Witnessed Bon Iver 2 weeks ago in Melbourne, they don't perform, or play to the audience. Instead They've ascended above that level of musicianship to something ethereal. They're playing to someone unseen, each artist completely lost in the moment for over two hours. They don't perform, they devote. And eventually they surface, thank us all for coming out, and walk off the stage. Leaving us feeling so empty and yet so full.
I saw them around the same time as well, and maybe because I've been such a huge fan since a decade and seen pretty much every live show on youtube it was kinda underwhelming.. I really felt like just another live show
To be honest, I wasn't completely impressed by Perth live. This is the first video that I have seen of them doing it live and it was very unlike them to underperform the studio version. They overall seemed not together and under-rehearsed. To give them credit, they are only performing with 3 members when Perth is something like a nine part song.
They used to also tour with a million members, which isn't doing anyone any favors, as no one is making money. That might have something to do with it.
@@inflago I do love this version of Minnesota in this minimal form, Perth without two drummers and the additional musicians doesn't have the same thickness in sound I find.
@@rarecordings5934 True on the Perth statement, it's weird without the super heavy wave of instruments. But that version of Minnesota... holy fuck that's incredible
Anybody knows how he/they are making that kind of overtone/feed tone at 2:43? Is it the guitar? Is it some kind of pre-recorded sample? Or is it something completely different? Thanks in advance!
@@Politicalrobot öncelikle çok teşekkür ederim böyle güzel bir yazıyı yazdığın için, heath ledger'in o kara komedi ve düşüp, parçalanan kötü karekter rol modeli imgeleminin bende etkisi epey var. bu şarkıyla ve benim bu şarkıya denk düşen yaşadıklarımlada ilintili. benim hikayemde de bir kaybetme durumu var, hatta geri dönüşü olmayan bir kayıp belki fiziksel değil ama etkisi aynı belkide daha acı verici :) şimdi hatırlayınca bu şarkı ve sabah odama giren ilk ışıklarla balkonun önündeki limon ağacının yapraklarının rüzgarla savruluşunu... ilk günkü gibi olmasa bile ince bir sızı oluyor kalbimde. bu yazıyı yazarken önerdiğin cover'ı dinliyorum başa alıp. tekrar ve beğeniyorum... hayatımın ne kadar farklı bir yönde olduğunu görüp üzülmek ve mutlu olmak arasında başka bir seçenek olduğunu düşünüp umutlanıyorum.
Even though I love Bon Iver so much it should be recognized that this isn't as good as an overal performance by them, but it's fine, no one's perfect all the time
Witnessed Bon Iver 2 weeks ago in Melbourne, they don't perform, or play to the audience. Instead They've ascended above that level of musicianship to something ethereal. They're playing to someone unseen, each artist completely lost in the moment for over two hours. They don't perform, they devote. And eventually they surface, thank us all for coming out, and walk off the stage. Leaving us feeling so empty and yet so full.
I saw them around the same time as well, and maybe because I've been such a huge fan since a decade and seen pretty much every live show on youtube it was kinda underwhelming.. I really felt like just another live show
Still alive for you, love
Absolutely terrific. This version of Minnesota, WI is just masterful.
this song>>>>>>>>>>>>> every song in history
4:39-8:38 is just pure magic. For the most part I just love the stripped back version of Minnesota, WI performed here.
Thanks Lindsey
i saw these guys in memphis with the same ambience/light show and ill never forget it
I love Bon Iver so much
Perth 🙏 ❤❤❤
MINNESOTA, WI!!!!
que performance lindaa✨
Sounds about as good as it could with just 3 of them..
Interesting
LOVE THE ENDING, ICONIC
I’ve been so into i,i that I forgot all about this album.
I have the opposite problem lol
pure beauty
a lesson of music
아 진짜 지린다
반가운 한국댓글...
Mamma mia...
Anyone know why the full concert was removed from youtube? Might be my favourite performance of all time by anyone.
ua-cam.com/video/esIoysoTqmY/v-deo.html
there you go
Wisconsin guy here. I'll tell Justin the next time I see him. For real.
Even more interesting 🤔
To be honest, I wasn't completely impressed by Perth live. This is the first video that I have seen of them doing it live and it was very unlike them to underperform the studio version. They overall seemed not together and under-rehearsed. To give them credit, they are only performing with 3 members when Perth is something like a nine part song.
It is a different version, I did not like also
They used to also tour with a million members, which isn't doing anyone any favors, as no one is making money. That might have something to do with it.
@@inflago I do love this version of Minnesota in this minimal form, Perth without two drummers and the additional musicians doesn't have the same thickness in sound I find.
@@rarecordings5934 True on the Perth statement, it's weird without the super heavy wave of instruments. But that version of Minnesota... holy fuck that's incredible
Peter Miller they did amazing live version of this in manila
Anybody knows how he/they are making that kind of overtone/feed tone at 2:43? Is it the guitar? Is it some kind of pre-recorded sample? Or is it something completely different? Thanks in advance!
2:43 is kind of quiet - I think just before that is the Les Paul, and after that is a combination of tones
its his fuzz/overdrive pedal
So good i hear this south korea
phd in music
Anybody knows where the full concert has gone!? Seems to be down. Anybody know where we can find it. It is pure gold. Thanks
Joel Tegman m.facebook.com/artetv/videos/10154981520007060/
@@kieranjames514 thank you so much for this reply. I'm very happy to hear this piece of art!
Would really benefit from a second guitar in the mix
What? No. They were obviously going for a more stripped down vibe. Honestly, Justin is best and most creative when there's less instruments.
heathcliff andrew ledger.
🤔
zillerde istanbuldan :)
@@Politicalrobot epey yüklü anısı olan muhteşem bir şarkı :)
hopeless bird heath ledger ile alakası nedir :)
@@Politicalrobot öncelikle çok teşekkür ederim böyle güzel bir yazıyı yazdığın için, heath ledger'in o kara komedi ve düşüp, parçalanan kötü karekter rol modeli imgeleminin bende etkisi epey var. bu şarkıyla ve benim bu şarkıya denk düşen yaşadıklarımlada ilintili.
benim hikayemde de bir kaybetme durumu var, hatta geri dönüşü olmayan bir kayıp belki fiziksel değil ama etkisi aynı belkide daha acı verici :) şimdi hatırlayınca bu şarkı ve sabah odama giren ilk ışıklarla balkonun önündeki limon ağacının yapraklarının rüzgarla savruluşunu... ilk günkü gibi olmasa bile ince bir sızı oluyor kalbimde.
bu yazıyı yazarken önerdiğin cover'ı dinliyorum başa alıp. tekrar ve beğeniyorum... hayatımın ne kadar farklı bir yönde olduğunu görüp üzülmek ve mutlu olmak arasında başka bir seçenek olduğunu düşünüp umutlanıyorum.
Even though I love Bon Iver so much it should be recognized that this isn't as good as an overal performance by them, but it's fine, no one's perfect all the time
I could not disagree more 🖤
Doherty.
Does anyone have the full concert?
beatriz It’s linked in the description on this post. If you’re looking on mobile, you have to pull down the full description
Charles Wallace yes, I saw it but unfortunately the video it's not available anymore at least not for me. Thank you for answering
Rip
Less is more.
As in this a really performance?? Because it's the smallest configuration of his band...
He's awesome but his vocals were awful towards the end
Perth sounds awful. What a disaster... 😖😖😖
Perth here is bad. Let’s admit