New BMW M5 vs Mercedes-AMG E 63 S - which is fastest on track?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024
  • SUBSCRIBE for more great car videos: aex.ae/2gY9ABE
    BMW M5 vs Mercedes-AMG E 63 S: aex.ae/2qtz9Qb
    The BMW M5 and the Mercedes-AMG E 63 S are the cream of the crop when it comes to supersaloons: the former churns out 592bhp and 750Nm of torque, while the latter has 604bhp and 850Nm at its disposal. And with both costing just shy of £90,000, these two rivals couldn’t be closer. Time to find out which is fastest on track…
    More Auto Express videos
    Car reviews playlist: aex.ae/2gY4ViX
    Drift off! M5 takes on E 63 S in sideways battle: aex.ae/2qLJc3o
    E 63 S Estate vs Panamera Turbo Sport Turismo: aex.ae/2pfA2va
    More on AutoExpress.co.uk
    BMW M5 review: aex.ae/2G0KEoG
    Mercedes-AMG E 63 review: aex.ae/1VUWIsM
    Top 10 best executive cars: aex.ae/2eDiPbf
    Top 10 best performance cars: aex.ae/25P2yTm
    Follow us
    Twitter: / autoexpress
    Facebook: / autoexpress
    Instagram: / autoexpress. .
    Snapchat: / auto.express

КОМЕНТАРІ • 759

  • @gusserks5609
    @gusserks5609 6 років тому +41

    The cars are so similar it just comes down to personal preference. I choose the AMG

  • @TheFunkyair
    @TheFunkyair 6 років тому +267

    As a BMW fan
    Respect to E63s AMG
    Faster on track (0.1 sec)
    Faster on drag (to quarter 0.1sec)
    Faster on roll
    But way much better sound

    • @goga511
      @goga511 6 років тому +32

      TheFunkyair glad to hear that from BMW fan

    • @johnbobby6281
      @johnbobby6281 6 років тому +18

      TheFunkyair the difference on the track and drag stop between them is incredibly small and can go either way... So really both are equally fast. In that respect the better car comes down to personal preference.

    • @av8743
      @av8743 6 років тому +5

      It also looks better inside and out. Personal opinion here.

    • @yurann8102
      @yurann8102 6 років тому

      Thank You For Assuming .

    • @maxpowell2733
      @maxpowell2733 6 років тому +11

      As a BMW fan who actually owns and drives BMWs, who has seen with his own eyes that the E63 AMG S is faster on a straight line (not tracked), will admit both these cars are legendary powerhouse German saloons. These 2 cars are very close in my opinion track is based on the driver not the actual vehicle, even though BMW have had better track performance cars in the past. These two cars are almost identical.

  • @stubones
    @stubones 6 років тому +10

    Finally a track comparison and not just a drag race :)

  • @jryalls
    @jryalls 6 років тому +355

    Not sure why everyone’s talking about the tires. These are the tires that the manufacturer has chosen to sell their car with, end of.

    • @Kaisuke971
      @Kaisuke971 6 років тому +55

      That's a valid observation, but people are specifically pointing that out because the M5 is also available with the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S tires. Actually, it was presented with them not the Pirellis.

    • @johnbobby6281
      @johnbobby6281 6 років тому +12

      Kaisuke971 I have no issue with agreeing that the tires can make a difference which conveys that both are neck in neck and are equally as fast as each other.... But the issue is that had the BMW won you know very well yourself that you wouldn't be talking about the tire difference.

    • @Kaisuke971
      @Kaisuke971 6 років тому +27

      John Bobby Actually i'd have still pointed it out to say that the gap could've been bigger lol

    • @olivertoronyi2462
      @olivertoronyi2462 6 років тому +6

      I would love to see a switch / Merc on Pirelli & M5 on P4S :D :D :D /

    • @ERVDSR
      @ERVDSR 6 років тому +11

      the Bmw won on top gear when they used the same tires tho

  • @DoctorBenz
    @DoctorBenz 6 років тому +16

    Benz is a crazy sound!!!

  • @soawn29
    @soawn29 6 років тому +275

    44.7 and 44.6 this proves nothing.. I would like to see best bmw driver and best mercedes driver to push their cars on track and see who would win..

    • @TheGbizaille
      @TheGbizaille 6 років тому +17

      colt1998 you are so right. 0.1s is literally nothing.

    • @soawn29
      @soawn29 6 років тому +11

      TheGbizaille next lap bmw can vin, this is pointles

    • @marklingling
      @marklingling 6 років тому +16

      Best Mercedes driver: Lewis Hamilton
      Best BMW driver: ???

    • @t4n4s3
      @t4n4s3 6 років тому +4

      R Kubica, R Schumacher, K Raikkonen and so on.

    • @muzzy1502
      @muzzy1502 6 років тому +13

      Lewis Hamilton...AMG///... the best or nothing

  • @maxpowell2733
    @maxpowell2733 6 років тому +24

    I’m a mature BMW fanboy and will say these two beautiful German machines are both super quick, the E63 is just a bit quicker straight line and will admit that, track driving my opinion comes down to the driver as both these cars are just sooo close in tech and added goodies.

    • @strykz63
      @strykz63 6 років тому +8

      Max Powell .... I am a mature mercedes fanboy and I agree with your comment...

    • @maxpowell2733
      @maxpowell2733 6 років тому +7

      The Truth - sadly most BMW fanboys are kids just like hooligans at a football match, they don’t own a BMW and just watch some BMW sponsored videos on UA-cam and base their opinion over that. In saying that I respect the 3 main German marquees Mercedes and Audi as well as BMW as this is what makes it more interesting everyday knowing a rival will come and make a car to match that of the E63 or M5 now waiting on Audi’s RS6-RS7 platform, it’s always about one will bring out a car quicker and more brutal and then vice versa and the long battled saga between these 3 giants will go on!!!

    • @neilbezuidenhout9284
      @neilbezuidenhout9284 4 роки тому

      Nicely said, the first reasonable non fanboy comment

    • @albania2347
      @albania2347 4 роки тому

      Mate the thing is in a straight line either can win just depends who gets the better start

  • @dragivasilev3636
    @dragivasilev3636 6 років тому +14

    I am AMG fan but we can't say we have a winner here. We need more laps and bigger tracks.

    • @mihaay1
      @mihaay1 5 років тому +2

      And a m5 competition

  • @InteriorDesignAnderson
    @InteriorDesignAnderson 6 років тому +216

    I like the Mercedes, but I love the Bmw m5

    • @shashankreddy3646
      @shashankreddy3646 6 років тому +11

      BMW ///M fanbois

    • @johnbobby6281
      @johnbobby6281 6 років тому +7

      BMW ///M I love both but love e63 more.

    • @InteriorDesignAnderson
      @InteriorDesignAnderson 6 років тому

      John Bobby fair enough,

    • @VaunShiz
      @VaunShiz 6 років тому +5

      Mercedes looks better inside and out and unarguably sounds way better

    • @NM-jj5hl
      @NM-jj5hl 6 років тому +10

      your name is literally BMW ///M I think we already knew u liked BMW more

  • @BigBalco
    @BigBalco 6 років тому +12

    M5 Competition pack is going to be insane

  • @bcraftin7846
    @bcraftin7846 6 років тому +4

    E63 sounds like Cape buffalo being attacked....I love it

  • @sergiode5336
    @sergiode5336 6 років тому +14

    People need to understand that the difference between the E63S and "normal" E63 is not the same with the difference between the M5 and M5 CP.
    The S AMG has slightly more power, drift mode and some other options that don't have to do with the performance of the car, but with luxury. On the other hand the M5 CP is more track focused than the M5, it has more power and some weight shaved from the body. Another point is the price which is the nearly the same for the M5 and E63 S. All in all this comparison is fair for both cars.

    • @nhlanhlamagagula7467
      @nhlanhlamagagula7467 6 років тому +1

      Sergio - this mean the E63S has been or has to be downgraded to base since it's comparable to base M5...AMG have to come up with rivals to CP and CS

    • @hkjhhkhkjk
      @hkjhhkhkjk 4 роки тому

      and amg gt63 and amg gt63 s are faster than e63s and m5 competition

  • @Kaipeternicolas
    @Kaipeternicolas 6 років тому +6

    I used to have an M5. Didn't like the F10 so I skipped that and now I'd go with an E63 S. Not because it is .1 seconds faster here, but because I like the design better, the interior quality is much higher, and the interior sound is absolutely 'bonkers' as you brits would say.

    • @Kaipeternicolas
      @Kaipeternicolas 6 років тому +1

      I couldn't disagree more. Have you seen the trim BMW sells as Carbon Fiber in the new M5? It's a joke. The two red M buttons look hideous, the gear lever looks and feels crap too. In reality, I know BMW is saving money under Reithofer so it's no surprise you see the result in these cars.

    • @av8743
      @av8743 5 років тому

      Kaipeternicolas and in exterior you don’t find the m5 looks more aggressive?

  • @rl2239
    @rl2239 6 років тому +5

    2 of the absolutely best cars money can buy. BMW has won me back with this M5.
    Love them both and would be happy in either one.
    There’s nothing in it, 0.1 tenth? It’s a tie.

  • @Olph1
    @Olph1 5 років тому +2

    That sound from the E is amazing!

  • @alianjumdar
    @alianjumdar 6 років тому +11

    the PZ4s are Pirelli's latest tyre. They have a softer compound than the michelin 4s. They would definitely be a stickier tyre on a dry surface. The Michelins are much better in the rain. The E63S and the M5 both come with the Michelin 4S or the new Pirelli PZ4s. Manufactures wouldn't put them on if they affected the performance of the car. 0.1 tenth of a second is nothing. These cars are a coin flip any single day. Better driver takes whatever you do with them. Never seen cars so comparable in terms of performance.

  • @shehroz6220
    @shehroz6220 6 років тому +5

    If I was given a choice between these two I would pick the M5. That thing is gorgeous.

  • @likza4
    @likza4 6 років тому +11

    I'm a mercedes fanboy, i love the E63s, it is an insane car, but i do have to give credit to the beemer, its doing bits, 0.1s is pretty much a tie, these two are so close together in terms of performance its as if bmw and Mercedes worked together to make them. Now normally me as a fanboy i would say the merc came out a year before so maybe bmw used the same tech? but ill let you all in the comments argue that lol

    • @aidenp5768
      @aidenp5768 6 років тому

      But the M5 and E63 compete not the M5 vs the E63S

    • @av8743
      @av8743 6 років тому +2

      Dont forget, even the 5.5 m157 amg motor from previous gen E63/CLS63 is also far more reliable. For that reaosn alone id even choose one of those over the new M5 as well.

  • @bosshunterman
    @bosshunterman 6 років тому +5

    It seems like the suspension of the M5 is set up to be quiet a bit softer than the E63's (you can clearly see how much more body it has, not just here, but in other comparison videos as well), it's very obvious that they've left room for the Competition Package in this area.....
    Still though, it has a CFRP roof and a bunch of carbon bits in the drivetrain as well + it has a bigger, thirstier(according to both EPA and NEDC) engine, starting price is almost identical, and it's the newer car too, so no valid excuses for camp BMW this time around....

  • @Ghanamericanboy
    @Ghanamericanboy 6 років тому +2

    I wish they would stop comparing the regular M5 to the E63 "S". Can we just wait until the M5 Competition Package come out?

  • @cristiandemirel1918
    @cristiandemirel1918 6 років тому +52

    There is no shame for BMW! That E-class is probably the best sedan ever made!

    • @joebloggs4191
      @joebloggs4191 6 років тому

      The best sedan ever made is a Rolls Royce!

    • @WeAreSMC96
      @WeAreSMC96 6 років тому

      For the sheer power that beast makes I’d not hesitate to line it up with the super sedan league…

    • @skyisdlimit6125
      @skyisdlimit6125 6 років тому

      joe bloggs rolls royce are for super rich old farts who doesnt know how to drive so they got someone to do it for them

    • @peterhammer6915
      @peterhammer6915 6 років тому

      cristian since this "test" the m5 has beaten the E63S in every test, drag, circuit everything. Clearly the M5 is a better car. The reviewer in this test is always negative biased against BMW, so no surprise regarding this tests outcome.

    • @cristiandemirel1918
      @cristiandemirel1918 6 років тому +1

      the problem is that I saw a test where the E 63 beat the M5 hands down!

  • @Patrick_T_Peni
    @Patrick_T_Peni 6 років тому +1

    It amazes me how these two beast stack up to each other. so closely matched in strengths. when all is said and done, it comes down to personality and preference. The M5 is beautiful, but I'm an undying Benz fan... E63 any day.

  • @Akurupcm
    @Akurupcm 3 роки тому +1

    M5 is to e63 AMG
    M5 Competition is to E63 S AMG
    Smh; when will people apart from Mat and the Carwow team get this?

  • @nib95
    @nib95 6 років тому +1

    I switched from some P Zero's to Pilot Sport 4 S's on my XF S a few months back. The Michelin's blow the Pirelli's away. Better grip, roll, feedback and stopping distance. Do the test again but this time with both on the Michelin's. I don't know why these sites even bother with these comparisons without matching these things first.

  • @MichelOM1995
    @MichelOM1995 6 років тому +17

    Imagine a M5 competition 😍😍😍

    • @michaelsieber98
      @michaelsieber98 6 років тому +2

      Imagine the AMG GT 63s or the E63s Facelift. Those will probably come out before/at the same time as the Competition . The E class was at market since 2016 so the facelift is due 2019-2020. Probably around the time the Competition comes. They will probably take a Year to put this out. The M2 Competition came out 3 years after the original M2

    • @MichelOM1995
      @MichelOM1995 6 років тому

      gamerforever take it easy, I dont care what cars is faster, I only say imagine the M5 with the competition relax!

    • @TheFunkyfeel
      @TheFunkyfeel 6 років тому +1

      Michael Ocampo
      Imagine a MC Lerean or a Zonda.. both have AMG Mercedes Engines..RIP

    • @drdj69
      @drdj69 5 років тому

      YES it destroyed the e63s

  • @wiktorkawala6298
    @wiktorkawala6298 6 років тому +4

    still waiting on that M5 competition package

  • @abdulahtariq3944
    @abdulahtariq3944 6 років тому +7

    *Competition Pack is yet to come and this is an E63s :)

  • @anpenguin9463
    @anpenguin9463 6 років тому +3

    Many peoples arguing that the tires fitted on the E63s was grippier than the tires on the M5. and not denying the fact that it actually is, but think about it, the E63s weighs 100kg more, so.... :/

  • @strykz63
    @strykz63 6 років тому +49

    Wow.... these bimmer boys are not liking the outcome of the Benz beating bimmer lately....lmaooo😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @alieublues2180
      @alieublues2180 6 років тому +4

      I just feel sad for this so called Fanboys...even two similar cars have inches difference when it comes to speed. ..for me just pick ur preference or Match simple but some deny and insult for nothing.

    • @xlrvlac
      @xlrvlac 6 років тому +1

      They even do it when Cadillac beat them. It's now officially a norm, but I respect all of these sports sedans.

    • @tracyrosss4516
      @tracyrosss4516 6 років тому +3

      Why dont they do bmw m5 competition vs e63s amg..then it would be bmw...but these channels keep using the base m5 against e63s...use the base e63 against bmw m5 competition then u see wat i mean..NOT FAIR AT ALL

    • @DexxonGamer77
      @DexxonGamer77 5 років тому

      I love visiting these old vids. The M5 destroyes the e63s AMG in everyting. The M5 competition is the current fastest 4 door.

    • @veljkomitic1595
      @veljkomitic1595 5 років тому

      @@DexxonGamer77 GT 63 s*

  • @Nissannx2000svg
    @Nissannx2000svg 6 років тому +87

    If you haven’t owned an AMG you won’t understand how they bring out a whole other personality from you , easiest way I can put it is “Clark Kent - Superman” I love the M cars but other than the M3/M4 do the rest really look that special from the original models ? You can tell an AMG from miles away.

    • @MrGoochelaar
      @MrGoochelaar 6 років тому +43

      Jspecwerks this looks just like a reg e class lol

    • @TeacherToolkitDemo
      @TeacherToolkitDemo 6 років тому +12

      Yea an M3/M4 look vastly different to a normal 3 or 4 series. You can spot them a mile off.

    • @jasonyang2288
      @jasonyang2288 6 років тому +9

      Jspecwerks U never owned M cars have u

    • @tonyross5829
      @tonyross5829 6 років тому +15

      Mercedes are loud and proud for people with pan roofs and shades bmw m cars are drivers cars

    • @Nissannx2000svg
      @Nissannx2000svg 6 років тому +1

      Jason Yang I’m actually looking to purchase an E36 M3 soon.

  • @AngelInTheDesert
    @AngelInTheDesert 6 років тому +180

    The Merc’s interior is miles ahead

    • @gbej1
      @gbej1 6 років тому +14

      As is the exterior and that’s coming from someone who has bought only BMWs for 10years. The Merc is just much more upmarket in appearance. BMW designers have truly lost their way in terms of car designs

    • @ICEMANZIDANE
      @ICEMANZIDANE 6 років тому +2

      +Smooth Herb Exactly. BMW still uses the same buttons which they used for years! Merc is many years ahead especially when it comes to interior. The funny thing is tgat thus is the case since 2014 i think.
      BMW and Audi still have these bulky oldscjool interior. I cant understand how the fanboys dont see this. They look old the day they leave the dealership.

    • @DS-kw3nj
      @DS-kw3nj 6 років тому +9

      the BMWs exterior is miles ahead

    • @んや-s7z
      @んや-s7z 6 років тому

      The interiors are similar on all Mercedes cars, unless you’ve been inside all of the models you won’t understand.

    • @sokratisgramnenos2461
      @sokratisgramnenos2461 6 років тому

      Angel G in your DREAM, another Video bmw WIN

  • @KLF_
    @KLF_ 6 років тому +1

    Waiting for The competition pack for sure, it's gonna be a destroyer

  • @longtailgt
    @longtailgt 6 років тому +108

    The E63 is faster, looks better and sounds better. But I'd still have the M5. Because I like it more!

    • @davidg8628
      @davidg8628 6 років тому +12

      BlackWind Fair enough! this cars are very similar in every way, chosing one over the other because it's a little bit faster here or there is just stupid, both are amazing and the choice should come from personal preference not by anything else

    • @oxidalpha6350
      @oxidalpha6350 6 років тому +7

      Look better? Nooo way!!!

    • @TheJsjay2345
      @TheJsjay2345 6 років тому +7

      It's an s vs a reg m5 wait till BMW drops a gts or a competition pack its over

    • @eliteiel9747
      @eliteiel9747 6 років тому +2

      The Truth Yet more people chose the M5 over the E63S in a pole.

    • @iAnas65
      @iAnas65 6 років тому +1

      there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

  • @wesselerasmus9997
    @wesselerasmus9997 6 років тому +1

    So happy the Merc won, even though its only by a tiny margin! Considering that it weights more than the M5 and it managed to use that extra power and torque to win, it is amazing.

    • @ryanshaw6191
      @ryanshaw6191 2 роки тому

      Its all down to the Driver aswell really how fast u can shift through the gears etc I would prefer the M5 but both brilliant cars

  • @Jims5543
    @Jims5543 Рік тому

    I was recently shopping for a Das Uber Interstate Cruiser, I had narrowed my search down to a used E63 and the F10 M5. I decided on the M5 mostly because I started hearing about rear main seal issues with the S63. My friend is a tech at the local Mercedes dealership, he alerted me to the problem. I did not want to believe him, I went to the AMG boards and found a whole thread on the subject. The problem is real. Now, the M5 is supposed to be prone to rod bearing failures. I started to look into that, it seems I can avoid that problem with a con rod bearing update costing around $4k. For now? I sent my first oil change during my ownership to Blackstone labs for analysis. My first report came back stellar. I have only owned my M5 for 3 months now, it is a fantastic machine.

  • @mthonde4950
    @mthonde4950 6 років тому

    We are fortunate to live in a world where we have such potent super saloons. E63S and M5 are absolute gems, hard to separate the two. It will all come down to personal preference; if I had the money I'd buy both (E63S Estate). Keen to see more drag races alongside track times.

  • @hengweizhang6008
    @hengweizhang6008 6 років тому +1

    of course, this is in line with the CARWOW's review of the two cars. E63s is the king in MB as well as the german autos.

  • @Hantz22
    @Hantz22 6 років тому +31

    So this means the new M5 competition package will smoke the e63s any day. It’s funny how they never use a new regular e63 in any video Vs the new regular M5. 🤔

    • @jfb_surfing
      @jfb_surfing 5 років тому +2

      Hantz BII look at the prices

    • @quentinfreeman7516
      @quentinfreeman7516 5 років тому

      I don't know about the UK, but in the US we don't even get the regular e63

    • @Brx01
      @Brx01 4 роки тому +1

      Probably because there's no regular E63s 🤔

    • @hkjhhkhkjk
      @hkjhhkhkjk 4 роки тому +1

      and amg gt63 s would smoke m5 comp.

  • @enesalkovicguitar
    @enesalkovicguitar 6 років тому

    Man, this 2 cars are just out of this world... I am Merc fan, but I would like to own both of them... Greta job Mercedes and BMW, just great job...

  • @andilekunene9409
    @andilekunene9409 6 років тому +1

    The Germans with the F90 M5 and E63 4matic+ have given us a topic to debate on for years! I personally think to settle this one. We'd have to see a head to head between the base E63 and the M5 in their best configurations and tyres, then also see a head to head between E63s and the M5 comp pack in their best tyres and configs. Maybe this test should be done by Chris Harris/ Motor Trend or both.

  • @tryingmybest123
    @tryingmybest123 6 років тому +4

    Less power and still same result thats proper engineering

    • @hkjhhkhkjk
      @hkjhhkhkjk 4 роки тому

      NO ,thats 100+ less kilos!

  • @lizparks1662
    @lizparks1662 Рік тому +1

    I'd pick the AMG

  • @ST5S5
    @ST5S5 6 років тому +17

    Hmm so The E63 is faster in a straight line and around a track, sounds better, looks better inside and out... Seems like it is pretty clear now which car is better

    • @teet0n
      @teet0n 6 років тому +1

      Steven T why I canceled my M5 order and bought an e63s

  • @peterhammer6915
    @peterhammer6915 6 років тому +2

    Just checked Sport Autos test and the M5 was almost ONE SECOND faster on Kleiner Kurs Hockenheim. Thats lightyear.

  • @XX-qr3ru
    @XX-qr3ru 4 роки тому

    Lol you have a great video here but i got my answer from the first 2 seconds of the video 😂❤️

  • @yassirbelarabi1686
    @yassirbelarabi1686 6 років тому +3

    Crazy how childish are people out there.. Do you really think that BMW and Mercedes are rivals? I'm sure they will sit together and laugh out loud reading those comments !!

  • @gee6924
    @gee6924 6 років тому

    Race them 10 different times, you’ll get 10 different results. Both of them wonderful machines

  • @roweng831
    @roweng831 6 років тому +26

    Who cares who won or lost. How will this result change your life is the question. The answer is: it won't.

    • @mikea5205
      @mikea5205 6 років тому +4

      Spitz Tom Gizmo - Finally. A decent, rational human being actually commenting! At this point it’s all about personal preference. I like them both personally, they’re so similar I can’t choose.

    • @supaahflyy
      @supaahflyy 6 років тому +3

      Hahah comment section ended 😂

    • @goguhu
      @goguhu 6 років тому

      It does ...
      1) Wait for the M5 CP
      or
      2) Get the GT63s instead

    • @user-kb5ey4gn6e
      @user-kb5ey4gn6e 6 років тому

      Exactly

    • @zakariahlafreniere1332
      @zakariahlafreniere1332 5 років тому

      DJ Giz Audi beats both in sales

  • @Billeh556
    @Billeh556 6 років тому

    Steve is back?! Rejoice. Subbed again.

  • @mikelarey8738
    @mikelarey8738 6 років тому +1

    Should it not be just the standard E63 in this video and wait for the M5 CP Vs EE63 S

  • @skhumalo3971
    @skhumalo3971 6 років тому +1

    I love BMW but between these two I’ll take E63s just for that sound. Oh it sound so beautiful 🙌🏿

  • @TheTmat007
    @TheTmat007 6 років тому +1

    LOL...It's funny how people make such a BIG DEAL of "laptimes," when it doesn't necessary prove one car's performance capabilities over another. DRIVER SKILLS can significantly affect a car's laptime. Even when the same driver is doing all the test runs, he/she can make a mistake while approaching a corner, at any given moment, since the margin for error is greater when driver around a track compared to doing so in a straight line.

  • @gloritodorov
    @gloritodorov 6 років тому +8

    As in the old times: Mercedes and all the rest!

  • @maxthemaltesedog3597
    @maxthemaltesedog3597 6 років тому

    Both Cars are amazing . Either one you buy , you win !!

  • @JA-ui3gg
    @JA-ui3gg 6 років тому

    These are both stunning vehicles. I am happy to have both.

  • @sukhrajjhawar6644
    @sukhrajjhawar6644 6 років тому +1

    Wait for M5 competition packages

  • @sergiode5336
    @sergiode5336 6 років тому +17

    So the Bmw M5 is 2 years newer, it weighs 100kg less than the E63S and still cannot beat the AMG.
    ***Not mentioning the dyno test that shows that BMW lied about the numbers and that M5 actually has 625hp+.

    • @tonystafford978
      @tonystafford978 6 років тому +6

      look at other videos on youtube and the m5 beats the E63 AMG dont base it on one video and beside winning by 100th of a second is nothing to brag about that could come down to driver error

    • @bradenmchenry995
      @bradenmchenry995 6 років тому +3

      Sergio DE it has on the pirelli p zeros not the optional pilot sport 4s. Motor trend just tested the m5 is .2 seconds faster around the figure 8 and stops from 60-0 18 feet shorter. Tires make a huge difference. So yes the e63 beat the m5 but only because it was on the lesser of tires

    • @tracyrosss4516
      @tracyrosss4516 6 років тому +3

      Sergio DE ...well this is wat i dont understand..why not use the base amg e63 vs the base m5...the amg e63s vs m5 competition..then talk. Its not a fair battle..base against base car..smh

    • @sergiode5336
      @sergiode5336 6 років тому +1

      You have to understand that the difference between the E63S and "normal" E63 is not the same with the difference between the M5 and M5 CP.
      The S AMG has slightly more power, drift mode and some other options that don't have to do with the performance of the car, but with luxury. On the other hand the M5 CP is more track focused than the M5, it has more power and some weight shaved from the body. Another point is the price which is the nearly the same for the M5 and E63 S. All in all this comparison is fair for both cars.

    • @sadaloveliveunion9835
      @sadaloveliveunion9835 6 років тому +1

      No exactly....593 HP BMW

  • @nileshgoburdhun
    @nileshgoburdhun 6 років тому +2

    Why is everybody testing the M5 to the E63s? A fairer comparison would be to compare the M5 to the E63 or the M5 *competition* to the E63s right?

    • @nhlanhlamagagula7467
      @nhlanhlamagagula7467 6 років тому +2

      This proves M division superior...they are way ahead of the game

    • @staywoke9172
      @staywoke9172 6 років тому

      Nilesh Goburdhun the e63s been our since 2014. There is a newer m5 which is current in the video. That m5 is newer than the Benz so what r u saying ??

  • @LuisCalderon-jg7lv
    @LuisCalderon-jg7lv 6 років тому

    They both amazing machines! Now let’s see how fast it will be the new M5 competition package.

  • @staywoke9172
    @staywoke9172 6 років тому

    These both cars are amazing. If you have anyone of them you can’t go wrong. Even if one may have a sec on the other, the numbers are almost identical. I love Benz, but the bmw is an amazing car as well.

  • @flaviu5428
    @flaviu5428 6 років тому +1

    What's with the 100" tv from the Merc ? Why've they put a tv in a car ?

  •  6 років тому

    I'm a BMW fan but that E63's engine sounded like a lion's roar 💪
    Still obviously very proud of the M5. The master of super-sedans IMO.

  • @michal.laskowski.
    @michal.laskowski. 6 років тому +6

    This Merc looks so much more focused on the race track than an M5.

  • @spearce713
    @spearce713 6 років тому +118

    Tie.... Within the margin of error

    • @amgsocallounge
      @amgsocallounge 6 років тому +8

      ^ Objective statement alert! :)

    • @TeacherToolkitDemo
      @TeacherToolkitDemo 6 років тому +7

      Its literally equal performance agreed.

    • @senorgato70
      @senorgato70 6 років тому +2

      LOL. Try that at, say, the Olympics.

    • @HypnOlli
      @HypnOlli 6 років тому +1

      But the track was really short and slow (favors the m5 with lower weight); do it on a proper track and the Merc pulls a lot more gap...

    • @TeacherToolkitDemo
      @TeacherToolkitDemo 6 років тому +1

      Bud Chronic Hockenheim M5 is faster so it depends on track. The cars are evenly matched.

  • @brunobegic3841
    @brunobegic3841 5 років тому

    Both amazing. Its nice to see cars this closely matched, because it makes both manafacturers work harder and eventually come up with something even better in all ways. And you childish fanboys have to respect both because they are sensational and I would be happy with either one of them. Cars this sofisticated can hardly become better than they already are...

  • @Kaisuke971
    @Kaisuke971 6 років тому +129

    Pirelli P Zero vs Michelin PS4S, don’t @ me 😴

    • @heamees4822
      @heamees4822 6 років тому +20

      @ Kaisuke971

    • @C0DFR3AK11
      @C0DFR3AK11 6 років тому +15

      The ps4s is miles better for track use

    • @dogrubi2823
      @dogrubi2823 6 років тому +16

      1855 kg vs 1955 kg!

    • @johnbobby6281
      @johnbobby6281 6 років тому +14

      Kaisuke971 excuses excuses. Why can't we just appreciate both cars?!?

    • @BobbyAngmalaysia
      @BobbyAngmalaysia 6 років тому +8

      Kaisuke971 yupe. The P zeros cant match the Ps4s in every aspect. Tested them back to back same car same track and the ps4s are grippier, quieter, more comfortable. Wet or dry.

  • @danielohio9462
    @danielohio9462 6 років тому

    I don't get people complaining about the BMW being more understated. All M5s and indeed all M cars - apart from the monstrous E60 - have been understated. It's a crucial part of what makes M cars so special. Slightly flared arches and bigger wheels and that's it. AMGs are like American football players - all shoulder pads and knee pads and look massive - M cars are like rugby players - no need for any padding.

  • @faisalharoon9167
    @faisalharoon9167 6 років тому +1

    Interesting that the E63s, in the reviewers own words, "just" edges past the M5. The Merc here is a an S model with more power while the M5 Competition Pack is yet to be released. For the standard M5 to do that well against the E63s is fantastic. I'm an AMG guy through and through but BMWs always keep you on your toes

  • @tonydmty1234567
    @tonydmty1234567 6 років тому +2

    I heard Steve Sutcliffe's voice and thumbed up immediately.
    ";-)

  • @kaviitjahikika4294
    @kaviitjahikika4294 4 роки тому +1

    I don't believe what a BMW is faster than a Mercedes like what , than they must put them to face each other am I right

  • @luckistryke13
    @luckistryke13 6 років тому

    Performance twins in my eye. For daily use and the sounds of the AMG is my winner

  • @letsrunit2131
    @letsrunit2131 6 років тому

    as a bmw fan who wanted the bmw to win I must admit the e63s is the current best 4 door on the market.I would still take the m5 because with a proper exhaust that turbo whistle is gonna be lovely.

  • @peterparker8630
    @peterparker8630 6 років тому +66

    One tenth of a second... that’s not even a heartbeat. I bet that if you take another lap the M5 may have it. This is race is a tie

    • @johnbobby6281
      @johnbobby6281 6 років тому +1

      Peter Parker same for drag race the difference is also a tenth of a second... Literally these cars are neck and neck... Both equally quick and fast. Really it comes down to personal preference.

    • @Fearzzy
      @Fearzzy 6 років тому

      69mrbrightside691 what do you mean the M era is over, we both know very well the M era isn't even close to being over. If youre refering to the golden era of M, that already ended about 10 years ago with the N/A V10.

    • @Fearzzy
      @Fearzzy 6 років тому

      69mrbrightside691 okay fair enough, and yeah small BMW's like the M2 are still great

    • @davidg8628
      @davidg8628 6 років тому +4

      Peter Parker "It doesn't matter if you win by an inch or a mile, wining is wining!" -Wise words from Dominic Toretto. Now I'm not saying that one is categorically faster than the other, or that the Mercedes will win in every circumstance, maybe if they raced again it would lose or maybe it would win. What matters is that this was not a tie, the e63 won, although with a small margin, it doesn't invalidate the race

    • @peterparker8630
      @peterparker8630 6 років тому

      Winning a Pole Position is something entirely different than winning a Race (in the real world), no matter what a fictitious character in a movie says. The Merc got a faster laptime in ONE lap which to me does not prove that it's a faster track car. A drag race is something entirely different nowadays with awd and launch control. 9 out of 10 times would give the same result if raced on the same day. But really, one thenth in one lap... Cmon, I do like the E63S a lot, but it only proves that these cars are equally matched in fact.

  • @Gearsandco
    @Gearsandco 6 років тому +1

    Wait for the M5 competition package and compare it was the e63s

  • @imtiaazhassan6394
    @imtiaazhassan6394 6 років тому +2

    All the butthurt bmw fanboys saying the m5 is only 0.1 sec slower but the e63s is a year older than this brand new m5 yet it takes the win on the track and the drag. Why are they also crying over the tyres if those are the stock tyres the cars come with ? Don't blame merc for being faster because they used a different tyre to bmw

    • @nhlanhlamagagula7467
      @nhlanhlamagagula7467 6 років тому

      It's a shame for year old e63s to be 0.01s faster to a base model this proves that M division is ahead of AMG..so the e63s has been downgraded to a base if it compares to a base (base v base) then the normal e63 for 550 series...M5 CP coming this summer then later a CS ...AMG have no clue how to react...M division are benchmakers others follow

  • @oneman7638
    @oneman7638 5 років тому

    At this point and this level of tech they're essentially identical cars. It all comes down to preference on looks & luxury & feel. Personally I'd pick the M5, just because I like how it looks.

  • @platonicdreamer
    @platonicdreamer 6 років тому

    steve sutcliffe, one of the finest automotive reviewers! better than chris harris or any of those who are there to please the broad audience, steve sutcliffe is as real and objective as it gets and feels his cars and knows what he is talking about...

  • @santana9537
    @santana9537 6 років тому +9

    Wait for the M5 Competition

    • @crimsonpirate1710
      @crimsonpirate1710 6 років тому +3

      There wont be one..........

    • @aidenp5768
      @aidenp5768 6 років тому

      There will be and the competition won't be the bigger dog the biggest dog will be the M5 CSL and even more insane M8 CSL grand coupe and yes those are actually a name BMW announced those name plates

    • @michaelsieber98
      @michaelsieber98 6 років тому +3

      So yeah by the time those are announced we will have the AMG GT 63S on the road and the E63s Facelift will probably be there too with even more power and performance. Just accept it. BMW is behind on this one. Normally the newer Car beats the older cars from the competition was always this way between Merc, BMW and Audi. It is the first time a new Car is beaten by the older competitor.

    • @aidenp5768
      @aidenp5768 6 років тому

      Are you stupid or what ? The M8 is isn't a M6 the M8 will murder any Mercedes bro that's not even a discussion why your trying to make it one .. the M8 is going to be a supercar on 4 doors you don't get it , it's not a super saloon it's a supercar getting 4 doors 60-70hp more then the normal M5 and lighter of course for BMW to bring back the M8 is crazy because the original M8 was suppose to hit 3:4 to 60 and a top speed of 222mph fact by the way! Also had 550hp and weighs 3,200lb

    • @michaelsieber98
      @michaelsieber98 6 років тому +1

      What are you talking about. The M8 isn´t murdering any Merc. The AMG GT 63S AMG will be the direct competitor and it will be as dynamic as the AMG GT so it will kill BMW on every track and it will get a Top Version with close to 800hp and a Hybrid. But even the 639hp standard GT 63s will kill any BMW just like in any other category currently

  • @xyvous2963
    @xyvous2963 6 років тому +1

    We need a BMW M5 F90 Competition 😁👍

  • @orangemerc
    @orangemerc 6 років тому

    I think both are great and what ever you chose to drive you will be happy with ..

  • @abdullaalmarri902
    @abdullaalmarri902 5 років тому

    Bring the competition one and it will rule

  • @bblifestyle6191
    @bblifestyle6191 6 років тому +1

    Well keep in mind that this is the S version of the E63 and that there will be a M5 competition pack soon ..

  • @Zouguuh
    @Zouguuh 6 років тому

    I think both those cars beast!!! I'm a big BMW fan, but have to say respect for MB. I drove E amg 2 week ago. It's just crazy. Nezt week testdrive M5. But I already know what I choose. M5. BMW has something that toucht my heart more.
    Audi is nice to go straight. No more.
    BMW #1
    MB #2
    Porsche #3
    Audi #10

  • @zichaowang8617
    @zichaowang8617 6 років тому +1

    i don't understand why these generic auto reviews can't be rigorous in their testing procedures. ONLY german reviews like sportauto makes sense to me

  • @DynamicAttraction
    @DynamicAttraction 6 років тому +2

    Dont make a car a winner when the difference in time is 0.01 that much of a difference can be changed by just a change of drivers or tires ect lol basically this video is a tie and it falls on which one visually suits you

  • @joehew1641
    @joehew1641 6 років тому +10

    Mercedes AMG all the way!

  • @louisperron4918
    @louisperron4918 6 років тому +3

    Fair enough, but we have to remember that is a standard m5, if it's alread tied between the two now then the competition pack is gonna gap it

  • @buldhana
    @buldhana 6 років тому

    Exactly why have different tyres?? Why both both with PS4s?

  • @maxtroy8511
    @maxtroy8511 6 років тому

    Great review from Steve as always. But how many owners actually take these cars out on the track? How about a review telling us which car is best to live with and drive every day like most owners would end up doing.

  • @datniggami7
    @datniggami7 2 роки тому

    Benz owner for years…must say tho…I respect both. Even within the S, I feel it would be an even match. Cleary you can see there’s someone else with eye glasses driving at different times.

  • @wordpress4373
    @wordpress4373 6 років тому

    Have you test RS6 performance on this track, I wonder what time it can do?

  • @arunroolzutoo
    @arunroolzutoo 6 років тому +4

    Tat Merc just looks and feels better than the M5... Sry BMW... Merc is the Governor...

  • @edwill1595
    @edwill1595 6 років тому +4

    BMW and Nissan GT-R fanboys are the same breed...

  • @yakupyildirim5901
    @yakupyildirim5901 6 років тому +1

    We all wait for the m5 comp...

  • @skilledea
    @skilledea 6 років тому

    Both cars are great, no doubt. No one cares which one is better but which outsells which one.

  • @Zillozee
    @Zillozee 6 років тому +1

    Why everybody compare e63s(!) to m5?
    You should do m5 and e63, or wait, until BMW made a competition version of bmw m5 to compadre it with the Mercedes e63s version.

  • @oumaniac
    @oumaniac 6 років тому

    2 amazing machines! But I like the looks of the 5 better. C and S Class are beautiful, but the E just doesn't look right to me

  • @edwill1595
    @edwill1595 5 років тому

    These cars are so similar in speed...
    at the end of the day it’s all about personal preference...

  • @swansmeister
    @swansmeister 6 років тому +1

    lets wait for the competition pack m5

  • @TheGo4live
    @TheGo4live 6 років тому

    Until know you are the only pro drivers who tested this two cars in youtube all the other tests are so slow pls do proper drag race for this two machines to end up this debate

    • @TheGo4live
      @TheGo4live 6 років тому

      The Truth yeah i saw the two other tests i am 100% sure that the E63s is faster cuz the numbers of this car are out of this world