You Shouldn’t Time The Market (Here’s Why)| Joseph Carlson Ep. 251
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 вер 2024
- Sign up for FTX Mobile: link.blockfoli...
📈 Qualtrim Insights: / josephcarlson
💵 Dividend Portfolio: m1finance.8bxp...
🚀 Growth Portfolio: m1finance.8bxp...
Revenue Charts: qualtrim.com/
In this episode, we discuss all the different ways investors try to time the stock market and the downfalls of doing so.
Join the Patreon and get access to a discord community with over 2,000 active members. Exclusive episodes, qualtrim (dividend tracking app and website), notifications of buys/sells, and much more: / josephcarlson
Joseph Carlson After Hours: / @josephcarlsonafterhours
M1 Finance (broker used in video): m1finance.8bxp...
Instagram: / joecarlsonshow
Twitter: / joecarlsonshow
Have a question for me?
Email me: joseph@josephcarlsonshow.com
(I won't share your name if I use your question on the show)
This show is for entertainment purposes only and not to be considered financial advice. Some of the links above are affiliate links that help financially support the channel at no cost to you.
FTX Mobile: link.blockfolio.com/9dzp/iyvwqrcp
FTX Desktop: ftx.us/home/#a=carlson
Use referral code "carlson" to get $10 after $100 deposit. Also, if you haven't already, check give the Patreon a try, it's $10/month and comes with a free trial: www.patreon.com/josephcarlson
You gain access to qualtrim.com which just had a major update, it's received very good feedback so far. Try it out risk free.
does ftx work with CAD?
Just an FYI - according to customer support you have to make a $100+ transaction to claim the $10 bonus, not just make a deposit. Since the stock trading option wasn't available to me yet I transacted $100.02 in $BTC (which immediately dropped in value, naturally!) to claim the $10 bonus. Waiting for $BTC to edge up a bit so I can unload it and wait for the stock trading to open up.
Don't fight the market. Take what the market gives you. If there's volatility, use it to your advantage. A down day tomorrow is a good opportunity for long term investors to buy quality stocks and ETFs cheap.
Picking quality stocks require a lot of factors and seems daunting for beginners like myself. I would say the ideal thing to do is investing weekly into my Total Market Index Fund.
From my own point of view, you need to invest smartly if you need a good life, made over 600k investing with an advisor in my corner and I believe anyone can do it if you have the the right approach. Index funds takes long time but investing smartly is the key for short term.
@@ryandennis4792 how are you investing? I have around $140k, only index funds, half in s&p and half in vigax. What do you think I should try?
I would advice you to reach out to my advisor. Her name is Camille Anne Hector. She's quite known and has got a website. So, you can check her out online and subsequently contact her from there.
This way you can get strategies designed to address your unique goals and financial dreams.
Trying to time the stock market is like trying to understand women. You may at some point think you have somewhat mastered it, before it whacks you across the head.
"Don't try to understand women. Women understand women and they hate each other" - Al Bundy
✊🏿🙌🏽
@@homersimpleton3044 is he by any means related to Ted Bundy? His quote would make a lot of sense if he is.
Joseph. This video gives value to a lot of people. Easy explained and high quality. Thank you!
Is Ashlee Action single by chance?
5:18 that “slight decrease” in dividends paid is actually -20%,sure, less than price drops but still significant
This episode is a must-watch for investors - good market-timing is close to impossible for retail investors and why DCA or investing once the money becomes available is the wisest approach.
Why do you accept the research on market timing but not on efficient market theory?
would you buy tesla if it payed a dividen fx yield of 4% payout ratio 20%?
I like to just dollar cost average into the stocks that I think are the best value to buy. Dividend Investors should be more excited when a stock drops, cause then they are getting a higher dividend yield on cost!
Depends on the strength of the company. If you owned the highest dividend paying companies, those dividends tend to get cut, a LOT, during downturns, as they get unsustainable real fast. The companies this channel promotes are a little more sustainable, so the strategy works better, but it very much depends on the quality of the company and its underlying earnings.
@@sprinkle61 good point. Don’t chase yield.
Dollar cost averaging for the long term is the less stressful 😁
Hi Investing Sensei! Love the videos !
@@acali18 hey my friend 😁
Hi Joseph,
It will be immensely helpful from learning prospective if you can share the links to the studies and papers mentioned in the video. (In description or comments)
Schwab: www.schwab.com/learn/story/does-market-timing-work
Wells Fargo: www.wellsfargo.com/investment-institute/sr-perils-time-volatile-markets/
@@JosephCarlsonShow
Thanks!
@@JosephCarlsonShow Yeah having a "sources" section in the description would be very helpful. There have been multiple times that I want to go and look through it myself too
Where can wee see whole your portfolio possitions?
Anyone thinking they can time the market is arrogant and stupid. Simple. Most people when asked if they think they're smarter/more intelligent than average say yes. Even a lot of the objectively dumbest in society that have failed every test they've ever had, can't read or write and have screwed up every decision still say yes. Therefore if most people think market timing is achievable it should be avoided. Think back in history about collective wisdom; at one point everyone thought smoking was good for you then a small group of people work hard to chip away at that thought with counter evidence and eventually people change their minds. Right now most people have never managed their own investing but apps and increased knowledge thanks to social media are making it more common than ever. The vast majority of these people will be stupid and make lots of mistakes. Attempting market timing as a means to faster & bigger returns is one of them.
Where i can find this study ?
This is the best investing channel by far. Low clickbait, no drama, just analysis and facts, real portfolio instead of random excel sheets. Thanks!
Can we just take a second to appreciate JC for *never* having to say “FYI I’m not a financial advisor” in his videos. Grinds my gears when UA-camrs in their mom’s basement presume we think of them so highly.
They do that as a legal protection. It’s got nothing to do with their (or your) presumptions.
@@davidm1411 I get it, but give advice, then immediately tell you they are not an advisor. If they focus on telling you what they are doing or general commentary like JC does, they wouldn’t have to use that disclaimer.
@@same.7939 maybe people “in moms basement” have better attorneys then you? Not to be mean, but, again, it has nothing to do with them presuming anything about how you may feel about them (narcissistic much?). Maybe have a cold beer and let people who are providing you content for free implement the legal strategy they feel best for their specific situation? Or, let ‘‘em grind your gears if you think that’s the best strategy for you……
We live in a litigious world -- people want to protect themselves, and if were to start a financial channel I'd do the same thing.
Why VICI over Reality Income, would like to hear your opinion or maybe a video on it. Great video
If you have still underperformed the market by 2025, will you switch to index funds?
As of right now the passive income account hasn’t underperformed. It’s been pretty close to SPY. The story fund, my growth account has underperform.
I am building a bigger position in SCHD in the passive income account. I want it to make up 30% million f the account.
I have a question: why not just leave auto invest on and just purchase shares when they’re at a relative discount to your overall portfolio?
Because he likes to time the market on individual stocks. Pick what is purchased.
Buy low - sell high 👌😁🔥
3:34 Irrespective* Regardless and irregardless would mean the same thing.
Could you talk about Intel in a video again? Would like see your opinion and have you changed your mind.
I'm very confused, why are you setting up four individual monthly reoccurring deposits into M1? Wouldn't one weekly deposit suffice?
Now do this for the perfect stock picker vs. the worst stock picker! :D
It doesnt matter what happens while youre invested it only matters when you bought and when you sold. Unless youre getting dividends.
So your going to ignore the multiple studies demonstrating that preservation of capital during bear market was the key factor in success with outperforming the market over long periods of time or that allocation of investments should change based on market conditions for greater success in a portfolio. DCA is effective technique if your buying indexes over long periods but when your buying individual stocks it becomes about your decisions. So buying Amazon stock in May of 2000 beats any other decision that you make. But if you have $100000 in stocks and market drops 50 % and you hold the index you have half. But if your holding a sector that doesn't crash as hard say utilities and they drop 10%. Now you redeploy back into the market with a 40000 advantage. You haven't done this but I have in multiple crashes over the years. And studies demonstrate this. I'm in the market just not blindly. Warren Buffett, Peter Lynch all do this. A study showed that if you only buy stocks when the vix is above 30 beats everything you said.
Do you have a video that goes through your dividend stock picks?
Joseph what's your dividend yield on this portfolio? I never seen you mentioning... I'm curious can you pls share your dividend yield?
*Talking about trading crypto/stock, crypto market has brought me great success!!! Irrespective of the economic downturn I can boast of over $57000 every month on my investment(Ethereum and XRP). Thank you Kimberly Jose for your focus on quality management. blessings🙌*
Despite the slow start of Ethereum to 2022, many experts are still bullish, predicting ethereum's price could potentially hit and exceed $12,000 this year. Despite the recent slump, ethereum still had a relatively strong close to 2021
It's fascinating to hear that someone here employ expert Kimberly's trading strategy, I thought I'm the only one trading with her
All you need as a beginner to make good profit trading cryptocurrency is a professional trader who will trade on your behalf else you may make losses.
With expert Kimberly everything is possible, i traded my Ethereum worth 3,000USD with her for a start, i'm proud to say i made it today
After a successful investment you have nothing to worry about, whether the rise and fall in the market or anything won't affect you, make your future brighter, by making good investment.
The best days during the bear markets and the worst days during the bull market point was priceless. Keep up the good work.
4000 dollar per month lol! That is like 10 times more what people can spend at the end of the month.
Damn Joseph advertising for a crypto company? They must of thrown you a big bag or my boy got a side crypto portfolio if you do we'd love to hear about it.
So perfect or worst timing doesn't matter - time in market matters most!
The stock market has been a really tough one this past year, but I watched an interview on CNBC where the anchor kept mentioning " TERESA JENSEN WHITE ". This prompted me to get in touch with her, and from March 2022 till now we have been working together, and I can now boast of $540,000 in my trading portfolio.
That's right, getting in touch with a consultant during the pandemic was how I was able to scale through the crazy stock downtrend.
That's massive. Can you please connect me with your personal broker, I would love to work with her
Like I said previously, her name is TERESA JENSEN WHITE , and you can reach her via her website.
Just run a search on her name, and you would see all you need.
thanks for the info . Found her website and it really impressive
MO is down 9% lol I already own BTI but good lawd I'm so on board for at least 50 shares...damn goverment overreach
Buy high and sell low baby! Innovation!
Lump sum investing baby. Dogs of the Dow method shows the power of lump sum investing...
For those still in the accumulation phase of wealth-building, your advice is good. I submit, however, that as retirement approaches, the probabilities and risks shift toward a stronger cash position. I'm 68, and plan to retire in a couple of years. That changes things, I think.
9:30 am and 2 pm with the platform you use, this are your options nothing in between ;)
It’s not a day trading app.
I got out of vici. Worried about the water situation in Vegas
On Qualtrim, can we please have the following info for REITs?
FFO
AFFO
Price to FFO
Price to AFFO
FFO Per Share
AFFO Per Share
A chart showing historicals would be so cool too.
It is stupid to say market timing doesn t work. In times when there is greed everywhere it is time to build cash and in times of great fear it is time to raise the dca and it is buying time.
DCA 💵
The question of do we try to time the market was back in January 2022, when it was pretty obvious this was all heading down big time. Some of us decided that this was not a situation to DCA, but rather stick to targeted shorter term bets on energy for example and/or just sit it out on the sidelines until the market was much, much lower. And we were right and you were wrong, plain and simple. QQQ is down around 30% YTD. You don't have to time perfectly. No one says you have to. But if you had just not been so greedy, you could have avoided a lot of pain. I think there is still a fair amount of room to the downside. I say this because there is still way too much greed in the market.
Best show in a while. Well done mate.
Could you link the media about market timing?
Ah found most.
Joseph, I too dollar cost average on a weekly basis, just not quite as much. But I have 20 equally weighted companies in my M1 pies (there is a taxable account and a Roth IRA). The proceeds are invested each week according to the weighting and, therefore,
I buy more of what is down and less of what is up. This is a “dogs” strategy which has crushed the S and P since I implemented it. I am slightly down in 1 portfolio and modestly up in another. Part of the reason I love M1 is its auto invest feature, which allows me to do this. All (except Disney) are dividend growth companies and, right now, the dividends are saving me.
Doesnt matter if you are beating the sp500 lol. You are a dividend investor. You will never sell the stocks nor realize the share price appreciation in your taxeable account.
What happens to the dividends that you earn from your ROTH IRA? Do they have to stay in the IRA?
@@arthurpokotylo2466 yes, until age 59.5. But I would reinvest them anyway back into the portfolio.
@@WheresWaldo05 point taken. In fact, a flat to declining market would benefit me.
@@michaelswami thank you! When do you pay tax on those dividends if they stay in the account and get reinvested?
You should check out Ben Felix's video "Are 'Good Companies' Good Investments?" if you haven't already. Should make for a good segment if you're looking for something to talk about in a future video.
Is that the same Ben Felix that made video after video about how renting is better than home ownership 4 years ago?
@@JosephCarlsonShow he never did that. he made videos about the math of buying vs renting to make a rational choice.
@@nikolavrbanic647 he made video after video discouraging buying over renting based on a bunch of theoretical studies. He has a 2 part video called “the case for renting a home” where he does the same thing he does in every video. Uses a bunch of theoretical studies to guide his conclusions without any real world application. He takes the contrarian stance of showing why renting “is not such a bad thing”. Since those videos. Rent has doubled. Home prices have gone up 2-3x and everyone that rented (encouraged by his adamant defense of renting) is completely screwed. This stands in contrast of the advice of Peter Lynch who strongly encouraged buying a house before investing in the stock market.
@@nikolavrbanic647 www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/behfin/2013_04-10/asness-frazzini-pedersen.pdf
There's a Yale study showing that Quality Minus Junk factor earn better risk-adjusted returns.
From the study: "high-quality stocks have high risk-adjusted returns. Indeed, a quality-minus-junk (QMJ) factor that goes long high-quality stocks and shorts low-quality stocks earns significant risk-adjusted returns in the U.S. and globally across 24 countries."
The way that Ben defined "good companies" in his video is not how I define good companies. He used "popularity" as the definition of good companies. I define a good company by profitability, growth, payout, safety (lower volatility).
I see Ben's video more geared towards the Tesla and Palantir investors who simply invest in a company at any price simply because it's popular and has a bright future. I certainly do not try to do that.
Ben Felix purchased a house recently. FYI lol
Yeah good argument but you bought sbux. I can’t give any kind of relevance
So many finance UA-camrs trying to time the market like chicken genius lol
I agree about not timing. That said, I think we have much farther downside.
In general, timing stock market is not a good idea,.. but what after HUGE Run Up's like in 2020 ??
If you invest $10k into S&P 500 from 1980 to 2020 without timing the market and keep all your money everyday, the overall return is $952,512. But if you time the market and just get out to missed the best 10 days in the midst of the bear markets, the total return of the investment become $425,369.
And when you missed the ten most red days?
you spend so much time doing research on your stocks, the income is no longer passive
Dollar cost averaging is for suckers. It’s all about high frequency trading, naked calls and puts, and buying the crypto dip.
Lots of really wealthy suckers out there. Also lots of broke traders.
My boy said "irregardless" ❤
Odd to me how it seems like it takes years for the market to go up, only for those gains to be wiped out in 3-6 months. Why is the downturn so rapid? Or is it just my imagination?
Lol. This is pure common sense. If you have 100,000 invested you can remove it all at once. But can you invest an initial 100,000 or does it take years to be able to invest that amount if you are a normal rube?
It's not just you that's how market cycles work people always say it stairs going up and elevator going down
I buy high and sell low.... :)
Same... smh
Why don’t you just have one transfer set up to deposit weekly..?
Quality and valuable advance here
One of your best videos
Still trying to convince yourself huh??? Lmao. What was a good strategy back in 1929? Did your grandpa buy the dip and dca?
A DCA strategy during the Great Depression and its aftermath would have returned 11%. The Dow went nowhere from 1929 to 1954, but DCA was up 11%.
The missing the market's best days chart blew my mind. Excellent share.
If you can only save $150 to $200 a month what would DCA in? Just curious, something like SPY?
That would be your best option, maybe when you can save more you can dabble in individual stocks for fun
Voo is a better ticket than spy. Less fees.
@@APKHD02 thank you for that information.
@@zacharycarlson3865 thank you for that information.
Great video...thanks!
For your list of people in your test, although it was stated as a lump sum division for #3 in comparison to #2, I personally feel that it doesn't do DCA enough justice. Just like you are doing with monthly DCA the moment you get cash, #2 should have pulled behind #3 on the fact that you don't usually get a lump sum in the beginning of the year.....so in a more realistic sense, I think #2 should have been stated as someone who "holds their money for a year and then invests it all at the end" and would fall behind #3. Either way, it's still marginal anyway and both are still good.
However, the big thing is that m1 isn't just about DCA....but rather it purposely chooses your underperforming companies in the list over your overperformers....this is a DCA boost because it already takes into account "bear" territory clearances for collection. I would wager that if you were to pick a good set of companies and did the test using m1 ideology, you would actually outperform the s&p quite easily.
This is what I never understood when people say "you can't beat the market"....but then look to an ETF as "the market." I'm sorry, but if that's the grade of determination, then yes, you definitely can beat the market, each and every time. When you add option plays into the mix and you get proficient with them, it's not only easily possible, it's a defined certainty. You can't "time" the market, sure, but you can definitely beat it.
Congrats
Are you going to be adding to DIS since its around your cost basis or below.
I really liked the studies presented, thanks!
You are sort of contradicting yourself when you say you should NOT time the market but still use dip finder to buy your companies
Even if Caesars or any other tenant went out of business, VICI owns prime real estate how long until another operator moves into those buildings 5-10 minutes? How long would those buildings really stay empty? Not long
Why don’t you just make the rules 1k/week? Instead of 4 1k/mo rules? What am I missing lol
What about the Great Depression?
DCA strategy during the depression resulted in average returns of over 11% annually. And the dividend yield was 14%. Next question.
There is one very important aspect, that is selling, missing in this study. Mainly getting out completely or majorly when market is going down and then get in when it is going up. One doesn't have to perfectly time it. But selling and coming out is important. This study doesn't factor that.
Wow genius. I bet in over 100 years of stock market history, no one ever thought of that before. I believe you can outperform 10% p.a. consistently in that case. Just save 50k for your retirement and over 30 years at 15% p.a. you get 3.3 million. Plus you can probably write an investment book and get another 10 million. Sooo easy right
This point is covered in the " some of the best days are in bear markets and worst days are in bull markets section ". No one knows the day when things will turn.
Is that not "timing the market"?
Lol. Please post for all of us Vivek when the market is “majorly” gonna go down and when to get in BEFORE it goes up again. btw, the study does factor that scenario in as well. The Indian Tommy Boy in the house!
"The nice thing about dividends is that they are not in the control of the investors, dividends are in the control of the actual company" - Joseph Carlson
The best and worst days argument may work for indexes but it's entirely out the window for individual stocks.
Hi Joseph… I believe my method of timing the market is similar to yours. I have a method of identifying stocks when they are more favorable for purchase that is similar to your dip finder. It works great, but it is definitely not DCA. I would never use a DCA approach. DCA requires a scheduled approach for buying and it doesn’t make sense to me.
I usually give you a hearty thumbs up, but not this time.
Thank you so much for your insight and research info you provide. Many of the stocks I ended buying over the last several years have been based on your excellent analysis!
Are you worried about the impact of the water shortage on Las Vegas and VICI?
"The best days occur in the bear market, and bad days occur in the bull market. The best days and worse days have often occurs close together." Well said!!!
Lump sum at the top and wait.
My portfolio is only a bit larger that yours Joseph and I was up 185K at highs and now I'm down 35K. Wild swing!
So you are saying now is a good time to buy a house?
Dividend is taxed as ordinary income in a taxable account. If you take into account the tax bite is dividend investing more profitable than non-dividend stocks?
You are wrong about most dividends, which are taxed very favorably compared to ordinary income. Qualified dividends are taxed the same as capital gains for most investors. And if all you have is dividend income, the tax rate up to 40,000+ is zero for a single filer. 80K for a married joint filer.
He means if you gross up to 40k year in wages you dont get taxed at all on dividends. Anything over that income level and its 20%
@@WheresWaldo05 15% 41000 up to 490,000+, 20%’above that
Anyone else just stop watching as soon as the promotion starts?
The what vs if could just be an error, english is not a first language for many people
Don’t buy yourself out’ some told me at a bar.. but in fact, even if you’re still down; invest
Musk did not say he’d fire 10% of its workforce. He said 10% of its “waged employees”. So that’s around 3000 people, not 10’000 - because like other car manufacturers a lot of the workforce is contractors.
Few weeks later Musk also confirmed that Tesla will keep growing its workforce.
I just can’t get passed Disney’s P/E ratio. They have a sticky brand and strong library of content but the earnings are underwhelming compared to price even with this drop in share price.
PE ratio is based on last years numbers. Which were crap due to COVID. Also being woke and SJW is wrecking Disney.
Said that, I have some Disney and will add some more at 85 USD!
Go woke, go broke.
Even the edited versions for other countries, like China, don't do well.
Disneys forward PE is 23. The average analyst estimate has them earning $4.06 next year.
@@JosephCarlsonShow do you think they will bring back the dividend in the near future? Seems like they want go for growth narrative.
How’s your Disney and Costco positions?
I know this is a rhetorical question. But I'll answer anyway. Costco is fine, and has outperformed SPY during every time period and every year I've owned it. Not that it really matters because I plan on holding the company for 20 years. Disney stock has gone down into territory I consider far undervalued. It's performance has been awful. I'm fine holding it until their streaming platforms reach profitable scale and they fully recover EBITDA to pre-pandemic levels.
@@JosephCarlsonShow not rhetorical, because I also hold them, and I bought because I listened to you, and now I am probably more down than you. Just going to hold like you said.
@@JosephCarlsonShow by the way, if you considering DIS a value play, then you should also look into META and NFLX, both are in value territory.
@@bspiderm ahh. Yea. I actually think Meta is grossly undervalued. I think the one big risk to dropping Facebook further is if their engagement numbers or daily active users falls next quarter.
I’m still in on Netflix. They trade at a market average multiple. I plan to hold for the next few years and see if they can regain investor confidence in their business model. Netflix by far is my worst investment across both portfolios as of now.
@@JosephCarlsonShow thanks for replying man, I have been critical of you only because 1. You don’t like crypto, and 2. I still think buying BRK B is more of a value play than your portfolio in the long run. However, I am slowly realizing I am in more wrong than right. So, I sincerely apologize.
During the 2001 recession, the gaming revenues within the United States increased even as economic activity in the other industries decreased (AGA, 2008). However, casinos in all markets did not fare as well during the latest recession (2007/2010).
Timing the market is not for everyone. You can't enter the market during bull cycle expecting to make incredible gains and then when you start to loose money during bear market sell it all. That's a recipe for disaster. Stock market is all about patience, decades of patience..
Ceasars bankruptcy would barely be a blip. Ceasars would likely be a debtor in possession during the bankruptcy and would need to stay in operation in order to have a viable operation during and after the proceeding.
Uh, no. The dividends are just part of a total return. They are not "keeping you in the green". Had they not been paid, you would have the same amount of total return - it would just be moved over to the capital gains section of THE SAME TOTAL RETURN, lol.
Daddy
Hi Joseph! What do you recommend for someone who receives income in different currencies? Namely one that is down 30% compared to USD is just a year. I'd happily dollar cost average in but the USD-HUF exchange costs are discouraging to say the least.
What happens to vici if property in Las Vegas becomes less valuable over time? Lake Mead is dropping at a rapid rate, this supplies water and electricity to millions of people. Lots of UA-cam videos of local people showing how serious this problem is. Having such a large portion of their portfolio in Las Vegas do you see this as a problem?
This is why I got out of vici while I was ahead.
Man I went to the dam when I visited earlier this year. The lake is way down. They only had one generator running at the time. They were making up for the loss in power by other means though. They have the electrical infrastructure already as a backup. Dont know what they'll do about water though. Its a city in the desert.
Rosie Rotten gang where you at 💪
😂😂😂✌🏾
Hindsight analysis with historical data of uptrend market 😅
By selling at the highs and buying at lows u are timing the market too. Not investing until a Bottom is not a good choice no.
Not accurate - Buffett never tries to time market movements but has continually traded in and out of specific positions based on their particular valuation. Don't confuse individual security valuation with trying to time broad based economic market movements.
@@JosephCarlsonShow buffet also says buy index funds.. yet never does himself.