@@Bombastic_daioh Nah I 100% Wonder. It was a really fun game. The bosses is lacking and some of the repeated levels like; The shadow level and musical levels really lose it’s appeal a third time around. Kinda sucks that I can’t interact with my friends in game tho. Really passive multiplayer. But it was still an overall amazing game. I love collect-ithons. Mario moves like butter. Levels are constantly fun and the art and animation is extremely appealing. The music is god tier as usual. Another amazing Mario game. Can’t wait for more!
@@Bombastic_daioh Oh boy, dude, I’m obsessed with Sonic. But I like expanding my taste in other games. There is nothing wrong with liking both products.
@@Bombastic_daioh So my opinion on a game is wrong? Even tho, subjectively, I like Sonic Superstars more but objectively Mario Wonder is the better game? My brother in christ, that’s just silly. I would like to hear what you have to say about Superstars that makes it OBJECTIVELY the better game than Wonder. Cuz I am interested in what you have to say, if this is going to be a discussion and not a straw man argument.
@@Bombastic_daioh Alright… You are wrong in many ways. Something tells me you didn’t even play Mario Wonder or watch the UA-cam video. And you keep straw-manning Mario (The one thing I didn’t want). Obviously you don’t want to have a discussion, just a one-sided echo chamber. As a Sonic fan, I am upset that fans like you give Sonic such a bad name. You can live in your delusional sonic bubble, Imma do my own thing. Shame too, I really hoped I could meet you half way in this discussion but you never had the intention to have a real conversation about Sonic and Mario game design. What a waste of time.
Yah, how you really gonna blame them for this if this is sonic first multiplayer. Plus, I just have a feeling for liking Sonic superstars more because I can actually enjoy it and see some funny moments while crossing this. And am a Mario and Sonic fan which played both games.
@@jeremymklinger *Even perhaps lesser than that. Sonic Mania was $20. I admit, I paid full price for Frontiers, but Superstars does not seem worthy of $60.*
I appreciate your positive feedback in video! It's always refreshing to engage with the gaming community and share perspectives on titles like these. The unexpected joy in your response resonates with the intricate nuances of your analysis, highlighting the delightful surprise in my positive stance on both games. It's truly heartening to witness the success of these titles despite their acknowledged imperfections, especially for enthusiasts of both the Mario and Sonic franchises. Your satisfaction with the balanced critique, meticulously weighing the strengths and weaknesses of each game, aligns with my intention to provide a fair and comprehensive comparison. The amalgamation of detailed insights and thoughtful examination aims to contribute to the broader discourse surrounding these gaming experiences. Thank you for recognizing the effort to maintain equilibrium in the evaluation, fostering a sense of appreciation for the diverse qualities each game brings to the table.
3:54 I honestly think that was the best part of the badge system I could play my favorite character how I wanted instead of beings stuck with a character I didn’t like or a playstyle I don't like. Making so many playble characters more appealing sense I and my freinds can actually play as our favorites with no downsides.
@@Storm-ft3hyAnd that was a good thing since Sonic continued to stomp Mario with his library of bangers even more on a bigger scale so I see this as a absolute win. And besides, a game being exclusive doesn't make it less of a game or less legendary and Sonic's library of bangers proves that espacially in the 2000's.
How'd you think of Superstars (Story Mode)? As a Classic fan I'd like to know if it's worth picking up on a $40 or so sale. (I don't care about Trip Mode, Final, or the Emeralds too much.)
$60 was definitely a lot, especially if you don’t care about the extras, but for $40 I think it’s a reasonable deal. Definitely play mania first at $20 if you haven’t though
@@jeremymklinger Oh I got all the $20 gems! Mania, Generations, even the Genesis games as I had them in the Classics Collection *before* they were delisted. (Also they usually go down to $5 during holiday sales)
The boss fights in superstars are HORRIBLE at least in wonder there quick, while in superstars they take forever and dying to them is frustrating! That's why I prefer wonder!
Wonder, even though I now hate singing piranha plants. But everything else in Wonder makes up for it! Sonic on the other hand, Tails’s entire existence brings the series down imo
I prefer Sonic Superstars. After the "wow pretty game" effect wore off for me on Wonder i just found it kind of boring. Maybe its the difficulty, but every couple months i tey to go back to it to beat it with other characters and i just get bored after like 2 levels. Not saying its a bad game and if you enjoy it im happy for you, but injust feel like once the spectale was gone it just doesnt do much for me. I also beat it the first time in basically one sitting.
Wonder is obviously better multi-player and it's really cool but I've replayed sonic superstars like 5 timed and I have no desire to replay mario wonder unless its with another player
I love mario wonder but it's local co-op is horrible, most levels, especially when the wonderseed comes in, are ubplayable for the co-op partner the further u go down the game
In my opinion SONIC SUPERSTARS IS A MEDIOCRE HOT GARBAGE is just an average sonic game with no new abilities besides the avatar and vine creation gig. Seriously how many times are you gonna bring classic sonic here? its awsome and all but its just sonic mania but a mid 3d remake. on the otherhand MARIO BROS WONDER WAS A BLAST BRO. sorry for all the sonic fans out there
Confirm everyone think Sonic have epic graphics mais Mario win for the new temátics about the better graphics in the new 5g maybe this is the Game created ever
Why arent we discussing how shit and uninventive the bosses of mario wonder are. They put all their ideas into the levels and Completely failed the boss fights like everyone is reviewing this game but no one is talking about this completely shit aspect of the game. The levels are phenomenal but bosses fail entirely
Just beat Superstars and hyped to play Wonder. Nice to see a reviewer that understands the fundamental game design of Mario and Sonic.
@@Bombastic_daioh Nah I 100% Wonder. It was a really fun game. The bosses is lacking and some of the repeated levels like; The shadow level and musical levels really lose it’s appeal a third time around. Kinda sucks that I can’t interact with my friends in game tho. Really passive multiplayer. But it was still an overall amazing game. I love collect-ithons. Mario moves like butter. Levels are constantly fun and the art and animation is extremely appealing. The music is god tier as usual. Another amazing Mario game. Can’t wait for more!
@@Bombastic_daioh Oh boy, dude, I’m obsessed with Sonic. But I like expanding my taste in other games. There is nothing wrong with liking both products.
@@Bombastic_daiohAnime pfp. Yup you are delusional
@@Bombastic_daioh So my opinion on a game is wrong? Even tho, subjectively, I like Sonic Superstars more but objectively Mario Wonder is the better game? My brother in christ, that’s just silly. I would like to hear what you have to say about Superstars that makes it OBJECTIVELY the better game than Wonder. Cuz I am interested in what you have to say, if this is going to be a discussion and not a straw man argument.
@@Bombastic_daioh Alright… You are wrong in many ways. Something tells me you didn’t even play Mario Wonder or watch the UA-cam video. And you keep straw-manning Mario (The one thing I didn’t want). Obviously you don’t want to have a discussion, just a one-sided echo chamber. As a Sonic fan, I am upset that fans like you give Sonic such a bad name. You can live in your delusional sonic bubble, Imma do my own thing. Shame too, I really hoped I could meet you half way in this discussion but you never had the intention to have a real conversation about Sonic and Mario game design. What a waste of time.
Sonic Superstar's multiplayer is literally unplayable lol.
On the contrary, Sonic Superstars is much more fun when in with friends
I guess you just don't have them lol
@@Whatag Is that why the game bombed in sales?
@@WhatagWhy are my favorite LPers having shit times with Sonic MP, but people are living it up with Mario?
One did it better- A Sonic Fan
Only if your partner is slow than you or the reverse. The focus of Sonic is being fast.
Yah, how you really gonna blame them for this if this is sonic first multiplayer. Plus, I just have a feeling for liking Sonic superstars more because I can actually enjoy it and see some funny moments while crossing this. And am a Mario and Sonic fan which played both games.
Wonder is obviously better, but both are peak.
@RealSuperStar_SonicSpeed Nah, uhhh I didn’t say that, Superstars is the best game of all time, dude!
Nah that's a disrespect to both Mario and Sonic
@@giganticmoonSuperstars looks like Forces but All 2D.
@@Amirisphere I was joking with that random Sonic kid.
No and it will never be.
The reason sonic bosses took longer is cause of their 20 years cutscene invurability
Sonic Superstars shouldn't cost more than Frontiers, that's all what I'm gonna say
That’s true, would look a lot better at $30-$40
@@jeremymklinger *Even perhaps lesser than that. Sonic Mania was $20. I admit, I paid full price for Frontiers, but Superstars does not seem worthy of $60.*
I appreciate your positive feedback in video! It's always refreshing to engage with the gaming community and share perspectives on titles like these. The unexpected joy in your response resonates with the intricate nuances of your analysis, highlighting the delightful surprise in my positive stance on both games. It's truly heartening to witness the success of these titles despite their acknowledged imperfections, especially for enthusiasts of both the Mario and Sonic franchises.
Your satisfaction with the balanced critique, meticulously weighing the strengths and weaknesses of each game, aligns with my intention to provide a fair and comprehensive comparison. The amalgamation of detailed insights and thoughtful examination aims to contribute to the broader discourse surrounding these gaming experiences. Thank you for recognizing the effort to maintain equilibrium in the evaluation, fostering a sense of appreciation for the diverse qualities each game brings to the table.
"Throw your brother into a lava pit" hits close to home. We played co-op super mario 3D world.
3:54 I honestly think that was the best part of the badge system I could play my favorite character how I wanted instead of beings stuck with a character I didn’t like or a playstyle I don't like. Making so many playble characters more appealing sense I and my freinds can actually play as our favorites with no downsides.
That’s true, I guess it’s a double edged sword, I’d personally prefer having to switch a lot, but I see where you’re coming from
Badges mean you can play who you like and then give them a ability wich I think is actualy better then preset character movement options
Hot take but i prefer that most characters play similar to each other. Bagdes fixing the issue of your favorite character having no ability
Still it would've been nice for each character having there own ability rather than feeling similar. Like in Mario 2 USA, 3D World & Run.
Sonic superstars was my favourite
Me to
With super mario wonder, I personally went through the main game, then went back through as nabbit to 100% and get all the medals
Sonic is better tho as always lol
@@Bombastic_daiohIf it was better, it would've sold better. Simple as that.
Suuure buddy @@Amirisphere keep on crying harder. Nothing changing lol
@@Bombastic_daioh bro sega literally pussied out of making consoles cuz sonic and them couldnt compete with nintendo and mario 💀
@@Storm-ft3hyAnd that was a good thing since Sonic continued to stomp Mario with his library of bangers even more on a bigger scale so I see this as a absolute win. And besides, a game being exclusive doesn't make it less of a game or less legendary and Sonic's library of bangers proves that espacially in the 2000's.
I enjoyed Mario wonder more tbh but sonic superstars is still an amazing gAmE
How'd you think of Superstars (Story Mode)? As a Classic fan I'd like to know if it's worth picking up on a $40 or so sale. (I don't care about Trip Mode, Final, or the Emeralds too much.)
$60 was definitely a lot, especially if you don’t care about the extras, but for $40 I think it’s a reasonable deal. Definitely play mania first at $20 if you haven’t though
@@jeremymklinger Oh I got all the $20 gems! Mania, Generations, even the Genesis games as I had them in the Classics Collection *before* they were delisted.
(Also they usually go down to $5 during holiday sales)
Then yeah, I guess picking up superstars for $40 would be your best move. Especially if you’re a big classic sonic fan, you’ll get your money’s worth
The 3D games are still better so I would recommend playing those first as they are supperior anyway.
Sonic had co-op all the way back since sonic 2 way before super Mario bros. what are you talking about sonic didn’t have co op until now?
but was the coop good…?
@@giganticmoon yeah when I was a kid I would always choose sonic and my brother would choose tails we had fun times and memories I will never forget
That is the worst lie ever. In Mario Bros (not Super Mario Bros), they had two player co-op with Mario and Luigi
@@trichromatic5717 was tails in the camera…?
@@JKJ44 well it’s not a lie too be honest I didn’t play much super Mario back then so I just forgot they had 2 player
Both are good games that's my final opinion...i don't do comparison just enjoy both if you want simple as that
I want to say thank you for not treating superstars as the worst game since 06
I love it when you can tell it's biased from the beginning
7:24 "Sonic's very first attempt"
*Ahem* Sonic 4 Episode 2
The elephant power up was very advertised
heavily
I 100% agree with everything you said
Im a Sonic fan and honestly,yes i prefer Superstars over Wonders but both are peak and even tho i didn't play wonder it looks so great!
You nailed this review 👏
8:18 holy shit IHY luigi reference
Dude the timed high jump is literally the triple jump
The bosses in mario wonder suck not the final Bowser fight
The boss fights in superstars are HORRIBLE at least in wonder there quick, while in superstars they take forever and dying to them is frustrating!
That's why I prefer wonder!
Skill issue
@@Ashton_pattI looked back at my comment, and realized it was dumb to say
Wonder, even though I now hate singing piranha plants. But everything else in Wonder makes up for it! Sonic on the other hand, Tails’s entire existence brings the series down imo
I prefer Sonic Superstars. After the "wow pretty game" effect wore off for me on Wonder i just found it kind of boring. Maybe its the difficulty, but every couple months i tey to go back to it to beat it with other characters and i just get bored after like 2 levels.
Not saying its a bad game and if you enjoy it im happy for you, but injust feel like once the spectale was gone it just doesnt do much for me. I also beat it the first time in basically one sitting.
Sonic superstars is better I give this game a 10/10
Glad you enjoy the game! I like it too, but Wonder is next level imo
I like mario wonder more because I dont have super star but Sonic X Shadow Generations is a game I have and I enjoy it more then wonder!
You know what they say Better games gets all the fame
I don’t like how long the stages are on sonic superstars and unnecessarily difficult the bosses are!!!!
Wonder all day HELLLLLLLLLLLLLPPPPPPP!!!!!!!
I love new super Mario bros 2
Wonder is obviously better multi-player and it's really cool but I've replayed sonic superstars like 5 timed and I have no desire to replay mario wonder unless its with another player
The reason mario maker works and sonic maker wouldnt
Is cause mario is more fun
There I said
Lmao imagine singing this delusional
Every,body thinks one game it’s more fun than the other, but I see what you mean
I just beat Mario wonder and I did play sonic superstars but I just could not play it anymore and uninstalled it
I love mario wonder but it's local co-op is horrible, most levels, especially when the wonderseed comes in, are ubplayable for the co-op partner the further u go down the game
Especially the bits where you have to move fast. The one with the crown typically end up dragging the others behind them lol.
New Super Mario Bros Wii and U are better on this
Super mario wonder without a doubt 😊
Jumjumpjump isnt hard... how is everyone so bad lmao
mario wonder is not EASY ONE OF THE HARDEST GAMES I HAVE EVER HAD EXPERIENCE I MEAN I DIE EVEN ON OUTMAWAY VALLEY
Skill issue
@@Punkyyyyy🤓☝️
Super mario wonder's WAY BETTER THAN SONIC SUPERSTARS,NINTENDO IS BETTER THAN SEGA AT MAKING GAMES AND CHARACTERS,WAKE UP
NOBODY ASKED FOR YOUR OPINION
Of course it’s coming from a Mario pfp, who would’ve guessed
Thank you being so kind help me and these people to better understand you God Amen
Just because you're a mari fan
no
That fang boss fight was trash and while sonic superstars is a fine game it just doesnt compare to the genesis era games or even mania.
so super mario wii U deluxe just doesnt count ok...
Sonic's library is better anyway lol
@@Bombastic_daiohnot it’s not 💀
In my opinion SONIC SUPERSTARS IS A MEDIOCRE HOT GARBAGE is just an average sonic game with no new abilities besides the avatar and vine creation gig. Seriously how many times are you gonna bring classic sonic here? its awsome and all but its just sonic mania but a mid 3d remake. on the otherhand MARIO BROS WONDER WAS A BLAST BRO. sorry for all the sonic fans out there
the chaos emeralds gave new abilities but yeah mario wonder is better, i give superstars a 7/10 but wonder is 9/10
I like both games, but Wonder is superior in my opinion.
Definitely Wonder, Superstars is am ok game, but the con out pros when it come to its gameplay.
as a huge sonic fan, superstars doesnt even come close to mario wonder lol
I hate Mario
Sonic superstars better
Super Mario Wonder is better =)
The answer is obvious! Mario Wonder Is ten times better than Sonic Superstars
Mario wonder is wayyyy toooo overrated
Confirm everyone think Sonic have epic graphics mais Mario win for the new temátics about the better graphics in the new 5g maybe this is the Game created ever
Why arent we discussing how shit and uninventive the bosses of mario wonder are. They put all their ideas into the levels and Completely failed the boss fights like everyone is reviewing this game but no one is talking about this completely shit aspect of the game. The levels are phenomenal but bosses fail entirely
Still better than Sonic Superstars' long, tedious and boring bosses
Yes, Mario Wonder really have a lot of mistakes but in general it is just more fun and creative (well, more fun is personal but creative is a fact)
First