So glad to have acess to such wonderful memories. As a young man who joined the military at 17 years of age. I carried hi music with me. So many great songs of that era. I would be hard pressed to pick a favorite. This song would definitely make the rop ten, in my opinion.
OMG!!!! This just breaks me up. it was one of my most fav songs by Billy!! I listened to it as a teen when it first came out SO MANY TIMES OVER AND OVER AND OVER! GAWD i miss those days SOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH!!! Can someone PLEASE invent a time machine so i can go back and relive all this great music again and again and again!!!
When I left Hollywood and moved back to New York .. and left the one true love of my life .. I played this over and over for two years ...and New York State Of Mind ... until we got back together ... and still are. Bill Joel, you are the songs of my life. You once asked, on here, which was my favorite (if that was really you) and I said that every song that you have ever written, sung are my favorites. You have written the story of my life. Thank you, my friend. From Bensonhurst ... with LOVE!
Nothing to say when speechlesssss- bn since 1970...started listen then..thanx BJ- you made many happy by shutting up my mouth..And I got 2hear you!!❤🌞🤗
That voice just as pure and clear as it was in the 70s...what a gorgeous talented man...he wrote songs that are all of our memories from those great years ❤❤❤
Wow he sounds amazing. This has always been my favorite of all his songs from the moment it hit the radio, and it aged perfectly. His voice is the same.
THANK YOU! I had a death in the family and had to sell my tickets for this show. This is one of my top five Joel songs and being he NEVER performs it any more, I was so mad I missed it. Hopefully he keeps it in the rotation and I get to see him do it Monday.
I know this is a reeeeeeeeeeeally overdue reply but I just wanted you to know that I attended Billy Joel's concert this past January (2020) at Madison Square Garden in NYC and he performed it. It's my all-time favourite Billy Joel song and it was the first time I'd seen him live. Did NOT disappoint!! :) You'll get another chance x.
I get It. My first concert experience was Billy's in México, but i was so sad because i was at the backseats and i didnt thought about that since It was my first experience. And also It was his farewell concert so Id never see him again, but i still love Billy Joel and at least i could hear His voice live and watch him on screens, maybe i'll have a better experience next Time, not with Billy but with other artists thanks to this experience, all i can do Is to keep enjoying his songs.
When you get a Billy Joel song in your head, it is best to just go ahead and listen to it. They're really just that good. A wonderfully brilliant songwriter, and talented musician.
My favourite song for nostalgia purposes. When I was 5 years old, 1984, my parents had a vinyl single (45) of this song (Songs from the Attic Version) and I literally played my first record ever as they showed me how to use the record player. Well, I was then hooked on music and records. I played this song over and over so much, my parents still to this day tell the story to our family, friends and acquaintances. I became obsessed with it for months, even years later as I learned how to play piano. Needless to say I became a huge Billy Joel fan as a kid, child, teenager and adult. It still to this day takes me back to a happy place and happy time. I saw Billy in MSG Nov. 2017 and it was unfortunately not on the set list that night (my only time seeing him as I live in Newfoundland, Canada.) But man, what a show and experience for my and my wife on a weekend trip to NYC. I plan to see him again and hopefully I'll get to see this song live before either me or Billy aren't around or playing anymore. And the sax solo on the "Songs from the Attic" live version, is still my favourite sax solo of any band of any timeline. You can feel the soul / passion in that solo so much. Needless to say for me, it's one of my favourite Billy Joel songs.
Hello Thanks for your comment and supports, your comments and constant support has brought me this far. Keep Supporting ❤️ Please send me a mail,bj3810743@gmail.com
Saw him in '89 in Montreal.....had a hankering to find some live footage from this year and this blew my mind how great he still sounds.....time to catch Billy on the road again.
0:49 begins the "most repeated" that lasts throughout the entirety of the song. The overwhelming majority of the people who came to this video stayed for the entire thing :)
I guess the 70s were the best years that everything has perfect taste. So the music reached the best level accordingly. The progress in music mainly accelerated by the ignition during 70s.
Jong Hao absolute it has. Have a listen to songs in the attic. Different key and a shit load more life. Besides which liberty devito and the others made this song.
Has changed substantially. Ever since he started changing his '76-'81 band lineup it's slowly gotten worse and worse. I'd still pay top dollar to see this guy live (and I did in 2014), but there is NO question his songs sounds much, much different. I'm not even talking about his lowered voice, I don't mind the key changes. Just the overall feel of his songs are a lot worse (in my opinion at least). Though it's not an opinion that his sound hasn't changed. Once again, it totally has. Like Dom O'Leary said, go listen to Songs in the Attic. I'd die to see THAT Billy Joel in concert. Okay, have a nice day. Long live the Joelster.
I love the lyric “that life is a series of hellos and goodbyes”
Me too, there’s something so sad about that line. Always gets to me.
Kind of has a new meaning now that you're not 20.
'You are not my fast gun anymore...", I've always loved that song, I've said that to many people, "say goodbye to Hollywood, say goodbye my baby..."
There is talent and then there is whatever the hell Billy has....legend!
Billy is so talented, people still want to hear this song and knowing that he is not a young man anymore, he made the song still work brilliantly
+Tony P
the best part i like
he knows he can sing
NO ER PIECE
hes like bach or beeetoven hes that good hes better than the beatles
@@MrBillcale Beatles were a fad ..didn't last
Billy joel tremendously talented. What a great piano player. Greg
Billy Joel was and his amazing. He's so talented. He's a living legend.
Its stunning that his voice has not changed!
it got lower, it matured :)
@@egett And that's just okay, because it's natural. How wonderful if it still sounds great!!!
@@Blueridge1961 yes it's still powerful and clear
Yer Blues, not a whole octave. Maybe a step and a half.
It’s better now
So glad to have acess to such wonderful memories. As a young man who joined the military at 17 years of age. I carried hi music with me. So many great songs of that era. I would be hard pressed to pick a favorite. This song would definitely make the rop ten, in my opinion.
OMG!!!! This just breaks me up. it was one of my most fav songs by Billy!! I listened to it as a teen when it first came out SO MANY TIMES OVER AND OVER AND OVER! GAWD i miss those days SOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH!!! Can someone PLEASE invent a time machine so i can go back and relive all this great music again and again and again!!!
my fav BJ song and he made some great music.....
LesSmith45 ditto
wow, it means you had been aware of BJ's talent before his name became so big.
When I left Hollywood and moved back to New York .. and left the one true love of my life .. I played this over and over for two years ...and New York State Of Mind ... until we got back together ... and still are. Bill Joel, you are the songs of my life. You once asked, on here, which was my favorite (if that was really you) and I said that every song that you have ever written, sung are my favorites. You have written the story of my life. Thank you, my friend. From Bensonhurst ... with LOVE!
My favorite song from Turnstiles. Saw Billy at MSG in 1999. He blew the house down. My favorite singer. William Martin Joel.
Glad to see I'm not the only one that
Loves thus song!!!
Billy is an absolute treasure, simply the best. His band is amazing!
Let's all give a respectful bow to the medical genius who restored this great man's voice, and gave all of him back to us.
lebarosky , what are you talking about? Maybe you are mixing Billy with Elton? Elton had throat surgery.
Bill's still trying to fuck up his voice.
Nothing to say when speechlesssss- bn since 1970...started listen then..thanx BJ- you made many happy by shutting up my mouth..And I got 2hear you!!❤🌞🤗
To this day this man sounds INCREDIBLE!
Yes!! He does
I can't believe I'm still listening to this song from when I first heard it in the 70's! Unbelievable! Billy Joel's music will never die!
Wow he is on fantastic form here. Brilliant voice.
That voice just as pure and clear as it was in the 70s...what a gorgeous talented man...he wrote songs that are all of our memories from those great years ❤❤❤
I saw Billy in concert years ago. It was "the best". He is a very talented man. Greetings from Canada. 🇨🇦👋
So happy I was there for this one! Billy Joel nails it once again!!!
The Great Billy Joel. A living legend
Always Billy!!! A spectacular music genius !!!
His songs always take you back to when and where you heard them.....wow!
Yes, he wrote songs that became our memories for sure
❤Toll,einfach nur Leidenschaft und Stimme, ein Genuss
Wow he sounds amazing. This has always been my favorite of all his songs from the moment it hit the radio, and it aged perfectly. His voice is the same.
Flawless vocal of a classic. Cant wait to see him again live in Melbourne, December this year.
I'm going too, can't wait!
I hate needing anything. Another Voice I couldn't live without. Maybe I needed you so much I hated you. God bless.
THANK YOU! I had a death in the family and had to sell my tickets for this show. This is one of my top five Joel songs and being he NEVER performs it any more, I was so mad I missed it. Hopefully he keeps it in the rotation and I get to see him do it Monday.
I know this is a reeeeeeeeeeeally overdue reply but I just wanted you to know that I attended Billy Joel's concert this past January (2020) at Madison Square Garden in NYC and he performed it. It's my all-time favourite Billy Joel song and it was the first time I'd seen him live. Did NOT disappoint!! :) You'll get another chance x.
I get It. My first concert experience was Billy's in México, but i was so sad because i was at the backseats and i didnt thought about that since It was my first experience. And also It was his farewell concert so Id never see him again, but i still love Billy Joel and at least i could hear His voice live and watch him on screens, maybe i'll have a better experience next Time, not with Billy but with other artists thanks to this experience, all i can do Is to keep enjoying his songs.
I used to believe that old urban myth "it tears up his voice" Don't worry he has been doing it all along and continues to this day
@@ericlee2931 Well, there was about twenty years where he did not do it, so...
@@ginalofaro5967 I went to 50 of the residency shows, I got it a few times, thank you.
All his songs tell a story. My all time favourite this one. Cannot beat the attic recording. Awesome
He created his own genre of music, Bill Joelism. Alot of hits, a Joy to behold, gold.
my favorite song!
When you get a Billy Joel song in your head, it is best to just go ahead and listen to it. They're really just that good. A wonderfully brilliant songwriter, and talented musician.
My favourite song for nostalgia purposes. When I was 5 years old, 1984, my parents had a vinyl single (45) of this song (Songs from the Attic Version) and I literally played my first record ever as they showed me how to use the record player. Well, I was then hooked on music and records. I played this song over and over so much, my parents still to this day tell the story to our family, friends and acquaintances. I became obsessed with it for months, even years later as I learned how to play piano. Needless to say I became a huge Billy Joel fan as a kid, child, teenager and adult. It still to this day takes me back to a happy place and happy time. I saw Billy in MSG Nov. 2017 and it was unfortunately not on the set list that night (my only time seeing him as I live in Newfoundland, Canada.) But man, what a show and experience for my and my wife on a weekend trip to NYC. I plan to see him again and hopefully I'll get to see this song live before either me or Billy aren't around or playing anymore. And the sax solo on the "Songs from the Attic" live version, is still my favourite sax solo of any band of any timeline. You can feel the soul / passion in that solo so much. Needless to say for me, it's one of my favourite Billy Joel songs.
i love you billy you were one of the best parts of my youth
Songs in the Attic is my favourite album and this is my favourite track on it - live it's just superb!
Hello Thanks for your comment and supports, your comments and constant support has brought me this far. Keep Supporting ❤️
Please send me a mail,bj3810743@gmail.com
His sax player is absolutely incredibly talented .
Great song. Billy is tremendously talented and still going strong. Simply amazing.
A wonderfully brilliant songwriter, an extremely talented musician! Ronnie Spectre did a wonderful version of this song too.
sorry Spector. ;)
So did Bette Midler. Great song!
Ronnie Spector did an outstanding cover of this song. Rest In Peace Ronnie.
This is my favourite Billy Joel song:)
Saw him in '89 in Montreal.....had a hankering to find some live footage from this year and this blew my mind how great he still sounds.....time to catch Billy on the road again.
Timeless Billy Joel classic stellar production as always....
Billy un Maestro así con mayúsculas. Genio, de lo mejor que dió la música de todos los tiempos.
Going to see him Tonight Can't Wait!
Hope you had fun! Sounds like a blast! I have always wanted to see him. Maybe one day... 😁
Para mi . ...La mejor canción de Billy Joel!!!
If only you come to LA so I can see you perform this :(
Remember kids work real hard and practice everyday and even if you look like Billy Joel you can have all the beautiful girls you'll ever need.
True words.
I remember seeing an article where he said he was so thoroughly out of his league with Christie...
I've been waiting to see this live for a long time, one of my favourite of billy's songs . Legend .
He still has it!
0:49 begins the "most repeated" that lasts throughout the entirety of the song. The overwhelming majority of the people who came to this video stayed for the entire thing :)
love this song the timeing and the feel of the song
Un grande!!!!!!
Mastery...
Wish he would have played this at the Philips arena show! I was there!
Real music
Thanks so much for this! Also thanks for it being complete
Thank you so much for bringing this tune back. It is a great one. Was ecstatic to see it here in LA when you broke it out.
Love u billy❤️
Mi admiración mas profunda para el gran Billy.Desde Argentina❤
A living musical legend. The East coast's gem of a musical story-teller. Jersey was good for something after all. :-)
He's actually a New Yorker. Close enough though.
Once again, MR nails it big on sax......
I love my piano man!
ファンが見たいのはこういうCDに忠実なアレンジのコンサートだと思う
I really love this song
Saw him in 2017 at Dodger Stadium. It felt so right when he sang this song in LA.
Tremendous performer and tremendous song! Love it!
BILLY: YOU HONESTLY SING THIS SONG BETTER NOW THAN YOU DID ANY OTHER TIME IN YOUR CAREER.
Still amazing
Great lyrics..so true!
I guess the 70s were the best years that everything has perfect taste. So the music reached the best level accordingly. The progress in music mainly accelerated by the ignition during 70s.
So many faces in and out of my life!!
Great line!!
Im seeing him tomorrow night in philly and am ecstatic!
Well how was it?
Love This!
Real F''ing music.
I want to billy joel japan come again!
outstanding
Perfect
Billy sang this at Camden Yards in Baltimore and I freaked!
"Life is A Series of " Hellos" and "Good-byes", I'm Afraid it's Time For "Good-Bye" Again... tragically true.
Every person on that stage is incredibly talented especially Mark Rivera
Unico da brividi
最高🎉
The sound has not changed
Jong Hao absolute it has.
Have a listen to songs in the attic. Different key and a shit load more life. Besides which liberty devito and the others made this song.
Quality is the same,but he sings in lower key,however that is understandable,with years it's getting harder to vocalise.
Has changed substantially. Ever since he started changing his '76-'81 band lineup it's slowly gotten worse and worse. I'd still pay top dollar to see this guy live (and I did in 2014), but there is NO question his songs sounds much, much different. I'm not even talking about his lowered voice, I don't mind the key changes. Just the overall feel of his songs are a lot worse (in my opinion at least). Though it's not an opinion that his sound hasn't changed. Once again, it totally has.
Like Dom O'Leary said, go listen to Songs in the Attic. I'd die to see THAT Billy Joel in concert. Okay, have a nice day. Long live the Joelster.
Melhor do que antes ! ! !
最高です。
Uno de los mejores el gran Billy Joel y el inseparable Mark Rivera en el saxo .
６３歳の日本人です。
私が２３歳の時、流行りました。
Deine Stimme ist seit 40Jahren die gleiche. Ich bin ein Fan.
A good artist and piano plsyer
A great song to say goodbye to 2023 with.
love that fucking song!!
💋
i have heard he wrote this song as a tribute to ronnie spector ....
Its 'be my baby' by the ronettes.
👌👌👌👍👍👍👋👋👏🙏🌹
The quality of this video is excellent. Is this on DVD?
Liberty needs to come back.
okay, that guy is seriously loooking like Bruce Springsteen :O
Amazing song, who knows how many times I've actually played it on repeat. :)
"...say goodbye to Ronnie
say goodbye my babyyy..."
The REAL Epic Sax man is at 3:00 and 4:47
Look up the performance of "...Italian Restaurant" at Jazz Fest 2013.
Mr Sax God really struts the stage in that performance too.
声量えぐいな。
Why are they pumping the synth strings so hard? I can't hear the piano parts!