeans frame the discussion on "emotionality." I promise: this effete, bourgeois, therapeutic take on human psychology as articulated by Europeans (and many of their descendants) does not comport with the experiences of the rest of us. "Verbal abuse" is a debatable concept. Pretending otherwise is propaganda and (Western) cultural supremacy. Basically, Rublev did nothing wrong. I love his passion. He can come yell at me on a public court any day of the week. I'm a man and I live in a country with free speech codes (for now) and I'm not at all threatened by curse words. Lol Are people really this soft? 😂
I have been all over the world and I have never been to a place where that kind of conduct is tolerated in normal interactions. It's definitely not a Western cultural thing. Have you spent much time in Western countries? If anything, in my experience, that behavior is more tolerated in Western countries (at least in the States).
What a weird spot to put flowers LOL
Underrated comment.
hahahaha
The way he supports Andrey >>>
My respect for him 📈📈📈
Thank you Sasha!
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
well said by Bublik, people before they comment whatever they like need to put themselves in the player’s shoes, where emotional and physical state were already taxed as the match went on for 3 hours or so, and to put in context that the outburst happened in deciding points, especially considering what is at stake here: millions of money, etc which will put tremendous stress on the player
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
I love Andrey but he can't verbally assault a human.
No consideration for the fans. They were cheated. A point penalty would have been sufficient. Especially since it was a case of I said/you said. The director didn't know who was right. Personally I've been tired of officials who think they're bigger than the game.
Personally I've been tired of player who think they're bigger than the game
Derp. Tennis is not a religion. Lol @@jwkl7
I agree that a point would have been enough, but then rules should have been different. You can't change them on the fly
Maybe they were watching him for a while and decided the next time this kind of behavior will be punished? It’s not like it’s the first time he is intimidating someone like this. I feel bad for him but also he has himself to blame, no one else. Kids are watching him and taking example.
The players are the game, lol
If not electronic line calling, at least have a camera fixed on the lines wirh the opportunity to challenge.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
They had audio and video to replay what the Rube said, but they didn't bother looking at it. ATP is ridiculous and fascist.
I think it would get a bit ridiculous if the crowd has to wait for the umpire to listen - possibly with the help of interpreters - what was SAID. This should be done carefully after the game to determine whether fines are justified. The default was unfortunate, a harsh judgement call, but maybe it'll help Andrey control his temper a little bit better in the future.
Very well said, Bublik! Huge respect for you! Carreno Busta, Rune? Do you see how it is done? Learn something from Bublik.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
@@TalkingTennisTT it is counter productive to tell this to people directly. You just make quality of your content lower. I was subscriber, but I am going to unsubscribe now.
@@DeltoidBeast fair enough :)
@@DeltoidBeast I am going to subscribe to you instead :)
@@TalkingTennisTT Haha! Cool :)
We are humans, we have emotions, if someone wants people to play without emotions, then think how audience will feel about these boring games. For me the solution if to replace referees with robots who don’t care about being called moron, but very accurate with identifying whether the ball is in or out
It is not a question of emotions or human beings - the umpire made a mistake - can you imagine such a mistake on a crucial point?Rublev didnt do anything wrong - ABSOLUTELY ANYTHING WRONG , HE WAS EVEN TOO POLITE TOWARDS THE UMPIRE .They are not playing for fun or for leisure , this is 100% PURE BUSINESS WITH MONEY AT STAKE , WITH PLAYERS SALARY AT STAKE! Can you imagine a business trade involving mR tesla, Mr Microsoft , HSBC BANK (or another bank)m and one of the accountants , or one of the sollicitors involved makes a mistake during the trade?? Only idiots and born losers can accept such mistakes during a business activity!
@@andreasmissiroli6915you sound like a person who would retort to violence to solve problems.
@mamijot69 You sound like someone who would cower under the kitchen table while his/her family was getting whacked by an intruder.
@@mamijot69 YES- There have been situations and times when I took things in my own hands and was ready to use the violence ; I certainly have abused some authorities over the time because I was in the right - AND I AM CERTAINLY READY TO BEHAVE IN THE SAME WAY IN CASE THE SAME SITUATIONS HAPPEN -- NO TH ING W R O N G W I T H T H A T . I always ask ' can I ' ; I am always ready to help other people - but I am not a born loser. Only BORN LOSERS IDIOTS CAN ACCEPT MISTAKES OR WRONG DECISION / CALLS WHEN THEY ARE IN THE RIGHT
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT@@mamijot69
that was an amazing match and to cut it short for someone being upset for a potential missed call is lame. and they said they’d review the cameras and then follow it up with not wanting to? even rublev was admit about reviewing the cameras and just taking a word of one person? not even the linesman was the one that was upset about it
He still called the line judge a moron and yelled in his face
I think upset is an understatement. Rublev got in the guys face. Totally disrespectful. Yes its a shame that the match ended this way, but Rublev has no one to blame but himself. He could have called for a review of the call as soon as it happened if he was so damn sure it was a bad call.
Yelling a ref a moron should never get you disqualified. It’s not classy or appropriate, but to be DQ hell no. Sports is about emotions- sometimes if it goes over then a point penalty is fine. In basketball players go at refs and get a Technical Foul. If it happens again then 2nd tech and DQ. Calling a ref a moron and yelling at that point of the game and to be DQ is embarasssing to any real competitive sport
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT@@magdalenaborek8350
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT@@gregg9694
Such a classy guy, ....love Bublik (and Rube)!
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
@@TalkingTennisTT ATP is so fascist -- I'd start looking for another sport to report about. Seriously. [You 'agree'd with the arm-chair psychologizing comment further down the thread of comments on this vid. Stay with tennis -- you fit in with the dumb-as-sheeeeeet country-club condescending crowd.]
@@TalkingTennisTT why did you 'agree' with the arm-chair psychologizing comment below on this thread of comments to your vid? you're a dumb-sheeeet, probs. Not interested in subbing.
One of the best matches I have seen in a long time. 42 winners before the end in a 3 setter for Bublik. 13 unforced errors. Rublev similar. Amazing. Terrible ending. I remember bublik saying: I’m ok to continue. (Even at the risk of losing). The fans lost today. Respect is important sure. Point penalty even game penalty. Same result but less drastic. IMHO. Good luck Andre. Best of luck tomorrow Sasha.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
Only Russians and Serbs get disqualified. Serena argued for 18 minutes with the empire and guess what ??? He never should have been disqualified
Don’t forget to subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/talkingtennistt
The bigger problem here is umpires and line judges act like they are above the rules and they’re too subjective to be professional adjudicators. If you’re going to act on your ego and take players for a ride at least let them know early so they can prepare what to expect. Otherwise you’re being chickenshit. It’s too deliberate to believe it’s a simple mistake now. I empathized with Coco and her set-to with the chair umpire who was patronizing her throughout that entire dialogue and didn’t allow her the right to consult with the supervisor. I’ll empathize with Rublev here. Most people are concerned about Rublev’s outburst but the bigger problem is the umpires actions have been driven by their ego and nobody wants to talk about it. I would hate to see this be a trend. It’s time to keep the umpires honest.
Tennis umps have always sucked and never been held accountable. Never forget: chalk flew up.
Especially the ones who oversee the Dubai tournament. They suck. I knew there was something fishy going on since the umpire was patronizing Coco and then Monfils and Medvedev had to go through unanticipated barriers to win their matches.
hostofGerulaitis Mr Mcenroe we are going to penalize you a point.
I dont like to see Rublev behaving like this, when he seems like such a good person, always, off-court. I think a point penalty would be fine. Not a DQ.
Also agree about the Umpires, many feel the need to self-insert themselves. Rules need to be enforced, but many give problems due to perceived disrespect, real or otherwise,
their job is to be impartial.
Man, you see it much differently than I do. Rublev gets in the guys face, insults him, totally disrespectful actions and you think the larger part is the officials doing their best to make calls, which actually appeared to be the correct call. BTW- looking at the replays, the ball appears IN! Rublev has no one to blame but himself. He went too far.
Rublev was wrong. The replay showed the ball was IN, it was not OUT, like he was claiming and making a whole fuss about. He got rightly DQ
Rublev did not just say something, he got in the linesman face and pointed racquet in face. Learn to control emotions and grow up.
sure, but the punishment doesn't fit the offense. do you know what he said? did he touch the official? no
@@z1az285 you're wrong. That is not the way a professional athlete should act towards a person. Goodnight.
@@kawai99100 Correct, but neither you nor i nor the lines person is a professional athlete and that is why we need to have electronic line calling and video reviews. Not draconian umpires and arbitrary rulings. good day to you too.
No, it was cool. Tennis is better when guys like Rublev can express themselves freely.
Why do they still have line judges anyway? Can't they just use hawk eye and get rid of that frumpy old slobs that only getting in players way!?
Consequently any roraring, yelling should be forbidden on the court during games. Also excitement yelling.
As well as shouting or making noise while the ball is in game.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
Bad audio
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT so next year we can have better mics
No, one point, warning, is not enough. It doesnt matter what Rublev said . What matters is he behaved in a threatening, extremely aggressive way. The linesman was timid and clearly he was scared. Nobody knows if Rublev winds himself up to a point when he strikes, hits, fires a shot at someone . He is a very good player who has a problems containing his nerves and following the code of conduct.
Emotions, -yes. Bullying, threatening, screaming in someone's face -no.
"Threatening." 😂
Oh, my. This is so typical for tennis, and nothing happens.
i totally agree. its not matter of what he said but the way he screamed at someone`s face. These kind of behaviours shouldnt be tolerated.
Rublev didn’t do great thing as man, however in such intense match lines umpire don’t do their job in time is really problematic. It’s just nerve-wracking always when human does judge on such high speed sports.
@@nikosgr9290 Better if he had gone to his team box and vent his anger. Should not have been shouting at the line judge.
Rublev should have stopped and challenged the call if he was so sure the ball was out. ELC would've shown the ball was in and he wouldn't have have shouted at the linesman. Rublev is the architect of his own downfall.
yes, but he was out of challenges at that point
His behavior warranted disciplinary action as outlined by the rules...code of conduct violation that progresses from warning, to loss of point, to loss of game, then default. The word of one linesman should not set the table for an immediate DQ and loss of earnings and points. It's outrageous and if Rublev was from a country other than Russia, he would have been warned and nothing more. Serena Williams actually threatened an official with violence, and she was sanctioned as is appropriate by the rules with code violations. Once again, the rules are enforced whimsically and inconsistently depending on the location and player, and that hurts the sport.
How stupid can someone be to say something like this?
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
Terrible audio, ATP / organisers , are you too poor for good mikes ?
They have a curious way of spending money, let’s say
This whole thing reminds me that pro tennis desperately needs to stop letting Europeans frame the discussion on "emotionality." I promise: this effete, bourgeois, therapeutic take on human psychology as articulated by Europeans (and many of their descendants) does not comport with the experiences of the rest of us. "Verbal abuse" is a debatable concept. Pretending otherwise is propaganda and (Western) cultural supremacy.
Basically, Rublev did nothing wrong. I love his passion. He can come yell at me on a public court any day of the week. I'm a man and I live in a country with free speech codes (for now) and I'm not at all threatened by curse words. Lol
Are people really this soft? 😂
are you ok?
I have been all over the world and I have never been to a place where that kind of conduct is tolerated in normal interactions. It's definitely not a Western cultural thing. Have you spent much time in Western countries? If anything, in my experience, that behavior is more tolerated in Western countries (at least in the States).
worst hot take ever.
@@nobelkamberi1829you mean one can’t just take his gun and shoot you in the USA?
@@alessandrovalente7645he is more than okay. Have you ever played any sport in the neighbourhood?
A middling guy who will never be at the top, with arrogant ambitions.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT
You are so arrogant. He 's number 5, are you the 5th best salesman , accountant in the world ? No ?
Позор судьям и организаторам.
Please hit like on this video and subscribe if you haven't already done so: www.youtube.com/@TalkingTennisTT