Brexit A Delusional Decision, Says India’s Minister Hardeep Singh Puri
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- He’s a former Indian career diplomat who has served in the United Kingdom and has also been India’s permanent representative to the United Nation but Hardeep Singh Puri-now a minister in the Narendra Modi government-likes to describe himself as “somebody who has professionally studied the false narrative”. In an interview with SNI’s Editor-in-Chief Nitin A. Gokhale, Puri, who was among the few people who had famously predicted that Donald Trump would become the 45th President of the United States, cites his reasons for doing so in the face of a deluge of opinion polls predicting Hillary Clinton’s win. Puri, whose second book “Delusional Politics” was launched recently, also delves into history to cite how Adolf Hitler goofed up big time when he was so close to winning the Second World War. The minister also says multilateralism is going through an existential crisis at the United Nations, and that Brexit was a decision Britain could have done without.
#Brexit #Modi #Trump
I wish we had Ministers like Mr Puri in Belgium. What an interesting guy !
@Arid Im surprised too .
Ahhh...considered, compelling and authoritative. Shame there's not more of this type of politician in every country.
Logical and clear thinking chap. Unlike those on the Indian liberal left side of the conversation..
This man has got more sense and intelligence than the whole uk political class!
@me hee update data bro..95 coverage of sanitation has been achieved till dec 2018 recognized and lauded by UNO and WHO... i understand that updating knowledge is not a procedure followed by propagandists but alteast try to read comprehensively and continuously so that you can participate in informed debates and discussions. All the best
@me hee Listen you skumbag, all countries in this world are not equal and rich. If you have any pbrain iota, you should know that all SE Asian countries are poor and are progressing under corrupt administrations. So, your fucking illiterate post is ridiculous.
@Tony S I vist that country and I can tell you categorically, that the population boom can never allow any progress and the elite will remain landholders, businesses, ex royals, industrialist etc. (only 5% or less). The country needs communism to eradicate inequality, no other way. Look at China and see their progress, though still an average Chinese is poor. But their infrastructure allows some relief, some equality, some solace etc.
@me hee Have you looked around a British city these days? Seen the numbers of homeless? Where do you think they are shitting?
@me hee thank you for that accurate stereotype. You're very superior to us. Stay happy in your la la land.
This guy gets it....BIG TIME.
A true pleasure to listen to what a learned mind has to say. True Indian hero. I am going to read his books.
Very interesting and informative interview. HS Puri is very knowledgeable & so is Mr Nitin
Thank Nitinji, excellent conversation.
Hardeep Puri is quite free minded. Not too bad!
It is an ABSOLUTE DELIGHT to hear a seasoned professional reason out in a calm collected way. Thank you very much, Mr Puri, for serving India as a diplomat and carrying that expertise into politics.
Henry Ford, the founder of Ford Motors is reported to have said: 'History is bunk' and you, as a student of history, confirmed it, sir.😊❤👍😊
Mr puri is surprisingly refreshing as he was with the civil services.Civil services r such a rot in india
Right.
And yet UK thinks it'll get a good reception trading wise with India.
Well just listen. ... Also it will want UK to take more immigrants.
So how will that be the EUs fault Brexitards??!!!
Remoaners, they get everywhere, like dog shit on your shoe lol
Well, US takes in a lot of British immigrants. You should not have problem with Indians just because of our skin color.
Learn to be humble and know who your partners are.
Deka 001 No one has a problem with indians or skin colour in the UK, the problem in the UK is Zionists and Muslims.
Headline today shows UK defense minister requests more money after Brexit as a reaction of the new challanges in the world.
Make your own conclusion now.
Intelligent, sensible man.
Well said sir
Thanks sir🙏
Present BJP leadership is able to attract good talent and knowledgeable folks in party. Hardeepsing Puri is one of those.
There wasn't a major political leader apart from Donald Trump and Putin that thought Brexit was a good idea.
@Russian Troll so Im told David Cameron....the guy quit
@Russian Troll so Im told "major political leader" did you read that bit, Cameron presently holds no office and is an ordinary citizen so he is neither major nor a political leader. However I can see that he would like to justify the chaos that he initiated just like Blair tries to justify the second Iraqi war. No major political leader supported Brexit apart from Trump and Putin, do have another go.
"Let us contemplate for a moment that romantic nation [Ireland]. I would like the reader to, believe with me that it is not the blood that the Irishmen have taken which has given them what appears to be their liberty. But it is the gallons of blood they have willingly given themselves. It is not the fear of losing more lives that has compelled a reluctant offer from England, but it is the shame of any further imposition of agony upon a people that loves its liberty above everything else. It is the magnitude of the Irish sacrifice which has been the deciding factor . . . And England has yielded when she is able no longer to bear the sight of blood pouring out of thousands of Irish arteries" - Collected Works of Gandhi, 15/ 12/1 921 (Volume XXII, p 17).
Now Ireland has an Indian leader intimately familiar with the blood of the Irish and the english are still trying to control our destiny. Ireland will be a member of only one union the European one not the genocidal xenophobic racist cancer imploding next door.
I am a Canadian of Indian origin, and it delights me to see people of Indian origin rise in politics of other countries.
Hope people of Indian origin provide Ireland with poets and novelists as well. I love George Bernard Shaw and his sparring with Winston Churchill.😊
Portugal too has a PM of Indian origin, I think?
Ireland and the rest of Europe must stay in the EU. I hope the world roots for globalization despite the hiccoughs it is going through right now. I hope the whole world gets together to solve the collective problems that face humankind.
Good luck to Ireland and Europe at large.
Maybe Britain will come to her senses about Brexit as well?
@@TameTusker It will take a lot of english blood to wash away their sins.
Idiot
Je etude francaise, Je sai meme anglais ne peut pas present 100% situation orignale. (pardon my language I am very much beginer)
Ireland leader is Irish. His father is Indian.
Great Interview! But why use Brexit in the title when Brexit is hardly discussed in the first 2/3rd of the interview, and even when it is mentioned... its not more than a couple of min. There are a lot of other interesting things that Mr. Puri talks about!
Clickbait
Mr Puri did not study European history well. Hitler’s decision to go to Russia was not delusional, it was quite pragmatic. German army was fueled by oil from Venezuela and Germans expected Churchill at some point to reneg on the 1940 agreement on not interfering with each other’s oil supplies. So German army went after oil in Caspian Sea. Unfortunately for German army Russian winter stepped in.
I agree with you.
Germans never thought of occupying the whole of Soviet Union. They only wanted to bring the Soviet leadership to the table so that they could force them to an agreement favorable to the Germans, just like the Vichy France. Soviets on the other hand, despite taking gigantic losses in men and materials never came to the table, and then in came the winters and we know what happened afterward.
This minister saying Hitler invaded Soviet Union due to drugs is just asinine. Decisions like these are backed up by years of planning and feasibility studies done by multitude of departments etc.
@@f1azizThinking that winter would hesitate to manifest while German troops are around appears… delusional.
@@thephidias Rather, given the quick defeats of two military powers in Poland and France and Red Army's poor condition with Stalin's purges, they were confident of bringing the Soviets to the table before the winter sets in. German Army ravaged the Red Army in the eastern European theater as per their plans but the Soviets kept on fighting. A lot of historians believe Soviets would have collapsed or might not have put up as much resistance as they did if Allied military and material support wasn't there.
@@f1aziz And that was the delusion.
@@thephidias Given their quick victories and weaknesses in the Red Army they might have overestimated their capacity to wage such a large scale operation with overstretched supply lines, but Germany was already teetering due to British Naval blockade, the oil production in the Eastern Europe was the only fighting chance to acquire much needed fuel for German military and industry.
Nobody thought Germany could put down an old military superpower like France as quickly as they did too. British military was awestruck by the scale and speed of the whole operation in France. German operation in France in WW2 is still studied in various military academies.
It's only hubris if you lose, if you pull it off would have been a genius move.
Superb man
I have a question do india need a 24/7 News channels ?
Leave means leave. Sign the UK open petition for a no deal Brexit 353,425 MBGA
Brexiteers voted leave because they like leaves!
@shaun muppet finder that was an insane and rude response Shaun you twat.
Me thinks they are more like horse sh!te hitting the trail.
Love this channel
And while everyone is having fun playing the hokey-cokey with EU membership and wallowing in delusions of economic grandeur, the country will remain economically divided and in constant state of misery because of the government's socio-political and economic agenda which has not changed since being part of the EU and will not change after leaving. People should think in the now. Not the past or the future.
I have a predicted same, year ahead on Trump also voted.
We said. Civil servants are worse than politicians. More unfortunate that they stay untill their retirement. Lol
Germany needed Russia's oil the war had dragged on too long.
If you want to get ahead get a hat still holds sway in India.
a puff piece full of one mans opinion and a yes man interviewer
You expected an episode of BBC 'HARD TALK' ?
Nitin wanted to just pick his brain !
this govt has lawyer running economy n diplomat in urban housing!!
@Pavan Gupta yoy growth rate is same except the crash years, this govt hasent performed anything exceptional even with low oil prices and world growth picking up.. jobs lost in china went to vietnam and bangladesh..
India to join a treaty with
Pakistan
Bangladesh
Afghanistan
Sri Lanka
600m muslims 1,000m Hindu
80m Christian 40m Sikh
Wonderful SCU Sub-Continent Union
CAPITAL CITY Dhaka
All laws to be agreed by majority rule
As soon as this guy said casino roulette tables were rigged, with the croupier having a switch, that did it for me, he lost his credibility. They do not need to be rigged, as the mathematical odds are that the house will always win.
Who cares matey.
Is this conversation rigged?
Smart cities...hahahaha
Your indian people who are so clever to telling a story bad word in this two guy into the youtube ..your indian citizen have more money youtube 105K or your personal acount . US money ..
yes the state leader like ajay bhist?? better not be, better less charismatic pappu but with heart..
@Barindra Bal haha Congress thinks nation progress on basis of having heart.
@Barindra Bal that much stupid..
What does this guy know??? Another so called expert!
He knows more than you lazy idiots in uk
Indeed, according to you racist brit Nigel. Boxhead englander.
@@bhuttasingh2980 Thank you Bhutta the Chhalli.
No Deal Brexit is the way forward. Not the half baked brexit deal theresa may proposes
Only if you're a treasonous English millionaire out to make a killing by shorting the £ at the expense of the UK population and think the break up of the UK is an acceptable level of collateral damage.
Why? So it pushed around by more powerful trading blocks?
Akula Sri Rahul
Rahul get real.
Akula Sri Rahul Well, it would make me some good money. I’m paid in €.
@@edgeyt1 If you think being a vassal state of Useless EU which already has too many financial strains on its side and ignoring much bigger and lucrative trade deals with USA, South America and Asia then good luck with your bogus nonsense. UK is the second biggest contributor to the EU, it would be a significant dent to EU economy if Britain is out. But remoaners don't seem to understand economics of trade and the concept of sovereignty so why bother discussing
Maybe they should feed their people instead of building giant statues
nothing to do with him they live in a bubble of corruption
Who, in their right mind would pay any attention to India and Indians, one of the most backward and primitive peoples and places on Earth?
A nation so backward - and stupid - it allowed itself to be taken over by a tiny island people of less than one fiftieth of its size AND six months sailing time away.
Even today, the GDP of India is only about the same as the UKs, even though it’s population is twenty times greater. To those who don’t quite understand what that means, it means the average person living in Britain earns twenty times more than the average person living in India.
And Indians still blame the events of a many, many years ago for their backwardness now. Ignoring the fact that most of the excuses are insane. For example when a foreign country invests in Britain we know that makes us richer, but when the British build railways in India it’s “stealing”.
Sort your own problems out - you with your average intelligence quotient of 85 - and shut up.
Just think. Germany returned to being a rich and prosperous country in just ten years after being completely destroyed and occupied in World War Two.
Oh dear... I suspect you will claim you are not being racist
skyblaze eterno. Just tell me where I am wrong. But you can’t.
Ofcourse the British monarchy were in India for charity, what a noble breed of people.
dre. No one says that. The British went to India to make money. But they began to realise that Indian culture could be very cruel and felt obliged to stop the worst of it.
Human nature makes it very difficult for one person to acknowledge the debt they owe to another. The Chinese have a saying which I can’t remember exactly but (in translation obviously) goes something like “Why do you hate me? I have never been kind to you.”
The British bought civilisation to India, though I notice some Indian leaders would rather say (through gritted teeth) the British brought modernity to India. You were civilised but not modern!! Clever.
Old man you are talking rubbish look around the world india saved you in the world wars sikhs, look at space progam india is a superpower what are you nothing just a laughing stock of the world😆😆😆😆😃😂😁😀lazy little island you did not rule india you went in uninvited then a guy wearing a loin cloth kicked you idiots out shall i go on,no we wont waste anymore time on you knobhead lazy,moan moan thats all you do good luck with your brexit nonsense