Is Miami Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa Worth $50 Million Per Year?? | The Rich Eisen Show

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
  • Rich Eisen and the guys debate if Miami Dolphins QB Tua Tagovailoa is worth $50M per year.
    Tune in to the Emmy-nominated Rich Eisen Show live for FREE on The Roku Channel at go.roku.com/thericheisenshow and also streaming on Audacy, Sirius channel 161 and XM channel 206 (Online channel 998) weekdays from 12--3 PM ET!
    Showcasing insightful sports expertise with an offbeat mix of humor and pop culture, The Rich Eisen Show attracts the most recognizable names in sports and entertainment.
    Subscribe here to keep up with the internet's best sports and pop culture commentary, interviews, and much more!
    ------ SUBSCRIBE HERE:
    bit.ly/2VjWSBC
    FOLLOW US HERE:
    / richeisenshow
    / richeisenshow
    / richeisenshow
    / thericheisenshow
    www.audacy.com/richeisen/listen
    #richeisenshow #nfl #miamidolphins
  • Спорт

КОМЕНТАРІ • 764

  • @danb2083
    @danb2083 16 днів тому +124

    Every QB in the league can thank Daniel Jones for setting 40 million as the new starting QB minimum. If the worst QB in the league gets 40 million then that's where negotiations start for everyone.

    • @ngc-fo5te
      @ngc-fo5te 16 днів тому +7

      He wasn't the worst in the league though. That's just wishful thinking on your part.

    • @cfredtmbg
      @cfredtmbg 16 днів тому +6

      @@ngc-fo5te Agreed, he’s not the worst, but he’s not a good QB. At all. Everyone around the NFL knows it was a horrible contract and it’s messing up the market.

    • @ngc-fo5te
      @ngc-fo5te 16 днів тому +2

      @cfredtmbg Oh I don't think he's good but there are a few worse.
      Actually I don't think it really affected the market - the contracts were spiralling up anyway.

    • @salamander337
      @salamander337 16 днів тому

      That's because the Giants has no one else. And they planned to sabotage other teams from keeping everyone. 😂 They can afford to play that game.

    • @nightshift8249
      @nightshift8249 16 днів тому +3

      Giants fan here. DJ is far from ideal but he’s middle of the pack. You couldn’t even judge him last season. Our line had him seeing ghosts from week 1 and he wasn’t healthy. I don’t agree with paying him what we did, but he’s had the deck stacked against him his entire career. And who was there to throw to? The key was supposed to be Darren Waller but naturally he was hobbled all year. Worst I can say about Jones is that he’s mediocre.

  • @MartinFWhite
    @MartinFWhite 16 днів тому +129

    Burrows made it to the Super Bowl. Tua hasn't won a playoff game. There's the difference.

    • @PA96704
      @PA96704 16 днів тому +9

      So what about the rest of them? Stat man?

    • @NewRimHoops
      @NewRimHoops 16 днів тому +8

      Tua has only played in 1 playoff game lol

    • @joshuaphilbert7995
      @joshuaphilbert7995 16 днів тому +17

      Burrows post seasons stats are worse than Kirk cousins. The difference is the Bengals defense was top notch, especially in turnovers both years.

    • @milesligon5696
      @milesligon5696 16 днів тому +3

      Burrows and Tua both lost to the Superbowl winner. So they have that in common.

    • @nnjjee1
      @nnjjee1 16 днів тому +4

      And he can't perform in cold weather

  • @Hitman1978
    @Hitman1978 16 днів тому +43

    Owners and GMs are being really stupid lately betting the house on all these young QBs who really haven't proven anything. How in the world are you going to pay a QB $50M a year and they haven't even won you a playoff game yet. There definitely needs to be a market reset on QB prices, but it'll never happen.

    • @southsidetone
      @southsidetone 16 днів тому +2

      Tua just finally stayed healthy 4 a whole season. If paying tua stops them from keeping players u just can't do it

    • @Ballaholic17
      @Ballaholic17 15 днів тому +4

      With a loaded roster too.

    • @mr.doctorcaptain1124
      @mr.doctorcaptain1124 15 днів тому +1

      I think we’re in a very strange NFL era where the GMs are seemingly incompetent, but the coaching staffs are the best they’ve ever been.

    • @NightcoreNewbie
      @NightcoreNewbie 13 днів тому

      As odd as it sounds, the market reset will probably come from Purdy. Think about it. Purdy has 2 NFC championship appearances and 1 superbowl appearance regardless of how much or little he was carried by the team depending on who you ask. Other teams will go to their qb and say "Can you do what Purdy did?" and then go based on whatever pay Purdy gets from his contract. Weird world we live in but that's just how it is now.

  • @lhfirex
    @lhfirex 16 днів тому +47

    $50 million a year for Tua... sounds like Jerry's sequel to All In.

  • @karenhardie1132
    @karenhardie1132 16 днів тому +40

    It's what the market is now. Tua will get his bag. Kirk has 400 million for one playoff win. 😂

    • @camreese
      @camreese 15 днів тому +4

      Yeah but kirk has a strong arm and is actually accurate not the Fugazi accuracy of tua

    • @lowkey6597
      @lowkey6597 15 днів тому

      ​@@camreese- 🤡

    • @robertdering2608
      @robertdering2608 15 днів тому +5

      I'd take Kirk , over Tua in a Second.

    • @MarsPegasus
      @MarsPegasus 14 днів тому

      ​@robertdering2608 Man, I think you're smoking weapons-grade crack to take Cousins over Tua, who just led the league in passing yards.

    • @lowkey6597
      @lowkey6597 14 днів тому

      ​@@robertdering2608- 🤡

  • @rorroreyes1739
    @rorroreyes1739 16 днів тому +46

    It’s always so tough for rich to say he’s wrong lol

  • @bluepuma12
    @bluepuma12 16 днів тому +11

    He's worth 50 Filet-o-Fish sammiches

  • @mr.doctorcaptain1124
    @mr.doctorcaptain1124 15 днів тому +6

    Everyone in the world: “Burrow made it to a Super Bowl and is probably the second best QB in the league. Tua hasn’t even won a playoff game.”
    Rich Eisen “Yeah they’re basically the same QB in terms of accomplishments.”

    • @ryandodsonmusic
      @ryandodsonmusic 11 днів тому +1

      As a Bengals fan I would be horrified if we went from Burrow to Tua.
      Burrow is a super star. Tua is an okay qb… there’s a massive difference between a quarterback who gets you to the playoffs and one who gets you to the Super Bowl.
      Bengals have had both.

  • @pewterpirate4560
    @pewterpirate4560 16 днів тому +17

    I think Miami suffers "the curse of the Marino." 13 years, sniffed the Superbowl once as the greatest passer in the game, and was never given a running game.

    • @ultra13907
      @ultra13907 15 днів тому +2

      or defence

    • @MSgt_0699
      @MSgt_0699 14 днів тому +2

      Except the Dolphins right now have a running game and the Defense is going to be improved from last year.

    • @JiandiP
      @JiandiP 14 днів тому

      I hope they're better but that's yet to be seen. Losing Wilkins is probably the biggest game changer. Also AVG to a lesser extent. Then there's question marks on Chubb and Phillips. How will the rookies develop? Will Cam Smith finally get some snaps? Is Fuller an upgrade over Howard? Will the defense remain relatively healthy over the course of the season? Anthony Weaver has his work cut out for him.

    • @Sacred_G_
      @Sacred_G_ 11 днів тому

      They had a #3 defense with Marino one year ​@@ultra13907

    • @c2jones
      @c2jones 9 днів тому +1

      Dan played 17 seasons and won playoff games on the road late in his career solely on his arm.
      The last Miami QB to win a playoff game since Marino wasn't even Tua. (Jay Fiedler.)

  • @jakehalf4050
    @jakehalf4050 14 днів тому +2

    Why repeat a contract scenario like Russell Wilson. He just isn’t a 50mil a year guy.

  • @Norseman311
    @Norseman311 15 днів тому +10

    No one should make more than Pat Mahomes drop mic

    • @roguebossa
      @roguebossa 15 днів тому +1

      You sir are Correct

    • @SeventhSonofASeventhSon77
      @SeventhSonofASeventhSon77 12 днів тому +2

      Give me a break.
      I'm not going to dispute Mahomes being a great QB, but I see too many games where the refs essentially give them wins to act like it's all him.

    • @JediTiga
      @JediTiga 11 днів тому

      Mahomes makes 25 mil a year in endorsements, he doesn't care about having the biggest contract

  • @AlainNavasDrama
    @AlainNavasDrama 16 днів тому +20

    Ima a dolphins fan, I love Tua…I want to keep him, that being said, he is a mid level tier qb….Somewhere in the 40-45million range …Goff has better size, and playoff proven…One SB appearance and a conference final appearance …

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому +8

      As another Dolphin fan, I keep hoping we would ditch Tua altogether IF we're really serious about building a winning team. Tua, it is awful to say, is a very good tier2 QB, but way too limited to carry a team when needed. What he does, any good QB would do it better under McDaniel. Imagine Herbert or even Dak coached by McD...

    • @ZGh0st1422
      @ZGh0st1422 16 днів тому +2

      ⁠@@jeanfourcadehow do you plan on being a “winning team” by getting to rid of the guy the offense and scheme is built around? Have fun replacing the entire offense, coaching staff and scheme just to build another team that might bring you to the playoffs

    • @knowa745
      @knowa745 16 днів тому +2

      @@ZGh0st1422exactly, people act like it’s easy to find Mahomes type QBs which as Dolphins fan we should know it’s extremely rare. Moving on from Tua will only set us back

    • @andrewwilliams5487
      @andrewwilliams5487 16 днів тому +2

      Tua gonna shut yall all up watch

    • @davegenther6877
      @davegenther6877 16 днів тому +1

      Dolphin fan, 40 is what i’d pay. After that…its a reach

  • @PFlow007
    @PFlow007 16 днів тому +24

    It's ridiculous seeing average quarterbacks like tua and dak get these ridiculous contracts because they've got great players around them... But if you're not a top 3 quarterback if you get paid that kind of money your team has 0 chance

    • @PA96704
      @PA96704 16 днів тому +3

      So no one else has good WR's on their teams? Hmm....

    • @luism8130
      @luism8130 16 днів тому +1

      He led the league in passing.... but ok.

    • @ZGh0st1422
      @ZGh0st1422 16 днів тому +1

      Devante Parker and jakeem grant are such amazing players 😂🤣😂🤣 recency bias going crazy in y’all’s heads

    • @quattrocity9620
      @quattrocity9620 12 днів тому

      Well they will probably pay Tua because they built the team around his strengths and he stayed healthy last year. Now he needs
      to show he can win when we really need it. (- Phins fan)

  • @Kevinjimtheone
    @Kevinjimtheone 16 днів тому +12

    Rich cannot possibly be comparing Burrow to Tua. Come on, man. “Not far off”?

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому +1

      Rich is aging quickly, I think.

    • @luism8130
      @luism8130 16 днів тому

      Tua has played more games than Burrow..

  • @vince5579
    @vince5579 16 днів тому +24

    Make him prove it

    • @scamswish8664
      @scamswish8664 16 днів тому +3

      Prove what lol?

    • @TheMattTrakker
      @TheMattTrakker 16 днів тому

      @@scamswish8664 That he can win a playoff game. That he can continue to stay healthy. That he can be consistently good. That he isn't just a product of that offense, where you could plug anyone in and get very similar results.

    • @joec8942
      @joec8942 16 днів тому +2

      @@scamswish8664that he can beat a good team. That he can win on the road. That he can win in December. That he can throw outside the numbers. That he can not completely choke in the big moments. Tua is a Hawaiian Tebow

    • @luism8130
      @luism8130 16 днів тому +1

      @@joec8942 When did Tebow lead the league in passing?

    • @daylanm66
      @daylanm66 16 днів тому

      @@scamswish8664prove that he can beat playoff teams LMAO vs playoff teams he was 1-6 had a 62 completion % 8 tds 8 ints passer rating of 80 Vs the tomato can teams he looked good it’s unfortunate you can’t play those teams in the playoffs though 😂 and he can’t beat Josh Allen who is in the same division as tua

  • @kevinandrewrea123
    @kevinandrewrea123 12 днів тому +3

    Tua is the best QB they’ve had since Marino & it’s not even close.
    He is getting his 45 to 50 million

  • @double5338
    @double5338 16 днів тому +32

    Everybody seems to forget that Burrow went to back to back AFC championship games

    • @LAMARViCK
      @LAMARViCK 16 днів тому +7

      okay and

    • @trazz407
      @trazz407 16 днів тому +2

      Cool! You should say that in a video that's about the Bengals! We are here watching a Tua video, so maybe you should know where you are in the time space continuum

    • @scruffd0g193
      @scruffd0g193 16 днів тому +3

      Yes and ? He’s got hurt again last year. Stay healthy and actually beat a healthy Ravens team (something burrow has never done)

    • @jimmyhooks
      @jimmyhooks 16 днів тому

      this dude comments this on every football video 😂 he's determined to remind us all

    • @RayWilson-bf5qz
      @RayWilson-bf5qz 16 днів тому +1

      Did that add up to a Superbowl?

  • @SunniMerlot
    @SunniMerlot 16 днів тому +27

    The NFL just needs to have position caps or something

    • @verafiedairman
      @verafiedairman 11 днів тому +1

      Nahh, let the market dictate value. Management needs to be held accountable if it doesn’t work out. No one needs a $40M Daniel Jones. There’s already league minimums, and team salary caps. Let the players get paid.

    • @seansnyder6421
      @seansnyder6421 9 днів тому

      Lmao it's called low ratings/views

  • @thehalftimeshow
    @thehalftimeshow 15 днів тому +2

    Very surprised that owners are not fighting back on these QB contracts.

  • @ralphrex9118
    @ralphrex9118 16 днів тому +30

    QB salary is an eerie parallel of capitalist society, give me more than I need and let my team suffer.

    • @JalapenoSteve
      @JalapenoSteve 16 днів тому +1

      Then play QB lol. The great thing about capitalism is it awards people who have skills other people don't. Wouldn't trade it for anything else.

    • @citizenx8710
      @citizenx8710 16 днів тому +12

      @@JalapenoSteve We don't actually live in a meritocracy. That is the lie.

    • @maxrobbins4835
      @maxrobbins4835 15 днів тому +2

      A scholar, I see

    • @MSgt_0699
      @MSgt_0699 14 днів тому +4

      @@JalapenoSteve Um, no. Capitalism, like any other economic system, needs to be regulated. The reason kids graduate college owing $170,000 is because people with skills are not "awarded." It's why the working class struggle to buy a house or budget for groceries. Capitalism is for the poor, socialism is for the rich. How many bail-outs and tax breaks do you receive? And do you realize that the working class pay more taxes for salary income than the top bracket?

    • @MSgt_0699
      @MSgt_0699 13 днів тому

      @@MosheGoldbergTheKing My teenage girls used to like splashing emoticons all over the place too. They grew up though.

  • @VROOOOOOOOOOMMMMMM
    @VROOOOOOOOOOMMMMMM 16 днів тому +30

    Bills fan here. PAY TUA!!

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому +6

      😂

    • @JoshTito22
      @JoshTito22 16 днів тому +11

      Extend Allen!! So the Superbowl drought can continue PLEASE

    • @joec8942
      @joec8942 16 днів тому +3

      @@JoshTito22🤦‍♂️🤡

    • @werb24
      @werb24 16 днів тому +2

      @@JoshTito22 stupidest take ever. You dream of having Josh Allen as your QB. All but 1 or two teams in the league dream about having that dude aa their QB.

    • @daylanm66
      @daylanm66 16 днів тому +2

      @@JoshTito22literally every team except KC would take Allen lmao the 13 seconds game was on the D this past season was on Diggs and Tyler bass none of the playoff games was 100% on Allen it’s been his supporting cast that has let him down The bills have this #1 D that plays amazing in the regular season but then come playoff time they play like a mediocre Defense

  • @MichaelBarinque-Manahan
    @MichaelBarinque-Manahan 16 днів тому +2

    Only a handful of QB deserves 50+ Million. The rest is just base on being "their turn." As they say, don’t hate the player, hate the game...business.

  • @waynetompkins3006
    @waynetompkins3006 16 днів тому +11

    Tua is in the tier with Kirk Cousins, Dak Prescott and Jared Goff. Solid, but not elite.

    • @mightymitch1421
      @mightymitch1421 15 днів тому

      Tuas numbers aren't nearly as good as Kirk's or Daks. Goff level sure.

    • @iyaayas2010
      @iyaayas2010 15 днів тому +5

      ​@@mightymitch1421you dropped your crack pipe, sir. Goff is the best QB in that group

    • @mightymitch1421
      @mightymitch1421 13 днів тому

      @@iyaayas2010 You think Goff is better than Kirk or Dak? That's fucking hilarious.

    • @fortshucker
      @fortshucker 10 днів тому

      @@mightymitch1421cousins playoff record is 1 and 4, Dak is 2 and 5. Goff is 5 and 4. You my man are fucking hilarious.

  • @josephnoneofyourbeeswax8517
    @josephnoneofyourbeeswax8517 14 днів тому +2

    How do Tua's playoff numbers compare to Skyler's playoff numbers?

  • @Floridaman1780_
    @Floridaman1780_ 14 днів тому +2

    It's not about proving anything for Tua but health. Why wouldn't he play out his rookie deal. There is NO BENEFIT for the team to sign him right now and guarantee him money when he's one bad hit away from being done. He's not even a year past contemplating retirement.

  • @robinburrowes6807
    @robinburrowes6807 15 днів тому

    Yes

  • @ZGh0st1422
    @ZGh0st1422 16 днів тому +2

    1 and a half good years?? Tua took Miami from a losing team to 4 straight winning seasons, 2 of those years with a terrible coaching staff and mostly bums to play with. Why do people not acknowledge this?

    • @stewartbergman1812
      @stewartbergman1812 4 дні тому

      Never will be a Super Bowl contender, if you are happy knowing that sign him for whatever, 50 plus million.

    • @ZGh0st1422
      @ZGh0st1422 4 дні тому

      @@stewartbergman1812 best qbr 2022, led the league in yards 2023, but sure, pretend he’s the issue. People love to admit they dropped out of high school online

  • @richardmartinez2910
    @richardmartinez2910 16 днів тому +3

    I like how the top 10 highest paid QB'S and only 1 has actually won the Superbowl.. how bout we devalue the salary cap

    • @roguebossa
      @roguebossa 16 днів тому

      4 of them sat last year out with injuries🙃

  • @WoodyWard
    @WoodyWard 16 днів тому +4

    He's no Jared Goff - I can tell you that.

    • @josephlawrence9584
      @josephlawrence9584 12 днів тому

      Jared would have been in superbowl with that offense miami has

  • @jd229
    @jd229 16 днів тому +9

    Active QBs would would lead the league in passing in Miami with mcdaniel, hill, waddle etc
    Mahames
    Allen
    Burrow
    Herbert
    Rodgers
    Lamar
    Kyler
    Purdy
    Cousins
    Hurts
    Dak
    Russ
    Goff
    Stroud
    Love
    Maybe geno Smith and Derek carr.

    • @ZGh0st1422
      @ZGh0st1422 16 днів тому

      If this is true, why didn’t hill have such amazing seasons with mahomes? Why did it take tua for hill to have back to back best career seasons? You can’t say it’s because mahomes had more people to throw to because Miami had Wilson, waddle, cracraft, smythe, Mostert, berrios, achane, just to name a few of the other options

    • @jamelwilliams1144
      @jamelwilliams1144 16 днів тому +1

      Wrong 😂😂😂😂

  • @anthonystone6031
    @anthonystone6031 15 днів тому +3

    Give him 40 million with incentive clauses…. Prove yourself against winning teams and playoffs 👍

    • @ChefDaveKingKong
      @ChefDaveKingKong 7 днів тому

      Tua and his agent turned down and incentives contract already.

  • @bourbontrail565
    @bourbontrail565 16 днів тому +1

    Thanks for this topic caller. Let him play this year out because he’s under contract. Next Year if they pay him 300 or 400 million that contract will have voidable years and injury clauses so he’ll get 2 years out of that contract maybe 3 . With the chance that the Retirement Concussion messing everything up. Stay Healthy, Tua .

  • @obarbeito
    @obarbeito 16 днів тому +8

    Did Rich and Brock forget that besides the SB, Burrow was a drive away from a 2nd SB? Tua is not close to Burrow.

    • @jjames130xPS3xCOD
      @jjames130xPS3xCOD 15 днів тому

      Lol that was 3 years ago brother, Burrow is more injury prone than Tua

  • @John-Edward
    @John-Edward 16 днів тому +3

    It’s been 20+ years since the Dolphins 🐬 have had a QB as good or better than TUA! That was an old Dan Marino! Dan is in the building all the time now and Likes TUA! So TUA is getting paid! I personally would like to see something in the Pat Mahomes mid $40’s range! That gives the team way more room to continue to build and sustain the team in a competitive way!!

    • @anthonystone6031
      @anthonystone6031 15 днів тому

      I agree that he should get 40 million and then give him incentives when he can prove himself against winning teams and the playoffs 👍

  • @wtmodnar
    @wtmodnar 10 днів тому

    Rich got him good. Chris said Burrow is a little more proven than Tua by saying Burrow had 2 seasons at 4500+4600 and Tua had 1.5 seasons at 3500+4600. If he wanted to prove his point, he should not have used those numbers.

  • @PatrickTuriano
    @PatrickTuriano 15 днів тому +1

    Lamar only scored 3 more points than Tua against the same team, but he was at home, in significantly better conditions. Context matters and these people love to omit it.

    • @thomashyink8866
      @thomashyink8866 11 днів тому

      The MVP got bounced in the first round just like Tua.

  • @offtilt
    @offtilt 16 днів тому

    in my opinion the middle 3 of the 40 apy + tua can be plugged and played wherever, and we're probably talking the same results. kyler, deshaun, kirk, and tua are all the same caliber quarterback to me.

    • @jamessanders145
      @jamessanders145 16 днів тому

      Tua can be plugged in anywhere? The man neeeded a mad genius to come and tailor an entire offense to make him look good, he needed to get star WRs and elite offesive head coaching and he still can't beat teams with a winning record... good luck plugging him in anywhere

  • @donnafarmer111
    @donnafarmer111 16 днів тому

    Interesting how not one word about paying the QB who just took his team to the SB, and also took them to the NFC championship the year before in his rookie season. Extension is coming after this year, which will be his 3rd year.

  • @edwardshaw1743
    @edwardshaw1743 15 днів тому +2

    As a Jets fan I want Tua to be the highest paid QB in NFL history

    • @kevingrandyify
      @kevingrandyify 13 днів тому +1

      Tua is 5-0 against the Jets

    • @edwardshaw1743
      @edwardshaw1743 12 днів тому +1

      @@kevingrandyify and yet the Jets have a more recent playoff win.

    • @thomashyink8866
      @thomashyink8866 11 днів тому

      A Jets fan talking smack. Classic!

    • @thomashyink8866
      @thomashyink8866 11 днів тому

      @@edwardshaw1743 And the Dolphins have a more recent SB win!

    • @edwardshaw1743
      @edwardshaw1743 11 днів тому

      @@thomashyink8866 Congrats on winning a Super Bowl during the Nixon administration 👴🏻

  • @edoardovicario4837
    @edoardovicario4837 11 днів тому +1

    I'm big on Tua and I don't think he's a 50mil QB, but a solid 40.
    That being said, there's a tendency for Tua haters being the people with the least ball knowledge on TV

  • @Gray_Bush
    @Gray_Bush 15 днів тому +5

    Anyone suggesting that Tua won't get $50M doesn't understand the market, or the salary cap. Nor do they understand Tua's value.

    • @elijahechicagobearsboyd5734
      @elijahechicagobearsboyd5734 13 днів тому +1

      I understand that it’s all capitalistic bullshit, and Tua isn’t even close to worthy of 50+ million per year…

    • @Gray_Bush
      @Gray_Bush 13 днів тому

      @@elijahechicagobearsboyd5734 😂 Sounds like you're going to be upset when he signs.

  • @edmoss7952
    @edmoss7952 15 днів тому

    If we can still legitimately have a debate this far in as to whether or not Tua (or any other player) has proven he's worth elite money that essentially means he hasn't. When you are genuinely worth that type of money there's nobody arguing about it.

  • @thenhl1015
    @thenhl1015 15 днів тому +2

    if kyler and deshaun can get paid 46 mil than so can tua

  • @matthewkantar5583
    @matthewkantar5583 16 днів тому

    Who would take Tua in a trade? What would be the price?

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому

      Let's ask the Giants. HOw about a swap?

  • @jeanfourcade
    @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому

    Offering the highest contract won't turn a QB into a better one, let alone the best one. Those Tua-Dak-Cousins-Lawrence, or previously Russ-Watson-Murray conversations prove that the money paid out to QBs has nothing to do with their performance on the field. But exclusively with the commercial windfall the owners think they'll milk from the aura of their QB . No franchise goes bankrupt by failing to win SBs.

  • @natej84
    @natej84 16 днів тому +7

    Lets compare them, Burrow vs Tua. Tua has played 1 more game. Burrow has a better completion percentage by 1%. He has 1,800 more total yrds and 20 more TDs. All while being sacked 50 more times. Now the playoffs, Burrow has 5 wins to Tua's 0. Burrow has a 16% better completion percentage and 1,700 more total yards and 9 more tds. This same thing happened to Lamar last offseason bc he got hurt and everyone wrote him off too

    • @werb24
      @werb24 16 днів тому +1

      Lamar wasn’t worth the money either. He will always implode in the playoffs bc he has an obvious and exploitable weakness that the good teams can exploit.

    • @Dabbers41234
      @Dabbers41234 16 днів тому +1

      @@werb24 Falls on the coach then. Every player is like that. Brady got destroyed anytime he faced a team with all a stall of amazing interior rushers. Eli still laughing how he got 2 rings thanks to D line play. The coach has to maximize his strengths and minimize his weaknesses like bell dd w brady early in his career.

    • @christophermarks7110
      @christophermarks7110 15 днів тому

      Brady's probably not the best example of a team overcoming his weaknesses

    • @Dabbers41234
      @Dabbers41234 15 днів тому +1

      @@christophermarks7110 I mean every time they couldnt handle the interior rush they lost. Brady is the goat but he had amazing teams and coaches around him esp the first 3

    • @thomashyink8866
      @thomashyink8866 11 днів тому

      Actually Tua has played more games.

  • @funnykids572
    @funnykids572 16 днів тому

    Yes and should not take that to help the team

  • @MAFIACAPO1015
    @MAFIACAPO1015 14 днів тому

    No Quarterback outside of Mahomes is worth 50 million a year but that is what the market is se at for a starting top 10 QB

  • @joevasconcelos3409
    @joevasconcelos3409 16 днів тому

    This is what will define tuas career. He has to know he is not on burrow, Herbert and Jackson’s level. Leave some cap room to keep his stats high

  • @lorenzocasillas3850
    @lorenzocasillas3850 9 днів тому

    Besides following the recent Tik Tok trend and signing QB’s for $50M, there should be no reason why any of these QB’s should be even paid half of that.

  • @TheCephalon
    @TheCephalon 16 днів тому +2

    What is this man talking about. Burrow went to the superbowl. The next year he was in the afc championship game.

  • @Quickfeet3
    @Quickfeet3 15 днів тому

    My dawg Rich! You tell em

  • @austintaylor1378
    @austintaylor1378 15 днів тому

    They’re gonna sign him. Before camp. He’s worth 40-50. Do 4 years with a huge signing bonus that way you can move on after 2 years and not be killed in dead cap space. Survivable. I think next year they need to show that they have consistent success and Tua has done that so yea. Winning the Division alone would make his contract ironclad valid

  • @dougstory2285
    @dougstory2285 10 днів тому

    Right on Rich, put him in his place, Tua is the Dolphins franchise QB, live with it, too bad if you don't like it!

  • @anthonyr8906
    @anthonyr8906 12 днів тому

    I think Tua wouldn't want to hurt the team to fill his pockets. I think it's gonna be a team friendly deal.

  • @ericstorm5285
    @ericstorm5285 8 днів тому +2

    Tua only led the NFL in passing last year. He was only top 5 in every important passing category. Has only had 4 straight winning seasons since entering the league and helped lead the team to back to back playoff appearances.
    All this while playing behind a poor O-Line since entering the league (last year due to injuries on the line).
    So ya I’m not sure he deserves to get paid. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @somectguy17
    @somectguy17 9 днів тому

    As a dolphin fan, no I don't think so, but the quarterback market is just too high now. It's either pay him a ton of money or one of the other QB hungry teams will pay him that much.

  • @michaelhelms2378
    @michaelhelms2378 10 днів тому

    You guys are supposed to be the experts and you’re saying that Tua is on par with Burrow? Are you kidding me???

  • @closer2theheart684
    @closer2theheart684 16 днів тому +1

    Might as well give it to him. Who else you gonna get?

  • @thecarguy4304
    @thecarguy4304 16 днів тому

    I think teams start dumping core backs after the rookie contract unless they are a mahomes or Brady type quarterback

  • @jl4646
    @jl4646 12 днів тому

    not sure if Tua is worth 50mm a year for 5 years but he is def worth 200m + (non guarantee) long term contract. Tua is THE GUY

  • @chowder3ful
    @chowder3ful 16 днів тому

    Hank Schaeder?

  • @lpadron13
    @lpadron13 14 днів тому

    Yes. He is worth it. As with EVERY quarterback he needs the right pieces to work with. No QB wins a game, much less a Super Bowl, without great talent at all the other positions.

  • @VBshredder
    @VBshredder 15 днів тому

    Rich is right. We will know shortly

  • @eastcoastghost420
    @eastcoastghost420 13 днів тому +1

    No... Let Skylar play if that's the case!!!

  • @lonnieswag100
    @lonnieswag100 8 годин тому

    "I wouldn't have given Joe Burrow all that money either"... bro WHAT? lmaooooo he would be fired as the GM immediately

  • @josephlaregina126
    @josephlaregina126 15 днів тому

    As a phins fan give him like 45 million and ill be happy. Use the facts that we can keep paying guys like waddle or tyreek. Also no state income tax.

  • @charliedavis7576
    @charliedavis7576 16 днів тому

    I guess they're going to have to raise the cap to $ TRILLION

  • @joeflynn3474
    @joeflynn3474 14 днів тому

    Get it done ✅🐬🆙😎

  • @user-ym2ve7be8l
    @user-ym2ve7be8l 16 днів тому

    Yes, I want to see a 5th year "prove it" for Tua.

  • @te2934
    @te2934 11 днів тому +1

    Lot of armchair GMs in this chat. None of you know anything. The market for QBs in the NFL is insane, it is what it is, period. QBs who are 6-12 ranked are going to be at least 40+ million. That is the market value, you gotta play to pay. I can tell none of y'all know anything about business. Tua is in the 6-9 range with a solid argument for being 5. Again it is what it is. If Miami let's him walk the same people saying "get rid of Tua" are going to be the same people complaining "Miami is so bad." Actually good QBs are hard to find, not running first QBs (Justin Fields) Pocket QBs are what you really need. Look at Lamar, great runner, not great in the pocket, hasn't made a super bowl. MVPs are cool but irrelevant. Lamar hasn't made a superbowl but you know who has? Actual pocket QBs like Goff, Burrow, and Purdy. Mahomes is an anomaly because there hasn't ever been a QB elite at both, maybe Steve Young is the closest. Tua is going to get his bag because 1. The market is the way it is and 2. Tua has substantially improved every single year. Led the league in a few major passing statistics. Tua is a better QB than 99.99999% of the population and in the NFL maybe 5 QBs are better. Cope harder clowns.

  • @davidstick9207
    @davidstick9207 16 днів тому +13

    None of these players are worth this. No ticket is worth hundreds. It is insanity run rampant

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому +1

      Parallel worlds... grown men debating whether throwing balls around is "worth" 40 versus 50 mil/year. Utterly histerical.

    • @rzawistowski33
      @rzawistowski33 16 днів тому +3

      The full stadiums would say otherwise

    • @JohnDoe-kh6mt
      @JohnDoe-kh6mt 16 днів тому

      ​@@jeanfourcadethe offseason is always like this..

    • @R17759
      @R17759 16 днів тому +1

      The NFL makes billions of dollars. And the players are the reason why. So they should get paid a lot.

  • @scott7621
    @scott7621 13 днів тому

    As a Dolfan, Tua has proved he can pad his stats against bad teams, and underperform against good ones and in the playoffs. Lets be realistic here with Tua. Our third string QB did a better job against the Bills last year in the playoffs than Tua did this year. Tua is holding this offence back if anything. Put Allen, Rodgers. Mahomes or any actual top 5 QB on this team last year, their numbers would have dwarfed Tuas. Real talk 😮

  • @davidhogenmiller248
    @davidhogenmiller248 16 днів тому +1

    Unfortunately, if you want to keep your quarterback you have to pay market rates. Maybe you can get away with 48-49 but probably not. QB's cost money. It's like the stock market. You can't make money with cash. You have to invest it in something. If they didn't like Tua they should've gone after Cousins or trade for picks and get someone this year. They didn't. So they will pay Tua.

    • @judithoberpaul509
      @judithoberpaul509 16 днів тому

      You say you can't make money with cash, you have to invest it. That's basically right. You have to invest it in a team and not the QB's role based on a dollar ranking. With some of them it seems to me like a modern-day human trafficking, the highest bidder gets the goods.

  • @richardkeys5214
    @richardkeys5214 14 днів тому

    In the corporate world are you awarded double your salary by not meeting your goals

  • @Aaronak3
    @Aaronak3 16 днів тому

    Doesn’t matter if he is Goff isn’t but that’s the market

  • @ownaronulteron3099
    @ownaronulteron3099 16 днів тому

    If Tua went to the Super Bowl, he would have earned as much le-way as Burrow. Cmon Rich...

  • @dardell2001
    @dardell2001 16 днів тому

    If he had started his career on a team that cares about it's players he would have done better I'm sure. Miami owners have a long history of just wanting ppl in seats

  • @victorcarrero4187
    @victorcarrero4187 16 днів тому

    Rich is right

  • @gonzolo4
    @gonzolo4 16 днів тому +22

    Tua is the best QB in Miami since Marino. Pay him, because it was 20 years before you got this kind of production from the QB position.

    • @roguebossa
      @roguebossa 16 днів тому +3

      That's simply true, like it or not.

    • @Ballaholic17
      @Ballaholic17 15 днів тому +8

      Sorry, but if he can't win a division title or playoff game with the roster we've had around him these last 2 years, going on 3, and 5 years total, then why would paying him 50+ million be any better moving forward? Isn't the goal to beat the best teams and win a championship? If you can't do that while he's cheap and with a good roster, then why waste another 3-5 years trying to do it with a worse roster? Waddle, Philips and/or Holland are due big money, too. You can't settle for mediocrity by paying a qb that can't help you get over the hump just because you don't know who the next guy will be. The job of the GM is to bring a championship to Miami, not to just be competitive. Unfortunately, this is a salary cap league. If your qb is making 50+ million, then you can't build the same around him. If we can't even win this division, then why not try and get someone who can give us a shot while still being able to build a good team around him? The team will only get worse talent wise the next 3 years, not better. I'm all for letting this year play out to see if Tua can do it, but if we get the same results and he can't come up in big moments in a contract year, then when will he do it? I love the guy, but this is football related. He's a great face of the franchise and great person. I have nothing bad to say about him, he's a solid qb, just not 50+ million solid. That's my beef with Tua, it's the money and money only.

    • @JamesHavlin-ez4gw
      @JamesHavlin-ez4gw 15 днів тому +1

      Ok concussion Tua is not going anywhere you can’t even trade him…….

    • @BrettL250
      @BrettL250 15 днів тому +11

      You’re crazy. Miami has such a good team and the only thing they are missing is a quarterback. Tua is not that guy. As a bills fan I hope they keep him because he sucks. Tyreek Hill and waddle I’m afraid of. Tua no way.

    • @JamesHavlin-ez4gw
      @JamesHavlin-ez4gw 15 днів тому +2

      @@BrettL250 totally agree!

  • @vinnyconsolini488
    @vinnyconsolini488 13 днів тому

    As a Dolphins fan, I'm not basing our negotiations on what other teams paid their QBs. Almost all of those big money QB deals turned out to cripple those teams. Murray and Watson are great examples of why Tua should NOT get $45M+/yr

  • @bigbadjohn7053
    @bigbadjohn7053 16 днів тому

    As long as there is a Brady style QB like Pat Mahomes willing to take less money or at least restructure his deal to be cap friendly ($35 mil over the past few seasons), None of the other guys mentioned in this video will win a Super Bowl. Other teams with a cap friendly QB will win some, but no team paying these guys 40+ or 50+ will win.

  • @jimmyjames2903
    @jimmyjames2903 13 днів тому

    3:35 well Rich the NFL wasn't going to allow that😮

  • @kurtrogers9658
    @kurtrogers9658 16 днів тому

    As a Fins fan and one that likes Tua; Call it 45M APY and keep it moving. Both the team and Tua win with that

    • @legend1849
      @legend1849 16 днів тому

      That's the problem the team won't win

    • @kurtrogers9658
      @kurtrogers9658 15 днів тому +1

      @@legend1849 I think they can. The lack of depth on D last year and Tua not being available down the stretch two years ago got us. I think we've made steps in the right direction under McDaniels every year. Is Tua a top 5 QB; no but this is the most logical hope this team has given me in my 30 years as a fan. Extend him but don't reset the market is all I'm asking

  • @jibbt4059
    @jibbt4059 16 днів тому +1

    With the overvalued qb market he’ll get it, is he worth it, no

  • @dirtyrandy2592
    @dirtyrandy2592 15 днів тому

    You don’t pay a player for what they’ve done. You pay them for what they’re going to do in the future.
    - And Tua’s future, looks to be filled with first round playoff exits.

  • @ATXFootball2112
    @ATXFootball2112 16 днів тому

    So sick of this Deshaun talk. He went off against the titans with a broken shoulder, went off against the cardinals, and went off against the Ravens in Baltimore. Was 4-1 as a starter last year. None of these media guys actually watch the Browns

    • @ngc-fo5te
      @ngc-fo5te 16 днів тому +1

      He didn't look good.

  • @dcaslick
    @dcaslick 16 днів тому

    The first $70M per QB is almost certainly already in the NFL. The first $25M per happened in 2017. In 7 years that’s more than doubled. The first $70M per will happen before the end of the decade. Stroud will absolutely be looking at that number if he continues to play up to the level he did as a rookie. If Williams lives up to his hype he’ll be looking for it too.

    • @benoitwaffle5439
      @benoitwaffle5439 16 днів тому

      In 2017, the cap was $167 million, and Matthew Stafford led the league at a $27 million salary. With the cap at $255.4 million and projected to go up to $314 million by 2027 (the life of Goff's deal), the QB position is growing faster than league-wide revenue and cap, but not by as much as people think due to the cap surge over the past three years and expected growth over the next few.
      Also, yes, $70 million per will happen in relatively short order as a result.

  • @5r3t5n0m
    @5r3t5n0m 15 днів тому

    50 mil per year is too much. 35-40 mil per year is insulting. 45 mil per year sounds fair. No better option currently available either for a team that's ready to win now. I'm sure other teams would give him 40 mil, but Dolphins want him to be content so they'll have to pay 45-50 mil

  • @christopher4100
    @christopher4100 16 днів тому

    Being a Dolphins fan since 1980 I would totally disagree with Ritchie boy.

  • @gjv001
    @gjv001 11 днів тому

    Tua is a top 10 QB in the NFL. What is the pay today for that ranking?

  • @vladdelto7491
    @vladdelto7491 16 днів тому +1

    No team would pay TUA 45+ millions If the dolphins let him test the free market. He is a good QB but need to be surrounded by really good to elite players and he has shown that he is not capable of winning against playoffs teams.

    • @benoitwaffle5439
      @benoitwaffle5439 16 днів тому

      All things can be true. Multiple teams would absolutely offer him more than $50million per, he needs great players around him, and his body of work is not great against playoff teams. Bad QB play gets coaches and GMs fired. If a team can get one without emptying the draft pick arsenal, they will be willing to pay what it takes figuring they can make up the cost by hitting on draft picks and cheap second chance players elsewhere.

    • @jeanfourcade
      @jeanfourcade 16 днів тому

      If salaries were based on performance, Tua's contract should be below Mayfield's. But so should the contracts of many other star QBs... starting with Herbert, followed by Cousins, Murray, DS Watson...

    • @TheMattTrakker
      @TheMattTrakker 16 днів тому

      @@benoitwaffle5439 If other teams are giving Tua 50/yr, the guarantee is going to be really small. Dude is meh and has an injury history. That's not the type of player you should line up to sign.

    • @benoitwaffle5439
      @benoitwaffle5439 16 днів тому

      @@TheMattTrakker His guarantee is going to be two-to-three years like they all tend to be depending one whether it is a four or five year deal. Tua isn't a perfect QB, but he is either going to get the Goff contract this offseason or Goff+ whatever the cap increase amounts to next.

  • @jaythevibe7130
    @jaythevibe7130 15 днів тому +1

    Pay him now whatever Herbert is making Herbert blew a 30 point lead in the playoffs

  • @judithoberpaul509
    @judithoberpaul509 16 днів тому

    The topic sounds like I'm at a QB auction. Who is offering more? Ah, 50 here, 55 the next, oh, there's another offer for 60 million. But there's a team and everyone wants to be paid fairly. Who can still understand these amounts? Ah, there's something else: It's supposed to be the market value.

  • @Billsdude17
    @Billsdude17 12 днів тому

    As a Bills fan i hope they give it to him...

    • @thomashyink8866
      @thomashyink8866 11 днів тому

      Keep choking in the playoffs. WIDE RIGHT!

    • @Billsdude17
      @Billsdude17 11 днів тому

      @@thomashyink8866 Yeah things that happened 30 years ago don't bother me which is why Dolphins fans have nothing to brag about at least the Bills are actual contenders now a days with an elite QB unlike noodle arm Tua and the rest of the overrated Dolphins team...

  • @aidana4033
    @aidana4033 14 днів тому

    The guy's played in 1 playoff game and lost to the B2B SB Champs in their building in below freezing weather. If Daniel Jones is making 40 then 50 for Tua isn't unreasonable. The market dictates the price

  • @SplitTHEBILLIDKY
    @SplitTHEBILLIDKY 12 днів тому

    Yes he is

  • @xelim3171
    @xelim3171 16 днів тому +15

    Please pay Tua!
    From Jets fans all over.

    • @danielsantana7370
      @danielsantana7370 16 днів тому +7

      Tua 5-0 vs jets

    • @scruffd0g193
      @scruffd0g193 16 днів тому +2

      Tua is 5-0 vs the Jets.

    • @troyortiz2414
      @troyortiz2414 16 днів тому

      I don’t like Tua but why would Jets fans care one way or the other?

    • @dkgdkg2178
      @dkgdkg2178 16 днів тому +2

      AND BILLS fans!!

    • @aaronanders855
      @aaronanders855 16 днів тому +1

      Why Jets fans doing victory laps to a guy they haven’t beat since he got to the NFL lol 😂

  • @drinkmesilly
    @drinkmesilly 15 днів тому

    He's worth it. But the guy needs a good defense team.

  • @JalapenoSteve
    @JalapenoSteve 16 днів тому +1

    He's going to put up more numbers than Rogers.

    • @BFree775
      @BFree775 13 днів тому

      Number don’t matter lol wins do ..