I'm a passionate Scot from the Lowlands, Lanarkshire to be precise. I've took up learning my native tongue. The tongue I should've been speaking in from the start... And I'm not the only one. Scottish gaelic is on the rise! We should've been taught this at school! Alba an aigh.
@clpro, no worries about the translation, it's still a beautiful piece of music that speaks of an undying spirit of scottish people. Thank you for sharing it with your upload and translation.
@paparossco I was born & raised in Irvine, Ayrshire. I moved to Lanarkshire when I was 17. So, you could say my 'native tongue' is where The Gaels inhabited along with the rest of the West coast of Scotland.
greetings from ireland the bbc or whoever shouldn't have changed the middle verse it captured the feelings of a scottish patriot at the time it was written it was really beautiful to hear the children singing
@clpro That is a good bit off-topic in the context of this song. It was been banned at a cathedral service there (to mark Queen Elizabeth's 80th birthday) .That would rightly (in my view) have been a breach of "international protocol" since Hong Kong had reverted to Chinese rule. It would be a bit like singing the Horst-Wessel song in Germany. I am sure that if the Queen were to visit China it would be , quite rightly, played.
Q: Who is the blond woman singer dressed in black at 1:32 and what kind of music does she sing? Thank you in advance A: Kirsteen MacDonald a word about the subtitles in this video - the BBC isn its wisdom sang the updated post-parlamaid na h-Alba BUT kept the onscreen subtitles as per the Runrig original ? it doesnt make sense to have done that - why did they just not subtitle it as it is sang!
If anyone needs proof that Gaelic was spoken in the lowlands, you just have to look at the place names. Place names may change over time, as language inevitably does through evolution of language, but the basic form of Gaelic words will be there plain to see. It wouldn't take too much work from language experts to work out the origin of place names across scotland. Here in Ireland when the original Ordinance Survey mapped Ireland they changed the Gaelic names to English.
Yes I think a lot of people would be surprised at the Gaelic roots of some of their ancestors. On the other hand I believe my Great Grandfather born in Rothesay was not a Gaelic speaker and had his wife from the Islands not died young, his son (my grandfather) would have been brought up in Paisley as an English speaker. Yet in 1911 his cousin in Greenock lived next to a Gaelic speaker from Lower Dunkeld, A language can be gone from an area in a single generation , sadly.
aggyuvf Daily Record found that the majority of Scottish born and bred people voted Yes and found that it was the 500,000 English population and other people from foreign countries that voted No. The Scots that did vote No, did so to protect their financial assets, you found that people in better off areas voted No because they have so much to lose financially if it goes tits up. BBC survey also found that 66% of Scots would vote Yes if they were guaranteed £1 better off.
I really disagree with the translation of 'an gabh sibh comhnaidh air leth'. The subtitles say 'in the midst of all the Earth' but the Gaelic says 'in which you can take up residence'. I sort of see why they chose the former though because it's an equivalent.
Some BBC ALBA programmes can be viewed by pressing the on demand button with Virgin media or BBC iplayer. I agree with you though, it is an outrage, we pay a licence fee and should have access to all programmes.
Why did you write different words over the original meaning of the words in the song ? The song sings of our seat of government in Edinburgh without the power of authority. Why did you cover that up ? Do you think if people don't hear it said in a song they won't notice it ?
The old lyrics are still relevant, shame the bbc or whoever decided to change them. The beautiful soil of the people still in the hands of the few. - yep I see the Wheels of industry at a standstill. - even more so And the northern lands wasted. - yep The empty house in Edinburgh without Authority or voice. - on many issues it still doesn't... including broadcasting!
I just hope you won't ban us half breeds from coming home. Hate being "English" when I know more about the Scottish side of my family. Love Scotland and wouldn't abuse it like the English lords and lairds did...
@LaFarfalla246 You say "we've always spoke a form of english." but your ancestors couldn't speak a form of English there before the first Anglo-Saxon settlers displaced the aboriginal Britons in the 4th Century. There are no native Gaelic speakers (except incoming Gaels) in the Lowlands now but don't re-write history in an attempt to trivialise its place in Scotland's melting-pot of peoples from many backgrounds.There is nothing wrong with me saying that. :-)
Jesus said 'Father, you give Scots the finest water to make whisky. You give them beautiful mountains, forests and Glens. You've put salmon in their rivers, heather on the moors and a host of other wonderful things. Surely they are the chosen people.' God replied ' Aye maybe, but wait till you see the fucking neighbours their getting!!
so where exactly is dumfries and galloway alonng with most of ayrshire ?? ... Ayr is a Gàidhlig name ... their were over 200,000 Gàidhlig speakers in Scotland in 1901 .... the Gàidhlig language did not die but the british goverments did a good job of trying to kill it by banning it in schools where children were punished harsly for speaking their language.
I know what you mean about the denial. Thing is though, many if not most Gaelic speakers are Presbyterian themselves. Besides, if those Lowlanders actually read the Bible they would see that God gave nations different languages and that all languages will be spoken in heaven.
Sorry guys ......the british national anthem is what you want ........us Scots don't care we have fought long and hard for the UK and it's about time we cut the ties....and moved on so goodbye England!
hey, if you are scottish you must know how the scottish culture was "killed" by english imperialism. The unionists just want to keep more power in their hands!! A independent Scottland would not pay taxes to the brittish monarchy and so on! It can be very beautiful to say that the countries must be united. But the question is that this union was created not because the people of Scotland wanted it; it was created by an England that imposed its culture in Scotland!! And this process is still happening today. The english culture and language are transforming Scotland in the backyard of England. Scottish Gaelic is almost dead, and Scots has each day less speakers too... I am not scottish neither english, actually I live far away from britain. I am brasilian. All that I know from the situation on scotland is from things that I hear about it. Maybe you know more about the problem. But I really think that every people should have its nation and try freedom by itself. So, say yes for an independent scotland!! Or should I say... SAY AYE!!! ;)
![[tvRhk] 2011-11-17 tvRhk就香港版權修訂條例草案之反對書](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kGjUMzRINQ8/mqdefault.jpg)
Damn, that makes me cry and I'm not even Scottish!
I'm a passionate Scot from the Lowlands, Lanarkshire to be precise.
I've took up learning my native tongue. The tongue I should've been speaking in from the start... And I'm not the only one. Scottish gaelic is on the rise!
We should've been taught this at school!
Alba an aigh.
great version of a classic song.
0:00 - 4:17 This Is Where BBC Alba Started Broadcasting For The First Time Ever!
@clpro, no worries about the translation, it's still a beautiful piece of music that speaks of an undying spirit of scottish people. Thank you for sharing it with your upload and translation.
@paparossco
I was born & raised in Irvine, Ayrshire. I moved to Lanarkshire when I was 17. So, you could say my 'native tongue' is where The Gaels inhabited along with the rest of the West coast of Scotland.
Awesome version.
a specially recorded, extended version of ALBA by Paul Mounsey featuring a cast of Gaelic singers including Karen Matheson and Arthur Cormack.
greetings from ireland the bbc or whoever shouldn't have changed the middle verse it captured the feelings of a scottish patriot at the time it was written it was really beautiful to hear the children singing
Thank you a lot
Lovely!
It's ok, like I said I can see why they used that version. It just makes it more accessible to people who don't understand the language.
this makes me so homesick :(
Great idea!
@clpro That is a good bit off-topic in the context of this song. It was been banned at a cathedral service there (to mark Queen Elizabeth's 80th birthday) .That would rightly (in my view) have been a breach of "international protocol" since Hong Kong had reverted to Chinese rule. It would be a bit like singing the Horst-Wessel song in Germany. I am sure that if the Queen were to visit China it would be , quite rightly, played.
Tha misha Subhiart Macaoidh, Borgie. x
Q: Who is the blond woman singer dressed in black at 1:32 and what kind of music does she sing? Thank you in advance
A: Kirsteen MacDonald
a word about the subtitles in this video - the BBC isn its wisdom sang the updated post-parlamaid na h-Alba BUT kept the onscreen subtitles as per the Runrig original ?
it doesnt make sense to have done that - why did they just not subtitle it as it is sang!
Who is the blond woman singer dressed in black at 1:32 and what kind of music does she sing? Thank you in advance
If anyone needs proof that Gaelic was spoken in the lowlands, you just have to look at the place names. Place names may change over time, as language inevitably does through evolution of language, but the basic form of Gaelic words will be there plain to see. It wouldn't take too much work from language experts to work out the origin of place names across scotland. Here in Ireland when the original Ordinance Survey mapped Ireland they changed the Gaelic names to English.
Yes I think a lot of people would be surprised at the Gaelic roots of some of their ancestors. On the other hand I believe my Great Grandfather born in Rothesay was not a Gaelic speaker and had his wife from the Islands not died young, his son (my grandfather) would have been brought up in Paisley as an English speaker. Yet in 1911 his cousin in Greenock lived next to a Gaelic speaker from Lower Dunkeld, A language can be gone from an area in a single generation , sadly.
Freedom for Scotland and The Northern Irish! Neither of us need the Crown!
Ulster and Scotland say British forever
Scotland, just say YES!
We said No. Loser !
aggyuvf Daily Record found that the majority of Scottish born and bred people voted Yes and found that it was the 500,000 English population and other people from foreign countries that voted No. The Scots that did vote No, did so to protect their financial assets, you found that people in better off areas voted No because they have so much to lose financially if it goes tits up.
BBC survey also found that 66% of Scots would vote Yes if they were guaranteed £1 better off.
aggyuvf Btw your wains a shiter.
truefalse Only a Scottish nat could pick on a wean that is 6 months auld you really are the lowest of the low, bet ye support ra Celtic
+Punkarama you were the loser ! bet you wish you could be struck dumb !
@clpro I sang the british national anthem on Remembrance Sunday but I don't understand the point youare making! :-)
I really disagree with the translation of 'an gabh sibh comhnaidh air leth'. The subtitles say 'in the midst of all the Earth' but the Gaelic says 'in which you can take up residence'. I sort of see why they chose the former though because it's an equivalent.
Some BBC ALBA programmes can be viewed by pressing the on demand button with Virgin media or BBC iplayer.
I agree with you though, it is an outrage, we pay a licence fee and should have access to all programmes.
Why did you write different words over the original meaning of the words in the song ? The song sings of our seat of government in Edinburgh without the power of authority. Why did you cover that up ? Do you think if people don't hear it said in a song they won't notice it ?
'S math sin! Tha mi an dochas gun còrd a riut (y)
(Great! I hope you enjoy it)
The old lyrics are still relevant, shame the bbc or whoever decided to change them.
The beautiful soil of the people still in the hands of the few. - yep
I see the Wheels of industry at a standstill. - even more so
And the northern lands wasted. - yep
The empty house in Edinburgh without Authority or voice. - on many issues it still doesn't... including broadcasting!
I just hope you won't ban us half breeds from coming home. Hate being "English" when I know more about the Scottish side of my family.
Love Scotland and wouldn't abuse it like the English lords and lairds did...
@LaFarfalla246 You say "we've always spoke a form of english." but your ancestors couldn't speak a form of English there before the first Anglo-Saxon settlers displaced the aboriginal Britons in the 4th Century. There are no native Gaelic speakers (except incoming Gaels) in the Lowlands now but don't re-write history in an attempt to trivialise its place in Scotland's melting-pot of peoples from many backgrounds.There is nothing wrong with me saying that. :-)
pretty
@clpro That really is btw. Well Off-topic. There is no more to say.
ik most ppl in this vid :D yes i am a scottish gaelic speaker! GAIDHLIG GU BRATH!
Jesus said 'Father, you give Scots the finest water to make whisky. You give them beautiful mountains, forests and Glens. You've put salmon in their rivers, heather on the moors and a host of other wonderful things. Surely they are the chosen people.' God replied ' Aye maybe, but wait till you see the fucking neighbours their getting!!
perhaps, but regardless of that it's not what the line says.
David Hume was Scottish!
is that spain or france?
freedom for scotland
Duncan Ferguson was Scottish!
so where exactly is dumfries and galloway alonng with most of ayrshire ?? ... Ayr is a Gàidhlig name ... their were over 200,000 Gàidhlig speakers in Scotland in 1901 .... the Gàidhlig language did not die but the british goverments did a good job of trying to kill it by banning it in schools where children were punished harsly for speaking their language.
Moran Taing
This song should be used as the athem of Scotland why I'm not sure
I know what you mean about the denial. Thing is though, many if not most Gaelic speakers are Presbyterian themselves. Besides, if those Lowlanders actually read the Bible they would see that God gave nations different languages and that all languages will be spoken in heaven.
💙🤍💙🥰
@TheCastlerankie Sorry yer talkin pish British now and British forever check yer passport
Sorry guys ......the british national anthem is what you want ........us Scots don't care we have fought long and hard for the UK and it's about time we cut the ties....and moved on so goodbye England!
I am NOT Scottish!
Love the song but say NO
no, say YES.
pepa nao quero Nop Just Say NO !
are you scottish?
pepa nao quero Of course i am that's why i'm saying NO, 4 countries 1 flag 1 nation united :)
hey, if you are scottish you must know how the scottish culture was "killed" by english imperialism. The unionists just want to keep more power in their hands!! A independent Scottland would not pay taxes to the brittish monarchy and so on!
It can be very beautiful to say that the countries must be united. But the question is that this union was created not because the people of Scotland wanted it; it was created by an England that imposed its culture in Scotland!!
And this process is still happening today. The english culture and language are transforming Scotland in the backyard of England. Scottish Gaelic is almost dead, and Scots has each day less speakers too...
I am not scottish neither english, actually I live far away from britain. I am brasilian. All that I know from the situation on scotland is from things that I hear about it. Maybe you know more about the problem. But I really think that every people should have its nation and try freedom by itself. So, say yes for an independent scotland!! Or should I say... SAY AYE!!! ;)