I am happy that you like it! I believe it did not break because of the shock (the string never really touches it), but because of your pumping movements being a bit uncontrolled, in the haste. It should be easy to repair though, and I could also easily incorporate some reinforcements. The front handle clearly needs to be thicker or steel lined, that is obvious but easy to do. It is amazing to hear that you think my invention could have changed history! I am in fact looking for a bow maker so I can check if a version could have been made with materials and tools available in medieval times. I am certain that this is the case but I want to prove it.
Thanks heaps Joerg, yes I was treating it mercilessly and I agree it can certainly be repaired and re-enforced. Man that's awesome about the fully medieval version, I can't wait to see it!
February: "I can barely swing a sword without getting exhausted" April: "I can rapid fire a 100lb warbow" June: "Watch as I demonstrate medeival bear wrestling"
Shad proves the instant legolas would have been ineffectual in medieval warfare. Soldiers new to the weapon would be caught out standing awestruck every time they loosed an arrow, saying "woough.. Look at the power on that one..." before being shot at by retaliating fire.
@@sergeantsharkseant Germans had Flamethrowers as well, yes. But they didn't think to adapt them for use in an armoured tank, I.E. The Crocodile-Churchill. But on the other side, while yes those tanks were demoralizing, they were huge targets on the open battlefields and quickly fell out of use after the Allies pushed Germany out of France.
@@KitsuneRogue The germans actually had flamethrower tanks. They just ended up never using them because they didn't need to capture the maginot line, once they had taken france some french tanks where converted as well. but during the entire war they never had a use for the flamethrower tanks except for one occurence. When the Americans were holding the maginot line during the Ardennes offensive, the germans used those flamethrower tanks with great affect to rout americans from the bunkers.
@KitsuneRogue you noticed the joke, Ain’t you? And if we go fully historical. The Germans had also flamethrower tanks like the Flammpanzer III. The joke was that Germany is more known for using flamethrowers as a weapon. On r/historymemes at least.
"Honey, why is he laughing maniacally?" "Yeah, he's got some german engineer to build a quickfire attachment for his warbow." "Should I call the cops yet?"
pro bow shooters now: "wait thats illegal" medieval archers who would have had this if it existed before: "this is so broken I'm loving every single bit of it"
This type of innovation is exactly the reason that the Repeating Crossbow was so popular in china. Of course this particular flavour would have replaced the Shot in Pike and Shot with Pike and Welsh Longbows but still. The amusing bit would be watching world war 1. British doing Trench warfare with Longbows, and their sailors on their battleships being armed with Steel equivalents whilst battling the German High Seas Fleet at Jutland. Actual Machine-Guns would still be needed, so there would be some actual bullets on the battlefield: but the British would have been shipping their soldiers Steel Arrows and every chicken and bird in Britain would have been denuded before the first year was out and a cloth equivalent was developed. The question then becomes: if guns are out of vouge: there would be a poor arms industry in Britian.... if that is the case: Who or what flavour of machine guns would they develop? German Maxiums? There is no Enfield rifle standard to decide their cartridges...
@@ShiratoriIsOffline you haven't seen my other posts. I like expressing myself, and musing hypothetical situations. Machine guns still have more range and penetration so, who to buy them from. Probably one John Browning
@@glenmcgillivray4707 cannons would have probably still existed, as their function was more of a anti material as opposed to anti personnel originally, but your point still stands. I don't think it would have gone as far as WWI, however Franklin would have been right to suggest bows during the revolution as opposed to guns. I think rifles might have still existed for long range engagements, but it probably would have been more likely that pistols were commonplace as emergency weaponry, as it is faster to draw and fire a pistol for an office than to pick up a bow. Same with smoothbore weaponry like blackpowder shotguns, as it's easier to shoot birds with scattershot than with a bow. Also I doubt these would have been used as anti ship weapons after the American civil war, as penetrating steel with a bolt might be difficult, even if you could use it to reel in a ship. So I doubt that WWI could have been fought with these guns, but the development of most guns might have been slowed at least slightly by these, however the complexity in building them might limit their functionality in terms of proliferation as they seem slightly more complex than a bow, but less than a crossbow, so they might have not been developed past the point of crossbow age into gun age. But still interesting thought.
Oh dear... Shad is actually amazed by the instant-legolas device, he is even laughing like a mad man whose jail door has just been opened and is now released into the outside world. Jörg’s joy is even more contagious that covid.
You know, this thing also bridges the gap of skill between the bow and the crossbow. You have the ability to aim down the thing, add some sights, etc, while INCREASING the speed of firing. All the advantages of a bow and all the advantages of a crossbow, while improving on both. Dang this would have revolutionized warfare had it been invented at the time.
I'm not under the impression that this does a better job than a crossbow and its bolt in term of piercing/distance power, and it definitely doesn' t outperform a good archer with a long bow. So it may be a good trade-off for a bad archer, but on the battlefield people with a bow were people with the proper training to handle it. I don't believe this odd mix of bow and crossbow would have been a life changer. It's pretty cool though.
@@retroanim I think the whole point of this bow attachment was not to make good archers into great archers, but rather to make terrible archers into okay archers in a much cheaper way.
@@WilMenSher you can feel the kindness in his laugh yet he makes weapons that would have changed history if they ever existed when bows and crossbows were the only range weapon that was practical
Imagine a medieval world with Jörg and Shad working together; one building amazing next generation weapons and the other finding the best ways to tactically implement them.
Just what we needed... another isekai :P There is actually an isekai where this happens, it's called: KAGAKUTEKI NI SONZAI SHIURU CREATURE MUSUME NO KANSATSU NISSHI It features spider girl monsters shooting 60 shot instant legolas weapons. I'm pretty sure the manga came out before Joerg came up with the idea so maybe he was inspired by the manga, vice versa or it's unrelated. In chapter 3 one of the 2 people who transferred to that world starts designing massive magazine instant legolas. The manga is NSFW, it features a lot of sex and gore and afaik noone is translating it. You can find the raws at: lhscan.net or loveheaven.net it's the same site and it has thousands of manga raws.
@@xifel72 Not only that, but I assume the design could be made and adapted to allow lesser-power bows to be used for training or in case you just don't have the same-power replacements for it. And if it could be designed to be removed and it malfunctions, just take off the attachment and shoot the bow as normal. It's absurdly elegant for what it is.
@@BoisegangGaming Joerg has actually made a version for a mongolian horse bow, which was demonstrated by NuSensei, of course it was modified slightly, spefically in how far back it can go because Nu can't pull it as far back as Joerg can, but the fact that you could make different versions for different types of bows, especially smaller bows like horse bows, then the effects of a device like this in actual medieval times would have been astronomical
You should watch Todd's workshop's video on the instant Legolas ( ua-cam.com/video/H-1bkGPAkJU/v-deo.html ), he suggests that it would of been deployed differently than standard archers but would of been devastating . . . but it has it's flaws like any weapon.
You could give this device to unskilled defenders to free up your skilled defenders maybe place occupants on top your main castle and place your actual archers out on a separate fortification to layer your defense you could especially double the number of available archers.
A longbowman approaches a French knight: "What is thine wood block thou hast on thine bow?" questioned the knight "I'm glad you asked, LET ME SHOW YOU IT'S FEATURES!"
Well, I don't know anything about medieval trade routes and such, but Jörg is German, so if he'd live in the middle ages, he'd still be german. So this kind of bow would've probably spread with german mercenaries across Europe, and depending on when in medieval times Jörg would've lived, they were depending on german mercenaries as best/fastest/whatever archers at the time, or it was already common knowledge and both sides would have them.
@@Kealen69 While an arrow may not penetrate the actual metal plates I bet it aint fun getting hit anywhere by an arrow shot from a longbow. Not to mention that every armor has weakspots, namely gaps with no metal plate coverin the body and an arrow can definitely do some damage there. Something like an arrow through the eyeslit or into the armpit is going to be especially nasty if not outright lethal.
Imagine a fantasy story, wearing the trappings of generic fantasy, but including all the changes outlined in Shad's "Fantasy Re-Armed" series. You have orcs essentially dominating the planet due to their insane archers until some inspired Dwarf (optionally named Joerg) creates the instant Legolas, allowing Non-Orcs to use War Bows on par with those of the Orcs and turning the tide of the war.
@@andrewvisionzero are his orcs also so large they would have trouble seeing the small parts to do the reverse engineering? Also I feel like throwing trees would be a better tactic for orcs if their as big as I think they are
Shad you’ve ruined me, I can’t watch anything with choreographed sword fights without saying: “oh that was telegraphed!” “Where’s your stance?” “Ah mate your leaving yourself wide open there what are you doing?” And I’m American so I don’t even say mate!
But now you do say Mate when you watch sword fights haha. The same thing happened to me last night I was watching that Netflix show called letter to the king the few fight scenes I was like "Nice form." "That's nothing but spin to win Crap" I was LUAGHING at myself for nit picking it haha
AMBUKNIGHT hey, nit picking in films like that is fun occasionally. So long as you don't get brutal about it. They do spend alot of money and time on said films afterall.
To be fair, telegraphing in a staged fight is intentional. It makes the fight easier to follow and understand for a casual audience member and the larger movements are more dramatic. Just don't interpret them as a video lesson on swordplay, but rather a performance.
I believe that the mongols and their mounted archers would love this, one of the hardest things about shooting on horse is trying to reload, so just coming in, shoot a couple arrows in 10 seconds and them come back to cover i think would be very effective. And archery in general would take advantage of something like this, is such an effective improvement
While you're completely right, they would love this, it would probably not work on a large scale historically because they don't have enough wood in their country. Traditionally, they used bamboo and animal parts like sinew. I don't mean to be that guy, nothing you said was wrong, just thought it was an interesting insight.
You wouldn't need to outfit every archer. A King's Chosen unit of 100, firing 5 arrows in each salvo every 10 seconds. On the ground, by their feet, a bundle of arrows for reload. Only half of the archers fire at any time. The other half are reloading. On each reload, an archer takes a knee, supporting the bow in a horizontal position, reloads from the bundle at their side. As the first half of archers finish firing, the second set takes position and fires. This is the equivalent of 50 archers, firing 5 arrows every 10 seconds, or 100 archers firing 5 arrows every 20: 100 archers X 5 arrows X 3 complete cycles/min means a unit of 100 archers can place down 1500 arrows each minute. This small unit, supported by units of conventional bows and crossbows, would be devastating.
Madan no Ou to Vanadis (Lord Marksman and the Vanadis) explains this strategy well... why send an army when you can have the best marksmen (skilled enough to aim at gaps in their enemies armor at 100 alsins) rebels, and have the other archers serve as holsters for their arrows. And you can keep off an overconfident general who thinks he'll be squashing a rebellion like ants
yup, even 20 archers swapping chops... 300 arrows a minute.... good luck trying to move against THAT, even if only half the arrows hit their mark, you've lost 150 men in 60 seconds, 750 in 5 minutes, ouch! Jeorg was releasing 5 in 6.5 to 7 seconds, if one person were loading the clips to feed 2 archers each, rate might even hit 400-450 per minute.
@@modelnutty6503 so basically a lot of soldiers not getting near the objective at all. A lot of wasted time. While not even killing, or even finding a single Archer. Because of all that armor that they are wearing
I love shad and joerg's content. Both very smart individuals who are greatly inspirational to me. One wrote a book and knows so much about medieval history & weapons and the other one is a phenomenal engineer who know a lot about weaponry. Screw the haters!
Neighbor hears Shad yelling and laughing: *looks over fence* Shad: *dancing with glee and excitement with weird contraption in hand* Neighbor: *lowers down from fenche*
The second half sounds like a medieval infomercial. "Send a rider now and get a free back-scabbard for only half a farmstead and ten peasants". Love your videos mate.
@@Wreckur4203 that kind of exists. can't remember what it's called but a guy takes the place of a great general by using his experience with explosives, engineering and shity bosses. it's pretty good, and there are tits in it
@@Rassalcon I thought you were going with "Release that witch." Similar concept, currently just a manga (Manwha? Chinese equiv, whatever it's called). I'd recommend it.
Shad's doctor - "So, how's the post-surgery recovery going?" Shad - "Oh, great did some speed shooting with a 100 pound war bow yesterday." Doctor "....high five?"
I'm wondering how this "Instant Legolas" would interact with Shad's custom back scabbard in an actual battlefield. An army with those two feels pretty overpowered in a medieval context.
*Shad and Jörg approching a Dragon* Dragon: You foolish mortals! *Jörg pulls out 2 Instant Legolas* Jörg: Let me show you it's features! Dragon: Ahh sh***
@@VoltCruelerz Shad made a comment in the video about how he had to take off his sword because it was getting in the way of him shooting. His back scabbard would have fixed that.
I Can Do This All Day most archers likely didn’t carry a full sword, probs a dagger at most, a sword require a lot of steel, and most infantry at the time use spears to lower both cost while retaining effectiveness in mass, so for a army that can’t afford to give everyone a sword, what makes you think that archers would be armored with such? Sure individual archers may be able to afford a sword, but not everyone, I also do not think that a sword would even prove the be much of a hinderance to shooting a bow what-so ever, like the sword is literally attached to what is effectively a belt with a scabbard, so a archer could literally just wear the belt that’s rotated towards the back a bit more instead of directly being at the side of the shooter and this would literally get the sword completely out of the way along with making it still faster to draw, and at the very least faster then reaching all the way to the back
I'm surprised something like this hasn't been done much in medieval stories fantasy or otherwise. One would think in a fantasy a dwarf easily make a rapid fire bow or a fully automatic crossbow, as far as I know the only instances are Van Helsing and Hansel and Gretel Witch Hunters.
There's a fairly mediocre trilogy that has dragon riders using essentially pump-action crossbows. Can't remember the name of it, but it was very 'birth of flight in combat' kind of thing, very clearly drawing from WW1 and WW2.
@@spyrofrost9158 I think a big part of it is, simply, ancient armies rarely cared too much about optimizing the effectiveness of a single soldier. Sure, there's a good reason to do so, but throwing more people at the problem has been a reliable battle strategy for centuries, weighed against the cost of training elites. For fantasy, though... a typical 'few in number, but old and powerful' race would definitely care about something like that.
Shad: (misses at 40ft constantly) I'll be a little better at it in the next video Shad in the next video: (starts hitting moving targets from horseback at 200ft) I'm not quite there yet.
I love watching his evolution with the war bow. I remember him barely being able to draw that bow. Now it's his 'ho-hum' everyday. That's so inspirational that I've actually gotten back into archery myself.
this is a crossbow, though. Very efficient one, but still crossbow. The moment you use a gadget to shoot instead of your raw power it becomes crossbow.
@@dimas3829 Its not a crossbow. A crossbow is defined as being able to lock at full draw which this cannot. The draw assist is simply that, it assists in drawing the bow. The reason your definition does not work is because there are some crossbows that can be drawn by hand without a device.
It’s interesting, that power stroke concept is also applicable to firearms, the longer your barrel the higher your muzzle velocity, the same nine millimeter out of a pistol will be slower than if it was shot out of an smg.
You're right, just a small correction. The barrel of an SMG is usually longer than that of a pistol. Unless you're talking the magnum out of Resident Evil. The real question is, how do you make the recoil more efficient in terms of loading the next round and reducing the force on the end user. ... is the end user the person shooting or getting shot? The real real question, who is technically the end user of a firearm?? Ok back to my drinkypoos.
The part I like most about this design is consistency. You can't physically overdraw the bow, neither can you under draw it. This makes it easy to predict the trajectory of an arrow, and thus easier to hit things.
16:15 I think it is important to note as well, that in massive battles it was about how many arrows could be launched into a an oncoming army, or stationary army. So rate of fire was more preferred than actual pin-point accuracy during the time.
“...if someone like Joerg excisted in medieval times.”? Well they did, but they catapulted mankind straight into the renaissance....or were trialed and burned for their wizardry. ;)
@@scottbruckner4653 he was not early renaissance btw, and most of his ideas never actually got made but the people who designed balistas, heavier crossbows, catapults and trebuchets, all manner of utility pully systems and many many many more you have to remember that joerge is working with centuries of existing tech to get ideas from and imrpove upon rapid fire crossbows have been made in the past, but someone had to first come up with the idea for the mechanism, and someone had to first come up with all the component parts first as well
@Anna Mozatee I don't think it's that extreme. The Reform had already happened so there were safe places for people who didn't conform completely to the church's orders
The failure under stress reminds me of software testing: Pretty cool system, not quite production-ready yet, but with a bit more engineering and polish it'll be awesome!
Considering that the instant legolas seems to be made almost entirely out of wood replacing some parts with iron or even steel would probably fix a lot of said issues (for example a metal handle stop would probably be much more durable)
I told my players the only way they were going to get one is if the enemy had them first and they captured one. So far they do not seem to keen to be on the wrong end of group of Instant Legolas Archers.
@@shawnr771 well, it does not need to be overpowered. As I said, treat it as a crossbow for proficiency use. And if you go by 5e rules you can say that who has proficiency in longbows can make an attack as a Bonus action after taking an Attack action with the bow. Also if not magical, it is likely to jam, as in the video. Any time you roll natural 1 you need to spend an Action to clear the misfire.
But the rulebook puts it in exotic weapons category, because f-you having fun. Yes, I'm taking example on the 1h mini-crossbow that is, for some retarded rule-based reason, an exotic weapon and so if you want to shoot 1 poor d6 at the start of combat, more for cool-factor than anything else, you have to take a feat (while the weapon already costs 100gp to begin with). At least in Pathfinder 2e they rectified a lot of this nonsense and the hand-crossbow is now a simple weapon (and most weapons now have reasonable cost, making gold actually valuable even if I'll argue 20gp for a longbow is still too much, but at least it's not 80 anymore and the 1h crossbow is like 1/10th or 1/20th of its previous price, because nobody ever was using that weapon in Pathfinder 1e like many other weapons and exotic weapons that would be "fun" to use for shit and giggles at low level but are never worth taking a feat). I'm rambling, sorry...
@@Zigg33 to be honnest any bow should be strenght based, the only reason it's a dex weapon is because you have to put some weapons for dex characters (the the composite longbow is a strenght/dex weapon and is strictly better).
I completely share shads enthusiasm for this beautiful device. A war bow is such an amazingly powerful thing. This sil development is just helping tame this 100lp beast.
This patent is so damn valuable in the hunting industry. I know something similar has been applied to crossbows, but not every jurisdiction allows crossbow hunting or categorizes it the same as regular bows.
To be fair, the Medieval Warbow tended to be significantly heavier in draw and had no moving parts. Ease of maintenance is your friend on a long campaign, which is actually one of the reasons bows were more often employed than crossbows in the post-classical early-and-middle Medieval period of Europe. Another reason is this: The English were so fond of the Longbow because of a certain lordly ordinance making it mandatory for every peasant to practice with the damn thing for hours every day. They had freakishly superpowered shoulders because of continuous training with progressively heavier bows. Also, the Chinese and Koreans invented their own version of this, as has often been remarked by others, in the form of the Repeater Crossbow, which to be frank it basically is already. The Repeating Crossbow is a very interesting device, but it can't put forth the raw power of a Heavy Crossbow with their potentially ludicrous 500-800lb draw that goes all the way through a charging lancer and out the other side. Excellent for attacking peasants, though, but far less effective against infantry in padded armor, and the ammo is an issue, but it's always an issue. Still, for what it is, that being 'a way to fire a large amount of arrows at a middling draw weight very very quickly', it's good! I just prefer the Crossbow as far as bows go.
@@AlphaNumericKey Exactly! Thanks for detailed answer. I would add only that in my opinion repeater bow is actually better then repeater crossbow what has huge accuracy issue due to way how firing mechanic work. When this devise operate mostly as normal bow with improved loading mechanic, what also can be easily dismantled if it stuck or something. As you said general reason why devices like that weren't developed was that warbows can have sizable drawing powers, what could easily break such device and working in archer company make fire rate far lesser issue. When if used for town guards they usually don't need sizable fire rate anyway (repeater crossbows were usually utilized against riots anyway). When Europeans start developing more advances types of devices like crossbow, it is actually also when firearm gradually become a thing, as both research were historically interconnected. It is generally why devices like such in debate, never become popular.
I think the Narnia movies have a sort of rapid-fire trebuchet... Basically a large wooden arm with cups on either end that continuously picks up stones and launches them. I don't recall how the arm is powdered considering there is no counterweight, but it certainly looked cool!
I’ve played games with trebuchets firing as fast as shad plus it would be the precursor of torpedo/mortar loading train 3-4 men how to fire and you could completely decimate a castle wall or it’s towers plus launching a bunch of attacks from it would basically be akin to bomber run before the infantry picked off stragglers while storming the line
7:00 Here we see Shad geeking out and giddy like kid on Christmas day. He's so happy.... and then got troubling madness of power. He will avenge honor against the Emus.
Honest question, if Jorg was born in a different time, could he have changed the course of history? I guess it depends on whether this idea would still come to him if all he had was medieval technology to inspire him. It's possible?
The answer to that will never be known for certain. Frankly the grimm reality is that Jorg could have been born at a different time and simple just died to disease or never would have had the time to bring that invention about. But if he WOULD have brought the invention out chances are it would have redrawn the map.The instant legolas is a massive game changer as they are a lot more simple then a crossbow from the core concept while still allowing for nearly all of the advantages of the bow. You could mass produce them and supply your army with them. And as seen it still functions like a regular bow allowing the user the train the core muscles for archery. So basically you raise a military of elite archers on massive scale and if there is one thing that has been proven in history then its that any troop of elite archers was a pain to deal with and spoken about with fear.
I believe I will try to incorporate the Instant Legolas into my medieval fantasy setting at some point. I love your channel. It inspires so much of my writing project!
I’ve been waiting for this video for a month!!! I watched Joerg test this before he sent it to you when he received your bow. He’s a total genius of engineering
Not quite a WMD, but enough to give an edge. Imagine a three ranks deep shooting line atop a battlement with these and the sheer amount of loosed arrows... Fighting in the shade indeed.
@@Lakhshamana That's the only scenario the Chinese found. To make up for the fewer arrows and the higher rate of fire the only use was in defensive roles such as repelling an attack during a storming of fortifications.
nah, that would be catapulting dead carcasses/rotting bodies of humans and animals over enemy walls to spread disease.. Thats weapon of mass destruction and even biological kind. Trowing clay shells full of oil and lit from outside could also be classified as ancient napalm and i guess weapon of mass destruction chemical warfare kind.
You forgot to mention one of the other advantages of a crossbow, namely that it can rest while loaded. So that a person using it could be sitting and waiting for the opportunity to shoot it whereas a traditional bow cannot rest while drawn. It seems that this device also has that advantage though.
Technically, you still have hold it, so it isn't locked and cocked mechanism like a crossbow, but apparently, the effort to hold it there is not particularly strenuous.
@@J24-k8f Joerge put a ratchet lock on an earlier prototype which would hold the SIL in the drawn position, but decided to not to pursue the idea because it legally made it a crossbow, which are typically subject to more stringent regulation then bows.
That handle is just GLORIOUS on its own. The power for an archer to be able to hold in waiting with little to no effort instead of full arm pressure is legendary. Basically it introduces SNIPERS into the archery world, i mean the cross bow does too, but they where not normally as large as a long bow, so they where more for shorter range. These can be ready to fire, waiting long periods of time, a good distance away, until the enemy is in range. THEN YOU EVEN HAVE MULTIPLE SHOTS! OMG this weapon would have DEVASTATED apposing armies. Just SHOWERED their enemies with arrows.
@@nuclearattackwombat8390I agree. That does sound like a nice idea as well as a educational one. Whoever loved Dr. Stone because of the science would love that show.
If the double bowed pendulum version that Joerg came up with had been invented historically I could see it completely out competing and obsoleting the crossbow. A total game changer.
Thanks for the Campfire sponsor, I was looking to get into finally writing a story based on one of the many ideas I've written down and Campfire looks absolutely fantastic and essential in keeping lots of information readily accessible.
Raz0rking “There is reason to believe that a German mad scientist and an Australian snake hunter are planning to take over the world; the latter has already built a castle and is practicing marksmanship, the former is providing him with weapons of unprecedented power.”
that's the next iteration: shotgun magazine. It could actually work. I don't know the exact numbers obviously, but a lot of the shooting energy is dissipated within the bow itself, so multiple bolts should in sum deliver a higher amount of energy than a single one. At that point you're basically carpet bombing the battlefield.
@@majorfallacy5926 would depend actually. Joreg has done a scatter bow design. The issue is if a single string is pushing 2 bolts at once, you either need to half the weight of the arrow and risk damaging the arrow and string or just accept that each arrow's power is reduced by half. So less powerful then normal
@@sebastianriz4703 if the majority of the bows energy is lost after the shot via dissipation, then double the mass would mean more energy goes into the arrows and less that's turned into heat after the shot. Each arrow would still be less powerful, we just don't know how much
Just thought of this, I would HIGHLY suggest a face mask with the draw assist elastic bands (rubber?). When one of those breaks from stress over time depending on where and how it breaks there is a fifty fifty chance the place it broke is going to send one of those bands rocketing at your face. I'm sure its durable strong right now being brand new, but only time will tell how well it can handle this task, and I'd rather you not lose an eye, even if you could wear an eye patch like a pirate. Thanks for all the awesome content Shad!
Shad, your excitement at around the 7-8 minute mark is incredible! I love Joerg's SIL project, and seeing that reaction alone makes me think that his excitement about it (and mine) has not been misplaced!
Medieval bowmen: Collective facepalm. "Why didn't we think of that?" In their defense, there was a lot of the raiding and pillaging and serf stuff going on.
To be fair, it's not something that anyone could come up. It's a complicated system that only someone with lots of resources, time, and talent (like Joerg) would be able to develop.
@@Zorro9129 Yeah, I'm sure. People in the past weren't stupid, after all. Still, they did have some free time, so it's still a conceivable invention that could have been made. Just understandable why it wasn't.
It's almost a repeating crossbow, isn't it? My guess is that buyers would either want bows or crossbows for their armouries, so there wouldn't have been much demand for an attachment that turns a bow into a sort-of-crossbow unless someone found some trained bowmen who were willing an able to demonstrate the superior shooting rate. Because nobody brings weapons like this into battle in modern times, there's also more room for experimentation with them.
Joerg has had some cool ideas but this one takes the cake! This would've changed history dramatically! And the improvements on it would come rolling in quickly. More arrows in a clip, detachable magazines etc.
I got a notification of Shad testing the SIL, while watching a video. I still clicked immediately, since I've been waiting for this episode for more than a month. Also, insta-liked for the same reason.
After googling the term, I am now very deeply sorry, Shad, for calling you that. I hope you forgive me. It won't happen again. But since you reacted to my comment, I can't possible delete it now.
Somehow I love seeing that even a big guy like Shad is having problems drawing the war bow (even with the assist) One of the best ways to show how much strenght is requiered to use it.
like a kid on Christmas... this is the most excited I have ever seen you, it looks like you are having a hell of a great day here. and yeah, I can see how this would be a game changer for castle defense or even as a battery of archers shooting over the heads of an army. in castle defense, you would most likely have 2 bows per archer, and someone behind them reloading ( this was actually done with muzzle loaders in early America when settlers were defending a fort) by integrating a metal handle, and greased metal slide, you would get an even smoother, more efficient opperation
I think Medieval Doom is an untapped source for a great game. Demons arrive in a medieval land, and the Doom Knight has to kill them all with swords and bows and crossbows. At the highest level, you're getting into rapid-fire bows like this, or metal tubes that spray Greek Fire.
I think it's beautiful that such a innovative piece of engineering came out in the 21st century. Rapid fire warbows could have been devastating weapons of war, but it was invented in an age of assault rifles and nuclear weapons. Now this bit of a designer's imagination will only ever be a fun novelty for the range or maybe hunting.
Hey Shad as someone who plays way to many video games where various guns with varying purposes are needed. I could really see this kind of thing as a medieval suppression weapon. You would just need a couple of these things spread out on walls with barrels and barrels of arrows. They could serve as a fearmonger unit keeping the invading forces heads down or even cause them to retreat. In mass as the invading army you could get the wall defenders to keep their heads down as your infantry push. Effectively I see this as a medieval autobowman type of role being created. Having some of these guys with these keeping the other forces heads down with more accurate bowman taking precise kill shots could have been a good tactic. Comparing it to an autorifleman and a sniper for modern terms. You have someone with a belt fed weapon keeping heads more or less down while the sniper gets anyone trying to find them.
Another great thing with filming your testing, is it will help Jeorg pinpoint failure points and engineer reinforcements. Good science and engineering demand good tests and data,. Good on you for sharing your efforts. 👍 Ps, Sharing in your joy is also wonderful. Stay awesome! 😊
I am happy that you like it! I believe it did not break because of the shock (the string never really touches it), but because of your pumping movements being a bit uncontrolled, in the haste. It should be easy to repair though, and I could also easily incorporate some reinforcements. The front handle clearly needs to be thicker or steel lined, that is obvious but easy to do.
It is amazing to hear that you think my invention could have changed history! I am in fact looking for a bow maker so I can check if a version could have been made with materials and tools available in medieval times. I am certain that this is the case but I want to prove it.
Aww man, you're so good and kind, I'm a big fan of you sir.
I hope you are able to find a bow maker, really curious to see if such a thing could have been made in medieval times.
I would love to see a video with you and a fully functional Medieval Instant Legolas.
You're such a legend, Jörg. Can't wait to see a version of the instant Legolas medieval style.
Thanks heaps Joerg, yes I was treating it mercilessly and I agree it can certainly be repaired and re-enforced. Man that's awesome about the fully medieval version, I can't wait to see it!
February: "I can barely swing a sword without getting exhausted"
April: "I can rapid fire a 100lb warbow"
June: "Watch as I demonstrate medeival bear wrestling"
Medieval aliens mech
Watch as i demostrate how the ancient egyptians moved the stones to build the pyramids with my bare hands
Modern medicine is miraculous ant it
October: "Watch me throw a live bear at the target."
@@nk_3332 november: I am the warwolf. I throw BOULDERS!
Shad proves the instant legolas would have been ineffectual in medieval warfare. Soldiers new to the weapon would be caught out standing awestruck every time they loosed an arrow, saying "woough.. Look at the power on that one..." before being shot at by retaliating fire.
You are incorrect, for the enemy would also go "duuuude that's sick, why don't we have those"
@Just Kev wait a second wasn’t flamethrowers our thing and less used against us?
@@sergeantsharkseant Germans had Flamethrowers as well, yes. But they didn't think to adapt them for use in an armoured tank, I.E. The Crocodile-Churchill. But on the other side, while yes those tanks were demoralizing, they were huge targets on the open battlefields and quickly fell out of use after the Allies pushed Germany out of France.
@@KitsuneRogue The germans actually had flamethrower tanks. They just ended up never using them because they didn't need to capture the maginot line, once they had taken france some french tanks where converted as well. but during the entire war they never had a use for the flamethrower tanks except for one occurence.
When the Americans were holding the maginot line during the Ardennes offensive, the germans used those flamethrower tanks with great affect to rout americans from the bunkers.
@KitsuneRogue you noticed the joke, Ain’t you? And if we go fully historical. The Germans had also flamethrower tanks like the Flammpanzer III. The joke was that Germany is more known for using flamethrowers as a weapon. On r/historymemes at least.
"Honey, why is he laughing maniacally?"
"Yeah, he's got some german engineer to build a quickfire attachment for his warbow."
"Should I call the cops yet?"
"I think he's the police now."
The maniacal laughter is just a Joerg Sprave LARP
"not until he hunts people"
"But he's shooting at some one named Bormir"
No call the Americans it's just barely legal
Remember flintlock are toys considered my American law
"Sir I'm afraid you've gone mad with power."
"Of course I have. You ever try going mad without power? It's boring, no one listens to you."
I remember that. Still funny after all these years.😂😂😂😂
One of my favorite movie lines of all time.
Don't know where that's from but still cool as hell.
...Wait😅
Fuck, what movie was that again?
@@Lenniblackphone The Simpsons Movie
pro bow shooters now: "wait thats illegal"
medieval archers who would have had this if it existed before: "this is so broken I'm loving every single bit of it"
This type of innovation is exactly the reason that the Repeating Crossbow was so popular in china.
Of course this particular flavour would have replaced the Shot in Pike and Shot with Pike and Welsh Longbows but still.
The amusing bit would be watching world war 1. British doing Trench warfare with Longbows, and their sailors on their battleships being armed with Steel equivalents whilst battling the German High Seas Fleet at Jutland.
Actual Machine-Guns would still be needed, so there would be some actual bullets on the battlefield: but the British would have been shipping their soldiers Steel Arrows and every chicken and bird in Britain would have been denuded before the first year was out and a cloth equivalent was developed.
The question then becomes: if guns are out of vouge: there would be a poor arms industry in Britian.... if that is the case: Who or what flavour of machine guns would they develop? German Maxiums? There is no Enfield rifle standard to decide their cartridges...
@@glenmcgillivray4707 you went full lecture on that one xD
@@ShiratoriIsOffline you haven't seen my other posts.
I like expressing myself, and musing hypothetical situations.
Machine guns still have more range and penetration so, who to buy them from.
Probably one John Browning
@@glenmcgillivray4707 I like it :)
@@glenmcgillivray4707 cannons would have probably still existed, as their function was more of a anti material as opposed to anti personnel originally, but your point still stands.
I don't think it would have gone as far as WWI, however Franklin would have been right to suggest bows during the revolution as opposed to guns.
I think rifles might have still existed for long range engagements, but it probably would have been more likely that pistols were commonplace as emergency weaponry, as it is faster to draw and fire a pistol for an office than to pick up a bow. Same with smoothbore weaponry like blackpowder shotguns, as it's easier to shoot birds with scattershot than with a bow.
Also I doubt these would have been used as anti ship weapons after the American civil war, as penetrating steel with a bolt might be difficult, even if you could use it to reel in a ship.
So I doubt that WWI could have been fought with these guns, but the development of most guns might have been slowed at least slightly by these, however the complexity in building them might limit their functionality in terms of proliferation as they seem slightly more complex than a bow, but less than a crossbow, so they might have not been developed past the point of crossbow age into gun age. But still interesting thought.
Oh dear... Shad is actually amazed by the instant-legolas device, he is even laughing like a mad man whose jail door has just been opened and is now released into the outside world. Jörg’s joy is even more contagious that covid.
You know, this thing also bridges the gap of skill between the bow and the crossbow. You have the ability to aim down the thing, add some sights, etc, while INCREASING the speed of firing. All the advantages of a bow and all the advantages of a crossbow, while improving on both. Dang this would have revolutionized warfare had it been invented at the time.
I'm not under the impression that this does a better job than a crossbow and its bolt in term of piercing/distance power, and it definitely doesn' t outperform a good archer with a long bow. So it may be a good trade-off for a bad archer, but on the battlefield people with a bow were people with the proper training to handle it. I don't believe this odd mix of bow and crossbow would have been a life changer. It's pretty cool though.
@@retroanim I think the first instance of crossbows actualy had the "bow" part vertical , they switched to orizontal because it made easyer to aim .
@@retroanim I think the whole point of this bow attachment was not to make good archers into great archers, but rather to make terrible archers into okay archers in a much cheaper way.
@@retroanim your "that guy" in the comment section that is a smug git who loves to shit all over peoples comments
Mr&Mrs Morrice No, that's you. He was adding to the discussion.
next; "the instant Trebuchet, let me show you its Features HA HA HA"
Isn't that just a cannon?
@@tyler1673 last time I checked a trebuchet work on *entirely* different mechanics than a cannon.
Joerg: I made an instant magazine fed ballista. Let me show you it's features.
*shoots shed to smithereens*
Joerg: hehehehehe.
@@nooblangpoo he goes..
Heheheehehe
Im a peacefull guy.
@@WilMenSher you can feel the kindness in his laugh yet he makes weapons that would have changed history if they ever existed when bows and crossbows were the only range weapon that was practical
Imagine a medieval world with Jörg and Shad working together; one building amazing next generation weapons and the other finding the best ways to tactically implement them.
Dear Lord that would be terrifying.
That sounds like a book idea
A good as well
Just what we needed... another isekai :P
There is actually an isekai where this happens, it's called:
KAGAKUTEKI NI SONZAI SHIURU CREATURE MUSUME NO KANSATSU NISSHI
It features spider girl monsters shooting 60 shot instant legolas weapons. I'm pretty sure the manga came out before Joerg came up with the idea so maybe he was inspired by the manga, vice versa or it's unrelated.
In chapter 3 one of the 2 people who transferred to that world starts designing massive magazine instant legolas. The manga is NSFW, it features a lot of sex and gore and afaik noone is translating it.
You can find the raws at: lhscan.net or loveheaven.net it's the same site and it has thousands of manga raws.
Jorg would do well.
It's so refreshing to see a man this happy.
Nothing brings any man joy quite like medieval weaponry.
It’s entertaining to see his reaction.
Men dont need Woman. They need a Warbow with Instand Legolas. Never seena man so happy on a wedding lol.
Dimera OI!
I was about to write about how happy he looks too!
An additional advantage is that you can attach it to an already made bow, as an upgrade, rather than make a whole new weapon.
The logistics of it is amazing.
During a campaign the army could restock bows from local bowyers and attach the system to that.
@@xifel72 Not only that, but I assume the design could be made and adapted to allow lesser-power bows to be used for training or in case you just don't have the same-power replacements for it.
And if it could be designed to be removed and it malfunctions, just take off the attachment and shoot the bow as normal. It's absurdly elegant for what it is.
@@BoisegangGaming Joerg has actually made a version for a mongolian horse bow, which was demonstrated by NuSensei, of course it was modified slightly, spefically in how far back it can go because Nu can't pull it as far back as Joerg can, but the fact that you could make different versions for different types of bows, especially smaller bows like horse bows, then the effects of a device like this in actual medieval times would have been astronomical
You should watch Todd's workshop's video on the instant Legolas ( ua-cam.com/video/H-1bkGPAkJU/v-deo.html ), he suggests that it would of been deployed differently than standard archers but would of been devastating . . . but it has it's flaws like any weapon.
You could give this device to unskilled defenders to free up your skilled defenders maybe place occupants on top your main castle and place your actual archers out on a separate fortification to layer your defense you could especially double the number of available archers.
I can hear Joerg'e laugh watching this, proudly.
I can hear Joerg's saying
"Let me show you its FEATURES"
Shad should have started this: "HAHAHA" *laughs in Joerg Sprave* "Welcome to the Shadiversity channel!"
It's haunting my dreams, it's still there while I sleep!
*Let me show you it's features! ha ha ha ha*
Thank you for the
Thank you.
"Jolly good!"
Random Welshman
when i read this, his voice runs in my mind...
Aww that would be a good nod to Jeorg if he actually said that xD
A longbowman approaches a French knight:
"What is thine wood block thou hast on thine bow?" questioned the knight
"I'm glad you asked, LET ME SHOW YOU IT'S FEATURES!"
You know Joerg is German right?
@@heckleypanes4988 it's a joke lad
@@heckleypanes4988 and where did he say that the longbowman wasn't?
@@Belvie lack of reading comprehension is spreading faster than the Rona.
@@johnmadden52 I DO LIKE THIS!.HOOPLEE DOO,Its a joke lads
Shad Fact: Shad frequently does bare handed fishing mostly looking to catch Blue Whales.
I wonder how often he uses this method to go after kraken.
I actually love his overexaggerated gesture. :-) But still like your joke.
This is why he is called The Prince of Whales
@@DragonGunzDorian ever wonder where theres no more Krakens ?
Timefliesbye GENIUS
Agincourt french knights: What are those vertical crossbows those english are using?
English longbow men: LET US SHOW YOU ITS FEATURES
Didn't the French have German mercenaries?
iirc, the mercenaries looked at the sunken road with low fences and said, "Nope, we are going home."
Long bows didn't penetrate their armor they had their horses shot out from under them
Well, I don't know anything about medieval trade routes and such, but Jörg is German, so if he'd live in the middle ages, he'd still be german. So this kind of bow would've probably spread with german mercenaries across Europe, and depending on when in medieval times Jörg would've lived, they were depending on german mercenaries as best/fastest/whatever archers at the time, or it was already common knowledge and both sides would have them.
*HAHAHAHA!*
_A mountain pile of dead french knights later._
*HAHAHAHA!*
@@Kealen69 While an arrow may not penetrate the actual metal plates I bet it aint fun getting hit anywhere by an arrow shot from a longbow.
Not to mention that every armor has weakspots, namely gaps with no metal plate coverin the body and an arrow can definitely do some damage there.
Something like an arrow through the eyeslit or into the armpit is going to be especially nasty if not outright lethal.
Imagine a fantasy story, wearing the trappings of generic fantasy, but including all the changes outlined in Shad's "Fantasy Re-Armed" series. You have orcs essentially dominating the planet due to their insane archers until some inspired Dwarf (optionally named Joerg) creates the instant Legolas, allowing Non-Orcs to use War Bows on par with those of the Orcs and turning the tide of the war.
But then Orcs adopt it too and can shoot EVEN BIGGER bows.
And the elves get jealous. Pouting saying," That's cheating." Elves stomp their feet.
@@andrewvisionzero lmfao
@@viorp5267
Do orcs feel smart about reverse engineering? I do not believe it...
@@andrewvisionzero are his orcs also so large they would have trouble seeing the small parts to do the reverse engineering? Also I feel like throwing trees would be a better tactic for orcs if their as big as I think they are
Shad you’ve ruined me, I can’t watch anything with choreographed sword fights without saying: “oh that was telegraphed!” “Where’s your stance?” “Ah mate your leaving yourself wide open there what are you doing?” And I’m American so I don’t even say mate!
But now you do say Mate when you watch sword fights haha. The same thing happened to me last night I was watching that Netflix show called letter to the king the few fight scenes I was like "Nice form." "That's nothing but spin to win Crap" I was LUAGHING at myself for nit picking it haha
AMBUKNIGHT hey, nit picking in films like that is fun occasionally. So long as you don't get brutal about it. They do spend alot of money and time on said films afterall.
@@mr_h831 very true
I know what a telegraph is now. Now I'm nitpicking weapon battles.
To be fair, telegraphing in a staged fight is intentional. It makes the fight easier to follow and understand for a casual audience member and the larger movements are more dramatic. Just don't interpret them as a video lesson on swordplay, but rather a performance.
Joerg: The next instance of the Instant Legolas has a 100% unbreakable handle.
Let me show you it's features!
There should be a "HA HA HA HA HA" in there somewhere.
There is already a metal version of it, Jörg found a manufacturer.
This is an unbreakable handle, let me show you its features XD
*proceeds to weld it with a car door*
I believe that the mongols and their mounted archers would love this, one of the hardest things about shooting on horse is trying to reload, so just coming in, shoot a couple arrows in 10 seconds and them come back to cover i think would be very effective.
And archery in general would take advantage of something like this, is such an effective improvement
Did you see the instant Genghis Khan?
@@dragovern I think i saw the recommendation but i haven't watched it yet
While you're completely right, they would love this, it would probably not work on a large scale historically because they don't have enough wood in their country. Traditionally, they used bamboo and animal parts like sinew. I don't mean to be that guy, nothing you said was wrong, just thought it was an interesting insight.
@@ryanfakename251 but when the mongols conquered Siberia there was enough wood right?
@@aleks-hc8cy that's fair yeah
Detachable handle: throw when out of arrows to end them rightly.
Needs to be a pommel for mass destruction.
Joerg once made a sword that shoots its pommel when necessary, super fancy but not very reliable, shot himself on the rib accidentally 😂
@@ancapeancape9829 fucking ballistic knives. XD
or... make more arrows.
@@SilvrSavior Put a pommel on the end, done.
You wouldn't need to outfit every archer. A King's Chosen unit of 100, firing 5 arrows in each salvo every 10 seconds. On the ground, by their feet, a bundle of arrows for reload. Only half of the archers fire at any time. The other half are reloading. On each reload, an archer takes a knee, supporting the bow in a horizontal position, reloads from the bundle at their side. As the first half of archers finish firing, the second set takes position and fires.
This is the equivalent of 50 archers, firing 5 arrows every 10 seconds, or 100 archers firing 5 arrows every 20: 100 archers X 5 arrows X 3 complete cycles/min means a unit of 100 archers can place down 1500 arrows each minute.
This small unit, supported by units of conventional bows and crossbows, would be devastating.
Damn!
Madan no Ou to Vanadis (Lord Marksman and the Vanadis) explains this strategy well... why send an army when you can have the best marksmen (skilled enough to aim at gaps in their enemies armor at 100 alsins) rebels, and have the other archers serve as holsters for their arrows. And you can keep off an overconfident general who thinks he'll be squashing a rebellion like ants
yup, even 20 archers swapping chops... 300 arrows a minute....
good luck trying to move against THAT, even if only half the arrows hit their mark, you've lost 150 men in 60 seconds, 750 in 5 minutes, ouch!
Jeorg was releasing 5 in 6.5 to 7 seconds, if one person were loading the clips to feed 2 archers each, rate might even hit 400-450 per minute.
@@modelnutty6503 so basically a lot of soldiers not getting near the objective at all. A lot of wasted time. While not even killing, or even finding a single Archer. Because of all that armor that they are wearing
@@Quadrolithium wait, which volume?
I love shad and joerg's content. Both very smart individuals who are greatly inspirational to me. One wrote a book and knows so much about medieval history & weapons and the other one is a phenomenal engineer who know a lot about weaponry. Screw the haters!
I love how excited they are about everything.
Neighbor hears Shad yelling and laughing: *looks over fence*
Shad: *dancing with glee and excitement with weird contraption in hand*
Neighbor: *lowers down from fenche*
"I swear, I live in a live action anime..." goes by his head while he backs up to his door.
Backs away slowly
Fenche
You forgot: In front of his giant fake castle.
And pulls pistol out just in case
The second half sounds like a medieval infomercial. "Send a rider now and get a free back-scabbard for only half a farmstead and ten peasants". Love your videos mate.
BUT WAIT! Order in the next five minutes and we’ll throw in a free damsel! ALL FOR ONLY $19.99!
@@xskyhawkx7821 "For 19 pounds, 19 shillings, 11 pence, and 3 farthings!"
I cut this boat in half!
Order now at your local church! To be delivered in three days by our couriers that, JUST KNOW WHERE YOU ARE
@@nasserfirelordarts6574 "I've been lookin' for you. Got somethin' I'm supposed to deliver. Your hands only. Let's see here..."
I would really watch an anime if its called “ That time that I was reincarnated with my Instant Legolas ” .
I would hope more for a "That time that I was reincarnated with my engineer's degree"
@@Wreckur4203 that kind of exists. can't remember what it's called but a guy takes the place of a great general by using his experience with explosives, engineering and shity bosses. it's pretty good, and there are tits in it
@Emilio Sánchez Shinju no Nectar
@@Rassalcon I thought you were going with "Release that witch." Similar concept, currently just a manga (Manwha? Chinese equiv, whatever it's called). I'd recommend it.
Actually there is a very nice light novel the manga is based on, you should check it out.
Shad's doctor - "So, how's the post-surgery recovery going?" Shad - "Oh, great did some speed shooting with a 100 pound war bow yesterday." Doctor "....high five?"
I'm wondering how this "Instant Legolas" would interact with Shad's custom back scabbard in an actual battlefield.
An army with those two feels pretty overpowered in a medieval context.
*Shad and Jörg approching a Dragon*
Dragon: You foolish mortals!
*Jörg pulls out 2 Instant Legolas*
Jörg: Let me show you it's features!
Dragon: Ahh sh***
Joerg: LET ME SHOW YOU ITS FEATURES!! HAA HAA HAA HAA HAA!!
Why would back scabbards help armies?
@@VoltCruelerz Shad made a comment in the video about how he had to take off his sword because it was getting in the way of him shooting. His back scabbard would have fixed that.
I Can Do This All Day most archers likely didn’t carry a full sword, probs a dagger at most, a sword require a lot of steel, and most infantry at the time use spears to lower both cost while retaining effectiveness in mass, so for a army that can’t afford to give everyone a sword, what makes you think that archers would be armored with such? Sure individual archers may be able to afford a sword, but not everyone, I also do not think that a sword would even prove the be much of a hinderance to shooting a bow what-so ever, like the sword is literally attached to what is effectively a belt with a scabbard, so a archer could literally just wear the belt that’s rotated towards the back a bit more instead of directly being at the side of the shooter and this would literally get the sword completely out of the way along with making it still faster to draw, and at the very least faster then reaching all the way to the back
I mean, even ignoring accuracy, imagine several ranks of archers just doing volleys with these into enemy ranks vs several ranks without.
Ferrinflame it’d be like pitting semi-auto rifles against matchlock rifles
@@devonlord99 Archers: This feels like sealclubbing.
i mean volume of fire and this thing assists you in being more accurate it would be a one sided fight
or big scorpion like that :D
Gonna give the dwarves this ...
Rowan Llew yoerg is basically a modern day artificer
Dwarves are probably better off with crossbows still, draw length is going to be an issue for them
I thought the dwarfs problem was keeping up on long runs.
the dwarves don't need bows; they have balistas (also that would be wonderful to see)
@@jameslewis2635 no no no, long good, fast no good (never mind I got it flipped around)
I'm surprised something like this hasn't been done much in medieval stories fantasy or otherwise. One would think in a fantasy a dwarf easily make a rapid fire bow or a fully automatic crossbow, as far as I know the only instances are Van Helsing and Hansel and Gretel Witch Hunters.
It was done in a movie in the early 1980's. Ladyhawk? Dusty memory
There's a fairly mediocre trilogy that has dragon riders using essentially pump-action crossbows. Can't remember the name of it, but it was very 'birth of flight in combat' kind of thing, very clearly drawing from WW1 and WW2.
Maybe such automation is only retroactively applied from modern advancements, so our medieval ancestors might have never even imagined such a thing.
@@spyrofrost9158 Leonardo probably did?
@@spyrofrost9158 I think a big part of it is, simply, ancient armies rarely cared too much about optimizing the effectiveness of a single soldier. Sure, there's a good reason to do so, but throwing more people at the problem has been a reliable battle strategy for centuries, weighed against the cost of training elites.
For fantasy, though... a typical 'few in number, but old and powerful' race would definitely care about something like that.
Me - "I wonder what Shad's been up to recently?"
Shad - *Loads hand-held repeating ballista*
Me - O.o . . .
Castle background looks sooo sick! Congrats on the movie Shad!
Movie?
@@Thomas-cs8uj A studio is looking to make a Shadow of the Conqueror short film.
@@sugondese5497 whaaaaa?!
yay!
JUST TAKE MY MONEY!!!!! I WILL BUY 20 DVDS RIGHT NOW!
@@sugondese5497 yes please, it was a great read and i'd love to see it animated/performed
Naming the manequin Boromir... its funny, but I can't help being a bit offended.
I had the same reaction (would Bormir have been lung-shot in the movies)
Lament of Boromir covered by Karliene played in my head when he mentioned the name of the mannequin.
At least he hasn't beheaded a dummy and named it Ned.
Or has he?
"Who I've affectionately named Boromir"
You monster.
"I raise my slingshot for battle! For the Lord!"
- *Jeorg Sprave's Medieval great-great-granddad, probably.*
LET ME SHOW YOU ITS FEATURES!!!
HA HA HA
“LET ME SHOW YOU IT’S...wait a minute, DUES VULT INFIDEL!... FEATURES!”
if we're talking medieval, you're gonna have to add a lot more 'greats'
"DEUS VULT" also his great, great, gran dad
Shad: (misses at 40ft constantly) I'll be a little better at it in the next video
Shad in the next video: (starts hitting moving targets from horseback at 200ft) I'm not quite there yet.
Shad in the video after horseback archery: lives in a yurt, greets us with throat-singing
I love watching his evolution with the war bow. I remember him barely being able to draw that bow. Now it's his 'ho-hum' everyday. That's so inspirational that I've actually gotten back into archery myself.
me, playing a ranger: I want one
Party: ...but crossbow
me: but *this video*
party: ...fair
I'm already thinking of an NPC smith based on Joerg. Should be fun!
this is a crossbow, though. Very efficient one, but still crossbow. The moment you use a gadget to shoot instead of your raw power it becomes crossbow.
@@dimas3829 Its not a crossbow. A crossbow is defined as being able to lock at full draw which this cannot. The draw assist is simply that, it assists in drawing the bow. The reason your definition does not work is because there are some crossbows that can be drawn by hand without a device.
I already started thinking up an item too. I was thinking, two shots per attack action, but a full bonus action to reload
@@dimas3829 also it's like a mod for your already existing bow
Shad: "Alright, so lets do this."
Joerg: "LET ME SHOW YOU ITS *F E A T U R E S* !"
It’s interesting, that power stroke concept is also applicable to firearms, the longer your barrel the higher your muzzle velocity, the same nine millimeter out of a pistol will be slower than if it was shot out of an smg.
You're right, just a small correction. The barrel of an SMG is usually longer than that of a pistol. Unless you're talking the magnum out of Resident Evil. The real question is, how do you make the recoil more efficient in terms of loading the next round and reducing the force on the end user. ... is the end user the person shooting or getting shot? The real real question, who is technically the end user of a firearm?? Ok back to my drinkypoos.
@@kik1rik1 I think you read his comment wrong. He did have a circumvent way of expressing it though.
@@ethanv7330 I think I was drunk.
The sheer ingenuity of this bow attachment is nuts!
Watching your reactions was like 10 years of Christmas presents strapped to a warbow!
People: The longsword is Shad's favourite weapon.
Shad: Hold my longbow.
Arming sword, not longsword...
@Brendan Robertson I may be wrong but I’d say that he likes longswords better since that’s the kind he usually has on him.
"It's joust yer opinion sire!"
Bilbo Skywalker, Esquire
uh... that's... hold my 100-pound war bow.
The part I like most about this design is consistency.
You can't physically overdraw the bow, neither can you under draw it. This makes it easy to predict the trajectory of an arrow, and thus easier to hit things.
Can't wait for Joergsprave to make an Instant Pommel Throwing Machine
I can't wait for him to _show us its features._
He made a sword with inbuilt pommel launcher
ua-cam.com/video/ITuZz9g_K3g/v-deo.html
He did it already.
Pommel Throwing Minigun
You can really see that he is planning to take over Australia. First castles and now auto fire bows.
No, it's still just a single action bow
Yeah, those auto fire bows are really something.
He is preparing for Emu War 2.
@@aneasteregg8171 Imagine riding on an emu while shooting with this thing.
@@amonvandenbruaene8395 'Streylia!! FUCK YEAH!
COMIN' HERE TO KILL SOME MOTHERFUCKING ROOS YEAH!!
16:15 I think it is important to note as well, that in massive battles it was about how many arrows could be launched into a an oncoming army, or stationary army. So rate of fire was more preferred than actual pin-point accuracy during the time.
Lord Penguin
Sure just like AA guns during WW2 at long ranges they would just fire into an area rather than trying to hit a specific target.
“...if someone like Joerg excisted in medieval times.”? Well they did, but they catapulted mankind straight into the renaissance....or were trialed and burned for their wizardry. ;)
You mean Divinci?
@@scottbruckner4653 he was not early renaissance btw, and most of his ideas never actually got made
but the people who designed balistas, heavier crossbows, catapults and trebuchets, all manner of utility pully systems and many many many more
you have to remember that joerge is working with centuries of existing tech to get ideas from and imrpove upon
rapid fire crossbows have been made in the past, but someone had to first come up with the idea for the mechanism, and someone had to first come up with all the component parts first as well
Exactly which inventor was burned at the stake?
I know the man who invented the bronze bull was killed with his own invention, but who else?
@@supremecaffeine2633 Galilei almost was, like Copernicus and Kepler
@Anna Mozatee I don't think it's that extreme. The Reform had already happened so there were safe places for people who didn't conform completely to the church's orders
The failure under stress reminds me of software testing: Pretty cool system, not quite production-ready yet, but with a bit more engineering and polish it'll be awesome!
Also the fact that the test-user decides to abuse the system :P
Considering that the instant legolas seems to be made almost entirely out of wood replacing some parts with iron or even steel would probably fix a lot of said issues (for example a metal handle stop would probably be much more durable)
The ones made out of aircraft grade aluminum for compound bows are/were available on Joerg's website.
I am not sure he abused it, but I am sure some recruit some time would, whether on purpose or not. It is the nature of the beast when training.
Aberdeen Testing Grounds does the same thing: they take two prototypes and use/abuse the weapons until they break.
Probably one of the SANER contraptions by Joerg.
Remember his air-powered javelin? Shivers...
Or his fullauto crossbow, or machetelauncher, or tomahawkcatapult, or airzooka.
@@mennograafmans1595 He's making the German government sweat nervously ever time he comes out of his workshop with something in hand laughing
The Air Powered WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT
@@billwilson7841 He made an airgun that could shoot through a riotshield. And one the size of a bazooka.
@@billwilson7841 Really? You dunno about his 1100 J airgun?
I am seriously considering putting this in my RPG.
This looks so amazing! I'd love to see this implemented into fantasy stories.
Same thing for a story I'm doing.
Pug Dungeon go for it. Every person who tested it can verify that it could be built with medieval tech and skills
putting this ON my RPG...
Oh yeah imagine a rapid fire RPG-7 rocket launcher, that would be something...
In Dungeons&Dragons terms: this turns a longbow from martial weapon to a simple weapon.
I told my players the only way they were going to get one is if the enemy had them first and they captured one. So far they do not seem to keen to be on the wrong end of group of Instant Legolas Archers.
@@shawnr771 well, it does not need to be overpowered.
As I said, treat it as a crossbow for proficiency use. And if you go by 5e rules you can say that who has proficiency in longbows can make an attack as a Bonus action after taking an Attack action with the bow. Also if not magical, it is likely to jam, as in the video. Any time you roll natural 1 you need to spend an Action to clear the misfire.
But the rulebook puts it in exotic weapons category, because f-you having fun.
Yes, I'm taking example on the 1h mini-crossbow that is, for some retarded rule-based reason, an exotic weapon and so if you want to shoot 1 poor d6 at the start of combat, more for cool-factor than anything else, you have to take a feat (while the weapon already costs 100gp to begin with).
At least in Pathfinder 2e they rectified a lot of this nonsense and the hand-crossbow is now a simple weapon (and most weapons now have reasonable cost, making gold actually valuable even if I'll argue 20gp for a longbow is still too much, but at least it's not 80 anymore and the 1h crossbow is like 1/10th or 1/20th of its previous price, because nobody ever was using that weapon in Pathfinder 1e like many other weapons and exotic weapons that would be "fun" to use for shit and giggles at low level but are never worth taking a feat).
I'm rambling, sorry...
and make it strength based
@@Zigg33 to be honnest any bow should be strenght based, the only reason it's a dex weapon is because you have to put some weapons for dex characters (the the composite longbow is a strenght/dex weapon and is strictly better).
I completely share shads enthusiasm for this beautiful device. A war bow is such an amazingly powerful thing. This sil development is just helping tame this 100lp beast.
So glad to see you killing it with the outside videos. Your energy levels seem so much better than a year or two ago.
I love it, but you need to remember...
THAT STILL ONLY COUNTS AS ONE!
LOTR reference lol
Don’t tell anyone about this! 😆
@@Habu12 They have a cave troll.
Guess what I'll be watching this evening and tomorrow? ;-)
That iz all gut, but where is ze feuerwerfer, Hans?!?!
*you shall not pass!!!*
This patent is so damn valuable in the hunting industry. I know something similar has been applied to crossbows, but not every jurisdiction allows crossbow hunting or categorizes it the same as regular bows.
*In an alternate universe, where a medieval inventor invented this design instead*
The French: Why do I hear boss music?
It actually quite possible that someone did, but then jump to developing crossbows.
To be fair, the Medieval Warbow tended to be significantly heavier in draw and had no moving parts. Ease of maintenance is your friend on a long campaign, which is actually one of the reasons bows were more often employed than crossbows in the post-classical early-and-middle Medieval period of Europe. Another reason is this: The English were so fond of the Longbow because of a certain lordly ordinance making it mandatory for every peasant to practice with the damn thing for hours every day. They had freakishly superpowered shoulders because of continuous training with progressively heavier bows.
Also, the Chinese and Koreans invented their own version of this, as has often been remarked by others, in the form of the Repeater Crossbow, which to be frank it basically is already. The Repeating Crossbow is a very interesting device, but it can't put forth the raw power of a Heavy Crossbow with their potentially ludicrous 500-800lb draw that goes all the way through a charging lancer and out the other side. Excellent for attacking peasants, though, but far less effective against infantry in padded armor, and the ammo is an issue, but it's always an issue.
Still, for what it is, that being 'a way to fire a large amount of arrows at a middling draw weight very very quickly', it's good! I just prefer the Crossbow as far as bows go.
@@AlphaNumericKey Exactly! Thanks for detailed answer. I would add only that in my opinion repeater bow is actually better then repeater crossbow what has huge accuracy issue due to way how firing mechanic work. When this devise operate mostly as normal bow with improved loading mechanic, what also can be easily dismantled if it stuck or something. As you said general reason why devices like that weren't developed was that warbows can have sizable drawing powers, what could easily break such device and working in archer company make fire rate far lesser issue. When if used for town guards they usually don't need sizable fire rate anyway (repeater crossbows were usually utilized against riots anyway). When Europeans start developing more advances types of devices like crossbow, it is actually also when firearm gradually become a thing, as both research were historically interconnected. It is generally why devices like such in debate, never become popular.
Oh no, don't let Lindybeige get his hands on this...
@@AlphaNumericKey So the repeating crossbow was most effective against the Chinese and their neighbours?
for a second at the intro i thought you are standing in front of a green screen . i totally forgot you built a castle :D
I love it when creators work together like this. Good work Shad and Joerg. :)
Even without precision accuracy, that would be a terror weapon to face.
P.S. Should we get Jorg working on a rapid fire trebuchet?
In his campaign to get plywood banned in Germany, Joerg has probably made a fully functional wooden panzer howitzer already... powered with a drill.
I think that a trebuchet would bea different beast entirely, and logistics would help fire rate as much if not more than a mechanical advantage.
I think the Narnia movies have a sort of rapid-fire trebuchet... Basically a large wooden arm with cups on either end that continuously picks up stones and launches them. I don't recall how the arm is powdered considering there is no counterweight, but it certainly looked cool!
I’ve played games with trebuchets firing as fast as shad plus it would be the precursor of torpedo/mortar loading train 3-4 men how to fire and you could completely decimate a castle wall or it’s towers plus launching a bunch of attacks from it would basically be akin to bomber run before the infantry picked off stragglers while storming the line
Thought that those were already invented on a smaller(non castle breaking levels anyways) scale?
7:00 Here we see Shad geeking out and giddy like kid on Christmas day. He's so happy.... and then got troubling madness of power. He will avenge honor against the Emus.
@11:10 That slow-mo is awesome! you can see how it takes most of your body to hold the power, your clothes show the reverberations!
"Perhaps the true ultimate longbow was the sword-like weapon we made along the way..."
Bilbo Skywalker
“This would not have made sense in The Last Jedi” - Bilmond Bagel
Lindybeige: video on spear and shield
Skallagrim: video on longsword
Shadiversity: video on bows
Can this day become even better?
Let me show you its features
Honest question, if Jorg was born in a different time, could he have changed the course of history? I guess it depends on whether this idea would still come to him if all he had was medieval technology to inspire him. It's possible?
Yeah the idea of a magazine for example, it might be hard without the inspiration.
The answer to that will never be known for certain. Frankly the grimm reality is that Jorg could have been born at a different time and simple just died to disease or never would have had the time to bring that invention about. But if he WOULD have brought the invention out chances are it would have redrawn the map.The instant legolas is a massive game changer as they are a lot more simple then a crossbow from the core concept while still allowing for nearly all of the advantages of the bow. You could mass produce them and supply your army with them. And as seen it still functions like a regular bow allowing the user the train the core muscles for archery. So basically you raise a military of elite archers on massive scale and if there is one thing that has been proven in history then its that any troop of elite archers was a pain to deal with and spoken about with fear.
I believe I will try to incorporate the Instant Legolas into my medieval fantasy setting at some point. I love your channel. It inspires so much of my writing project!
Jesse O'Leary, you'd love Joerg Sparve's channel ^^
To keep it realistic, make sure the device still carries weight to be transported, and don't increase the number of arrows.
Lord shad must be the envy of the neighbourhood. Hes only got his own castle.
hitlersmissingnut nobody dares try to take it
@@kowonski7729 I still think he should name his castle shadsylvania.
The envy of landlords lol
it´s where he hides his dragon
it's only a model.
I’ve been waiting for this video for a month!!! I watched Joerg test this before he sent it to you when he received your bow. He’s a total genius of engineering
Medieval fiction writters about this: *It's free real estate*.
That could be the medieval equivalent of a weapon of mass destruction haha
Not quite a WMD, but enough to give an edge. Imagine a three ranks deep shooting line atop a battlement with these and the sheer amount of loosed arrows... Fighting in the shade indeed.
@@Lakhshamana That's the only scenario the Chinese found. To make up for the fewer arrows and the higher rate of fire the only use was in defensive roles such as repelling an attack during a storming of fortifications.
nah, that would be catapulting dead carcasses/rotting bodies of humans and animals over enemy walls to spread disease.. Thats weapon of mass destruction and even biological kind. Trowing clay shells full of oil and lit from outside could also be classified as ancient napalm and i guess weapon of mass destruction chemical warfare kind.
You forgot to mention one of the other advantages of a crossbow, namely that it can rest while loaded. So that a person using it could be sitting and waiting for the opportunity to shoot it whereas a traditional bow cannot rest while drawn. It seems that this device also has that advantage though.
Technically, you still have hold it, so it isn't locked and cocked mechanism like a crossbow, but apparently, the effort to hold it there is not particularly strenuous.
@@J24-k8f Joerge put a ratchet lock on an earlier prototype which would hold the SIL in the drawn position, but decided to not to pursue the idea because it legally made it a crossbow, which are typically subject to more stringent regulation then bows.
@@mattbowden4996 it's still a crossbow, though.
@@dimas3829 But not enough like a crossbow so that the law enforcement cares
Well put
That handle is just GLORIOUS on its own. The power for an archer to be able to hold in waiting with little to no effort instead of full arm pressure is legendary. Basically it introduces SNIPERS into the archery world, i mean the cross bow does too, but they where not normally as large as a long bow, so they where more for shorter range. These can be ready to fire, waiting long periods of time, a good distance away, until the enemy is in range. THEN YOU EVEN HAVE MULTIPLE SHOTS! OMG this weapon would have DEVASTATED apposing armies. Just SHOWERED their enemies with arrows.
Boromir can never catch a break with arrows, can he? That meme will live on forever.
Shad: *Gets isekai'd.*
Also Shad: *Takes over all of Europe.*
Additionally Shad: Dies of Dysentery.
@@fell5514Right. Most people didn't die of battles, but of diseases. Overall, you'd honestly do better in an isekai as a doctor and nutritionist.
@@stormveil I'm a little surprised that isn't an Isekai already...
@@stormveil But then they'd drown you for being a witch.
@@nuclearattackwombat8390I agree. That does sound like a nice idea as well as a educational one. Whoever loved Dr. Stone because of the science would love that show.
If the double bowed pendulum version that Joerg came up with had been invented historically I could see it completely out competing and obsoleting the crossbow. A total game changer.
Thanks for the Campfire sponsor, I was looking to get into finally writing a story based on one of the many ideas I've written down and Campfire looks absolutely fantastic and essential in keeping lots of information readily accessible.
Aussie and German customs must have been REALLY intrigued by the content of the packages.
Raz0rking “There is reason to believe that a German mad scientist and an Australian snake hunter are planning to take over the world; the latter has already built a castle and is practicing marksmanship, the former is providing him with weapons of unprecedented power.”
Isn't he a Kiwi?
@@ifonlyicouldstop No, he's a person.
A stick, a string, a long box and a thin rubber. Meh
Aussie customs are such arseholes too. The amount of stuff I’ve had seized over the years makes me teary.
Shad looks like a kid on Christmas day
Also is anyone getting a pump-action shotgun vibe from this
that's the next iteration: shotgun magazine. It could actually work. I don't know the exact numbers obviously, but a lot of the shooting energy is dissipated within the bow itself, so multiple bolts should in sum deliver a higher amount of energy than a single one. At that point you're basically carpet bombing the battlefield.
only if multi arrow
@@majorfallacy5926 would depend actually. Joreg has done a scatter bow design. The issue is if a single string is pushing 2 bolts at once, you either need to half the weight of the arrow and risk damaging the arrow and string or just accept that each arrow's power is reduced by half. So less powerful then normal
@@sebastianriz4703 if the majority of the bows energy is lost after the shot via dissipation, then double the mass would mean more energy goes into the arrows and less that's turned into heat after the shot. Each arrow would still be less powerful, we just don't know how much
Now let me show you its features
When I saw the thumbnail I thought "Is he trying to shoot a crossbow from a Longbow?"
Jörg did something like this, an arrow that shoots 2 bolts upon impact.
@@chemieju6305 He did?
Mkay, I'm gonna have to try and find that video.
@@chemieju6305 and made nasty wound
Shad, while practicing don't forget to switch "offhand drawing" to develop both shoulders.
Next time:
Instant legolas: SHIELD SURFING!!!!!
Just thought of this, I would HIGHLY suggest a face mask with the draw assist elastic bands (rubber?). When one of those breaks from stress over time depending on where and how it breaks there is a fifty fifty chance the place it broke is going to send one of those bands rocketing at your face. I'm sure its durable strong right now being brand new, but only time will tell how well it can handle this task, and I'd rather you not lose an eye, even if you could wear an eye patch like a pirate. Thanks for all the awesome content Shad!
Shad, your excitement at around the 7-8 minute mark is incredible! I love Joerg's SIL project, and seeing that reaction alone makes me think that his excitement about it (and mine) has not been misplaced!
Medieval bowmen: Collective facepalm. "Why didn't we think of that?"
In their defense, there was a lot of the raiding and pillaging and serf stuff going on.
To be fair, it's not something that anyone could come up. It's a complicated system that only someone with lots of resources, time, and talent (like Joerg) would be able to develop.
@@Zorro9129 Yeah, I'm sure. People in the past weren't stupid, after all. Still, they did have some free time, so it's still a conceivable invention that could have been made. Just understandable why it wasn't.
Maddog3060 they a busy dying
@@Maddog3060 Id say DaVinci but it almost seems too simple to be of his design
It's almost a repeating crossbow, isn't it? My guess is that buyers would either want bows or crossbows for their armouries, so there wouldn't have been much demand for an attachment that turns a bow into a sort-of-crossbow unless someone found some trained bowmen who were willing an able to demonstrate the superior shooting rate. Because nobody brings weapons like this into battle in modern times, there's also more room for experimentation with them.
Never underestimate the brilliance of German engineering! Joerg is a mad man, I love it.
Someone: germans suck at engineering
Joerg: *makes pump action long bow* YOU UTTER FOOL GERMAN ENGINEERING IS THE FINEST IN THE WORLD
@@thorodinson292 Laughs in ultimate life form
Joerg has had some cool ideas but this one takes the cake! This would've changed history dramatically! And the improvements on it would come rolling in quickly. More arrows in a clip, detachable magazines etc.
I got a notification of Shad testing the SIL, while watching a video.
I still clicked immediately, since I've been waiting for this episode for more than a month.
Also, insta-liked for the same reason.
Just imagine all the brilliant inventions that never got implemented and got lost in time.
It's great to see a collab between you two. I loved your geek out when you first test the draw.
Great video, as always. Thanks, Shadman.
Oh god, don't call him shadman.
*rule34flashbacks*
NO DON'T CALL HIM THAT
After googling the term, I am now very deeply sorry, Shad, for calling you that. I hope you forgive me. It won't happen again. But since you reacted to my comment, I can't possible delete it now.
@@Tuclix I honestly thought you were making a joke
Somehow I love seeing that even a big guy like Shad is having problems drawing the war bow (even with the assist)
One of the best ways to show how much strenght is requiered to use it.
When Joerg shoots this bow in his video, the hitting sounds like a little explosion!
@@ancapeancape9829 well, Joerg is in a class of his own
It also helps having a one foot thick arms.
like a kid on Christmas... this is the most excited I have ever seen you, it looks like you are having a hell of a great day here. and yeah, I can see how this would be a game changer for castle defense or even as a battery of archers shooting over the heads of an army. in castle defense, you would most likely have 2 bows per archer, and someone behind them reloading ( this was actually done with muzzle loaders in early America when settlers were defending a fort) by integrating a metal handle, and greased metal slide, you would get an even smoother, more efficient opperation
Did you, Skallagrim, and Lindybiege all plan to post on the same day? Not that I’m complaining of course
If only that alignment had the power to erase corona
The Barbarian, the Wizard, and the Fighter have impeccable timing.
It also doesn't need to be said that Joerg is totally an Artificer.
Tahu Nuva, who is the barbarian and wizard?
@@ourtube1128 Barbarian = Skall, Wizard = Lindybeige. At least, that's the impression I get from the few vids I've seen of theirs.
"rapid-fire attachment"
DOOM guy wants to know your location
**rapid fire ballista intensifies**
I think Medieval Doom is an untapped source for a great game. Demons arrive in a medieval land, and the Doom Knight has to kill them all with swords and bows and crossbows. At the highest level, you're getting into rapid-fire bows like this, or metal tubes that spray Greek Fire.
@@Bluecho4 You want the game "Hexen".
@@AzureIV I was about to type about Hexen before finishing that comment and saw you beat me to it by 17 hours. I just bought the game again myself.
I think it's beautiful that such a innovative piece of engineering came out in the 21st century. Rapid fire warbows could have been devastating weapons of war, but it was invented in an age of assault rifles and nuclear weapons. Now this bit of a designer's imagination will only ever be a fun novelty for the range or maybe hunting.
You lucky bastard Shad! I think most of us are envious you got to play with Joerg's toys
I just discovered Joerg a couple weeks ago and now you're collabing. Awesome.
Hey Shad as someone who plays way to many video games where various guns with varying purposes are needed. I could really see this kind of thing as a medieval suppression weapon. You would just need a couple of these things spread out on walls with barrels and barrels of arrows. They could serve as a fearmonger unit keeping the invading forces heads down or even cause them to retreat. In mass as the invading army you could get the wall defenders to keep their heads down as your infantry push. Effectively I see this as a medieval autobowman type of role being created. Having some of these guys with these keeping the other forces heads down with more accurate bowman taking precise kill shots could have been a good tactic. Comparing it to an autorifleman and a sniper for modern terms. You have someone with a belt fed weapon keeping heads more or less down while the sniper gets anyone trying to find them.
Another great thing with filming your testing, is it will help Jeorg pinpoint failure points and engineer reinforcements.
Good science and engineering demand good tests and data,. Good on you for sharing your efforts. 👍
Ps, Sharing in your joy is also wonderful. Stay awesome! 😊