The Future of Modi’s India
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 кві 2024
- In a year in which half the world votes, India, the largest democracy, stands out. Ethnic tensions, nationalist rhetoric, and concerns about the influence of AI and other misinformation campaigns form a tense background for this spring's election. What is the historical context for such a contentious political climate? What does this year’s Indian election say about the future of global democracy? Featuring Shuja Nawaz, founding director of the South Asia Center at the Atlantic Council, Safiya Ghori-Ahmad, senior director with APCO Worldwide and Dr. Paul Staniland, Professor of Political Science at University of Chicago. Moderated by New York Times correspondent Emily Schmall. Co-sponsored by the Pearson Institute for the Study and Resolution of Global Conflicts.
😂😂 they brought two Muslims to two Christian to discuss
The man is from Pakistan, so their intentions are obvious
Well said
As expected...copious amounts of false propaganda!
All of Congress accounts were unfrozen within a day of 'freezing' them...all of it was merely procedural given how brazenly Congress violated all the rules/laws of the land. Even though Congress has access to all it's money (barring the few hours), every TDH in the WORLD keeps clamoring that Congress has NO ACCESS to its accounts.
Also, the Indian Muslims worrying about their Indian citizenship status is due to FALSE PROPAGANDA that their status will be affected. In reality there no such threat. A Hindu or a Muslim in Hyderabad (where Sofiya's aunt is) will have same opportunity/challenge. It's ridiculous to think that a Hindu in Hyderabad who has no documents will just say that he/she's a Sindhi/Bengali/Afghan Hindu from Pakistan/Bangladesh/Afghanistan. (even /w zero documents folks will be retain citizenship merely by having someone vouch for them....as simple as that!)
Not only muslim but from Pakistan.
😂😂
If your institute is non-partisan as you claim, I am Don Corleone!
This type discussion made me vote for bjp😂😂😂😂
Same here bro 😁😁😁😁😁
exactly
Two muslims and two christians to talk on future of Narendra Modi who is leader of Greatest Hindu nation. What a hypocricy 😂😂😂
Kaun sa great Hindu nation be Kam nahi hai Paisa nahi hai logo ke pass kya leke comment kar raha hai
@@geeksatish8010 aja mere dukan pe 15000 dunga monthly
Well said. 👌👌👌👌👌
These Anglo Saxon agents are real succors
Typical angling - Propaganda couched in sophistry - trying hard to harm the "India story" & BJP as party that 's leading India towards progress. But best part is people of India see through these "toolkit" games
That's what is propaganda is 😂😂
As a South Indian, I'll not be surprised this election BJP getting seats from South India as well.
Modi looks politics as a game and rose to ranks from Grassroots. He is sucessfully navigating the international geopolitics imo.
while rahul gandhi is threatening openly to burn the country if BJP wins....his allies are advocating destroying the Hindus, changing the demographics like the west so we do not rise...CIA & these "elite universities" & their think tanks want absolute power forever & they will topple governments, cause riots, bio warfares & what not to divide & rule the world.... they are scared because MODI is busting their bubble & people from the Global South are uniting once again...the SCAM of UN is being exposed & US $ hedgemony is getting destroyed thanks to these expert intellectuals & their policies.....
Typical angling - Propaganda couched in sophistry - trying hard to harm the "India story" & BJP as party that 's leading India towards progress. But best part is people of India see through these "toolkit" games
That's why US, UN criticized AK arrest by ED 😂😂
@@beinghuman852 Their job is to poke nose in internal matter.
Modi will win big this time
Two Muslims and two Christians discussing what? Really funny.😊😊😊
discussing hindu's future. LOL
😁😁😁😁😁
2 Pakistanis discussing about Indian Democracy and Pluralism.
This is like China, Russia talking about American Democracy.
By the way Shuja Nawaz brother was head of notorious ISI, dreaded, rouge intelligence agency of Pak.
Last line.. exactly that what I was looking for.. thank u for confirming it.
That makes sense, which also makes the intention of this panel questionable(a polite word)
One Pakistani and One Indian.
Shuja Nawaz comes from a military family in Pakistan. That's how he got his hands on internal Pakistani records and was able to paint a more clearer picture of how Pakistan's foreign policy worked.
YOU SAID IT!
Such a pathetic panel of outsiders with zero knowledge on India to talk about India.
They all hid their biases fairly well.
Pakistanis talking about democracy of India is like a lamp-post showing path to the Sun.
As someone from Eastern India PM Modi is winning it big by winning the trust of the largest most diverse democracy on the planet.
Bro he is talking pro India. Listen it.
We want Modi ji not only in 2024 but also in 2029. Modi ji has transformed India and under his leadership India will soon become the Third Largest Economy in the World.
No hindu in panel! ghosh
But there's a pakistani
Even some Hindus are fake who dont speak for hindu interests. but yeah this panel is pathetic
Enough to tell the story 😁😁😁😁😁@@sageofsixpaths98
But still some people listen these ****** people 🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼
about Dharavi, the largest slum, the state government had planned a huge development and rehousing project for the residents of the slum but then the government changed and the congress and allies came into power and the project stopped (because a major vote share comes from those slums). This is what democracy in India looks like and thats why we feel modi being there long term at the centre atleast will have a positive impact on the country.
Exactly! That bint almost said 'stench' before correcting herself with 'jarring'.
Also, she's portraying Dharavi slums as Modi's doing! Dharavi slum is the result of failed socialist policies of Congress govts.
90's japanese cartoons will give you more information than this so called intellectual discourse
One of the speaker says " BJP is a very powerful party". In a democracy, it's citizenry of a country which makes a party powerful. Indians are not fools. They can see the speed at which Indian landscape is changing. Why would they want the whole process to change and the country goes back to " chalta hey" kind of leadership.
Expert panel? Expert in what? none of them have political expertise in Indian political scenario
One of them was in New Delhi for a few years. What more expertise you expect from a New York Times reporter ? If all of them are on ISI rolls, what different can we expect.
Actually this kind of discussions pushes people like me more towards people they hate, because of their hypocrisy 😂😂😂😂😂
@55:00 Anand when did the Modi vilify the dignity of OBC ?!
Bro Modi himself is from OBC …..your question/statement doesn’t hold any substance!
might be congressi worker
Question for Ms Ahmed on CAA : Does your 80 year old grandmother not have a ration card, Aadhaar card or ANY piece of official paper in the 80years that she has lived in Hyderabad, India ? Does she NoT get any benefits from the state ? Why the drama of “where are we going to go “ ?
Taquiya. Her ancestors also took land in Pakistan.
tell me this is a comedy show and not an actual discussion
It's more of a sh!t show
@19:19 the moderator had the audacity to juxtapose Pakistan’s “election”(which obviously aren’t election rather selection where Pak Army selects the stooge who could do their bidding) with India’s ….this shows how much the host/moderator is versed with the definition of ‘deteriorating democracy .
‘
Westerners should stick to topics they understand, like the Kardashians
ROFLMAO. Stop dividing India. BJP is a powerful force in Karnataka and an emerging power in Telangana.
14:48 okay, at least there is some sanity.
Secondly ,the Government has planned a redevelopment project of Dharavi Slum.
18:55 Lol , can't expect logic from Pakistan. Why don't they talk about minorities in Pakistan. Minorities in India are happy and thriving but minorities in Pakistan are decimated.
Two former colonizers of India: Islam and the west are scratching each others' backs, as they both see their influence decline in India. Eagerly waiting for the west to become Muslim majority though, they deserve it.
Once M population reaches 51% in India, will the country remain secular?
Good discussion, yet it could have been better if you found someone supporting the Right wing, as even the questions asked by students paddle the left wing narrative.
these universities do not have any space other than their own...they are secular liberals dont forget
Lol, this is so propagandist in nature. None of the speakers have any idea what is happening on the ground.
Lol 🤣🤣🤣
I haven’t even clicked play , but I’m sure it’s all dribble…some bloody propaganda..
All muslims & Christians to discuss India 😂
future is bright in modi's india.
My vote goes to Modi.
55:00 that anand guy literally don't have any idea about obc it's the congress who want to do cast census not modi moreover modi himself is obc and rahul gandhi is barahim somhow😂
Not Only Brahmin but Jainau dahri Brahmin...😂😂
In about 20 years , we will talk about USA future...I have hedged against US since 2020 and already getting some gains....that definitely indicates....ppl are starting to believe this idea.
Islamo-facists and Christian colonism, targetting rise of Bharat,
Very interesting discussion. Few were knowledgeable who been on ground in India . but mostly it's a left-wing liberal stereotyped narratives on India.
Even the students questions were so left wing like the New York Times or Wapo who were focusing just on caste and minorities .
The government policies has not discriminated anyone by cast or religion to receive the government benefits . That is why a lot of them support Modi
All in all this discussion is like - 4 blind people, touching different parts of an elephant 🐘 , and telling that's the whole elephant 🐘 😂😂
As expected...copious amounts of false propaganda!
All of Congress accounts were unfrozen within a day of 'freezing' them...all of it was merely procedural given how brazenly Congress violated all the rules/laws of the land. Even though Congress has access to all it's money (barring the few hours), every TDH in the WORLD keeps clamoring that Congress has NO ACCESS to its accounts.
Also, the Indian Muslims worrying about their Indian citizenship status is due to FALSE PROPAGANDA that their status will be affected. In reality there no such threat. A Hindu or a Muslim in Hyderabad (where Sofiya's aunt is) will have same opportunity/challenge. It's ridiculous to think that a Hindu in Hyderabad who has no documents will just say that he/she's a Sindhi/Bengali/Afghan Hindu from Pakistan/Bangladesh/Afghanistan. (even /w zero documents folks will be retain citizenship merely by having someone vouch for them....as simple as that!)
This is full of fake shit. Only one sided view on the panel.
yes, no mention of electoral bonds is what made it very evident that this is propaganda
Looking at US and UK Indian democracy is in much better shape 😂
@23:56 the so called Pakistani intellect is crediting BJP’s massive Victory because they had borrowed/rephrased Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s Slogan (ironically Atal ji lost the elections for his 2nd term) so Atal ji himself couldn’t win with that slogan but Modi did ……😂😂😂😂 This is the level of “intellectual’” analysis in this Discourse
Ab ji baar 400 par ……#NaMo #2024 #BJP #victory #world’s #largest #democracy #liberaldemocracy
India would become centre of attraction in the world under Modi regime in another decade.
" BJP is a party that likes to win , to mobilize" - Now thats the biggest criticism of BJP coming from leftist ecosystem 😂😂
Anti Hindu people talking about India. This is like KFC talking about the welfare of chickens.
Abki baar 400 paar😂😂😂 jitna chahe jor lagalo
No country has an example where judges appoint judges. The new system brought to appoint judges was given in the constitution of India by its formers and it was passed unanimously across party lines in the parliament. But sadly strike down by judiciary by 1 vote.
Exactly what is discriminatory about CAA as written? Please don't leave the impression that it is inherently discriminatory.
Sure. Have similar rhetoric at every platform. But good for us that we have social media explaining ground realities.
Lady talking about nrc not caa
How dumb this conversation get, Citizenship Amendment Act was about Hindu's, SIkh's & Christian's who were India and escaped religious persecution in Afghanistan,Pakistan or Bangladesh
What is u pol idea about apni world wide
Who the hell r u to lecture on India's future? There are half billion educated middle class Indians to decide, and they want hindu Rashtra, and of course Modi.
India is big israel with per capita only 30000 dollar remember when it's become 10 thousand youare in trouble only last hindu country in world remaining
This is one of the dumbest panel discussions. They are simply taking the Indian opposition parties' talking points. It is getting boring now. I'd like you to have deeper and better discussions.
Also, you couldn't find 1 Hindu panelist. Come on guys. You found a Muslim from Pak and an Indian origin Muslim and 2 white Americans(presumably either Christian/atheist liberals). Just for the sake of tokenism, you could have invited 1 Hindu panelist who is sympathetic to the BJP and the non-left in India!
All companies will invest in india like they are doing in America.😂 So don't worry.
Bangladesh per capita and india per capita is almost same . India population is more than Bangladesh almost 5 times
They are up to good, uniting India 🎉
Typical angling - Propaganda couched in sophistry - trying hard to harm the "India story" & BJP as party that 's leading India towards progress. But best part is people of India see through these "toolkit" games
Blind men confined since birth in dark room explaining colors and layout of kaleidoscope
Abki baar 400 Paar.
55:15 A question on Hindu diaspora’s overwhelming support for Modi. The organizers carefully fixed the panel but forgot to disclose it to the audience.
The lady's view on CAA convinced me that she do not understand CAA
How much these people earn by berating India and Hindus
A lot! There's a ton of money flowing into the far-Left groupies
Not even bought indian muslim bought Pakistan muslim how come pakistanis know about indian elction and public😂😂😂🎉
Yes, India has many challenges, but nothing will change unless the economy grows to a point where many of the social challenges can be effectively handled. That is the focus of the Modi Govt while still taking care of the actual real poor. This overarching view is missing.
44:30 LOL What lies. Everyone knows there were no birth certs in India even 50 years ago, let alone 80 years ago.
who is the "civil society" here saying democracy is declining...the ones who are voting Modi/BJP to power....
First of all there is nothing like Modi’s India. Modi is the least interfering PM. He has allowed India to blossom. Obviously those who have not India agenda will have a problem with India progress .
funny video. It's like asking Cuba how the US democracy is doing 🤣
Shuja Nawaz's perceptions of India are 10 years in the past. He is still talking of the India he is familiar with from circa 2010. Staniland is quite perceptive....
If a country with 80% Hindu population is not already a Hindu state, would these so-called professors care to tell us what is?
What is there to fear from a Hindu state whose fundamental principles are grounded in the oneness of not just humankind but of all of creation that resulted from the BIG BANG.
"What we shall find in Modern Physics is an exemplification, an encouragement and a refinement of old Hindu wisdom."
Julius R Oppenheimer in The Tao of Physics by Fritjof Capra
Simple statements like "Modi Govt froze the bank accounts of the Congress" without any context i.e. that Congress did not pay their taxes for several years, I think is irresponsible. Give the whole truth if you have to say something.
Unless one is Hindu it is not possible to understand India and its psycology. Anyhow fairly fair assessment on india.
These types of channel actually help us why to vote Modi ji 😂🤣😂🤣😂
Red Chili to muslims and christians for only My god people 😃😃😃
The Pakistani guy lives in alternate reality... Pakistan is where it is now because they have these kinds of people inside and outside their country...
New motto. Nice Luck Uncle Sam.
Indians MUST make note of a name dropped by Shuja, AF Chief Arun Prakash.
andhbhakts in the comments are just looking what religion the speaker belongs, instead of listening to what they are saying....
UofC just proved that it is a just a big f*cking joke.😂😂😂
More reasons why we should elect Modi again 😀
I would just say it's one sided bullsit nothing else
Maharashtra has the highest GDP and will be a trillion dollar economy very soon. Because the ingredients and recipes in place. Is it South Indian or North Indian state?
MODI 2024 🚩 💪
Dear Indian students at Chicago school: do you know what you are doing to your matrubhumi? You are selecting two Muslims from Pakistani to discuss democracy, does it make any sense? And you have selected a NYTimes person to moderate the discussion, the most biased person and organization against India. What are guys thinking? Haven’t you got any political sense and you going to a political school? You guys have to grow up and the USA is not a place to learn. I being an Indian, sorry to say, 20:28 Better go back home and get rid of your colonial mindset. You should have at least selected a BJP person to defend all this nonsense. 🙏
Please be careful next time.
Education even in the south is significantly inmprivate hands
Due to technological advancement, most people across globe can understand what is propaganda and what is reality faced by majority of citizens.
None other than Indians can understand what the truth is and what democracy means to them. We just listen to all these discussions and laugh a lot 😂 people can ignore or can be agitated ...but the world will go on by its virtue without anyone's opinion or perception
About 20%of muslims are estimated to be voting modi
Modi’s India will keep its head down and focus on doubling its GDP to $7-8 trillion in the next 10 years. The West can keep talking, forecasting and dissecting Indian democracy till the cows come home. It is their prerogative. Close to 80% of the World is non-Western and therefore the inability to see the world through a non-Western lens is worrying to say the least.
#bjpforkerala
Great Discourse ….its just that it’s devoid of any intellectual substance….they just did the “headline” hunting… that is to take cursory view of complex diverse vast Indian society and very poorly tried to coerce into their template view of “Modi’s India”
Modi ji be like- Inn logo ko kya takleef hai bhai 😁😁😁😁😁
Modi modi modi modi modi.....
Indian sub-continent, not South Asia.
A lot of recent successes of india's foreign policy is because if jaishankar,'s understanding of isdues and modi's courage.No indian muslim will be thrown out.Laws are only intended tk be uded ti identifyBillegal entrants
Why these people are putting their legs in India's affairs ❓❓❓❓❓ what if India starts doing this... 😁😁😁😁😁
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
When westerners try and understand India with their simplistic world view of the left vs the right
I will vote to Modi only 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
she has no idea about CAA!! CAA expedite citizenship of non-muslims migrants who are already in India, who fled their Islamic state homeland of Pak, Afg, Bangladesh due to persecution...it has a whole history of partition............
#bjpfortamilnadu
Why would any botivcal party demobilse
Pakistanis, Muslims, christians ; great panelists and so called hypocritical biased International realtion talk. 😂😂
These types of talks make me firm to vote for BJP led by Modi ji.
No Hindu in the panel but two Christian and 2 Muslim talking about India and its future 🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼🤦🏼, what a remarkable comedy 😁😁😁😁😁