Shimano Ultegra Spod XTD VS Daiwa Emblem 35 Spod - Which is best - Carp Fishing

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 90

  • @CaravanCarpers
    @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

    Don’t forget to Like & Subscribe!

  • @jamies4319
    @jamies4319 2 роки тому +3

    Got the Daiwa and the first thing I done was put a new folding handle on it from the 45s for £40 and now it's the best spod reel I've ever used.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +2

      Good bit of kit isnt it! I need to put folding handles on mine. Makes it miles quicker to store

    • @smiffyuk2003
      @smiffyuk2003 2 роки тому +1

      Do you have a link to these?

    • @电光祝
      @电光祝 2 роки тому +1

      @@smiffyuk2003 Hi Andy,Happy New Year!I am Jack from Gomexus (a custom reel company ),We are going to design a plug-and-Go handle for daiwa emblem SCW 45,would you mind drop us some suggestions on the handle and knob that we should make?We would like to send you one once we released them handle.Thanks in advance 😊

  • @nickm3140
    @nickm3140 2 роки тому +2

    Good evening, no-rant from me tonight lol. I have got 1400 xtd reels and matching spod reel. Must admit the spod reel is the best one I’ve had tbh, used Diawa, wychwood riot. Line lay is great, like you said the drag isn’t the quickest so I put carbon washers in and now in less that half turn it’s solid. With my fishing reels there is an issue with the line going under the spool, happens more when I use fluorocarbon, must be the lack of suppleness I’m guessing but the idea of the line guard is to stop this, but it doesn’t so pointless really. Again line lay is great and line peels off on cast. Just purchased some fox rx plus alarms. They are a treat. Loving ur info.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Evening Nick! Cheers for watching, what do you think of the carbon washers? Which ones are the best to buy. I’m going to get some 5500 ultegras to use on my stalking set up for the caravan.
      I have the same issue with fluorocarbon too. I tend to tie it off and stretch it and that helps but I’m not a big fan of the stuff.
      How are you finding them? Never used them myself.

    • @nickm3140
      @nickm3140 2 роки тому +1

      Just purchased the ice washer kit , cost about £7 a pack couple years back. There’s loads on market now and most of them are good quality anyway. Had no issues. Makes all the difference

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Happy days I’ll have to invest!

  • @tomferguson3449
    @tomferguson3449 Рік тому +2

    Coming from a being a big shimano fan,im absolutely shocked at how bad the ultegra xtd is.
    4 months of use and it started locking up at times,5 months in and it properly siezed up!
    And i NEVER dunk my reels!
    Sent it back to shimano as was under warranty,shimano said the gears are completely siezed due to severe water ingress and the warranty is void because i must of been dunking them🙄
    They said it would be around £80 to repair.
    Absolute shocking response and Absolute shocking reel.
    Told them to send it back to me and I'll buy a diawa emblem!
    The shimano xtd is the worst reel ive ever had👎🏻

  • @safugim5526
    @safugim5526 2 роки тому +1

    The best bang for your buck for a spod reel it's: Okuma inception 8000 ! It's light, it gots 2 line clips, and it retrives 123cm of line. It's not marketed as a spod reel but it's a best buy for spoding. I bought it for a heavy feeder but surprize it's a spod reel. I wanted to buy the daiwa but now i stick with the okuma :)

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Never used any of the Okuma range to be fair pal but a lot of people do swear by them. Have you used either the Daiwa or the Shimano? If so what do you think of them?

    • @safugim5526
      @safugim5526 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers I use daiwa emblem 45 for my fishing and love them, and the inception 8000 for spod and marker.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Happy days 👌🏻

  • @alantyler5079
    @alantyler5079 7 місяців тому +1

    Hi buddy if was advertised to buy the Diawa spod reel my my local shop it worked fine for 9 months then it sized up solid. I returned it to the shop and they returned it to Diawa I was fishing every week so purchased another Diawa spod reel they told me they would credit me with the new price if Diawa just replaced the seized reel they returned it serviced. It lasted 18 months and failed again. I bought a Shimano spod reel it was way smother and retrieved more line per turn. I was so surprised how smooth the retrieve was. I do use Diawa main reels Baisers so not a Shimano fan. But the new latest Shimano Spod reel was a revelation . Diawa should get a new design team working on a much better spod reel they get much more hammer than a normal fishing reel and need beefing up and making smoother in operation.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  7 місяців тому

      Hi Alan sorry about the late reply I’ve been very unwell the last few weeks. Couple of things to take in to consideration. When you leave it against your bivvy when it’s raining do you keep the spool in the lowest position this protects the inner workings. Do you dunk your reels to wet the line. Both my Daiwa and shimano reels have been battered and they are both working as new after a couple of years and no servicing. Thank you for watching much appreciated. I’ve not seen the latest models of the shimanos I need to have a look

  • @sla8z91
    @sla8z91 2 роки тому +1

    I used the emblem spod and no but issues but just noisy and felt clunky. Just bought shimano ultegra spod and has been good with no issues. I've always used shimano reels GTE 10000, longcasts, ultegra 5500 and 12000 black mags... never any issues with any and all work like new!

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      They are both good reels arnt they! Have you seen the new mags with the 45 spool 🔥

    • @sla8z91
      @sla8z91 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers I haven't seen them yet. 1 thing that did concern me with the new shimano reels is they're made in Malaysia rather than Japan... any difference who knows?!

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      I’m not sure but I guess it’s got somthing to do with cost

  • @CarpFishingDiaries
    @CarpFishingDiaries 2 роки тому +1

    Looking forward to the frontier review pal. Another top vlog mate. 👌

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Haha defiantly going to be a honest one after today! Lmao I’ll drop you a txt pal 👌🏻

  • @garydurling4569
    @garydurling4569 2 роки тому +1

    Loving your honest reviews.keep up the good work.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Cheers Gary thanks for watching 👌🏻

  • @kevinpain2420
    @kevinpain2420 2 роки тому +3

    Being a shimano man I was really disappointed with my new spod reels as they let water in and seized so have since bought the daiwa spod reels and they seem much better just to say that I do not dunk my reels thanks

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Happy days pal! Madness isn’t it I’ve got some old windcast z’s never been serviced ect and they are bomb proof but the newer stuff just isn’t as good! Shame really

  • @kenwarburton2578
    @kenwarburton2578 2 роки тому +1

    Really interesting honest review Lee. I look forward to watching your future "Tackle Tuesday" reviews, and comparing the Daiwa / Shimano reels with Dave "Carponeiger".

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Hi Ken thanks for watching! He’s a good lad Dave a good mate of mine should be a laugh

    • @kenwarburton2578
      @kenwarburton2578 2 роки тому

      @@CaravanCarpers I agree Lee, Dave is great guy.

  • @michaelfleet4058
    @michaelfleet4058 2 роки тому +2

    Used shimano 14000 plastick rotary just split to pieces so now looking at the daiwa

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      You won’t be disappointed with the Daiwa pal

  • @TheCarponeiger
    @TheCarponeiger 2 роки тому +1

    Top video Lee, honest as always mate, looking forward to visiting the Tackle shack 👍

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Cheers Dave! Soon as we are both free we will get it sorted 💪🏻

  • @kevinstanton9982
    @kevinstanton9982 2 роки тому +2

    Another great vid mate , I use the shimano and can’t honestly fault it , looking forward to next tackle Tuesday also be good to see the Carponieger in the shack 👌👌💪💪

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Cheers Kev thanks for watching pal! Be good to get Dave on it 💪🏻

  • @pvinnie.73
    @pvinnie.73 9 місяців тому +2

    Disappointed with the xtd line lay went to pot for some reason even added some washers and still no better, not even been abused

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  7 місяців тому

      Your joking that’s not good is it 😤

  • @seantwomey7816
    @seantwomey7816 2 роки тому +1

    Another brilliant and fair review 👏🏻

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Cheers Sean! Thanks for your support 👌🏻

  • @minds.matter.carping500
    @minds.matter.carping500 2 роки тому +2

    Spot on reviews every time mate I love the fact you give so much detail and go into great depths with them but also keep them nice and simple👌 really looking forward to your next review with Dave keep smashing it brother 👊🏻👊🏻🙏

  • @colintennant4182
    @colintennant4182 2 роки тому +2

    If u want to speed the drag up on shimano switch washers to ice drag washers as the xtds come with greased felt washers unlike the xtcs which come with ptfe washers which is loads better and whilst ice washers are too fast and don't give enough increments for fishing situations there brilliant for a spod and marker reel and there fairly cheap. And like u I don't have a preference between diawa or shimano I have xtc14000 for distance fishing and crosscast 5000 for shorter range but all of my spod reels are shimano 2x xtd14000 long range 13ft rods and aerex 10000 on my 10ft spod I am surprised people think shimano reels fall apart build quality is second to none hence why they hold value really well but diawa have been about since the dawn of time and are usually reliable surprised to hear mag sealed seized up a bit i wonder if all mag sealed do this just a thought

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Hi Colin, believe it or not I’ve ordered some ice washers, I’ve not fitted them yet though. Yea I’ve had no issues myself and a few friends have them but in the fishing groups I’m in on WhatsApp/Facebook a few people have had bad experiences. It’s mainly the BR version of the Daiwa Castizm that have had the issue I believe. My QDA versions have been brilliant. It could be isolated to that reel model but it just puts me off spending the extra for it now if that makes sense. Thank you for taking the time to comment such an in-depth comment 👌🏻

  • @awilderireland
    @awilderireland 2 роки тому +1

    I just bought a Spod reel (for tench mainly). I bought the original Daiwa Emblem Spod reel that has been around for years. I could have got the reel in your video for less money but I reckoned the plain old Emblem Spod looked better built and more gutsy. Even if it is old tech and agricultural looking in comparison.
    You mentioned the old Cast izm 25 QDA's. I managed to get three of those new from an Austrian dealer even though they are now discontinued. I felt they were better than the current offerings. For my needs anyway.
    I was always a Shimano Guy but rightly or wrongly I feel they are not as good as they used to be. Then again what is? I still have a pair of their old 5000 GTE Baitrunners and three of the original 10,000 XTE (10 K) Baitrunners. I will never let them go. 🙂
    Take care.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Hiya pal,
      To be honest I toyed on the idea of getting the original but was advised to get the newer version. Not had no issues with it so far so pretty happy with it. In all fairness it’s a bit of an iconic spod reel isn’t it so it’s stood the test of time.
      Castizm QDA’s are one of my fav reels absolutely love them but the br 25A version is terrible!
      A lot of people saying that at the min to be fair I’ve never been a fan so I though I’d just try one and it’d been ok so far.
      Thanks for watching and commented much appreciated pal 👌🏻

    • @awilderireland
      @awilderireland 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers So much to choose from! It was easier years ago. 😂
      All the best.

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      @@awilderireland cheers pal

  • @geoffbanks8591
    @geoffbanks8591 2 роки тому +2

    Just picked up my emblem 35 scw spod. Going to back it with 0.4 and then add the esp spod braid which is 0.22 any ideas on backing capacity calculation id really appreciate that mate 👍 cheers geoff

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Hi Geoff, yes mate no probs ill do it for you later 👌🏻

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +2

      78 turns of backing line will do you then put the spod braid on

    • @geoffbanks8591
      @geoffbanks8591 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers mate, you're a gentleman 👏 keep doing what you do, are you on insta also

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому +1

      Yes pal caravancarpers no spaces 👌🏻. Hopfully in final bits of a video from cromwell hoping to have it out for weekend

  • @cgn749
    @cgn749 Рік тому +3

    So which one is better overall ?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  Рік тому +1

      I’d probably go with the Daiwa that’s the one I take the most when only having one rod

    • @cgn749
      @cgn749 Рік тому +1

      Oh well ordered the Shimano yesterday, but thank you for reply. I will find out if it pleases me

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  Рік тому +1

      Hiya pal no worries they are both decent mate you won’t be disappointed

  • @sla8z91
    @sla8z91 2 роки тому +1

    Have you used many spod/marker braids and/or leaders that you can recommend?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      Ive used the korda stuff, changed to the fox stuff and love it. Ive just bought the thicker Gardner stuff and yet to try it. Shock-leader Gardner all the way or armakourd if you dont mind the price

    • @sla8z91
      @sla8z91 2 роки тому +1

      Thanks👍I was using j braid straight through for short range in a decent breaking strain but would crack off at the knot after a while. I'm using it with armakord shockleader again now but was trying to stop the faff of knot at bottom of spool... can't have it all I guess!

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      The gardner stuff is a bit thicker and 35lb so you dont need a sock leader. Im just yet to use it and see how it effects long range work but when i do ill let you know pal

  • @fredigsellmann5781
    @fredigsellmann5781 Рік тому +1

    Hi, is this the fox exocet spod braid on the ultegra?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  Рік тому

      Yes mate it’s on both the spod reels. Had it on well over a year now been bang on.

    • @fredigsellmann5781
      @fredigsellmann5781 Рік тому +1

      Oh great, do you have mono under the braid?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  Рік тому

      @@fredigsellmann5781 yes mate just some old 0.35

    • @fredigsellmann5781
      @fredigsellmann5781 Рік тому

      Do you know how many meters?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  3 місяці тому

      Hi yes sorry I’ve just seen this it is fox

  • @dannymoore6102
    @dannymoore6102 2 роки тому +2

    Top video

  • @raybriggs4529
    @raybriggs4529 2 роки тому

    Hi.
    I have the Shimano spod reel, could you use these as a normal fishing reel?

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      I think some people do for long range and boat fishing as it has a higher retrieval rate pal

  • @aarondavies8486
    @aarondavies8486 2 роки тому +1

    I had the ultegra xtd 5500 they are the shittest reels I ever have used got them a week after they came out and with in 6 months the bearing started I had the serviced and found they ain't bearings no more just plastic bushings I have okuma trio rexs omg so much smoother and I have had them few years now all I have done is grease them once a year

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      To be fair some of the Daiwas have been the same I’ve had just getting 3 of mine repaired at the min that have been used on decking at the caravan in nothing but the odd bit of rain! I think that’s the thing these days everything is more expensive but far worse made as they cut corners to make the most money don’t they. Never seen the Okumas in the flesh. Might be worth a look if I ever want some new reels in the future

    • @aarondavies8486
      @aarondavies8486 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers I think all the big manufacturers build them like mobile phones now days tbh the mid range stuff is nothing like it used to be but the okuma t rex has proper ball-bearings and not cheap Chinese tat ether they are a bit on the heavy side but are on buzzers most of the time but they are made from aluminium 100 quid for one the waterproofing is so much better than shimano to

    • @aarondavies8486
      @aarondavies8486 2 роки тому

      I keep putting the same message about the manufacturers of fishing stuff for you to look at won't let me post it on UA-cam they don't like it and gets deleted with in seconds

    • @aarondavies8486
      @aarondavies8486 2 роки тому +1

      @@CaravanCarpers I have put a comment on you recent Facebook Post about the company I have tried to show you on here mate would love to hear your thoughts on it not many people know they just know it comes from china

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 роки тому

      I’ve seen a lot of that stuff I’m the past it where a lot of the budget tackle comes from, a friends company called carp 2 bank used to get all the hooks and swivels ect from a shop on Alibaba like that. Problem with the rods and that there’s a minimum order of like 60 or something.

  • @lukebalicki7103
    @lukebalicki7103 2 роки тому +1

    Thank god you just do my reels for me much easier 😆👍🏻

  • @ondreejpolasek1306
    @ondreejpolasek1306 11 місяців тому +1

    Daiwa❤

  • @WeihrauchShooter
    @WeihrauchShooter 2 дні тому +1

    "The handle comes loose all the time on this reel and it does do my head in" few seconds later you say but ill be happy with either of them 😂 how can you be happy with something that does your head in ffs 🤦

    • @CaravanCarpers
      @CaravanCarpers  2 дні тому

      It’s not a big enough issue that would stop me using the reel I’ve changed to the folding handle on there now so not an issue anymore

  • @dannybartlett4225
    @dannybartlett4225 2 роки тому +1

    What are you doing ?? Lool 😆