M81 Galaxy photography and some ZWO EAF struggle

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 73

  • @frankskeen1310
    @frankskeen1310 2 роки тому +2

    I am thankful for your video.I think its cold when we get below 30f, minus 30F is ridiculous. You are a hard core astronomer and I give you praise.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thank you! 30f could be cold if you're not used to it and don't have clothes adapted for the temperature. Sometimes I think it's damn cold here, but I can't let it limit me. And after a period with temperatures below -30C, it actually feels pretty warm when it's -15-20.

  • @byronblanchard1354
    @byronblanchard1354 2 роки тому

    Just chillin on the reindeer rug. I love it!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Yes, I had a nice time there. I had a lot of clothes so it was comfortable!

  • @gomanastro
    @gomanastro 2 роки тому

    my favorite quote " wishing it was warmer, like -15" !

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      haha yes, after the midwinter, -15 feels as the spring is soon here. 😀

  • @Diocrew
    @Diocrew 2 роки тому

    Beautiful scenery and a great video. You are braver than most of us astrophotographers!!! ❄️ ❄️ ⛄

  • @korvdploeg4529
    @korvdploeg4529 2 роки тому +1

    This will never get bored. Not for you, nore for me. Unfortunatly your gear did not work as planned, but no worries. Its not the end result that matter's (for me) but the whole buissness around it is whats worth watching. Thank you

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you! The journey is the destination, and every session is an opportunity to learn something new. For me it's a lot of getting out and experience nature. But I hope for a little bit warmer temperatures; it's a lot of struggling in temps below -30°. (Now it's +2,5° but cloudy and windy)

    • @korvdploeg4529
      @korvdploeg4529 2 роки тому

      @@NorthernPanorama i can only imagine. Temperatures never get this low in the Netherlands. Even here up north Temperatures are about 10 degrees, Rain and clouds day in day out. A few weeks ago temperature dropped to minus 7, clear skies every day. That was the best time for me to be outside way past midnight🤗
      I hope better days are heading your way so you can continue making this awesome content!

  • @detlefberger6303
    @detlefberger6303 2 роки тому +1

    Hallo I Hope you have good memories from Hannover. Your Video clips is like a trip to Swedisch- Lapland to a Bortel1 Sky with Aurora boreaallis.. Clear Sky und not so cold...

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Hallo, Hannover was great! I have also driven through Germany quite many times! Nice that you enjoy the journey to Swedish Lapland! 😀

  • @Planetreefastro
    @Planetreefastro 2 роки тому +1

    David I admire your skill and your tenacity. I have not been able to image for two years due to spinal fusion surgery with lots of complications but I’m slowly getting better and I hope to be out there imaging again by end of summer or fall this year albeit in better temperatures. Keep up the great work. Love your videos.
    Luis

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thank you Luis! I hope you getting better soon, take small steps forward and soon you will be out imaging again! 🙏

  • @frosthastrophotography
    @frosthastrophotography 2 роки тому +4

    I haven't tested my EAF below -20 yet, but will keep it in mind. How about a dew strap? Waiting for a clear night to test my new camera here. Nice video as always, keep up the good work!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks! Yes, a dew strap is probably the most easy solution but I think of buying this one. Pretty cheap also. www.conrad.se/p/thermo-tech-polyester-vaermefolie-sjaelvhaeftande-12-vdc-12-vac-12-w-kapslingsklass-ipx4-l-x-b-110-mm-x-77-mm-532878?fbclid=IwAR3XmTC4TF6EKfLO1n9LniEDIRQmO_KbCMFfUq5eGg0LMUdGsReGkgGb02g

  • @KarlKyhl
    @KarlKyhl 2 роки тому +1

    I am really enjoying your videos! Especially ones with the 190MN. I have this same scope and struggle under much better (temperature) conditions to get results 1/2 as good as yours! I wish you continued success!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thank you Karl, it's a great scope! A little heavy to carry around though, but it's exercise! 😄

  • @SimonsAstro
    @SimonsAstro 2 роки тому

    Great Video David. I love the way you just lay down on the snow covered ground and stare at the stars! Its a pain having to go back to manual focus after being used to the EAF, but hopefully it will be fine again when its warmer! My EAF played up the other night and I lost over 1 hour of subs, they were all out of focus! Don't know what caused it, but seems to be ok now! Your M81 looks brilliant, great work, keep it up and Clear skies!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you Simon! The image lacks some detail and has quite bad SNR, I had to throw away almost two hours of lum data. Let's hope for some warmer temperatures soon. Clear skies!

  • @andre-dx4yw
    @andre-dx4yw 2 роки тому +1

    i had to turn my heating on watching this video, why would humans settle somewhere so damn cold lol, you have great dedication,

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      😅 That's a good question, but it's not always this cold. But sometimes I fantasizing about doing astrophotography in shorts. The summer could be pretty hot here, but then the night is all bright though.

  • @briankotak403
    @briankotak403 2 роки тому

    It is amazing that any electronic equipment would work at those temps! I suppose that NASA has figured out how to get things to work in temps much colder than -33oC, but they also have a slightly larger budget to work with than us! Keep up the inspiring work David. Dr B from Manitoba, Canada

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thanks! Yes, they have probably a slightly larger budget. 😀And the astro market for those of us that lives in cold regions is probably pretty small!

  • @davidjennings2733
    @davidjennings2733 Рік тому

    Wow, and here I am complaining about it being 53 degrees f. I am such a wimp.. You go David..

  • @iansoileau
    @iansoileau 2 роки тому

    26C down here in Florida last week! 😂

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      26C is a very warm summer day here. But then it's bright around the clock so it's not possible to do astrophotography (besides the sun though..) 😀

  • @davidleejenkins
    @davidleejenkins 2 роки тому +1

    Beautiful image! Here in Canada, I was imaging at minus 20 Celsius the other night and my EFW froze up and wouldn’t switch from H to S. It’s supposed to be clear and minus 30 tomorrow night, hopefully my EAF doesn’t freeze up too.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thank you David! I have not had any problems with the EFW (so far). How did it go? Did the EAF complain about the cold?

    • @davidleejenkins
      @davidleejenkins 2 роки тому

      @@NorthernPanorama To my surprise, the EAF worked well.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      ​ @David Jenkins Great! Maybe there are some batch variations? It's only -5-10C now but next time it's cold I will try with a modified dew heater band!

  • @DSOImager
    @DSOImager 2 роки тому

    Nice image... I get so cold watching your videos, lol. Hopefully you can get the focuser issues worked out.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Cold!? 😅 (it was a little bit chilly, I can admit). We will see what I come up to when it comes to the EAF!

  • @keithhanssen7413
    @keithhanssen7413 2 роки тому

    Enjoyed watching you take in the stars. I haven’t automated my acquisition because I enjoy being out and doing everything manually. Nice result, but unfortunate that the eaf konked out on you. It’s a tough hobby! Cheers!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thanks, yes sometimes it's demanding. And it's tough with problem solving out in the dark when it's cold like this.

  • @astrophoto_andy3335
    @astrophoto_andy3335 2 роки тому

    I had the same issues with my EAF but issue was with the ASI Air. Check the settings in the AIR. The latest firmware update supposedly resolved the issue. It had set the Max Travel setting to Zero; removed the backlash setting, and so on.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Thanks, I will look into it. I have noticed that the updates sometimes mess up settings.

  • @lsa168
    @lsa168 2 роки тому +1

    Had some -30 F here in North Dakota, USA

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      It's cold! I don't enjoy cold, but don't let it limit me either.

  • @paulyoung4817
    @paulyoung4817 2 роки тому

    Thanks David sorry about the EAF thang! As others have said, maybe a small ish dew heater tape. Do you think the drawtube maybe seizing up in the cold? Weather in South West of UK is hovering around zero degrees C but the humidity is 90% at night!!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      I tried to loosen the tension on the drawtube but it did not help. First I thought that was the problem, but now I'm pretty sure the problem is in the EAF. A small heater tape will probably help to solve this, I will order some stuff and try! 0° with 90% humidity sounds quite demanding. At least, the air is very dry up here!

  • @astrophotonics9470
    @astrophotonics9470 2 роки тому

    Not surprise the EAF failed at that temperature. dew strap time.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Yes I have to heat it up in these temperatures. At -20° it works fine though, so the limits seems to be below -25-30°

  • @JVRost
    @JVRost 2 роки тому

    Yes ... in China -30 ° is unlikely to happen, the designers of the ZWO did not foresee everything)) I look at your procedure for installing all the equipment and every time I think, I can build a remote complex, a frame on which I assembled everything warm and only rolled it out on a sled winter, summer on wheels. I also carry everything in parts and assemble it in my yard and I’m already pretty tired of it, now I’m drawing sketches of an astro cart, on which I will place 90 percent of the entire setup, except for a tripod or column.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      That sounds as a pretty nice solution. It's a lot of gear to carry around. I use a small plastic sled now, and it helps. I also look into a lighter set up so I can more easily go out to remote locations. This hobby is a lot of problem solving and find solutions that works for you own situation!

  • @photonbucket
    @photonbucket 2 роки тому

    Love watching your videos. The worst i've experienced is -17 and I wouldn't have dreamed of going out to image. Probably a daft question, but couldn't you just wrap a dew heater round the EAF? Keep up the great work.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Thank you for watching Robert! Yes a dew heater is probably the most easy solution but I think I will make a more slick solution it I find the type of heated plate I'm looking for. Something like this (in swedish though) www.conrad.com/p/thermo-tech-polyester-heating-foil-self-adhesive-12-v-dc-12-v-ac-2-w-ip-rating-ipx4-55-mm-1216621?searchTerm=thermo%20tech%20po&searchType=suggest&searchSuggest=product

  • @Bogfra1
    @Bogfra1 2 роки тому

    I have read a few comments and it is indeed advisable to look for a solution to keep the EAF warm in some way.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Yes, I will try to construct something! We will see what I come up to! :)

  • @hael8680
    @hael8680 2 роки тому

    How is your EQ6-r tracking in those temperatures? Mine doesn't like -25°C. Both axis get very stiff. I don't think SW used grease that was intended to be used at low temperatures.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      The guiding is actually pretty good even in these temperatures. I had a mean error of about 0.7-0-8 this session. I have not done anything with the mount so maybe there is some batch differences, I don't know!?

  • @gregoryneufeld7566
    @gregoryneufeld7566 2 роки тому

    Hello David, I wondered about a solution as others have. I have used mine to -25 but worried the whole time that the mechanical components would seize. I was gonna suggest a dew heater as someone else has. Would it be possible to use a different lubricant like graphite? Keep us posted, I suspect you will arrive at something uniquely suited.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Hello Gregory, I will look into it. I think the most easy solution is to heat with a pad powered from the asiair. There is pretty much space inside the EAF so I think it's possibly to make a slick solution if I find a small enough heated pad.

    • @gregoryneufeld7566
      @gregoryneufeld7566 2 роки тому

      @@NorthernPanorama Yes, I agree, probably easiest to use some type of heating pad. Dew heater to wrap around, powered from ur asiair or directly from battery. Has ur battery held up ok in the cold? Keep us posted as to how you work it out, much good luck!

  • @slzckboy
    @slzckboy 2 роки тому +1

    all these manufactures should be paying you for test proving their kit in extreme temperatures. Do you bother turning on the camera cooling ? :)

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      haha that would be great! If they dare! 😄I use cooling but the main reason is to get exact temperatures on each sub so I can use darks from my library! But when it's around -30C it's too cold to run the camera at -20C. There should be a camera heater too! 😁

  • @Zealor365
    @Zealor365 2 роки тому

    Just remember, if you fall asleep at -30, you might not wake up...

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Yes, it's a risk if you're not prepared. It would be a dramatic end to this channel. 😀 I have good gear though and if I sleep outside I use my warm sleeping bag.

  • @fiorenzomanganiello2853
    @fiorenzomanganiello2853 2 роки тому

    Hi, how is the quality of the sky in those places so cold?

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Hi, at this location I measured SQM around 19.96-20.00 but it's pretty near a city. If I drive an hour I can reach bortle 1 or 2 areas. During the M101 session I measuerd SQM 21.54 but then it was also snow and northern light, so it could be even darker.

  • @CaptRescue2
    @CaptRescue2 2 роки тому

    When we start this hobby know one tells us that problem solving will be as big a part of is as it is!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Haha yes, spot on. It could be very frustrating from time to time!

  • @tullyfisher
    @tullyfisher 2 роки тому

    Very interesting video. - Thank you. Did you find an alternative for the ZWO EAF already? And how's are your batteries working at those conditions? For first solution I would try a heating band, I guess... - Anyways... beautiful M81.

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks Tully! A heating band is probably the most easy solution. But I think of make something with a heated plate like this. The batteries works fine, I use two 73Ah marine batteries, a cheap and very reliable solution. I have to struggle with other batteries though - for my microphones, light, film camera and so on
      www.conrad.com/p/thermo-tech-polyester-heating-foil-self-adhesive-12-v-dc-12-v-ac-2-w-ip-rating-ipx4-55-mm-1216621?searchTerm=thermo%20tech%20po&searchType=suggest&searchSuggest=product

    • @tullyfisher
      @tullyfisher 2 роки тому +1

      @@NorthernPanorama In general, I like your idea to use a heated plate. But don't you think it would probably lead to an non-homogenous heating? The metal shell of the EAF is good for heat treansfer but it also cools down very fast...mybe some additional insulation could help (?)..I don't know..just my spontaneous thoughts about that. - Anyways..I'm VERY curious how you'll solve the problem. Maybe you can show it in one of your upcoming videos? - Thanks for the link. Probably a very helpful tool... All the best, Michael ;-)

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому +1

      @@tullyfisher Yes, I've been thinking about it and if I find a small enough heated plate I will try to attach it on the inside. There is plenty much of space actually. I've also thinking about making a small isolated box. If I come up with some fancy, I will show it in an upcoming video!

  • @Calzune
    @Calzune 2 роки тому +1

    Låser du fokuserings skruven när du fotar med EAF? (det ska du inte göra) Den skall du skruva bort när du har en fokuserare.
    Kämpa på i kylan!

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      Tackar! Vet inte riktigt vilken fokuseringsskruv du menar. Testade dock att lätta på anspänningen i fokustuben så i princip inget motstånd låg på EAF'en. Problemet uppstår bara i väldigt låga temperaturer.

    • @Calzune
      @Calzune 2 роки тому +1

      @@NorthernPanorama jag tänker på den tumskruven man tightar till när man har focuserat så att fokuseringen inte rör på sig. Svårt att förklara.. Ja kan skicka en bild till sig på Facebook om du vill?

    • @NorthernPanorama
      @NorthernPanorama  2 роки тому

      @@Calzune Ja skicka gärna. Tror jag vet vilken du menar, men den har jag aldrig låst. Däremot så brukar jag reglera anspänningen mot fokustuben i crayford-fokuseraren. Den här kvällen lättar jag på den så den nästan gled ut av sig själv bara för att testa om det var den som kärvade eller om problemet låg i själva EAF'en.

    • @Calzune
      @Calzune 2 роки тому

      @@NorthernPanorama jag har skickat ett meddelande på Facebook så du vet 😊