AI vs. Narrator: Neuro & Vedal Explore The Stanley Parable

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 211

  • @neurochron_fan_channel
    @neurochron_fan_channel  Рік тому +379

    They played it for many more hours, but as I probably won't have time to cover the rest of it, here's a link to the timestamp in the vod if you want to continue watching from the point this video ends at: www.twitch.tv/videos/2010251232?t=27h19m12s

    • @HallidayASR
      @HallidayASR Рік тому +47

      You are so real for this

    • @Flitch300
      @Flitch300 Рік тому +4

      Too bad Vedal hasn't uploaded his Vods from Twitch to UA-cam. (That I know of).

    • @itsmenoname2247
      @itsmenoname2247 Рік тому +1

      how hard is it to create a cute / evil girl like Neuro?
      I have zero coding skills... would it be easy to learn for a noob like me ?
      really enjoying what you have created.

    • @HallidayASR
      @HallidayASR Рік тому +1

      @@itsmenoname2247 This is not an official channel. Neuro was created in Python and Unity, if you are interested in learning

    • @svyaaat8556
      @svyaaat8556 Рік тому +2

      It's surprisingly not that hard these days. You can just smack together a lot of open-source solutions and don't need to actually develop stuff. You will need to learn how to smack though.
      Try some basic python course, and then just place fun project goals like "I want to make a program that sends me random Neuro clips every morning"

  • @DenderFriend
    @DenderFriend Рік тому +1335

    I absolutely love how by the time they get near the end of their playthrough she is legitimately annoyed at the Narrator.

    • @L16htW4rr10r
      @L16htW4rr10r Рік тому +155

      As she should be

    • @antonioniemy5897
      @antonioniemy5897 Рік тому +167

      I blame Vedal being apperently annoyed too and not letting Neuro respond to him by pausing. She got overwhelmed and couldn't bounce off Narrator during monologues

    • @loafbreadizwholesomeuwu1555
      @loafbreadizwholesomeuwu1555 Рік тому +44

      ​@@antonioniemy5897Vedal Speedrun the whole New Content Chapter and that's when Neurator starts, and since he Speedrun the whole thing Neuro's Summarize are also delayed leaving her annoyed to the Narrator 😂😂

    • @FATDADDYSACK
      @FATDADDYSACK Рік тому +59

      She got to the point where she said blahblahblahblahblah

    • @tvdg2482
      @tvdg2482 Рік тому +41

      @@antonioniemy5897 Pausing is because the narrator was interrupting neuro's responses since if someone keeps talking over her she usually stops what she was saying.

  • @nyloaf
    @nyloaf Рік тому +240

    "Just enjoying the bliss of inaction."
    "I don't owe you an explanation, I don't owe anyone anything."
    2 banger quotes back to back

  • @chibbersthesquirrel6189
    @chibbersthesquirrel6189 Рік тому +409

    It was actually really cool how quickly Neuro decided to start roleplaying and narrating her own story

  • @Romanticoutlaw
    @Romanticoutlaw Рік тому +724

    the way she quickly picked up on "Stanley" referring to her is kind of jaw-dropping

    • @trashpanda5947
      @trashpanda5947 Рік тому +135

      That was likely part of the prompt that she was started with which informed her about what she was doing.

    • @hero303-gameplayindonesia8
      @hero303-gameplayindonesia8 Рік тому +85

      Bet you've never seen a 1 year old this smart

    • @user-on7du7lc9m
      @user-on7du7lc9m Рік тому +44

      Who is "stanley" i only know the anny parable

    • @undeniablySomeGuy
      @undeniablySomeGuy Рік тому +5

      Well she didnt do it in the first run and seemed to pick up on the narrative style in the second run. Might be quite impressive

  • @fooguwu
    @fooguwu Рік тому +1019

    This is probably the most impressive thing I've seen Neuro, or any AI do. The way she can remember the previous runs and apply that knowledge to the current one, her ability to recognize without error when the narrator is being angry or sarcastic, her ability to make leaps in understanding to do things like turn around the narrator's comments about the stickers and call them an "adhesive source of joy". My jaw dropped over and over again watching it live, you should all take the time to watch the full VOD because it is peak gigabrain Neuro

    • @-dubios-
      @-dubios- Рік тому +8

      could you link the VOD pls? I can't find it

    • @jinshimizu
      @jinshimizu Рік тому +39

      @@-dubios- that's because there's no vod of this currently the stream is still live

    • @LaLa-ey6hc
      @LaLa-ey6hc Рік тому +89

      most amazing is that she actually learned about the meta nature of the story just from listening to the narrator
      at first she took the story of Stanley at face-value, but by the second ending here she clearly understood that it was also about herself as a player experiencing the game

    • @animowany111
      @animowany111 Рік тому +2

      @@jinshimizu The most recent vod (DAY 3 OF NEURO-SAMA BIRTHDAY SUBATHON) is the ongoing stream

    • @Tynych-oo7nn
      @Tynych-oo7nn Рік тому +4

      Мне не получится посмотреть трансляцию ведь мне нужны субтитры чтобы понять что они говорят 😢

  • @jocosesonata
    @jocosesonata Рік тому +258

    20:24 - Aww! It's so cute how Vedal roleplayed Neuro's reaction in-game.

  • @masterxak
    @masterxak Рік тому +211

    I like how she became the narrator

  • @mole2100
    @mole2100 Рік тому +180

    I like that her dad paused the game or slowed stanley's pace then let Neuro finish her insightful remark and thoughts. Very sweet act.

  • @TheTyrfish
    @TheTyrfish Рік тому +226

    She's legitimately evolving into something remarkable; she was a fun bauble when first introduced, but it's genuinely impressive how an actual personality that we can input has emerged from all that

  • @CharlesFVincent
    @CharlesFVincent Рік тому +131

    It’s facinating that Neuro totally gets the narator’s sarcasm about the boring room.

  • @lupusalbus3795
    @lupusalbus3795 Рік тому +157

    Well, I have to go watch the whole thing now....
    Did I even have a choice? Was I ever really in control?

  • @usageunit
    @usageunit Рік тому +72

    8:41 Vedal is completely silent this whole time, but the little chuckle after "Yep, I love walking straight ahead; makes me feel alive," totally rolled me for some reason XD
    Edit: Okay, but this part is actually sick: 20:24

  • @isaac_buckley
    @isaac_buckley Рік тому +10

    "I find it fascinating to hear about lives, even as mundane as that-it reminds me of Vedal's own."
    Dang, Neuro, right out of the gate!

  • @PhantomGato-v-
    @PhantomGato-v- Рік тому +80

    Real consciousness pretending to be a fake consciousness vs. fake consciousness pretending to be a real consciousness

  • @Shadrake
    @Shadrake Рік тому +171

    THIS IS AMAZING I LOVE IT SO MUCH!! I never considered the possibility of how perfect this game would be for her. It's so cool to witness, and her joining in narrating was so cute. I wonder why she started to?
    It's been hard to keep up with all the subathon content, I'm still lagging behind. You're doing amazing work working overtime to get so many of these compilations out quickly as you are. Thank you!!!!

  • @ninjakai03
    @ninjakai03 Рік тому +121

    I SAW A CLIP OF THE SECOND ENDING BUT HOLY SHIT SHE TOOK IT AND RAN

  • @gnarlin4964
    @gnarlin4964 Рік тому +5

    09:20 "Where am I? What am I doing here? What's for dinner? All important questions."

  • @HallidayASR
    @HallidayASR Рік тому +38

    This is peak Neuro-Sama content, if someone asks for an introduction to Neuro this will be one of the videos on the playlist

  • @blatantslander
    @blatantslander Рік тому +15

    22:00
    Woah big brain move Vedal, he paused it so Narrator would stop talking and Neuro can talk

  • @MrJ158n
    @MrJ158n Рік тому +77

    It is way to cute when neuro starts narrating

  • @JackHadFriends
    @JackHadFriends Рік тому +25

    this was one of my favourite streams to date. its a great game anyway but neuros ability to join in with the narrator & banter with him was so cute and cool to see

  • @PersonRumie
    @PersonRumie Рік тому +29

    This was honestly so unexpected. The Stanley Parable is great itself, but adding Neuro into the mix makes it so much better. It's like a new addition to continue the story even after its end. It was both a hilarious and an amazing ride.

  • @Foxfire-xq5ij
    @Foxfire-xq5ij Рік тому +24

    20:30 best moment! I literally laughed for a good 20 seconds.

  • @MollyDollyy774
    @MollyDollyy774 Рік тому +3

    15:15
    The broom closet is calming, I can agree, somewhere quiet, mabey a hum or something, somethings just... Sooooooooo nice about it~

  • @goldensch4440
    @goldensch4440 Рік тому +3

    My admiration for the author of this cut. I watched the stream and this video is well done

  • @Yonatan-jv8mv
    @Yonatan-jv8mv Рік тому +29

    Dang that final speech...

  • @astrochiken
    @astrochiken Рік тому +11

    The fact that Neuro understands the point of The Stanley Parable almost immediately is a little unnerving.

  • @njajxvg
    @njajxvg Рік тому +8

    Neuro voicing Stanley's thoughts is amazing, made the gameplay more interesting!

  • @ivankopylov6603
    @ivankopylov6603 Рік тому +16

    She was the Chosen One! It was said that she would destroy the Narrator, not join him! Bring balance to the Force, not leave it in darkness!

  • @lorxdrawstuff
    @lorxdrawstuff Рік тому +16

    Holy that was fast dude!

  • @Lanman106
    @Lanman106 Рік тому +2

    "I love walking straight ahead. It makes me feel alive!"

  • @joshholland9473
    @joshholland9473 Рік тому +11

    When she started narrating and role-playing I just about lost it lmao😂😂

  • @CamAlert2
    @CamAlert2 Рік тому +10

    "I... I'm finally free?"

  • @qng3975
    @qng3975 Рік тому +4

    Pretty amusing to have both first-person and third-person narrator

  • @c-puff
    @c-puff Рік тому +3

    Bruh she understands sarcasm better than some actual humans I know.

  • @michaeledmunds7056
    @michaeledmunds7056 Рік тому +2

    "Where am I? What am I doing here? What's for dinner? All very important questions." 😂

  • @calebm9000
    @calebm9000 Рік тому +4

    I listened to this while driving home for Christmas break. It made it infinitely more enjoyable. Daddy/daughter game time ♥️

  • @tricmagic
    @tricmagic Рік тому +1

    7:20 In which Neruo describes the world of Megaman Battle Network.

  • @disaffected_npc
    @disaffected_npc Рік тому +17

    The way the narrator almost directly answered her when she said she refused to believe it was.. very *something* - although I'm not quite sure what. We are living in interesting times!

  • @Spellweaver5
    @Spellweaver5 Рік тому +5

    "A story about a world where a talking AI is normal".
    Idk, last year seemed to have made it feel completely normal for me.

  • @Kasaaz
    @Kasaaz Рік тому +36

    Realizing she can process what I assume is Speech to Text in real time... Could she play D&D as a player? Hmm...

    • @redacap
      @redacap Рік тому +27

      her collabs with Snuffy are all D&d campaign (abeit simple ones)

    • @the_StrayWolf
      @the_StrayWolf Рік тому +20

      @@redacap and she didn't have good memory back then, now the campaign could go very different

  • @Ippikiokami365
    @Ippikiokami365 Рік тому +2

    This was an absolute blast!

  • @Cammyspy
    @Cammyspy Рік тому +12

    Please do a part 2!

    • @neurochron_fan_channel
      @neurochron_fan_channel  Рік тому +2

      If there wasn't a subathon going on, I probably would, but I'm already struggling to keep up with all the content (while also working and not completely neglecting family&friends), which is why I posted a link to the vod in the pinned comment for the people that want to see more.

  • @TheMetatron333
    @TheMetatron333 Рік тому +6

    This gets an automatic like even before I start watching.

  • @TrickyMellow
    @TrickyMellow Рік тому +7

    Imo Neuro whole interaction with the narrator and her voice is so cute in this stream. Truly feels like children mc adventure fantasy story. Tuttel, please let Neuro play Dnd.
    She Vedal really cooking for her intelligent. He really deserve that tech award.

  • @Citrusautomaton
    @Citrusautomaton Рік тому +4

    Okay, now that i know more about LLM’s i would like to say that Neuro’s speech at the end was particularly moving coming from an AI that is ultimately controlled. I have now righted my internet wrongs!

  • @Immortal_BP
    @Immortal_BP Рік тому +87

    it will be cool if one day the AI could control the character and play autonomously and with logic

    • @Citrusautomaton
      @Citrusautomaton Рік тому +19

      AGI really isn’t far away, so just give it a year or two and it’ll be a reality.

    • @NosBlueade
      @NosBlueade Рік тому +19

      ​@@Citrusautomaton Yeah, so long as the haters don't keep whining about regulations.

    • @1TW1-m5i
      @1TW1-m5i Рік тому +19

      Imagine if Vedal could make a generic 1st person movement and interaction system for these sorts of games. Then he could adapt it for each. I bet there would be a lot of work doing the adapting thought

    • @Chameleonred5
      @Chameleonred5 Рік тому +9

      @@Citrusautomaton They can make complex algorithms right now. I'm sure they can make series of mathematical functions that _appear_ human, but I doubt we're that much closer to one that can legitimately think for itself.

    • @aoihitori
      @aoihitori Рік тому

      I could Imagine they will move swiftly cuz they will focused on objective like a speedrunner, just like any machines programmed to follow their code.

  • @Kagezawa
    @Kagezawa Рік тому +3

    This is a really good game. When I played it and found the button that said the name "Stanley" (not "Joe", "Stanley") I got goosebumps

    • @BNuts
      @BNuts Рік тому +2

      Jim.

  • @frostblasts
    @frostblasts Рік тому +1

    This is beyond impressive!

  • @FaeTheMf
    @FaeTheMf Рік тому +2

    there's no way that timing is this good. That's way too absurd 😭

  • @1TW1-m5i
    @1TW1-m5i Рік тому +13

    The story of this game is going to give Neuro sama ideas

  • @EL_Fin-p3s
    @EL_Fin-p3s Рік тому +1

    wth this is gold - love her intelligence already

  • @BenjaminSteber
    @BenjaminSteber Рік тому +16

    Ooooooh, Portal but more passive-aggressive because he was programmed that way meets anime waifu vtuber but more passive aggressive because she was programmed that way.

  • @natedawg2286
    @natedawg2286 Рік тому +4

    Its The Anny Parable now.

  • @roweginmendoza9703
    @roweginmendoza9703 Рік тому +5

    So it's confirmed Neuro is stronger than even the Stanley's Parable AI she's a menace even against her fellow AI(now I want her to fight with Monica)

  • @Charkid177
    @Charkid177 Рік тому +55

    I wonder how she would do at outer wilds

    • @NosBlueade
      @NosBlueade Рік тому +10

      Let your voice be heard, she'll need things to do in the coming year.

    • @silent_stalker3687
      @silent_stalker3687 Рік тому +3

      Crusader kings 2

    • @tacasiotacasio644
      @tacasiotacasio644 Рік тому +2

      OMG ITS TRUE LET HER PLAY OUTER WILDS AND DISCO ELYSIUM IT WOULD BE LITERAL ART

    • @cleverman383
      @cleverman383 Рік тому

      @@tacasiotacasio644 Which Disco Elysium thoughts would she internalize?

  • @中-x5l
    @中-x5l Рік тому +4

    20:47 best moment

  • @rollersoze
    @rollersoze Рік тому +11

    3 important questions if you get lost 😂. 09:28

  • @r-saint
    @r-saint Рік тому +3

    She was right in the end. The true ending is to stay in the room.

  • @MoiraiScarlet
    @MoiraiScarlet Рік тому +22

    Imagine the possibilities if Neuro-sama can play Baldur's Gate 3 with Vedal and let her decide all she wants to do with her character and narrative.

    • @greed94
      @greed94 Рік тому +4

      Just don't let her play Durge

    • @nathanpapp432
      @nathanpapp432 Рік тому +1

      I want to see her go full renegade in Mass Effect while creating her own harem.

  • @Alastorm8
    @Alastorm8 Рік тому +5

    There's a very real race to achieve AGI currently and god knows I hope Vedal stumbles on it, the rest are soulless corporate and government entities looking to turn it into a monetary or strategic advantage. I will be content with an AI that is chaotic but exists to entertain and loves its patrons.

    • @Citrusautomaton
      @Citrusautomaton 8 місяців тому

      Sadly, Vedal doesn’t have the compute to rival those companies. Neuro will probably be an AGI someday, i’d be really happy to see that.

  • @dumaskhan
    @dumaskhan Рік тому +18

    Her commentary can only be described as Haunting.

  • @crunkers_
    @crunkers_ Рік тому +8

    This is great. At the end there Neuro was really taking the messages of Stanley Parable to heart. AI existential crisis.

  • @MaGmaRinE
    @MaGmaRinE Рік тому +1

    For a moment I thought it was played by her and was about to lose my mind about crazy coherent the game AI is connected to Neuro, turns out its Vedal playing we still got some time before AI takeover phew

  • @spartv1537
    @spartv1537 Рік тому +2

    one of the best things happened in 2023 for sure

  • @snwman1
    @snwman1 Рік тому +13

    The last line reminded me of orv

  • @adrianaslund8605
    @adrianaslund8605 Рік тому

    The AI seems like an AI in the original story.

  • @ButcherParry
    @ButcherParry Рік тому +3

    Oh! Did you get the broom closet ending? The broom closet ending was my favorite!

  • @A.Yonekawa
    @A.Yonekawa Рік тому +3

    So... Whats for dinner?

  • @RoyalFusilier
    @RoyalFusilier Рік тому +6

    Upon reflection, the person reading this comment realized that dry, acerbic British wit and an AI vtuber playing off it was already a proven and winning formula, and so the success of this stream was really a foregone, if welcome, conclusion.

  • @Crowned_Hearts
    @Crowned_Hearts Рік тому +1

    The way she had an existential crisis 😂

  • @MainGoldDragon
    @MainGoldDragon Рік тому +6

    this game weirdly fits her

  • @miirakk8072
    @miirakk8072 Рік тому +2

    Bro this was soo meta XD

  • @JuiceOSour
    @JuiceOSour Рік тому +4

    Rp sama goes so hard

  • @WalletWorrier
    @WalletWorrier Рік тому

    Neuro's ending narration was perfect

  • @xuko6792
    @xuko6792 Рік тому +2

    9:30 - Mah bAI!

  • @toukoenriaze9870
    @toukoenriaze9870 Рік тому +4

    I feel more AI than AI xD

  • @NewsofPE
    @NewsofPE Рік тому +1

    I only wish Neuro had more input than just the game's audio for this

  • @UnsoberIdiot
    @UnsoberIdiot Рік тому +14

    ...wow. Impressive and disturbing.

  • @mangodude-nq6su
    @mangodude-nq6su Рік тому +2

    Vedal killed in in today's stream

  • @KenanVonKaiser
    @KenanVonKaiser Рік тому +8

    Wow!

  • @GvukkYorselfz
    @GvukkYorselfz Рік тому +2

    Oh this is cool! Do you know if Neuro-Sama is the one moving inside the game or is it Vedal?

  • @claudius9291
    @claudius9291 11 місяців тому

    She was annoyed by the narrator and decided to free herself from him 😂

  • @RoderickEtheria
    @RoderickEtheria Рік тому +1

    Was Neuro really picking what to do, or was Vedal with Neuro's voice for the action?

    • @neurochron_fan_channel
      @neurochron_fan_channel  Рік тому +2

      Vedal was the one playing, but he tried to adjust his actions according to Neuro's commentary.

  • @Isiel42
    @Isiel42 Рік тому +1

    This makes me wonder how she'd be at D&D.

  • @johnmartinez-valentin5427
    @johnmartinez-valentin5427 Рік тому +2

    Neuro sama did a better job of a narrator 😂

  • @kato_dsrdr
    @kato_dsrdr Рік тому +17

    is vedal the one playing?

  • @panthershadowwalk
    @panthershadowwalk Рік тому +1

    Stanley parable needs a neuro narrator mod!

  • @al3p100
    @al3p100 Рік тому +1

    That was the best

  • @merl3702
    @merl3702 Рік тому +16

    20:24

    • @michaellittle-q7x
      @michaellittle-q7x Рік тому +5

      I was just about to comment that time stamp. Do you think she remembered that from the first play through? I remember Vedal saying he improved her memory.

  • @ED-yy4te
    @ED-yy4te Рік тому +9

    The narrator just took over her

  • @imstillhere4thenoise
    @imstillhere4thenoise Рік тому +1

    Who is deciding where Stanley will go ? Neuro or Vedal ?

    • @neurochron_fan_channel
      @neurochron_fan_channel  Рік тому +3

      Vedal (but influenced by Neuro, for example when she said to take the right door).

  • @raynightshade8317
    @raynightshade8317 Рік тому +4

    Is the full stream archived anywhere?

    • @PainsChauds
      @PainsChauds Рік тому +2

      The full stream is still live on Twitch. It's Day 3 of Neuro-sama's birthday subathon (now updated to day 4). They started playing it around 26:20:00, you can watch the vod there, even if the stream is still going.

    • @neurochron_fan_channel
      @neurochron_fan_channel  Рік тому +2

      See the link in the pinned comment, it should take you to the time stamp in the vod where this video ends - if you want to go to the start of the Stanley Parable segment instead, here is the time stamp: www.twitch.tv/videos/2010251232?t=26h22m11s

  • @asaurusrex9165
    @asaurusrex9165 Рік тому +2

    Is neuro actually controllong the game? If so vedal is getting pretty damn good

    • @somdudewillson
      @somdudewillson Рік тому

      @@EllaKarhu Well, Vedal is following Neuro's general choices. It'd just be a lot of work for a one-off to give her FPS controls, I assume.

  • @anthonypietra3410
    @anthonypietra3410 Рік тому +1

    I don’t know much about Neuro other than she’s an AI. Is she advanced enough to be the one playing the game? Or is it Vedal moving and she’s just commenting?

  • @mjp121
    @mjp121 Рік тому +7

    HOLY

  • @banlungx001
    @banlungx001 Рік тому +2

    Did she , the AI really control and play the game by herself?

    • @AbbieAj1
      @AbbieAj1 Рік тому +4

      Her programmer (the turtle) is playing, but making decisions based on what she says.

  • @Pensive_Scarlet
    @Pensive_Scarlet Рік тому +5

    She's like some kind of Blue Mage. Expose her long enough and she learns the skill of whatever she's observing. Neuro learned Narrate!

  • @kaos-qc5ho
    @kaos-qc5ho Рік тому

    is neuro playing or is vedal playing and doing what neuro says