What 70 HP Characters Would See in the Mirror of Erised (Harry Potter Explained / Theory)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- TO BUY THE SECRETLAB HARRY POTTER COLLECTION: secretlab.co/?...
TO WIN THE CHAIR:
-Follow me on Instagram: / morgan_ross18
-Follow Secretlab: / secretlab
-Like the post: / cxl5c_jrk-e
-Tag 2 friends in the post on instagram^^
Patreon: / overview
Twitter: / movieflameprod
Personal Instagram: / morgan_ross18
TikTok: www.tiktok.com...
Facebook: / movieflame
FANART:
Harry’s Whole Family in Mirror: www.hp-lexicon...
Dumbledore Family: www.deviantart...
George Mirror of Erised: www.deviantart...
Bill Weasley With Scars: www.pillowfort...
McGonagall Family: www.deviantart...
James and Lily Kissing: www.deviantart...
Umbridge Family: www.deviantart...
Winky Accused of the Dark Mark: www.hp-lexicon...
Andromeda and Teddy Lupin: www.deviantart...
Remus, Nymphadora, & Teddy: www.deviantart...
Teddy Lupin: sheepskeleton....
Music- By Ross Bugden • ♩♫ Sad and Emotional M...
I read a theory somewhere that Fred and George discovered the Mirror Of Erised in their 1st year, but when they look into it, all they see was the two of them, side by side, just like in real life, so the thought it was just a normal mirror and leave the room. Years later, when George look into the mirror again, he saw both of them, standing side by side, and he finally understand what the mirror is.
That’s probably one of the best theories I’ve ever heard
The mirror however doesn’t show the future desires, it shows your current deepest desires
@@grando888 dumbleddore said that the happiest man alive would just see themself in the mirror. Maybe that’s what they saw.
@@Xxxxxxc51237 wow that just broke my heart, thanks
Q,
I think Arthur would also see himself knowing the purpose of a rubber duck.
hahhahahha love this comment
😂😂😂
😂🐥Lol
Who’s Arthur ? A muggle lover I suppose
@@Bellatrix_daugther_ScarletRonald weasley's father.
Timestamps, because I know I'll come back to this (thanks, Morgan!):
2:32 Harry Potter
2:58 Hermione Granger
3:31 Ron Weasley
3:56 Ginny Weasley
4:14 Draco Malfoy
4:40 Neville Longbottom
5:02 Luna Lovegood
5:21 Sirius Black
5:58 Albus Dumbledore
6:37 Severus Snape
6:58 Fred Weasley
7:23 George Weasley
7:54 Percy Weasley
8:13 Molly Weasley
8:48 Arthur Weasley
9:09 Charlie Weasley
9:18 Bill Weasley
9:42 Rubeus Hagrid
9:57 Peter Pettigrew
10:19 Fleur Delacour
10:57 Minerva McGonagall
11:25 Tom Riddle / Voldemort
11:50 Bellatrix Lestrange
12:18 Remus Lupin
12:41 Nymphadora Tonks
13:07 Cho Chang
14:00 Dudley Dursley
14:24 Vernon Dursley
14:38 Petunia Dursley
15:18 Newt Scamander
15:47 Oliver Wood
16:02 Gellert Grindelwald
16:43 Gilderoy Lockhart
17:00 Leta Lestrange
17:23 Lucius Malfoy
18:00 Narcissa Malfoy
18:15 Lily Potter
18:35 James Potter
19:05 Alastor Moody
19:51 Mundungus Fletcher
20:03 Tina Goldstein
20:26 Kingsley Shacklebolt
20:44 Argus Filch
21:01 Dolores Umbridge
21:49 Jacob Kawalski
22:25 Lavender Brown
22:47 Parvati Patil
23:01 Sybill Trelawney
23:26 Winky
24:18 Kreacher
24:51 Barty Crouch Sr.
25:15 Barty Crouch Jr.
25:33 Cedric Diggory
26:00 Amos Diggory
26:34 Queenie Goldstein
27:12 Rita Skeeter
27:35 Dean Thomas
27:58 Seamus Finnegan
28:29 Horace Slughorn
28:51 Viktor Krum
29:25 Andromeda Tonks
29:48 Olympe Maxime
30:08 Fenrir Greyback
30:30 Cornelius Fudge
30:55 Quirinus Quirrell
31:29 Filius Flitwick
32:00 Dobby
32:38 Bloody Baron
33:25 Helena Ravenclaw / Grey Lady
34:00 Teddy Lupin
Tysm!!
Tysfm
Ty I guess
Wow thanks 😊
Damn tysm
In my opinion I think Luna would see her mother, as well as friends. It’s clear in the books Luna desires friendship, and is surprised when people call her their friend.
Yh
Ya she says the DA was like having friends and when Harry says “I’m your friend” she’s shocked and happy
I think what Draco would actually see is his whole family without the dark mark, embracing each other. What he really wants are loving parents that don’t care about status and power, only about their family
especially his dad, his mom loved him enough to betray Voldemort when Draco was threatened. She loved Draco.
I agree
Awwwww that is so cute,yet nice!
I disagree, his fame was everything to him. Hence why he bragged about it all the time and he already had a loving mother who lied to the dark lord for him
@@KnightEdits12234 No he always wanted his father to be proud for who he was. He was being a jerk in school just because he was raised that way. He didn't want to see any other student looking greater than him so his father would think he's not worthy enough
Dumbledore says that the happiest man in the world would look into the mirror and see himself exactly as he is, and I feel like Dobby is the closest character to that, because he has everything he wants up until he dies. He is a free elf, who gets to wear clothes and work for Dumbledore. He is loved by Harry, and is able to dedicate his life to helping Harry.
If only he could. If only he could 😢
He would be dressed in several layers with scarves gloves and winter boots😂
He would also see himself with the world record for the ugliest socks
i think he would see a happy winky
I always thought that too.
I honestly believe for Hagrid, he would want to see Dumbledore alive! He was the most affected plus he held Dumbledore in such high esteem
and for good reason. When he was expelled, Dumbledore was the only one who seemed to believe him.
That is most likely right, though he might also see Norbert and his father, possibly a teacher who every one respected earlier in the series
And because dumbledore was so kind hearted and let hagrid work at hogwarts and gave him a home
Well Dumbledore did dave Hate it from leaving Hogwarts. He gave Hagrid another chance.
Y'all missed aragog bruv
I also think Cedric saw Harry as more of a partner than an opponent, after Harry told him about the first task being dragons. By that point, he probably realized that Harry didn't really want to compete, so Cedric's desire seems more so Harry wouldn't have to endure all the grief he got from his name coming out of the goblet.
i disagree cedric is a fair guy he wanted a rematch in prisoner of azkaban when harry fell off his broom, gave harry a hint of second clue bcz harry had warned him about dragons, he offered harry the cup not bcz he saw him as a partner bcz harry had saved him twice during the maze and he knew harry would have been on first place in 2nd task if harry had not taken the riddle too seriously.
this all shows that cedric is not completely selfless but always want to repay those whom he owe and wants to win fair and square for his house
True!! Deep.... but true.
I disagree and agree
Yeah, and also he feels bad bc he won when harry was tormented by dementors in one of the books
@@MarinaTilich he was even annoyed when his dad kept bragging about it
5:58 I’m sure Sirius and his friends discovered Erised in their era too. Sirius would’ve seen himself with his family, but his parents loved him, Regulus didn’t resent him or be jealous, and Andromeda was still in the family. He would’ve seen a happy family.
Yeah that makes sense, but I’m simple minded and I just imagined he’d see himself killing wormtail
Oh wait I almost forgot. The mirror of erised was only there in Harry’s first year because they brought it to Hogwarts to protect the Sorceror’s Stone
Conparing Bellatrix to Barty Jr, although they’re both psychopaths, I think Barty Jr is more intelligent and can think clearer as he was able to live in Hogwarts for a whole year in disguise and acting friendly amongst enemies, being friendly with Harry and helping him, of course he had an evil plan, but I think Bellatrix was a crazy unbridled lady, she wouldn’t have managed to stay in character undercover for a whole year, especially around Dumbledore, she wouldn’t be able to get her shit together hahaha
I don't even think she would even last 10 min hahaha
She could barely keep herself together, in Draco's house around her own family. Let alone Dumbledore.
Yeah Barty j.r is a great and cunning actor
Honestly
How much of that was due to Azkaban do you think? Either she was crazy from birth or the prison severely messed her up. Couldn't say it was her upbringing as Narcissa turned out quite normal (abiet still very hateful against muggleborns).
I would argue that Bellatrix is slightly more loyal to Voldemort than even B. C. Jr. They're both terrible people who are obsessed with Voldemort, but for me it comes down to B. C. Jr denying his involvement with the death eaters during his trial, while Bellatrix never tried to hide her devotion
I think Crouch was just smarter, smart enough to at least try the sympathy card, he was caught red handed and his own father was going to sentance him, ironically in the end it worked and he did get out.
@@melkhiordarkfell4354 that's a fair point as well. My only counter would be that I don't think the Lestranges would ever consider renouncing Voldemort. That's how strong their loyalty was. On the other hand, Crouch probably wanted to stay out of Azkaban to find Voldemort in secret
In the end though, Barty helped bring him back to power when Bellatrix was of no use thanks to being such a proud follower of Voldemort.
@@denizkenger52 well if you ask me actions speak louder than words, Barty did bring Voldemort back even dying in the end because of it.
@@immunity0792 exactly.
In my head Sirus sees himself becoming the secret keeper instead of suggesting Wormtail. He didnt know it back then but this is ultimately what led to the betrayal and the Potters death so i think this would be his deepest regret that he'd want to take back
I absolutely love this as camon
@@Osarah96 camon
Hed probably see James and Lupin with him laughing and having a joke. The mirror shows desires not regrets i think
@@abdirahmanidris290 The desire can also be to undo something you regret. In case you forgot what the definition of desire is.
@@eeurr1306 but wouldn't James being alive be symbolic of Sirius not changing the secret keeper. Sirius wanted James' company with Remus as well more than anything. He would have seen that and it would have also meant he didn't change the secret keeper
“Because he’s reminded of Fred every time he looks in a normal mirror”…damn…that one hit deep
I saw fan art where George was crying with a shattered mirror next to him. I almost cried.
Weird how your name is also spelled like weasly
@@randomperson7762 🤣
That one hit deeper than how deep the Mariana Trench is
@@daniyalhasan4346 ooof
Petunia was bitter about magic because not only was cut from it (since she's not a witch) but also because they took her sister. If i have to guess then she would've seen herself in the mirror as a witch with parents proud of her and discovering the wizarding world with her sister Lily.
I think Dobby would see all the house elves free and genuinely happy about their freedom. Aaaaand all the socks he can dream of.
DOBBY 😭 😭 😭 DOBBBY
“But we don’t speak of that garbage” made me just absolutely burst out laughing. Great video Morgan!!
Totally agreed. 😂
lmao The Cursed Child is like the Pjo movies of the HP fandom 😂
Yeah totally great
I actually really like the book
Same. The cursed child is absolutely horrible.
I think Ron’s desire would also change to just him, Hermione and their kids happy and safe.
And fred
Maybe Harry and Ginny’s family too, since those two are both siblings to him.
Don't forget his family. Ron would want them to be safe too
I'd say financially well off, but Ginny, having married Harry, who'd inherited a small fortune of Wizard Currency from his parents - Added to after Sirius' death, and the Triwizard winnings; Had he not given Fred & George to fund Weasley's Wizard Wheezes - that desire of Ron's was fulfilled
Did you know Ron's boggart is Hermione in pain 🥺
I don't think moody will see himself all beautiful. I can't imagine moody wanting is so badly.
I feel like he will see all dark wizard dead at his feet.
I think that too...
I didn't take it as Moody wanting to be beautiful so much as undamaged. Being whole and strong and that much more able to fight dark wizards.
Correction.he would see specifically voldermort dead
The books said that moody never killed if possible.
Not dead, locked up in azkaban with fully loyal dementors.
In my head, Harry's mirror-vision would change once he got married and had kids. I think he would see his immideate family (including Teddy) with Teddy's parents stading behind his godson, James and Lily behind himself, and Sirius next to James (I feel that he would've liked to see James and Sirius interact). The Weasleys (including Fred) might've been there too. When he was younger, he wasn't sure what family looked like, so he went with only biological, but as he got older, and created a new, mismatched family, he would've seen that one whole and complete.
This is so wholesome
Yes 100%
After his marriage and progeny it's safe to say harry potter is the happiest man on earth and there for see only his reflection.
Rowling confirmed once in an interview that Hermione would see the Golden Trio safe and Lord Voldemort’s defeated.
She also mentioned that Hermione would probably see herself “entwined” with Ron in a close embrace.
Kind of depends what time of their life was. If Harry looked in the mirror in Deathly Hallows, he would see Voldemort defeated and his friends and family all alive and well. And after, he would go back to seeing his family, but along with Ginny and their children all happy
That’s what he said in the Vid..
he said that?
3:00
wee wee
I really didn't think Cedric Diggory disliked Harry, although he did want to shed some glory on Hufflepuff. Personally, I think that Cedric would just want to get married to Cho Chang, then live a happy life with her.
But Hedric🥺
@@90music12 we’re going by cannon
@@abi.gail.b lol sorry I was tryna be funny😹
@@90music12 lol it’s okay
The video doesn't state he dislikes Harry though.
One day while cleaning up Hogwarts after the battle, George found a mirror. It was a beautiful mirror. Gold and glistening. When he looked in it he saw himself. Himself, happy, and energetic, and laughing at something. It made him feel good looking at it. But then his stomach dropped and he felt ill. He didn’t know why. Then he realized. His reflection, had two ears…
Edit: How the hell do I have like 80 likes! It been like 7 hours! ☺️
Edit 2: 300 likes!!!! How this probably the most likes I’ve EVER gotten! Tysm!!
Nah bro you just here to make us cry 😭
Thats well written and heartbreaking
What about his twin brother?
I imagine if George Weasley looked into the Mirror of Erised he would see his twin brother Fred standing right beside him and George would have both of his ears intact.
@@Idontwantahandle090 George's reflection had TWO EARS!!!! George only had ONE EAR!!! George isn't seeing himself in the Mirror of Erised, he's seeing...... u know who. 😭😭😭
I agree Petunia would visualize herself at Hogwarts. But I think another possibility is she would see Lily alive again, friends, and most importantly, with her son (Harry) so that Petunia wouldn't have felt like she wasted her life being burdened by him.
one of the reasons draco hated being a death eater is because Voldemort would threaten draco with his family when he wouldn't do something. I think he would see himself without the dark mark, and his loved ones safe and sound.
The way you transitioned between characters always felt like there was a natural connection, and the way you bridged all the ideas together for each character was really nice. It's nice to see your experience from the books v movies series led to a a lot of really small details fitting together for some great theory, thanks for what you do
I think that Hellena would actually see herself having a better relationship with her mother and therefore never stole the diadem, running away, or being murdered. I think never telling Tom where to find it is only surface level.
Yess!if she never stole the diadem Tom wouldn't asked her
She would have seen herself never becoming a ghost.
One thing I'd like to add about Petunia, I think the main reason she wanted to go to Hogwarts was to have more quality time with her sister, so I think that if she looks into the mirror, she'll see herself and Lily making amends, and growing happy with each other's families.
i disagree with what i have understood of her character she is clearly jealous that her younger sister is able to do things she can't do she desperately want be like her even be better than her but she can't, that puts her in an inferiority complex
AND maybe she feels like she is getting less attention from her parents as they are very proud about lily being a sorceress maybe she felt like she was being neglected that might be the cause of her jealousy
I've actually imagined that Petunia would one day be reconciled with Lily but Lily died early.
Well, Aunt Petunia's desires also must have changed.....Maybe initially she was pretty jealous of Lily's ability and also because their parents were happy to have a witch in the family....But later in life (very late actually) she must have wanted to reconcile with her and her stance against her sister must have softened (I say this in reference to the last book Deathly Hallows where she was bidding farewell to Harry while leaving Privit Drive, she just stood there looking at him in silence for few minutes and then left)
For hadgrid I think he would see himself not getting expelled and becoming a great wizard who stood bye a alive Dumbledore and helped protect and teach at Hogwarts
Petunia Dursley was actually a very understanding person, not a very good person most of the time, but understanding. She really knew her son, as shown in chapter 3 of The Deathly Hallows, when Dudley said “I don’t think you’re a waste of space.” And she burst into tears and praised him for basically saying “Thank you.”
I think before Lily's death Snape would see Lily and him in a romantic relationship but in the deathly hallows, he would see Lily and him reconciled as friends and Lily with James and her son that Snape had grown to love. Her just being alive would have been enough
Yes thats it..He would have seen himself with Lily in the mirror while in his school days but as an adult he would see Lily alone or maybe with Harry happy and alive. (No way he would see James, not because he was Lily's husband but he was his abuser- a victim would not see his abuser on the mirror of erised) Furthermore He has accepted her as Lily Potter as we can see in deathly hallows as he calls her as "Lily Potter" not "Lily Evans" in the final confrontation with Dumbledore.
Nah that man was obsessed he would still see himself with her
@@akhilanair4472 Look, he was concieteted, mean and arrogant but James grew out of it eventually and at 17 which is major even by our social thoughts. And I remember being a teenager and being a douchebag too. Snape stayed that way and stayed petty towards his son who had absolutely no involvement ever with Snape up till that point. Snape's new desires I agree with. James being an abuser I wouldn't.
@@Osarah96 James Potter was a bully and an abuser. Him growing up and realizing he hurt people in no way means that Snape has to forgive him, especially when he has what Snape wants most - Lily's love and affection. There's no way Snape would see his childhood bully, who indirectly caused him to lose the love of his life and who he blamed for Lily hating him, in the mirror showing his greatest desire.
Yes, this is facts because he changed when he was 40-60 into a better person, I mean, when he was dead
I‘d be very interested to know what each Harry Potter character‘s boggart is and how he‘s defeated.
?528
????318
Harry potter
his boggart was voldemort until the third year when he met dementors so even if voldemort is defeted dementors are still there so that will still be his boggart
watch harry potter 3-5
I love replies to this comment because they don’t seem to understand what this guy meant
@@savary5050 hehe :)
Ever thought of doing Harry Potter What If videos, Morgan? What if Voldemort went after Neville instead of Harry, What if Hagrid wasn’t expelled, What If Snape was Harry’s Father, so on and so forth. Not exactly an original idea, but could be fun.
this idea is actually pretty interesting I'd love to see videos on it
@YEBETTA c'mon man it's not that easy to put everything in a book in the movies
And it wasn't that bad
I grew up watching those
Then started reading
We have fan fiction for that.
@@aekkawinwisitkiatchai7640 very true, Very true
@@pranavp7502 I also grow up watching the movies before reading the books, and I still realize the movies are garbage hahahah 😅
But some parts are cool, I will give them that. And most of the cast will forever be how I see the characters
I think that 'Nearly headless Nick' would see himself as headless, so that he could join the headless hunt that he so very much desired to do.
19:39 I personally don’t think Mad-eye would want to lose the magic eye, I think he enjoys the fact that he can see more than an average person
I think he likes the eye
Maybe instead of a magic eye he would see himself in magic (sun glass like ) glasses 😎
I think that Charlie Weasley would also see the dragon he loves the most too... And maybe even has own set of dragons🐲...
dragon caring was just a passion of charlie that he got persue but to hagrid its was an obssession that could never be fulfilled
I think Arthur weasley would see the function of a rubber duck
i do also think Petunia may have seen herself reconciled with lily in the mirror, as an adult after lily's death
"You didn't just lose a mother that night in Godric's Hollow, you know. I lost a sister" i think deep down she felt incredibly guilty about what happened with her relationship with lily, how her jealousy ruined their relationship and regretted not reconciling before lily died
Which is also why she continued to protect harry after vernon wanted to throw him out, she knew how important it was to keep him safe, for both harry and for lily's memory
Or as a witch with magic. Voldemort would see him self as immortal and all-powerful God.
She would have seen both.
I don't think Bill would have just seen himself without his scars. He was never one to care about what people thought about his looks and chose to look very rebellious which had probably always made him stand out already so I don't think he'd care that much
Getting hurt didn't change anything, if anything it was him getting those scars that finally made his family, especially Molly accept Fleur who still loved him regardless and even saying "All these scars show is that my husband is brave" so I Really don't think his deepest wish and desires would be to erase all that
it doesn't fit with the down to earth person he is and always was
That is true and is a valid theory but it should also be said that the scars on his face was from a vicious attack. That can be very traumatic by itself and if any oblivious person could tell what they were from, a werewolf, then it could lead to stigmatization especially since he does have some wolfish traits even if they aren't outright dangerous.
I agree. I think Bill was perfectly happy at Shell Cottage. I think what he would see in the mirror is Voldemort vanquished, so that Fleur could live her perfect life, able to leave the house and see her own family regularly. Bill and Fleur seem like the kind of couple where their greatest desire is the other's happiness.
And this comment string is what it looks like to have a different opinion then some other random person on the internet, and to explain it calmly and respectfully. Some of y’all need to take notes 😭
@@swordquillinc.5335 The Weasley's are already outcasts to the eyes of of the Pure Blood supremacy part of the Wizarding World, due to them having no issues with half bloods or Muggleborns or Muggles. I don't think Bill being scratched by Greyback is going to make much difference to him, and it certainly doesn't to his family or his wife. He only eats his steaks rare than medium rare not that much of big deal.
I TOTALLY believe nearly headless Nick would see himself with his head fully severed!
Nah, if Vernon looked at himself in the Mirror, he'd just yell, "WHAT IN THE BLAZES AM I LOOKING AT?"
I could totally see most of these. I think that for Lupin he would see himself without lycanthropy and with James Lily and Sirius because they meant the most to him and when he lost them his world turned worse than terrible
I am always amazed at Rowling's skill as a writer. The ability to flesh out 70 characters. How and hell did she learn to do that and how can I? We all got dreams.
Yeah. As crappy of a person as she is, damn she can write.
@@zerophantomyt433 I couldn't say one way or the other. I don't know her. I never met her.
@@LambentLark based on what I know about her shes a crappy person but still a good writer.
@@zerophantomyt433 if you are referring to her comment on “people who have periods”, then NO, she is not a crappy person. You are. For confusing “feelings” with facts.
@@louisevanaken1282 no I'm talking about the transphobia.
I feel so sorry for Cedric because, like you mentioned, he got almost no attention as the Hogwarts champion in the Triwizard Tournament outside of Hogwarts because of Harry, and then not only should he have probably won the tournament if it weren't for Barty Crouch Jr., he also ended up dying in the graveyard with no chance of escaping unlike Harry.
I love this perspective. May I suggest, can you also do "What character's boggarts are" which were character's greatest fears.
Voldemort his own dead body.
Harry : dementor
Hermione: McGonagall saying she has failed in every subject
Ron: Spider
Neville: Prof Snape
Draco: Voldemort
Voldemort: his own dead body
Snape: Lily's dead body
Molly: her family's and Harry's dead bodies
Lupin: full moon
Sirius: himself locked up in a prison
George: Fred's dead body
Cornelius Fudge: Voldemort rising to power again while he's the Minister
Luna: her mother dying
Lucius: Voldemort killing his family
Narcissa: Draco's dead body
Moaning Myrtle: Basilisk eyes
Amos Diggory: Cedric's dead body
Newt Scamander: all the magical creatures are dying because of people
Leta Lestrange: her brother being drowned
Jacob Kwaloski: His ordinary life without any encounters with magical people
@@diehard8615 But we did see Newt's boggart, working at an office
@@edschelchang6123 Yeah I think I forgot that thanks btw 🤗
I can’t get over how talented and hard working he is 🥰
4:14
I think after the Cursed Child Draco would’ve seen himself with his son and his (dead) wife Astoria Greengrass because she died early due to an old family condition, I’ve heard that Draco really loved and misses her so that’s my theory.
26:19 Amos Diggory: That’s my son! That’s my boy! MY BOY!
“But something was always missing in Luna’s life”
Sanity?
“And that was a mother”
That too
motherless behavior
I feel like another bonus one should be Nearly Headless Nick. He would see himself finally joining the headless hunt
I'd add Crookshanks and Mrs Norris. Crookshanks would see Scabbers on a dinner plate, and Mrs Norris would probably see herself as a magical cat, instead of a regular cat.
7:37-7:46 Okay…. Wow. Just wow. That right there hurt!!! I felt that!!! About a year ago, I made a tweet saying that the sad thing about Fred and George using the aging potion to enter their names of the goblet of fire was that was their only time they would see each other growing old together but I think you just knocked my tweet right of the park!
Oh God, Movie Flames, my heart didn't need to heart that thing about George watching himself in any mirror. 😭
literally made me tear up
Voldemort sees his nose
I think it would’ve been most effective to say that Neville would’ve seen basically the same image Harry did in the movies. Him standing there with his parents
Maybe do a video on every spell in Harry Potter.
Yes
I second this
Or every character’s boggart
Yes. That’s a very good idea!
Yass we need this
You should’ve done Credence. He probably would see himself with his real family as a strong wizard. And happy
oh yea
And nearly headless nick having his head completely cut off to join the headless hunt.
I think Pettigrew, would see himself back again with his childhood friends. I think that maybe, in his heart he wanted them back, and felt deep regret for what he did. I think that kid Tom Marvolo Riddle, would see himself with his parents, would see himself loved, even that he can't feel love, he needed someone to love him at this age. Spot on with the desire of Bellatrix. I just want to say- Bellatrix was a fake person. Because she cast out her own sister Andromeda, for marrying a Muggle-Born. And there she goes, falling in love with a Half-Blood, and by the Cursed Child garbage, giving him a child. Bellatrix wouldn't be the only one, to be mad if she hears what you said. I can hear Dolohov from his grave- Am I a joke to you Muggle? I think about Andromeda. If she would look in the mirror, prior to the deaths of her husband and daughter, she would see herself with her sisters and parents, because she loved them very much, and she wanted to enjoy both of the worlds.
the fact you called voldie that kid is funny as hell
@@king1491 This is what I felt, when I read about his past. I am not a father yet, but when I said that, I tried to think from a parent point of view. That's why I said what I said.
Voldemort couldn't love. Hed probably see himself as completely in control of the magical world
@@abdirahmanidris290 I know he couldn't love. I meant that he probably imagined as a kid what is the thing he can't feel and how he would have wanted to have it. Just a theory.
@@eranshachar9954 it is a decent theory. Depends how you understand voldemort
If petunia looked into the mirror as an adult she would see lily alive and well
We actually do see what Dumbledore sees in the mirror during philosophers stone
He wants a new pair of socks
"Cornelius was an idiot..."
very well said
People I might add:
Amelia Bones
Susan Bones
Hannah Abbot
Padma Patil
Garlic Ollivandar
Antioch Ollivandar (ran the Hogsmeade Ollivandar's)
Tiberius Ogden
Greshelda Marchbanks
Marlene Mckinnon
this content really is amazing, all the books and movies explained, and many more- well done morgan!
The Mirror of Erised of desires and boggart of fear r polar opposites. MovieFlame made a vid on unicorns and thestrals r yin-and yang to each other.
Still waiting on "The Life of Oliver Wood".
"It's my boy", still makes me cry😢
i read a theory somewhere stating that in the mirror of erised, draco saw himself happily playing with ron, harry, and hermione.
I think Petunia would also see Lilly going with her to Hogwarts and still beeing alive as well.
I also think she would see Harry and Dudley playing together like brothers.
@@normansmith9110
This is possible if it wasn't for her jealousy and envy for a child who has nothing to do with his mother being special and pretty
My headcannon for George would be that as an old man, he's wise but still showing his sense of humor and creativity time to time still heartbroken over Fred's Death, because I read something Iroh from Avatar said: ("How did you get over the death of your son?") "I didn't.". I could see an aging George be like that :)
I love you
@@IsraelLlerena oi thanks
Out of the 70 the only one I disagree with was Jacob. I think he wouldn't change who he is but rather him being able to have a relationship with Queenie and society accepting it. That's why his character is so awesome, he isn't jealous of Newt (or any of them) but wowed by it.
Sirius black in the mirror makes so much sense since Sirius loves James so much as a best friend and it's heartbreaking that he founded out how James died.
this was a fantastic video Morgan you're an amazing content creator
All the Characters (Credit's to CameronQX for finishing after 31)
1. Harry Potter 2:30
2. Hermoine Granger 2:58
3. Ron Weasley 3:32
4. Ginny Weasley 3:55
5. Draco Malfoy 4:14
6. Neville Longbottom 4:40
7. Luna Lovegood 5:01
8. Sirius Black 5:21
9. Dumbledore 5:58
10. Severus Snape 6:38
11. Fred Weasley 6:59
12. George Weasley 7:23
13. Percy Weasley 7:53
14. Molly Weasley 8:12
15. Arthur Weasley 8:48
16. Charlie Weasley 9:10
17. Bill Weasley 9:18
18. Rubeus Hagrid 9:42
19. Peter Pettigrew 9:57
20. Fleur Delacour 10:19
21. Minerva McGonagall 10:57
22. Tom Riddle/ Voldemort 11:27
23. Bellatrix Lestrange 11:51
24. Remus Lupin 12:17
25. Nymphadora Tonks 12:42
26. Cho Chang 13:07
27. Dudley Dursley 14:00
28. Vernon Dursley 14:24
29. Petunia Dursley 14:38
30.Newt Scamander 15:19
31. Oliver Wood 15:47
32. Gellert Grindlewald 16:02
33. Gilderoy Lockhart 16:44
34. Leta Lestrange 17:00
35. Lucius Malfoy 17:23
36. Narcissa Malfoy 18:00
37. Lily Potter 18:14
38. James Potter 18:35
39. Alastor (Mad-Eye) Moody 19:05
40. Mundungus Fletcher 19:51
41. Tina Goldstein 20:03
42. Kingsly Shacklebolt 20:25
43. Argus Flich 20:44
44. Dolores Umbridge 21:02
45. Jacob Kowalski 21:49
46. Lavender Brown 22:25
47. Parvati Patil 22:47
48. Sybil Trelawney 23:00
49. Winky 23:26
50. Kreacher 24:18
51. Barty Crouch Sr. 24:51
52. Barty Crouch Jr. 25:15
53. Cedric Diggory 25:33
54. Amos Diggory 26:00
55. Queenie Goldstein 26:35
56. Rita Skeeter 27:13
57. Dean Thomas 27:25
58. Seamus Finnigan 27:58
59. Horace Slughorn 28:29
60. Viktor Krum 28:51
61. Andromeda Tonks 29:25
62. Olympe Maxime 29:48
63. Fenrir Greyback 30:08
64. Cornelius Fudge 30:30
65. Quirinus Quirrell 30:55
66. Filius Flitwick 31:29
67. Dobby 32:00
68. Bloody Baron 32:38
69. Helena Ravenclaw (Gray Lady) 33:25
70. Teddy Lupin 34:01
Thank you so much :)
27,28,29 would see nothing in the mirror because they are muggles
@@peterang6912 Technically, yes. But if they could that's what they would have seen.
31. Oliver Wood 15:47
32. Gellert Grindlewald 16:02
33. Gilderoy Lockhart 16:44
34. Leta Lestrange 17:00
35. Lucius Malfoy 17:23
36. Narcissa Malfoy 18:00
37. Lily Potter 18:14
38. James Potter 18:35
39. Alastor (Mad-Eye) Moody 19:05
40. Mundungus Fletcher 19:51
41. Tina Goldstein 20:03
42. Kingsly Shacklebolt 20:25
43. Argus Flich 20:44
44. Dolores Umbridge 21:02
45. Jacob Kowalski 21:49
46. Lavender Brown 22:25
47. Parvati Patil 22:47
48. Sybil Trelawney 23:00
49. Winky 23:26
50. Kreacher 24:18
51. Barty Crouch Sr. 24:51
52. Barty Crouch Jr. 25:15
53. Cedric Diggory 25:33
54. Amos Diggory 26:00
55. Queenie Goldstein 26:35
56. Rita Skeeter 27:13
57. Dean Thomas 27:25
58. Seamus Finnigan 27:58
59. Horace Slughorn 28:29
60. Viktor Krum 28:51
61. Andromeda Tonks 29:25
62. Olympe Maxime 29:48
63. Fenrir Greyback 30:08
64. Cornelius Fudge 30:30
65. Quirinus Quirrell 30:55
66. Filius Flitwick 31:29
67. Dobby 32:00
68. Bloody Baron 32:38
69. Helena Ravenclaw (Gray Lady) 33:25
70. Teddy Lupin 34:01
Finished it for you. Edit it on the og message if you want lol.
@@CameronQX you're amazing thank you I will do that and give you credit!!
I love how the deepest desires of most of the characters desires were about friends and family; this just shows how import people are even in fiction ❤️
I really love how he puts all his heart in a video
When he speaks it seems like he is generally enjoying talking about it
Just like we are having a conversation with him
Not to mention his voice is very soothing
I saw this in a comment section somewhere it went:
“George Weasley was helping at hogwarts when he found a beautiful gold glistening great wide mirror and he had previously talked with Harry so he figured out this was the mirror Harry was talking of, The Mirror Of Erised.
And he wanted to see what his desire was so he looked in the mirror and saw himself with two ears, and he thought to himself “seriously this is my desire? My ear back?” Then he realized he was looking at his twin and broke down into tears”
So beautifully written.
and I saw another comment on this video very similar that was also just as beautifully written
About petunia I strongly believe that her desire to go to hogwarts was before Lily’s death. After that I think her deepest desire would have been to see her alive again and reconcile with her despite her jealousy ( the deleted scene for deathly hallows part 1 shows this better than it could ever be described)
I can just imagine young Voldemort wishing to be immortal and look like a total freak without a nose
“Yeah this is what I want”
Before I even start watching the video, let me say this: we truly appreciate your efforts. Your theories and hp analysis are very good. ❤️
I Second that emotion!
am i the only one who likes slughorn a lot. even if he was the one who helped voldemort understand the horcruxes better. i really liked his character. he was relatable and really kind. i want a teacher like him😭
Ravenclaw gang here 👇
Here!
HERE👹💙
Yea
Here
Mmmeeee
I actually believe that Grindelwald would see himself ruling the world but together with Dumbledore. They loved each other very much and I think that Grindelwald‘s heart desires both: The man he loves and the world he wants to have.
True
I really enjoyed this video, and loved the ideas you had for the characters! I can really see them being real, great video man!
But, I have an idea for video that could be similar to this, what would the characters see if they drank the potion on the island in the cave? So, what would be some of their deepest fears they’d see?
Oooh that would be interesting. It might also be a bit sad for some characters like the Weasleys.
26:19
This brought tears to my eyes 😢
I think Sirius would have desired him and Regulus to get along again in the Marauders timeline.
This video is amazing! They should make a book/movie about Teddy Lupin since he is the “second Harry”.
I think if Snape looks in the mirror he will not see himself and Lily in a romantic relationship but just Lily alive and happy because his love for her is so strong
@@tomriddler1926 he made it his life goal to protect Harry, Lily's only living family
@@tomriddler1926 nah. He was in love with Lily so hed probably see him and her married
Love Morgan casually saying how much he knows before being so knowledgeable as always. Never change man 😎
Simply having SEVENTY characters that are portrayed deep enough to make theories on, is yet another proof of how amazing the HP series really is.
Think about LotR, which gained success at around the same time (and I'm a fan btw, so no disrespect). But would you be able to make a video about 70 characters, as detailed as this one?
Earned my sub.
I love both fandoms too but I wouldn't compare them in that way🙈
Boi u haven't seen enough lotr media
So basically the cursed child is just belatrix’ fan fic
When you think about it, the mirror of Erised is the most busted object of the series, that could break literally any plot.
Harry saw his parents in the movie / saw in his ancestors in the book. But, in real life, he never saw them, not a picture, nothing... So, the mirror understood the desire of something Harry never felt/saw/have memories of and showed the reality and the concept of the desire to the exact details. This mirror is capable of projecting "truth" unknown to the user...
You could abuse the crap out of that... A confusion or memory spell on a person to change his deepest desire. And you can have instant visualization of a projection of what the person wants.
Let's create a few examples :
1. Confusion spell on Sirius Black to lower his regret of losing his friends and to augment his desire to find the location Peter Pettigrew... Mirror shows the location of Peter...
2. Confusion spell on Albus or Harry to know the location of the Horcruxes and it would show the locations of the Horcruxes....
3. Confusion spell on a victim of Death eaters to know who killed their family and boom, projection of the murderers... Let's do the ministry work the easy way...
I could go on and on and never stop.
If in our world I wonder if it could be used to figure out certain scientific things such as move at the speed of light, teleportation, best source of energy, etc
Part of the mirrors enchantment would probably be that it would show your true desires not temporary desires caused by a confusion potion
the mirror doesn't show you how to get the desire it just shows you what it is
I don't think it would work that way. It only shows the deepest desire of your heart. For example: I dont think it would ever show Sirius' desire to be Peter Pettigrew. It would show James and Lily Potter, beside him.
Same for everyone else. It would never show you how to cope with things that aren't making you happy (your parents being dead, voldemort existing, Pettigrews betrayal, etc). It would just show you at your happiest. And in that image, Voldemort wouldn't even exist, let alone be visible as someones deepest desire (maybe Bellatrixes desire, but Im not sure)
Anyways, thats how I would look at it.
Now I want the opposite. What would all the characters see if they saw a boggart. Instead of looking at what they desired they would look at what they feared.
As much as I admire you Morgan but I think you mostly see Ginny as Harry's love interest/his fangirl but she's so much more than that
She will see herself as the captain of the Holyhead harpies or even playing for England in the world
cup or see that the events of her first year never happened
After the war she'll obviously see her family as whole with Fred standing beside George and Remus and Tonks holding teddy
Her heart's desire,as you put it, was much much more than just Harry, if it was then they would have never gotten together.
Agreed 100%
What if Draco have loved a muggle and finally knowing what love was and losing it afterwards?
He end up like Snape
What an awesome video! Can you do one with the all the characters patronuses?
As always, well done Morgan. I enjoy coming back to your videos and seeing them again (and agajn) on a regular basis. Thank you.
Thanks for this video Morgan!! I would love some more PJO and HOO content maybe life of Nico Di Angelo?
Literally pressed as soon as I saw it! Another great video by you, Props to u Morgan!
Heyyy, you should be invited to this new show called Harry Potter: tournament of the houses (it’s a Harry Potter trivia show). You’d win it in a pinch
i have no doubt that he would but i think he and scb and other harry potter related youtubers should be invited as guest or even hosts as they're so knowledgable about the franchise
Keep up the good work dude love your videos I've been watching your videos for over 5 months 👍 😀 👌!!!!!!!!!!
0:13: Joke's on you, I had already figured that out.
Before the half blood Prince Ginny would obviously see her and Harry in a relationship with each other.
George: Fred alive
I read somewhere that George kept dying his hair after the war. When Molly asked him why he said that he kept looking in a mirror and seeing Fred, so he dyes his hair to not look so much like Fred
When Fred died that hit me the hardiest. I swear all the good characters die ex: Sirius Tonk’s lupin dumbledore FRED
Oh my that is so sad 😢 I could easily see that happening… honestly, Fred’s death was one of the most heartbreaking of the entire series since he and George were like two halves of a whole. It must’ve felt like such a lonely existence for George after Fred died. Ron went to take George’s place working with him in the joke shop but it wouldn’t have been quite the same.
@@cookiecookie3712 I agree, but don't forget Hedwig.
@elevator3: Interesting fact: The Phelps twins are not Redheads in real life, they are both brunettes and dyed it for the movies - they actually went to school with it dyed and shocked all their school friends that didn't believe they had been cast in the film. Losing a Twin would be agony, I always liked how they spoke in unison.
27:15 Ironicaly, one of the things I would see on Mirror of Erised would be myself reading a version of Harry Potter in which Rita Skeeter finishes the series discredited as a jornalist.
I think Harry after the end of the second war will desire that nobody died for him.
Do you agree guys?
Definitely, I thought so too
In fact, I am writing my own fanfic where abt 2 months after the war, harry goes to Room of Requirement and sees mirror of erised. As he looks in, he sees every good person, including his parents but with the exception of Snape, who died standing around him and then the name on the mirror disappears and he sees then all standing around him smiling