The woman in the blue scarf in the front row that they show, is Jonathan Larson’s sister, and she said that when she was on set watching Andrew she said that it felt like she was spending time with her brother again. As if I didn’t need to cry more about this movie.
@@rocknroll20024 The Larson family is VERY involved with Jonathan's legacy. Both Allan and Nan would go and speak to the different productions, even high schools, thanking them for keeping Jon's memory alive. After they passed it was Jon's sister, Julie who keeps the legacy going.
So technically, he died a few hours after the last dress rehearsal which was also the day of RENT's first off-broadway preview performance. The show was canceled for that night and the cast and crew instead did sing through in memorial. The most crushing part of the story is that he had been having chest pains for days prior and even sought medical attention, but he was misdiagnosed and never got a relatively simple surgery that in all likelihood would have saved his life.
What bothers me is that every time he went to the hospital, the ER wrote off his chest pain as food poisoning and showed him the door. Why? He didn’t have insurance and it was obvious he wasn’t a big fish. He wasn’t going to make the hospital any money by treating him. Perhaps this is a bit morbid, but there’s even a story about Jonathan’s last week or so in a medical journal: “The Journal of Urgent Care Medicine.” The article is called “The Story of Jonathan - One Week in January.” I think this made it into this particular journal because whoever wrote this article is trying to teach its readers how to diagnose someone like Jonathan. That no, you don’t write it off as food poisoning and shove the patient out the door.
It's funny because you say "Because this is Lin-Manuel" about that quiet part, but by associating that type of moment with Lin when Jonathan was the composer, you're actually noticing the influence Jonathan had on him as a creator!
I love that this song illustrates something Andrew Garfield has said in interviews before and after this film was released. We all have unfinished songs. That within us all, we only have a finite amount of time to sing our songs and try to get them out in the world. Dr. Wayne Dyer always said, "Don't let your music die inside of you." What unfinished songs did Jonathan Larson have? That's a big part of the tragedy. But the triumph is what songs he left for all of us as his legacy! Thank you, Jonathan Larson...and Happy Birthday (February 4, 1960 - January 25, 1996)...he would have been 62 today!
Andrew Garfield deserves every award for this musical. Everyone who took one year of music lessons and have to impress Lin-Manuel fucking Miranda definitely deserves all the praise he gets.
EACH time he sings "ask the birds" I get chills on my back! And knowing his Mother passed away before they started filming this just makes me tear up more
Not gonna lie it's my favourite bit of the song. But that's also because I am a massive fan of Bradley Whitford who the camera cuts to in the audience at that point).
Yup same for me. It's so much better because it's kind of unexpected. We get that final dialogue about what Johnathan did and his impact, and then the narrator (was it Alexandra?) stating he still had "more" to do... all over that piano intro. Those few notes building up, unexpectedly, to something brilliant.
@@nwc628 right!! I’m so glad I found my people that love this stuff as much as I do .. one of my other favorite parts in there is when the screen goes into like it’s a video tape and just Joshua and Vanessa sing cages and wings .. oh the chills and now I have In the heights part in the club .. oh Lin lol
@@JSKatsky No worries at all. I kind of avoided musicals for theeeee longest time. I "knew" about the obvious ones, but the first one I really dove into was Hamilton. Became obsessed for a time lol. Then I saw the praise for this film and decided to put it on one night when I was going to bed. Bad idea... finished it and researched more for hours. Still haven't seen Rent or really anything else like that, but I'm more than open to suggestions. Guess I was a closet musical fan all along...
Please react to “no more” and “why”! “Why” was recorded and filmed live, which just proves how much more amazing he was and it’s freaking amazing, it makes me cry. Jonathan Larson’s sister was on set that day watching also. “no more” is just amazing in its own way.
The "Why" performance also took place at the end of the first week of filming because they only had use of the Delacorte Theater location in Central Park for that short window of time. Just think about those circumstances for a moment and it becomes even more clear what a fantastic performance that was. The way Lin tells it in an interview, they got their "Hathaway take" on the second take of filming that scene.
Something people don't talk about enough is that Andrew does have an amazing singing voice and it's insane he's this good after 1year of vocal training but he's also doing this in an accent that isn't the one he usually uses witch is insanely impressive he's incredible 😊
What’s so great thematically about this and 30/90 is it brings Jonathan’s coming-of-age arc to a close. He starts the show dreading his birthday, and by the end embraces it.
So, interesting note, the segment of "what does it take, to wake up a generation" was originally written without that high note. So far Andrew is the only person I've heard sing this that's gone high with it
This movie and soundtrack is a perfect circle, if you remember in 30/90 he says "they are singing happy birthday" and in louder that words he end it with the happy birthday song
I'm not that big of a musical fan but I 100% love this film mainly because of how Andrew Garfield can sing and the musicin general. The dude sings as if he's been singing for a long time. His performance is amazing 10/10 performance
The first time I watched this movie I cried my eyes out. Jon Larson gave the world a gift beyond measure with Rent; it’s more than likely that Rent and it’s message saved many LGBT+ lives and gave them hope. I was honestly so heartbroken when I thought about what else he might have given us if he’d had more time. Rent changed my life at 19 years old, and tick tick BOOM did it again at 27. Happy Birthday, Jon; thank you for what you’ve given us. I wish we could have given you more when you were with us.
This is my FAVORITE song from this movie. And it became my favorite song in general. It makes me tear up, and its my favorite song to sing. The line “cages or wings..which do you prefer? Ask the birds” gives me chills. I want to make a tattoo inspired by this song for myself. It changed my life
The entire song makes tears come to my eyes, but my favorite line that always makes me start crying is “if we’re so free, tell me why so many people bleed?”
I think it helped that he hadnt sung before and he was just like a fresh ball of clay for the vocal coach to mold whereas singers are harder to break of bad habits and teach new ones because they are so stuck in their ways (like old clay) . I also think that being half British/half American and great with accents helps because he has that ability to change things up and flow between sounds.
I really love Andrew Garfield as an actor, but I love him even more as a singer. This just shows that so many people have talents that we may not know of. I think it’ll be important to keep our eyes open and listen to everyone around us. Because they, too, could go from unheard to your favorite artist/singer. I find it fascinating and eye opening. 💕
And we should thank the masseuse who said that Andrew “can sing” 😄 when Lin Manuel asked if he knew if Andrew can sing. So he “lied” at first that he can but took some training and gave this amazing performance
I have no idea if it was on purpose, but the fact you posted this on Jonathan Larsons birthday.... Wow it made it extra special I genuinely got chills and cried a little with the "Happy Birthday" playing on the piano. Happy birthday Jonathan ❤️ he would be 62 today
So, I'm SURE that someone else has said this, but the reason Garfield hasn't been in a musical before is because he literally learned to sing for this film. Way I hear it, he was told early on that he can't sing, and had kind of avoided it for most of his life up to this point.
It might be apocryphal, but I heard something about how he took singing lessons at a young age and the teacher quite rudely told him he couldn’t sing. It humiliated and terrified him, so he never took singing roles until Lin-Manuel Miranda convinced him to give it a go and helped him find his voice.
It was drama school. The teacher/professor assigned him a difficult song and then gave him a failing grade instead of encouraging him. So he just believed he can’t sing. LMM on the other hand thought he could do it. As long as he isn’t tone deaf as he did handle a 7 hour play and didn’t lose his voice. I wonder how LMM managed to see that he has the potential.
Larson had so many perfect songs. Not only did he make absolutely flawless melodies, but his lyrics were so deep and meaningful. I love listening to his songs over again and focusing on the lyrics and the message. Absolute perfection.
I love your journey trough tick tick boom, is one of my favorites musicals and now movies! This is probably my favorite song, the line "why does it take a catastrophe to start a revolution" always gets me and makes me tear up. Happy birthday, Jonathan Larson ♥
Hi Audrey! Just wanna share that around 4:28 of this video, you'll see that the woman in the video is Julie Larson, Jonathan's sister and last surviving member of his immediate family. I always start to tear up whenever I see her in the film.
The end always gives me chills. Since the musical starts with Jonathan refusing to turn 30, denying it, questioning his life decisions, him playing “Happy Birthday” at the end shows his acceptance of getting older, albeit after he feels like he has accomplished something with a successful workshop for “Superbia”. After making a name for himself, having a, in his eyes, major accomplishment (not to say it wasn’t major, just that there were likely other accomplishments that he himself undermined and didn’t give due credit), does he feel like he can turn 30. That was his whole point prefacing “30/90”, that his parents did so much by the time they were 30, that he felt that he comparatively had done nothing with his life.
I liked what you said about Andrew not being pigeonholed into being Spider-man anymore. I saw him in 2012 thinking that he was not a recognized actor, and now that he has made a place for himself in the industry, seeing him play Spider-man again in the 2021 movie makes me feel that I can value him properly. He definitely doesn't need the character to be a great actor and a great person
Lin Manuel mentioned that it was really refreshing to coach him to sing since he had no bad singing habits prior him being casted! pretty interesting how voices develop. Andrew and Lin did one heck of a job!!!!!!
that little happy birthday bit at the end always makes me cry. So gorgeous, and after the whole emotional transcendence of the rest of the song, where it got so loud and suddenly stops. Like Jonathan kinda...
Yes that was Idina Menzel. She was the original Maureen on Broadway. It’s where she got her start. Rent is where a lot of now Stars, got there start. It is horrible that Jonathan died the day before opening. It’s heartbreaking.
You should definitely do “Why” next. Andrew sang and played it live and in two takes(which wasn’t allowed on set cause of Covid) and he absolutely killed it! Definitely one of my top songs from the movie
You need to watch "No Day But Today". It's the story of Johnny Larson, and on the RENT DVD special features. It has a little of Suburbia and Tick, Tick, Boom, and of course a lot of RENT info. I don't mean to react to it necessarily, but it gives a lot of context and shows why John was so important to musical theater even though he never saw one of his shows on Broadway.
I'm really looking forward to see your reaction to this song! I love the meaning of the lyrics so much! And the energy that Andrew gives to it is magical!
I’m so glad this movie is bringing these incredible songs to light. Back when I was a kid I used to be a performer and this was a song that me and my singing teacher would often sing as a duet during shows, one of my all time favourite songs and now to see it getting mainstream attention is just so great to see!!
The fact that I got teary and goosebumps all over just from watching this reaction video (with pauses)… is a testament of how good Andrew Garfield is 😭❤️❤️ and what a movie!! I hope at this point you’ve watched the movie and loving it ❤️
I can't believe that Im crying even watching it like this and over all without even being a fan, this movie has so much heart it just get to you either way.
Josh Henry is an incredibly versatile theater monster who's been in all of Lin's of projects. But you should check out his version of Soliloquy from the revival of Carousel. It's on UA-cam. It's amazing.
It's so funny because you said "look at her face she looks like me" at 5:57 and when I first started watching you II thought you looked just like her. That's Laura Benanti, she's been in loads of stuff and she has an amazing voice! I'd check out the 2016 She Loves Me Revival!
I know this is a vocal reaction video and meant to analyze the singing and what not but sooooooo much credit for this movie being amazing really goes back to Jonathon Larson being an absolute revolutionary artist. When i think about his story I always end up coming back to the "taken from the world too soon" can you imagine the things he would have done with time and experience. It's heartbreaking but i cherish the works of art he left us with.
Always glad to see more tick tick Boom reactions. This song is a wonderful finale and culmination of all the notes we see him make in the film. Can’t wait for Why, it’s my favorite song in the show.
Yeah, the opening night of Rent was just a thing of beauty. The cast opted to do a sing through to aid in the grieving process rather than cancel the show. I've watched the video from that night and...just chills
I love your videos, I've been watching them for awhile. I love how you break everything down. I meant to write this when you did the first video.... anyways, the reason you don't see Andrew in any other musicals, is, he learned how to sing and dance JUST for this role. The story of how Lin ended up casting him is kind of hilarious (you should look up them talking about it during the promotion of the film), Lin was told that Andrew was a great singer and could dance... Andrew couldn't. So, when Andrew said yes, he kind of hung up the phone and said, oh ****, I've got to find a vocal coach and dance teacher NOW. He learned it all in a little over a year. Zero knowledge to Tick Tick BOOM in one year. You should also absolutely look up the guest appearances in the film for the song Sunday. Everyone in the diner was an icon in Broadway. If you look at the credits of the film, they even list them all under the title of Sunday Legends. Also, Lin didn't write any of this music, this is ALL the music Johnathan wrote for his Musical Tick Tick BOOM, the precursor to RENT. Also, the Jonathan Larson tribute at the film's premiere screening is amazing. I can send you the link to the video if you want.
Actually he’s a trained gymnast so flexibility, choreography and movement wasn’t an issue. He was Spiderman- there are some behind the scene videos that shows shows him doing his own stunts and choreographed fight scenes.
Andrew Garfield really has the audacity to not only be such a passionate and sincere actor, but also an amazing singer. I know nothing about singing, so after having listened to the OBC of Tick Tick Boom and getting used to Raul Esparza's gritty vocals, I was expecting Andrew's to not be as strong but HOLY SH-- And top it all off, he seems like such a genuinely nice and thoughtful human being. Why, Andrew, whyyyyyyyyyyy T_______T
I loved this reaction!!! I was reacting the same way when I watched the movie for the first time. Will you be reacting to the Sextet Montage, Superbia? That's my favorite from this show.
Quick correction, Lin Manuel didn’t write the music, these songs were made by Johnatan when he was writing tick tick boom and though it never hit Broadway the production has actually been done by different theatres. The way they put it together here was to use those songs to tell Johnathans story while also celebrating his music. Lin Manuel directed the movie and coached all of the singers vocally but he himself never actually wrote it.
The guy in the green is Joshua Henry, a really well known Broadway actor. For a real treat, listen to his "Soliloquy" from the 2018 Broadway run of Carousel!
It feels to me that he worked on these simultaneously. There's a references to being in a group of Madrigals in this movie. And "Surface Pressure" has it's own tick tick boom reference. I'm so grateful to have Lin Manuel Miranda in our lives since we lost Larson so early. He would be 62 now. I will say, Andrew has an even better voice. This movie is a treat!
Andrew Garfield spent a year learning to sing for this movie. Not only did he have to learn to sing, he had to learn like Jonathan Larson specifically. I've noticed there's a video of 30/90 sung by Larsen up on youtube and it's fascinating how well Andrew portrayed him. It might be interesting to see a reaction to the songs performed by Larson or maybe one of the compilations of others who have done songs from this musical.
He was actually rushing because he wanted to be just like Sondheim and have released his first musical before turning 30. But it is DEVASTATING he never got to see the success of rent. It is my top favorite Broadway musical. La vie Boheme will forever be my #1 favorite song. And Andrew Garfield surpassed being spiderman and became ABSOLUTE PERFECTION 😍
YES! Idina was in the original CAST of RENT as well as in the movie (The RENT movie)! She was indicated to her first Tony for this role! If you wanna know more about Jonathan's life and about Rent, there's a documentary here on UA-cam worth watching, which is called "no day but today"
I was skeptical of this when I first heard they were doing it. But after watching it, I was blown away! Andrew Garfield became Jonathan Larson! I love that Andrew spent a year or so working on his voice so he could play Jonathan! He did such a good job! "Why" breaks me every single time! Please do a react to Why!
Don't know of I got wrong what you said, but just for the record, all lyrics and songs are original Jonathan's songs. Lin did that slow down thing but only from directorial aspect this time 😉 Either way , I strongly believe that Andrew and Lin deserve all the awards of the world for the detail and respect to that man's work!
Every song in the movie is a Jonathon Larson song. Supposedly, Lin Manual Miranda wanted all the music to come from Larson as a way to really showcase the man’s talent, and make this movie just as much a love letter to him as it is to his work and Rent and musical theater as a whole.
I'm sure someone else already said it, but Andrew lied about knowing how to sing when they called him for the part, and so he took a year to learn how to sing LOL. And he absolutely killed the part!
we hadn't heard him in other musicals because he didn't sing before This movie. Lin Manuel Miranda asked him if he could sing because he thought he would be perfect for this role. he said yes even though he didn't and went to a vocal couch in to learn.
⚠Watch the FULL MOVIE w/screen and audio! Come watch it with me!
👉 bit.ly/3paFFgO
The woman in the blue scarf in the front row that they show, is Jonathan Larson’s sister, and she said that when she was on set watching Andrew she said that it felt like she was spending time with her brother again. As if I didn’t need to cry more about this movie.
Awww that’s so sweet yet so sad. Glad she got to be on set
I'm gon cry again now
@@rocknroll20024 The Larson family is VERY involved with Jonathan's legacy. Both Allan and Nan would go and speak to the different productions, even high schools, thanking them for keeping Jon's memory alive. After they passed it was Jon's sister, Julie who keeps the legacy going.
So technically, he died a few hours after the last dress rehearsal which was also the day of RENT's first off-broadway preview performance. The show was canceled for that night and the cast and crew instead did sing through in memorial. The most crushing part of the story is that he had been having chest pains for days prior and even sought medical attention, but he was misdiagnosed and never got a relatively simple surgery that in all likelihood would have saved his life.
This story is so heartbreaking
Omg that TERRIBLE
What bothers me is that every time he went to the hospital, the ER wrote off his chest pain as food poisoning and showed him the door. Why? He didn’t have insurance and it was obvious he wasn’t a big fish. He wasn’t going to make the hospital any money by treating him.
Perhaps this is a bit morbid, but there’s even a story about Jonathan’s last week or so in a medical journal: “The Journal of Urgent Care Medicine.” The article is called “The Story of Jonathan - One Week in January.” I think this made it into this particular journal because whoever wrote this article is trying to teach its readers how to diagnose someone like Jonathan. That no, you don’t write it off as food poisoning and shove the patient out the door.
@@ElizaHamilton1780 imagine being the doctors that could've saved Jonathan Larson's life but didn't
@@ElizaHamilton1780 yes it is so maddening! If only the doctors did the right thing. We would still have Jonathan Larson!
It's funny because you say "Because this is Lin-Manuel" about that quiet part, but by associating that type of moment with Lin when Jonathan was the composer, you're actually noticing the influence Jonathan had on him as a creator!
Which I wonder why it wasn't known...
4th of february is also jonathan larson’s birthday 🥺
I love that this song illustrates something Andrew Garfield has said in interviews before and after this film was released. We all have unfinished songs. That within us all, we only have a finite amount of time to sing our songs and try to get them out in the world. Dr. Wayne Dyer always said, "Don't let your music die inside of you." What unfinished songs did Jonathan Larson have? That's a big part of the tragedy. But the triumph is what songs he left for all of us as his legacy! Thank you, Jonathan Larson...and Happy Birthday (February 4, 1960 - January 25, 1996)...he would have been 62 today!
Andrew Garfield deserves every award for this musical. Everyone who took one year of music lessons and have to impress Lin-Manuel fucking Miranda definitely deserves all the praise he gets.
(Since I only watched Tick tick boom) Hi Will, please give the Best Actor trophy to Andrew. Thank you.
EACH time he sings "ask the birds" I get chills on my back!
And knowing his Mother passed away before they started filming this just makes me tear up more
Not gonna lie it's my favourite bit of the song. But that's also because I am a massive fan of Bradley Whitford who the camera cuts to in the audience at that point).
I am beyond excited for your reaction to this, this is my favorite song from the whole movie
Same the piano gives me chills
Yup same for me. It's so much better because it's kind of unexpected. We get that final dialogue about what Johnathan did and his impact, and then the narrator (was it Alexandra?) stating he still had "more" to do... all over that piano intro.
Those few notes building up, unexpectedly, to something brilliant.
@@nwc628 I didn't watch all of that, I just know the song. But I did learn that he was behind RENT
@@nwc628 right!! I’m so glad I found my people that love this stuff as much as I do .. one of my other favorite parts in there is when the screen goes into like it’s a video tape and just Joshua and Vanessa sing cages and wings .. oh the chills and now I have In the heights part in the club .. oh Lin lol
@@JSKatsky No worries at all. I kind of avoided musicals for theeeee longest time. I "knew" about the obvious ones, but the first one I really dove into was Hamilton.
Became obsessed for a time lol. Then I saw the praise for this film and decided to put it on one night when I was going to bed. Bad idea... finished it and researched more for hours.
Still haven't seen Rent or really anything else like that, but I'm more than open to suggestions. Guess I was a closet musical fan all along...
Please react to “no more” and “why”! “Why” was recorded and filmed live, which just proves how much more amazing he was and it’s freaking amazing, it makes me cry. Jonathan Larson’s sister was on set that day watching also. “no more” is just amazing in its own way.
yes!! when he sang Why i cryed my eyes out
@@SMC-yq3xh me tooo 😭
@@SMC-yq3xh Me too.
The "Why" performance also took place at the end of the first week of filming because they only had use of the Delacorte Theater location in Central Park for that short window of time. Just think about those circumstances for a moment and it becomes even more clear what a fantastic performance that was. The way Lin tells it in an interview, they got their "Hathaway take" on the second take of filming that scene.
@@Lupin788 “Hathaway take” what’s that? I immediately think of Anne Hathaway 😄🙈
Something people don't talk about enough is that Andrew does have an amazing singing voice and it's insane he's this good after 1year of vocal training but he's also doing this in an accent that isn't the one he usually uses witch is insanely impressive he's incredible 😊
What’s so great thematically about this and 30/90 is it brings Jonathan’s coming-of-age arc to a close. He starts the show dreading his birthday, and by the end embraces it.
This song WRECKS me every time, it’s so good.
Also the fact that Laura Benanti, Christopher Jackson and Judith Light are in the audience…chills.
Not just that. Jonathan Larson's actual sister is in the audience
So, interesting note, the segment of "what does it take, to wake up a generation" was originally written without that high note. So far Andrew is the only person I've heard sing this that's gone high with it
This movie and soundtrack is a perfect circle, if you remember in 30/90 he says "they are singing happy birthday" and in louder that words he end it with the happy birthday song
I'm not that big of a musical fan but I 100% love this film mainly because of how Andrew Garfield can sing and the musicin general. The dude sings as if he's been singing for a long time. His performance is amazing 10/10 performance
The first time I watched this movie I cried my eyes out. Jon Larson gave the world a gift beyond measure with Rent; it’s more than likely that Rent and it’s message saved many LGBT+ lives and gave them hope. I was honestly so heartbroken when I thought about what else he might have given us if he’d had more time. Rent changed my life at 19 years old, and tick tick BOOM did it again at 27. Happy Birthday, Jon; thank you for what you’ve given us. I wish we could have given you more when you were with us.
This is my FAVORITE song from this movie. And it became my favorite song in general. It makes me tear up, and its my favorite song to sing. The line “cages or wings..which do you prefer? Ask the birds” gives me chills. I want to make a tattoo inspired by this song for myself. It changed my life
The entire song makes tears come to my eyes, but my favorite line that always makes me start crying is “if we’re so free, tell me why so many people bleed?”
@@emmybear9740 "if we're so free" is part of the previous lyric
I think it helped that he hadnt sung before and he was just like a fresh ball of clay for the vocal coach to mold whereas singers are harder to break of bad habits and teach new ones because they are so stuck in their ways (like old clay) . I also think that being half British/half American and great with accents helps because he has that ability to change things up and flow between sounds.
I really love Andrew Garfield as an actor, but I love him even more as a singer. This just shows that so many people have talents that we may not know of. I think it’ll be important to keep our eyes open and listen to everyone around us. Because they, too, could go from unheard to your favorite artist/singer. I find it fascinating and eye opening. 💕
Just a little fun fact, Andrew Garfield actually didn’t know how to sing before this role, so he learned how to sing for this role which is amazing ❤️
Lin manuel loved this about him, and said it was to Andrew’s advantage because he had “nothing to unlearn” and “no bad habits” : )
I actually was looking for a comment about this haha... I only discovered this today a couple of hours before seeing this comment
And we should thank the masseuse who said that Andrew “can sing” 😄 when Lin Manuel asked if he knew if Andrew can sing. So he “lied” at first that he can but took some training and gave this amazing performance
I have no idea if it was on purpose, but the fact you posted this on Jonathan Larsons birthday.... Wow it made it extra special
I genuinely got chills and cried a little with the "Happy Birthday" playing on the piano.
Happy birthday Jonathan ❤️ he would be 62 today
So, I'm SURE that someone else has said this, but the reason Garfield hasn't been in a musical before is because he literally learned to sing for this film.
Way I hear it, he was told early on that he can't sing, and had kind of avoided it for most of his life up to this point.
Yess he had said he tried singing but he felt suck so he just continued do an acting theater😩
It might be apocryphal, but I heard something about how he took singing lessons at a young age and the teacher quite rudely told him he couldn’t sing. It humiliated and terrified him, so he never took singing roles until Lin-Manuel Miranda convinced him to give it a go and helped him find his voice.
@@InfernalBanana that teacher must feel like a clown rn
It was drama school. The teacher/professor assigned him a difficult song and then gave him a failing grade instead of encouraging him. So he just believed he can’t sing.
LMM on the other hand thought he could do it. As long as he isn’t tone deaf as he did handle a 7 hour play and didn’t lose his voice.
I wonder how LMM managed to see that he has the potential.
Larson had so many perfect songs. Not only did he make absolutely flawless melodies, but his lyrics were so deep and meaningful. I love listening to his songs over again and focusing on the lyrics and the message. Absolute perfection.
I love your journey trough tick tick boom, is one of my favorites musicals and now movies! This is probably my favorite song, the line "why does it take a catastrophe to start a revolution" always gets me and makes me tear up.
Happy birthday, Jonathan Larson ♥
Hi Audrey! Just wanna share that around 4:28 of this video, you'll see that the woman in the video is Julie Larson, Jonathan's sister and last surviving member of his immediate family. I always start to tear up whenever I see her in the film.
The end always gives me chills. Since the musical starts with Jonathan refusing to turn 30, denying it, questioning his life decisions, him playing “Happy Birthday” at the end shows his acceptance of getting older, albeit after he feels like he has accomplished something with a successful workshop for “Superbia”. After making a name for himself, having a, in his eyes, major accomplishment (not to say it wasn’t major, just that there were likely other accomplishments that he himself undermined and didn’t give due credit), does he feel like he can turn 30. That was his whole point prefacing “30/90”, that his parents did so much by the time they were 30, that he felt that he comparatively had done nothing with his life.
I liked what you said about Andrew not being pigeonholed into being Spider-man anymore. I saw him in 2012 thinking that he was not a recognized actor, and now that he has made a place for himself in the industry, seeing him play Spider-man again in the 2021 movie makes me feel that I can value him properly. He definitely doesn't need the character to be a great actor and a great person
Lin Manuel mentioned that it was really refreshing to coach him to sing since he had no bad singing habits prior him being casted! pretty interesting how voices develop. Andrew and Lin did one heck of a job!!!!!!
How!?! How haven’t you watched this entire masterpiece start to end, like…. At least 8 times already!?! I can’t get enough.
that little happy birthday bit at the end always makes me cry. So gorgeous, and after the whole emotional transcendence of the rest of the song, where it got so loud and suddenly stops. Like Jonathan kinda...
Yes that was Idina Menzel. She was the original Maureen on Broadway. It’s where she got her start. Rent is where a lot of now Stars, got there start. It is horrible that Jonathan died the day before opening. It’s heartbreaking.
You should definitely do “Why” next. Andrew sang and played it live and in two takes(which wasn’t allowed on set cause of Covid) and he absolutely killed it! Definitely one of my top songs from the movie
You need to watch "No Day But Today". It's the story of Johnny Larson, and on the RENT DVD special features. It has a little of Suburbia and Tick, Tick, Boom, and of course a lot of RENT info.
I don't mean to react to it necessarily, but it gives a lot of context and shows why John was so important to musical theater even though he never saw one of his shows on Broadway.
Loved that video !!
That piano happy birthday in the end gets me every time. I’m so sensitive to that that my eyes always rain when I listen to it. I cannot explain.
This scene and song gives me chills every time!
I'm really looking forward to see your reaction to this song! I love the meaning of the lyrics so much! And the energy that Andrew gives to it is magical!
I’m so glad this movie is bringing these incredible songs to light. Back when I was a kid I used to be a performer and this was a song that me and my singing teacher would often sing as a duet during shows, one of my all time favourite songs and now to see it getting mainstream attention is just so great to see!!
The fact that I got teary and goosebumps all over just from watching this reaction video (with pauses)… is a testament of how good Andrew Garfield is 😭❤️❤️ and what a movie!! I hope at this point you’ve watched the movie and loving it ❤️
I can't believe that Im crying even watching it like this and over all without even being a fan, this movie has so much heart it just get to you either way.
Andrew Garfield blew me away in this, he was just enchanting, I couldn't look away.
I always wait for tick tick boom song content again😂
This has been one of my favourite songs for years! So glad you’re reacting to it the song is so important in this day and age lyric wise
I love this song so much, and that bit at the end where it doesn't resolve at the end of 'happy birthday' gives me chills every time!
You should react to Andrew singing "Why." IMO it's his best vocal performance of the movie.
I love all the passion you put into your reactions and commentary!! It makes your videos SO fun to watch!
Happy Birthday, Jonathan Larson ❤
Josh Henry is an incredibly versatile theater monster who's been in all of Lin's of projects. But you should check out his version of Soliloquy from the revival of Carousel. It's on UA-cam. It's amazing.
ua-cam.com/video/i3cmZxPfk6o/v-deo.html
It's so funny because you said "look at her face she looks like me" at 5:57 and when I first started watching you II thought you looked just like her. That's Laura Benanti, she's been in loads of stuff and she has an amazing voice! I'd check out the 2016 She Loves Me Revival!
I know, right?
this song ALWAYS makes my cry so hard, it's crazy🥺
I know this is a vocal reaction video and meant to analyze the singing and what not but sooooooo much credit for this movie being amazing really goes back to Jonathon Larson being an absolute revolutionary artist. When i think about his story I always end up coming back to the "taken from the world too soon" can you imagine the things he would have done with time and experience. It's heartbreaking but i cherish the works of art he left us with.
Always glad to see more tick tick Boom reactions. This song is a wonderful finale and culmination of all the notes we see him make in the film. Can’t wait for Why, it’s my favorite song in the show.
I really hope he gets the Oscar for his portrayal
genuinely hope Andrew Garfield does more musicals 🥺
At the end you said “ and then it rains “ but listen the rains sounds like applause !
1:21 "Now I have not seen this movie"
Me clicking on the video : "You're gonna spoil yourself the ending."
its been over 6 months and I see cry each time I hear this version
This was his first Musical. He took a year to learn how to sing so he was an open book when training for this film!
This and Come to your senses are two of my favorite songs in the movie.
Thank you!! I’m loving your journey through this songs, please, react to “Why”, that moment is so emotional!
This is such a beautiful song and an amazing movie. A love letter to struggling artists who sacrifice everything for their art.❤️
Yeah, the opening night of Rent was just a thing of beauty. The cast opted to do a sing through to aid in the grieving process rather than cancel the show. I've watched the video from that night and...just chills
Nice. I love vanessa's voice
I can never sit through the soundtrack or the movie straight! I always end up crying! Loved the reaction!
RIP and long live Jonathan Larson (February 4, 1960 - January 25, 1996), aged 35
You will always be remembered as a legend.
I love your videos, I've been watching them for awhile. I love how you break everything down. I meant to write this when you did the first video.... anyways, the reason you don't see Andrew in any other musicals, is, he learned how to sing and dance JUST for this role. The story of how Lin ended up casting him is kind of hilarious (you should look up them talking about it during the promotion of the film), Lin was told that Andrew was a great singer and could dance... Andrew couldn't. So, when Andrew said yes, he kind of hung up the phone and said, oh ****, I've got to find a vocal coach and dance teacher NOW. He learned it all in a little over a year. Zero knowledge to Tick Tick BOOM in one year.
You should also absolutely look up the guest appearances in the film for the song Sunday. Everyone in the diner was an icon in Broadway. If you look at the credits of the film, they even list them all under the title of Sunday Legends.
Also, Lin didn't write any of this music, this is ALL the music Johnathan wrote for his Musical Tick Tick BOOM, the precursor to RENT.
Also, the Jonathan Larson tribute at the film's premiere screening is amazing. I can send you the link to the video if you want.
Actually he’s a trained gymnast so flexibility, choreography and movement wasn’t an issue. He was Spiderman- there are some behind the scene videos that shows shows him doing his own stunts and choreographed fight scenes.
PLEASE react to Why from Tick, Tick... Boom! It's such a powerful song AND Andrew performed it live.
The woman in the audience at 5:03 is Jonathan Larson’s real life sister by the way!
JOHNATHAN LARSONS BIRTHDAY IS ACTUALLY TODAY HAPPY BIRTHDAY you would’ve been turning 62 this year and you were taken away from us too soon🥳❤️😭
Andrew Garfield really has the audacity to not only be such a passionate and sincere actor, but also an amazing singer. I know nothing about singing, so after having listened to the OBC of Tick Tick Boom and getting used to Raul Esparza's gritty vocals, I was expecting Andrew's to not be as strong but HOLY SH--
And top it all off, he seems like such a genuinely nice and thoughtful human being. Why, Andrew, whyyyyyyyyyyy T_______T
I loved this reaction!!! I was reacting the same way when I watched the movie for the first time. Will you be reacting to the Sextet Montage, Superbia? That's my favorite from this show.
Quick correction, Lin Manuel didn’t write the music, these songs were made by Johnatan when he was writing tick tick boom and though it never hit Broadway the production has actually been done by different theatres. The way they put it together here was to use those songs to tell Johnathans story while also celebrating his music. Lin Manuel directed the movie and coached all of the singers vocally but he himself never actually wrote it.
2:15 yes it is Idina Menzel, she was the original Maureen in Rent after she do Wicked playing OG Elphaba
This is the song ! The first few lines with the first Why…… my heart strings pulled
The guy in the green is Joshua Henry, a really well known Broadway actor. For a real treat, listen to his "Soliloquy" from the 2018 Broadway run of Carousel!
ANDREW IS SERIOUSLY TALENTED!!!
It feels to me that he worked on these simultaneously. There's a references to being in a group of Madrigals in this movie. And "Surface Pressure" has it's own tick tick boom reference.
I'm so grateful to have Lin Manuel Miranda in our lives since we lost Larson so early. He would be 62 now. I will say, Andrew has an even better voice. This movie is a treat!
this song never fails to make me cry
This is my all time favorite not just musically but lyrically. He was so talented and I’m so sad he couldn’t stick around to write more shows
Andrew Garfield spent a year learning to sing for this movie. Not only did he have to learn to sing, he had to learn like Jonathan Larson specifically.
I've noticed there's a video of 30/90 sung by Larsen up on youtube and it's fascinating how well Andrew portrayed him. It might be interesting to see a reaction to the songs performed by Larson or maybe one of the compilations of others who have done songs from this musical.
He was actually rushing because he wanted to be just like Sondheim and have released his first musical before turning 30. But it is DEVASTATING he never got to see the success of rent. It is my top favorite Broadway musical. La vie Boheme will forever be my #1 favorite song.
And Andrew Garfield surpassed being spiderman and became ABSOLUTE PERFECTION 😍
"He" in the "he has a country" sound is Josh Henry. He was an amazing Burr in the Chicago Hamilton. I saw him and he was incredible!!!
i didnt know he played burr in a hamilton cast, thats amazing! i wish i could have been there, so lucky
You gotta love this movie. They really did jonathan larson and all of his songs justice
You say "since this is Lin Manuel Miranda".... except for one thing, he only directed the movie. The song was written by Jonathan Larson.
this part of the film always gives me goosebumps🥲
It's so wild that this was kinda his FIRST musical since he learned to sing just for this role. I can't even with how incredible he is.
YES! Idina was in the original CAST of RENT as well as in the movie (The RENT movie)! She was indicated to her first Tony for this role! If you wanna know more about Jonathan's life and about Rent, there's a documentary here on UA-cam worth watching, which is called "no day but today"
I was skeptical of this when I first heard they were doing it. But after watching it, I was blown away! Andrew Garfield became Jonathan Larson! I love that Andrew spent a year or so working on his voice so he could play Jonathan! He did such a good job! "Why" breaks me every single time! Please do a react to Why!
Don't know of I got wrong what you said, but just for the record, all lyrics and songs are original Jonathan's songs. Lin did that slow down thing but only from directorial aspect this time 😉
Either way , I strongly believe that Andrew and Lin deserve all the awards of the world for the detail and respect to that man's work!
You need to also react to ‘why’ from tick tick boom. It was filmed live it’s so good
I believe that Louder than words was written by Jonathan Larson, not Lin Manual Miranda
Every song in the movie is a Jonathon Larson song. Supposedly, Lin Manual Miranda wanted all the music to come from Larson as a way to really showcase the man’s talent, and make this movie just as much a love letter to him as it is to his work and Rent and musical theater as a whole.
He died on my birthday, exactly, Im a musician too, connection and the feellllsss
Will you by any chance review ‘Boho Days’?
YESSS i was waiting for you to react to this one
I'm sure someone else already said it, but Andrew lied about knowing how to sing when they called him for the part, and so he took a year to learn how to sing LOL. And he absolutely killed the part!
From what I've read someone (possibly a teacher) told Andrew he wasn't a good singer, so he just didn't before now.
I know you said in this video that this was the last Tick Tick Boom song on your list but I'd love to see you react to Sunday as well!
He has a lot of talent. And to add to that he had Lin-Manuel Miranda as a director. That had to be great :)
Im really Happy that andrew Nominated for best actor for this musical Masterpiece in Oscars
we hadn't heard him in other musicals because he didn't sing before This movie. Lin Manuel Miranda asked him if he could sing because he thought he would be perfect for this role. he said yes even though he didn't and went to a vocal couch in to learn.
Actually Lin found a vocal coach for him. I’m amazed that Lin would trust someone who wasn’t a singer for his directorial debut.
Fun fact: Julie Larson (Jonathan's sister) was in the crowd during this performance, she's shown once or twice during this number
@Jacob Savidant She is his sister, not his mother.
Whoops! My bad! Read it somewhere but didn't quite make sense when I read it! My fault for not checking!