Oh, I love this man and his performance here! This is certainly among the best versions of Brahms' #2 that I've ever heard. Above all, the phrasing is impeccable. The pace is grand. A total delight! Praise to the performers, too. Thank you all!
An absolutely superb performance! We in the USA were privileged to have Maestro Masur in charge of the New York Philharmonic (1991-2002). He raised the performance standards of that orchestra considerably. But beyond that, he was a truly fine man, one for the ages!
I was lucky enough to have attended the Brahms Cycle including all the Symphonies at Barbican Centre in London while I was residing in London UK in 1990 or 1991 of the concerts by Leipzig Gewanthause mit Dirigent Maestro Kurt Masur UND they were “ Sehr Shöne ! “ Absolute Best of the Brahms even though I have been to almost all the well known concert halls as well as attended those concerts by the world notable orchestras so many times in my life ! I still recall the one of those many concerts that I attended - their ( Leipzig Gewandhaus mit K. Mazur ) as my most favourite performances in my life as classical music freak ! Especially Leipzig is the very special place for Clara Schumann and thus for Johannes Brahms ! From Japan CET 13h43 on 18th of November 2022 Yukie Kudo (=Yukié Kudo =工藤雪枝) PS On the same day back in 1862 dated as 18th of November 1862 written by Johannes Brahms to Clara Schumann “ Where do we - kind of those of us so few in number of existing people who can not find our each ideal location ?”
I'm a little biased here, because Brahms has been my favorite composer for decades. But I think that the slow movement of Symphony #2 is among the most beautiful ever written, and the entire work is a masterpiece. Effortlessly and beautifully played here. Just wonderful to witness music-making at this level.
I brought in the new year (2025) with this performance. The very last chord was played 12 seconds prior to midnight, just perfect, thank you! It was a genuine gift and the timing was too good to be true!
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser scheinbar idyllischen doch wesentlich perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt melodisch. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut betrachteten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wundervoll!
The immortality of great composers, artists and conductors will surely save Civilization itself from cacophony and discord. God Bless Kurt Mazur and all these lovely musicians, and of course, our dear Johannes Brahms for keeping the Human Mind and Spirit on high ground!
Thanks for posting this audio-visual record of the late, great Kurt Masur leading the famous Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra. It was my privilege some years ago to attend live performances of the four Brahms symphonies with this ensemble and Maestro Masur during one of their North American tours. And I have long owned the Philips recordings of Masur and the Gewandhaus Orchestra in Beethoven, Brahms, and Bruckner. I hope DW has more of their concerts recorded for release on your YT channel. These archived performances are not "old." They are very much alive. Thanks so much!
Qué divino lugar, fantástica dirección orquestal, de una hermosa obra de Brahms,muy bien interpretada por la orquesta. Muchas Gracias por compartir el vídeo.
What I really enjoy a lot with Brahms is his use of the wind section. He did the same later in his Symphony No.4. I'm a little biased towards wind instruments as it was the first thing I tried learning as a 9 year old. Sorry to admit I still suck at playing. LOL! Das ist wunderschön!
Thank you for your comment. If you would like to know more about Brahms' symphonies and their instrumentation, please also watch these two music documentaries: ua-cam.com/video/B-K3Gan-NA0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/UlI_k3RCADs/v-deo.html We are convinced that you will enjoy these videos! 🙂
I believe the proper technique with wind instruments involves blowing, not sucking, except with the harmonica, which requires both. But I'm not a musician, so I could be wrong.
Oh, qué bien escuchar esta sinfonía de Brahms, con tanto porte, calmada en su inicio, solemne y elaborada. Es verdad que hay personas a las que no les gusta Brahms, pero a mí sí (no todo), y creo que sus sinfonías constituyen una placentero viaje musical entre sonidos y melodías que se entrelazan y se separan, en harmonía. Creo que hay que escuchar más a Brahms.
Si música como esta pudiera atravesar el planeta, sin duda subiríamos de vibración. Sobretodo en estos años que estamos viviendo signos de tribulación. Maravillosos los músicos y la dirección del Maestro ✨✨✨
si te abres a esta sinfonía, si la dejas entrar, probablemente no podrás contener alguna lágrima... lamentablemente los políticos que ahora soportamos y estilamos son completamente sordos a este tipo de apreciación y por lo mismo, totalmente imposibilitados para entregarse dignamente a su trabajo. Solo saben arrastrarse por los niveles más bajos de descomposición humana
Ah this superb - very Popular in Gaza -last movement often played On loud speakers as the war criminals bombs hit their civilian targets - gives the Victims courage Especially the Young children
@@konstantinoskatsounis1109 Please comment on the relevant video and not on other topics. For live updates and in-depth coverage of the Israel-Hamas war, visit our website dw.com.
It's the church of St. Nicolai in the German city of Leipzig. More information about this special church you can find here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Nicholas_Church,_Leipzig
Haber del buen intérprete que es Kurt Masur sería muy largo, pero debemos admirar que hace un gran esfuerzo, ya que Desde hace mucho tiempo trae un marcapasos, lo cual es digno de admiración
What a wonderful performance of this wonderful symphony! And Brahms never seizes to surprise you with his amazing technique...For example, I have never understood why he gives the upper part to the celli in the second theme of the first movement(mes. 82), with the violas playing a third below. Maybe a professional musician reading this could explain it to the simple amateur that I am!
Thanks to Bramhs, Bach, Beethoven, Schutz, even Wagner (as a musician, not necessarily as a writer), we all in this planet "are" Germans..... Think the same of every superb representative of the humanity in every country....
@@hertzair1186 Of course I would not forget Mozart, Haydn or Schubert (whom I love so much)... But I was referring to Germany as an "state" more than a shared culture among several "states" (Austria-Vienna in particular). To continue with Germany as an "state" we should not forget, Telemann, Praetorius or, let's put the 20th century (why not?): Hindemith, Weill or Stockhausen!
@@CarlosCM62 Years ago I listed my top 10 composers. Here they are: 1 Bach 2 Beethoven 3 Mozart 4 Handel 5 Brahms 6 Schubert 7 Wagner 8 Haydn 9 Schumann 10 Tchaikovsky Agree? If not, who would you replace?
Having got a copy of the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra Playing the Beetoven Violin Concerto with Yehudi Menuhin Recorded in 1981 and Published 1982 on EMI His Master's Voice Record Number ASD-4280 I Consider Kurt Masur to be Equally as good as Otto Klemperer; Constantine Silvesry;and Willhelm Furtwangler who Yehudi Menuhin also Recorded the work with Between 1947 and 1981(Published 1982)and thank God for Gramophone Recording's and he lived until the same age as Otto Klemperer who both died at the age of 88:and next year Mark's the 50th Anniversary of Otto Klemperer's Death and I've also got all the four Brahms Symphony's Played by Sir John Barbirolli and the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra which came out in 1968 on first Pressing Stereo as well as the two Piano Concerto's with the Philharmonia Orchestra and again Conducted by Sir John Barbirolli on His Master's Voice first Pressing Stereo
@@chasfleming I recommend you to not be proud of what your saying. Stop blaming our generation for mistakes of previous. It doesn't change anything, only support rasism and ethical discrimination.
@@chasfleminghey charlie war ended in 1945 since then Great Britain lost all its colonies Germany had the wirt. Wunder took over the Eu produced the euro & is the indispensable-nation in Europe There is no Europ without Germany since - 1970 .England Lost not only their colonies -whose people They exploited & brutalized for centuries But their sense of identity - the germans Did horrible things but they have tried to atone -reparations to The jews -their former African colonies which They acquired in 1889 Unlike the English who Plundered their former colonies for centuries-Angela allowed 1.5 million Refugees to come on 2015 from war torn Syria -& Afghanistan England got war monger tony Blair-who was Bushes puppet in Iraq / remember no WMD They helped the USA kill a million Iraqi non - combatants -& the icing on the cake Was Boris - its poetic Justice -that the Brits r Ruled by Desi people Germany was the bulwark against soviet domination of Europep Thru - put the 60s 70s 80s until the wall fell Destroyed itself economically for decades with Brexit U guys meanwhile got Thatcher & had to beg Reagan to let u invade the falklands to bolster Ur pride - how pathetic
The announcement of trumpet, horn, and trombone at the coda should add more legato but not short - breathed, so that it becomes more solemn with a weight. I'm not particularly fond of urgent pitched climax of Brahms 1.
" . . . as played by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra under the baton of Kurt Masur. . ." Well, he's not actually using a baton, but a beautiful performance nonetheless!
Perhaps the film crew was realizing this may be an Immortal tribute to a senior conductor who may have less time to spend with us than the musicians who are united under his baton? Kudos to all who partook in performing, and preserving this Beautiful Treasure for Eternity🙏
Mittendrin seht ein verwirrter alter Mann mit unkontrollierten Zuckungen... - Spaß beiseite: Der Kurt dirigiert hier mal so ganz locker 40min OHNE NOTEN!! - sein Tischlein ist leer... - Alles im kopf... Alle Achtung. - und ich wette das ist nicht das einzige Stück dass er (auswendig) kennt.
A bit too pastoral for my taste. There has to be more than technical brilliance, coordination with precision; it evokes little in me, if I played this from my open window very few outside would stop and listen. But you're programmed to approve and will totally disagree with me, as always...
I agree 100%. The Second may be a pastoral symphony, but not in the sense of Beethoven's Sixth, which truly evokes someone walking in the quiet countryside and adoring the gorgeous trees and flowers and the sounds of chirping birds. This one by contrast, is filled with passages that alternately present a melancholic undertone, a sense of yearning and thoughtful pondering, and moments of revelation that cause great drama and exhilarating energy. In summary, it is not a leisurely relaxing pastoral scene, but rather one that transfixes the viewer, puts him in a thoughtful and exploratory mood, and ultimately elevates him into a rapturous and thrilling fantasy. By the time the last note is sounded, one should feel like jumping out of his seat in roaring approval. This performance doesn't nearly do the trick. Listen to the Abbado and Bernstein versions available on UA-cam instead.
J'ai pas mal de livres sur la musique... de mémoire : une bourgeoise parisienne qui parle à la fin du 19éme siècle..."Nous avons assisté hier soir à la représentation de la deuxième symphonie de Brahms...ce fut d'un ennui mortel." Parce que tu crois qu'à Paris il n'y a que des gros cerveaux peut-être... Le nombre de têtes à claques au km2...quand j'y pense...cela doit être effrayant ! Tiens, en 2001 je suis allé quartier de l'opéra pour un entretien d'embauche... après j'ai fait un tour au Printemps Haussman... QUI CONNAIT TOUTES LES SYMPHONIES DE BRAHMS ICI, QUI ? Ah ! Ah ! Bon, on est bien loin des Alpes ici, faut dire... 13:19... pas vrai Kurt ? 16:09 ! :°
Tiens, après Karajan, Böhm et Masur, je viens de trouver Szell pour 0.99 eur ! Hé, si la dame avait vécu dans le 74 que je connais si bien... peut-être qu'elle aurait apprécié... va savoir !
Oh, I love this man and his performance here! This is certainly among the best versions of Brahms' #2 that I've ever heard. Above all, the phrasing is impeccable. The pace is grand. A total delight! Praise to the performers, too. Thank you all!
Thank you! We're glad you liked it. Subscribe to our channel for the latest uploads.
Dieses ist meine Lieblingssymphonie von Brahms, voll himmlischer Melodien!!!!
😇
An absolutely superb performance! We in the USA were privileged to have Maestro Masur in charge of the New York Philharmonic (1991-2002). He raised the performance standards of that orchestra considerably. But beyond that, he was a truly fine man, one for the ages!
I was lucky enough to have attended the Brahms Cycle including all the Symphonies at Barbican Centre in London while I was residing in London UK in 1990 or 1991 of the concerts by Leipzig Gewanthause mit Dirigent Maestro Kurt Masur UND they were “ Sehr Shöne ! “ Absolute Best of the Brahms even though I have been to almost all the well known concert halls as well as attended those concerts by the world notable orchestras so many times in my life !
I still recall the one of those many concerts that I attended - their ( Leipzig Gewandhaus mit K. Mazur ) as my most favourite performances in my life as classical music freak !
Especially Leipzig is the very special place for Clara Schumann and thus for Johannes Brahms !
From Japan
CET 13h43 on 18th of November 2022
Yukie Kudo (=Yukié Kudo =工藤雪枝)
PS On the same day back in 1862 dated as 18th of November 1862 written by Johannes Brahms to Clara Schumann “
Where do we - kind of those of us so few in number of existing people who can not find our each ideal location ?”
I'm a little biased here, because Brahms has been my favorite composer for decades. But I think that the slow movement of Symphony #2 is among the most beautiful ever written, and the entire work is a masterpiece. Effortlessly and beautifully played here. Just wonderful to witness music-making at this level.
I agree Brahms is the best, but the 4th movement is where it's at for me.
I brought in the new year (2025) with this performance. The very last chord was played 12 seconds prior to midnight, just perfect, thank you! It was a genuine gift and the timing was too good to be true!
KURT MASSUR SUPERBE, BRAHMS A GÈNIE , L'ORCHESTRE EXTRAORDINAIRE MERRCI DU FOUND DU CŒURE !
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser scheinbar idyllischen doch wesentlich perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Der zweite Satz klingt besonders schön und echt melodisch. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im gut betrachteten Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wundervoll!
A wonderful and moving live performance by Maestro Masur and the LGO.
que dire devant la beaute de l'ecriture et la perfection de la direction d'un orchestre merveilleux !!!!!
Such a beautiful performance!! Thank you!
What a pleasure to watch the concert on tv now. Kurt Masur, the conductor who led many orchestras, exceptional! A delicious treat. Thank you.
The immortality of great composers, artists and conductors will surely save Civilization itself from cacophony and discord. God Bless Kurt Mazur and all these lovely musicians, and of course, our dear Johannes Brahms for keeping the Human Mind and Spirit on high ground!
Excepcional interpretación de la Gewandhaus y su magnífico Director Masur, y ni hablar de del Coloso mundial el exquisito Johannes Brahms
What a wonderful performance!
Words cannot describe how marvelous a composer was Brahms, and Kurt Masur brings out the brilliance of that work with this performance. Bravo!
Thanks for posting this audio-visual record of the late, great Kurt Masur leading the famous Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra. It was my privilege some years ago to attend live performances of the four Brahms symphonies with this ensemble and Maestro Masur during one of their North American tours. And I have long owned the Philips recordings of Masur and the Gewandhaus Orchestra in Beethoven, Brahms, and Bruckner. I hope DW has more of their concerts recorded for release on your YT channel. These archived performances are not "old." They are very much alive. Thanks so much!
Beatiful music and conduction.
Bravo Brahms.
This is my favorite Brahms symphony! Thank you very much! 😍❤️
Thank you for watching!
The only Brahms symphony that employs a tuba -- certainly his best!
ブラームスは素晴らしい!心を癒してくれました!感謝です!
Thank you for watching our channel!
Qué divino lugar, fantástica dirección orquestal, de una hermosa obra de Brahms,muy bien interpretada por la orquesta. Muchas Gracias por compartir el vídeo.
A pastorale symphony to bring humanity together.
What I really enjoy a lot with Brahms is his use of the wind section. He did the same later in his Symphony No.4. I'm a little biased towards wind instruments as it was the first thing I tried learning as a 9 year old. Sorry to admit I still suck at playing. LOL!
Das ist wunderschön!
Thank you for your comment. If you would like to know more about Brahms' symphonies and their instrumentation, please also watch these two music documentaries:
ua-cam.com/video/B-K3Gan-NA0/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/UlI_k3RCADs/v-deo.html
We are convinced that you will enjoy these videos! 🙂
@@DWClassicalMusic Thanks. I will watch. I'm trying to get to know these symphonies. This one is very beautiful.
I believe the proper technique with wind instruments involves blowing, not sucking, except with the harmonica, which requires both. But I'm not a musician, so I could be wrong.
@@b43xoit Are you trolling or just lack comprehension skills?
第1番の、重々しく重厚な響きとは、ちょっと趣かえた、抒情的で美しさを感じます。・そして《Orch》各パートの磨き上げられた、1つ1つの響きの共演が素晴らしく、感無量です。👏👏‼
Am richtigen Ort. Der Himmel öffnet sich, und wer es nicht spürt, ist zu bedauern.
Not pitied. But, gently show the magnificent beauty of God’s creation.
❤ Es una excelente versión de la gran obra de J. Brahms. Inmensa, sensible y detallada dirección e interpretación magnífica de la Orquesta.
Parabéns pelo belissimo trabalho! Gratidão a todos e muitas felicidades!
Oh, qué bien escuchar esta sinfonía de Brahms, con tanto porte, calmada en su inicio, solemne y elaborada. Es verdad que hay personas a las que no les gusta Brahms, pero a mí sí (no todo), y creo que sus sinfonías constituyen una placentero viaje musical entre sonidos y melodías que se entrelazan y se separan, en harmonía. Creo que hay que escuchar más a Brahms.
Kurt Masur grande guardiano di una grandissima tradizione musicale. Notevole.
Si música como esta pudiera atravesar el planeta, sin duda subiríamos de vibración. Sobretodo en estos años que estamos viviendo signos de tribulación. Maravillosos los músicos y la dirección del Maestro ✨✨✨
Os atores nefastos do panorama mundial não gostam da Grande Música.
si te abres a esta sinfonía, si la dejas entrar, probablemente no podrás contener alguna lágrima...
lamentablemente los políticos que ahora soportamos y estilamos son completamente sordos a este tipo de apreciación y por lo mismo, totalmente imposibilitados para entregarse dignamente a su trabajo. Solo saben arrastrarse por los niveles más bajos de descomposición humana
Bravo!!!!🌹 Lindos tocando e que fantástico esse lugar.Amei os detalhes do teto, enfim um presente para a alma.🎼🙏🎶DW Classic
Bravo! Very live performance, good spirit!
Wonderful performance - thanks for sharing
Ah this superb - very
Popular in Gaza -last movement often played
On loud speakers as the war criminals bombs hit their civilian targets - gives the
Victims courage
Especially the
Young children
@@konstantinoskatsounis1109 Please comment on the relevant video and not on other topics. For live updates and in-depth coverage of the Israel-Hamas war, visit our website dw.com.
Hermosa obra, excelente dirección y muy buena orquesta. Bravo 👌
Kurt Masur foi um dos maiores regentes da história da Música Clássica. Tive a honra e o orgulho de vê-lo regendo na Sala São Paulo. Inesquecível!
This wonderful and comfortable feeling are unrivaled, and beyond description, and irreplaceble
Wonderful rendition; expertly played, and recorded in a spectacular venue!
Bravo!
😊
Sono d'accord, Bravo!!!!!!
輝き、安定感、広さ、奥行き、微笑み、躍動感、明るさ、美しさ。素晴らしいです。
나의 분홍색 브로치 ㅡ 훔쳐간 놈년 ㅡ 대수 옴 붙어라 … 돈으로 망해라
What a location!
You can say that again. It's simply divine.
What church is this?
It's the church of St. Nicolai in the German city of Leipzig.
More information about this special church you can find here:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Nicholas_Church,_Leipzig
@@DWClassicalMusic Thank you! Absolutely beautiful
Haber del buen intérprete que es Kurt Masur sería muy largo, pero debemos admirar que hace un gran esfuerzo, ya que Desde hace mucho tiempo trae un marcapasos, lo cual es digno de admiración
Hermosisimo. Saludos desde el bello Pucon, Chile.
What a wonderful performance of this wonderful symphony! And Brahms never seizes to surprise you with his amazing technique...For example, I have never understood why he gives the upper part to the celli in the second theme of the first movement(mes. 82), with the violas playing a third below. Maybe a professional musician reading this could explain it to the simple amateur that I am!
Bravo. Merci beaucoup
Exquisite!! Spellbinding!!!
참 좋습니다(very good)!
Maravilloso concierto
Wow this is amazing wow beautiful 😍
Thank you 🙏 for such beautiful music 🎶. It’s a gift of love to all who listen and a true Blessing. 👏🏻👏🏻❤️❤️
Ein groβer Dirigent. Ein groβer Mensch.
October 1989, six months after April 1989, another significant moment in world history. Will they ever let us have peace?
questa sinfonia mi sta a cuore
Every bar of this symphony is about: "I love Clara, but she loves Robert" 😂
Soooooo beautiful!
Hermosa sinfonía de Brahms !! Un lujo
Vielen Dank !!! Grüsse aus Argentinien
Fernando Raúl Hidalgo 3°
¡Saludos desde Alemania!
Спасибо)
Good wonderful music.
Thanks to Bramhs, Bach, Beethoven, Schutz, even Wagner (as a musician, not necessarily as a writer), we all in this planet "are" Germans..... Think the same of every superb representative of the humanity in every country....
Agreed…but don’t forget Mozart and Haydn….
@@hertzair1186 Of course I would not forget Mozart, Haydn or Schubert (whom I love so much)... But I was referring to Germany as an "state" more than a shared culture among several "states" (Austria-Vienna in particular). To continue with Germany as an "state" we should not forget, Telemann, Praetorius or, let's put the 20th century (why not?): Hindemith, Weill or Stockhausen!
@@CarlosCM62 ….yes, thank you for remembering Schubert! He’s is my 3rd favorite (tied with Beethoven) after Mozart and Haydn.
@@hertzair1186 And let's not forget Robert Schumann and Felix Mendelssohn...
@@CarlosCM62 Years ago I listed my top 10 composers. Here they are:
1 Bach
2 Beethoven
3 Mozart
4 Handel
5 Brahms
6 Schubert
7 Wagner
8 Haydn
9 Schumann
10 Tchaikovsky
Agree? If not, who would you replace?
Brahms is a treasure , he is
bar 111 starts at 3:40 and bar E is at 3:47
Maravilla de concierto, Bravo Kurt Masur y la Leipziger Gewandhaus
Masur is a genius! Thank you LORD, the Almighty!
outstanding
Great Symphony! I think she talks about the philosophy of nature.
Having got a copy of the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra Playing the Beetoven Violin Concerto with Yehudi Menuhin Recorded in 1981 and Published 1982 on EMI His Master's Voice Record Number ASD-4280 I Consider Kurt Masur to be Equally as good as Otto Klemperer; Constantine Silvesry;and Willhelm Furtwangler who Yehudi Menuhin also Recorded the work with Between 1947 and 1981(Published 1982)and thank God for Gramophone Recording's and he lived until the same age as Otto Klemperer who both died at the age of 88:and next year Mark's the 50th Anniversary of Otto Klemperer's Death and I've also got all the four Brahms Symphony's Played by Sir John Barbirolli and the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra which came out in 1968 on first Pressing Stereo as well as the two Piano Concerto's with the Philharmonia Orchestra and again Conducted by Sir John Barbirolli on His Master's Voice first Pressing Stereo
Saludos y felicitaciones desde Lima (sá25/IX/2021)-Perú-América.
Johannes Brahms! !!!!!!!!DIVINE COMPOSER made in GERMANY too!!!!!!!💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
¹¹q¹qqqqqqqqqqqq Cz qqq1q
4@
You should be rightfully proud of your composers but sadly not much else in your troubled history, particularly in the 20th century.
@@chasfleming I recommend you to not be proud of what your saying. Stop blaming our generation for mistakes of previous. It doesn't change anything, only support rasism and ethical discrimination.
@@chasfleming ㆍ8ㅅ8ㅅ😮ㅆㅆㅆㅆㅅ😮ㅆㅆㅂㅆ😢ㅆ?ㅅ?ㅎ?ㅆ8ㅆㅂㅆ😮ㅅ😮ㅆ😮😮😮😮😮
@@chasfleminghey charlie war ended in 1945 since then Great
Britain lost all its colonies
Germany had the wirt. Wunder took over the
Eu produced the euro
& is the indispensable-nation in Europe
There is no Europ without Germany
since - 1970 .England
Lost not only their colonies -whose people
They exploited & brutalized for centuries
But their sense of identity - the germans
Did horrible things but they have tried to atone -reparations to
The jews -their former
African colonies which
They acquired in 1889
Unlike the English who
Plundered their former colonies for centuries-Angela allowed 1.5 million
Refugees to come on 2015 from war torn Syria -& Afghanistan
England got war monger tony Blair-who was
Bushes puppet in Iraq / remember no WMD
They helped the USA kill a million Iraqi non - combatants -& the icing on the cake
Was Boris - its poetic
Justice -that the Brits r
Ruled by Desi people
Germany was the bulwark against soviet
domination of Europep
Thru - put the 60s 70s
80s until the wall fell
Destroyed itself economically for decades with Brexit
U guys meanwhile got Thatcher & had to beg
Reagan to let u invade the falklands to bolster
Ur pride - how pathetic
Magnífica!!!!
Nice and good 🎉🎉🎉
The first movement is really a sort of Pastoral Symphony
Ох и хорошо, браво всем!
Thank you for your comment. If possible, please comment in English next time so that more people can follow the discussion. All the best!
Kurt Masur has that 100 metre stare : he's listening to the music in his head and letting it unfold in front of him.
@36:47 Mahler, is that you, my friend?
A little time-travel moment? ... or was Gustav saying thank you to Brahms?
Every time I listen to this, I wonder how much he had to drink while writing it..🍷🍷🍺🍺🍻🍻🍷........🍷🍷.........
💖💖💖👏👏👏
Good day. Bravo. Special performance.
.
81223
The announcement of trumpet, horn, and trombone at the coda should add more legato but not short - breathed, so that it becomes more solemn with a weight. I'm not particularly fond of urgent pitched climax of Brahms 1.
❤️❤️❤️
💖💖💖💖
Magie
❤
Brahms' pastoral symphony.
" . . . as played by the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra under the baton of Kurt Masur. . ."
Well, he's not actually using a baton, but a beautiful performance nonetheless!
Thank you for your correction! 🙏 😉
É como se eu estivesse no dorso de uma Baleia descobrindo os oceanos.
🐳 🎶 😊
for myself later: 33:05 is roughly reh. M
36:33 what's so funny ?? 😁
Great performance by the orchestra, but less so by the camera team. Audiences want to see the MUSICIANS, not the conductor.
Thanks for your feedback regarding how we can improve our videos! We're working on it!
Perhaps the film crew was realizing this may be an Immortal tribute to a senior conductor who may have less time to spend with us than the musicians who are united under his baton? Kudos to all who partook in performing, and preserving this Beautiful Treasure for Eternity🙏
25:38
かなり昔、この指揮者が若かりし頃に、日本公演がありベートーヴェンのエロイカを演奏したのだが、奏者全員が二日酔いか?とても聞いてられないほどメロメロな演奏だった。それ以降、この指揮者の名前は振るとまずわと言われているみたい!
Wow! Conducting without a score
“Here comes the coda!”
👏👏👏👏❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏❤❤❤👏👏👏
beTIFUL
B
A! To tu PiS schowało Antoniego Macierewicza!
Mittendrin seht ein verwirrter alter Mann mit unkontrollierten Zuckungen...
- Spaß beiseite:
Der Kurt dirigiert hier mal so ganz locker 40min OHNE NOTEN!! - sein Tischlein ist leer...
- Alles im kopf... Alle Achtung. - und ich wette das ist nicht das einzige Stück dass er (auswendig) kennt.
A beethovenian symphony
Lucky for the Germans in 1989, not the Chinese.
Better than Karajan
A bit too pastoral for my taste. There has to be more than technical brilliance, coordination with precision; it evokes little in me, if I played this from my open window very few outside would stop and listen. But you're programmed to approve and will totally disagree with me, as always...
I agree 100%. The Second may be a pastoral symphony, but not in the sense of Beethoven's Sixth, which truly evokes someone walking in the quiet countryside and adoring the gorgeous trees and flowers and the sounds of chirping birds. This one by contrast, is filled with passages that alternately present a melancholic undertone, a sense of yearning and thoughtful pondering, and moments of revelation that cause great drama and exhilarating energy. In summary, it is not a leisurely relaxing pastoral scene, but rather one that transfixes the viewer, puts him in a thoughtful and exploratory mood, and ultimately elevates him into a rapturous and thrilling fantasy. By the time the last note is sounded, one should feel like jumping out of his seat in roaring approval. This performance doesn't nearly do the trick. Listen to the Abbado and Bernstein versions available on UA-cam instead.
Being better than the average modern music is good enough for me :p
I can't disagree that you are unmoved, there is nothing wrong with preferences, I likewise prefer his 4th or even his 1st.
Ok so dont listen to it ! Its simple - no big deal - keep in mind long long after you are gone
@@lsmart long long after yuo are gone - people will be fascinated by it -hey no accounting for taste -
Всегда выглядел как бомж, а дирижер нечего себе 😅
Thank you for your comment. If possible, please comment in English next time so that more people can follow the discussion. All the best!
この指揮者ティンパニーが嫌いなのかね。全然聞こえないのだが。
J'ai pas mal de livres sur la musique... de mémoire : une bourgeoise parisienne qui parle à la fin du 19éme siècle..."Nous avons assisté hier soir à la représentation de la deuxième symphonie de Brahms...ce fut d'un ennui mortel."
Parce que tu crois qu'à Paris il n'y a que des gros cerveaux peut-être...
Le nombre de têtes à claques au km2...quand j'y pense...cela doit être effrayant !
Tiens, en 2001 je suis allé quartier de l'opéra pour un entretien d'embauche... après j'ai fait un tour au Printemps Haussman... QUI CONNAIT TOUTES LES SYMPHONIES DE BRAHMS ICI, QUI ? Ah ! Ah !
Bon, on est bien loin des Alpes ici, faut dire... 13:19... pas vrai Kurt ? 16:09 ! :°
Tiens, après Karajan, Böhm et Masur, je viens de trouver Szell pour 0.99 eur !
Hé, si la dame avait vécu dans le 74 que je connais si bien... peut-être qu'elle aurait apprécié... va savoir !
She said, "it was mortally boring," but what she should have said was, "I was shamelessly unmoved." 🤔
Yes, no shame... in Paris ! 😁@@PETERJOHN101