It wasn't a bad cover, it's just different from the original. Ed gave the song a new twist and personally I liked it, but I understand that some would prefer the original.
okay so i’ve been scrolling through these comments and it’s honestly irritating me a little bit. ed sheeran doesnt have to match up to hozier’s skill. they’re two completely different artists, different styles, different voices. of course ed is gonna make this song his own and put his own spin on it- he’s a naturally fast singer. the rasp and grain in his voice makes this cover so, so very good. for the people saying that hozier sung this better- OF COURSE HE DID! it’s his song!! this is HOZIER’S song, so of course his version will always be superior no matter what. ed was having fun with this cover. he added his own spins on it, stop hating on something that honestly is irrelevant. just pay attention to his amazing vocals. he twisted the song into his own. he made it much more angry and regretful, where as hozier’s original sounded so much more desperate and soulful. they’re two completely different people. of course ed’s version will sound different.
sunflower seeds ur def right. everyone saying he shouldve copied hoizer,like dude? they prlly dont know the technicalities of singing. i like hoziers better but ed is my man..
I really think the original is better. I love ed but he sounds happy while singing this? Almost doesn't seem like he paid attention to the lyrics of the song. It's supposed to be dark.
Guys its a cover he is meant to put his own spin on it, like be howard singing call me maybe. Covers would be pointless if they where sang the same as the original just with a different voice.
ClassicPork Mmm I can understand what you are saying, because the tempo is upbeat, but I feel the rasp of his voice conveys the pain it should...This is just Ed 100% I love Hozier and I love Ed, two completely different styles, but I love both versions. Even if the tempo is upbeat his rasp does counter the upbeat tempo to help show the pain.
He did faster than the original, but I personally think that's awesome sounds painful and makes me want to cry, I feel the anguish and despair of what occurs in the clip. Ed always killing it
+Gabriele Santos I find that whenever I play guitar slowly, I just feel uncomfortable and I feel the need to play it faster even if the song's not that fast. It's weird, but maybe it's the same thing with Sheeran.
"ed, here, take this cool guitar" "but...i want my guitar." "ed, you can't, we already shot the intro, you can't-" "i want my guitar." (i know this isn't mine but i couldn't find the original one.)
I am seeing a lot of comments saying that Harry or zayn should cover this song and few of the comments appreciating Ed sheeran, so because of that I wanna say this that Ed sheerans voice is amazing!!!💛
Why do people think other commenters who don't share the same opinion as them are automatically 12 year olds who don't know what good music is?! And why do you think you can clarify truly what good music should sound like?! The original AND this cover are both incredibly amazing and sung beautifully by two amazing artists! Ed isn't trying to displace it or make it better, he's simply singing it! If people feel it's better, it's their opinion. And if people don't like it, no one's forcing you to listen to it. Just don't bash on an artist's style for once and either listen to it, or find music that's more your taste. P.s. don't assume a person doesn't know music because of their age... (I am not 12 -.- ... or younger!)
It is rather amusing that among all the pro/against comments, how very few people have actually taken the time to understand the meaning of the song and yet argue about the interpretation.
I know this was a whole ago but I’m literally listening to all Ed’s songs and covers right know Bro people are saying this isn’t good this is amazing the point of a cover is to make it your own not to copy the original singing he’s making it to fit his voice and he sounds so good and the raspy parts just sound so good and raw
right. everyone saying he shouldve copied hoizer uhh like dudes prlly dont know the technicalities of singing. i like the orig better, but ed is my man.
Yes - and the whole point of the song is an objection to the Church's behaviour. With lines like "Worship like a dog, at the shrine of your lies", I don't see how you can conclude it is anything but anti-religious. He is talking about the controlling subjugating nature of religion, whilst the foundations are based on lies and hypocrisy.
Chris Campbell I guess you could view it that way though my view is the song is not anti faith (as in not atheistic), but anti religious. A bit of a fine distinction to make as the church forms the foundation of Christianity. It is a bit like saying to the police that you weren't speeding, but were pressing the gas pedal a bit too much. But distinction at this level is subjective interpretation.
Before I heard the original version, I heard this and Before hearing how slow the original is. I thought this was Ed's song at first, so when I heard the original, I didn't think that guy could lay it down like Ed.
I love how the pianist is so into the music that his body sways with every note. That passion is so infective. Also Ed has such great breath control, I'm taken aback❤️
i miss days when every song used to have lyrisc in comments. Here's one for you: My lover's got humour She's the giggle at a funeral Knows everybody's disapproval I should've worshipped her sooner If the heavens ever did speak She's the last true mouthpiece Every Sunday's getting more bleak A fresh poison each week "We were born sick," you heard them say it My church offers no absolutes She tells me, "Worship in the bedroom." The only heaven I'll be sent to Is when I'm alone with you I was born sick But I love it Command me to be well Aaay. Amen. Amen. Amen. [Chorus 2x:] Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life If I'm a pagan of the good times My lover's the sunlight To keep the Goddess on my side She demands a sacrifice Drain the whole sea Get something shiny Something meaty for the main course That's a fine-looking high horse What you got in the stable? We've a lot of starving faithful That looks tasty That looks plenty This is hungry work [Chorus 2x:] Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife Offer me my deathless death Good God, let me give you my life No Masters or Kings When the Ritual begins There is no sweeter innocence than our gentle sin In the madness and soil of that sad earthly scene Only then I am human Only then I am clean Ooh oh. Amen. Amen. Amen. [Chorus 2x:] Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life
Everyone is talking about how they want Harry or Louis to cover take me to church. Don’t get me wrong I want it too but can we please appreciate Ed’s vocals?
Some people are so annoying. Of course Hozier sang this better,it's his song but that doesn't mean Ed did bad. Ed just covered this song,he's not challenging Hozier,he's just covering a song so stop commenting who sang it better
to all of you morons saying "it's too rushed " He isn't singing karaoke, he's covering a song with his style. Might I add he did a fantastic job, too! :)
I would say each version is different. Ed’s cover still sounds awesome because he packs a lot power and emotion into it, making it catchy. Even though I like it, I still prefer Hozier because he creates this deep gothic yet holy feeling which is achieved through his combination of blues and choir.
Hozier has a higher voice than Ed Sheeran. You can tell Ed is singing at the top of his (chest voice) range here (especially in the chorus). Ambitious vocal for him but the character of Ed's voice shines in his dulcet tones with peaks of power - Thinking out Loud - perfect example.
Interesting considering hozier sings this song in a lower key live. Ed is singing it in the key it was originally composed. I have to hear hoz singing it live in its original key in order to compare. Otherwise I have to assume ed's range is higher than him
I've never heard of Ed Sheeran before, but as a Hozier fan, that was an absolutely brilliant cover (lol, look at me trying to sound British on the BBC channel).
Hozier and Ed.. they both have soft voice that is like a spring weather, one moment it is so still and the next, it gives you an energy rushing through your body. I love both of them. And it is exciting to see one doing other's cover 🤤😪
He posted an image of a blue square on his Instagram and Twitter this morning. :) Also heard that we should be expecting a new album soon. :D (heard all this on Radio 1 this morning)
I think Ed Sheeran, as someone who puts a whole lot of emotion into his own songs and songwriting, knew exactly what the song was about and knew the emotions it was supposed to convey. And of course he managed to convey these emotions through his voice. You can hear the emotion he puts into the song. And just because it sounds slightly more 'cheery' that Hozier's haunting original, doesn't mean that Ed didn't put that emotion in. It's a cover and covers aren't supposed to mimic the original. Ed and Hozier have very different voices, granted. But that doesn't mean that Ed didn't manage to successfully convey the same emotions within the song. He did. It was a great cover. As are all his covers, and songs alike. Does it sound like Hozier's? No. Do they claim it is better than Hozier's? No, rarely does a cover ever achieve that. Does it still carry the same powerful expression of emotion and opinion? Of course it does. An artist, with their own music is always going to be able to express their emotions through the song, the lyrics they write, far better than any cover will. It's their lyrics, their music, their opinions, thoughts and feelings. But that doesn't mean that anyone covering a song can't relate and put raw emotion into the words as well. Ed did a great job and I wish people would stop complaining because it doesn't sound like Hozier's version. If you were expecting Hozier's take on the song, then you probably should have watched his video.
Anyone who says he ruined the song is instantly just saying it because they either don't like Ed Sheeran or he's too poppy for them. Reason being is that it is REALLY similar to the original! except for 2 things: 1) It's not as heavy/chilling and 2) There's not as much emotion in the voice. Everything else is fine. His vocals are on point, especially with "Amen", and instrumentally there isn't anything that stands out as bad. Ed Sheeran, for all his 'poppy' background, is a fantastic musician and singer and I think he's covered it well.
there's really no point in comparing this to the original. both are good, but they have such different voices (styles and pitches) that there's nothing to compare. just enjoy both and respect both of their versions.
I have made a terrible life choice trying to work while listening to two of these live lounges in a row with Ed Sheeran. I just can't stop singing along and dancing. Love that man's voice!
My lover's got humor She's the giggle at a funeral Knows everybody's disapproval I should've worshiped her sooner If the Heavens ever did speak She is the last true mouthpiece Every Sunday's getting more bleak A fresh poison each week "We were born sick", you heard them say it My church offers no absolutes She tells me, "Worship in the bedroom" The only Heaven I'll be sent to Is when I'm alone with you I was born sick, but I love it Command me to be well A-, Amen, Amen, Amen Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life If I'm a pagan of the good times My lover's the sunlight To keep the Goddess on my side She demands a sacrifice Drain the whole sea Get something shiny Something meaty for the main course That's a fine looking high horse What you got in the stable? We've a lot of starving faithful That looks tasty That looks plenty This is hungry work Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife Offer me my deathless death Good God, let me give you my life Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife Offer me my deathless death Good God, let me give you my life No masters or kings when the ritual begins There is no sweeter innocence than our gentle sin In the madness and soil of that sad earthly scene Only then I am human Only then I am clean Oh, oh, Amen, Amen, Amen Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life Take me to church I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife Offer me that deathless death Good God, let me give you my life
honestly i freaked the fck out when i saw this, it's one of my favorite songs and ed singing it is just... i'm speechless. i much prefer the original version, but this is BEAUTIFUL. wow.
Honestly, the most talented artist of the modern day music industry! He has such a genuine passion for music. The fact he can drop into any cover and convey the emotional connection of those songs just proves that!
same, I feel like Ed is trying to make it more happier and cheery, but when Hoizer sings it, you can really feel the emotions, but Ed is a great singer, but I feel like this type of music doesn't suit him.
Karla toledo If you listen to Ed's music there is a LOT of emotion in is songs. Ed's is a cover, cover being the prominent word so he changed it to make it faster. Personally I like them both but it's whatever your opinion is.
Ruined it in my opinion. Ed is talented but this sort of song doesn't suit him, seems like he's trying to make it cheery. Also what makes this song is Hozier's deep vocal power which unfortunately Ed lacks. Shame he did this imo
Shelby Garcia Yes he is, not a big fan as his music is not to my taste (don't love the tone of his voice, despite his voice being good). however I do love some of his songs. Was addicted to A team when it came out. Quite enjoyed + when I had the CD and I love Thinking Out Loud, one of the best songs last year imo. This song just does not suit his voice whatsoever, think he could have chosen a much better cover. I think it would be hard however to find someone who could do a good cover of this song as the way Hozier sings is pretty unique (sorry for the long comment).
Yeah I think Ed is a good singer, but his voice just doesn't work with this song.. he's trying to make the song into something it's not as well. Ruining it a little, in my opinion at least.
Ismael Ybarra We never said that it's different. We said he didn't do a good job about making it different. If a cover is really similar and seems almost a carbon copy it isn't worth listening to. However some people alter songs and make them better or just as good but different. Ed made this song worse and kind of ruined it.
I saw people saying Hozier is much better at this song. Let me tell you something, first of all this song is Hozier's song, which means the way he says things will always come to ears familiar. Second of all, this cover is live lounge, which is live and i have seen couple of performances Hozier made live. He doesn't even sing it on the same tone as the original track. Don't compare live and soundtrack please. Ed Sheeran sings it perfect in my opinion.
I was gonna post something simular.. When you say tone you mean key. And your competly right! I can't find any live performances of Hozier where he performed it in the original key. Ed Sheran does however.
I think Ed Sheeran did a fantastic job of the song. He totally changed it so it worked with his style. Changed it from more dark to a little upbeat. However don't get me wrong Hozier version I love. It has such soulful meaning. And just depth to it. Plus I like that the song is a little dark. I think Hozier version is still better. But Ed Sheeran made the right call to change the tempo and make it into a more upbeat and soulful song, more of his own.
the point of the song is for it to be deep and soulful, to change it to upbeat may as well be a sin considering the message the song was suppose to send
People! Ed is not covering Hozier's song to better than him. He is covering it because he felt a connection with it and wanted to put himself into it, not to one up it's originator. Comparison is the thief of joy, my friends.
All these comments are so harsh ed never said he did it better than hozier he covered it cuz he loved the song so please stop putting this cover down because I'd really like to see any one of you do better.
Personally feel the upbeat tempo does nothing for the song. Much prefer the original but the backing singers were an interesting addition. Giving it a bit of gospel flavour.
mitja klinc Thank you for stating the obvious about the tempo. I am well aware covers do not have to be the same but a difference in tempo can be the making or breaking of a cover, which in my opinion the faster tempo here, as I commented earlier, does nothing for the song.
Lucy Foster On re-listening to both, yeah they are similar but they do set a different feel to the song. This one seemed more joyful while the original is declamatory.
All you have to do is listen to this cover while watching Hozier's music video to realize that Ed either doesn't understand what the song is about or doesn't care. Either way, totally misses the mark. And to those who prefer this because the original is "too dark" might I recommend the song "Everything is awesome" from the Lego movie -- this might be more to your liking
Omg it's an interpretation of a song! Meaning it's not going to sound like the original. Meaning this is the song in Ed's style. All you had to say was, 'I don't like this version'. You didn't have to be rude to everyone lol. This comment section is something else.
It a cover, he's not going to sing it the exact same because he's not them, he's Ed Sheeran. Therefore his going to sing it in his own style. I think he portrays plenty of emotion. You're fully titled to your own opinion but when it's just rude why even bother?
He sang really well but...it was like a lighter version of the original song and couldn't give me goosebumps that I get every single time I listen to the original version.
Guys you should remember one thing: covering is not copying a song completely, it's more unique when you add your identity to it.
And Ed is def doing that. I like the cover, shoulda slowed it down just a notch, but otherwise I love it
Sure, but, lyrics mean something. Do you bebop to they lrics of Take Me To Church? So odd.
Exactly!!!!
Yes!!! Thank you for this comment
Definitely
he can cover any song , can play, can rap and write. multi talented
ikr
+shan He can't rap, but he can sing with a flow XP
+UnknowinglyDerpy Wow, you just went there xD
He defintiely can he is absolutely incredible. Been my favourite singer/songwriter since before he was famous. Such a talented person
+shan great singer...mediocre rapper.
It wasn't a bad cover, it's just different from the original. Ed gave the song a new twist and personally I liked it, but I understand that some would prefer the original.
bro this is way too polite for the youtube world
hawkins jake I know lol, but someone had to say it
I agree with you,even though I prefer the original,I like his cover very much aswell :)
It wasn't great...
im a fan of ed sheeran :) but still go for the original ones.
okay so i’ve been scrolling through these comments and it’s honestly irritating me a little bit.
ed sheeran doesnt have to match up to hozier’s skill. they’re two completely different artists, different styles, different voices. of course ed is gonna make this song his own and put his own spin on it- he’s a naturally fast singer. the rasp and grain in his voice makes this cover so, so very good.
for the people saying that hozier sung this better- OF COURSE HE DID! it’s his song!! this is HOZIER’S song, so of course his version will always be superior no matter what.
ed was having fun with this cover. he added his own spins on it, stop hating on something that honestly is irrelevant. just pay attention to his amazing vocals. he twisted the song into his own. he made it much more angry and regretful, where as hozier’s original sounded so much more desperate and soulful.
they’re two completely different people. of course ed’s version will sound different.
Oh no people are allowed an opinion
It's way to fast though so...
Yeah but do you know that there is such thing as trying -.- he should of at least tried to sound like how the song sounds
Damn fam, you got time
sunflower seeds ur def right. everyone saying he shouldve copied hoizer,like dude? they prlly dont know the technicalities of singing. i like hoziers better but ed is my man..
I've listened to this at least 30 times in the last 2 days, and I have no plans on stopping anytime soon
have you stopped?
bosko aliker no lol
+Al Truist what about now?
Demi's cover was better imo.
Kimber Rhys I see
Ed Sheeran singing Hozier. My life is complete
ikr
Kate Kay RT❤
Kate Kay YEP
Kate Kay you have 1000 likes, looks so nice to see the round number that i'm not clicking it, but you have my like haha
Kate Kay amen
Yo BBC Radio 1 drag Harry Freaking Styles from wherever he is and make him cover this song please
Yeaaas plss
Do it, anyone please do it.
no
@@lili-ox8bf but whyyyy
@@amritasenvaidya5786 because he cannot sing
i honestly would pay big money to see harry styles cover this song
i mean not that i have big money but-
Wth i thought the same thing
exactly, for me, Harry is the best male artist today
dude id take out a loan to pay to see that-
She must have sang the song a little slower
Yessssss
im speechless , i don"t know what to say other than this guy is The man
and i think this is better than the original
am'i the only one who think so ?
I really think the original is better. I love ed but he sounds happy while singing this? Almost doesn't seem like he paid attention to the lyrics of the song. It's supposed to be dark.
Brittney Mars that's the reason why i like this version more
yes, i mean i love Ed but the original is perfection.
It's good but the deep bass is missing
Above the clouds music Why would you want a song without emotion and feeling?
Guys its a cover he is meant to put his own spin on it, like be howard singing call me maybe. Covers would be pointless if they where sang the same as the original just with a different voice.
But it's really awkward when the lyrics are sad and he is happy.
ClassicPork wtf??????
Diet Lam :P the story is really sad, but he sings it like he is happy and chipper.
ClassicPork Mmm I can understand what you are saying, because the tempo is upbeat, but I feel the rasp of his voice conveys the pain it should...This is just Ed 100% I love Hozier and I love Ed, two completely different styles, but I love both versions. Even if the tempo is upbeat his rasp does counter the upbeat tempo to help show the pain.
ClassicPork I understand you, but he's not happy, he's just singing it differently with more energy.
heard about 5 seconds and liked it, total chills, this cover fits him like a glove!
+tinari1 i have no fingers gloves don't fit me
+idontlikemonday did you type that with your nose?
Yeah, bro.
I read 5 seconds and I thought u were talking about 5sos 😆
haha
everyone is saying that they want harry to cover it, but imagine Zayn singing it
I. Would. Pass. Away.
That would be it.
yes but Harry is give the song more meaning , u know ... larry?
that would break the internet
no
I love Ed, but this song is just perfect with Hozier...
I agree.
Agreed.
It's just to fast for a sad song
And Demi Lovato
I definitely agree with you
He did faster than the original, but I personally think that's awesome sounds painful and makes me want to cry, I feel the anguish and despair of what occurs in the clip. Ed always killing it
I totally agree. I hate all the hate saying that he did it too fast.
+Gabriele Santos Totally agree. Sounds truly angry and upset with his tone, so fitting IMO. The way he strums the guitar is so powerful as well.
+Gabriele Santos I find that whenever I play guitar slowly, I just feel uncomfortable and I feel the need to play it faster even if the song's not that fast. It's weird, but maybe it's the same thing with Sheeran.
"ed, here, take this cool guitar"
"but...i want my guitar."
"ed, you can't, we already shot the intro, you can't-"
"i want my guitar."
(i know this isn't mine but i couldn't find the original one.)
hahahaha. it seemed so obvious 😂 he's truly adorable.
thats his guitar though he plays Thinking Out Loud with an electric
Weird seeing him with a PRS
That is one of his guitars
miranda I
hozier's version - angry god
ed's version - cute teddy
Demi Lovato version- The Best version in life
@ no
@@adnanhowlader143 sí
@ no
@@jalenclinton8568 yes
Now i have another excuse to constantly listen to the song, love both versions so much x
my first excuse obviously being that Hozier is magical and the song is beautiful
Harry Seaton Love you!!
Harry Seaton theUKandIreland
I Only love this Version because i Can't handle the gayness of the Other Version..
I Mean the music Video...
I like how his voice can sometimes be very soft and quiet and at other times raspy and strong
I am seeing a lot of comments saying that Harry or zayn should cover this song and few of the comments appreciating Ed sheeran, so because of that I wanna say this that Ed sheerans voice is amazing!!!💛
Love Ed Sheeran but this is not his best, it's like a boy singing happy song XD
Only Ed Sheeran could cover this so brilliantly.
Louis Tomlinson or Harry Styles HAVE to do this cover someday... PLEASE
no.
@@lili-ox8bf why not, love?
Yeahhhh
TOGETHER
@@shelby8137 EXACTLY
A stunning man covers a stunning song
Hannah Cheng⼁♡ might I add to it?
A stunning man with a stunning voice covers a stunning song
Ed is ugly as fuck, but good thing he’s talented.
ElectrikkPaperClipxx rude
EquestrianGirlUla he is tho.
ElectrikkPaperClipxx it isn’t about looks 🙃
It's like the louder eds voice the more raspy it gets. Which is a good thing lol
TheKYRw I agree
he can control it
R RRR he's so talented like Damn
Yea but he can control it
Them cigs get ya.
He is singing so fast i think and Hozier's version is masterpiece!
I mean Hozier made the song so obviously no one can top this song.
@Blue Bid he made it more country like in my opinion.
I agree, for me this song must be slow and when he sang it so fast it jist didn't sound good
@Blue Bid yeah but Hoizer's is definitely better .
He also did it with an acoustic set so he prob did it on purpose to emulate the deep ness
pls harry and louis tomlinson NEED TO COVER THIS SONG😭😭😭😭😭
no
@@lili-ox8bf k
Gosh, you literally stole my words 😭❤️
@@lili-ox8bf stfu and stop spamming everyone’s comment
@@lili-ox8bf oh honey you're everywhere just saying no?
What's your problem?????
Go away
Is there anything, really, anything that this man can not do? HOLY SHIT.
model
If Benedict Cumberbatch can get elected sexiest man alive, I'd say Ed has a chance too.
A backflip.
Ride a horse, whilst doin jum[ping jacks and juggling babies.
Eat a guitar.
love the way the pianist poures his heart in the song at 2:01
Why do people think other commenters who don't share the same opinion as them are automatically 12 year olds who don't know what good music is?! And why do you think you can clarify truly what good music should sound like?! The original AND this cover are both incredibly amazing and sung beautifully by two amazing artists! Ed isn't trying to displace it or make it better, he's simply singing it! If people feel it's better, it's their opinion. And if people don't like it, no one's forcing you to listen to it. Just don't bash on an artist's style for once and either listen to it, or find music that's more your taste. P.s. don't assume a person doesn't know music because of their age... (I am not 12 -.- ... or younger!)
Wow u spoke my mind...
*My life's argument... In a paragraph... MindBlown,*
So ur...13. -_-
It is rather amusing that among all the pro/against comments, how very few people have actually taken the time to understand the meaning of the song and yet argue about the interpretation.
oh, finnaly. SOMEONE WITH BRAINS.
I know this was a whole ago but I’m literally listening to all Ed’s songs and covers right know Bro people are saying this isn’t good this is amazing the point of a cover is to make it your own not to copy the original singing he’s making it to fit his voice and he sounds so good and the raspy parts just sound so good and raw
right. everyone saying he shouldve copied hoizer uhh like dudes prlly dont know the technicalities of singing. i like the orig better, but ed is my man.
It's beautiful and amazing. Ed Sheeran is the man. ❤❤❤❤
This is the reason god made me.... TO LISTEN TO THIS COVER!!!
Ironic given the anti-religious nature of the song ;)
Yes - and the whole point of the song is an objection to the Church's behaviour. With lines like "Worship like a dog, at the shrine of your lies", I don't see how you can conclude it is anything but anti-religious. He is talking about the controlling subjugating nature of religion, whilst the foundations are based on lies and hypocrisy.
Bob Seddigh I reckon it was less anti-religion and more anti-church
don't take it far.. it's a good cover but god didn't make you to listen to this cover. let's be real..😂
Chris Campbell I guess you could view it that way though my view is the song is not anti faith (as in not atheistic), but anti religious.
A bit of a fine distinction to make as the church forms the foundation of Christianity.
It is a bit like saying to the police that you weren't speeding, but were pressing the gas pedal a bit too much.
But distinction at this level is subjective interpretation.
Hmm I think a little too fast
then think slower
Yeah way too fast.
***** that was pretty funny
Before I heard the original version, I heard this and Before hearing how slow the original is. I thought this was Ed's song at first, so when I heard the original, I didn't think that guy could lay it down like Ed.
***** do you think?
Ron Weasley vs. Severus Snape 🤣✌🏼
Severus !😚💞
JAJAJA
Jajajajaja
🤟
😂
I love how the pianist is so into the music that his body sways with every note.
That passion is so infective.
Also Ed has such great breath control, I'm taken aback❤️
I 💕 Ed's voice !
강준범 Maybe in my memory , It's The factor X
Haruna katase Thank you!! :)
i miss days when every song used to have lyrisc in comments.
Here's one for you:
My lover's got humour
She's the giggle at a funeral
Knows everybody's disapproval
I should've worshipped her sooner
If the heavens ever did speak
She's the last true mouthpiece
Every Sunday's getting more bleak
A fresh poison each week
"We were born sick," you heard them say it
My church offers no absolutes
She tells me, "Worship in the bedroom."
The only heaven I'll be sent to
Is when I'm alone with you
I was born sick
But I love it
Command me to be well
Aaay. Amen. Amen. Amen.
[Chorus 2x:]
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
If I'm a pagan of the good times
My lover's the sunlight
To keep the Goddess on my side
She demands a sacrifice
Drain the whole sea
Get something shiny
Something meaty for the main course
That's a fine-looking high horse
What you got in the stable?
We've a lot of starving faithful
That looks tasty
That looks plenty
This is hungry work
[Chorus 2x:]
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife
Offer me my deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
No Masters or Kings
When the Ritual begins
There is no sweeter innocence than our gentle sin
In the madness and soil of that sad earthly scene
Only then I am human
Only then I am clean
Ooh oh. Amen. Amen. Amen.
[Chorus 2x:]
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
ashwin kafle god bless
Nepali ho ni
Goated
❤
this song and his voice are so well suited
+• Snøwflake With A Pen • 卌 THE CLIQUE HAS ARRIVED
aye |-/
hey hey |-/
+• Snøwflake With A Pen • 卌 føund yøu again |-/
|-/
Everyone is talking about how they want Harry or Louis to cover take me to church. Don’t get me wrong I want it too but can we please appreciate Ed’s vocals?
Exactly, this man is something else!
THANK YOU
This one is more upbeat and is more pop-like, and Hozier's is slower and soulful. I like Hozier's better, but this is still a pretty good cover.
well said !
That's right !!
Ed Sheeran isn't a singer.....he's the whole singing industry
Musically demonstrating
And ginger fucking pig whose sold their pants! 🤬🖕
Edsheeren fuivuvivivucù9eeueuueiehehejueoeie9eheiheueie
EDHFUF Ed Sheeran appp shape of you you meed you dont meed shape aisfsiga
I adore the rasp he's got in his voice in this song!
I love how he managed to apply his own style without taking the songs essence away
Some people are so annoying. Of course Hozier sang this better,it's his song but that doesn't mean Ed did bad. Ed just covered this song,he's not challenging Hozier,he's just covering a song so stop commenting who sang it better
I feel like he could've changed it up abit like he's done in the past with other covers. But i ain't even mad bout this. Fuck this lad is a prodigy.
Jake! I was literally about to message you asking if you could cover a hozier song, preferably work song or cherry wine if you already haven't?
JAKEEEE
Jewel Natasha Yes? :)
MrStrato444 Ill see what I can do. Hozier is amazing!
Exactly
I would like Harry Styles to cover it
Queen Queen how bout no
How bout HELL YES?
@@evaheaton702 how about yes?
OMG.! It will be amazing..! 😲🖤
SAME!! They have similar feels to their voices
He is just amazing......no matter what he sings his raspiness in voice is dope
Nobody can do Hozier's songs and make them sound as good as Hozier does..you need Dat Voice.
This comment is so spot on 👏
That’s why it’s a cover.
@@riverboatqueen9411 That’s why it’s not a particularly interesting cover.
to all of you morons saying "it's too rushed " He isn't singing karaoke, he's covering a song with his style. Might I add he did a fantastic job, too! :)
Try listening to it on .75 speed
He sings live faster...i also dont know why
You got that right he is soooo good
I acctually think this is a better version. Though both are brilliant I just love Eds voice.
thank god i'm not the only one
me too
There's no better version than the original one ... It's magical ! This one is too fast !
tim0france
YES...exactly what I thought too. Too fast of a tempo. Hoziers version is more haunting and emotional!
I would say each version is different. Ed’s cover still sounds awesome because he packs a lot power and emotion into it, making it catchy. Even though I like it, I still prefer Hozier because he creates this deep gothic yet holy feeling which is achieved through his combination of blues and choir.
One of my favorite songs covered by one of my favorite artists 👌 😍
his fucking voice dude fucking hell this cover is so good
Hozier has a higher voice than Ed Sheeran.
You can tell Ed is singing at the top of his (chest voice) range here (especially in the chorus). Ambitious vocal for him but the character of Ed's voice shines in his dulcet tones with peaks of power - Thinking out Loud - perfect example.
damn singing is hella complex
sorry! over-analysis?
you´re the man
who the man?
Interesting considering hozier sings this song in a lower key live. Ed is singing it in the key it was originally composed. I have to hear hoz singing it live in its original key in order to compare. Otherwise I have to assume ed's range is higher than him
Whoever wrote the piano music for this cover..... Brilliant.
I've never heard of Ed Sheeran before, but as a Hozier fan, that was an absolutely brilliant cover (lol, look at me trying to sound British on the BBC channel).
+Michael Francis he's the best
You should listen to his music. He does tons of different styles; Pop, Ballard, Rap, and tons more!
+cheese4g Thats surprising that you have never heard of Ed Sheeran before he is amazing and very popular ! been around a lot longer than Hozier
+cheese4g You've "never heard" of the biggest hit in pop since Michael Jackson? Good one. He's the worlds biggest artist.
+UA-camr hahah (y) :)
Everything that he does is perfect. I mean EVERYTHING
Or just a music that he did
lion heart you predicted the future
Yes i just love him❤️❤️❤️
Not EVERYTHING
lion heart yes
This hurts makes my heart ache because it's so fucking beautiful and his voice is so so filled with emotions
So true
Hozier and Ed.. they both have soft voice that is like a spring weather, one moment it is so still and the next, it gives you an energy rushing through your body.
I love both of them. And it is exciting to see one doing other's cover 🤤😪
Sometimes I just forget how talented Ed is and then I click on something like this...
Listen it on 0.75x speed , sounds amazing!
No dude
@@sipotol5255 yes "dude"
SleepADayAway no “”dude””
@@qwertyqwerty4603 no "no ""dude"" " dude
@@willherondale6367 dude, where's my car?
Is it just me that's digging the pianist?
nope.
Yassssssss
ikr
def not just you! rawr!
No. Me too me too. He rocks!
Ed gives me shivers with his voice. Ed Sheeran is a masterpiece.
I swear as soon as Ed Sheeran covers your song it is no longer your song.
that's true
So true
yass cuz Ed Is Slay King💖💖💖
+ogi ogisson That is an excellent comment and very funny. But true.
agreed
MISS HIM SO MUCH
what happened?
Ana Mimi he went on a break last december but he should be coming back soon with some new tracks/an album
Italian food cant cure erectile dysfunction you knob head so fuck of
He posted an image of a blue square on his Instagram and Twitter this morning. :) Also heard that we should be expecting a new album soon. :D (heard all this on Radio 1 this morning)
Jessica Banks HE IS BACK I'M SO HAPPY
That pianist really enjoyed playing during this cover haha. Amen.
This is great done by Ed Sheeran in his own style!!
And greetings to all of you who stand up for him doing so!!
He should be much more famous...
He writes so many fantastic songs
.... I'm, hoping you know he didnt write this.
+Zash of The Kyobi I think he/she was talking about Hozier.
no one can this sing better than hozier himself !! he looked flawless in this song
I think Ed Sheeran, as someone who puts a whole lot of emotion into his own songs and songwriting, knew exactly what the song was about and knew the emotions it was supposed to convey. And of course he managed to convey these emotions through his voice. You can hear the emotion he puts into the song. And just because it sounds slightly more 'cheery' that Hozier's haunting original, doesn't mean that Ed didn't put that emotion in. It's a cover and covers aren't supposed to mimic the original. Ed and Hozier have very different voices, granted. But that doesn't mean that Ed didn't manage to successfully convey the same emotions within the song. He did. It was a great cover. As are all his covers, and songs alike. Does it sound like Hozier's? No. Do they claim it is better than Hozier's? No, rarely does a cover ever achieve that. Does it still carry the same powerful expression of emotion and opinion? Of course it does. An artist, with their own music is always going to be able to express their emotions through the song, the lyrics they write, far better than any cover will. It's their lyrics, their music, their opinions, thoughts and feelings. But that doesn't mean that anyone covering a song can't relate and put raw emotion into the words as well.
Ed did a great job and I wish people would stop complaining because it doesn't sound like Hozier's version. If you were expecting Hozier's take on the song, then you probably should have watched his video.
Man really loved the grove in this version! YEAH ED!
That strum pattern n rythm is amazing-love it
Ed sheeran is my favorite make singer hands down omg!!! That's bae lol jp
Amen. Ed Sheeran resonates plenty ... and this performance did just that. Tiffany Jones Jax XIV *****
I don't wanna put my hand down 🙋🏼🙅🏼
Been mine since before he was famous, he is incredible isn't he :)
Anyone who says he ruined the song is instantly just saying it because they either don't like Ed Sheeran or he's too poppy for them. Reason being is that it is REALLY similar to the original! except for 2 things: 1) It's not as heavy/chilling and 2) There's not as much emotion in the voice. Everything else is fine. His vocals are on point, especially with "Amen", and instrumentally there isn't anything that stands out as bad. Ed Sheeran, for all his 'poppy' background, is a fantastic musician and singer and I think he's covered it well.
I agree with that. He's technically brilliant but lacks emotion and the power of the hozier version.
Can this man get anymore perfect.
gosh i need to see this man perform live.
Ed Sheeran has an amazing range of vocals it's beyond any other artist.
there's really no point in comparing this to the original. both are good, but they have such different voices (styles and pitches) that there's nothing to compare. just enjoy both and respect both of their versions.
Hozier must be proud.
haha
I have made a terrible life choice trying to work while listening to two of these live lounges in a row with Ed Sheeran. I just can't stop singing along and dancing. Love that man's voice!
My lover's got humor
She's the giggle at a funeral
Knows everybody's disapproval
I should've worshiped her sooner
If the Heavens ever did speak
She is the last true mouthpiece
Every Sunday's getting more bleak
A fresh poison each week
"We were born sick", you heard them say it
My church offers no absolutes
She tells me, "Worship in the bedroom"
The only Heaven I'll be sent to
Is when I'm alone with you
I was born sick, but I love it
Command me to be well
A-, Amen, Amen, Amen
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
If I'm a pagan of the good times
My lover's the sunlight
To keep the Goddess on my side
She demands a sacrifice
Drain the whole sea
Get something shiny
Something meaty for the main course
That's a fine looking high horse
What you got in the stable?
We've a lot of starving faithful
That looks tasty
That looks plenty
This is hungry work
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife
Offer me my deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins so you can sharpen your knife
Offer me my deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
No masters or kings when the ritual begins
There is no sweeter innocence than our gentle sin
In the madness and soil of that sad earthly scene
Only then I am human
Only then I am clean
Oh, oh, Amen, Amen, Amen
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
Take me to church
I'll worship like a dog at the shrine of your lies
I'll tell you my sins and you can sharpen your knife
Offer me that deathless death
Good God, let me give you my life
That rasp in his voice defines my existence. 😍
honestly i freaked the fck out when i saw this, it's one of my favorite songs and ed singing it is just... i'm speechless. i much prefer the original version, but this is BEAUTIFUL. wow.
-I miss this ginger teddy bear so much-
Cat Nicole he's back now !!!➗➗
Cat Nicole -hi-
Cat Nicole SAME! BUT HE'S BACK NOW
hey, can you tell what is the code to cut the words like you did?
use: ~~
Louis and Harry need to cover this. Just saying-
YESSSSS💚💙💚💙💚💙💚💙
PLEASE
Guys. watch it in 1.25 speed. its CRAAAAZY good
its so intense
the intro at 1.25 speed and the rest of it is like he's OD'd on coffee! mega good though haha, its unreal
Its shit.
This meme needs to die.
Ed Sheeran today
Ed Sheeran tomorrow
Ed Sheeran forever.
I love the grit Ed gets in his voice during the chorus. I've never heard him sing like that and it is an interesting change.
Honestly, the most talented artist of the modern day music industry! He has such a genuine passion for music. The fact he can drop into any cover and convey the emotional connection of those songs just proves that!
I love the Hoziers version more. I think he sing it more powerful and I could really feel it.
same, I feel like Ed is trying to make it more happier and cheery, but when Hoizer sings it, you can really feel the emotions, but Ed is a great singer, but I feel like this type of music doesn't suit him.
Karla toledo If you listen to Ed's music there is a LOT of emotion in is songs. Ed's is a cover, cover being the prominent word so he changed it to make it faster. Personally I like them both but it's whatever your opinion is.
Ik :)
Ed sings ‘ my lover’s got humour ‘
Me : likes, subscribes , adds to watch later , adds to favourites ... continues watching
Me too❤
LITERLALYMERMEMKJWLAENUJKWLD
U will be disappointed 😢
He's got a fantastic voice, but this is sped up way too much, and it feels like he missed the intent of the song.
thats more than a Little true
Best comment here
True
I absolutely luv this song. I interpreted differently then it was intended. He is amazing when he sings he draws u in.
Ruined it in my opinion. Ed is talented but this sort of song doesn't suit him, seems like he's trying to make it cheery. Also what makes this song is Hozier's deep vocal power which unfortunately Ed lacks. Shame he did this imo
But you have to admit Ed is very talented
Shelby Garcia Yes he is, not a big fan as his music is not to my taste (don't love the tone of his voice, despite his voice being good). however I do love some of his songs. Was addicted to A team when it came out. Quite enjoyed + when I had the CD and I love Thinking Out Loud, one of the best songs last year imo. This song just does not suit his voice whatsoever, think he could have chosen a much better cover. I think it would be hard however to find someone who could do a good cover of this song as the way Hozier sings is pretty unique (sorry for the long comment).
Yeah I think Ed is a good singer, but his voice just doesn't work with this song.. he's trying to make the song into something it's not as well. Ruining it a little, in my opinion at least.
Well of course its different. Its a cover. Why would it be the same?
Ismael Ybarra We never said that it's different. We said he didn't do a good job about making it different. If a cover is really similar and seems almost a carbon copy it isn't worth listening to. However some people alter songs and make them better or just as good but different. Ed made this song worse and kind of ruined it.
I saw people saying Hozier is much better at this song. Let me tell you something, first of all this song is Hozier's song, which means the way he says things will always come to ears familiar. Second of all, this cover is live lounge, which is live and i have seen couple of performances Hozier made live. He doesn't even sing it on the same tone as the original track. Don't compare live and soundtrack please. Ed Sheeran sings it perfect in my opinion.
thank you! 👏
Your welcome :)
Thank you.
Can Dedeoglu WOW,TRUE FAN HERE ~RESPECTED~
I was gonna post something simular.. When you say tone you mean key. And your competly right! I can't find any live performances of Hozier where he performed it in the original key. Ed Sheran does however.
I think Ed Sheeran did a fantastic job of the song. He totally changed it so it worked with his style. Changed it from more dark to a little upbeat. However don't get me wrong Hozier version I love. It has such soulful meaning. And just depth to it. Plus I like that the song is a little dark. I think Hozier version is still better. But Ed Sheeran made the right call to change the tempo and make it into a more upbeat and soulful song, more of his own.
the point of the song is for it to be deep and soulful, to change it to upbeat may as well be a sin considering the message the song was suppose to send
The message was still sent regardless of the tempo. I think it was still dine extremely well. And I still like the original version better.
I like them both, to be honest Ed actually got me into this song but they are both really good!
Just the fact that Harry freaking Styles was so damn close to sing this song
dont it hurts 😭😭
Who the fuck is harry
@@chaeyoung212 😨
@@chaeyoung212 me
@@harryindiano hi Harry
People! Ed is not covering Hozier's song to better than him. He is covering it because he felt a connection with it and wanted to put himself into it, not to one up it's originator.
Comparison is the thief of joy, my friends.
All these comments are so harsh ed never said he did it better than hozier he covered it cuz he loved the song so please stop putting this cover down because I'd really like to see any one of you do better.
his voice at "good god" sent shivers through my spine. gotta love Ed!!!!
I love both Hozier's and Ed's versions, they are both great, please stop hating Ed just because he made a cover in his own way
Personally feel the upbeat tempo does nothing for the song. Much prefer the original but the backing singers were an interesting addition. Giving it a bit of gospel flavour.
it is a cover it is not supposed to be the same tempo
the original has a similar gospel-style backup (which on the recording is also Hozier--his range is ridiculous and he used to sing in Anuna)
mitja klinc Thank you for stating the obvious about the tempo. I am well aware covers do not have to be the same but a difference in tempo can be the making or breaking of a cover, which in my opinion the faster tempo here, as I commented earlier, does nothing for the song.
Lucy Foster On re-listening to both, yeah they are similar but they do set a different feel to the song. This one seemed more joyful while the original is declamatory.
Agreed.
Covers aren't ever about "who's better". Never were.
All you have to do is listen to this cover while watching Hozier's music video to realize that Ed either doesn't understand what the song is about or doesn't care. Either way, totally misses the mark. And to those who prefer this because the original is "too dark" might I recommend the song "Everything is awesome" from the Lego movie -- this might be more to your liking
Omg it's an interpretation of a song! Meaning it's not going to sound like the original. Meaning this is the song in Ed's style. All you had to say was, 'I don't like this version'. You didn't have to be rude to everyone lol. This comment section is something else.
Barbara Just look at the original song's comment section.
haha i love you
It a cover, he's not going to sing it the exact same because he's not them, he's Ed Sheeran. Therefore his going to sing it in his own style. I think he portrays plenty of emotion. You're fully titled to your own opinion but when it's just rude why even bother?
why ya hatin on ed, just go away if it's not angsty enough 4 u
He sang really well but...it was like a lighter version of the original song and couldn't give me goosebumps that I get every single time I listen to the original version.