Ngl I've thought about her befriending Brightflower and Lilywhisker before to cope but I ADORE the idea of a friend group between her, Lily, Bright, and SNOWTUFT. Big brained ideas here only
I don’t get why they put her in there tbh. IF you were going to put a maples book cat in there why not oakstar?? Of anyone he “caused” the kits deaths. I don’t think anyone other than maple should be there but y’a know
@@RowanthekittydogOwO it isn’t ok. But I’m not sure being understandably upset that your best friend has been lying about your brother being the father of her kids when they aren’t is different than y’a know, killing three people for funzies
@@streamlily5971 i agree im not saying she's worse than mapleshade, im saying shes just not innocent , i get being mad at maple for going along with a assumption but taking it out on innocent babies is awful.
it's not been written or explained in the books, they just have her listed as a dark forest cat on the official website for some reason so it's probably canon now dbghdfhg like there are so many cats you could retcon into there instead, why frecklewish :(
While grieving might I add. It's not justified but if people say maple was right because she was grieving then freckle was right cause she was grieving
@@burnedflame2990 yaa, freckle dont deserve the df, calling the kits creatures was also unjustified grief or not, im just making a point since people call her the devil yet justify murder with grief. :)
bro i dont get it- she only did what she had to , MapleShade laid about having her brothers kits , and she was hurted when she found out they werent the father- that hurted- she never negleted the kits or is the responseble of there death
@@RioBlitzle I thought a new book dropped and star clan changed their mind about frecklewish??? I don't know I thought frecklewish went to starclan after she died
@@sushisushi5434 it's not something that's happened in a book- we haven't actually seen her in the dark forest- but she got categorised as a dark forest cat on the official website and is therefore now listed as such on the wiki :( it's not entirely solid written canon but it's still been officially stated, if that makes sense? sorry for confusion!
Ngl I've thought about her befriending Brightflower and Lilywhisker before to cope but I ADORE the idea of a friend group between her, Lily, Bright, and SNOWTUFT. Big brained ideas here only
Well they're all cats who SHOULD be in starclan so it makes sense. Also I think they would all help protect freckle from mapleshade
homegirl is not coping
I don’t get why they put her in there tbh. IF you were going to put a maples book cat in there why not oakstar?? Of anyone he “caused” the kits deaths. I don’t think anyone other than maple should be there but y’a know
well frecklewish was the first one to call for maple AND the kits to be exiled
@@RowanthekittydogOwO yeah but oakstar didn’t have to listen 🤷🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️
@@streamlily5971 yeah but that doesn't make calling for children to be kicked out of there home ok
@@RowanthekittydogOwO it isn’t ok. But I’m not sure being understandably upset that your best friend has been lying about your brother being the father of her kids when they aren’t is different than y’a know, killing three people for funzies
@@streamlily5971 i agree im not saying she's worse than mapleshade, im saying shes just not innocent , i get being mad at maple for going along with a assumption but taking it out on innocent babies is awful.
IM LOSING IT OVER THE MINECRAFT ONE HAHA
I used to be one of those people who hated Frecklewish she didn't deserve the Dark Forest
the erins arent even trying anymore tbh
Wait! Why did they write her to be in the dark Forest?...poor frecklewish 😿
it's not been written or explained in the books, they just have her listed as a dark forest cat on the official website for some reason so it's probably canon now dbghdfhg like there are so many cats you could retcon into there instead, why frecklewish :(
@@RioBlitzle ye that's so sad. She doesn't deserve to go to cat Hell 😿f💔
It's because they dont like innocent grieving woman. But the man who exiled a queen and her kits? OmG HE DId NOtHinG WrOnG!! STArcLaN TimE
0:57 flashbacks from pushing baby lions
seems like a suitable punishment for referring to kits as creatures one single time
What
While grieving might I add. It's not justified but if people say maple was right because she was grieving then freckle was right cause she was grieving
@@zrainyday5266 and i say that whe should not make grief a excuse tho :D so they both wrong
@@burnedflame2990 yaa, freckle dont deserve the df, calling the kits creatures was also unjustified grief or not, im just making a point since people call her the devil yet justify murder with grief. :)
@@zrainyday5266 for sure,people need to stop justifying horrible actions with "grief"
If Freckle’wish is in The Dark Forest, how come Apple’dusk isn’t?
He doesn’t need to be in the DF 💀
You were so right. So sad
0:52 как мило :3
YOOO SNOWTUFT LOOKS SO HAPPYYYY 0:58
bro i dont get it- she only did what she had to , MapleShade laid about having her brothers kits , and she was hurted when she found out they werent the father- that hurted- she never negleted the kits or is the responseble of there death
WAIT IM SO CONFUSED WHY DID SHE GO TO THE DARK FOREST
Presumably for "letting Mapleshade's kids die" despite the fact she couldn't swim? They didn't specify a reason
@@RioBlitzle I thought a new book dropped and star clan changed their mind about frecklewish??? I don't know I thought frecklewish went to starclan after she died
@@sushisushi5434 it's not something that's happened in a book- we haven't actually seen her in the dark forest- but she got categorised as a dark forest cat on the official website and is therefore now listed as such on the wiki :( it's not entirely solid written canon but it's still been officially stated, if that makes sense? sorry for confusion!
Omg, I'm cry
:((((
666 views