Catholic vs. Orthodox Papacy Debate (Jay Dyer vs. Erick Ybarra)

Catholic vs. Orthodox Papacy Debate (Jay Dyer vs. Erick Ybarra) Hosted by Michael Lofton #debate #catholicism #papacy #jaydyer
Michael starts out by discussing Canon 6 of Nicaea I and Roman Primacy with Erick. After an hour Jay Dyer joins the video for an impromptu debate with Erick on the papacy. The show then examines many issues including epistemology, the papal charisms, development of doctrine, etc.
00:00 Introduction
1:08 Canon 6 and the Papacy
9:06 Five Primacies of Rome
12:55 Immediate or Mediate Jurisdiction?
16:40 Jay Dyer Chat Questions
21:15 Formula of St. Hormisdas
23:40 Forgeries of Pope Symmachus
28:20 Motives of Credibility
31:52 Why Ecumenical Councils?
38:31 Final Thoughts on Canon 6
41:16 Nicea and Chalcedon
45:00 More Jay Dyer Questions
50:00 Jay Wants to Debate
51:12 Vatican II and Indifferentism
58:24 Multiple Primacies in Church
1:01:50 DEBATE BEGINS
1:07:24 Back to Canon 6
1:13:24 Orthodox Ecclesiology
1:17:30 Problems with Jay's Argument
1:26:40 Papal Infallibility
1:29:46 Icons and Doctrinal Development
1:33:04 Orthodox Internal Schism
1:37:36 Is Erick Hard-Headed?
1:45:18 Can Ecumenical Councils be Wrong?
1:52:00 Letter of Pope St. Agatho
1:59:50 Confession of St. Sophronius
2:03:15 History and Neutrality
2:06:02 Pope Hadrian II and Papal Supremacy
2:10:30 What Counts as Evidence?
2:19:06 Perfect Consistency
2:25:15 Vatican I Can't Tolerate Error
2:40:05 Theoretical Agreement (?)
2:47:14 Epistemology and the Holy Spirit
2:53:24 Personal Insults
2:54:20 Nous and Divine Energies
2:57:07 Enlightenment Through Institutions
2:59:28 Classical Foundationalism
3:02:51 Good Wishes and Conclusion
___________________________________________________________________
Disclaimer: Any view expressed by a host, contributor or guest is not necessarily reflective of the views of other hosts, contributors or guests.
🔴PLEASE HELP THIS CHANNEL GROW🔴
Disclaimer: Any view expressed by a host, contributor or guest is not necessarily reflective of the views of other hosts, contributors or guests.
🔴SUPPORT
Subscribe: / @reasonandtheology
Become a Patron: / reasonandtheology
Donate: reasonandtheology.com/donate/
🔴VISIT
Website: ReasonAndTheology.com for more information
Facebook: / reasonandtheology
Facebook: / michaelloftonrt
Discord: / discord
Twitter: / michaelloftonrt
🔴LISTEN
Itunes: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Stitcher: www.stitcher.com/show/michael...