Right?!?! I so badly wanted to come through my phone at him!! He's disgusting and he's hoping that the bad rap that pitbulls have is enough to win. It wasn't even the pitbulls fault!!!
Wow, the plaintiff said he should have left his wife home?!? He didn't learn!! His son must have been mortified that his own father not only sued his mother-in-law, but still seems to blame her. Not good sir.
@Jayne Hogue No, she was for one outside first... She checked to make sure she was alone. The other person came out after allowing those little dogs to run out without checking to see it was safe. She didn't hold or leash those little dogs. It's not the fault of the pit-bull owner.
@Alfonso Rodríguez For the sake of sustaining the family relationship for her son, damn right that husband of hers needed to be called out on this. His wife has a mind of her own. The wife assessed this situation and expressed her sincere feelings. He was wrong, and that's that...
"Shoulda left his wife at home"? Sounds like he's blaming HER for him losing his case. I feel bad for her, I hope he's not an unkind (ab*sive) husband 😢
Sorry, but, ALL breeders are PsOS…they shorten dog’s life by breeding. You obviously have never given birth-dogs too feel pain birthing. Also, and most importantly, this world is loaded with homeless and sheltered dogs who need loving homes!
@@Aceofwolves Nah, most dogs are good with puppies. They either ignore them or play with them. Their first instinct is not to kill them. The Pit was not "protecting it's home" from a tiny puppy lol. It was simply being a Pit Bull. Genetics. Science is real.
This case should have been thrown out the moment they both said they weren't there. The only eye witness isn't present, why are they there and not the caretaker?
They should have at least had a notarized witness statement from the caregiver. Though, the plaintiff dif evict her, so maybe they knew she wouldn't testify OR that her testimony would exonerate the defendant.
The wife kept throwing her husband under the bus 😂😂😂😂u can see the husband wanted to tell her to shut up! Lol. But the wife was only telling the truth and the husband was only being greedy, just seeing how much money he lost.
Judge Milian: "Was she taking out two puppies, without a leash, to an area that was open?" Plaintiff's wife: "Yes." Judge: "Wow! Your caretaker needs to be talked to." Wife: "Thank you." The subtext there is just enormous. And then later, (8:50) after the Judge rants at the plaintiff, wife says, "Your honor, I happen to have said exactly the same thing to my husband." Wife did not think they should have been in court.
One of my pit mixes (pit and husky) HATES other dogs, but LOVES people, my other pit mix (pit and lab maybe) LOVES other animals and HATES people 🤦🏼♀️ it's super fun lol But we have a fenced in yard, and if another dog came into our yard I know my girl would NOT be happy...and she has that right. This case is sad, and easily could have been avoided!
@@ButtonsCasey some dogs will eventually warm up to a new dog in their pack. This is common when you get a new puppy and have an established dog. They older dog will take the dog in and imprint on it. This can make the dog protective of the new dog
That wife / Plaintiff is awesome! She is an honest, honorable, intelligent, kind and funny person. I have no idea what the hell she is doing with him! lol The defendant also seems honest and kind. It’s an unfortunate situation but the husband and the “caretaker” are the ones at fault.
“I should’ve left her at home”. WHAT!? I audibly GASPED when I heard that. I wish my husband would say, on national television, that he should’ve “left her at home”. Pssh
Guy plaintiff was screwed from the start. His own wife was against him and agreeing with the judge 100 percent. He seems kinda dense tho....like he don't listen to people and don't have sense
The husband has some sort of bizarre / inappropriate relationship with this "caretaker". Something is so off about that dynamic and while the wife clearly thinks she's surplus to requirements, it seems like he doesn't care. It's all about his world and his perspective. He's the kind of man that has never admitted he was wrong about anything. He's the kind of man that thinks, "I'm sorry you feel that way" is a genuine apology. He's the kind of man that is so used to bulldozing the people in his life in order to get what he wants. It's his way or the highway and that mindset will lead to him being verrrrrrry lonely when he's older.
You can tell he wanted to say "what she did wrong was have a pitbull." As if that is an excuse You are responsible for your dog regardless of breed. Its NOT always the pitbull owners fault.
Leave his wife at home.....? His wife is the sane one here. He doesn't like being wrong at all. It's going to destroy so many relationships. Pitbulls are amazing dogs. The person caring for the puppies wasn't caring for them at all.
IT'S COMMON SENSE THING DAD! I HOPE THIs VERDICT WILL GIVE BACK YOUR SENSES. DO NOT RUIN YOUR FAMILY RELATIONSHIP JUST FOR THE SAKE OF PRIDE AND MONEY. MOVE ON! ... and i'm glad i see the humbleness to the defendant. No holding grudges.
I watch these videos to cheer me up somewhat. Of all the people involved I like that Harvey person. He is so pleasant all of the time and always happy and generally cheers things up some.
Come on governments...stop people like this breeding dogs. These poor puppies should naturally have parents to protect them, not morons who do things like this.
Plaintiff wife allowed a caretaker of puppies to be drunk to care for newborn puppies? Sickening. I feel for the defendant. And the plaintiffs' do not know how long they have been married and evict people without talking to each other. Mess.
So they knew they were suing the wrong person? What makes them think they could’ve got that much money for the dogs anyway? The judge should’ve made his wife go stand over with the Defendant.
You can love your pet just as much as another human. It’s not just an ANIMAL! You care for them and love them, it doesn’t hurt any less when they pass for me.
@@pinkosmondfan You better go outside and find another star to make a wish on. Karma might let you come back in your next life as someone’s pet who really doesn’t care that much.!
@@taylorbrickman3872 if it wasn’t the point of the case then the Judge shouldn’t have said it. And in such a hateful tone. It’s not a fact, it’s her opinion. She doesn’t know how everyone in this world feels emotionally about anything.
Being the son’s mother in law has nothing to do with this case . A puppy isn’t going to attack a mature dog, there was no dog fight. Defendant has a vicious dog and should be held at least half responsible for the attack/killing of puppy. In most jurisdictions a vicious dog would be impounded for quarantine and in some cases euthanized .
Plaintiffs did not care about that puppy, they only cared about the potential money they lost…not my kind of people, to say the least(I’m being lame to keep my UA-cam account intact 🙄🙄🙄)!
The male plaintiff is just stubborn. His wife was absolutely the reasonable one.
The judge’s advice was sound. The wife is the smart one!
Gosh, the plaintiff's smug smirk was gross. He didn't give a crap about the puppy, he just saw it as lost money. I hate breeders so much.
Right?!?! I so badly wanted to come through my phone at him!! He's disgusting and he's hoping that the bad rap that pitbulls have is enough to win. It wasn't even the pitbulls fault!!!
And after all that he says “I should’ve left her at home” …when his wife was right! Ya sued the wrong person! 😑
so where is the caretaker today?? why not at court? All the best to you!
Breeders should be outlawed…there are way too many dogs in need of loving homes that live on the streets and in shelters…
They’re property that’s all he can do whatever he wants.
that lady was amazing lol she did not care one bit about her husbands thoughts lol
😂
Honesty and accountability!😇
Lol when her eyes got big so did mine! 😂
My favorite part of this case! 😂😂
Her husband is a total dummy! 😂
Wow, the plaintiff said he should have left his wife home?!? He didn't learn!! His son must have been mortified that his own father not only sued his mother-in-law, but still seems to blame her. Not good sir.
But contradicting him outright makes no sense. She added nothing to the case, just made sure everyone know she thinks her husband is an idiot
So no accountability given to the Pitbull owner whose dog is the one who killed the puppy. make it make sense people
@Jayne Hogue No, she was for one outside first... She checked to make sure she was alone. The other person came out after allowing those little dogs to run out without checking to see it was safe. She didn't hold or leash those little dogs. It's not the fault of the pit-bull owner.
@Alfonso Rodríguez For the sake of sustaining the family relationship for her son, damn right that husband of hers needed to be called out on this.
His wife has a mind of her own. The wife assessed this situation and expressed her sincere feelings. He was wrong, and that's that...
@@apllu17 Some people are flat-out anti-pitbull, regardless of the circumstances.
The plaintiff is gross. "I should have left her at home"
She wishes she married the other guy before you but yet there you are, buddy lol
"Shoulda left his wife at home"? Sounds like he's blaming HER for him losing his case. I feel bad for her, I hope he's not an unkind (ab*sive) husband 😢
That was my thought too. I felt nervous for her watching the end
The Plaintiff is *so smug and arrogant* here. Wow. Just NO shame.
I have a Cavalier King Charles and they are the sweetest dogs! I HATE IRRESPONSIBLE dog owners/breeders!!! He is a POS!!!
I agree. He is a big pile of ****
Sorry, but, ALL breeders are PsOS…they shorten dog’s life by breeding. You obviously have never given birth-dogs too feel pain birthing. Also, and most importantly, this world is loaded with homeless and sheltered dogs who need loving homes!
mine was 1/2 cavalier and 1/2 cocker, i miss her, miss her chasing squirrels
@@mokkamellb6811 😔😔
Love my cavalier ❤
I so badly wanted the plaintiff to walk over and take a seat on the defendant’s side 😂
Kudos’ to you. the wife. He is something else with his response of leaving her home. Awkward overall.
Why wasn’t the plaintiff suing the caretaker? Pit bull is like, “I get blamed for EVERYTHING!!” 😂
Yeah you might get blamed for everything it's the pit bull that killed the puppy
@@jaynehogue2459 the pitbull was protecting ITS home. That's what dogs do.
@@Aceofwolves Nah, most dogs are good with puppies. They either ignore them or play with them. Their first instinct is not to kill them.
The Pit was not "protecting it's home" from a tiny puppy lol. It was simply being a Pit Bull. Genetics. Science is real.
He lost a puppy, a lawsuit, and pretty soon, a wife.
Lost his self respect too
@KrustyKlown I don't thunk he came with any...
Good for her if he does.
This case should have been thrown out the moment they both said they weren't there. The only eye witness isn't present, why are they there and not the caretaker?
Yeah they allow for a lot of hearsay on this show
They should have at least had a notarized witness statement from the caregiver. Though, the plaintiff dif evict her, so maybe they knew she wouldn't testify OR that her testimony would exonerate the defendant.
I think the judge admitted it because the defendant corroborated what they said.
The wife kept throwing her husband under the bus 😂😂😂😂u can see the husband wanted to tell her to shut up! Lol. But the wife was only telling the truth and the husband was only being greedy, just seeing how much money he lost.
Judge Milian: "Was she taking out two puppies, without a leash, to an area that was open?"
Plaintiff's wife: "Yes."
Judge: "Wow! Your caretaker needs to be talked to."
Wife: "Thank you."
The subtext there is just enormous.
And then later, (8:50) after the Judge rants at the plaintiff, wife says, "Your honor, I happen to have said exactly the same thing to my husband."
Wife did not think they should have been in court.
Why didn't he sue the caretaker ??
I should have left my wife at home.....wowza
She should have left him already!
Shows how dumb he is. He said, should have left her home… like that would make a difference. He already lost before the wife spoke. He doesn’t listen.
Shouldn’t he have sued the caretaker because it was her negligence that the dogs died? He’s a piece of work
I love his wife!!! 😂
Dude thinks the wife tanked the case. They didn't have a case.
Yep and had the defendants dog got hurt... She could have countersued
This breaks my heart. Cavaliers are the sweetest dogs. The pit is not to blame either. That caretaker is 100% responsible
One of my pit mixes (pit and husky) HATES other dogs, but LOVES people, my other pit mix (pit and lab maybe) LOVES other animals and HATES people 🤦🏼♀️ it's super fun lol
But we have a fenced in yard, and if another dog came into our yard I know my girl would NOT be happy...and she has that right.
This case is sad, and easily could have been avoided!
How they get along??
@@ButtonsCasey some dogs will eventually warm up to a new dog in their pack. This is common when you get a new puppy and have an established dog. They older dog will take the dog in and imprint on it. This can make the dog protective of the new dog
all irresponsible "adults"
They are suing the wrong person, they should be suing the dog carer who by her negligence got the puppy killed...
Lol major backfire glad his wife was honest
I don't like the plaintiff. He was arrogant as hell. It was his caretakers fault. She should have put them on a leash.
He’s cheating with the care taker!
Doug is a savage 😂
He really is lol 😂😂😂
😂😂
😂😂😂 wow that wife was not letting it lay. She was NOT gonna stand there and listen to her husband lie and embellish. Right is right and good for her.
Dude is an asshole causing family trouble ... family is 1000X more valuable than the $2K he lost.
I would have charged the defendant ~10% contributory negligence for taking her dog off leash before closing the gate.
No. If a dog is in its OWN house and a random dog shows up... It's NOT that person's fault.
They needed to sue the lady who had the puppies, it was her fault.
That wife / Plaintiff is awesome! She is an honest, honorable, intelligent, kind and funny person. I have no idea what the hell she is doing with him! lol The defendant also seems honest and kind. It’s an unfortunate situation but the husband and the “caretaker” are the ones at fault.
“I should’ve left her at home”. WHAT!? I audibly GASPED when I heard that. I wish my husband would say, on national television, that he should’ve “left her at home”. Pssh
Dude is suing the WRONG PERSON ... sue the care taker who feed the puppy to that pitbull.
“you lose, goodbye!” lollll salt in the wound
Defendant should sue the Landlord for Slander , False accusations, and should be penalized for kicking her out illegally.
I can hear judge Judy now. "I don't want to hear the word "basically". 😂
The male defendant doesn't understand ACCOUNTABILITY!
“it’s the case of, what you eatin?!” 💀💀😂
When you give your dog to someone it is THEIR responsibility to keep them safe. NOT a tenant who LIVES there.
Guy plaintiff was screwed from the start. His own wife was against him and agreeing with the judge 100 percent. He seems kinda dense tho....like he don't listen to people and don't have sense
Why are breeders so dense?
The judge is such a smart ass.
Why would you leave your puppies with a drunk 😡
WHY AREN'T THEY SUING THE CARETAKER OF THE PUPPIES?????
The husband has some sort of bizarre / inappropriate relationship with this "caretaker". Something is so off about that dynamic and while the wife clearly thinks she's surplus to requirements, it seems like he doesn't care. It's all about his world and his perspective.
He's the kind of man that has never admitted he was wrong about anything. He's the kind of man that thinks, "I'm sorry you feel that way" is a genuine apology. He's the kind of man that is so used to bulldozing the people in his life in order to get what he wants. It's his way or the highway and that mindset will lead to him being verrrrrrry lonely when he's older.
He said you lost cut an dry! Goodbye !! Lol😂😂😂
He's having an affair with the character. She should be the one being sued.
You can tell he wanted to say "what she did wrong was have a pitbull." As if that is an excuse
You are responsible for your dog regardless of breed. Its NOT always the pitbull owners fault.
Finally a case where the pit bull wins!!! 🐶 A DOG JUST BEING A DOG
No dog eat puppies
They finna argue in the car. 😂
You should've just listened to your wife. If you haven't learned that in 21 years idk what you're gonna learn 😂😂
Why did he bring his wife if she was going to testify against their own case 😂
She may have lost a husband but she gained a best friend (defendant) 😂
Lol the wife wa a looking at him like, “I told you.”
A Pitbull shouldn't be eating puppies for breakfast. That is a dangerous dog and to what extent is children safe from this dog?!
Did Harvey really say this case was called “whatcha eatin” ?!?! Omg!!
Big guy isn’t that bad. He loves his wife I’m sure of that. I pray the peace prevails in this family.
The smug smile on the plaintiffs face says it all.
The looks the wife kept giving her husband made me think she was a bit scared of him. 😐
Leave his wife at home.....? His wife is the sane one here. He doesn't like being wrong at all. It's going to destroy so many relationships.
Pitbulls are amazing dogs. The person caring for the puppies wasn't caring for them at all.
Pitbull chow! Ouch. Shouldn’t have gone to court if the wife was there to sabotage it. Just get a day out and appearance fee.
IT'S COMMON SENSE THING DAD! I HOPE THIs VERDICT WILL GIVE BACK YOUR SENSES.
DO NOT RUIN YOUR FAMILY RELATIONSHIP JUST FOR THE SAKE OF PRIDE AND MONEY. MOVE ON!
... and i'm glad i see the humbleness to the defendant. No holding grudges.
I smell a divorce!
He doesn't deserve her.
Lord have mercy. Judge Milian NEVER lets the litigants answer the questions she asks before cutting them off mid sentence. So aggravating.
I watch these videos to cheer me up somewhat. Of all the people involved I like that Harvey person. He is so pleasant all of the time and always happy and generally cheers things up some.
Come on governments...stop people like this breeding dogs. These poor puppies should naturally have parents to protect them, not morons who do things like this.
Shouldn't he have been suing the caretaker?
They need to sue the care taker
" You lose...goodbye"...lmbo
Remember dog agression is NOT a sign of human agression and APBT pass human tempermalet tests MORE often than labs.
Plaintiff wife allowed a caretaker of puppies to be drunk to care for newborn puppies? Sickening. I feel for the defendant. And the plaintiffs' do not know how long they have been married and evict people without talking to each other. Mess.
Damn!! What an effed up name for this episode.
It would have been interesting to know how old the puppies were.
To be a fly on the wall in their family...
The caretake "is somebody" to somebody
That guy definitely has something going on with the caretaker.
Use me as the
“My Wife’s are ALWAYS right” button
The minute JM hears "pit bull" the case is over.
For good reason
So they knew they were suing the wrong person?
What makes them think they could’ve got that much money for the dogs anyway? The judge should’ve made his wife go stand over with the Defendant.
The lady in leopard print behind the defendant looks very unhappy to be there
Watching this is worse than trying to pull teeth 🙄
He didn't care about the dog. This whole court case was a money grab at least he thought it was going to be
Doug was a beast!!! GOODBYE!!!
Plantiff was like, Say it to my face bucko!!!
“I should have left her at home” 😂
She should have left him at home and gone to the riverboat. 😅
He still tried to say something about her character.
Hate when the judge says “we don’t punish the dogs” yes we do. They get euthanized because of bad owners all the time.
It’s the case of,
“Puppies 🐶in the pit of her stomach!”❌🐕🦺
I can see the plaintiff has a little bit of attitude
You can love your pet just as much as another human. It’s not just an ANIMAL! You care for them and love them, it doesn’t hurt any less when they pass for me.
I hope no one loves a pet as much as a human being. Of course it's just an animal.
@@pinkosmondfan You better go outside and find another star to make a wish on. Karma might let you come back in your next life as someone’s pet who really doesn’t care that much.!
Well that can be true for some but that's not the point of the case. Not trying to be rude, just pointing that out!
@@taylorbrickman3872 if it wasn’t the point of the case then the Judge shouldn’t have said it. And in such a hateful tone. It’s not a fact, it’s her opinion. She doesn’t know how everyone in this world feels emotionally about anything.
@@turdfacey6478 I think she mainly means because in the eyes of the law animals aren't humans. She says that in many of her cases!
Both parties are at fault honestly.
Gee another kill by a pitbull, who would have thought that ? 🤷♂️
Please JM ,why all these loud yelling almost in all Eps.Otherwise i like to watch the Courtshow
IKR. My ears bleed with my air pods 12:35
The wife was obviously not in support of the husband's case. She killed it!!! 😮 They should've collaborated before they left the house
Being the son’s mother in law has nothing to do with this case . A puppy isn’t going to attack a mature dog, there was no dog fight. Defendant has a vicious dog and should be held at least half responsible for the attack/killing of puppy. In most jurisdictions a vicious dog would be impounded for quarantine and in some cases euthanized .
No one said it was a dog fight. They know the pit killed the other dog. The issue the other person irresponsibly let the puppies out without checking
I know they do all those things against the dog when it bites a human. Not so sure it applies to other animals.
@@Possumpat84 It does in some situations.
Nope. When a strange unleashed dog goes onto another dogs property. The dog is NOT at fault for protecting it's OWN property
The dog is not vicious if it is PROTECTING it's OWN house or owner.
Greed
Plaintiffs did not care about that puppy, they only cared about the potential money they lost…not my kind of people, to say the least(I’m being lame to keep my UA-cam account intact 🙄🙄🙄)!
YOU LOSE... GOODBYE!! 😂
I wonder if the husband had an affair with the other tenant who was taking care of the dogs