Why Does Pakistan Want To Resume Trade With India? | Geopolitical Analysis by Abhijit Chavda
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 бер 2024
- World's Best Masterclass on Geopolitics: Geopolitics From First Principles.
Enroll here - openinapp.link/g8wgn
For business/collaboration, email at business.chavda@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
For Behind The Scenes & Exclusive Content, Join My Whatsapp Channel: whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaDG...
📸Connect online:
INSTAGRAM: abhijitchavda.page.link/Insta...
TWITTER: / abhijitchavda
TELEGRAM: t.me/TheAbhijitChavda
DISCORD: / discord
SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/1WmKYRI...
My gear for shooting this video:
🎙Shure MV7 USB Podcast Microphone: amzn.to/3n1rcme
🎥Logitech C922 Pro Stream Webcam: amzn.to/3ZYyg1G
🎤RØDE Rodecaster Pro II: amzn.to/3Jwo3Cj
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
Support The Channel:
►UPI (G-Pay/PhonePe/Paytm): abhijitchavda@icici
►PayPal: paypal.me/AbhijitChavda
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
✅ Subscribe To My Other UA-cam Channels:-
Abhijit Chavda Clips: @AbhijitChavdaClips
Abhijit Chavda हिंदी (Hindi Channel): @AbhijitChavdaHindi
Abhijit Chavda Vlog: @AbhijitChavda2
Indian Interest (Podcast): @IndianInterest
- - - - - - - - - - - - -
In this video we talk about how the foreign minister of Pakistan has announced that they will look into having trade relations with India.
This is controversial as Pakistan has cut off all business and trade relations with India in 2019. This was done after the revocation of article 370 in Kashmir region. We answer two fundamental questions worth looking into. Why has Pakistan made this offer? And why have they made it now? Right before the general elections of India? We discuss 6 possible scenarios for the motives of Pakistan.
About:
The Abhijit Chavda channel is an expansive library of content that offers insights into geopolitics, contemporary world affairs and history from an Indian perspective.
Abhijit Chavda's unique research-backed worldview has made him one of the strongest voices in the Indian Digital Space, and he has represented India at international forums, including the G20 summit.
Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE and HIT the notification bell to stay up-to-date with the latest videos!
Trusting Pakistan is like…. Crossing mighty river Ganga holding tail of a dog….
🤣🤣🤣super analogy brother
Even dog tail is more reliable than the terroristan.
Not Dog...Suvar kaho...
Can't stop laughing 🤣🤣🤣
Haha😂
If we were under Congress govt we'd already see the PM going to Pakistan to start negotiations for trade.
I'm glad we're under BJP govt!
Not really
Bjp don't want to do again
What vajpayee sir did
@@Ayu____shhhhhwhat he told 🤔
True😅
@@kushagrananda3142 he visited Pakistan for better relation
And then uk
There will be no trade or any relations until all terrorists are dealt with, PoK handed over, GB handed over and ISI dismantled. Else Pak can do trade with China and Afghanistan 😊
It is in India's interest that Pakistan remains economically, politically unstable. It is evident from past that whenever Pakistan starts doing financially well, they continuously support activities to destabilize the internal structure of India.
R&AW must ensure that Pakistan stays busy on the Afghan border, Iran border, in the Balochistan and KP province. The more they stay busy in their internal conflicts, the better it will be for development of India.
But we can't forget that Pakistan has nuclear weapons so if it goes unstable and if those weapons go rogue then that's an issue
True bro 😂
@@rajtibarewala8972 Who told you we don't have a contingency plan for that?
Bhai woh aacha na bhi kare toh atankwadi me paisa lagayege
I thought Pakistan can never use their weapons because if they their is no chance to get money from imf,world bank,America, china . Unka attack unhi ko khtm kr dega
When tummy is empty-Aman ka Cutzspa,trade and business
When tummy is full-Gazwa E Hind.
Well said
Facts,these converts are the most radicalised species on earth 🐖💀
this is the mindset of every Muslim ngl
That is what it says in the asmaani kitab ,kindof@@ad67804
Aman ka cutzspa😂😂😂😂😂😂
No trade with terrorists, period.
No more relations with Garbagistan
Beggaristan
CHUSLAMISTAN 😂
Never Pakistan given the history. We should blockade any goods and services from india
Don't say like that jessa bhi h beta toh India ka hi h
Baccha kitna bhi bhigad jaye rehta toh apna baccha hi h 😂😂😂
Pakistan is learning from Hamas, first get access to India and then attack.
darr gaye kya
@@Azamtariq-gw5qc Han tere bheek mangne ke katore se Darr lagta h
@Azamtariq-gbeing more careful is the correct word. We believe in using our brains rather than our jazba w5qc
@@Azamtariq-gw5qcHaa Bushar Bibi Se...😂
@@Azamtariq-gw5qcha dekh rahe hai gaza mein kiski G phati hai ki ceasefire ke liye chikh rahe hai😂
Well said,
We don't negotiate with terrorists.
They decided to halt trade, now we decide when to consider and restart. Everything won't happen as per their will.
Sure, if u say no, we'll say well we tried...and if u say yes...then that's good for us
Here in Germany, if one asks Pk people where they are from, they usually say that they from India.
True. They hide behind 🇮🇳 or south asia. 😂
Lots of their restaurant are having Indian names
lol
Indian NRI's should wear some form of earrings and have Hindu God shrine in their shop to show off their are authentic Indians. This will tell Non-Indians if someone is actually Indian. And, I said Hindu Gods because Punjabis are also in India and pak
Bruh which Pakistani... apni taraf se Kuch bhi😂
average lahori : if indians stopped trade with pakistan, china should also stop its trade with india....
me as an indian citizen: oh yess...
That is ok. We do not need CCP trade. CCP is also desperate for trade
The influence of Chinese markets on India have been reducing, if this keeps om going India will become self reliant and will be able to openly criticise Chinese policies without worrying much about it's economic interest
Well its it be a huugggeee setback. but india will manage somehow.
@@subham.biswasbruh, u know how much u import from China😂😂
@@legendaryhound5261 Thats why I said a huge setback.
Sincerely hope that Bharat doesn’t trade with Pakistan.
Never forget,
Never forgive.
No trade, no talk no relationship with Pakistan... Period
If india 🇮🇳 starts trade with Pakistan then there must be prior conditions
1) stop terrorism
2) Change indus water treaty according to our need I.e 80% water to India and 20% to Pakistan
3) Open markets in Pakistan for indian companies (So that we will take over their market from cheap Chinese products and make them dependent on us) .
It will be good for our economy as well and this way we can make them dependent on us and when time comes will do adventure in POK 😊
Bruh😂😂...u think by integration in our economy u can take over POK😂😂....if that was the case...China and US would have done it long time ago😂
2025 PoK will be annexed to Republic of India with PoK ppl support PoK ppl not interested with begger pakisthan and it's barbaric adventure in PoK
No relation...no tension
26/11, pulwama, Uri all this have taught us a good lession
Just study mohammad. That is enough to teach a good lesson.
In fact, we have been taught thousands of lessons for 1300 years.
NO TRADE WITH PAKISTAN !
NO FRIENDSHIP WITH ISLAM !
NEVER TRUST MUSLIMS !
@@gauravshah89 Muhammad is himself and uneducated labour, what good it can teach?
India is well off without pak trade, it's not so for pak.
1. Not much vehicular movement, thereby curtails the terror movement.
2.pak's weakened economy , gives them not much leeway to fund terror networks
But Ishaq Dar has to think whether INDIA wants to Trade with Beggeristan??
No Way
JAI SRIRAM
JAI HIND
The title is a statement, not a question, the question mark is superfluous, unless you wanted it to be a question, in which case it should read "Why Does Pakistan Want to Resume Trade with India?".
This Pakistani FM was speaking from London when he said it. Muslims and supporters of Pakistan raised close to 2 billion dollars in London to help Pakistan out after British Government raised Pakistani flag on West Minister Abby. West minister Abby has never raised another country's flag before.
British are the creators of Bikaristan.
Haha-- Why bother whats happening in UK- they are almost bankrupting themselves and joining with right partner haha
Don't go with Newspaper reports.
Pakistani minister never says we want trade relations without Kashmir.
Abhijeet sir first you need to listen what pak minister says. 🙏🙏
He did say that my friend...... Later he backtracked that's a different thing
lol other option is to ignore what they talk and behave as if we don't know what they said.
Russia might not accept them into brics because the Moscow attackers (ISIS-K) are having a link of being trained in Pakistan
Sir, India should say Pakistan to hand over any Indian PoW in Pakistan viz "Missing 54” as a first condition.
No negotiations with terrorists
Indian Govt.pls don't want any trade with Pakistan...
😂😂😂 lmao China
जय शिवराय जय शंभूराजे
It doesn't matter anyone wants
we should not do any trade with terrorists
What Pakistan ? What is Pakistan ? Dont know where is Pakistan. Relations with Balochistan should be improved.
In case of BRICS the US is irrelevant so it's logical to estimate China who advised them to do so because Putin is pro India, and he had talks with Jaishankar recently.
They have stated time and time again that the Chinese are with them and they have always disregarded India on various issues therefore it's logical for India to refuse trade without some Binding Agreements like the one you proposed at the end.
Good Analysis! 🎉
India should establish ties with the Republic of Balochistan
Umm I think, this is more to do with Americans arm twisting Pak's military, and Chinese tactic (for words only) and this is reflected with front face of their minister. Don't think there is any sincerity in this. Expect a mischief, very soon, and use this for a narrative- see "we want to trade, and India is aggressive on us".
India must remember the jawans and the atrocities done in kashmir by Pakistanis
India must remember the Mughal Colonization and how it destroy the Sub-Continent.
@@SuperSky9
Bro forgot about the British Empire 💀
@@_SUPREME_ARCHAILECT_OF_MALAYS Congress still exists. 🤣🤣
@@SuperSky9
What do you mean?
@@_SUPREME_ARCHAILECT_OF_MALAYS The Congress Party has active connections with current British government enough to influence India in favor of foreign powers who themselves are in the pocket of China.
Pok is must if they want to resume trade
Pakistan will never stop trying to be "clever."
Is ki pati hoi hai! Beek mange ko koe ungli nahi kar raha
Jald tootne wala hai
Tension mat leyo bhae logo
Kkkkk
Free Balochistan❤
how is baloch freedom struggle going on?
India will likely trade with free Balochistan
Keep up the good work, dear sir!
Pakistan must give pok back instead of trade.
Will India trade with Pakistan? Will India maintain its pressure on Pakistan continue? Will India have limited trade with Pakistan?
Jihadi organizations grounded due to pressure from India. Will India ease the pressure and provide an environment for them to reactivate?
Will India forget everything?
Trusting Pakistan and it's leaders is like trusting snake that it won't bite again......😂😂 No dialogue ...our response is very loud and clear....We all love you Mr Jayshankar 👏👏💐💐
One more scenario could be that they want to improve relations with India by posturing as peace loving people and also wanting to host the champions trophy under this false grab. As nothing isolates them better when Indian govt refuses permit for cricketer to travel to Pakistan. Also once India has agreed to participate in champions trophy then will also issue lot of visas to Indians to travel to Pakistan mostly youtubers and possibly help in building their image both internationally and withhin India. Free PR
Bhai ek baar ko unki government sudhar Sakti hai per unki army kabhi nhi sudhregi #nomercy
I don't think India will bother on point 2.
Yes they are becoz no food in tummy and head is bummy.
But let them be on their own for a while until Baloch, Afghan and Sindh take their territories and Bharat takes POK, G&B.
With whatever left start, trade 👍🏽
What makes u think that Sindh and Balochistan will seperate and India will take PoK😂😂...sweet dreams....seedha seedha jawab do trade karna ha ya Nahi....na khud time zaya Karo...na hamara time zaya karo
@@legendaryhound5261nhi krna. China ke pass ja krne trade. POK le bhi lenge toh kuch kr nhi paoge.
@legendaryhound5261 do you think Bharat needs to trade with Pakistan in this whole world? What do we get? Kachha and Pyaaz ??
No sorry, put the pyaz in your kaccha and be acha bacha with lahori churan in mouth.
Good Explanation Sir.
Even good politicians of Pakistan cannot help them, too much damage already done
How about their British billionaire friends help them??????
To rehabilitate Pakistan wants to restore trade with India to improve its international image.Pakistan is restless not able to resume terrorism in Kashmir.This is possible if India starts trading through Kashmir border so that slowly he is able to infiltrate pojk radicalised Kashmiris in to India Kashmir.
NO RELATIONS & NO TRADES WITH PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 FIRST KASHMIR THEN OTHER TALKS.
Excellent analysis, you have covered all the points. India has changed a lot in the last 10 years and will not succumb to the gimmick.
I think second reason is there Pakistan knows that not going to happen but just making there image in international community
No more aman ki asha Bs. We have already paid a huge price in blood for this
Brilliant analysis !!
Aadat se majboor. Bharat se fayda lete raho aur doosri ore satanki bhejte raho. Bleeding bharat by 1000 cuts is still an unfinished business. Our unfinished businness is to finish them. Ultimstely this must be done. At worst pak wants to buy time to rebuild, and at best destroy Bharat. So trade with Bjarat ??? Out of question. It does not require too mucj thought to arrive at this conclusion.
Sir, your videos are coming out less frequently these days, please keep your opinions flowing
India should offer investments in Pok, development of temple in pak
loans on similar terms like china
Is Pakistan ever not desperate??
Government should try to reduce the poverty rates in places like mumbai, Bihar, UP, jharkhand etc. If not the whole country won't become developed
No trade with papistan
Getting closer to 1M...great new series.
There is this pakistani youtuber in fact, a fitness influencer perhaps, I don't remember his name because it doesn't matter. He loves to say things in response to videos everywhere related to pak's current status. He just keeps saying with a stupid smug that- Humare paas itna paisa hai mat pucho etc,etc. And I do believe him. As long as people like him have money while the big majority of pakistan remains hungry, those few people can easily get away with that 😆. That would still not change the picture today. They never came ahead to help their falling nation. They never continued diplomatic dialogues with UAE, US or China. Why? Because the generals, the elites were busy stealing what they could steal and just board the next flight leaving for UK.
Agreed. Excellent analysis. Scenario' s complete. Hats off your efforts.
I think, that the point where he mentioned that Pakistan knows that India will not accept Pakistan's offer and Pakistan will say to the world that atleast we tried...is the most logical one...or the one where he mentions that Pakistan needs direct trade routes with India....other than that, being a Pakistani i don't think there is any other reason for us to be inviting India for trade
Hello Sir,
Another scenario could be that Pakistan aims to utilize trade to increase the flow of narcotics into India, subsequently using the generated funds to support terrorism within India.
last one that i thought is that american idea is that pakistan will be a Bricks nation from american side as u can call Bivishan of bricks as spy
No negotiation with Mughal Colonizers.
No ! No ! No !
India should not engage and reward the bad behavior -picking and choosing what they do and when they do it and on their terms.
Show them no mercy!
Great!
No trade nothing...never forget
No engagement whatsoever with Pakistan.
Indian father's and mother's, of all caste, creed, religion, sex, colour across all states in India, are diligently engaged in a healthy competition to educate their son's and daughter's vocationally / professionally, so that they get better and better job's, with better CTC's, so that they can experience enhanced standards of living. This silent effort by the visionary Indian parent's has essentially catalysed the phenomenal growth in Indian GDP and reserves by way of remittances from overseas. Why on earth should the Indian Government donate the hard earned money of ordinary Indian tax payers, for the betterment of youngsters from hostile neighbouring countries, whose parent's do not want to educate their own children vocationally / professionally and pursue the opportunities available in the competitive fields of high technology or medical sciences, towards furtherance of the human race. Obselete are the mindsets that depends only on "ALMS" and "ARMS" and essentially try to beg, borrow or steal from Indian's who have earned their bread and butter by sheer dint of hard work.
Do we need it though 😅😅😅
about pok???
Ghar wapsi
Namaskar from Europe. I like hinduism a lot, and hinduism as a dharma feels many many streams and sampradayas and diverse schools of thought spirituality and philosophy in one name. This is hinduism's strongest point. It cannot be easily centralized like Islam or Christianity which have a single defined theology and submissive massive suited for imperialistc religions.
Since you mentioned "ghar wapasi" or "turning back home" (to sanatan dharma) it is not easy. I am saying this as someone who was born christian, studied islam for many years, even judaism, a bit of sikhism and buddhism too, and hinduism is very attractive to my soul.
But there are some problems within hinduism that need to be addressed. The caste problem was indeed solidifed by the muslim rulers and the british colonialists, but lets not forget the egoistic brahmins and greedy rajas (brahmana kshatriya varna) who often, for money, greed, power influence, and of course ahankar/nafs (ego) oppressed other hindus. They are not less to be blamed for this caste chaos in Bharat.
and a reason many hindus became muslims and christians is this non sense.
This caste issue must be terminated.
Either hindus, who keep their varna just for marriage, and do not live according to it, must just do away with this concept and leave it completely (as you know you do not live in a vedic society in Bharat today, even if you make it a hindu rashtra by name) or implement a real Varna and Vedic way of life in which a Shudra and Vayshya, in fact even the ones hindus call avarna/dalits or mlecchas (barbarians or foreigners to vedic culture) can reach God consciousness far more than Brahmanas and Kshatriyas. And Brahmanas must live as such, and be humble. And Kshatriyas must be such and live as such, with selfless devotion not to misuse their authority. This is too difficult to achieve anyway.
There is a raise of hindu consciousness, but not enough for ghar wapasi. I am telling you this Lakshmi (if your name is Lakshmi or just the name in UA-cam, may Maa Lakshmi bless you didi/behen or bhaya, whatever your gender is) as I am in a way a ghar wapasi too. Keep in mind before islam and christianity, our ancestors, many of whom are falsely accused as pagans, in all over the world followed natural faiths (prakriti maa) and dharmas too but we turned into adharma. Thats why our ancestors were converted so easily to churchianity and islam, and I say this from my heart, I want the Hindu dharma to not only gain ghar wapasi, or awaken sleepy hindus, but can you inspire people to bhakti worldwide, apko swagat hai, i welcome you). Not just ISCKON, far more than that.
But since many call ISCKON abrahamic or missionary hinduism, I think they learned the tactics of the peacefuls and missionaries and spreading their own version of Krishna Bhakti.
Arya Samaj also strictly monotheistic interpretation of Hinduism, but involved in real ghar wapasi.
See, I think it is Prabhu's will that these hindu groups exist, even though most traditional hindus may not like them, because they are doing a real job of ghar wapasi and spreading bhakti. Although I do not want to see bhakti become dance and parties only.
Har Har Mahadev! 🙏🕉
@@G.S.30Which school of thought or sampradaya are you following rn?
@@user-ek3fd2sk9q Initially I was involved in serious learning on Sanatan Dharma. Then I was attracted in Bhakti. After praying to Mahadev I was guided to be a shaiva. I follow the Natha Panth Sampradaya of Guru Gorakthanth ji. I have taken deeksha from my guru a few months back after Mahadev guided me. Otherwise, I am attracted by Vedanta schools a lot, and generally I am very keen to learn (gnyana) yoga but without a guru, since I am not from a hindu background, I would be lacking something fundamental to grow in the Vedic path. But as it goes Prabhu/Mata is the Absolute Guru and they guide a shyshya to his guru. But I am not brahmachari or aghori yogi a normal student only. The path of brahmacharya is not for everyone. Most people stick and should stick to the 4 Purushartas (aims of life: Dharma, Kaam, Arth and Moksha) for a reason.
Otherwise I learn a lot from the vaishnavas and shaktis too. Even smarti sampradaya is interesting. I am interested to find more people who follow Saurism (Surya dev sampradaya). Ganapatiya Sampradaya is largely followed in Maharashtra, and it is also close to my heart because Ganesh ji is my Isht Devta.
Jay Shree Raam!
Har Har Mahadev!
Jay Maata! 🙏🕉🚩
Akahand Bharat?
I concur with you 100%.in fact , my view is if pakistan is forcefully admitted into BRICS india must move out of it.
Pakistan was is and always confused and will remain confused. India's stand is always clear. India is comfortable in seeing Pakistan confused and unstable. Pakistan is on the way to making another Ethiopia.
Pakistan is worst than ethopia
India's stand is clear😂😂....bruh u will take 100 years to make ur own stupid decision, which I know will be no... Pakistan probably knows that India will not accept their request, But Pakistan will have a excuse to say that atleast we tried
Lol what confused😂😂.... Pakistan is just playing diplomacy according to it's needs....We want a simple answer, U want trade or not??
@@legendaryhound5261we don't want. Moreover Y r u commenting in an Indian Channel related video everywhere?
They are even confused of their existence!
Lets wait and see what will happen?
I think Pakistan Sherriff govt with establishment’s advice is hoping Modi in his 3rd term will offer an olive branch to Pak or surprise them with a visit or some kind of gesture. And they are preemptively want to open trade.
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation:
00:00 *🇵🇰 Pakistan considers restarting trade with India, driven by business community sentiments and the costly routing of imports.*
01:49 *🇮🇳 India's Foreign Minister emphasizes Pakistan's attitude towards terrorist groups, highlighting the hurdle to any talks.*
03:13 *🏦 Pakistan's offer to resume trade could stem from a desire to free itself from IMF's conditions, although sincerity is doubtful given the country's power dynamics.*
05:00 *🌐 Pakistan may seek to improve its international image through this offer, portraying itself as proactive in fostering relations with India.*
06:24 *🌏 The offer could serve as a means for Pakistan's foreign sponsors to gauge India's response and understand its long-term geopolitical strategy.*
07:34 *🗳️ Engagement with Pakistan might be aimed at denting Prime Minister Modi's re-election prospects in India.*
08:41 *🧱 Pakistan's attempt to gain entry into BRICS could motivate its overture towards India, as it needs good relations with all member states.*
10:02 *🇷🇺 Russia might have prompted Pakistan's offer to India to further its own geopolitical agenda, particularly in relation to the upcoming BRICS Summit.*
Made with HARPA AI
Well made article. All points covered.
You said that Pakistan sincerely wants to trade. Let’s not be naive.
He didn't. He listed the scenarios and right after mentioning that particular scenario, he said the scenario is highly unlikely.
The relative peace and stability on our boarder is because Pakistan is economically and politically unstable.India should make sure Pakistaj remains on wheelchair economically,not dead but barely alive.
No need to do anything 😂 Pakitan do it to themselves
Well deciphered
@Abhijit sir ♥️
Continue this daily doze of 1 video
1 live on every sunday if u can
No not at all
If it happens the over/under invoicing proceeds will be used for terror in India
SUPERB EXPLANATION
Excellent
Pak realised sentiments don't bring money.
Till Pakistan’s political map is realigned and their part of Punjab is isolated no relations of any kind with Pakistan. That’s the ultimate scenario.
They might expect the opposition to win a large number of seats then resume dialogue.
#AskAbhijit
Could you explain the underlying causes of a revolution? What can we take away from the ones that have happened?
you deserve the best youtuber/content creator
nor ranveer
🙏🚩🇮🇳
Pakistan might have asked for bricks.
Namaste Sir,,, Of all the possibilities listed, the last scenario is the leqst expected .
Super Interesting
#AskAbhijit why we are not focusing on our navy. You also know that if India has a good navy Chinese will stop bullying india and the millitary personels as well as the politicians know that. so my question is it is because of the other western nations or Russia or may be U.S don't want ,that indian navy should be powerful? Please reply 🙏
Whatever but any relations wid Pakistan, everything has a boundary
Please make a video on geopolitics, geoeconomics and the history of these of Central and South America