Jennifer Baird can I ask what’s wrong with the video? I’m trying to learn asl sign language but I want to learn the right way. Also do you have any recommendations to any other sources that can help me?
I really want to learn sign language, not because there’s someone that I know is deaf but it’s really beautiful when you meet someone deaf and know a little of their language imagine how happy would they be 💗💗💗
I personally don't know anyone who's deaf but I love to study sign language because it's beautiful and is so fun to learn and might come handy in the future
I'm deaf and even though it was probably unintended, they promoted inncorrct signs for both asl and bsl. I think they should let the people that are well educated in asl/bsl post informative videos for educational purposes.
As a deaf person and an ASL teacher for 13 years, this is wildly inaccurate, and a disservice to our community. I am saddened at the disregard for our culture, and at the lack of response from the channel to take this down as a sign of respect and re-do it accurately with a Deaf person.
I want to learn sign language because I am a server and I would really like to talk to my guests that use it , everyone says how all these videos are wrong , can you help or do you know of help so I won’t go make a complete idiot of myself ? If I have to pay that’s not a problem but I want to step it up and not make people feel out of place .
Thank you all to those who are fluent in sign language to point out the mistakes. I am competely new to sign language and would not have known. Do you know any good sources that I can use to learn propper sign language? Also what is the difference between ASL and BSL?
Take this video down. You are spreading misinformation. I can't believe it's still up after two days, when I've seen thousands of comments from Deaf people and fluent signers, British AND American, telling you how wrong this all is! Really disappointed.
@Medina The Gacha Proxy same I just started the vid and I watched the vid for like 30 seconds and I accidentally went down to the comments section and saw the top comment saying something like THIS IS ALL Wrong which really helped cause I tried to memorize it but when I saw the comment, i stopped.
As a CODA (someone who grew up with deaf parents, and is a native ASL speaker), this video disgusts me. What makes me laugh/cringe the most is the description. “All you need this!” Not this, we don’t.
I am trying to learn sign language, do you think you could tell me which of her signs are wrong? Unfortunately, I don't have any classes available in it where I live, so I have to rely on the internet, but most of the videos I have gone to on ASL have comments (like this one) saying that the signs are all wrong.
@@lelia408 Maybe try joining a group on facebook, I feel like there's less room for misinformation to spread there. UA-cam has a reputation for not dealing with this sort of content effectively.
Reylin i recommend the youtube channel Signed With Heart, she teaches CORRECT asl signs and she shows side views of them and slowed down editions as well to make it easier to learn. hope it helps and good luck signing!
@@vaishnaviindikar757 ua-cam.com/video/v1desDduz5M/v-deo.html all the signs seem right and I am learning then :) hope this helps and plus there so easy!
Please take this down. Many of your signs are incorrect. Historically there has been friction between the Deaf and hearing community because hearing people have been rude and disrespectful and oppressed the Deaf. Your video is miss informing people who are genuinely trying to learn to sign. I am a hearing person with Deaf friends. We want to be able to communicate effectively. But some in the Deaf community would be against me learning because they are afraid of their culture and language being defiled and lost. Videos like this make me see their fears are not as un founded as I had first imagined. Maybe you meant well but many are telling you this video is harmful. Now please listen to them and take it down.
I am trying to learn sign language, do you think you could tell me which of her signs are wrong? Unfortunately, I don't have any classes available in it where I live, so I have to rely on the internet, but most of the videos I have gone to on ASL have comments (like this one) saying that the signs are all wrong.
@@lelia408 most of what she signed was wrong. If you want to learn ASL that's great but the 5 minute hack people are not who you want to learn from. You need to search for channels ran by people who are actually fluent in ASL or you could look for online classes or classes where you live. I think most will say it's best to learn from a deaf person but there are people who aren't deaf that use ASL to communicate as well. My 6 year old son has severe stage 3 autism and is 100% nonverbal. He has never said a single word in his 6 yrs of life which has made communication with him very difficult. He has rejected most alternative ways of communicating until recently. We've been trying to teach him sign language and he's actually starting to use it. We got lucky that my fiance learned ASL when he was growing up because he had a close friend that is deaf so he's been able to teach our son some of the stuff he remembered learning from his friend. Learning to sign is a wonderful thing but you wanna make sure that you learn how to do it the correct way. Signing incorrectly can be very disrespectful.
Well yes, most people came here to learn sign languages. Thank you all for pointing out that this is not a good source though to those who are trying to learn.
Rebekah Covington | I’m also a native ASL speaker. I’m just saying that SOME were right. Most weren’t, but some, a minute minority, were right. Like “sorry,” that’s how I sign that sign in ASL.
Why don’t we just dislike this video as it’s inaccurate. I feel proud of myself now that I always read comments. This is the reason I come to know that it’s incorrect. Thank everyone.
These signs are inaccurate. You need to #takeitdown this is literal trash. This is a disservice for the Deaf and our community. Look at your comments section and delete this disaster. Get actual Deaf people to sign in your video. Stop with the disrespect and get your act together.
I didn't look at the comments before I started memorizing, but I'm glad I saw some other videos before this. I thought something was fishy when the "mother" sign was different from what I've seen.
i am a beginner at asl and i have to say she had almost all of the signs wrong. if anyone is trying to learn American sign language, i recommend the channel Signed With Heart and not this channel. she has side views of the sighs and slowed downs movements for signs to make it easier to learn. Please use that instead of learning the nonsense in this video.
This is terrible! As a CODA I’m super disgusted that you couldn’t bother to check if your signs were correct. Some people are trying to learn and I’ve literally had people come up to me and by gf (who is deaf) and try signing, but their ASL is terrible and impossible to understand, probably because they learned it from you guys...
Are you kidding me? Not only have you switched several signs from ASL to BSL and vice versa, but you also have the "signer" signing a lot of those signs incorrectly. Also, the signer is cleaely neither deaf nor fluent. Take this video down, apologize to the Deaf people of America, Canada, England, and everywhere else. Stick to crafts.
Omg this is soooooo bad! As an asl major, you clearly do not know asl or bsl. You signed mom and dad wrong, and you labeled some asl signs as bsl and vice versa. Hope this video gets taken down.
do you know what else is bad your attitude and your face and she knows a lot more sign language then u ever could so stop commenting things like that since u suvk
As a kid I had what we would call selective mutism, I was not very vulnerable back than. But now here I am talking, reading, and so much more. In a certain kind of way it’s great to learn sign language because if you have a friend that has this or Evan deaf you can ask someone to help ya out with it.
Ty for doIng this video for those interested in Learning ASL. I am stilll learning all I can & have used what you sign here & more with some deaf friends also able to talk to the deaf that come around & sell stuff . It is a awesome feeling to watch others sign,others learning to sign. Me ,I love being able to interpret for others who don't know sign-up wanna talk to these people. May GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS with the best of everything for doing this Video
Incorrect signs used, this is misleading and you’re teaching a language that you obviously don’t even know. I say obviously because you’re signing so many of those words incorrectly. #TakeItDown
Oh wow, I am glad to see these comments, I am a beginner, and trying to learn from from these u tube channels, but how can I know these is wrong if I am a beginner. Can you people out there recommend a good one. Thanks a million!
This video is riddled with errors ! In some cases she mixed up ASL with BSL. Some are signed incorrectly. DO NOT USE THIS VIDEO TO LEARN SIGN LANGUAGE PLEASE. And we do not sign LOL the way she did it
I’m learning sign language. I know how to do Mother,Father,Want,I love you,Thank you,Please. I got so confused I’m like ‘Wait.. Isn’t it this.. *insert mother sign language*’
sameeee and I was already half way through, I just learnt the basics today and when I came to see this I thought I got it all wrong, I checked the comments because it was getting suspicious after the woman in red ended 😂😂
learning asl & motorbike riding. I was not ready for the ' I love you.' haven't heard that without abuse for a while. I picked the wrong path in life but this one right here, feels right.
I've been a big fan of 5-minute crafts till now... I'm shocked that you would do cultural appropriation and with so many mistakes... SMH. Please take this video down and let a Deaf ASL native user and a Deaf native BSL user teach the signs. This goes to show that even with basic signs, hearing non-native signers can get it wrong.
this is all wrong, I just choose it cause its a short video but this is wildly wrong, inaccurate. I studied this when i was younger, and i know this is all wrong.
@Brayden DeafPersonCamo They just said that the video has wrong signs. Did you really have to scream at them, call them a crybaby, call them dumb, call their friends dumb, and say your better at asl/bsl and fortnite than them. That was incredibly rude of you! How did fortnite come to this conversation? Instead of saying that these are correct, you instead say that they're dumb because they said a video was wrong? Please fix your attitude towards the commenter.
As someone who is not fluent in ASL, I'm not aware of which signs are right/wrong. I have seen a few of these signs before in different videos, signed the same. If someone fluent could tell me which signs are correct, it would be much appreciated so that I can learn the correct signs.
I sincerely feel for the deaf and for the mute. Our media is giving so little for them. I know I can make the world a better place, by practicing and learning it myself. Love the video!
No. This video is wrong and you SHOULD NOT be learning from it. If you're wanting to learn sign, use the passion you got wanting to watch this and put it into watch deaf people and learn from them. This video is wrong and you shouldn't learn this video
Quick question. Does it matter if you do the signs with the left or right hand? I am a lefty and have been learning the basics, but noticed that I use my left hand to memorize them.
Hey guys, As a hearing person I am disappointed in the response from the channel after reading the comments section. However, instead of not doing anything we can help take this down by reporting this video as misleading to Google. Pls do this if possible. Let's stop this injustice to our deaf friends! After reporting the video it would be great if u would leave a comment showing your support!
The ones that are completely wrong in ASL: 1:06 1:13 1:32 1:37 1:53 2:07 2:15 2:21 2:53 (you is wrong) 3:15 3:34 5:31 5:36 5:49 I’m 11 and I am not deaf. I have deaf parents and I had to learn ASL to speak to them. You are horrible at sign language. In the way I do it, literally almost the whole section was incorrect. Family was mixed up with BSL and ASL. This is very rude to deaf culture.
Hello, I have a deaf friend and i'm trying to learn ASL to speak to her most of the ASL videos I find have comments saying its all wrong. Could you maybe direct me to a video with the correct ASL. Thank you, Have a good day/night
2 years and this video is this up?? I'm not fluent in asl although I definitely know the basics and all of these were COMPLETELY WRONG!! This is spreading misinformation and totally offensive to the deaf community. This is horrible to see
One big disservice to signing is after how long its been around, it's not been adopted as a true universal language in all countries. It could litteraly be a go to language for interpreters that may not know a certain language somewhere, plus if it where consolidated to the same signs internationally, it would help grow awareness for signing immensely*. I always assumed it was a universal language, but the signing differs from country to country. A universal language, and this can not be stated enough, is supremely overdue. Imagine how it could break barriers so much more quickly not to mention more easily. Sounds like a no brainer eh, but it remaines a mystery why no one has gotten this language consolidated to one basic language. Understanding is the first part in any major positive shift.
I can't know the accuracy of languages used in countries outside of the USA, but for people saying that the ASL was completely inaccurate are wrong. There are "dialects" across the country. I have seen truly deaf people teaching the same signs as shown in this video as well as some variousness.
I actually respect the deaf I'm only 11 but I saw a drive through vs. deaf man and the disrespect that deaf people have to deal with when trying to work so I was like well I feel as if more people should learn sigh language and there should be at least 1 person that knows it in the store/place because it's unfair so I wanted to learn sigh language and I'm glad that I read comments because this was actually a bit disrespectful because people memorize these so they can end up to be incorrect I feel as if a real deaf person should teach sigh language and/or a person who knows correct sigh language
I think only thing wrong is they mix up signs like they did asl family for bsl and they sloppy and got signs wrong most are right for asl I’m pretty sure
Unfortunately, most of her ASL signs are wrong.
o shit
What’s asl?
Olivia (ASL) American Sign Language and (BSL) British Sign Language
TEACH ME 😭😭
@@livs4721 american sign language...
Wtf Guys thanks for These comments I was Just about to start memorizing all of the signs xD
Rasin Dawn what’s wrong with it? I realize some things she did was different from other videos but I thought it was just BSL?
Same
Same
don't copy their sign language video 5 mins magic is sign so many wrongs ways she is not profession!
@@MDgp5dl Yup they are but they didn't said which is ASL AND BSL so she doing almost wrong but I think all ASL they are so wrong.
I'm fluent in ASL. I'm an interpreter and my son is Deaf. Take this down!!!
Can you please tell me what ASL and BSL means? I want to learn sign language and I don't understand anything in this video
@@kpopstan4204 asl= American sign language, bsl= British sign language
Jennifer Baird can I ask what’s wrong with the video? I’m trying to learn asl sign language but I want to learn the right way. Also do you have any recommendations to any other sources that can help me?
the family part in ASL and BSL were incorrect
I’m just learning and she had the G wrong when she did the alphabet. She did it as the p
I really want to learn sign language, not because there’s someone that I know is deaf but it’s really beautiful when you meet someone deaf and know a little of their language imagine how happy would they be 💗💗💗
It's a bad video
Me too
I personally don't know anyone who's deaf but I love to study sign language because it's beautiful and is so fun to learn and might come handy in the future
I’m so glad I looked at the comments before memorizing this
Same, I almost memorized the whole video
I came to this after watching another video on gestures and was so confused
Ik
Me too
I am glad I saw your comment under the video😂
*Thanks for the comments guys* ... Or I would have embarrassed myself in front of my date.
What do you mean, is she or he deaf?
@@arunashinde2462 maybe he wanna show off to her date that
He can speak ASL
Or she is deaf or cannot speak
@@conserztasfia0078 yah, that's what I wanted to ask
wrong signs...someone mixed up ASL (American Sign Language) signs for BSL signs... is this a joke?
May be botched at editing.
They probably just googled everything and used the first result that came up.
What is BSL?
QueenAJ7, British sign language.
My mom ia from England and all her family is in england except one sister. So I find that really cool. Thank you ❤
I'm deaf and even though it was probably unintended, they promoted inncorrct signs for both asl and bsl. I think they should let the people that are well educated in asl/bsl post informative videos for educational purposes.
Love you
Lead on plz I would love to learn all 3 in time
Which were incorrect?
As a deaf person and an ASL teacher for 13 years, this is wildly inaccurate, and a disservice to our community. I am saddened at the disregard for our culture, and at the lack of response from the channel to take this down as a sign of respect and re-do it accurately with a Deaf person.
@@rebekahcovington7116 to be honest no one gives a shit it's a video from a company that makes millions from tricking kids into watching fake stuff
Can u pls help me in learning sign language.mam
Aw :( Can u teach me?
I’m agreeing with you , they should remake this video but with someone that actually understands the deaf culture
I want to learn sign language because I am a server and I would really like to talk to my guests that use it , everyone says how all these videos are wrong , can you help or do you know of help so I won’t go make a complete idiot of myself ? If I have to pay that’s not a problem but I want to step it up and not make people feel out of place .
Thank you all to those who are fluent in sign language to point out the mistakes. I am competely new to sign language and would not have known. Do you know any good sources that I can use to learn propper sign language? Also what is the difference between ASL and BSL?
BSL is British sign language and asl is auslan or American Sign Language I think-
If you want to learn ASL, I good place would be Take Lessons. It’s super helpful for beginners and teaches it fast and easy! :)
@@tryingtomakeapropperuserna3625 whoa whoa whoa whoa!!! WHAT!!!
@@stellastudio3260 WHAT! WHY I HAVE A MY BSL! THAT IS SO EASY!
@@stellastudio3260 yea do you know any group I could join to learn, sorry I'm just seeing this
Take this video down. You are spreading misinformation. I can't believe it's still up after two days, when I've seen thousands of comments from Deaf people and fluent signers, British AND American, telling you how wrong this all is! Really disappointed.
@Medina The Gacha Proxy same I just started the vid and I watched the vid for like 30 seconds and I accidentally went down to the comments section and saw the top comment saying something like THIS IS ALL Wrong which really helped cause I tried to memorize it but when I saw the comment, i stopped.
It's been a year and they still haven't taken it down
Now it’s been an entire year and they haven’t seemed to even have noticed the comments
AJ Noel its been a year! Although im so so glad i read comments like yours
They still kept this video up, wow
I’m so glad I looked at the comments before memorising these 😅
I’m happy I looked at the comets first and did not remember these
Omg me too
I'm fluent in sign language and this is ALL WRONG!!!
Dalaizy awesomeness yea that’s right
Dalaizy awesomeness teach me
I've??? Never seen someone sign like this????
Dalaizy awesomeness same this is like a 1 year old
It’s not all wrong
Just flagged it for "misleading".. glad i read comments. Was trying to learn basic to communicate with a guest at work who is very sweet.
As a CODA (someone who grew up with deaf parents, and is a native ASL speaker), this video disgusts me.
What makes me laugh/cringe the most is the description. “All you need this!” Not this, we don’t.
I am trying to learn sign language, do you think you could tell me which of her signs are wrong? Unfortunately, I don't have any classes available in it where I live, so I have to rely on the internet, but most of the videos I have gone to on ASL have comments (like this one) saying that the signs are all wrong.
CODA = Children Of Deaf Adults?
@@why-gf8lt yes
@@lelia408 Maybe try joining a group on facebook, I feel like there's less room for misinformation to spread there. UA-cam has a reputation for not dealing with this sort of content effectively.
Reylin i recommend the youtube channel Signed With Heart, she teaches CORRECT asl signs and she shows side views of them and slowed down editions as well to make it easier to learn. hope it helps and good luck signing!
As a deaf person myself I just want to congratulate you for embarrassing yourselfs.
Oop
Thank god I read the comments I was actually gonna try to memorize this-
LMFAOO
I am deaf and I confirm that this is inaccurate! Please take this video down.
What's wrong
X the signa are
hey! I really wanna learn sign language, is there any video you can recommend, something that is beginner level and correct..
@@vaishnaviindikar757 ua-cam.com/video/v1desDduz5M/v-deo.html all the signs seem right and I am learning then :) hope this helps and plus there so easy!
I though i am about to learn some thing but I am confused by the comments
I can’t even begin... to describe how incorrect every single sign is
Widdhqjrpeamaziqo6o9180279990321
Please take this down. Many of your signs are incorrect. Historically there has been friction between the Deaf and hearing community because hearing people have been rude and disrespectful and oppressed the Deaf.
Your video is miss informing people who are genuinely trying to learn to sign. I am a hearing person with Deaf friends. We want to be able to communicate effectively. But some in the Deaf community would be against me learning because they are afraid of their culture and language being defiled and lost. Videos like this make me see their fears are not as un founded as I had first imagined.
Maybe you meant well but many are telling you this video is harmful. Now please listen to them and take it down.
I am trying to learn sign language, do you think you could tell me which of her signs are wrong? Unfortunately, I don't have any classes available in it where I live, so I have to rely on the internet, but most of the videos I have gone to on ASL have comments (like this one) saying that the signs are all wrong.
@@lelia408 most of what she signed was wrong. If you want to learn ASL that's great but the 5 minute hack people are not who you want to learn from. You need to search for channels ran by people who are actually fluent in ASL or you could look for online classes or classes where you live. I think most will say it's best to learn from a deaf person but there are people who aren't deaf that use ASL to communicate as well. My 6 year old son has severe stage 3 autism and is 100% nonverbal. He has never said a single word in his 6 yrs of life which has made communication with him very difficult. He has rejected most alternative ways of communicating until recently. We've been trying to teach him sign language and he's actually starting to use it. We got lucky that my fiance learned ASL when he was growing up because he had a close friend that is deaf so he's been able to teach our son some of the stuff he remembered learning from his friend. Learning to sign is a wonderful thing but you wanna make sure that you learn how to do it the correct way. Signing incorrectly can be very disrespectful.
I need to convince my friends to not do any of this...
Do yourself a favor and take this down. It's inaccurate and already has (and will continue to) make a lot of people upset.
Those who did the thumbs-up obviously don’t know sign language
That because some signs she been doing wrong signs
Well yes, most people came here to learn sign languages. Thank you all for pointing out that this is not a good source though to those who are trying to learn.
All incorrect, take this down
Well, I noticed some that were right, at least on the ASL side. I don’t speak BSL, but I assume a lot of them were wrong.
Rebekah Covington | I’m also a native ASL speaker. I’m just saying that SOME were right. Most weren’t, but some, a minute minority, were right. Like “sorry,” that’s how I sign that sign in ASL.
Rebekah Covington | Yes, I agree with all of those examples, though. The social media service signs made me cringe a lot.
@@BreadLoeuf but the i don't understand was wrong ik sign language to and thats not how you typically say it
Zamiya Reese | Yeah, me neither.
Why don’t we just dislike this video as it’s inaccurate. I feel proud of myself now that I always read comments. This is the reason I come to know that it’s incorrect. Thank everyone.
Please remove this video.
@@kayliefenton7115 stfu
Kaylie Fenton Haha... no
Bobby McDonald ughhh cadette step a side and get a job sir
Mimi Whatsupp Uwu this video is incorrect!
Kaylie Fenton no this video provides wrong info
0:35 Don't stop...Keep going....Just like that...yeah!
You mean "stop misinformation!"
These signs are inaccurate. You need to #takeitdown this is literal trash. This is a disservice for the Deaf and our community. Look at your comments section and delete this disaster.
Get actual Deaf people to sign in your video. Stop with the disrespect and get your act together.
Me: Starts watching it
Me: sighs* immediately stops video*
Gg you read comments
Many of the signs in ASL and BSL are wrong!! Take it down!!
I didn't look at the comments before I started memorizing, but I'm glad I saw some other videos before this. I thought something was fishy when the "mother" sign was different from what I've seen.
Stop doing this .. You doing all wrong .. You are very rude about our culture .
i im not good the landon hunt
$
How do u know this is wrobg
its not a culture :)
Ma'am...
@@bmw-owner is there an isue?????
i am a beginner at asl and i have to say she had almost all of the signs wrong. if anyone is trying to learn American sign language, i recommend the channel Signed With Heart and not this channel. she has side views of the sighs and slowed downs movements for signs to make it easier to learn. Please use that instead of learning the nonsense in this video.
What? So wrong video! So many mistskes sign language....
@@rebekahcovington7116 If I report it, what problem will I choose from the list?
nobody's killjoy I dont know
@@asha_sequoia the last one on the chart thing
This is terrible! As a CODA I’m super disgusted that you couldn’t bother to check if your signs were correct. Some people are trying to learn and I’ve literally had people come up to me and by gf (who is deaf) and try signing, but their ASL is terrible and impossible to understand, probably because they learned it from you guys...
Are you kidding me? Not only have you switched several signs from ASL to BSL and vice versa, but you also have the "signer" signing a lot of those signs incorrectly. Also, the signer is cleaely neither deaf nor fluent. Take this video down, apologize to the Deaf people of America, Canada, England, and everywhere else. Stick to crafts.
guys, honestly what did you expect. it's an associate with 5-minute crafts.
Omg this is soooooo bad! As an asl major, you clearly do not know asl or bsl. You signed mom and dad wrong, and you labeled some asl signs as bsl and vice versa. Hope this video gets taken down.
@@rebekahcovington7116 I agree some parts of it is wrong, but it's not culture appropriation...
do you know what else is bad your attitude and your face and she knows a lot more sign language then u ever could so stop commenting things like that since u suvk
@@keliiokalanitauiliili1553 But she is telling the truth. She is spreading misinformation
@@keliiokalanitauiliili1553 as a deaf person. IT OFFEND US, very wrong. it not your place to say it right because you’re not dead. respect us.
@@keliiokalanitauiliili1553 deaf*
I thought ASL and BSL stood for Advanced sign language and Basic sign language. Glad to know better and really interested to learn sign language
This video is inaccurate
ASL mean American Sign Language and BSL mean Britain Sign Language
@@why-gf8lt I know.
Thought it stood for Advanced and Basic before,
But I looked more into it online and now I know better
I am an ASL interpreter, this is incorrect!!! Please learn ASL from a Deaf person or credible source!!!!
Rebekah Covington Shut UP!!!!!
@@xxrubyxx2017 what's your problem? Is this your language that has been taken and made into some token video that teaches incorrect signs?
Thank you!
@@xxrubyxx2017 Stfu kiddo there are people who suffer from inability to talk or to hear and you say "SHUT UP" like wtf
As a kid I had what we would call selective mutism, I was not very vulnerable back than. But now here I am talking, reading, and so much more. In a certain kind of way it’s great to learn sign language because if you have a friend that has this or Evan deaf you can ask someone to help ya out with it.
Look at lifeprint if you wanna learn sign, not this video
Ty for doIng this video for those interested in Learning ASL. I am stilll learning all I can & have used what you sign here & more with some deaf friends also able to talk to the deaf that come around & sell stuff . It is a awesome feeling to watch others sign,others learning to sign. Me ,I love being able to interpret for others who don't know sign-up wanna talk to these people. May GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS with the best of everything for doing this Video
Incorrect signs used, this is misleading and you’re teaching a language that you obviously don’t even know.
I say obviously because you’re signing so many of those words incorrectly.
#TakeItDown
I'm not deaf I'm just tryna communicate with the homies across the classroom.
This is bad
I have just started learning BSL and even I know that’s not the sign for hello.
Oh I'm happy to see this VIDEO!! Thank you fot sharing!!
0:03 wrong at the very start lmao
Dancers: Actually dance but make tiny amounts of money
Tik Tok dancers who become millionares:
Please don’t watch this. THIS IS NOT ASL, as far as the bsl I don’t know. BUT THIS IS NOT ASL!!!!!! Please do not watch.
Let's see if you can do it better
@Brayden DeafPersonCamo What?! You insulted them! That doesn't mean you're better than them!
@@diegoaraujo8521 umm this isn't about them trying to outdo them it's he fact this video is spreading misinformation
Oh wow, I am glad to see these comments, I am a beginner, and trying to learn from from these u tube channels, but how can I know these is wrong if I am a beginner. Can you people out there recommend a good one. Thanks a million!
I’ve only started learning asl and this is completely unacuarate (I support community)
Comments:
99.5% Wrong... TAKE THIS DOWN!!!!
0.49% i want to know sign language
0.01% nice video to teach sign language
Stop being very disrespectful please
@@why-gf8lt welcome to the internet
I know sign language because I am from deaf school this is wrong 😐
Are you from **Insert USA State** School for the Deaf right?
Thanks so much five minute magic
😂😂😂 butch This is completely wrong ASL
Thank GOD a community of ASL people are here! I would have made a fool of myself
This video is riddled with errors ! In some cases she mixed up ASL with BSL. Some are signed incorrectly. DO NOT USE THIS VIDEO TO LEARN SIGN LANGUAGE PLEASE. And we do not sign LOL the way she did it
I was just beginning to learn... thanks a lot guys for the comments
I’m learning sign language. I know how to do Mother,Father,Want,I love you,Thank you,Please. I got so confused I’m like ‘Wait.. Isn’t it this.. *insert mother sign language*’
sameeee and I was already half way through, I just learnt the basics today and when I came to see this I thought I got it all wrong, I checked the comments because it was getting suspicious after the woman in red ended 😂😂
I have ear damages within makes my hearing so harder some of her signs are not right pls DONT do that on deaf people
learning asl & motorbike riding.
I was not ready for the ' I love you.'
haven't heard that without abuse for a while. I picked the wrong path in life but this one right here, feels right.
Thanks to the comments, I almost wanna use this video to learn Sign Language
me: memorizing the signs
mind:plz tell me this is not wrong
me:checks comments
me again:I KNEW IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I've been a big fan of 5-minute crafts till now... I'm shocked that you would do cultural appropriation and with so many mistakes... SMH. Please take this video down and let a Deaf ASL native user and a Deaf native BSL user teach the signs. This goes to show that even with basic signs, hearing non-native signers can get it wrong.
Hello ASL THAT!
Technically this girl has never been seen in five minute crafts by me. But Ik where you are coming from
@@elietayeh2298 the channel is owned by those fake news maker
i was kinda expecting the middle finger. Everyone was thinking it. The whole world knows that one...................
this is all wrong, I just choose it cause its a short video but this is wildly wrong, inaccurate. I studied this when i was younger, and i know this is all wrong.
@Brayden DeafPersonCamo They just said that the video has wrong signs. Did you really have to scream at them, call them a crybaby, call them dumb, call their friends dumb, and say your better at asl/bsl and fortnite than them. That was incredibly rude of you! How did fortnite come to this conversation? Instead of saying that these are correct, you instead say that they're dumb because they said a video was wrong? Please fix your attitude towards the commenter.
Thank you for the comments I am glad I didn’t learn these
She mixed up a bunch of the asl and Bsl signs I am fluent in both so I would know Plus my cousin is deaf
As someone who is not fluent in ASL, I'm not aware of which signs are right/wrong. I have seen a few of these signs before in different videos, signed the same. If someone fluent could tell me which signs are correct, it would be much appreciated so that I can learn the correct signs.
This is disgraceful, if not taken down, I'll talk to 5 min crafts to take this video down.
Lol
0:35 .. its fine.. i get it ..
I sincerely feel for the deaf and for the mute. Our media is giving so little for them. I know I can make the world a better place, by practicing and learning it myself. Love the video!
No. This video is wrong and you SHOULD NOT be learning from it. If you're wanting to learn sign, use the passion you got wanting to watch this and put it into watch deaf people and learn from them. This video is wrong and you shouldn't learn this video
NO DONT USE ANYTHING IN THIS VIDEO ITS MISLEADING
Thanks for helping deaf, I hear but I shall be grateful to you forever bcz u helped many.
No instead the video humiliated many
Quick question. Does it matter if you do the signs with the left or right hand?
I am a lefty and have been learning the basics, but noticed that I use my left hand to memorize them.
Which ever is your dominant hand you use. But you can choose which one, just make sure you stay consistent and use only one hand.
Hey guys,
As a hearing person I am disappointed in the response from the channel after reading the comments section. However, instead of not doing anything we can help take this down by reporting this video as misleading to Google.
Pls do this if possible. Let's stop this injustice to our deaf friends!
After reporting the video it would be great if u would leave a comment showing your support!
#takeitdown this is insulting to anyone who is deaf or trying to learn asl or bsl
As a fully deaf kid watching this- no TAKE THAT DOWN!
#TakeItDown
Amazing another way to talk. Away to communicate. People are beautiful. In all and every way!
All wrong! SHAME ON YOU!
Omg thanks guys I was memorizing these then scrolled
I love this video so much thank you for making it
This isn’t sign language don’t learn this
They did it wrong
They did it wrong. All the signs. PLEASE don’t memorize this.
I'm glad I came to the comments
The ones that are completely wrong in ASL:
1:06
1:13
1:32
1:37
1:53
2:07
2:15
2:21
2:53 (you is wrong)
3:15
3:34
5:31
5:36
5:49
I’m 11 and I am not deaf. I have deaf parents and I had to learn ASL to speak to them. You are horrible at sign language. In the way I do it, literally almost the whole section was incorrect. Family was mixed up with BSL and ASL. This is very rude to deaf culture.
Hello, I have a deaf friend and i'm trying to learn ASL to speak to her most of the ASL videos I find have comments saying its all wrong. Could you maybe direct me to a video with the correct ASL. Thank you, Have a good day/night
Hey! Could u help me to find better sources!
I started learning today! I’ve learnt:
-hello
-bye
-pink
-purple
-and
-cake
-no
-yes
In 30 mins :D
I wrong sign all it WRONG WRONG!!!
you was right sign say no on BSL but same of ASL
2 years and this video is this up?? I'm not fluent in asl although I definitely know the basics and all of these were COMPLETELY WRONG!! This is spreading misinformation and totally offensive to the deaf community. This is horrible to see
It is very good and nice explanation
This is DISGRACEFUL, 5-minute crafts. TAKE IT DOWN.
Let's see if you can do it better so stop criticizing
One big disservice to signing is after how long its been around, it's not been adopted as a true universal language in all countries. It could litteraly be a go to language for interpreters that may not know a certain language somewhere, plus if it where consolidated to the same signs internationally, it would help grow awareness for signing immensely*. I always assumed it was a universal language, but the signing differs from country to country. A universal language, and this can not be stated enough, is supremely overdue. Imagine how it could break barriers so much more quickly not to mention more easily. Sounds like a no brainer eh, but it remaines a mystery why no one has gotten this language consolidated to one basic language. Understanding is the first part in any major positive shift.
YOU ARE SAYING (sort off) MY NAME. MY NAME IS ASLI AND YOUR SAYING ASL LOL
I can't know the accuracy of languages used in countries outside of the USA, but for people saying that the ASL was completely inaccurate are wrong. There are "dialects" across the country. I have seen truly deaf people teaching the same signs as shown in this video as well as some variousness.
Oh my god. That’s so wrong!
This guy need to watch “ A silent sound” to know the importance of sign language
Thank you for your efforts
Please, can you give me a list of static(without movement) words of American Sign Language?
Thank you in advance
This video is bad!
Most of these aren’t signs.
its my pleasure to meet you Victoria
I actually respect the deaf I'm only 11 but I saw a drive through vs. deaf man and the disrespect that deaf people have to deal with when trying to work so I was like well I feel as if more people should learn sigh language and there should be at least 1 person that knows it in the store/place because it's unfair so I wanted to learn sigh language and I'm glad that I read comments because this was actually a bit disrespectful because people memorize these so they can end up to be incorrect I feel as if a real deaf person should teach sigh language and/or a person who knows correct sigh language
I think only thing wrong is they mix up signs like they did asl family for bsl and they sloppy and got signs wrong most are right for asl I’m pretty sure
Rip fluent speakers
So nice good