How to Reface a Fireplace with Granite | Generation Next | Ask This Old House

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
  • Ask This Old House mason Mark McCullough teaches apprentice Krysten how to reface a granite fireplace.
    SUBSCRIBE to This Old House: bit.ly/Subscrib...
    Time: 3-4 hours
    Cost: $2000
    Skill Level: Moderate
    Tools List for Refacing a Fireplace with Granite:
    Prybar
    Brick hammer
    Bucket
    Notched trowel
    Level
    Rubber mallet
    Shopping List:
    Granite pieces, cut to size
    Drop cloth
    Mortar
    Concrete construction adhesive
    Steps:
    1. Handling heavy masonry materials is a two-person minimum job. Do not attempt to do this alone.
    2. Carefully pry away the old granite using a prybar. Start from the top and work your way down.
    3. Protect the floor with a folded drop cloth. A scrap piece of 2x4 can be used as a lever to pry the hearth.
    4. Apply a layer of mortar on the subhearth using the trowel. Add a few blobs in key areas to allow the hearth to be wiggled into place.
    5. Place the hearth on the mortar and check for level. Hit it with the rubber mallet to make adjustments.
    6. Generously apply concrete construction adhesive to the back of the legs and the top granite piece.
    7. Place both legs on each side and check them for level.
    8. Place the top carefully and check for level.
    Resources:
    Refacing a fireplace is a two-person job. Use caution when handling heavy materials.
    It’s challenging to match granite, so it makes more sense to order four new pieces rather than just one or two replacement pieces. A local stone fabricator can template the fireplace and cut and round each piece to the appropriate size. In this case, Mark used granite in the color Black Pearl, fabricated by International Stone, Inc. (www.internation....
    To adhere the granite to the fireplace, Mark used a concrete construction adhesive manufactured by Quikrete (www.quikrete.c....
    The other materials Mark used for this job, including the chisel, hammers and buckets, can all be found at home centers.
    About Generation Next:
    This Old House’s Generation NEXT initiative shines a light on the urgent need for young people to enter the building trades and fill the skills gap in America today. “There’s a critical need for people in home construction,” says the This Old House master carpenter Norm Abram. The initiative has involved recruiting apprentices-some with no skills, some with a few years under their tool belts-to work alongside the TOH TV pros.
    Looking for more step by step guidance on how to complete projects around the house? Join This Old House INSIDER to stream over 1,000 episodes commercial-free: bit.ly/2GPiYbH
    Plus, download our FREE app for full-episode streaming to your connected TV, phone or tablet:
    bit.ly/34RYEP5
    Follow This Old House and Ask This Old House:
    Facebook: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    Twitter: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    bit.ly/AskTOHTw...
    Pinterest: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    Instagram: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    bit.ly/AskTOHIG
    For more on This Old House and Ask This Old House, visit us at: bit.ly/ThisOldH...
    How to Reface a Fireplace with Granite | Generation Next | Ask This Old House
    / thisoldhouse

КОМЕНТАРІ • 131

  • @nathanstephenson7917
    @nathanstephenson7917 6 років тому +27

    This is amazing stuff. Old school teaching new school to keep the tradition and skillsets alive and going! I loved watching TOH on Saturdays when growing up, and still today (20+ years later)

    • @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744
      @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744 6 років тому +1

      Nathan Stephenson Same here! Been watching *This* *old* *house* since I was in High School since the 1990's . Saturday mornings I also watched Norm and his *New* *Yankee* *Workshop* and then *Home* *Time* . I miss those old shows.

  • @kylefogle6022
    @kylefogle6022 6 років тому +12

    As a stone mason I've laid miles of flagstone and stacked many walls. The first flagstone patio I laid, I revisited a few months later and to my surprise the stones sounded hollow when I tapped on them. You guessed it, I didn't back butter them. A scratch coat of thinset on the back of every stone became standard. No hollow sounding stones since. When it came to stacking a thin veneer, I'd always fasten masonry ties to whatever I was veneering over, and always have some sort of a ledger to stack on. Far to many people rely on the adhesive quality alone, but gravity will eventually win. I've driven by houses and seen whole sections of natural stone veneer peel right off the wall. No masonry ties, no ledger. Another hard lesson was my first day of setting stone without kneepads. It was painful watching this video seeing the lack of kneepads. I'm not a big fan of brick, but in this case I think it looked better. Seeing the edge of the veneer looks cheesy as most do, like it's trying to be something it's not.

    • @serjstoned
      @serjstoned 2 роки тому

      Good info right here

    • @matthewkutilek3632
      @matthewkutilek3632 Рік тому

      What’s the best way to remove granite from a brick fireplace face? Appears to be stuck with liquid nail.

  • @TheMixmastamike1000
    @TheMixmastamike1000 6 років тому +13

    Kristen is awesome and great job you two

  • @kenjarabek9901
    @kenjarabek9901 6 років тому

    Perfect timing. I am just looking at my fireplace and wanting to finish the face appearance of it...thank you for the inspiration.

  • @Brian-Burke
    @Brian-Burke 6 років тому +177

    Anyone else wish they just cleaned the brick and left it original?

    • @TheOtherBill
      @TheOtherBill 6 років тому +11

      I'm not crazy about the granite but that original brick didn't look good at all.

    • @68camarorsss33
      @68camarorsss33 6 років тому +3

      Rick Alwaysprepared You’re a classy dude!

    • @corey2242
      @corey2242 6 років тому

      Was thinking the same thing

    • @Engineer9736
      @Engineer9736 6 років тому +2

      I think the granite looks better than the bricks.

    • @lukasncolin6604
      @lukasncolin6604 10 місяців тому

      I wish they left the brick as it originally was.

  • @shadowblack1987
    @shadowblack1987 6 років тому +31

    Red bricks complimented that place quite nicely. That black/grey crap is horrid.

  • @aaronbays4
    @aaronbays4 5 років тому +6

    So what was ever wrong with the brick??? It looked great, I liked that original terra-cotta tile hearth as well, worked great with the traditional woodwork/general feel of the home. Also as a side rant, I've lived in a couple houses where the fireplace really blocks the view of the back yard. Parents house is a prime example, 1970's ranch, beautiful back yard with a step off patio, their main den has a huge masonary fireplace in the middle of the wall facing the back yard, french doors on one side, a big floor to ceiling window on the other side. Well if they put the fireplace cati-corner in the room, they could have had floor to ceiling windows looking out on the back yard, great view, it faces north so no hot sun like their formal living room which does have huge floor to ceiling windows.

  • @Doobie2100
    @Doobie2100 6 років тому +1

    Nice job Kristen!!!

  • @jasonsgroovemachine
    @jasonsgroovemachine Рік тому +1

    Everyone in the comments yelling "Why didn't they just fix the brick! This looks like garbage!" probably needs to take a moment and remember that this is a home, and that's what the home owners wanted.

  • @regibson23
    @regibson23 6 років тому +35

    7:15 That's plumb?

    • @oldhandyluke
      @oldhandyluke 6 років тому

      Rob Gibson itt almost never plumb in a old house

    • @scottymsu6063
      @scottymsu6063 6 років тому

      haha good catch

    • @oldhandyluke
      @oldhandyluke 5 років тому

      @@Stackali thats just the way i like them

  • @pjdexter168
    @pjdexter168 4 роки тому +2

    haha "Kristen you're a natural" with headphones on, that was really creepy 6:25

  • @trainfever1
    @trainfever1 6 років тому +26

    I definitely would have went with the brick instead of granite.

  • @farooq2000
    @farooq2000 4 роки тому +1

    What would be the best way to remove thinset on the brick if you wanted to keep the brick or paint over it?

  • @edwardperez6729
    @edwardperez6729 Рік тому

    Would it be wrong to tackle this job like a tile job? Use thinset, proper notch, and even back butter? Also, do you prime the tile first. I’ve seen some videos where they place cement board over brick, just wondering best method.

  • @EYALAVRAHAMI
    @EYALAVRAHAMI Рік тому

    Jesus Christ, how beautiful Krysten is😍

  • @albertastorms
    @albertastorms 6 років тому

    This fireplace looks to be from before WWII which means this house is old. So this brick is nice but is the whole fireplace! I also like the interior brick around fireplaces and interior brick walls that were common in house built in the 1980's though I have noticed interior brick is becomming popular again with new home construction and renovations!

  • @BrokenLifeCycle
    @BrokenLifeCycle 6 років тому +7

    ... aren’t you supposed to notch the cement before placing any tile-like slab down? And for the size of it, shouldn’t it be back-buttered? Or is the sheer girth of the granite more than enough to compensate for the air pockets bound to form underneath?

    • @RubbinRobbin
      @RubbinRobbin 6 років тому +5

      BrokenLifeCycle ALWAYS Backbutter! And always get a notch size specific to the large format install.

    • @johndaniells4440
      @johndaniells4440 6 років тому +1

      Hahaha....girth 👀

    • @rapid8067
      @rapid8067 6 років тому

      No.

  • @TeamEmperor
    @TeamEmperor 5 років тому

    So much Skill! Keep it up

  • @H0peAnL0ve
    @H0peAnL0ve 5 років тому

    I appreciate the shared knowledge

  • @TimSchilling-gz4rd
    @TimSchilling-gz4rd 3 місяці тому

    I have a dumb question here. I'm attempting something similar here, where I'm attaching a hardie backer concrete board around a metal fireplace to hide the black firebox so that it will sit flush with the drywall around it for ledge stone tiling. I was thinking about using the same quickrete that is being used here, but it doesn't seem rated for high heat. Can the product being used to attach the legs and top withstand the temperature of that fireplace?

  • @saulgoodman2018
    @saulgoodman2018 6 років тому +1

    So is "blob" the technical term for it?

  • @ledmk2
    @ledmk2 6 років тому

    Nice made

  • @teebee1204
    @teebee1204 6 років тому

    Is there supposed to be an edge showing proud on the header? I would want mine flush. It would have been nice if he had said how he measured for all dimensions of the granite, including thickness. It seemed like the header, at least, was too thick. We could not get a good look at any of the other parts.

  • @Engineer9736
    @Engineer9736 6 років тому +7

    5:54 Nothing changed after that “a little bit more”. I do not believe that silly hammer is going to change anything to such weight and mortar surface. I think using your whole body weight is the tool for this. Put one foot on it and press gently.

  • @AnthonySDurant
    @AnthonySDurant 6 років тому +11

    Why does this guy look like Doctor Evil hahaha

  • @JohnSmith-ze8qw
    @JohnSmith-ze8qw 6 років тому +4

    Spot bonding?

  • @StevenHibbs
    @StevenHibbs 6 років тому +3

    Did the dampener ever get hooked up after the new granite was installed? Curious to know if the top piece came pre cut with that hole or if they did on the job. Looks good.

    • @Ryman624
      @Ryman624 6 років тому +11

      Steven Hibbs I don't think they used the disconnected one since the homeowner had a better one installed.

  • @allansmith5554
    @allansmith5554 4 роки тому +1

    hi you guys need some help on how to read a level. And no that level is not perfect . Sorry to see a master mason show a student that when the bubble on a level touches the line , its perfect.!

    • @malkav_ils
      @malkav_ils 4 роки тому

      you have to account for the angle of the camera on the level itself.

  • @RichardGMoss
    @RichardGMoss 6 років тому +5

    The brick looks nicer, just clean it up!

  • @jptrainor
    @jptrainor 5 років тому +1

    Polyurethane construction adhesive has a specified max service temperature of 70 C (160F). Is that a concern?

    • @stevefifield1207
      @stevefifield1207 5 років тому +1

      They didn't use polyurethane construction adhesive. What they used had a Service Temperature of -90 F (-68 C) to 425 F (218 C). Datasheet here: www.quikrete.com/pdfs/data_sheet-advanced%20polymer%20construction%20adhesive%20990210.pdf

  • @jimbol8695
    @jimbol8695 6 років тому +40

    That's a toe stubber right there.

    • @damannoa
      @damannoa 6 років тому +6

      Yup, that's what I was thinking. That granite should have been level with the ground or inclined like a ramp. Those edges could easily tear a ligaments on your foot. If it were me, I'd put some sort of soft edges around the border.

  • @Andrico77
    @Andrico77 3 роки тому

    Could you have made the legs and header one piece ... a cleaner look

  • @justinwoods240
    @justinwoods240 4 роки тому +1

    Him: alright put a little there.
    Her: ok. And puts a huge amount on there. Do you want more
    Him: DONT YOU SEE HOW MUCH YOU JUST PUT DOWN! NO I DINT WANT MORE

  • @HuyenLe-fl5eb
    @HuyenLe-fl5eb 5 років тому

    Which adhesive should I use to adhere granite to the fireplace surround metal part? thanks.

  • @TahirChaudhryartist
    @TahirChaudhryartist 4 роки тому

    Nice

  • @justinwoods240
    @justinwoods240 4 роки тому

    Can you send brick to get the thin set off??

  • @giovannipetitti1588
    @giovannipetitti1588 6 років тому +1

    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 from Italy

  • @MoneyManHolmes
    @MoneyManHolmes 6 років тому +4

    Didn’t he just use a different version of spot bonding?

  • @prakashgudimetlagudimetlap2533
    @prakashgudimetlagudimetlap2533 5 років тому

    NYC work

  • @japan-e9j
    @japan-e9j 6 років тому

    Perfect job very neat work👍

  • @justinwoods240
    @justinwoods240 4 роки тому

    I like how he said the face was plum but you can see it be looking like this /

  • @sheriftartar1
    @sheriftartar1 6 років тому +1

    how to install glass shower door?

  • @bogey19018
    @bogey19018 2 роки тому

    What about the heat softening the caulk?

    • @volundrfrey896
      @volundrfrey896 Рік тому

      It's not caulk, it construction adhesive made for higher temp applications.

  • @djamelazerty7549
    @djamelazerty7549 6 років тому

    Nice work and well done

  • @Ragnaroek190
    @Ragnaroek190 6 років тому +6

    I like cats

  • @abscomm
    @abscomm 6 років тому +7

    5:58 Not level. 7:15 not plumb. Send this guy to the optician! Bring back Norm!!!

    • @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744
      @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744 6 років тому

      John Jones well it's good as it can be.

    • @oldhandyluke
      @oldhandyluke 6 років тому

      John Jones nothing is plumb in an old house

    • @abscomm
      @abscomm 6 років тому +3

      I'm not the one who said they were level and plumb when obviously they were not now am I?

  • @DXSUCKIT1990
    @DXSUCKIT1990 6 років тому +4

    Hope they recycled those marble pieces. They are in good condition

  • @johnal4560
    @johnal4560 5 років тому

    what is the name of that glue that you used for this please

    • @leorbaratian6374
      @leorbaratian6374 3 роки тому

      i am stuck as well. the glue they used is only rated for 200.

  • @stevenpdx
    @stevenpdx 6 років тому

    Okay.

  • @borys444
    @borys444 5 років тому +2

    The point job on that original brick was beautiful. What r u doing covering it up?? Such a waste

  • @davide82843
    @davide82843 5 років тому +1

    Should have used a nice tile pattern and not the 80s black look

  • @laskahusky7313
    @laskahusky7313 2 роки тому

    i dont get it....old granite out new granite in

  • @Crazboy101
    @Crazboy101 4 роки тому

    what type of construction adhesive should i use to glue granite to drywall?

  • @richardlynch329
    @richardlynch329 6 років тому

    The shine from the granite would bother me while watching TV

  • @johndaniells4440
    @johndaniells4440 6 років тому

    Good tradespersons, but he's a very sweaty man.

  • @ihate4413
    @ihate4413 6 років тому

    Is that Dr. Evil?

  • @nicholassmith82
    @nicholassmith82 6 років тому +1

    Technically, we could have installed some of the existing pieces of granite, but I would much rather give you the piece of mind knowing that I'm charging you more. Enjoy!

    • @johnathanbahna7495
      @johnathanbahna7495 5 років тому

      Nicholas Smith that’s not the homeowner he’s with but sure

  • @lucastillo1375
    @lucastillo1375 6 років тому +1

    He never applied any glue to the seams

    • @keyroncampbell
      @keyroncampbell 6 років тому

      Lu Castillo liquid nail... It works a lot better... If you ever laid tile in a uneven area and it won't dry... Use liquid nail

    • @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744
      @gregsplace.greecenewyork2744 6 років тому

      Lu Castillo I wouldn't

    • @mikegillert
      @mikegillert 6 років тому

      Use 100% silicone caulking. Works way better.

  • @Joemama-km9np
    @Joemama-km9np 11 місяців тому

    She got the soccer moms need sleeve tattoos memo!

  • @DanielDayiscoolaspoop
    @DanielDayiscoolaspoop 6 років тому +2

    I thought it was Dr. Evil in the thumbnail.

  • @microphonixvirtualstudio1634
    @microphonixvirtualstudio1634 4 роки тому +1

    She is such a beautiful woman who spoiled her beauty with a tato

  • @tjwatson0403
    @tjwatson0403 5 років тому +2

    Why on Earth would you put granite over that beautiful brick?

  • @moisesfernandez4189
    @moisesfernandez4189 6 років тому +1

    Okay lol

  • @blakesmith325
    @blakesmith325 6 років тому +3

    Please stop with the loud music in the middle of the video.

  • @ironman23gt
    @ironman23gt 5 років тому

    Click bait warning! Dr Evil is NOT in this video.

  • @MrFitness94
    @MrFitness94 6 років тому +10

    She’s cute.

  • @donb5794
    @donb5794 6 років тому

    👍

  • @themalacast
    @themalacast 20 днів тому

    I wonder what the job satisfaction rate is for female masons. Or the average length of their careers. But then again, why get all specific when we know what we NEED the answers to be?

  • @clickbait7322
    @clickbait7322 6 років тому +1

    I would've left the original brick..looks Way nicer

  • @23gsxr1k
    @23gsxr1k 5 років тому +1

    " this is going pretty smoothly " .....yet continues to breath heavily and out of breath.

  • @jodygroshon7969
    @jodygroshon7969 5 років тому

    Why is Dr.Evil on the thumbnail?

  •  3 роки тому

    Wood painted white.
    Granite over brick
    Nothing to see here.

  • @arisdhaftvani7210
    @arisdhaftvani7210 3 роки тому

    HUM? Same color????????? Really?

  • @2kclv601
    @2kclv601 6 років тому +1

    What's up? Listening to hereby you speak wisdom :-$ £€§ 09/05/2018 cycle 5.

  • @thisisyourcaptin
    @thisisyourcaptin 5 років тому

    Who all saw the video thumbnail and though “how to face a fireplace with Dr. Evil”?

  • @bill1957111
    @bill1957111 5 років тому

    shes a cutie. I love the way her jeans fit too

  • @TheDarthJesus
    @TheDarthJesus 4 роки тому

    Not level at 5:58; Not plumb at 7:15.
    Unfinished top edge sitting proud at 8:20, with seams visable.
    From the look of it, they're both apprentices.

  • @Undermeman
    @Undermeman 6 років тому

    There is no R in the word idea.

  • @khaledrjoub
    @khaledrjoub 5 років тому

    Boy oh boy she's a muffin 😍

  • @GreenCroco1
    @GreenCroco1 Рік тому

    as you lay tiles or granite ,, you should not tap with hammer..!!! The taps on tiles or granite causes air gaps between the tiles/granite and the mortar..!! !!!

  • @tombomombodombo
    @tombomombodombo 5 років тому

    What waste of granite. The old material was re-usable

    • @morlamweb
      @morlamweb 4 роки тому

      Only the bottom piece and the sides were re-usable in that fireplace. The top piece, as was pointed out, cracked in two places and fell off the face of the fireplace. He'd have to find another piece of granite to match the existing pieces, but mostly likely wouldn't find an exact match. As a pro, he wouldn't put his name to substandard work, so he made the call to replace all of the pieces.

  • @epenaloza52
    @epenaloza52 6 років тому +3

    I can't tell if its a girl or a guy

  • @REPDAT5SIX2
    @REPDAT5SIX2 6 років тому

    I rather clean up the bricks.

  • @dahawk6474
    @dahawk6474 4 роки тому

    poor workmanship

  • @eduardosanchez1316
    @eduardosanchez1316 6 років тому

    Should have just had one entire piece of granite cut instead of having those the seams. Would have looked cleaner.

    • @briancnc
      @briancnc 6 років тому +3

      and cost significantly more. If they cut it as one U piece it would have had the entire center as waste material. Cutting it in pieces yields better and probably made it 1/2 the material cost.

    • @keyroncampbell
      @keyroncampbell 6 років тому +2

      Eduardo Sanchez you try cutting one big piece.... It don't make sense, you'll waste more than you'll use

  • @robsonandamy9849
    @robsonandamy9849 5 років тому

    Absolutely not the right way to do this job. I've been doing granite for a long time.

  • @fixitjerry
    @fixitjerry 6 років тому

    Hes definitely not an actor, everyone is always so serious. Make some jokes

  • @microphonixvirtualstudio1634
    @microphonixvirtualstudio1634 5 років тому +1

    God made Krysten is a beautiful woman! Why would she want to tell God, his are work wasn't good enough, by putting a tattoo on her arm?

  • @thetupolevtu-1602
    @thetupolevtu-1602 6 років тому

    2nd