Is Democracy Good Or Bad? - Nas Debates #3
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 тра 2022
- Democracy as a form of governance has been here for a long long time!
Is it broken?
Can we improve it?
Or do we need a whole new system?
Let’s see what Nuseir and Alex have to say!
Subscribe to the official UA-cam page of Nas Debates here - bit.ly/38Z2kVr
Hope you enjoyed this episode. We've launched a whole new UA-cam page just to release more debate content like this one. You can subscribe and stay updated here - bit.ly/38Z2kVr
1
Alright, nice
Yoo 4th 👏👏
Thank you! I really enjoyed this video, Keep up the work!! ✨
technically democracy is about the will of the majority has the right to override the existing rights and have laws are made by the majority. And what your talking about is a mixed of republican, democrats and a bit of liberals views. So this agreement is very much irrelevant as everyone have mixed views of different political ideology if you dig deeper of what those things truly means you might understand why some are the way they are. It's not the leader or the government, its more of your will, your emotions, your lies, your deception, your ideals and all those human consciences are the very thing that makes it bad. Its not about what laws, leaders or governing system that we want, its more about a combined governing system like the roman empire used to have, a mixed of democrats, monarchists, aristocracy, socialist , communist, and all that you know
This debate was crazy! Waiting for more action packed debates!
Oh aap bhi yaha😊
You Here!!!!!! 👍
Blessed to have you here
@Jahnab Dewri man I literally just commented the same thing..
*TELEPATHY*
Aagya spammer.apne dead channel ko active kaarane
"Democracy works, only when the population is sufficiently educated." 👌👌👍👍
But not based on degree
if the only 2000 smart people in my country its probaly gonna be corrupt af
but what does sufficiently educated mean and how will we know when the population is sufficiently educated
@@q8692 when they stop making decisions that are detrimental to the interests of the whole.
@@witnesstochange1801 but that’s subjective
The main issue in democracy, is : we need something to control the government to avoid abusive systems. It could be fixed.
There is something to control the government. In most modern democracies, there is a parliament that the government must be accountable to
@@flighttex3574 you must be living under a rock if you think the parliament themselves are not relatively corrupt,no one can win either ways
Wow, I enjoyed this debate a lot. I can't think how 20 minutes have gone. I learned many things from a different view in this debate. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I am also from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩😊
Dhaka also
These debates are very informative. Hope to see more👍
Thank you for watching :D Glad you enjoyed it :D
@@NasDaily I've one question for nusier that who gonna decide who are the smartest people of a country? How we gonna decide this? Then obviously the people in power will only think about themselves and we all know power's corrupt minds. Then what about 98% population what they will do? i also agree that democracy has so many flaws but still it's the best form of government out of all.
@@samriddha_Sahaaaaaa we all know it's the best rn but it's not perfect and if we don't even try to think of a better government,we probably will never have one.
@@samriddha_Sahaaaaaa True!
@@NasDaily hi
Actually I think that Nas was actually being pretty vague.
First of all in my opinion it's important to specify if you're speaking for a particular form of government (like the two you mentioned) or you're speaking about a supposed 'better' form of government, which probably doesn't exist yet. The advantage of democracy is that we've already implemented the system worldwide and we know the issues and drawbacks that it offers. This provides us with an opportunity to improve the idea of Democracy itself, thereby it being a form of self improving government. Also, different regions and countries around the world adopted democracy differently, according to their own needs. Therefore it is illogical to expect the same results from everywhere. Those supposed form of governments probably haven't been tested out yet, or have been tested on only small scales.
Secondly, about the issues in contries like Bangladesh, there are way too many factors to contribute to the poor development than democracy. Do Bangladesh and Sweden have the same population? Do they share the same kind of past history? Do they have the same kind of relationships with their neighbouring countries? Are the religious ethnicity of the indigenous population the same? There are way too many variables being ignored by Nas. Again, there are many flaws in the arguments from both sides in my opinion, and the debate could've been better.
Thirdly, what is the proof that the supposed 'smart' people who'll run the top positions in an ideal form of government, would not become arrogant because of their achievements and use the power for their personal gain? How can just smartness be a criteria for selecting people? Even if you were to conduct some examinations, how can we really ensure that some contestants wouldn't pass off by unfair means? What is the proof that the influencial would not use their power to directly fuse themselves with the government? How is this any better from democracy?
In the end, Nas I would like to comment on your argument regarding Hitler. It was not democracy that made Hitler a dictator. It was the building of a poor constitution by the German( refer of Article 14 of German Constitution back then). It was the misuse of the Constitutional power that brought him power to disregard democracy and act as an independent power. This itself goes to show how delicate the entire framework of democracy is.
Don't misunderstand me, I'm no way in favour of democracy. In fact I believe that a better system than democracy must exist out there. In fact, no system is perfect, we'll continue to find different systems with different advantages, and democracy is very flawed.
However, I was unsatisfied with your side of argument Nas.
I wrote my own view on this argument as I believed that both sides could have done better, and I think our views align very closely.
Its cool to see a person see this argument in a similar way, I also added maybe people need to be taught to not believe all they hear and make voting a more serious and slow process to deter people voting more or less for fun. So that people who really researched it can then feal the need to put in an informed opinion.
For me it's not about the governance it's about the people who are in the government and in the country
That's a very nice critique, really goes to prove Nas' points of only the most intellectual people should decide who will run the government. But the Irony here is that those same people decide that democracy is better just because of it's loads of evidences. But in all seriousness, it should also be wise to equally consider the rational perspective of things. Theoretically, we very much find his arguments about Epistocracy and Technocracy good even if it's not backed with empirical evidences, like democracy. It's unwise to dismiss of doing something just because it doesn't exist yet. Hypothetically, if there's a world only ran by Totalitarianism, fascism, and dictatorship, why would we only base our world around these just because there's no evidences of democracy, and not take a step further? Same case here, if democracy really makes a country worse, the country should apply a new one, even if it's theoretical. That's my take anyway. On a side note, what government system in which you think is better than democracy? I'd like to hear your thoughts.
@@fakerboy7409 well I wouldn't say much but that those countries have adopted democracy because democracy might not have shown perfect results but it shown more results than any other form of government that the nation has gone through in the past. Also I do agree with your point that we should look forward to new things but they necessarily aren't always good or for the best. Democracy has established a way for everyone's voice being heard, and despite all the negatives, you cannot deny that it is an effective system of government.
@@yash1756 yep Democracy is only better on developed countries with good education it's easy for the bad leaders to rule on a country with poor education just like Germany before because after the WW1 germany dropped and lower with super high inflation and debts
The debate was insane...! Me being an Indian with democratic government, I know the problems and benefits of Democracy.
If a leader has started to build a national highway, but he gets replaced in the next election and the new leader doesn't show any interest in completing the highway project, it would be a disaster. But at the same time, if a leader makes bad decisions for the country we have a chance to change our leader after 5 years. We even can retain them if we like the way the leader worked and managed the country's affairs. Just vote for them and elect them again in the next election. There are many other ministers who take incharge of different responsibilities.
Democracy is efficient only when the people don't go by their emotions, and think in the perspective of the country's welfare. Especially, as India is a diverse country with many religions, people try to make a person of their religion; or a person who supports their religion, the leader. Even if the system is corrupted, the democracy won't be efficient, as it happens in India.
Yea I am also a Indian and I know many things about democracy and I respect that our democracy try to fulfill everyone needs and we all have different religions, languages, culture and many other things, we live like a huge family and always be and for this we need to educate and if we don't like any rules we can change them. Democracy are made for all the citizens I like to support democracy even after knowing the bad things also
Democracy won't work in uneducated population, especially where uneducated people are running the country /w full of corruption. Nothing get's don't here without BRIBE. Voting is fake & booth are often compromised.
lemme tell u what happend in my country, there a was an elected government or a party or whatever u call it, and they baited the people by giving them wrong information through tv, radio and stuff, and then they ruled for about a whopping 20 years while the period was 4 years, in this moment there was still democracy but it wasn't really implied if u can already tell, So this is the thing, the uneducated portion of the country still doesn't know what was happening and what was about to happen, then they did so much damage to the country by economy weapons and just made the country vulnerable and the rest is history, and my point is democracy is a bit unstable cuz in some part of the world if u are the government you can do everything u want. So we need a new form of governance which is more stable and ruled by the smartest people possible...
The problem is that representative democracy gives too much power and influence to the politician instead of giving it to the people.
In a real democracy, If a highway project was started and the politician changes, the highway project still goes on because the people do not change
Democracy is not ideal for all time and place.
All I can say is that
We need a Modified Democracy Right know!
Love this amazing debate from India 🇮🇳✌
Yep, but what India has become now is a Modi-fied democracy!
@@BlackShadow-tj5jd 😂 modi
@@BlackShadow-tj5jd Lol
@@BlackShadow-tj5jd right wing democracy
Any Arab country would be perfect ground for that experiment!!
This episode was brilliant! Love to see more of these debates!
Come check out more debates!!
I love debates so much. They are so interesting, waiting for more interesting debates made by you guys!!!
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥............
Nas, you need to make more of these! I absolutely love these types of videos, honestly. I appreciate your content, bro.
Personally I don't like democracy but I think it's the best solution we have at the moment.
@cerry wtf
I love democracy
huh? if you don't like, you must have at least better imagination of what system you want.
why don’t you like it?
I love democracy - Emperor Palpatine aka “The Senate”
" Trust takes years to build, seconds to breaks and forever to repair"
That's an amazing quote right there 🥰
1
THIS BOT
xavier?
I know right! that’s how life works
He lost alot of trust stealing another man's microphone!
He can not be trusted
This is so informative and hope you continues this. I love this series and worth watching too
Awesome!!!!!we are waiting nas debates #4
I can’t believe I really watched a 20 minute video and enjoyed it. That’s the beauty of NasDaily and I love it. Always cures my boredom
🐑
Thank you so much for watching :D
@@NasDaily thank you so much for seeing my comment 😊
@Døom he is say that in sarcasm
@@NasDaily Nas daily talk about India.... Please.... One lady has said bad about mohammed Nabi... Some muslims people protested... But protesters houses were destroyed...still that lady is not arrested... But many Muslims are in jail without doing any mistake... They already demolished on masjid and built temple taking 500 back history.. now another masjid is in limelight that it was also a temple.... This is democracy..... Some nasty politicians take control of the country... They divide Muslims and Hindus and gain votes telling they will retrieve Hindu temples... If you can speak about North Korea... Why can't you speak about illness of India?? When Muslims in India will live peacefully????????????? Our Muslims brothers are killed for being muslim... They are jailed for no reason ..... Women in Karnataka (indian state ) is not allowed to wear hijab. Please speak about it ..
Hey nas! I just love your videos ❤ please make more videos related to economy and economics. As an economics student it would be great learning for me... 💖
this was undoubtedly the best nas debate i really enjoyed both alex and nausri explaining their points and it would be really great if we see this debate live on youtube always nas daily
What a video!!! Hats off to the nas daily team ,I'm improving my knowledge by watching the videos from nas daily
Just loved the video.
Nuseir keep going on and make knowledge full videos.
BTW I totally argue and accept your point
This are really knowledge full videos worth watching and sharing.
Make more Nas debates thay are full of knowledge
Glad you enjoyed it :D
@📩𝙬hatsApp+⓵⓻⓷⓻⓶⓵⓺⓷⓽⓵⓶ nice one
"Democracy is two Wolves and a Lamb deciding on what to have for dinner." - Benjamin Franklin
I loved this debate so much, looking forward to more debates
Dear Nas, please continue this type of debates🙏🙏🙏
I love these debates
I liked this , keep it Nas🔥
The debate was really awesome. Very informative. Thanks nas academy for this wonderful thoughtful debate. This debate has now opened my mind to think deep about democracy.
This is the kind of debates that really can change the world. You changed my opinion about this. Doesn't matter is you doesn't agree with an idea, you have to listen those people you don't agree with to get the best of every point
Nas daily, is shariah law good or bad? Is communism good or bad? Who controls the government?
@FaZe saba non-aligned applies to alignment of polarity, say USA or Former Soviet block etc,.governance model is different my dear friend! Can't have non-aligned Shariah law, or non-aligned communism....its an oxymoron
“However good a Constitution may be, if those who are implementing it are not good, it will prove to be bad.
However bad a Constitution may be, if those implementing it are good, it will prove to be good.”
-A quote from the father of the Indian constitution, Dr B.R. Ambedkar
A man of opposites, though.
@@nikhilalbert3084 You must be UC and loves oppressing LC so I am not surprised, bro. Have a good day.
@@varunnikam If a constitution says that Nobody has right to own property and the property of rich people are deserve to be taken over or those who are against state ( all level of governments from local to national )should be hanged in public.
And a allegedly good person implement the constitution , you say that it will prove to be good.
What Kind of dumb logic is this?
PS: The example is not based on Indian constitution .Indian constitution is very progressive when it comes to property rights and free speech.
This is not true
Great idea... you should upload more videos like this one... it helps a lot to educate people and understands the problems that we are facing in our daily lives today and trying to find out the best solution
This was just the perfect video I needed for my debate tomorrow! Thanks a lot.
Update: Coming next day~~~
Philippines is a great example of this. The greater population isn't sufficiently educated to even distinguish reliable information vs. fake news, historical denialism vs. history.
I love how Nas argued for the changes needed in full democracy. It's an old system that's destroying a lot of lives today just because voters don't know how to even vote.
exactly,im surprised nas didn't bring Philippines up in the video
@@Kpoping727official atleast philliphine is great
Wow! The debate session was mind blowing! 👏👏 Hope to get more such great videos in future! All the best for all of you! ❤️ fom India 🇮🇳
Great to see you educating us through informative videoz. Nice editing!!
Thanks mann, crazyy help to win my debate. That's all the help i needed , really appreciate it .
Democracy isn't about real management, it's about legitimating
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥.........
6:22. Congratulations nas, because this point for me is spot on!
This debate was so good. You guys should arrange this kinds of debate more and more ❤️
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥....
Thank for the best content 💝 i love this brother , and my eyes turn into tear's for this ....
I live in Switzerland and we run a direct democracy. The people decide everything, and it’s working really good. I personally think that we have one of the best politic systems in the world, but there are a few factors which need to be fulfilled, people have to be well educated in order to understand politics upto a certain level. I like to argue with the Human Development Index, most of the countries at the top run a democracy.
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥...
Democracy is good only when the financial status of the country is good, if switzerland fell into 5 year financial depresson your system will surely fail. Deomcracy needs money otherwise it wont work
Agreed with you.even tho am not from Switzerland I think their democracy is one of the best
But it can work only because you are tiny nation with small population, you have 26 cantons and thats it. I cannot imagine expand this kind of system on country like US where its like completely different world just in next county/state. 50 states 3143 counties thats too much.
Isn’t it a semi-direct democracy? Since politicians still have the final say?
I really like how Alex is there to defend himself rather than attack 😂
Pretty much he doesn’t have a way to comeback
I love these nas debates. Keep on giving us more of this
How come I'm watching this just now 😯
Wonderful debate , this debate is just wow 😀👍🏻
Kuwait has democracy, but as a transgender there is no safety for me, in my own home and by my own people, so I had to move away now living in a different country whose people accept me and actually mean it when they say they support diversity without discrimination. My point is, democracy is better if run by educated people, there is still hope.
Good we don't need infidels in the Arabian peninsula 😉🏴
this is some dharmann level scripted acting
Such a wonderful debate
Awesome concept and incredible debate
Nuseir’s idea of a perfect system to run a government reminds me of Rhodesia, where weather you could vote was based on your wealth and education.
I think along with his WEF friends, he must have met Sussman 🤔
The debate was informative.
We need more Nas Debates
This is called the real debate where both of the participants listen each other's perspective not that what we usually watch on the news channel and tbh you both are right 👍 in my opinion
Nas daily is one of the true democratic channels on UA-cam to provide such excellent mind blowing debate for us, this is democracy 😆
Your vids are inspiring to everyone btw
Omg I’ve never got pinned by anyone you deserve more support!
You inspire to have love to the poor and a lot of political stuff is just very complicated sometimes
Democracy is very bad it isn’t good to make people go against what they don’t like but it’s also sometimes good for the community and this video can be helpful for some people including me!
Wow! The debate.
It's a request come up with more topic discussions on such a serious issues.
Thanks
I want more of this stuff.I like this because here I pick a side i believe in and its like you people are saying what i want to say but in much more better way and also there are ups and downs at various point within the debate .
I would say that if there was no democracy then Nas or Alex would themselves decide that their winner but as democracy existed the audience got a chance to vote in the debate
Imagine, if this debate was international... 😶😶😶
This is best debate on this channel 👍
Perfect debate, wanna see something like this again
NasDaily ty so much for the awesome content and the effort you put into it 💕 I love the debates and they are also really interesting
Hey Nusier I have huge respect for you and whole Nas team. Even you are my role model for my life. Your work is amazing and I hope one day I will collab with you
Love you so much Brother ❤
From India🇮🇳
He stole another man's microphone and that's a roll model?
You need a rethink
@@adityathakur9433 he stole a journalists microphone while promoting "you will own nothing and be happy"
He is brainwashing you
@@hillbilly23 like i didn't understood can you please explain me?
Don’t look at this guy as a role model, lots of things he said in this video are flawed as well.
Thank you nas daily for making again this debates
Nas daily I like all your videos. I watched all the nas debates.
Debate was really interesting i hope you will continue these debates in another topic with another video
Yes! We need to Modify the democracy to catch up with Times!
The Debate is AWESOME! Love from India ❤
Technocracy is one of good options right there... But practically speaking, it will be hard to change the form of governance of any country, ex. My country, India. Because it will take long time to convince people about the alternatives of democracy...
USA:- hold my coup
This is very educational/informative.
What a fantastic debate👍👍
i can come and show that democracy is the best.
It finally depends on the ruler, even if a ruler is good hearted and a dedicated person to his career, even if he does dictatorship his country would flourish.
I request you guys to continue debating.
Its really very interesting and intellectual to grab on the good or bad at a time and to have a 360° look on any topic.
I hope and request Nas daily for this. 😊
This is the most amazing and educating video I have ever seen.
*i would probably argue that the debate itself relies on democracy of its people otherwise rebuttals are awesome !!!*
Democracy sucks when it's relied on as a solution for EVERY SINGLE ISSUE. At some point democracy can kill liberty and nobody wants to have a conversation about it.
Get government out of people's individual lives.
that’s what federalism is for, to have the most important issues decided by individual states
Lmao, you don't want equality 🤣🤣
@@lullc2985 I want everyone to be equal under the law.
@@whimbrella What are these "most important" issues?
@@TheKelsey also democracy is fine, who want some leader decisions , unlimited power until he dies or dies and his offspring is new, or "monarch"? Democracy is created for no protest to each other, people are equal and everything, that seems very right, who think it's false, he should be greedy and foolish, and think fight is a wise for them, who also wants to live in those eras where that power was
Wonderful debate! Out of words..
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥....
Nas Daily you are really doing a nice work. Great ideas and realistic, and I agree with you 💯, we do need a better form of Democracy.
Amazing content... I support democracy.. And secularism.. Love from India🇮🇳
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥
@Nian thomas no but in every country some bad peoples r present who makes bad spot on their country's name
@Nian thomas Source : trust me bro
@Nian thomas "worst". but india is one of the most successful democratic country. Can you elaborate why do you think it worst? India gives every citizen equal chance to vote unlike some other
@Nian thomas democracy works that way. Just because you don't Agree with some parties ideology doesn't mean that Democracy is rigged. Some are authoritarian while some are liberal. It all depends on who the majority votes for.
India's democracy isn't bad, its party system is.
Good People Bring Out The Good In Other People.
I love this video of your channel
Waiting for more episodes of educative point of views! 💯💡✨
This man literally changed the meaning of democracy 😂
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥........
U r being watched by world's biggest Democracy.. 🇮🇳
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥
This is the best debate!
DM WE REALLY 👆👆NEED TO TALK 💬💌..........
A really good debate with valid points.. Keep it up guys
Nusair told us everything perfectly. Right words, right decision.I still can't understand why there are still some people left believing in democracy.
Democracy: an opportunity to choose
Decentralisation: an opportunity to participate
Twitter: an opportunity to free speech
A decentralized democracy :o. That would be perfect imo.
It's so fun to watch Nas Debate even when you're not interested in the topic!❤❤❤❤
Wonderfull Debate!!!
It’s better then a lot of others, could be better. Done.
No. There's better forms of government. Personally I'm an anarchist because all forms of government is an utter failure
I love how he's like:
"DEmocrAcy was designed 200 years ago so you shouldn't use it!1!1!"
*meanwhile nas trying to propose an idea that is about 2600 years old*
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥..
He contradicted himself. He said do you rather have a phone 20 years without upgrading. Also for him what is a educated person?
What if I was a doctor And He didn't have any knowledge about it? Then for me he would be not educated and should not have the right to vote. Also thanks to democracy he can do this debate right now lololol
Do more something like this, which is impressive
Loved it!!!!
Enjoyed this episode..I agree with Nas 💪🇿🇦🌍🇶🇦
Pls conduct a debate on communism. I am really curious and I think not all people have proper knowledge about it. By the way the video was nice.
amazing debate
I really loved the debate. Yes there pros and cons of democracy. So Nuseir I would like know what is the alternative
Was the girl at the beginning Dutch?
This man always tries to do something new and extraordinary and makes his audience feel excited for every next video , Hats off to him ,❣️❣️❣️🧡🧡❤️❤️.
Thanks for this video it help a lot in my politics study
This debate was craaaazy! Loved every second of this video.
Would love it if you could debate on a topic which speaks about the growing population of the world.
⤴️Appreciate your feedback and thanks for watching! Don't forget hit the subscribe button and for more guidance and investment info send me a direct message with the number above 📥