Been seeing a lot of the "roast your tone/song/playing" videos on guitar YT recently. The legitimate constructive criticism and just overall positive vibe with these people's art was like a breath of fresh air
Correction it’s rate or roast. Not just roast so don’t play on words just to suit your point. And the overwhelming majority of the rigs get rated not roasted and is widely positive so stop it kid. We all watch the same content.
I really appreciate this type of content, Rhett -- constructive criticism from an accomplished musician helps everyone learn. Novices like me often don't know what we don't know and videos like this shine spotlights on new (to us) techniques, styles, etc...
@@nickk8650 Thats an awesome point Nick! How many albums would you rate as your favourite by an artist and its their first? By the same token though, a new artist is probably going to be given an inexperienced producer to cut their first album.... and even then, magic still happens. 😊
@@nickk8650 Nah that's a definite preference that depends on the person. The punk or lofi production thing is popular in some circles and not in others. Personally I enjoy it sometimes but I love lush production other days, just depends
@@CatmanJimbo Right. They're just two different things. The raw energy and attitude of punk is a beautiful thing, but so is the product of John Frusciante locking himself in the studio for a few days.
Just slap that mic in front of anything and it sounds pretty good. My friend that knows stuff told me to use a cloud lifter with it so it isn’t so noisy, so I do. Great mic if you don’t wanna have to tinker with anything. Less mic tinker time and more time to play guitar!
This is a brilliant idea! Would love for you to make a series, as it’s fun to see a pro musician’s take but it’s also fun to just hear what other people have going on. Definitely got some ideas from these clips on different sounds and playing styles to implement Going forward, maybe request that they do a quick rundown of the stuff they used? Pedals, amps, etc?
This is/was a great idea to do Rhett. All kinds of styles and technique. Most guitarists appreciate the efforts of others. May try and submit something for evaluation!
These are the kind of submission results I like. There is a variety of different playing and recording levels. From a live performer with someone filming, to high quality video and audio recording, to someone with just a webcam pointed at them, and limited audio recording. I wish I knew about it, but I like it more than the ones that just show the players with the best equipment and access to record a music video.
I loved how you looked at all the positives and lifted these guys up! What some great players and you nailed the critiques. Great job to the players and to you!
It's always surprising to see how many talented people are not only interested in, but also actually playing music. It's exciting. It's a good series you're starting there. Personally, I would never dare submit. So I admire the confidence of all these people. It's amazing.
This is such a great idea! As somebody who's just started to learn about electric guitars, I found it super helpful because I heard a bunch of new terms (that I need to Google). Props to everyone who submitted!
I love this type of criticism. It allows musicians from all types of genres to share knowledge and pass on very important information regarding, not only tone, but other important information that makes each and every one of us better performers/musicians. Keep up the wonderful work you do!
Sooo money on your critiques Rhett! And a lot of fantastic playing in the video. We are all so unique in our styles. It’s nice how u can compartmentalize everyones uniqueness
Rhett this was a fantastic session. There’s so much to be learned from listening to you break down a given tone and playing style. I appreciate how you quickly cut to the chase, offer constructive criticism, and above give praise where praise is due. I congratulate the players who submitted videos. Wow. Your channel continues to evolve; it gets better and better. I say do more of these videos. Sp
This was a fun idea. Some really great playing! If any of these people have UA-cam channels, you should link them! The only thing you missed on is the title of the video. You totally should have called it “Rhett My Tone.” I give this video 9/10 denim jackets 😆
Yes, yes please do more of these! Hearing your thoughts on tone against practical applications really brings a lot of what you have to say into a more understandable context. My favorite video of yours in a long time.
I love this idea! Thought all the players did a great. Excellent comments on each of the videos. Would love to see more of this, and maybe one day I will get the courage to submit something.
So, I was thinking “this is pretty cool… maybe I should think about submitting something?” And then around 5 seconds into Brady’s playing I was thinking “yeah… ok… maybe not then!” That was soooooo good 🥰
To be honest, I'd rather hear more shitty tone and shitty playing to get some actual criticism than very experienced players just looking to show off their skills.
Hey David. Submit stuff! There is always like some 10 year old kid in some country that can mop the floor with all of us. Don't let that hold you back!
@ghost mall don’t compare bro. Somewhere in the world there is always some freak of nature that can shred...at like 4 years old. The internet puts them in front of our faces. The rest of us (the majority of us) are mere mortals.
Hi Rhett..I think u have discovered a new angle to approach your channel content...this is real time everyday people looking to a professional for opinions and tips to improve tone and playing guitar in general...I really enjoyed it and I think this could take off for you... nicely done.. refreshing honesty and kind words really affects us all..ty man.. nice job..good work
Good idea for a series Rhett! I'm constantly amazed at the level of talent thats out there. It takes a lot of courage to submit to a critique like this so kudos to all these players. Your tone and playing insights are spot on. Great job.
Love your channel Rhett! Gilmore is one of my biggest heroes. I read an article where Gilmour says that he actually used a Les Paul with P-90's for the solo in Another brick in the wall which is imo one of the best solos ever played. The same guitar is used for "On an island". All the best! //Pontus
I am 57 years old and Rhett, you are my favorite guitar instructor! I have been following your channel since you pretty much started and only had 30.000 subscribers. Enjoyed the journey with you all the way!
I love that you're helping these people out and not just roasting them like so many other people that do this format. That just says a lot about the kind of person you are, that you want to help them and love to contribute and lift people up. Keep doing what you do.
Love this series and what you’re doing here! Absolutely perfect idea. I really appreciate your honest critiques Rhett. I think it means a lot for all of us as guitar players and enthusiasts.
Great stuff, Rhett! Every now and then we need to be reminded that ALL GUITAR PLAYING IS BEAUTIFUL! Whether it's a seasoned pro or a beginner 8 year old banging on an A power chord through a solid state amp with a 6 inch speaker, IT'S ALL BEAUTIFUL!
I am working while listening to this, when that guy with the strat started ripping the blues, I got goosebumps, I immediately had to see him. Reminded me so much of SRV. Fantastic player!
Great concept - I really enjoyed it! People did really good, and it's great to see what other players are coming up with! Your tips and opinions are great too, and I'm sure we can all learn a lot from it - so please do keep this concept going! Have a great weekend!
Hey Rhett, thank you for doing this and giving anyone who wants to send a vid in a chance, from all different levels/styles and settings. A really constructive fun thing to do. Really appreciate it.
Well done! Your perspective on the audio clips provided useful insight. The variety of styles in the video demonstrate the range of your community. Music brings people together.
I think you hit an interactive way to engage your subscribers and give up valuable advice from your experience. Because it is so positive; it sets yourself up as being very different than the usual negativity. I give it 10 out of 10 Beatos.
Very nice. It takes some confidence to even send in a video, so I'd say awesome job to all these guys! Great critiques on your part as well Rhett! You definitely understand tone and what kind of tone is appropriate for what you are trying to convey. Very good points about digging in deeper with a heavier touch on that Gilmour brick in the wall part 2 solo.
This is my first comment although I've been watching for a while. Please do more of these, and, thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience with us. :)
@@RhettShull BTW sorry for not including any background info, your analysis was pretty spot on. It was a lawsuit era Ventura ES175 copy through an HX Stomp. I recorded it just after I got the guitar back from having a re-fret and having the stock pickups swapped out for some Gibson 57 classics that were sitting in the closet unused.
Rhett, as a new subscriber I am impressed (blown away) with your expertise and focus in getting to the heart of TONE. I loved hearing the various submissions and your excellent and constructive feedback. Your critiques are spot on and with each player you highlight what each player could do to make their tone even better. I would be so intimidated to send in one my tunes but I love to learn and explore what others are doing. I think you've hit on something really solid with this Submit Your Tone - keep doing it.
WOW!!....there are so many talented and creative people out there...we gotta get this world fixed so we can get out there and enjoy all these great things!!!!.....thanks Rhett...great vid!!!!
Not sure how the heck I missed this, wish I had been able to submit! As always, incredibly humble and great advice Rhett, I look forward to seeing more
Great idea having listeners engaging more closely with your channel. Really like your supportive suggestions to the submissions, this is good teaching. Great stuff Rhett really enjoy your videos :)
Way more of this! The interaction between you and your subscribers is so good to watch and the great constructive critisism (and Belle's explosive feathery hats) make this a great one! "Reaction" videos with a Rhett twist. Superb!
Really love seeing some good professional feedback. You have good things to say and give everyone something to work on. Makes me wish I had you as a guitar teacher.
It's great that you not only gave a rating but some feedback on what they did well and where they could improve. Of course these things are all subjective but feedback like "doing this will make it sit better in the mix" and that sort is all super positive and effective. Great video Rhett!
Rhett, this was fantastic. Lots of useful reactions and most of all, you sharing the ways in which you evaluate tone, style, and performances overall. Short video but loads of content. Also hugely entertaining! More, more....
I think that this is a great idea for a series. A good opportunity for suggestions, and a good showcase of some people that have enviable tone to aspire to.
Blues guy here! Thanks so much for reviewing my tone! Definitely gonna cut back that delay! And thank you for doing this type of video!
Great playing man!
Thanks bro!
Killing it bro! You blues dudes rock.
Ian you ripped man. That was awesome. Are you a Nashville guy? Whats your set up?
@@dubzga yes sir! In this video I’m using my Squier hardtail strat w/fender replacement neck, mxr Timmy mini, boss dd3, and katana artist.
Been seeing a lot of the "roast your tone/song/playing" videos on guitar YT recently. The legitimate constructive criticism and just overall positive vibe with these people's art was like a breath of fresh air
Definitely, already way too much negativity in UA-cam comments.
Reminds me of Adam Neely's series that started out as "how to not suck at music" but has since been reframed it into a more positive version of that.
Correction it’s rate or roast. Not just roast so don’t play on words just to suit your point. And the overwhelming majority of the rigs get rated not roasted and is widely positive so stop it kid. We all watch the same content.
100%! I knew Rhett would be constructive and this will actually help out a lot of people rather than just make them feel inferior.
I was pleasantly surprised. There's hope after all...
I really appreciate this type of content, Rhett -- constructive criticism from an accomplished musician helps everyone learn. Novices like me often don't know what we don't know and videos like this shine spotlights on new (to us) techniques, styles, etc...
I feel like not knowing is part of the magic- most people prefer most artists early stuff cause it’s raw and unpolished
@@nickk8650 Thats an awesome point Nick! How many albums would you rate as your favourite by an artist and its their first? By the same token though, a new artist is probably going to be given an inexperienced producer to cut their first album.... and even then, magic still happens. 😊
Hit it on the head brother 🤙
@@nickk8650 Nah that's a definite preference that depends on the person. The punk or lofi production thing is popular in some circles and not in others. Personally I enjoy it sometimes but I love lush production other days, just depends
@@CatmanJimbo Right. They're just two different things. The raw energy and attitude of punk is a beautiful thing, but so is the product of John Frusciante locking himself in the studio for a few days.
Your ability to critique while not sounding critical is astounding. Free, positive musical consulting! Great!
Agree, Rhett's a class act!
Really an outstanding video series Rhett.
That acoustic guitar was recorded with an SM7!? What an absolute legend.
One of the goat mic’s!
Just slap that mic in front of anything and it sounds pretty good. My friend that knows stuff told me to use a cloud lifter with it so it isn’t so noisy, so I do. Great mic if you don’t wanna have to tinker with anything. Less mic tinker time and more time to play guitar!
@@bradybills134 its a great drum mic too. i use it as an overhead pretty frequently
@@willderr1469 recorded an excellent album with two SM7s for overheads, X/Y
More proof talent is everywhere! Great work guys.
Also, such a cool idea for a video.
On the flip side, it's more validation that I am, in fact, trash.
@@Smitty_Werbenjagermanjenson LOL I was having the same emotion!
Thanks for using the Tidalcaster in this video buddy! She's looking and sounding great!
You built a beautiful guitfiddle, congrats!
I’m not sure what a Tidalcaster is….but I like it man!!!
I can't concentrate on the video when he has that thing out. Maybe he should sell it to me and buy a new screen for his phone.
The Beauty and the Beast rendition is beautiful. He made his steel string sound really warm, so lovely
You should check out Kent Nishimura's rendition of Beauty of the Beast. Its amazing.
Never ceases to amaze me how many terrific musicians there are out there. This video is another reminder. Kudos to all who submitted!
This is a brilliant idea! Would love for you to make a series, as it’s fun to see a pro musician’s take but it’s also fun to just hear what other people have going on. Definitely got some ideas from these clips on different sounds and playing styles to implement
Going forward, maybe request that they do a quick rundown of the stuff they used? Pedals, amps, etc?
Yes, would be great as a series.
@@Halliday7895 …he’s a pro. he goes on tour and plays stadiums.
Totally respect your input and thoughtful comments. Great to hear some other players as well. Hope there might be more. THANK YOU RHETT!
This is/was a great idea to do Rhett. All kinds of styles and technique. Most guitarists appreciate the efforts of others. May try and submit something for evaluation!
Diggin’ this for sure. Congrats to all who had the guts to submit a performance, well done! I would love to see more!!!
These are the kind of submission results I like. There is a variety of different playing and recording levels. From a live performer with someone filming, to high quality video and audio recording, to someone with just a webcam pointed at them, and limited audio recording. I wish I knew about it, but I like it more than the ones that just show the players with the best equipment and access to record a music video.
The third player with the STRAT gave me chills. MONSTER.
Thank you so much!!!
@@IanBennettGuitar you are a monster guitarist.
Me too! I watched it twice and got chills both times. At 6:22 he goes supernova and just fucking tears it apart. Spectacular playing @Ian Bennett.
@@sam-browne thanks so much Sam!!!!
@@IanBennettGuitar I like but don't love blues but I'd listen to you all day man. Tone, feel, playing, everything.
I loved how you looked at all the positives and lifted these guys up! What some great players and you nailed the critiques. Great job to the players and to you!
It's always surprising to see how many talented people are not only interested in, but also actually playing music.
It's exciting. It's a good series you're starting there.
Personally, I would never dare submit.
So I admire the confidence of all these people. It's amazing.
Props to everyone who submitted! And thanks to Rhett for a great idea and all of your insight
This is such a great idea! As somebody who's just started to learn about electric guitars, I found it super helpful because I heard a bunch of new terms (that I need to Google). Props to everyone who submitted!
I love this type of criticism. It allows musicians from all types of genres to share knowledge and pass on very important information regarding, not only tone, but other important information that makes each and every one of us better performers/musicians. Keep up the wonderful work you do!
Sooo money on your critiques Rhett! And a lot of fantastic playing in the video. We are all so unique in our styles. It’s nice how u can compartmentalize everyones uniqueness
Rhett this was a fantastic session. There’s so much to be learned from listening to you break down a given tone and playing style. I appreciate how you quickly cut to the chase, offer constructive criticism, and above give praise where praise is due. I congratulate the players who submitted videos. Wow. Your channel continues to evolve; it gets better and better. I say do more of these videos. Sp
This was a fun idea. Some really great playing! If any of these people have UA-cam channels, you should link them! The only thing you missed on is the title of the video. You totally should have called it “Rhett My Tone.” I give this video 9/10 denim jackets 😆
Yes, yes please do more of these! Hearing your thoughts on tone against practical applications really brings a lot of what you have to say into a more understandable context. My favorite video of yours in a long time.
hats off to these guys for putting it out there for a billion people to critique! nice ,constructive commentary rhett, nice vid!
Probably one of my favorite videos you've done. Hopefully we'll have a series out of this. Thank you.
Hey o! Beauty and the Beast guy here. Thanks for checking out my tone! Means a lot.
I dig it, Man!
I love this idea! Thought all the players did a great. Excellent comments on each of the videos. Would love to see more of this, and maybe one day I will get the courage to submit something.
Pretty fun Rhett and I agree with and appreciate your insight on these players. More please.
Cheers!
So, I was thinking “this is pretty cool… maybe I should think about submitting something?” And then around 5 seconds into Brady’s playing I was thinking “yeah… ok… maybe not then!” That was soooooo good 🥰
To be honest, I'd rather hear more shitty tone and shitty playing to get some actual criticism than very experienced players just looking to show off their skills.
Hey David. Submit stuff! There is always like some 10 year old kid in some country that can mop the floor with all of us. Don't let that hold you back!
@@MCMFF1 dig the mos def pic!
Brady is amazing
@ghost mall don’t compare bro. Somewhere in the world there is always some freak of nature that can shred...at like 4 years old. The internet puts them in front of our faces. The rest of us (the majority of us) are mere mortals.
Particularly enjoyed this installment. Hope you do part 2!
Hi Rhett..I think u have discovered a new angle to approach your channel content...this is real time everyday people looking to a professional for opinions and tips to improve tone and playing guitar in general...I really enjoyed it and I think this could take off for you... nicely done.. refreshing honesty and kind words really affects us all..ty man.. nice job..good work
E.B. in Nashville was on fire! Hope we see some more of him. Great playing there, just raw and real.
Good idea for a series Rhett! I'm constantly amazed at the level of talent thats out there. It takes a lot of courage to submit to a critique like this so kudos to all these players. Your tone and playing insights are spot on. Great job.
Love your channel Rhett! Gilmore is one of my biggest heroes. I read an article where Gilmour says that he actually used a Les Paul with P-90's for the solo in Another brick in the wall which is imo one of the best solos ever played. The same guitar is used for "On an island". All the best! //Pontus
So exciting to see Rhetts tips, tricks and advices applied to "real world“ scenarios.
I ´d love to see it going. Top innovative format - thanks Rhett
Love this video Rhett. Very good players out there. Like the approach of how your building people up not tearing them down.
This is a great video. Its awesome seeing the players and other styles. It’s also great hearing the praise and constructive notes.
I am 57 years old and Rhett, you are my favorite guitar instructor! I have been following your channel since you pretty much started and only had 30.000 subscribers. Enjoyed the journey with you all the way!
Thanks Kevin!
Where can I submit my guitar tone video ?
This is super interesting to watch
I love that you're helping these people out and not just roasting them like so many other people that do this format. That just says a lot about the kind of person you are, that you want to help them and love to contribute and lift people up. Keep doing what you do.
Man the swampy guitar tone parts starting at 14:23 are so rad you killed it !
thx for the great content, peace from Paris, France
Love this series and what you’re doing here! Absolutely perfect idea. I really appreciate your honest critiques Rhett. I think it means a lot for all of us as guitar players and enthusiasts.
The Beauty and the beast guy should post the full performance. Superb playing and voicings
Great idea. This helps us think about how to improve our own playing and tone. Thanks Rhett!
This is going to blow up 👍🏻 great idea and your scoring is hilarious. ❤️ it!
Great stuff, Rhett! Every now and then we need to be reminded that ALL GUITAR PLAYING IS BEAUTIFUL! Whether it's a seasoned pro or a beginner 8 year old banging on an A power chord through a solid state amp with a 6 inch speaker, IT'S ALL BEAUTIFUL!
Awesome video idea and I hope it becomes a recurring thing. So fun to see all these talented people getting to share their work.
Her huge props to everyone who submitted!
I am working while listening to this, when that guy with the strat started ripping the blues, I got goosebumps, I immediately had to see him. Reminded me so much of SRV. Fantastic player!
Thank you so much!!!!
That rendition of beauty and the beast is absolutely jaw dropping
Great concept - I really enjoyed it!
People did really good, and it's great to see what other players are coming up with!
Your tips and opinions are great too, and I'm sure we can all learn a lot from it - so please do keep this concept going!
Have a great weekend!
Definitely do more of these episodes. Really enjoyed it.
Hey Rhett, thank you for doing this and giving anyone who wants to send a vid in a chance, from all different levels/styles and settings. A really constructive fun thing to do. Really appreciate it.
Fantastic video, super interesting, definitely would like to see a series made of this.
Well done! Your perspective on the audio clips provided useful insight. The variety of styles in the video demonstrate the range of your community. Music brings people together.
I think you hit an interactive way to engage your subscribers and give up valuable advice from your experience. Because it is so positive; it sets yourself up as being very different than the usual negativity. I give it 10 out of 10 Beatos.
Great idea… I love this. Showcasing folks and some good constructive feedback too. Nice. 👍
As primarily a drummer, I was most excited to see what unit of measurement you picked for each example.
Very nice. It takes some confidence to even send in a video, so I'd say awesome job to all these guys! Great critiques on your part as well Rhett! You definitely understand tone and what kind of tone is appropriate for what you are trying to convey. Very good points about digging in deeper with a heavier touch on that Gilmour brick in the wall part 2 solo.
Hope you do more "Rate my tone" videos. Lots of great unknowns out there, I really enjoyed watching these folks strut their stuff.
I got chills and almost cried when I heard Ian Bennet's tone and playing, that was just fantastic! It's how a strat should sound
Excellent. It's great to hear you break it down and offer some insight. Kudos to everyone who contributed their vids.
Do more of these please!
I like it ! Very informative comments from Rhett. My comments to all that submitted there videos!!!
Cool premise for a series. Loved it!
Love this! Definitely gets my vote to see more of
Nice guitar symphony no. 2. Daniel. Great job.
This is my first comment although I've been watching for a while. Please do more of these, and, thanks for sharing your knowledge and experience with us. :)
Dude these were great. Would definitely love to see more in the future!
Would love to see more of this Rhett!! Keep killin it
Thanks for including my video. I enjoyed the whole video, lots of great players out there!
Thanks for submitting Sam!
@@RhettShull BTW sorry for not including any background info, your analysis was pretty spot on. It was a lawsuit era Ventura ES175 copy through an HX Stomp. I recorded it just after I got the guitar back from having a re-fret and having the stock pickups swapped out for some Gibson 57 classics that were sitting in the closet unused.
Rhett, as a new subscriber I am impressed (blown away) with your expertise and focus in getting to the heart of TONE. I loved hearing the various submissions and your excellent and constructive feedback. Your critiques are spot on and with each player you highlight what each player could do to make their tone even better. I would be so intimidated to send in one my tunes but I love to learn and explore what others are doing. I think you've hit on something really solid with this Submit Your Tone - keep doing it.
You should DEFINITELY do more of these!!!
Great to see so many exercising their talent. Well done, all.
Super cool series, hope to see more of this!
WOW!!....there are so many talented and creative people out there...we gotta get this world fixed so we can get out there and enjoy all these great things!!!!.....thanks Rhett...great vid!!!!
Love that slide tone at the end - beautiful guitar too
I love how you picked a very diverse range of players and styles. Your experience as a teacher shines through too. 🙂
Not sure how the heck I missed this, wish I had been able to submit! As always, incredibly humble and great advice Rhett, I look forward to seeing more
the ratings were spot on. I really liked this video, please keep doing it
I’d like to catch the next one! Very cool and fun to see other musicians on your shared platform.
Great idea having listeners engaging more closely with your channel. Really like your supportive suggestions to the submissions, this is good teaching. Great stuff Rhett really enjoy your videos :)
Way more of this! The interaction between you and your subscribers is so good to watch and the great constructive critisism (and Belle's explosive feathery hats) make this a great one! "Reaction" videos with a Rhett twist. Superb!
This was fun! I'd be happy to see another episode of these :)
Very cool these players put themselves out there like this and I think overall it proved that tone is in the hands
Really love seeing some good professional feedback. You have good things to say and give everyone something to work on. Makes me wish I had you as a guitar teacher.
I'll give you 9.5/10 Shull's Skulls. Well done. Your critiques were thoughtful and well intentioned. Want more!!
Super cool video concept Rhett. Would love to see more episodes like this.
Brilliant idea, reaching through the screen and showing interest in what your viewers are up to.
Good subject Rhett, I liked that you gave the unknown players a chance to see what they have for Tones and sounds . Very cool, ! Thx
Loved this. Had a fun community feel to it. Thanks Rhett.
Thinking about plinking! Cheers Rhett!!
Great examples. Thanks to all who submitted for our education!
Congrats to all the players. I really enjoyed the arrangement of Horace Silver’s “Peace.” One of my favorite standards.
Love this eye opening vids, the comments on the swampy guitar tones was so inspiring!
It's great that you not only gave a rating but some feedback on what they did well and where they could improve. Of course these things are all subjective but feedback like "doing this will make it sit better in the mix" and that sort is all super positive and effective. Great video Rhett!
Rhett, this was fantastic. Lots of useful reactions and most of all, you sharing the ways in which you evaluate tone, style, and performances overall. Short video but loads of content. Also hugely entertaining!
More, more....
Super great. I LOVED YOUR PERCEPTIVE COMMENTS. Please do more of these...I would like to submit!
Super cool people, super positive feedback. Great video, man. Thanks
I think that this is a great idea for a series. A good opportunity for suggestions, and a good showcase of some people that have enviable tone to aspire to.