You know, what is funniest? From OG movie perspective, as much as Billy is created to be Walking Red Flag... Stu is doing MASSIVE INTELLECTUAL JOB. He, unlike Billy is able execute his alibi, kidnap Sid father, when Billy distract Sid, keep him at his house(Neil), when still actively participating in tormenting Sid, Ghostface activities, bailing out Billy, preparing party, manipulating everyone into places, where they are expected (Tatum, Randy, everyone at party, emotionally manipulating Sid, even if she seen Randy attacked). Stu also, even if most people believe it was Billy, due to look he gave, most likely killed Tatum. He literally paraphrase her last words to killer in final scene, when earlier he paraphrases Randy. And because Billy is Born Suspect, Macher fly under radar each time. By pure OG movie, Stu did MOST PLANNING, even if people think Billy is mastermind, because motive is connected to him and he behave like tsundere girl from anime. 😅 I like Billy, but him hitting Stu as thank You, You are annoying, shut up, and literally every time so on, makes me think of anime like TORADORA. 😅 And yeah. They are both PSYCHOTIC. That I think made them lose by end of a day. But Stu executed his alibi each time so well, even audience didn't suspect him of certain kills, that most likely by later plot proves, are his deeds. Like some think, even in opening scene Billy was alone, against solid clues like "Guess how I am gonna die?!" game, that involves two killers. Because Macher executed his alibi each time, no matter how much he play nuthead. Meanwhile poor Billy always ends alibi-less. 😂
@@mbuszka5295 Thanks for your comment! In the past, I’ve seen people mention a few scenes about Stu being shown as the killer throughout the movie, but I definitely agree that he was far less suspecting than Billy and played the killer role smarter. There’s always the speculation we could get Stu back! Depending on if you believe what a TV falling on your head would do.
@@BradHocTalk Another interesting fact about Billy and Stu is, as Billy character is rooted in PSYCHO, Norman Bates. Mom issues, sexual issues(by first script, Sid was suppoused to say Billy, before shooting him "And this, Billy studbucket, is for having INCREDIBLY SMALL WEENIE." (cringy, I know) Also being psychotic, standoffish and rather suspicious, if looked at closer. Stu's background is HALLOWEEN'S Michael Myers. We know his residence, his sister's name, HALLOWEEN is background for his house party, Stu got even some type of obsession with Jamie Lee, aka Laurie. But most of all, Stu got unnatural strengh, like in Kenny scene, where in seconds he puts 50 pounds overweighted Kenny on top of van. Don't know, how about his come back...BUT. Purely technically, putting aside all cases of surviving tv falling on someone... If he is unnaturally strong, just bracing himself, like he did, he COULD HAVE cover head from impact and GRAB TV. Then electroshocked, he pass out, like his whine suggest. What if biggest damage of this fall took HANDS, Not HEAD? Also, even putting away Myers strengh involved, he could just lessen impact covering face. At least that way Beyond the Mask made video about Williamson years ago saying, how Stu could have survive. I will be even happier, if they will FINALLY give Macher LEGACY, that was stolen from him. But as logically thinking person, I would love seeing why Stu's character got plot bullied. 😅
My ranking is so boring 1>2>3>4>5>6 1&2 are neck and neck for me I really like 3 based on how it concludes Sidneys arc. I also really enjoy the third act, while the first two get carried by Jennifer 😂 Scream 6 gets worse for me every time i see it, but i dont think i have it in me to say i dont like it. I'm teetering on it, though. Great video too by the way, valid points.
@@adrianphillips2136 Not boring at all! Even if in sequential order, that’s totally fair as your ranking! I can understand liking 3 with the idea of it wrapping up that original trilogy. Parker Posey definitely steals many of the early scenes lol. 6 had such potential but just fell flat for me. It’ll be interesting to see how they transition to 7. Thank you for your comment!
I actually agree that Scream 3 is the worst one. It's not a bad watch, but I've only rewatched this one a few times over the others in the franchise. Roman's role being retconned in there really undermines a lot of Billy and Stu's original plan.
You know, what is funniest?
From OG movie perspective, as much as Billy is created to be Walking Red Flag... Stu is doing MASSIVE INTELLECTUAL JOB.
He, unlike Billy is able execute his alibi, kidnap Sid father, when Billy distract Sid, keep him at his house(Neil), when still actively participating in tormenting Sid, Ghostface activities, bailing out Billy, preparing party, manipulating everyone into places, where they are expected (Tatum, Randy, everyone at party, emotionally manipulating Sid, even if she seen Randy attacked).
Stu also, even if most people believe it was Billy, due to look he gave, most likely killed Tatum. He literally paraphrase her last words to killer in final scene, when earlier he paraphrases Randy. And because Billy is Born Suspect, Macher fly under radar each time.
By pure OG movie, Stu did MOST PLANNING, even if people think Billy is mastermind, because motive is connected to him and he behave like tsundere girl from anime. 😅
I like Billy, but him hitting Stu as thank You, You are annoying, shut up, and literally every time so on, makes me think of anime like TORADORA. 😅
And yeah. They are both PSYCHOTIC. That I think made them lose by end of a day. But Stu executed his alibi each time so well, even audience didn't suspect him of certain kills, that most likely by later plot proves, are his deeds.
Like some think, even in opening scene Billy was alone, against solid clues like "Guess how I am gonna die?!" game, that involves two killers.
Because Macher executed his alibi each time, no matter how much he play nuthead. Meanwhile poor Billy always ends alibi-less. 😂
@@mbuszka5295 Thanks for your comment! In the past, I’ve seen people mention a few scenes about Stu being shown as the killer throughout the movie, but I definitely agree that he was far less suspecting than Billy and played the killer role smarter.
There’s always the speculation we could get Stu back! Depending on if you believe what a TV falling on your head would do.
@@BradHocTalk Another interesting fact about Billy and Stu is, as Billy character is rooted in PSYCHO, Norman Bates. Mom issues, sexual issues(by first script, Sid was suppoused to say Billy, before shooting him "And this, Billy studbucket, is for having INCREDIBLY SMALL WEENIE." (cringy, I know)
Also being psychotic, standoffish and rather suspicious, if looked at closer.
Stu's background is HALLOWEEN'S Michael Myers.
We know his residence, his sister's name, HALLOWEEN is background for his house party, Stu got even some type of obsession with Jamie Lee, aka Laurie. But most of all, Stu got unnatural strengh, like in Kenny scene, where in seconds he puts 50 pounds overweighted Kenny on top of van.
Don't know, how about his come back...BUT. Purely technically, putting aside all cases of surviving tv falling on someone...
If he is unnaturally strong, just bracing himself, like he did, he COULD HAVE cover head from impact and GRAB TV.
Then electroshocked, he pass out, like his whine suggest.
What if biggest damage of this fall took HANDS, Not HEAD?
Also, even putting away Myers strengh involved, he could just lessen impact covering face. At least that way Beyond the Mask made video about Williamson years ago saying, how Stu could have survive.
I will be even happier, if they will FINALLY give Macher LEGACY, that was stolen from him.
But as logically thinking person, I would love seeing why Stu's character got plot bullied. 😅
My ranking is so boring
1>2>3>4>5>6
1&2 are neck and neck for me
I really like 3 based on how it concludes Sidneys arc. I also really enjoy the third act, while the first two get carried by Jennifer 😂
Scream 6 gets worse for me every time i see it, but i dont think i have it in me to say i dont like it. I'm teetering on it, though.
Great video too by the way, valid points.
@@adrianphillips2136 Not boring at all! Even if in sequential order, that’s totally fair as your ranking!
I can understand liking 3 with the idea of it wrapping up that original trilogy. Parker Posey definitely steals many of the early scenes lol.
6 had such potential but just fell flat for me. It’ll be interesting to see how they transition to 7.
Thank you for your comment!
I actually agree that Scream 3 is the worst one. It's not a bad watch, but I've only rewatched this one a few times over the others in the franchise. Roman's role being retconned in there really undermines a lot of Billy and Stu's original plan.
@@meganberck6037 Cool to see we had the same thought! S3 definitely waters down the impact of the original ghostface duo. Thanks so much for watching!