Without Religion, Would We Still Believe In God? | Thought Experiment With Guru SakalaMaa

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 64

  • @Suyash965
    @Suyash965 21 день тому +30

    Even if somebody is raised in a box where these metaphysical concepts can't infiltrate his mind, there will be a time eventually, when that person will start questioning why and who put him/her in that box, what's the purpose of his existence. He/She will develop his own theory of some superbeing who put him there. Seeking answers to such philosophical questions is an innate attribute in all humans capable of reasoning. This is what actually happened to us, its just our box is a big one. There is a creator, formless or form doesn't matter.That's my outlook on this anyway.
    EDIT - just remembered a beautiful quote of Nikola Tesla, "My brain is only a receiver, in the Universe there is a core from which we obtain knowledge, strength and inspiration. I have not penetrated into the secrets of this core, but I know that it exists.”

    • @ThatBeing.
      @ThatBeing. 14 днів тому

      Your answer seems more wiser than her🤟😂

  • @raghavendravishwanath3265
    @raghavendravishwanath3265 20 днів тому +9

    What is the use of trying to understand all the things discussed here.
    I feel ,as long as you do not harm anyone ,you are a good human being .

    • @Suyash965
      @Suyash965 20 днів тому

      Evolution bro. We are designed in that way by nature. Evolution isn't just physical, it's mental and spiritual also.Until you reach the highest stage of being or until you realise that physical world is just an illusion and you and God are one, your soul will be stuck in birth death cycle.

    • @religionofpeace782
      @religionofpeace782 19 днів тому +2

      Are you a vegan, an Antinatalist and a minimalist. If not, then you ARE harming others and not a good human being

  • @bhavloves
    @bhavloves 19 днів тому +4

    Ranveer seriously has to bring more spiritual women to this show. Sakala Maa and Maa Gyaan Suveera have honestly blown me away.

    • @paawanarora1111
      @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

      Try listening to Premanand Ji maharaj to get even more blown away

  • @rajarani9172
    @rajarani9172 День тому

    This concept of how man explored or created god explained well by jayamohan one theory is dreams in southern part people still have the experience irrespective of their educational, class or spiritual differences

  • @sahilsahotavlogs8464
    @sahilsahotavlogs8464 18 днів тому +2

    Ranbeer after listening your question I can say, enlightenment or oneness can’t be easily understood doesn’t matter how many people you talking to,
    There is no ranbeer, no trees, no greenery.
    Ranbeer don’t talk to anyone stay alone and observe the way things are.

  • @mituacademyofmusic9284
    @mituacademyofmusic9284 16 днів тому

    The power is within us. To control the society God had to be created by some very very intelligent beings.

  • @sagartubeless
    @sagartubeless 20 днів тому +7

    Nikhil kamath disrespected World champion legend Vishwanathan Anand in a charity game in chess by cheating and he is your friend! Birds of the same feather flok together😂

  • @Konklish.
    @Konklish. 19 днів тому

    Was very interesting.. Thank you..

  • @thabassumnazeer2528
    @thabassumnazeer2528 20 днів тому +1

    Vaasana is flair. Something you are born with and starts to express when its time. In our local languange, we say that child has born with the vaasana for singing, dancing, cooking etc etc. So knowingness of God is in humans' vaasana. Nobody needs to tell you about God to know God. In order to believe that God is in a particular way, you need religion. Without exposure to all these outside belief system, humans are born with the vaasana of knowing God. You will know God and need not believe in it. Seeking is the result of the vaasana

  • @Sumeetkakodkar
    @Sumeetkakodkar 20 днів тому +1

    It’s quite natural for NK and RA to be intuitive and have such questions. NKs Bhagyank is 2 and RAs Moolank is 2. Such people are not atheist but tend to be agnostic as they need some sort of proof to believe in existence of anything.

  • @shivakumar511
    @shivakumar511 8 днів тому

    God created by intelligence🎉 it is a self image of himself

  • @Writer198
    @Writer198 21 день тому

    Amazing revelation🙏

  • @matt-r6c3z
    @matt-r6c3z 15 днів тому

    Religion evolved when humans evolved. Humans probably needed a moral discipline and moral judge(Religion and god respectively) to preserve and continue our own species. This applies to early humans such as hunter-gatherers, tribals, and some social animal species. The central idea is to preserve your species. Religion is the well well-organized, institutionalized discipline by present-day humans. Depending on the faith you were reared in, your brain has a classical conditioning for religion and God. I also feel there may be psychological benefits in having false beliefs such as religion which answer the question of our ultimate reality known as death without offering any proof of significance, Everything around you, including God, Heaven, and Hell, is merely a construct image of our thoughts. Nothing would be around us if that thought did not exist (A frightening concept). Guru Maa gave a clear explanation without endangering the believers.

  • @shawrove
    @shawrove 16 днів тому +1

    Vaasana means softer form of desire!

  • @AYooloo
    @AYooloo 20 днів тому +1

    Stonehench and native indian has a Ancient Vedic connection to Indian culture and history

  • @dr.priyankapathak1212
    @dr.priyankapathak1212 18 днів тому

    Superb🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @ThatBeing.
    @ThatBeing. 14 днів тому +1

    Haha...he was gonna ask something else however, she interrupted and he just couldn't figure out where the conversation is going😂😂

  • @binucheriyan4492
    @binucheriyan4492 13 днів тому

    Tendency to humanise God is hardwired in human mind.

  • @Tonixs.fx123
    @Tonixs.fx123 18 днів тому

    Ranveer, am totally surprised when you said citizen of Ghana has a different vasana than a citizen of afghanistan. Watching from Ghana here but am a citizen of Bharat not Ghana😊

  • @paawanarora1111
    @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

    Tell Nikhil Kamath to listen to Shree Premanand Ji Maharaj with an open mind and heart and he’ll be able to decondition himself from himself ✨

  • @satish1012
    @satish1012 19 днів тому +2

    If a person who has been blind, deaf, and mute for 30 years suddenly gains their senses and has no prior teachings about God, what would their thought process about the concept of God likely be?
    God is human concept, it is our image. It may not be animal's concept

  • @krishnanmattummal1338
    @krishnanmattummal1338 14 днів тому

    Semitic Religions force people to BELIEVE in the existence of Creators.😮
    Spirituality enables Seekers to REALISE the cause for Creation.😅

  • @zam1475
    @zam1475 17 днів тому

    GOD IS MADE IN THE IMAGE OF MAN OR MAN IS MADE IN THE IMAGE OF GOD....🎉 A SLIP OF TONGUE MAYBE

  • @manashbarman273
    @manashbarman273 19 днів тому

    Bring ABHIGYA ANAND next

  • @krishnarajshekar9829
    @krishnarajshekar9829 19 днів тому

    Nikhil kamath happy birthday even though it's belated

  • @shivakumar511
    @shivakumar511 8 днів тому

    Box theory itself is a human's false concept, people always governs respect to things which helps him directly visibly and later it helps him to decode microlevel and it go on as per his perception

  • @DasGemsStones
    @DasGemsStones 11 днів тому +1

    Vasana × Gut bacteria 😂

  • @paawanarora1111
    @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому +2

    Never watching another podcast of this guy specially so called SPIRITUAL ONES as after doing 100 of them he asks questions like Does God exist, if you are confused about this tf were you doing all these podcasts for, you confused boy ? All this love for Sanatan Dharma just for name and fame eh ?

  • @paawanarora1111
    @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

    After hundreds of spiritual podcasts for fame behind the name of spirituality my boy asks DOES GOD EXISTS 😂

  • @JMoni-h5u
    @JMoni-h5u 21 день тому +1

    4:06 WRONG " So God made man; in the image of God He made him"

    • @Gorchellyess
      @Gorchellyess 20 днів тому +1

      Thank you so much! What nonsense is she saying. 😂People need to stop twisting the written word, whatever form it may come it.

    • @raviteja8137
      @raviteja8137 20 днів тому

      In India we made gods, god has not made us ,

    • @Gorchellyess
      @Gorchellyess 20 днів тому +1

      @raviteja8137 That's not the point. She said that this was written in the bible that 'man made God in his image'. That's not what is written in the bible. What is written in the bible is as JMoni-h5u said it.

    • @Suyash965
      @Suyash965 18 днів тому

      @@Gorchellyess maybe she just couldn't remember it correctly, that's it. What really matters is what she's trying to convey. Correct her but don't criticize her.🙂

    • @ragulkuppa1018
      @ragulkuppa1018 18 днів тому

      @@Suyash965 she doesn't have to correct it... its just professional mistake anyone can do it... she is not here to promote Christianity if someone wants to learn about Christianity they can always learn for respective teachers.

  • @thuptenkunzes584
    @thuptenkunzes584 18 днів тому +1

    Ranveer
    Please don't bring china people. You read more about Tabit and you talk ok.

  • @mituacademyofmusic9284
    @mituacademyofmusic9284 16 днів тому

    Fear created God I think.

    • @satish1012
      @satish1012 16 днів тому

      Two things as per JK
      Fear and Desire of humans created God
      If you don't have Fear and Desire, you don't need God
      You can prove this experimentally , you ask any person who prays worship god, there 2 things will always prevail
      Fear - Fear of job, Fear of Future, Fear of death
      Desire - Desire for promotion, desire for cars and bungalows and desire for heaven

  • @GKBsince
    @GKBsince 20 днів тому +1

    Im wondering, the question itself invalid, why would you believe anything. If you believe or dont believe how the reality would change. Leave about God's, answer this - "Since you exists so thoughts arises, or Since thoughts arise so you exist ?"

    • @satish1012
      @satish1012 16 днів тому

      Yes
      Don't believe in the believing - OSHO

  • @draw3659
    @draw3659 16 днів тому

    in order To live you must die and to experience death you must live. GOD

  • @deepakrathod6633
    @deepakrathod6633 20 днів тому

    Ranveer for understanding meaning of vasanas you must need to study advait vedanta..I will refer to read a book of Swami Partha Sarathi...vedanta treaties...
    You need to learn lot more I guess according to questions you asked

  • @sharvasmuse6917
    @sharvasmuse6917 16 днів тому +1

    Can you question your speakers to speak in the normal language without using manifestation, consciousness,karma , sanskara -all yogic terminologies! It has to be generic simple explanation where kid should understand, people from any religion, non yogic practitioner should understand . Otherwise you listen and tell it to others , you read book and tell it to others , this cycling process continues!

    • @paawanarora1111
      @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

      Try listening to Premanand Ji Maharaj

    • @paawanarora1111
      @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

      One needs purification to understand spiritual concepts as we are all deluded by this illusory reality which we think to be real

  • @isujalkumar
    @isujalkumar 17 днів тому +1

    God is made in the image of man😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @satish1012
      @satish1012 16 днів тому

      and also women :)

    • @paawanarora1111
      @paawanarora1111 12 днів тому

      Yes because everything is god he is playing himself with himself and who we think we are nothing but an illusion
      Now to understand this do your sadhana and get purified so that you’ll be able to understand and ready to go beyond your mind

    • @tracylynm614
      @tracylynm614 9 днів тому

      Actually, it is that man is made in the image of God.

  • @ChinmayeeAbbey
    @ChinmayeeAbbey 17 днів тому

    Yes God exists...And noone has ever known him- The Real God..The real God only came into our Universe in 2015... Rest Gods of Religion or Gods of Spirituality are none other than Imposter faking to be THE GOD... Ranveer & the team @TRS you have a once in lifetime Opportunity to not only meet the Real God- The Ultimate but also to leverage your platform to take the Ultimate God to the humans..May you have enough God's Grace to discern my message here...I leave it to God...Thank You!

  • @tamilankumar007
    @tamilankumar007 9 днів тому

    Too much running around the bush

  • @thuptenkunzes584
    @thuptenkunzes584 18 днів тому

    I am very hard

  • @isujalkumar
    @isujalkumar 17 днів тому

    UNSUBSCRIBE