The Great Replacement Theory Explained
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лип 2022
- Mr. Beat explains the Great Replacement Theory and how manipulative propaganda fools us into believing white nationalist talking points.
Produced by Matt Beat. All images and video by Matt Beat, used under fair use guidelines, or found in the public domain. Animations by Rob Bellon. Illustrations by Omar K. Music by @ElectricNeedleRoom (Mr. Beat's band), @badsnacks, and @TrackTribe. A special thanks to Define American for support with this video and Shauna Siggelkow, Beth Goldberg, and Brian Hughes.
Sources/further reading:
www.scientificamerican.com/ar...
www.science.org/content/artic...
www.pewresearch.org/politics/...
www.ispu.org/who-are-white-mu...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/arti...
www.thejournal.ie/debunk-flig...
www.snopes.com/fact-check/isi...
www.hamhigh.co.uk/news/camden...
immigrationforum.org/wp-conte...
www.adl.org/resources/backgro...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_R...
www.newyorker.com/magazine/20...
• Paris Train Station Ov...
scholar.princeton.edu/sites/d...
rumble.com/vmvv07-tucker-carl...
nationalvanguard.org/2017/02/...
rhyclearinghouse.acf.hhs.gov/...
For business inquiries or to send snail mail to Mr. Beat:
www.iammrbeat.com/contact.html
/ iammrbeat
Buy Mr. Beat merch:
matt-beat-shop.fourthwall.com/
www.bonfire.com/store/mr-beat/
sfsf.shop/support-mrbeat/
Buy Mr. Beat's book:
amzn.to/386g7cz
How to support Mr. Beat:
Donate to Mr. Beat for great perks on Patreon: / iammrbeat
Donate to Mr. Beat on Paypal: www.paypal.me/mrbeat
Buy Mr. Beat a coffee: ko-fi.com/iammrbeat
“Free” ways to show support:
Subscribe to my channel
Turn on notifications
Like, share, and comment on my videos
Connect:
Mr. Beat on Cameo, yo: www.cameo.com/iammrbeat?qid=1...
Mr. Beat on Reddit: / mrbeat
Mr. Beat on Twitter: / beatmastermatt
Mr. Beat on Facebook: / iammrbeat
Mr. Beat on Instagram: / iammrbeat
Mr. Beat's Discord server: / discord
Mr. Beat's TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@iammrbeat?lan...
Mr. Beat’s website: www.iammrbeat.com/
Mr. Beat's band: electricneedleroom.net/
Mr. Beat's Pinterest: / iammrbeat
Linktree: linktr.ee/iammrbeat
#mrbeat #socialstudies #politicalscience
Mr. Beat’s second channel: ua-cam.com/channels/JYl.html...
Listen on Spotify: open.spotify.com/artist/62BsM...
Mr. Beat favorites:
POP! Icons: George Washington go.magik.ly/ml/11jrb/
Shampoo: rb.gy/vlqeym
Acne fighter: rb.gy/a6dnb0
Wallet: shop.ekster.com/mr-beat2
Recommended books:
Republic, Lost by Lawrence Lessing go.magik.ly/ml/11jul/
Truman by David McCullough go.magik.ly/ml/11jwc/
How the States Got Their Shapes by Mark Stein go.magik.ly/ml/1fdvf/
Command and Control by Eric Scholosser go.magik.ly/ml/1fdvi/
The Age of Fracture by Daniel Rodgers go.magik.ly/ml/1fdvn/
Blowback by Chalmers Johnson go.magik.ly/ml/1fdvw/
The Third Reich at War by Richard Evans go.magik.ly/ml/1fdvt/
Railroaded by Richard White go.magik.ly/ml/1fdwq/
The War on Normal People by Andrew Yang go.magik.ly/ml/1fdwi/
A Short History of Reconstruction by Eric Foner go.magik.ly/ml/1fdwk/
The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt go.magik.ly/ml/1fdwn/
Studio equipment:
Canon EOS M50 Camera EF-M 15-45mm Lens amzn.to/3dcNPen
Samtian LED Video Light Kit amzn.to/3llDwHO
TroyStudio Acoustic Panel amzn.to/33CkqHn
Blue Snowball iCE USB Mic amzn.to/2GseOHa
Affiliate Links:
Useful Charts: usefulcharts.com/?aff=12
Typesy: ereflect.postaffiliatepro.com...
Kids Connect: kidskonnect.com/?ref=iammrbeat
Ekster: ekster.com?sca_ref=444709.jvl...
I use MagicLinks for all my ready-to-shop product links. Check it out here:
www.magiclinks.com/rewards/re...
FTC Disclosure: This post or video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links.
people keep bringing up the fact that italians and irish weren't considered white. but i think the far more relevant argument is the fact that the "one drop rule" is one of the main reasons for statistical democratic shift. if someone has 1 black grandparent and 3 white ones, they are statistically considered black. of course, if you always count mixed people as "non-white", the actual genetic representation of "white people" will be massively underrepresented in statistics.
most african americans have some white ancestry (often through rape of slaves, but often also from times after slavery). by far most "latinos" have strong "white" ancestry, too. so, if we would count them as "partially white", the statistics would look VERY different.
yes, a modern society mixes more, because luckily a lot of us don't chose their partners based on racist ideas anymore. so there are much more mixed people than ever before. so? it's fucking awesome.
Im mixed race. Why am i awesome? Because i dont have a culture or an identity? I feel alone and dont relate to anybody? Theres realy nothing great about it. Its terrible living in such a racist world and not having your own tribe. The liberal white person is the only peeople with no ingroup preference. You will be replaced because you violate the first law of nature, self preservation.
people are fucking stupid, they incorporate dumb physical analogies to their everyday life because their minds are too small to see the world any different , that's why the one drop rule exist, because people saw how one drop of some other color always ruins the white paint, people knew nothing about genetics so they said fuck it we're paint now, we racists now, fuck everybody who says we're not paint.
It is like the Latino deal where they are largely European in ancestry, but not considered white.
Yeah, the one drop rule is also extremely relevant, it's why Obama is considered the US's first black president and not the US's 44th white president, because he's absolutely half white.
@@jeffreyheronemus1917 government created a whole Hispanic identity, just for them
Just wait until Native Americans hear about the "Great Replacement Theory".
okay, justify the white genocide in europe then.
It’s not a theory, it’s a fact for them.
Well, kind of. Most of the American Indian population in North America was wiped out by disease prior to any long term European settlement let alone conquest. This massive plague is sadly rarely talked about due to us having no record of it, but suffice to say some native populations had as much as 90% of people wiped out. So when the Europeans did decide to colonize much of the natives civilizations were pretty much on the brink of collapse and barely holding themselves together and much more land was empty then would have been otherwise. All in all, the situations aren’t exactly comperable.
they are in the very late stages of it, they will be gone very soon.
Of course, it can happen to the "Native Americans" but it cannot happen to whites.
How come refugees are mainly male working age ?
And no women, wouldn't a war not discriminate?
@@Illumirage Actualy it's twice as many men. There are women so that's hardly "no women"
STOP LYING RACIST
@@rn6312 im not lying. A war wouldn't discriminate. Thered be just at many women as men. But there aren't cuz there is no war and this invasion is on false pretenses
@@rn6312it's hilarious how angry a different opinion makes you
Working age men need jobs, you dont find a lot of stable jobs in civil war. You'll find them to be the main immigrant population even between nations of the same race or religion because immigration is seen as dangerous and women are less likely to find minimum wage work than men. If your family needed a breadwinner, theyd be most likely to send their young son rather than your grandma.
Sometimes I wish people still had that childlike sense of love and kindness. The older I get the more bitter everyone seems especially over arbitrary nonsense. If only we could still want to be friends with everyone.
true bro
Children get thrown into vans, and never seen again. There's a reason people target children...
Children are too trusting. Foreigners if given enough power will kill you and steal your country, it is what has happened across history.
@@northseapirate2313 nah.
I saw at first glance how you fuckers treat your own people, and how you treat grouos related to you.
Western European people have raped Europe before they attacked Americas and Africa.
We're all still children at heart; we're just wiser than the new children.
My Mom was a child in Brooklyn NY during the 1950's. She grew up in a Irish Catholic family. Her Aunt fell in love with a man from a Italian Catholic family that lived a couple of blocks away. At that time a marriage between a Irish kid and a Italian kid was considered a bad thing. Mixing I guess. After they got married they were not welcome in the Irish neighborhood or the Italian neighborhood. They ended up moving to Florida to start their family. In 2022 we would think that's nuts. I hope that what we are talking about today loses traction is considered old fashioned and weird in a generation or two. (Hopefully sooner than that!)
And the craziest part about your story is that THEY WERE BOTH THE SAME RELIGION. Yeah I'm glad we have made progress with that.
@@iammrbeat I'm glad that you caught that. My mother also told me that they had two Catholic churches that were close to each other. One for Irish families and the other was for Italian families. My mother was discouraged from visiting the Italian church. I do not understand the argument that all change is bad and everything was better in the past. The evidence tells a different story IMO.
Oddly I don’t think religion mixing will ever be 100% okay with a lot of families. In the 40’s they even the 80’s there were grumblings. I had when I got married in the early 80’s. It’s hopefully changed, but sometimes people need to let other people just be happy.
@@victoriabaker6943 religion has less and less bearing on most people
both of my grandmothers were swiss catholics and both of my grandfathers were swiss protestants. tge grandmothers essentially got kicked out of their families for marrying a protestant.
today, in my generation i havent heard of a single case of anyone careing about things like this anymore.
more and more people are atheist anyway
@@jurgnobs1308 yeah except that it had to do with the culture and not religion. And not many are atheist. A lot of them in europe are Christian and catholic.
Even in Japan they have cultural Christian weddings at churches.
I support open borders and diversity in Israel. It is essential for the development of their democracy!
Israel is pretty diverse, a fifth of their population are Arabs. And their Jewish population comes from all around the world with the predominant Jewish population being middle eastern
@@MohamedAli-nf1rp their nation isn’t diverse enough though. They need to bring in millions of muslims and christian’s and build mosques and churches everywhere so they can be enriched by other cultures and ideas!
@georgelyddane8283 there a ton of mosques and churches in Israel again a 1/5 of the population is Muslim way higher than an European country. You antisemitic people are weird lmao
@@MohamedAli-nf1rp Have you not seen the news in the past 4 months? They're cleansing Palestinians as we speak. Many are talking about migrating them elsewhere in the middle east or Europe and reselling the properties to Israelis
@@jo9932you shouldn't have attacked them unprovoked
As someone who is blind that opening line got me
Wasn't funny and he is right about being not too smart
@@annahawula2427I thought it was pretty damn funny
@@annahawula2427 OK karen.
Leftists are terrible people. There is a reasom they are the only ones that make these kinds of videos and are the only ones in the comment sections of said videos... Its bc yall make this bs up as you go and label it as conservative ideology when really it's all lies and projection. They take the reality of a situation turn it to an extreme radicalize the idea (their specialty along with projection) and turn it loose upon the world. Each leftist is like a tiny one man CNN.
@@theketaminekid1241 OK kid.
Thank you so much Mr. Beat. As a person who fell into this line of thinking once and knows the struggle to get out, it warms my heart to see these videos and wished that UA-cam was full of these when I had my dark times.
Thank you, Noelle. I got caught up in some of it, too, and one day I found myself watching a Stefan Molyneux video and suddenly realizing that the guy was basically a watered down white nationalist. The first video of his I watched and liked was one in which he explained why he was against spanking children, and the next thing you know YT was recommending his racist stuff to me. We all can get sucked in and begin to trust those who have darker ulterior motives. It is nothing to be ashamed of. All we can do is stay curious and continue to try to be better humans.
Good for you for getting out. That takes a certain strength of character that not everyone has.
You have to be able to look in the mirror and tell yourself that what you have been doing is wrong.
Thank you to both of you for having this kind of a honest dialogue. It’s important that White people stand up and confront this type of disinformation within their own communities and families.
@@iammrbeat I think it's great that you're being open about the fact that you got lured in a bit. All too often, the internet expects us all to be moral purists (in one way or another) and it's refreshing to hear someone admit to being misled or lured in by something before they realized how rotten it was.
@@iammrbeat May I ask what was 'the moment" that you realized that and how it happened.
Fun fact: while in the US Italian migration was oftenly perceived as a pollution of inferiors (some even classifying them "non-whites"), in Argentina, Brazil and most of Latin America Italian immigrants were not just welcomed (except for some purists) but invited to migrate, since, according to the Latin American hyperdescent logic of miscegenation, they'd "improve the race".
This is how nebulous the concept of "pure whiteness" is: for Latin America it was all Europeans, for Anglo-America it was only a certain kind of Europeans.
Yep, the term of "Mejorar la raza" its pretty common and usual around here.
@William Pierce wtf are you talking about.
In Anglo-America it is moreso the descendants of the Aryans, which includes native Iranians and North Indians. Don't be fooled into thinking you are dealing with entirely dumb people when discussing genetic ancestry.
@@extremosaur uh. Yeah but they arent white. So doesn't count to the expression.
@@CesarAugustoRocabadoVillegas clearly you don't understand how the people I am talking about define White. It's not literal. Chinese people are white, but not White, get it?
4:18 minor correction, that flag on the left is actually the Ivory Coast flag ( 🇨🇮) not the Irish flag 🇮🇪 ^^
Lol was just coming down to say that!! Nice catch
@msmissy6888 Irish people and people from Côte d'Ivoire care. Mr Beat welcomes corrections when he makes mistakes because he cares about facts and accuracy. Just cus you're ignorant doesn't mean everyone else should be.
@msmissy6888 i care xd
Its for Australians
Barbara Specter
And people if her ilk
Shhhh, don't talk about it for it sheds light on a lot of sensitive themes...
@@lordm1889 Talk anyway
Not evidence
@@soulplexisIt is but hey ignore it
She also stated Jews should accept the hatred since they are behind it all
Trump tweeted something about this once, right? From like an account with the name in it or something?
It makes sense that there is some overlap between support of Trump and this theory, given that especially in 2016, stopping or slowing down illegal (but truly all) immigration of those from hispanic and muslim countries was a top priority. A recent survey also shows that 6 in 10 Trump supporters agree with it, and if Trump didn't literally fully support it, it was a gateway to this type of ideology.
I do remember the sh** hole country thing from January 2018, Trump said a lot of things, he was a right wing populist after all
Yeah he did, wouldnt be surprised if it happened multiple times. Plenty of national candidates and tucker spouting this garbage, things are not looking pretty down here JJ.
Tucker Carlson mentions it frequently.
@@jerkyswiner2158no not really
Thank you for calling out the “normies are cowards, don’t conform” point. “Being unpopular= being right” has unfortunately become a genuine point to gullible people
Yeah but you follow the same opinions of mega capitalist corporations and massive institutions that don't give one shit about you.
“Being popular= being right” has definitely become a genuine point to gullible people who believe in CNN.
@@paulcooper126 he does not, actually your guys only lost support, after corporations realized that democracies are guillible and easy to manipulate as your dicatorships with cowards.
Capitalism is a evil and your guys are angry that they decided to see yourselves as futile
@@gahelo
You sure about that? He’s believing what massive billion dollar corporations and what big finance wants to push out and their agenda. If you can’t see that then you have no idea how anything in this world works. Not much more expected than a blind Bosnian liberal with zero functioning thought.
@@paulcooper126 hmm, they want to make money, this is why capitalism should be destroyed to ensure that their corruption does not enslave us.
You are just futile, this is why your guys lost support
Fellow high school history teacher here. I absolutely love your videos. I showed my students snippets of your House of Representatives calling vid, kids loved it, tried to get them to participate in mock elections. Thank you for being so awesome and providing all of this content that is educational, informative and making things so easy to access.
It's a shame you're indoctrinating children. The great replacement is real just look at the illegal immigrants coming into the USA. They are actively trying to change demographics in Texas to shift voting habits...
@@kingkoi6542they have every right to. They are the original and True Americans
So you are brainwashing children to accept them being stripped of their heritage and all historical legacy and identity destroyed? You are brainwashing them to accept their people being destroyed....you are UNCONDITIONALLY evil
@@supernimo739gaming7AMERICA DIDN'T EXIST BEFORE EUROPEANS BUILT IT😊
@supernimo739gaming7 no they aren't. They came over the ice Bridge
"Coudenhove Kalergi"
NOT a theory....
Leftists are terrible people. There is a reasom they are the only ones that make these kinds of videos and are the only ones in the comment sections of said videos... Its bc yall make this bs up as you go and label it as conservative ideology when really it's all lies and projection. They take the reality of a situation turn it to an extreme radicalize the idea (their specialty along with projection) and turn it loose upon the world. Each leftist is like a tiny one man CNN.
This channel is like hearing my passionate middle school history teachers time travel to right now and break down the world. I love it
"The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory, but it's also happening and you're a bigot if you have a problem with it."
This Algerian (the same people who are shooting up and burning down France right now) is telling us it isn't happening.
Yeah
You didn’t shy away from, “this was me” or “this is what I learned”. Well done. It’s hard to face the vulnerable parts of ourselves and this is a testament to your willingness to say some hard but true things. Thanks for being brave. The internet can be a trash can. Hope you received more understanding than not. 🥰
This isn't true, it's one big cope.
If you want reality - look up what the 1965 Hart-Celler Act is, and what it did to the U.S.
"The Great Replacement is a conspiracy theory, but it's also happening and you're a bigot if you have a problem with it."
Agreed! It is important to give people the tools to recognize when they are being manipulated. Examining memes is also great because the majority of the electorate has never been formally educated on media literacy in the age of the internet and some of the examples are disinformation.
He lied, Mr beet never understood the arguments from the beginning and dishonestly represents the point he wants to attack. Also the replacement theory is obvious, you live it everyday. The longer you live, the more obvious it becomes. This is a propaganda film meant to manipulate people. It's also full of failed tropes...
@@chronometer9931 I’m sorry to inform you, but demographic changes aren’t a sign of a “great replacement”, “white genocide”, nor any of the other euphemisms that have been employed to further white supremacy.
You don’t have to live in fear of non-whites, because whiteness is as arbitrary as detached earlobes or eye color for determining social caste.
"Theory"
Reality
@@AshkanPacino13dont cry when you’re next
@@AshkanPacino13 white people aren't going anywhere. Cope
No, white people exist. Cry more @@AshkanPacino13
@AshkanPacino13 they always will too. Much to your chagrin
Go to London, Amsterdam, Paris, or any Euro capital 20 years ago vs today. It's that simple.
No ones being replaced the white population is still growing rapidly. People around the world are shuffling around to places of opportunity and wealth instead of a third world country
@@I.am.the.real47 No, white people are being replaced and their population dropped by 20 million from the last census to the previous.
I've been to London. I enjoyed being there and hope to visit again.
Went from “It’s not happening” to “it’s happening and it’s a good thing” today
@@AshkanPacino13it'll be funny seeing you get deported
Sounds like climate change deniers
@@keyes858 I don't see the polar icecaps melting.
@@guillermoelnino They want you to remain blind
@@keyes858they want us to not exist. You want that too
“Fellow white people”
Every single time!
A lot of what you discuss is why I love the work of Jennifer Mendelsohn of Resistance Genealogy. She builds family trees of politicians and pundits who are anti-immigration and then explains how the policies these politicians want would mean their ancestors would not have been allowed to immigrate to the US.
I must check her work out! What a great way to confront this bigotry.
But did they come over illegally?
Honestly we need to restrict the large amounts of immigration into this country. Not anyone should just be able to show up because they want to.
@@iammrbeat Your video basically uses a strawman's argument for the Replacement theory. You know the theory is right but do not want to accept that. Immigration does bring replacement. You talk about immigration to the United States, for example. Anglo Americans WERE replaced in areas like New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, and Rhode Island by the Italian immigrants you mentioned. All 4 of these states have populations that are between 15-20% Italian nowadays and Italian American politicians and leaders are ever-present. There are numerous towns/cities/counties that are majority or plurality Italian Americans. In terms of religion, Catholicism is the largest religion in New York, for example. You won't be seeing English cuisine around, or other elements of English culture. Italian American culture along with other immigrant cultures is prominent within this part of the United States.
@@ferrisbueller9991 There were hardly any immigration laws at all until 100 years ago, so nice try.
The difference between a theory and reality is 6-9 months 🤷🏼♂️
Why are you scared of being a minority? Is it because you know theyre treated badly?
@@nathanstorm8093you're literally pushing for genocide ....
@@nathanstorm8093minorities are treated badly in the US? Last time I checked they have every advantage over the majority....
@@Illumirage If that's the case, why wouldn't you want to be a minority?
@@Illumirage womp womp i dont listen to morons who are lying to destroy our liberty. Go cry to big daddy trump in your echo chamber.
Beta physiognomy rarely lies.
Especially voice physiognamy.
Typical case of projection, sad!
@@theketaminekid1241 you're projecting
Our French presidential election had among others 3 themes :
- Le Grand Remplacement (a major campaign theme of Éric Zemmour)
- Le Grand Ruissellement (« the great trickle down economics », promoted by Macron although he spent a lot in aides to fight the inflation, and communist Fabien Roussel talked about the « Roussellement »)
- Le Grand Réchauffement (the emergency of the global warming)
That's really depressing
apparently france is now a complete hellhole though lmao
@@iammrbeat You clearly have not been in european cities recently. As a dutch person i can assure you this agenda is very real. We have small villages with a few hundred people that get swamped by thousands of migrants. These migrants get preferential treatment from the state when it comes to housing and other resources. To lump people who are concerned about this in with white nationalists and nazi's is beyond the pale. These things you dont see on cnn i'm guessing. We dont share your american obsession with race and being "white" whatever that means but we do fear for our children and the safety of our elders. I feel you should visit here and educate yourself on the subject and the policies that advocate for this dissaster.
@@iammrbeat Why isn't mass immigration being accepted into Japan, China, The Middle East? They'd be saying the same thing if they had that. It isn't specific to white people. It's because it is a phenomenon only happening in The West.
Spend money to fight inflation😂 Can you explain?
What is interesting is that people talked about demographic shifts for decades, and not a lot of people cared. It was only when people couched this in terms of framing it as *replacement* that anybody got up in arms about it.
It's one reason why their marketing works
Welcome to politics, it's just a war of words
@@iammrbeat *Their
@@youtubesucks1821 Quite, albeit with oppression and killing when words fail.
@@iammrbeat Yes. George Lakoff points out that the right tends to study business, where they learn marketing, whereas the not-so-right tends to study political science, where they don't. Now, cognitive science, studied by some less-rightists, is *better* than marketing, but see Bayes' Theorem.
Ask RainBolt to find out where the picture originated from
Amazing how people will argue that what we all see is not really happening.
They want to convince you it isn't happening long enough to the point where it's too late to reverse.
Anyone trying to gaslight you that it isn't happening is complicit with ethnic replacement and genocide of western peoples
It literally wouldn’t matter even if it were happening. Race is a social construct that doesn’t mean anything. You might as well whine about people with naturally straight hair being “replaced” by people with naturally curly hair or something.
@@uhlan30
@uhlan30 if race is a social construct, why are there hate crime laws?
@@IllumirageEthnic cleansing requires actual living human beings to be actively purged, not just people dying of old age naturally without passing on some meaningless biological trait like skin color.
And I don’t know what point you’re even trying to make with your second reply. It’s entirely possible to be hateful against someone based on a purely socially constructed identity.
Gotta thank my dad for how he educated me,being half japanese when I was younger I didn't understand why he showed me a video and explained about japanese war crimes and how terrible they are until I grew up and had knew that if it depended on my grandmother I'd never been born cuz she was against my dad "tainting the bloodline"
That still is a different example for what happens in america and those replacement theories but the end result is about the same thing in essence,just old people trying to make the world stagnate.
@William Pierce
Muh age William pierce whose now 90 and also has been gone for the last 20 years
Your grandmother was right.
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva no, she wasn’t
@@aleanajadeskywalker Cry about it.
@@HighFlyingOwlOfMinerva Bet you're a weeb who wish you were born in Japan or something 🤣
This type of critical thinking and media literacy needs to be woven into the school curriculum so that more people are equipped with the skills to easily decode the dog whistles.
You meant you need basic critical thinking, which would lead anybody to believe this is true rather than be a brainwashed NPC
@@paulcooper126 nah
@@paulcooper126 you’re right
It ?is not ´critical thinking´Mr Beat the low IQ you would not leave your kids with the creep deadBEAT, parrots a boring narrative. Throw in any valid evidence to the contrary, and you are met with the usual: It is a right wing conspiracy, your a fascist/nazi and so on, zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. This insect, in another segment, alluded he was intellectually superior to Ben Shapiro and Dr. Jordan Peterson. Whitey, please
@@paulcooper126 Correct sir
"theory"
@@AshkanPacino13 that's because you're psychotic and genocidal.
@@AshkanPacino13 OK, well when the rubber meets the road you're in for a rude awakening.
Psychopathy and being genocidal mean nothing when you have no testosterone to back it up you low test, 120 pound little boy
@@AshkanPacino13 Oh look, another racist democrat....
@@AshkanPacino13ok racist
@AshkanPacino13 referring to whites as barbarians isn't racist?
Mr. Beat how are you doing, here's a question does it ever occur that this type of hatred is still happening?
When immigration rates surpass birth replacement rates, the demographic faces a significant risk. It's a straightforward reality. Doesn't sound like pure hatred to anyone with a brain.
Can someone to explain to me how Luton being 31% White British, Slough being 35% White British, London being 37% White British, Leicester being 41% White British, Birmingham being 43% White British, Luton being 46% White British, and Savile Town, famous for being the most ethnically-homogenous place in the country, at
Go away. George Orwell was a socialist, and he wouldn't agree with your assessment.
There isn't an explanation, because it's the objective truth. I'm in Stuttgart, so I feel your pain.
The UK has been a melting pot since Roman times. Also homogeneity is bad because it makes you more ignorant and stupid.
@@RBEmpathy I don't care if George Orwell would agree with me, or if he was a socialist or not.
We are currently being gaslighted about what's happening. We're either told "It's not happening!" or "It's happening...here's why it's a good thing!" Schrödinger's Mass Immigration, if you will.
We're being gaslighted by the mainstream media and told what we see happening all around us isn't happening, we're being told to reject the evidence of our eyes and ears, which makes the Orwell quote fitting.
@@A-Young-Philosopher It's been happening before I was born, and will happen long after I'm dead.
It's so noticeable that when me and my family would go in the car to Dewsbury, Thornhill and Savile Town, we'd play a game called 'Spot the White man' where you'd just try to see any White people as you passed through. We never counted more than 10, let's put it that way.
Those towns look like Pakistani Muslim enclaves now. Savile Town, one of the most infamous towns for this, is less than 2% White British, according to a census that's 11 years out of date.
Traditional English pubs and churches are closing down because alcohol is haram in Muslim culture and Muslims obviously don't attend church, meanwhile it's home to some of the biggest mosques in Europe. There's literally not enough British people there to keep the pubs and churches open. British women are stared at by Pakistani Muslim men for not wearing burqas, niqabs and hijabs. Street signs and shop signs are all in Urdu/Arabic because barely anyone can understand English now. Even some local butchers admit they've never served a British person in their life, because out of 4,033 people (according to a 2011 census), only 48 are White British. And to top it off, 4 out of the 5 'Notable residents' on its Wikipedia page are Islamic extremists and committed suicide bombings/left to join ISIS, and 5/5 of them aren't White British. But yeah, totally not being replaced.
Him saying "goodness gracious" when the image of the KKK slid into frame is absolutely sending me
KKK? You mean the Federal Bureau of Investigation in white robes?
Shit jumped me too 🤣🤣🤣
But he approvingly shows ANTIFA or BLM in other vids. People wake the fxck up, this guy is a shill
The irony Is that probably His democrat ancestors were premium members of the kkk.
they had some extreme views but one thing they got right was racial inter breeding. why should people pollute their bloodline,? very irresponsible.
Humza Yousaf, the Pakistani First Minister of Scotland, openly talks about changing the demographics of the country. It's become very obvious at this point.
@@AshkanPacino13no he doesn't. I think the problem is the racism, most normal people take issue with
@@Illumirageyou just say "nuh uh!" To everyone who says this is not a theory. You must be a damn bot.
Humza yousaf has been forced to resign for making racist comments about wanting to replace white people in positions of power in Scotland.
@@Illumirage shalom!
@@mattl8774 not a theory? I think it's real and happening.
I am loving your channelt thank you so much for bring great factual content.....I have became a big fan of your videos.
I was only half listening when I heard the name "Camus" and I was like "What the hell??? What does this have to do with absurdism???". I had to go back and listen again. Scared me for a bit.
My thought too!
It's sad such a great man's name has been hijacked by such a Dingus.
@@jeffersonott4357 Very true!
@@jeffersonott4357 absolutely
I was like "well tha beach scene in the stranger was kinda sus" so it kinda bummed me then he said 2017 so i got happy cause i likey liked the stranger
"We don't need to fear each other. We just need to get to know each other."
Subscribed.
Twitter never learns that message sadly
You people keep saying this as if Detroit doesn't exist.
This is anti-human and anti-nature. You cannot denazify nature. You know for a fact this uncontrolled stream of immigration is only happening to European countries.
yeah except, only westerners wantto know others. It is not about race, it is about destructive cultures being imported. Destructive? yes, that is why they leave. And stupidly bring the stupidness with them.
@@jackdeniston59 It is about race you idiot. If White people cannot say “this country is only for us” than we will literally not survive into the future. Life is about blood and soil. Don’t let these leftist degenerates scare you into not speaking the truth.
I honestly have to thank you for this, I come from the rural south and left my home. I appreciate you just taking such a strong ultra fact oriented breakdown that’s so undeniable and understandable. I left my home because of what’s happening and how it affected my life. So thank you. None of us are perfect but I can tell you strive to be good.
Fake comment
@@Illumirage said the bot sheep. Go look into some conspiracy theories or something bud!
@@rickkroll what about me screams "bot"?
@@Illumirage your mindset is a bot sheep mindset. Youre inflicted with conspiracy contrianism. You think just because you have an unpopular opnion that makes it right? You do understand how society works right? The greater will of the people outweighs your small opinion. If you ever listened, instead of talking, you might actually learn something about yourself. What youve been lead to believe is a lie. Those people, that you cheer on, dont have your intrests in mind. Fox Entertainment is run by rupert murdoch, billionare. Trump, anti union anti labor anti work, also a billionare. Im sure youve been taught people dont deserve to make a living wage but the CEO billionare on top worked SO hard. Not off the backs of others. Youve been feeding at the trough as if youve found something real. Youve been filling your brain with soup instead of life and knowledge
@@Illumirage Im woke. If that means i stand up for minorities, that i support trans rights, if that means i think the rich should be taxed fairly, that women deserve equality, and we should all be able to thrive with the resources the USA has. Yet were all last place, banks get bailed out, rich people dont even pay taxes becuase of loopholes. You dont understand you pay more than donald trump in taxes. He gets to write off millions in properties, "expenses." That system is broken. Wake up. Thats what being woke means. It means not being blind
The last thing you said was the best: "Let's just get to know each other."
Great video!
Fake comment
And if I don't like them then?
Okay we get to know each other, we decide that we don't like them and want them to leave oops! they say it is their country now!
Mr. Beat, this is a provocative issue but props to you for making a video like this. Good job!
Thank you, Abe!
@@iammrbeat Thank you for your excellent videos!
You are great Mr. President
@@zainmudassir2964 Thank you!
See any good plays lately?
This video seem to tackle the more extreme and conspiratorial versions of this, but as a European, coming from a Swedish city that used to be ~95% sweds some 40 years ago (most of these 5% from neighbouring countries), and today have nearly 50% foreign born (mostly from mideast, Afghanistan and Somalia), the change is very much noticable, and its difficult to not admit these ideas come from an actual and real problem at its core.
To say 'the values are already similar, thats why they come here' is a common talking point in Sweden too; but theres little reason to believe this at all true, at least here, and a lot indicating it usually isnt.
The very secular and freespirited cultural style of Sweds, and the very religious, conservative and family controlled cultural style of these regions doesnt always go hand-in-hand, and motivation for picking our country specifically tend to be due to economic safety, not values. The cultural values of sweds are usually viewed as something weird and foreign; a strange enigma you're curious of but knows little about, or something already concluded to be immoral that you ought to avoid being tainted of.
In difference to the US, there is no tradition of multiculturalism here, but rather of a strong monoculture. We were a single people, with a single party (in power), with a single TV-channel, for a really, really long time. As more migrants enter a neighbourhood, Sweds tend to leave it to live locally in the monoculture they are used to; and migrants tend to pick neighbourhoods where they know someone from their home country. As a result, segregation is intensified and integration or assimilation becomes very weak, and plenty of neighbourhoods and schools in my city has no ethnic sweds at all anymore. At most, they are integrated though children of past migrants (who themselves have few or no Sweds in their social circles). To contemplate the "replacement theory", you only need to ask yourself; 'what if this trend continues, for another 40 years...?'
The talking point of 'whites are being exploited' goes back to the motivation of picking a country like Sweden; economic safety. We have a massive wellfare state, and very welcoming rules. When a group who didnt contribute to the wellfare system, then have really low employment numbers and live off it; its hard to not say that there is no exploitation in that. The average for a migrant from these regions is 8 years, until they had their FIRST job... That's a lot of years on wellfare. More than most Sweds have in their lifetimes... To put it simply; if the demographic trends of my city were to be extrapolated to the whole country, maintaining a wellfare state of the standard we´re accustumed to, would be utterly impossible. It only works now due to a system of local government wealth transfer; if not we would sit on a near 30% citybudget deficit. (City in question is Malmö, third largest city in Sweden.)
One can and should avoid the harsh and racialized terminology of "white exploitation/replacement" and the likes of it, while still recognizing that there are real and difficult problems at the core of this, which cant just be sumarized as some fake populist conspiracy theory. Below that conspiratorial surface, real problems are festering and growing; and the unfortunate fact is that high migration is exacerbating those problems.
Yeah if people don‘t actively seek relations with people of other races assimilation will not happen.
Literally hit the nail on the head. Both proponents and opponents of the "Great Replacement Theory" do a disservicee to the truth because the name makes it sound like some grand white-supremacist conspiracy theory. We can denounce the conspiratorial aspects of the issue while still acknowledging very clear data that shows a huge demographic shift in countries where that might've been unheard of.
You're about to be given a master class in cognitive dissonance...
"Nothing happened last night in Sweden. Nothing ever happens in Sweden; it's Sweden..." The BBC.
And the proof for all this bullshit your spewing is...........
I'd love to see how African and Asian countries would react if they had to deal with a huge influx of Europeans, to the point that they were outnumbered in their own communities.
@@AshkanPacino13 how are the creators of the modern world "barbarians"?
white people already did this you absolute brain melted dumbass, except they went to these different countries with the explicit plan to colonize and genocide, most immigrants now come looking for work and a place to raise their families
@@AshkanPacino13 psychotic ravings of a genocidal, racist madman
@@AshkanPacino13so no answer still, got it
Lol not yet.
I love the ending line of this video, it’s so simple but in a way very profound. I’ll be using “we don’t have to fear each other, instead let’s just get to know each other”
Let's not
That's how a bunch of Germans felt when they first invited in a bunch of migrants. They welcomed them with open arms and what happened to them? There were mass grapes......
@@Illumirage Yeah yeah we just know you hate anyone who doesnt have the same skin color as you. I treat everyone equally. How about you special ed?
@@Illumirage ur retarded brosef
@@rn6312 No, I just have a problem with instead of "refugees" being grateful for the asylum that they instead grape women....
That isn't cool. Not sure why you're arguing this...
I live in Rochester, NY, me and our greater community has felt so much tension since the Buffalo attack, and I'm sure more diverse communities have felt fear from the growing radicalism in the world.
I greatly appreciate that someone who has a more socially diverse fanbase covered this issue in an effort to combat hatred. I love your content, I binged your SCB series a few weeks back and hope you post more in future.
Thank you so much
So do I I agree
Nice to see another Rochesterian in the comments of Mr. Beat!
pink floyd fan?
Isn't it convenient how you systemcreeps just forget all the black on white crime.
Seriously props to you for making this, I’ve always loved your content but I’ve seen such an improvement in your recent videos in the past couple of months. Keep up the good work.
I appreciate that!
I was intrigued by some of his points so I looked in the description and found *every source* he used. UA-cam videos rarely cite sources so this transparency is definitely a welcome addition. Well done, Mr. Beat.
@David Herschel go away and ask someone who cares about "debates".
@@mistared4021 Yep, I assume you're talking about the "debates" that are just misinformed narcissists talking over and outyelling good-faith and passionate professors who took the time to even show up?
Edit: That's because I've been to one before and got frustrated when that guy couldn't stfu and let the professor speak
@Mr. Beat He's wrong on just about every single point. He's just being dismissive and likely did zero research.
It's not wrong. Even if ppl don't like it
it's an inconvenient truth
@@guillermoelnino Says racists.
@@rn6312 Y ou and all y ou r friends literally laugh about how y ou're doing it every f ucking day.
@@guillermoelnino Who the hell are my friends? I just know you're a shitty racist trying to hide behind a keyboard.
@@rn6312projection
I was taught in biology class that race was just biological variation in a species, like genotypes or phenotypes(physical stuff like skin color or fur color such as the colors of giraffes). No racism or xenophobia in this explanation, just minor genetic stuff with no noticeable effect on one's behavior.
@Tollahvision - The Ayatollah Historically black areas of the US are historically disenfranchised, and even now that racism isn’t so cool anymore, we fail to dig them out of poverty in a couple of generations because our system isn’t very good at giving them the necessary opportunities. There still exist harmful stereotypes of the people in those areas that make people less sympathetic to them.
As for sub-Saharan Africa, the borders of the countries were drawn up by European countries negotiating with each other over resources, not based on the people who already lived there, and their economies were intended to be dependent on their mother country as colonies. Thus, the independence of these countries left behind a patchwork of underdeveloped countries filled with ethnic groups and religious sects that often hated each other. Many were taken over by authoritarian strongmen who took advantage of the chaos to line their own pockets. That’s at least a very oversimplified version of it because each country is different in some way. Rwanda is actually fairly wealthy now, as crazy as that would’ve sounded 30 years ago.
@Tollahvision - The Ayatollah
What about them? All those places are suffering from being affected by years of oppression and segregation, not some case of natural aggression or whatever the fuck you think is the reason
@Tollahvision - The Ayatollah Sub Saharan Africa (and North Africa, not sure what the cause for the distinction is when there are sub Saharan countries richer than North African countries) can be pretty readily explained by both classical colonialism and, more relevantly, neo colonialism sabotaging every attempt to get a functional government set up. China is set to change the balance of power there though. Even if their methodology devolves into the exact same tactics as the west, the existence of a competitor will probably encourage the actual development of the region in order to help get strong allies. It all comes down to political culture, and much of Africa was shot in the foot to begin with when it came to setting up modern states. Botswana stands out has a prime example of a highly developed Sub Saharan country in Africa that has done very well for itself despite its initial status upon independence, due to the strong political culture it exhibited right form the very start.
@Tollahvision - The Ayatollah Look at the statistics on how Nigerians do in the U.S., and ask American teachers what they think of their Nigerian students. Through hard work and belief in the value of education, Nigerian-Americans are on their way to becoming a very successful ethnic group who are contributing immensely to our country.
@Tollahvision - The Ayatollah what not taking material conditions (and, yaknow... biology) into account does to a mf
I'm surprised you didn't mention the shooting in New Zealand that killed people attending a mosque. That event was huge for the Great Replacement Movement online. It also directly inspired other shooters who mentioned him in thier manifestos such as the El Paso Shooter.
Or the one in a quebec mosque by which the attacker admitted to police to be persuaded to believing Replacement Theory from far right internet celebrities.
I’m surprised he didn’t mention the daily harassment of whites by moslems in Western Europe, the rapes of white girls and how they team up to ambush and beat up white boys.
He did it bc of a string of terror attacks committed against Europeans. The media response to those attacks was non existent bc of the ethnicity of the ones committing them.
@@MAN-MILK bruh
Sounds like a fed op
130,000,000+ shouldnt be in America and 10,000,000+ shouldnt be in Britain.
@@AshkanPacino13 all of which will be sent back. Enjoy your last few months here, genocidal racist
@@AshkanPacino13 I'm 6'4". I tower over you, latinX colonizer
@@AshkanPacino13it? You mean they?
@@AshkanPacino13and yeah they will. We've had enough latinX people for one lifetime...
@@Illumirageno way are you calling him a genocidal racist 😭 you’re actually not a real person
The Celebration Parallax
I think that the '1 drop' theory also plays a role in this. That is the idea that if a "White person" and someone of a different "race", or "ethnicity", have children together this means that none of their children or future generations can be considered "White". This is if anything, even dumber than other reasons, but you can see where a belief of this sort could make people fear for the future of "White people".
I mean realistically there's no "they", there is only US. I was typing this while listening to the video, and then you said this yourself, so bonus points for you!
You said one of the quiet parts out loud
@@iammrbeat I certainly did. I think you did a great job on the video, it's important for people to understand this stuff, however unpleasant it may be.
What's crazy is some of the people who subscribe to the one drop rule and consider themselves White may have had ancestors that, by their own definition, were non-White.
@@agentdiamond9211 That is probably even more common than we'd think.
What do people mean when they say things like “abolish whiteness”, then? I mean, there seems to be no confusion about what white is when attacking it, but when running into a defense of it, the common reply seems to be “well it doesn’t even exist so whatever lol”
Matt, as a pragmatic fellow Kansan (KU educated, now in Seattle) I love your intelligent, no-nonsense, straight shooting, equality-based takes on subjects. Thanks for being a positive voice supporting critical thinking for our youth and the rest of us!
Walk into any highschool in the cities of Europe, Canada, Australia, or the US then tell me it isn't real.
@@pooppoop4805I can couch for this firsthand, and I live in a city of 30k. 40% of students (400) are non white
Key phrase critical thinking. These public schools are taking that away from kids so thank you for bringing it up.
Read your bible! (KJV, preferably) ♥
@@abel6298 you mean that book written by men and women with holes in every story that takes away from God? Yeah I’ve read it. It’s probably something republicans need to ban…oh wait they did. 🤣🤣
Loved this video (and many of your videos), Mr. Beat! Thank you for this and for taking on the heavy lift of putting this together!
Bot
@@guillermoelninocry
@@theketaminekid1241 Doesn't it suck that y ou r entire existence revolves around mur dering everybody y ou're told to based on skin color?
Open borders for Israel
"Open Borders for Israel" oh please, you think you're so edgy. Whats supposed to happen, am I supposed to pretend to groan and grumble? Oh! You really got us this time!
Do you think all of us Ashkenazis are interested in Israel? We are comfortable here, in America, we like what we have here. We're not all over there, we are in comfy positions, paying people to work (like you,) after work you go onto our social media platforms, watch our movies, and even your holy book is downstream from our very own ethnic religion. As an ashkenazi liberal, some of us dont even agree or pay much attention to what happens in Israel. Amusingly, you may be on our side on this issue (by accident of course.)
We can take your small "insult" than and then we giggle at your cute little "victory" like a trophy raised over your head. Its almost endearing.
@@SurfbyShootin my comments aren’t for you. I don’t watch movies. I don’t care. Wait until the AfD wins lol.
Lol.
@@chudboreaWhy would they?
@@chudborea???
Really appreciate you putting this positivity into a space so often filled with the opposite. Hope all is well! (PS, still got my ENR sticker on my bumper)
"They cannot replace us... Because they are us."
Wew, if only Israel subscribed to that same idea.
Ohohoho we don't talk about that here, its politcal friendly space !!!
based
Yes this applies to Jews as well,
Open borders for Israel but unironically.
Diversity and race mixing for Israel.
You mean the same country that actively supports the anti immigrant, racist, white nationalist regimes in Hungary, Poland and Brazil?
Another banger mr beat, I always enjoy your historical and political vids please keep it up!
You're just as delusional as this liar Mr. Deadbeat.
Braindead troll.
@@jimeatscorn6628
I come from Uruguay a small white country from south america and the native black african population was always less than 5% yet they get special quotas. Our country never had racial issues yet left and right do this all the time. We now have to take care of central americans all the time. Even here we are isolated and not in a good position economically but we need to keep taking people in. Why? Why always nations with white people are forced to take foreing people?
@@AshkanPacino13 Ah yes we uruguayans alone caused the colapse of central america. Also we are so evil that they risk their lifes to live among us. Also by that logic you should be punished also for the crimes your ancestors did...
@@AshkanPacino13 My ancestors came here fleeing the industrial revolution. They came worked and integrated themselves into society. They did not come here looking for welfare and entitled to place and keep on divinding us socially. We didnt have gangs carrying machetes now we do. Also our country was founded on masonic interest. If you know our real history and want to get mad be angry at masonic interests. After all it was a masonic general that killed all of the native people. But I dont know why I bother writting this you just want to be mad at white people. Generational revenge its what I get from you...
@@AshkanPacino13you won't be getting anything except a much smaller paycheck when you are sent back
@@AshkanPacino13 what did i personally start exactly?
superior to you in all ways @@AshkanPacino13
The mainstreaming of the Great Replacement Theory is essentially the 21st Century version of Woodrow Wilson's New Southern Revisionism. We're closer to 100 years ago than many would admit.
Sad, but true
Also the talking points made by the Know Nothing Party are mainstream with people being very open and proud of their xenophobia
Willlsoooonnnnn!!!!
@@iammrbeat though its kind of expected now considering recent economic issues and a pandemic, usually when the majority has an issue to face they can't comprahend nor understand they blame the minority and outsiders.
It's more the 21st Century version of Hitler's "Lebensraum"-theory, but reversed and more domestic: They pretend to be invaded for the purpose of living space, so instead of invading and conquering they shut out other cultures.
It's sad that we need videos explaining that we shouldn't fear and hate each other because of racial and/or cultural differences. I wish there was a simple & effective way to cure people of this small-mindedness, but it's sort of like "you can't fix stupid". It seems that racists have a sense of pride in their hatred, and I find it difficult to reason with them.
Mr. Beat thank you for taking the time to cover this topic.
I want my kids to look like me. I will date someone of the same ethnicity. Every race is allowed to do it except white people that is where it is demonized and called racist
@@geckoniner5625 If they're your kids they should look sort'a you. You should be able to date whoever will date you. Nobody's calling you racist for that. You're probably getting called racist for something else.
Personally, if I were single again, I'd enjoy dating ladies of various races and cultural backgrounds. (I can't imagine any of them would argue with me any more than the white woman I married 28 years ago.) There are beautiful and special people from all cultures. Understanding and appreciating that fact doesn't mean you can't choose to date, marry, and mate within your own race. It's the prejudice and hatred thing that makes someone a racist.
Now, if you're in the MAGA cult that would automatically make you a racist, as well as a fool.
Yep, like the racist non whites.
@@glennr9913 MAGA aren't even racist, I wish they were.
@@glennr9913 bro no offense to black girls and latinas but trust me they can be a bit crazier lol but that’s mainly from my experience
imagine being afraid that after only a few generations of foreign cultures immigrating to yours, your country will be overwritten and undergo a complete change of the way things work it's not like that happened ever.
Especially not in:
Ireland
England
Scotland
Norway
Sweden
Denmark
Germany
Poland
Russia
Australia
New Zealand
China
Japan
Korea
Taiwan
United States
Canada, particularly in more recent times Newfoundland
Greenland
Mexico
practically the entirety of South America
practically the entirety of Africa and I think particularly Egypt
multiple times throughout the middle-east particularly Israel
The entire Indian subcontinent
Ukraine
Mongolia
Wales
Georgia
many Polynesian islands
obviously many more.
I mean the larger theory surrounding it is pretty xenophobic, racist and whatnot but the fact is all it takes is one generation of people to be disproportionately populated in order to convert the culture. Sometimes it just takes more influential figures. i.e. what happened in Scandinavia when they were converted to Christianity and nearly all evidence of their former religion was wiped out. Another great example would be Ireland when they were converted, even further back and they have essentially nothing to show for the origin of their culture. Finally a more modern take involving more immigration than conquest is the country Wales, most people consider Wales to be a part of England nowadays. Wales honestly seems to have been near entirely culturally replaced/absorbed through immigration. I'd argue that's not really a good thing. But it seems to be what happens to everywhere on earth and has happened everywhere on earth for as far back as we can date. Idk, seems like it'll happen to me. It doesn't seem far fetched to imagine that if one cultural population grows significantly faster in an area than another and has more conservation efforts than another, it will become the dominant culture over time. I mean how do you think China towns popped up all over the globe? In those small areas it seems to be very much a Chinese based culture. That's fine but the fear of cultural overwrite seems pretty valid if a small town can become a city, state or country over time.
I’m not sure you’ve got this 100 % right. And it’s of your talk could backfire and be used to back up bad ideas.
Oh my lord Greek-Americans got a shoutout! Thank you so much! Discussing race as a Greek American is always difficult so I really appreciate just a mention in your video. It means a lot.
@@mangus3433 It's really not an own to go "hey random passerby, do you research everything or are you SHEEP" like people aren't known for just... Passing by.
Believers of the theory are the same way, if you're stupid enough to consider immigration an "invasion" or "replacement". You're doing exactly what talking point #2 is, if you even watched the video.
@@mangus3433
>implying arbitrary xenophobic rhetoric is well-researched and backed up
Eat the Falafel, go to Church, and drink some alcohol. Me IQ is increasing lol
Go and shove a gyro up where the sun doesnt shine.... AND PAY YOUR DEBTS, mykonos
I love to eat your name Fettucine
So your points essentially boil down to "Europeans do not have the right to their native land" and "It is literally impossible for one ethnic group to replace another" even though that exact situation has happened hundreds of times throughout history such as with the Native Americans and European colonists. But it's only a ridiculous and imaginary concern when it's happening to Europeans due to the original sin of being white?
90% of native americans died wich is why thry got replaced. America's ethnicities can not be replaced with birth rates and immigration alone.
@@bryanfongo327 Like Europeans.
YES!🤡
Maybe you did too MANY shenanigans all over the globe and now the globe is doing their shenanigans with you too hahahaha
@@phillipholland6795 true colours shine through, brown jealousy on display
"Its not happening" "okay its happening but not like you think" " its happening and heres why its a good thing"
Yeah it's happening. Multiculturalism is a lie.
This
They’re going to replace what? Your Oligarchs who actually hold power compared to their measly Disney dollars they have like the ones you have in your pockets?
@@zackfrost9541 Westerners
@@zackfrost9541 They're going to replace nobody. People who believe in this theory don't understand math.
During WWII the Army had to establish Japanese language schools, as many AJAs did not have the language skills, in spite of their parents efforts. In the Western U.S. Asians were institutionally discriminated against into the first half of the 20th Century.
There is a great video that talks about part of the subject, it's called "Tribalism: weaponizing culture". One of my favorite videos that breakdown how we fall into conflict of "we and they".
thanks. I'll look it up>
i will never vote democrat based on the 1965 inmigration act alone
@@bryanice3313 We do not care
@@bryanice3313 1965 sure had lots of American xenophobia... Hm. twenty years after the end of ww2. All the baby boomers, just military age, had grown up with all their parents stories of fighting the evil Germans and Japanese.
March 7 - "Bloody Sunday": Some 200 Alabama State Troopers attack 525 civil rights demonstrators in Selma, Alabama, as they attempt to march to the state capitol of Montgomery.
March 8 - Vietnam War: Some 3,500 United States Marines arrive in Da Nang, South Vietnam, becoming the first American ground combat troops in Vietnam.
@@jessielove1252 It is xenophobia to want to have a nation and people?
No.
Half of this comment section is fed bait
Are y ou refering to the half that say its not happening or the half that proves the other half wrong?
Remember, when the infrastructure starts to disfunction badly for the masses, they can't help but get stressed. Governments allowing huge immigration need to invest more in health, water sewage, roads etc, if not people become fearful, depressed and easily manipulated. Also in UK huge amount of housing is needed, and fertile (often flood planes) agricultural land is disappearing fast under huge housing estates, making the country less food self sufficient than it already is. Roads that used to function become gridlocked. Money money money and corruption. one love ❤️
PS all the people's money(taxes) is going into mindless cruel wars, making millions homeless with no understanding or genuine deplomacy. When will people put themselves in their opponents shoes and show some understanding.
While idk how it can work better in some places like middle east and also eastern europe.
(Peaceniks might got triggered...)
It’s not a conspiracy when it’s true and they BRAG about it.
They literally don’t care. They willingly propagate anti-European rhetoric because they want to feel like they’re culturally progressing, even if it means killing their own
lol theyre deleting replies
Who's they?
it's over man.
@@vidarmors Whoever is implementing the algorithm to determine who gets to speak on this forum. They use AI to determine that which violates a particular agenda for the way that a discussion is allowed to happen.
“Diversity enriches societies” then why Japan is so successful ? 🤔
Japan itself is a product of mixed societies.
Also, while certainly homogenous, let's say that Japan is not doing good.
They are a autocratic state, filled with corruptiin, depression and a state of constant fear of people discovering their State criminal actions.
Japan is diverse you dumb mf
@@gahelo It's doing better than your utopia which leads to nothing but destruction. Just look at Chicago.
@@paulcooper126 Hahaha you have 1k+ comments on this channel, most of them probably being on this video alone. That’s kind of sad, I hope you find something more meaningful to do with your life. Best wishes
George Soros approves this message.
He approves of chocolate eggs.
More insane lies about ole George. But it's not the "gotcha" ya'll think it is. You see, he's a Capitalist (aka; right-wing), one of your people. And as an actual Leftist, not a center right-wing Democrat, you can have him. lols
You've just earned yourself a new subscriber, thanks you+
As a young white man growing up in Canada I have noted significant cultural change in our large urban centres. Much of it is great in adding to the enrichment of Canada. Having said that I also noted many of the cities now have communities only populated by specific ethnic groups which some may argue has lead to a balkanization of many areas of the country. I dated gals from Japanese ancestry, Chinese ancestry, India ancestry and First Nation ancestry. The only time I never faced push back from dating these girls was when I dated the Japanese gal. The Chinese family didn’t like me dating their daughter but never openly said anything. The Indian gal told me her dad would literally kill me if he knew she was dating a white guy. The First Nation gal’s grandmother openly stated to me she only wanted her granddaughter “to marry pure Haida”. And yet throughout my life I was always open to other cultures and the enrichment they provide to our society and constantly hear I’m racist because of my colour. So I ask why is racism only discussed in one vein when it’s present in other areas? Racism is racism and trying to claim otherwise is dangerous. But I guess if it works to accuse people of racism to shut down any of their concerns it’s okay. London has changed dramatically and is not representative of the greater UK. The large urban populace in Canada has changed considerably and again is not representative of many areas of Canada. But I guess if anyone questions what’s happening just call them a racist to shut them up.
@@odenoki9571 Multiculturalism didn't fail, because its purpose was always the execution of the Kalergi Plan.
"enrichment"
@@matro2 Can you prove the Kalergi plan?
"questions what's happening" sorry, but this has happened since the beginning of time, humans migrating to other areas. you don't sound too intelligent and likely this energy was not given when white europeans came over and settled in the americas at the expense of native americans (literal genocide and forcible removal from their homes). cope and seethe
@@kennedy3682 Nobody is excusing ANY of the horrible acts of the past (Europeans were not alone in these horrible acts, cope and seethe 🤓). But to say that any European nowadays must pay for what their ancestors might not have even taken part in is so goddamn stupid. When did Slavs colonize anyone besides each other? When did the Irish, Swedes, Norwegians, or Finnish? I can definitely go on. Think critically for once, people like you reveal your own ignorance.
I'm French and the concept of "Great Replacement" or "Grand Remplacement" comes from here. I'm quite familiar with it and I must say there are several mistakes in this video. It is not meant to be a conspiracy by the elites to replace white people. It is meant to be a factual description of the immigration pattern France has experienced in the past 60 years. Besides, race is not necessarily the focus. The concept is associated with cultural replacement. When Mr Beat says it's not grounded in fact, I don't understand his point. There are 6M Muslims in France. Before WW1, there were almost none. There was 1 mosque in France in 1916, now there are 2500. Their impact is seriously felt due to the multiplication of islamic terrorist attacks and higher crime rates.
@àsper citation needed, also IQ is not a reliable measurement for intellect
@àsper do you think london and Europe were "crime free" before the black people came? have you seen the crime statistics in the 19th century? literally, the same talking point was used to justify discrimination by the WEALTHY WHITE ENGLISH AGAINST THE POOR WHITE ENGLISH! LOLOLOL.
Exactly. Although it also replaces people/population too. He knows this, he's just ignoring the obvious facts. Here, when you state these facts it's simply deemed racist to shut down the conversation. With 2 million Illegals per year, there's no denying it.
@@turtlemusic1509 LOL! Still going around throwing out cliche catch phrases at every fact you don't like and social science excuses. This is funny.
@@turtlemusic1509 That's ray-cisms! You can't say that to me. The trauma! 😆🤣
When I first heard of the us being the meltingpod of the world I thought that it was the place where people lived in harmony and respected each other's traditions as long as it didn't came in conflict with the law.
In Russia the problem with migrants is a bit different from the US. Many people from Central Asia come here because they can practice more radical forms of Islam which are strictly prosecuted in their countries. It’s weird to complain that there is too much freedom in Russia but in context of religion it led to growth of ethnic groups engaged in organised crime under cover of semi-legal religious organisations. Fortunately, the situation is steadily improving but the problem of the diasporas helping their members to get away with crimes still remains. Crazy conspiracy theories harm society to talk about real problems
Your Irish Flag was displayed incorrectly. Left to right, the flag displays green, white and orange. You displayed the flag, left to right using orange, white and green. That is actually the Ivorian Flag.
Could be the Irish flag flying to the left instead of the right. Course that would mean very strange cross gale for the Italian flag to point in the opposite direction.
yeah this guy is a stooge, obviously promoted by the fascist communist devs at UA-cam and Facebook
Goes to show how thick he is.He is using a great lie from a debunked Canadian liar named Noel Ignatiev ( a man who hated white people).The Irish issue was NEVER about colour.It was a religious fight the Irish and English took to America.
Really glad Mr. Beat decided to make this video. Back when I was around 13/14 I watched a lot of videos that promoted the great replacement theory, and bought into their narrative. I figured out eventually that the people who advocated for the theory were morons, but I wish I hadn't fallen for it in the first place, so I'm glad this video exists to hopefully keep some other people from falling for it
this says a lot about our education system. America spent trillions on wars in the past 20 years instead of investing in key elements such as education, healthcare, infrastructure and this paved a free green pass for china to rise to the global stage
It is not a theory_it’s just the description of a demographic process. The colonization of america was in fact also a Great Replacement. Ranaud Camus never mentioned any “secret plan” or whatsoever.
Europeans are the indigenous people of Europe, like native-americans in the US.
@@palamededepezenas3452 To some extent, yes, the great replacement theory is just a simple observation of a slow demographical shift, like the birth rates of white people going down while the birth rates of other races go up, and thus the average skin tone of an American getting like 0.05% darker. For the most part though it's just fear-mongering, because at the end of the day as long as you believe in American values then as far as I'm concerned you are an American. A lot of sad, tortured souls find solace and comfort in identifying as a white person since they have nothing better to identify so strongly with, and as a result they find it comforting to join cool hate clubs online. It's sad that people buy into the Great Replacement Theory, but I expect nothing less from people who were promised the American Dream and instead got chewed up and spit out by the capitalist system. The urge to blame our misfortunes on others is something we all have to struggle not to do, and not everyone is successful in that. That is why as times get tough, the economy goes down, the future looks bleak, and so on, people turn to tribalistic fearmongering such as the Great Replacement Theory.
@@palamededepezenas3452 no. It’s not just a description. It’s a warning and a call to arms to prevent a feared demographic change under the guise of that change destroying our national strength.
Explain the economic collapse due to increased immigration
This take down of the theory was very well done, it also applies in all directions. We see folks casting judgments over others, assuming guilt, based on European ancestry. If taken to its full conclusion, this ruins the notion over colonization too, and using such things to cast blame on people today, based on color and ancestry. I think the lesson is to treat individuals correctly, until you are proven otherwise.
Except he didn't take anything down. You praise propaganda
@@IllumirageGuess you just didn't watch the video then.
@@El_Crononauta this video is propaganda....
@@Illumirage I could practically say the same thing about..... anything?? It's a matter of perspective. You've already made up your mind, anything that you disagree with you view as propaganda. The video actively broke down the nonsensical theory and explained why it's harmful.
@@Illumirage Every word you spit out is propaganda
Commenting because I’m from London and all these points have made my city unsafe and so much worse
London was never that good tbh
@@Notreallyhereanymore 80s/90s London was genuinely the city people still think it is today mate. Used to be one of the best mate
This man content is trash and he lives in a bubble
More importantly london didn't have an afrocentrised glorified crime culture when it was white
wrong it's because of the bad policies your politicians have put in place, and also the systemic racism that didn't allow certain communities to integrate which lead them to crime, at the end those criminals are British and you're the reason they became like that and even their crime culture is British made, so take accountability instead of just being racist and xenophobic
“They can’t replace us because they are us” simple yet holds a very powerful message
No I am a European genetically, they are not. I want absolutely nothing to do with them, and the white majority that doesn’t want to be genocided isn’t just going to let nerdy little shills gaslight us into accepting it. No White protection, NO peace
No they're not. Breeding a race out of existence is not good
UA-cam has hidden comments
Wow, you’re such an intellectual. It’s not like people are made up of things that form their identity. Being American certainly isn’t one of those things, who on this planet uses their nation to identify themselves…pfff….losers.
Make an actual argument next time instead of linguistic red herrings. We are being replaced.
Am I missing something? Non-Hispanic Whites have gone from ~90% of the U.S. population in 1965 to 57% in 2022. Seems like they are getting replaced.
Excellent content. Thanks for making this.
19:15 "The picture was actually taken in 2012 and had nothing to do with the refugee crisis". You didn't mention what it *did* have to do with. Just curious.
Wow I didn’t think I would be Rick Rolled by Mr. Beat 😂
How?
@@sageex3931 oh it’s there. 😂 Haven’t seen the video in a long time, but I believe it’s a QR code.
The great replacement is not happening, and it’s good that it is happening.
If it *IS* happening, wouldn’t that mainly affect the minorities that mate with the majority more than said majority?
What he said at the end might be the most important point: "they" can't replace "us", because they are us.
@@PeaceOfMind8190 The white percentage of the population in the US in 1960 was 88.6%, compared to today's percentage of 59.3%. Since 1990, the US has accepted an average of one million legal immigrates (Not including refugees and asylum seekers) each year. The overwhelming majority of them coming from non-European nations with no sign of the current government and its party slowing down immigration now or in the foreseeable future; even though the current mass immigration has irrefutably negatively impacted important issues such as the housing crisis and stagnating wages for the working class. The US today has by far the most liberally extremist immigration laws in the entire world (I am not counting the EU's internal immigration due to them being in a union). Currently, 20% of the world’s foreign born immigrants live in the US despite the US making up only 4.4% of the Earth’s population. Each time the foreign born population in the US reached roughly 15% (The US is currently at 13.7%) throughout its history, the government has significantly cut back on immigration for economic and assimilation purposes. Calling on immigration to be lowered will only get you accusations of being racist from the other side no matter your reasoning in todays political sphere. With that information, one can only conclude that the main reason democrats want mass immigration to continue is to further lower the percentage of whites in the US; considering that the only time the left talks about white people or "whiteness" is in the context of them/it being a disease and responsible for all the problems the US is facing.
To answer your question, Yes. If the country already is overwhelmingly white with moderate or conservative immigration policies, the minority would be most affected, but that is not the case that has been happening in the US the past 60 years.
@@PeaceOfMind8190 No, it affects the people whose ancestors built the nation first. Secondary effects like what you mentioned are irrelevant.
“By 2017, those of us of European stock will be an absolute minority in the United States of America,” Biden said at a State Department luncheon for Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff. According to pool reports, Biden added that that’s “not a bad thing, that’s a good thing” because it means the country is becoming more diverse.
So it's not happening... but since it is, it's actually a goo thing.
I don't subscribe to the racist implications of GRT and believe in treating everyone equally and fairly, but a couple of points of contention:
1. If you have immigration to the West but not vice versa, there's going to be replacement. That's just being factual, especially with lower western birthrates. If China, India, the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America are allowed to stay relatively static with no inbound migration, but the West is the only region that needs to become more diverse, there will be replacement.
2. Progressives talk enthusiastically about replacement all the time. "Demographics is destiny" they say. It's no accident they have more immigrant friendly policies, they want to accelerate a changing demographic.
3. Western societies have implemented more social services and entitlements than in the past, meaning that immigration will become a more contentious issue because it's no longer just a matter of someone new moving here. Controlling who is a member of the 'club' also controls who is entitled to what financial benefits.
4. At a time when all demographics should have lower birthrates to fight resource scarcity, climate change, and environmental collapse, different groups will cynically use higher birthrates and population as a weapon against those who are responsibly trying to lower their footprint.
5. We have always been apprehensive of newcomers, but it is truly worrying when those new comers don't share your values. France didn't used to have to worry about professors being beheaded for free speech. Now they do. If you wouldn't let in a stranger into your home, why would you let in a group of people that wishes to strip your rights away?
6. Diversity as a strength is incidental. Japan and China have strong societies with less diversity. Diversity can be a weakness. It is much easier for China to send their best spy into American society than for America to send their best Chinese-American spy into China's society.
Just some thoughts...
Here’s a thought: German-Americans are Americans, Irish-Americans are Americans, Italian-Americans are Americans, African-Americans are Americans, Hispanic-Americans are Americans, Iraqi-Americans are Americans. America is better for the German, Irish, Italian, Jewish, Asian, Hispanic, Middle Eastern, etc. immigration of the past (and African-American which is technically not immigration). Diversity makes our culture stronger and richer. Get over it!
@@mikeg2306 Are America and Europe the only places on earth that should become more diverse? Should Africa, South America, and Asia become more diverse too? Why or why not?
@@Raptor302 I fully support your moving to Africa (or anywhere else but here).
@@mikeg2306 Smug, but you didn't answer the question.
@@mikeg2306 Ahh yes the beutiful cultur of california . Tents , poop and end less Narcissism XD
21:24: "Getting 'worn out' by all the fear and hate" is part of the strategy of "Sh*t-posting," an attempt to make critical thinkers give up and withdraw. Thanks for the insight and analysis.
Wait your and beat are "critical thinkers"?
lol
@@Illumiragefound the bot. Mad, bot?
@@LastRookie nope. I'm a human. Cope
@@Illumirageoh thats sad u made over a 100 comment on this channel
@@tennicksalvarez9079 cope, racist
Sidenote: this is why I thought the Stormfront character in the Amazon series The Boys was brilliantly written, she’s a master at being a subtle racist and using memes and even perfectly captures the modern American racist with the quote “People love what I have to say. They believe in it. They just don't like the word Nazi, that's all.”
Exactly
Well of course they dont.
Why would American racists want to be associated with German racists?
Heck, American Klan members even fought against the Nazis during WW2 and they were extremely proud of their military service targeting the Nazis.
They despised them because they were not American.
Yeah, almost like the left wing writers took normal people with normal opinions who like to have fun online by trolling and then used their likeness and culture and forced it upon an evil character. That’s grade-A propaganda.
That’s the equivalent of turning the likeness of Jewish people into vampires or monsters in the 19th and 20th century.
You can point out the obvious parallels but you can’t point out the intentions behind it. You’re so close to actually pursuing the truth. You do realize any person or group could have been storm front. It’s all based on the writers biases.
Demonizing a political movement by demonizing them is something the Nazis would do.
Lol. Talk about propaganda.
Amazon is a multi billion dollar corporation with a stake in getting people to accept a mass influx of foreigners into their countries: A diverse working class without a unifying religion, ethnicity, or culture is a working class whose rights and happiness you can trample on. You fell for propaganda
So tastefully done Mr. Beat! Keep on keeping on! The USA needs more teachers like you! Hurrah! Racism sucks!
I love how oversimplified everything is. Race is just your distance from the equator. Completely ignoring social psychology.
@@mangus3433 you are right. this was done so pisspoor, it has to be intentional.
Biology is destiny - Actually ignores the real claim. Demographics are destiny. Completely ignores birth rates which is the very foundation of the great replacement theory.
Then he calls out memes. Like wtf? As if logic is the only avenue of argument. What an absolute halfwit. Then proceeds to cherry pick leftwing memes.
It's called self preservation
Thank you
Given the mass expulsion of Jews almost 2000 years ago, what is the chance that you have a Jewish ancestor? Pretty good i would think.
The fact that these group of people have been persecuted for millennias, they should begin to ask themselves if it’s “us” or “their” fault.
@@DefyLov3 109 never their fault
That thought sickens me
Look what happened to the area called Palestine when they opened their arms to Jewish refugees
Biden has allowed more illegals in than American babies were born in the entire country. His goal is to flood the country with migrants, get them on welfare, and give them amnesty in time for the election so they will vote for him. Talk about election interference. It's not just some antisemitic conspiracy -- all Americans are being replaced -- do you think the Blacks on the South side of Chicago aren't being replaced? Or the citizens in NYC? Wake up, this isn't about Jews, this is about UN agenda 2030, and the WEF working with Biden towards the Great Reset.
Countries are absolutely changing due to immigration culturally, religiously, socially and politically.
At most, it's a slight change. Most immigrants assimilate into the culture that they arrive to.
@@El_Crononautano
@@El_Crononautait’s not a slight change
@@Illumirage Yes
@@rn6312meds, now
Im italian/white and grew up with my grandma in my life who is black. I wasnt raised to see color. I wish nothing in this world was about race. We cant just say we are humans from different places? Why not just work together for the benefit of everyone?
Anyone who identifies as "white" sees color, but selectively chooses to avoid the question of why race was invented and why ppl consider themselves "white."
@@brandonslone8937 You are married to a language.....?
@@b1chronixx688The problem is when they attribute negative characteristics by mere association. ?
@@applesandgrapesfordinner4626 . . .what's the problem with that? Most stereotypes are true. Stereotyping and judging is a great defense mechanism. We evolved to judge others that do not look like us as self-preservation in human nature. Diversity is not a strength it's a weakness. Diversity bring division and conflict. That is why most non-white countries have very strict immigration/citizenship laws structured to keep their ethnic/racial majority the same.
@@republitarian484 Assuming Japan, an ethnically homogeneous country, isn't having a birthrate problem and a fledging economy of their own.
I've always believed that The Great Replacement Theory is just Eugenics by another name. Same demon, different name. Thanks for the discussion and breakdown Mr Beat!
Why does he go the whole video without mentioning the talking heads on left news networks from CNN to NYT to WashPost and NBC all say “demographics is destiny”. Mr Beat is purposefully obfuscating not only the origin of this idea but the idea as whole. He inputs “biology is destiny”. It’s derived from French university professors. You are right that it is eugenics! Eugenics against white people. We need to make sure our families can afford to reproduce and not incentivize companies to pay NGOs to advocate for immigration based solely on job. They cast an idea that white children where too good to do menial labor (should take out 200k loans for college instead) that it had to be passed onto Mexicans who aren’t forced to taxes back into the system everyone else rightfully paid for. It’s not an idea that can understood in a one episode a sitting. It’s obviously deeper and I hope the rest of the internet cares to look further than pop science explanations. Because the reality is, it will only influence contemporary Western countries more. It’s time Whites understand they have the right to self determination. Anything that’s cast ‘right leaning’ will always be obfuscated on UA-cam nowadays. Harvard’s Belfor Center’s Election Influence Operation Playbook took care of that.
its eugenics against whites, yeah.
Ugenics is basically how can we make the human race the best, what's wrong with that? It includes like DNA manipulation like say taking the paws from a bear and putting them on us so we won't need shoes or get frostbite on our toes..
Pretty much. The absurd idea that there is a "pure" group of people of random ethnicity that need to be "protected" from "dilution" is as stupid as it is absurd.
It's just white people becoming ethnic minorities in their own countries, think of it that way.
Thank you sir for just being an extremely good and honest man. As an African American man myself, l am very proud to be to call you my brother. Again... thank you.
I just feel like if you’re not dumb you can curb this kind of stuff. Anything blaming whole groups = bad, anything saying “us” is usually bad. Cult behavior
I used to watch Lauren Southern. i havent heard from her since 2017 after rebels media fired her. Since then I realized how much of a rabbit hole I was in and had to dig myself out of there. Had to realize for myself that none of this world works like what they claim to be. We are all human and we need to treat each other with dignity and respect regardless of their background, culture, and appearance
Shes now making a comeback, but her beliefs have greatly mellowed out
I had some disturbing views when I was younger, too, due to being indoctrinated and manipulated. Stay curious!
@@perpetual_suffering1458 no, they haven't. She's only hiding her power level.
@@iammrbeat China is going to execute you first - history proves this as fact.
@@perpetual_suffering1458 even more nuts was Faith Goldy. Thank god she just shriveled up and went into the corner.
Before watching this video, I had never heard of this "Great Replacement Theory." When you mentioned the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, I remembered something that I heard on the news a few years back. My hometown had an anti-semetic synagogue shooting in April of 2019 and the shooter referenced the Pittsburgh shooter as an inspiration. When I looked into it, it turns out that his manifesto included many of the beliefs expressed by this theory. As a history major, it's always interesting learning more about my hometown, even if it isn't so great. Thank you, Mr. Beat.
@David Herschel based
@David Herschel but see it goes both ways. That's what a shooter could say to his alt-right buddies before "going in"
@David Herschel in facts I think that might've been what you were referring to...
It’s genuinely so disappointing reading hateful stuff online and even in this comment section cause it reminds me that it leads to real world consequences like the Pittsburgh shooting.
@David Herschel No dude I don’t think you’re some random hick from Alabama. I just can’t imagine constantly being angry and sad and hateful all the fucking time every day. I don’t think there’s anything logical about it