How to Determine if your Brushless Motor is Dead (Electrically or Mechanically)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024
  • Here we take a look at how determine if the cause of your power system failure is related to the motor. No special tools are required and you don't even need to disassemble the motor! Electrical and Mechanical Motor failures are considered.
    Full video on How to Measure Kv (RPM per Volt) of a Brushless Motor:
    • How to measure KV (RPM...
    What is Cogging within a Brushless Motor (May not be what you think it is)
    • Brushless Motor Coggin...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 51

  • @richarddorsch7275
    @richarddorsch7275 Рік тому +5

    Very informative. My new motor had those bumps you referred to. I thought the motor was garbage but now I know better...thank you.

  • @MakerFabio
    @MakerFabio Рік тому +1

    Thanks good job. To check the kV I usually go with a cheap speed controller without timing and measure the RPM at a given voltage (but i admit not everyone has an rpm meter at home)

  • @chrisduna6483
    @chrisduna6483 3 роки тому

    Really informative and appreciate the time it took you to post this.

  • @gehandx
    @gehandx 4 роки тому +2

    Great, the video I was waiting for, How about measuring the resistance of the 3 phases. will it help identify any problem ?

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому +1

      HI Gehan, thanks for the comment! Yes measuring the resistance of the 3 phases will also help identify any problem. However, measuring resistance of a phase is a bit more complex (video on the channel on this) and you will not get any understanding of the state of the rotor. Measuring voltage on each phase will provide you will all the information to make a full assessment.

    • @gehandx
      @gehandx 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained Thank you so much for the reply. I will watch the video.

  • @clmfilms8103
    @clmfilms8103 3 роки тому

    A few years ago, I got a hubsan h501a drone, and after about a year one of the motors stopped working and created a bit of smoke. At the time, I was planning on spending some money on a dji mavic air, so I took that as a chance to get one and never looked back. The hubsan kinda got abandoned in my closet. Now a couple of years later I'm thinking of fixing up the old drone just to fly for fun when I'm not flying my mavic. I know that it's the motor and not the esc because I tried swapping two motors around and the a different motor worked fine on the esc that the fried motor was on. I'm just wondering if it's at all possible to repair the motor, or do I definitely have to buy a new motor? Thanks 👍

  • @cigarr0000
    @cigarr0000 4 роки тому +3

    I don't know who to pass this on to, but there's almost no videos about vent holes in rc bodies. I want to know the aerodynamic effect and cooling performance that can be achieved with a few well placed holes for nitro and electric RC vehicles. Especially SCT bodies

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому

      It's something I can look in to, to see if I can get a CFD analysis done on it.

    • @cigarr0000
      @cigarr0000 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained Thanks for replying, forgot about rc buggy and their rear wing (I thinkTLR has a few with a front wing), I know it's pretty obvious what it does and how it works, but there's so many setups and adjustment that can be done to any RC car to meet the track condition, the body and wing play a huge role when the car is moving and in the air. I have a proline truescale ford F-150 '17 and cut vents on the hood, middle back window, 4 short vents on the bed, and vented the sidetop of the tailgate, just seemed logical to vent those areas but I haven't tested it yet.

    • @faiqcreates
      @faiqcreates Рік тому

      idk if u will still read this, but i removed the plastic windshield on my shortcoarse truck (took out the piece where the window sticker is (whole) and added a fiber tape mesh type thing there. same for the door windows. now the air has good flow, provides decent cooling to esc and motor (my esc has 4 rotor blades broken so yeah air cooling actually works) motor does get hot after 10 mins but i am using a onroad motor 12t 4300kv on a offroad car so i say it works.

  • @Mr_BUSINESS_24_7
    @Mr_BUSINESS_24_7 5 місяців тому

    what if the cogging feels much stronger on my brand new Trinity 4.5 t and even stronger on my Dash 7.5 t but very weak cogging on my Trinity Kill Shot 13.5 t ??

  • @89rc_dude33
    @89rc_dude33 Рік тому +1

    Thanks, mate. Very valuable video. 👌🏻

  • @TheTylerjoy04
    @TheTylerjoy04 2 роки тому

    Can A Overhead Brushless Motor, Fry Your ESC Or Short It Out?

  • @OldfartRC1
    @OldfartRC1 4 роки тому +6

    This is fantastic. You definitely earned a subscriber!
    What is the website you used to enter those values?

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому +2

      Thanks for the comment Luigi.
      The website is www.radiocontrolinfo.com

  • @racingrivals8934
    @racingrivals8934 4 роки тому +1

    Nice been waiting for this

  • @gamercat7004
    @gamercat7004 2 роки тому

    My brushless motor by castle creations which I have I noticed I run it off the rc and see powder black stuff shooting on the table and is that a indicator of damage? I'm hoping it's the pinion gear that is stripped and made the dust stuff.

  • @furiouswolf777voodoo4
    @furiouswolf777voodoo4 4 роки тому

    My rotor opened and locked the motor. Not sure what they use to wrap the rotor but it didn't work lol Poseidon 2200kv. Great info vid Thanks💯🙂

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому

      Oh no! An aggressive lock up could damage the stator to the point where replacement of the motor is your only option. Thanks for the comment.

    • @furiouswolf777voodoo4
      @furiouswolf777voodoo4 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained Yes I replaced motor 👍🙂

    • @rydirp
      @rydirp 2 роки тому

      They use Kevlar thread to wrap the rotor

  • @runngunrc1991
    @runngunrc1991 3 роки тому

    My motor doesn’t spin freely. I believe when I opened it up it was a crack in the magnets an the shaft has play forward an back can I fix this if so how ?

  • @turbinegraphics16
    @turbinegraphics16 3 роки тому

    I damaged a drone motor magnet by getting it stuck on a branch, i could feel the difference in cogging.

  • @irockz9723
    @irockz9723 2 роки тому

    My electric scooter motor is just juddering when I apply throttle,vibrates alot and doesn't move forward,any idea what the problem is ?

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  2 роки тому

      Try this ua-cam.com/video/ow3Ff61RV2I/v-deo.html

  • @GreatBirdOfHope
    @GreatBirdOfHope 2 роки тому

    My brushless motor in my stadium 1/10th scale truck only has half the top speed it used to but still has the same punch 👊 whats going on?

  • @Grimmy_2v
    @Grimmy_2v 3 роки тому

    I have a brushless motor that only spins when I’m holding the motor in my hand. But when I install it, it hums but doesn’t spin the wheels

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  3 роки тому

      That is quite strange. Do you know if a motor lead is shorting out when installed?

  • @colin1992
    @colin1992 4 роки тому +1

    great vid ryan! hows your jaw?

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому

      Hi Colin, much better! Turns out it was just sprained and took about a week to heal. Thanks for the comment and for asking!

    • @colin1992
      @colin1992 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained no probs!

  • @-dafhatas-6519
    @-dafhatas-6519 4 роки тому

    Hi, so i want to ask,
    Im going to get a goolrc 3400kv brushless motor, i think its max 105 a, also an 125a goolrc esc,
    and a 3000mah 35c (105a)lipo,
    Do you think it will be good to work?

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому

      How many amps are you going to be pulling from this system?

    • @-dafhatas-6519
      @-dafhatas-6519 4 роки тому

      I really dont know
      Also how can i get an mono or cataraman hull? I dont have something like an 3D printer
      It says that the motor suits
      600-800mm hull

    • @-dafhatas-6519
      @-dafhatas-6519 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained are you there?
      Its ok if you cant respond Fast, dont worry
      Im really excited, this Will hopefully be my first rc boat
      Also the first time that i Will buy something from the internet

    • @RCexplained
      @RCexplained  4 роки тому

      It sounds like you have selected a 2s LiPo with a 3400kv motor selection.
      If so this can work with a 600 to 700mm hull.
      A catamaran can be purchased as hull only. Look at offshoreelectrics

    • @-dafhatas-6519
      @-dafhatas-6519 4 роки тому

      @@RCexplained Its actually 4S

  • @Nitrogang
    @Nitrogang 2 роки тому

    red blue
    blue yellow
    red yellow
    you said it kind of fast

  • @vipnailspa
    @vipnailspa Рік тому +1

    talk too much